Replies continued
ParmasThread starterML · Mar 4, 2010#251The problem is probably a valve because if it was a piston ring the breather will show a considerable amount of oil coming out.
Finally the good news is that the authorities confirmed that there is no expense to change the engine (an amount that was thought to be near $2000). So now with these money I am going to fix the compression problem, port & polish head, lighten flywheel?, new seals and maybe a block guard.
Is there a brand that makes sales of a block guard for our 1NZ? Do you have for sale garm?
cali yarisCanoga Park, CA · Mar 5, 2010#252If the motor is sleeved properly there is absolutely no need for a block guard on our motor.
If you are going to drag race, don't get a light flywheel. For other types of driving or racing it's a good modification.
ParmasThread starterML · Mar 29, 2010#253I am making an estimate of all things I need...... I wish anyone who can help to post some useful info.
The tuner gave me this estimate of parts to replace\upgrade:
Parts marked are thought to be left out
- Toyota OE Overall Gasket Set
- Toyota OE Crank shaft Bearings Kit
- Toyota OE Trust Bearings
- Toyota OE Timing chain kit ?
- Arias Rings Set - Where to buy? Prices ?
- Block Guard Custom made ? What about sleeves? Cost? Need new pistons?
- Steel Head Studs - Thinking of AJUSA or ARP. Where To buy?
- Knife edge crankshaft ?
- Full bottom end Balancing
- Flywheel Lightening + faces ?
- Head Porting - There are different stages, can anyone explain in detail?
- Cometic MLS Head Gasket - Does AJUSA have better head gaskets?
If I am missing something please post reply...
cali yarisCanoga Park, CA · Mar 29, 2010#254I'm running a stock head gasket, no problems at all and you know my motor. What head studs are you using?
see post 257 about the block guard.
ParmasThread starterML · Mar 29, 2010#255 Originally Posted by
cali yaris ↑ I'm running a stock head gasket, no problems at all and you know my motor. What head studs are you using?
see post 257 about the block guard.
Head studs are the same it came with the engine which are probably stock ones.
I read the post 257 but I don't know where I can find for our 1NZ. Also what kind of issues I might get into if using the same pistons?
Garm I would appreciate any comments on the other parts mentioned aswell. Which in your opinion I might need or not...
cali yarisCanoga Park, CA · Mar 29, 2010#256stock head studs are not a good idea. We had to custom make a set, but there is a company overseas making them. Can't vouch for the quality though.
ParmasThread starterML · Mar 30, 2010#257 Originally Posted by
cali yaris ↑ there is a company overseas making them. Can't vouch for the quality though.
What company are you referring to?
cali yarisCanoga Park, CA · Mar 30, 2010#258yaris-meAnaheim, CA · Mar 30, 2010#259 Originally Posted by
Parmas ↑ The problem is probably a valve because if it was a piston ring the breather will show a considerable amount of oil coming out.
Finally the good news is that the authorities confirmed that there is no expense to change the engine (an amount that was thought to be near $2000). So now with these money I am going to fix the compression problem, port & polish head, lighten flywheel?, new seals and maybe a block guard.
Is there a brand that makes sales of a block guard for our 1NZ? Do you have for sale garm?
If valves get moved around on assembly, it will give you problems. Valves have to go back to the original location.
ParmasThread starterML · Mar 30, 2010#260 Originally Posted by
cali yaris ↑
Still getting broken link ...
Although I got some news that AJUSA head bolts are similar to standard Bolts or else equal. I will be probably getting them custom made from DP.
What can you tell about porting? Is it worth doing it from experience? What is the average increased hp?
What about Knife edging crankshaft? What are the pros and cons of it?
What about doing upgraded sleeves? At what power they are really needed?
Come on is only Garm helping here... where are the experts 🆘
1 attachment not included in this copy
CtrlAltDefeatIndianapolis IN · Mar 30, 2010#261cali yarisCanoga Park, CA · Mar 30, 2010#262I sleeved my Yaris block because we knew we were going for 20+ pounds of boost.
I would sleeve it if you intend to throw 15+ at yours.
Porting/polishing increases airflow. The effect and increased hp is amplified when you throw boost at it (more air trying to pass through, obviously). I would do it.
I am using stock crankshaft, and I like the results I'm getting so far.
rob323Joyner, Brisbane · Mar 30, 2010#263 What can you tell about porting? Is it worth doing it from experience?
If you have the head apart, then you may as well do it. NA motors benefit from it more so than forced induction motors (the pressure from the turbo helps negate some of the inefficiencies in the intake).
What is the average increased hp?
Impossible to say, it varies with each and every car and how the porting is done.
What about Knife edging crankshaft? What are the pros and cons of it?
It reduces the reciprocal weight of the crank shaft, good for high revving motors (8000 rpm upwards). I wouldn't worry about it on your motor as you will have to fully rebalance the motor once you have done it. (Then again, if you are replacing the pistons, then you should fully rebalance the motor anyway).
What about doing upgraded sleeves? At what power they are really needed?
I haven't heard of anyone cracking a sleeve yet? Maybe some of the Scion boys have though as they have been putting boost through these motors longer than most?
ParmasThread starterML · Mar 31, 2010#264Ok so porting will be one on my list.... Then what about stock valves and springs? Are they capable of 20+ boost?
I made some more research on knife edging the crankshaft. They usually make it on Honda engines but since it doesn't cost that much I would probably do it.
RE: Sleeves... My Power intensions are somewhere near 300Hp. Considering that I am using a turbo GT28 and using street pump low grade octane fuel (Below 90) the engine would need about 25psi of boost to get into that range. The tuner said, if going to do sleeves, the pistons could need to be replaced to match new sleeves... so it would cost me a fortune to make this happen!
changchewsoonMalaysia · Mar 31, 2010#265hi parmas,
im too getting my head ported as well. at the same time, i fully agree with what garm said. the more air you could flow, the better. and results will be amplified when you boost it. you should go ahead and get a "head job" :)
im also having my cams welded and grinded too, and the valve springs will be changed as well.
as for the AJUSA bolts, i could only comment that the bolts are much more heavier than the stock ones. however, heavier does not mean they are better. i can only tell you this much, and until my cylinder head is back i don't have further inputs on that.
im currently keeping my crankshaft stock though, tuner did not recommend me to have them knife edged so i did not pursue that.
ParmasThread starterML · Mar 31, 2010#266Thanks for the info changchewsoon
What valve springs are you intending to use? Regarding cams I think I leave them stock don't want to mess everthing at once
RE AJUSA bolts, heavier doesn't meen better but the quality of metal used. Do you know if they match exactly the stock bolts? I mean no rethreading etc..
RE Knife edging crank, Did you asked your tuner the reason not doing it?
cali yarisCanoga Park, CA · Mar 31, 2010#267 RE Knife edging crank, Did you asked your tuner the reason not doing it?
rob explained this point quite well.
I'm about to tune upwards of 25 psi, on stock crank and stock valve springs. I just don't see the need to spend money there when it's not necessary.
ParmasThread starterML · Mar 31, 2010#268What fuel octane are you using Garm?
cali yarisCanoga Park, CA · Mar 31, 2010#26991 with water/meth injection. Should be able to run 25 psi on pump gas. 😁
ParmasThread starterML · Mar 31, 2010#270 Originally Posted by
cali yaris ↑ 91 with water/meth injection. Should be able to run 25 psi on pump gas. 😁
I thought you have a better (directly from pump) octane than 91 there!
rob323Joyner, Brisbane · Mar 31, 2010#271Stock valve springs are designed to work with the stock rev limit and the stock lift and ramp angles on the cams. If you change any of those, only then do you need to look at a heavier valve spring.
cali yarisCanoga Park, CA · Mar 31, 2010#272 I thought you have a better (directly from pump) octane than 91 there!
I can get 100 down the street, and I can buy buckets of any race gas I want, but I don't need it with the meth injection.
cali yarisCanoga Park, CA · Mar 31, 2010#273 Stock valve springs are designed to work with the stock rev limit and the stock lift and ramp angles on the cams.
Correct. Although I will say we are doing fine up to 7200 so far, all valve parts are stock.
rob323Joyner, Brisbane · Mar 31, 2010#274That's good to know there's some head room left in the valve train, thanks Garm.
cali yarisCanoga Park, CA · Mar 31, 2010#275don't worry if they float, I'll post it! 😲
rob323Joyner, Brisbane · Mar 31, 2010#276Do they float/ bounce?
ParmasThread starterML · Mar 31, 2010#277 Originally Posted by
cali yaris ↑ Correct. Although I will say we are doing fine up to 7200 so far, all valve parts are stock.
I thought you rev limit to 6500? Can you give more info on the 7200?
Does it increase power or remain constant between 6.5-7.2?
changchewsoonMalaysia · Apr 1, 2010#278 Originally Posted by
Parmas ↑ Thanks for the info changchewsoon
What valve springs are you intending to use? Regarding cams I think I leave them stock don't want to mess everthing at once
RE AJUSA bolts, heavier doesn't meen better but the quality of metal used. Do you know if they match exactly the stock bolts? I mean no rethreading etc..
RE Knife edging crank, Did you asked your tuner the reason not doing it?
i just got a call from my tuner that my cylinder head just came back, im gonna go snap pictures tomorrow and i'll ask him about the valve springs.
reason why the shop that was working on my head changed the valve springs is because we told him that we wanted to increase the rev limit to at least 8,000 rpm or above.
the AJUSA bolts does match the stock bolts, the only think im not able to comment is the quality until we use it.
as for the knife edging crank, i did not asked him why we do not need to do it.
ParmasThread starterML · Apr 1, 2010#279 Originally Posted by
changchewsoon ↑ i just got a call from my tuner that my cylinder head just came back, im gonna go snap pictures tomorrow and i'll ask him about the valve springs.
reason why the shop that was working on my head changed the valve springs is because we told him that we wanted to increase the rev limit to at least 8,000 rpm or above.
the AJUSA bolts does match the stock bolts, the only think im not able to comment is the quality until we use it.
as for the knife edging crank, i did not asked him why we do not need to do it.
Wow man 8000rpm seems too much for a 1NZFE although I wish you all success in your project. I think in your case, knife edging the crank will help you more reach that goal.
Keep us updated 👍
cali yarisCanoga Park, CA · Apr 1, 2010#280 we wanted to increase the rev limit to at least 8,000 rpm or above.
Looking forward to your dynos, that will be really cool!
@ Parmas: we have the limiter at 7200 but if you've looked at my dynos, it quits making power about 6500.
It MIGHT make power up higher with the new custom intake manifold. Next tuning session will tell us a lot more.
ParmasThread starterML · Apr 1, 2010#281 Originally Posted by
cali yaris ↑
@ Parmas: we have the limiter at 7200 but if you've looked at my dynos, it quits making power about 6500.
Yes I saw that before but I thought you got it making power till 7200 after that.
BTW I heard some ppl saying that water injection reduces power output when used. I mean if you run the same setup with for example 16psi with water injection and dyno compare it without, it will result to a slight power decrease. Is this true?
eTiMaGoBangkok, Thailand · Apr 1, 2010#282possibly, any volume taken up by water vapor is not filled with air/fuel mixture... Not sure how big of a difference it would make, but it's a small compromise to be able to run on pump gas!
cali yarisCanoga Park, CA · Apr 1, 2010#283 BTW I heard some ppl saying that water injection reduces power output when used.
"some people saying" means nothing to me. Show me some results and I will be very interested, although I'm not trading away the ability to run high boost on pump gas - that is way too much fun to give up!
ParmasThread starterML · Apr 1, 2010#284 Originally Posted by
cali yaris ↑ "some people saying" means nothing to me. Show me some results and I will be very interested, although I'm not trading away the ability to run high boost on pump gas - that is way too much fun to give up!
In my opinion Water Injection is used to cool mixture and to be able to run higher boost values but with that said, doesn't mean it gives you power by itself. Is that right?
I happen to be in a forum to discuss these things before commiting myself into it. I am not saying they are right or wrong, I just want your opinions like Etimago commented and I am sure all good things have their bad things.
I don't carry lots of cash to try these things, I am here to knowledge myself more and prevent disappointment for future upgrades..
cali yarisCanoga Park, CA · Apr 1, 2010#285^ I'm here for that too, have learned a lot. Yes, I would agree that water doesn't add power by itself. But at cooler intake/cylinder temperatures (which is what the water does), more fuel is in the available air, and that makes more power. This would be true whether or not there is boost.
A good example of this is that a Cold Air Intake adds power to a stock car (n/a), simply by cooling down the incoming air. Water injection does the same thing, to my understanding.
What I meant was "some people saying" doesn't help any of us. Doesn't it depend on who said it, when they said it, and what they were talking about? So my request, respectfully is to be more specific in that regard.
ParmasThread starterML · Apr 1, 2010#286 Originally Posted by
cali yaris ↑
A good example of this is that a Cold Air Intake adds power to a stock car (n/a), simply by cooling down the incoming air. Water injection does the same thing, to my understanding.
I understand your thought so I ask what is the better?
- Having a very good intercooler that keeps the air as cold as possible
OR
- Cooling Mixture with water injection
In my opinion cooling the air without water injection by having a better intercooler is the point were you will see power gains without compensating with extra boost (less wear and tear). What are your opinions on this guys?
cali yarisCanoga Park, CA · Apr 1, 2010#287It's just as easy to do water/meth injection and get the octane boost from the alcohol. I wouldn't bother with all the effort for just water.
ParmasThread starterML · Apr 2, 2010#288 Originally Posted by
cali yaris ↑ It's just as easy to do water/meth injection and get the octane boost from the alcohol. I wouldn't bother with all the effort for just water.
Can you tell us by how much the water injection on your setup lowered the intake temps ?
cali yarisCanoga Park, CA · Apr 2, 2010#289No, (1) because we changed the manifold too and (2) we haven't tuned on the dyno yet (wastegate failed last time).
Hoping for a new appointment next week!
changchewsoonMalaysia · Apr 4, 2010#290thanks a lot garm and parmas, it is because of people like you guys all over the world inspires people like to me to want to push the 1nz-fe further! :)
i too can't wait to see garm's latest update and also parmas's build....man just thinking about them gives me goosebumps!
i've learnt a lot just by reading both your threads.
ParmasThread starterML · Apr 4, 2010#291 Originally Posted by
changchewsoon ↑ thanks a lot garm and parmas, it is because of people like you guys all over the world inspires people like to me to want to push the 1nz-fe further! :)
i too can't wait to see garm's latest update and also parmas's build....man just thinking about them gives me goosebumps!
i've learnt a lot just by reading both your threads.
That is why we post here my friend !
Of course we are many here and I think there are more than just us building the ultimate 1NZ so please contribute your info 👍
ParmasThread starterML · Jun 10, 2010#292Update:
Let me revise the situation.... During the last months I had my tuner claiming that the problem of the tune up was coming from a loss of compression. Since there were too much money to repair and buy the extra parts I decided to hold the project until I had further cash in my hands.
During the time, I came accross one of my friends who is an expert on this and decided to help me out on this. Of course we began by checking the compression again and duhhh it came out that it is good on all 4 cyclinders. We retried again the test and still no problems.
Seeing this out he told me to change the tuner and retry the tune again. I went to talk with the new tuner and he told me that we need to check all the necessary wiring in case the previous tuner messed up something. We indeed found some wiring not matching with the ecu instruction manual regarding VVT connection so this might be the problem.
The other thing that might mess up with the tune is that the ECU supports VVT but not VVTi. There is an option to activate the VVT at a certain rpm and switch it off at another rpm. I contacted the ecu company for more info on this and he said that the ecu was tested and tuned succesfully on a 1ZZFE VVTi engine.
I booked a tuning session for next week so until then crossed fingers
cali yarisCanoga Park, CA · Jun 10, 2010#293ooh, exciting! I'm very glad you checked the compression yourself, proving the first tuner to be wrong, making excuses like that for his lack of skill.
Good luck and we're all waiting to see how she does!
ParmasThread starterML · Jun 17, 2010#294Today I went to my tuner to discuss how we can get this right....
Well there is some issues we need to face and we are unsure whether the management used is capable to tune VVTi correctly.
1st problem: Mode selection
- On the ecu there are 8 Modes one can select, from batch fire with single coil mode to Full Sequential mode. The only problem I am seeing is the Crank Trigger. If you refer to the attachment you can notice Mode 6 - Phased Sequential with multicoils, Crank Trigger 36 -1 input, no TDC (which is my current setup). According to H3ilton, our engine crank trigger is 34. If he is right, (and we will check about this to confirm) the ecu will not support this crank trigger and so tuning cannot be done efficiently.
- 2nd Problem: VVTi control
The ecu surely support VVT with an on and off rpm setting but since now we cannot find a way in the ecu's software that can tune on a range of degree angles. We only can signal the camshaft timing plunger at a certain (still unknown) pulse modulation frequency at a set RPM number. Still, when signaling the plunger we don't know for sure how the cam will react in terms of degrees but we are assuming that when not signaling the plunger the engine is fully retarded and when singaling the engine is fully advanced. At this point, if we are assuming right, the midrange power will be affected drastically. If I am right our engine varies timing within a range of 40Degrees.
In order to solve this problem, my tuner recommended of eliminating the VVTi by making the stock camshaft fixed (if it can be done) or else upgrading the cams.
- 3rd Problem: Ignition Coils
I was thinking of putting the stock ignition coils as members of this forum suggested but when talking with my tuner he said that the ecu do not support the stock 4wire coil with igniters. In order to work we need 2wire coils that are capable to work with the ecu. (Refer to attachment) First wiring diagram shows my current setup while the other shows the wiring diagram for full sequential
- 4th Problem: Installing TDC - Currently not used
According the Toyota Engine manual page 40, the stock ecu use the camshaft position sensor (TDC) to make the VVTi work efficient. Our ecu supports this feature and it could be installed without problems. So I ask, is the TDC a must to have it installed to make the VVTi work properly on a standalone management?
Any suggestions are apprectiated
5 attachments not included in this copy
cali yarisCanoga Park, CA · Jun 17, 2010#295I've asked my tuner your question, Parmas.
But what did GoTech say? Since it's their tuning computer, they should be able to answer most of your questions.
ParmasThread starterML · Jun 17, 2010#296 Originally Posted by
cali yaris ↑ I've asked my tuner your question, Parmas.
But what did GoTech say? Since it's their tuning computer, they should be able to answer most of your questions.
I am awaiting response from them but certainly many engines that work with pulse modulation frequencies vary from engine to engine model. I think at this point it is more a Toyota thing than Gotech but thats just me.
What does the tuner told you about this Garm?
ParmasThread starterML · Jun 17, 2010#297cali yarisCanoga Park, CA · Jun 17, 2010#298The AEM EMS has a wizard for Toyota motors, I believe it automatically sets parameters for VVTI. So I'm not sure I'll be able to answer your question, but Art is going to look into it further.
ParmasThread starterML · Jun 17, 2010#299 Originally Posted by
cali yaris ↑ The AEM EMS has a wizard for Toyota motors, I believe it automatically sets parameters for VVTI. So I'm not sure I'll be able to answer your question, but Art is going to look into it further.
You are a life saver thank for your support and God Bless your management👍
Current Setting are :
- Frequency @ 60Hz = 3600rpm / minute
- DutyCycle @ 7.1% = 4.25s / minute
What do you think about the other issues I mentioned apart PWM?
rob323Joyner, Brisbane · Jun 17, 2010#300To me, it sounds more likely that the problem is the engine management, than the engine. Might be cheaper to use something like Adaptronic which utilises all the factory sensor & igniters and has continuously variable control over the vvti.
I'll pm you an email conversation I had with Adaptronic recently.