Replies continued
tooterThread starterLos Angeles · Jul 6, 2012#201I understand... and that's why I'm not concerned with the absolute output of any one dyno run as far as the exhaust is concerned. Right now I'm focused on the intake manifold and in the relative difference between two dyno runs with the manifold as the only difference.
Maybe later on I'll post another thread on "tooter's exhaust adventure". But not now. Just one project at a time. 😉
tooterThread starterLos Angeles · Jul 6, 2012#202 Originally Posted by
BEEF ↑ that's beautiful. excel can be your friend. that will show you the advantages and disadvantages to your intake manifold.
you have quite the project going here. now I am chompin at the bit for more.
I don't even have excel. That's just a copy of what Harry emailed to me. He was very competent, diligent, and thorough. 👍
tooterThread starterLos Angeles · Jul 8, 2012#203Finalized the flange today. 🙂 And they'll be starting on the throttle body adaptor next week. I'll be getting some scans of the 3D rendering this evening and will post an image. This is the CNC machine...
Picture not included in this copy
And this is the material for the prototype...
Picture not included in this copy
BEEFnorth carolina · Jul 8, 2012#204I may want to throw those number in excel myself (if you don't mind) that way you will see the positive and negative areas of your intake manifold once you get the second dyno. if he doesn't provide those differences I would be glad to throw it together. it would only take a few minutes.
after getting under my car, I can see where the 1.75" exhaust is really restrictive. you may want to do an exhaust thread (after you finish with this one).
how much are they charging you to run on the dyno? I want to run my car when it is all said and done with my mods. I was quoted $75 but not sure how many runs that is for. just trying to get something for comparison.
I wish I had a toy like that in my garage (the CNC machine)....I wish I had a garage. lol
tooterThread starterLos Angeles · Jul 8, 2012#205 Originally Posted by
BEEF ↑ I may want to throw those number in excel myself (if you don't mind) that way you will see the positive and negative areas of your intake manifold once you get the second dyno. if he doesn't provide those differences I would be glad to throw it together. it would only take a few minutes.
Please be my guest. 🙂
after getting under my car, I can see where the 1.75" exhaust is really restrictive. you may want to do an exhaust thread (after you finish with this one).
Sure will. 🙂
I just
can't change anything until
after the second dyno runs with the prototype manifold installed.
how much are they charging you to run on the dyno? I want to run my car when it is all said and done with my mods. I was quoted $75 but not sure how many runs that is for. just trying to get something for comparison.
It was $100 for the set of three runs... and I was happy to pay that for the service, because there is
no other objective way to accurately quantify the change in performance with the prototype manifold.
I wish I had a toy like that in my garage (the CNC machine)....I wish I had a garage. lol
It's truly an amazing tool. I'm scheduled for machine time on Tuesday, the 17th. 🙂
tooterThread starterLos Angeles · Jul 8, 2012#206Here's the 3D pics of the manifold adaptor flange...
Picture not included in this copy
Picture not included in this copy
They were done with Pro/Engineer 3D solid CAD modelling software.
If I can get time off work, I'll take a video of the machine making the part. 🙂
CrankyOldManWest Michigan · Jul 8, 2012#207 Originally Posted by
tooter ↑ They were done with Pro/Engineer 3D solid CAD modelling software.
Noooooooo!! I learned Pro/E my freshman year at school and didn't like it very much. I've heard that it's great for sheetmetal work, but it's much clunkier and difficult to do solid modeling that competing products. That said, it does accomplish the task. I'm really stoked about seeing this project come together!
tooterThread starterLos Angeles · Jul 8, 2012#208 Originally Posted by
CrankyOldMan ↑ Noooooooo!! I learned Pro/E my freshman year at school and didn't like it very much. I've heard that it's great for sheetmetal work, but it's much clunkier and difficult to do solid modeling that competing products. That said, it does accomplish the task. I'm really stoked about seeing this project come together!
I know nothing about software. As long as it generates the right information so that the machine can make a part that fits. 🙂
In this pic you can see how the two outer ports slightly angle inward to meet the offset intake ports on the head. That's why I specified a 1 inch thick flange, so that the transition between the two would be reasonably smooth.
Picture not included in this copy Here's the view fromt he other side where the transition is a little more noticeable. It's before adding the grooves for the stock O ring manifold gasket...
Picture not included in this copy BEEFnorth carolina · Jul 8, 2012#209is it really going to be an inch thick? I assume you are going to use different bolts to mount it.
tooterThread starterLos Angeles · Jul 9, 2012#210Sure. They're readily available from the hardware store. 👍
BEEFnorth carolina · Jul 9, 2012#211 Originally Posted by
tooter ↑ Just got back from the dyno shop... 🙂
Picture not included in this copy
Picture not included in this copy I think my excel sheet matches up pretty well. DATA!!!!!!!!!
tooterThread starterLos Angeles · Jul 9, 2012#212But what does it mean? 😕
BEEFnorth carolina · Jul 9, 2012#213just making sure our graphs line up. I can't wait for the second set. I am hoping to do a graph of the difference so you can see the drawbacks and advantages. I am hoping that there won't be much loss in the lower RPM range (2-3k) and a descen amount in the upper (4-5). I don't really care about 5-6k as most people don't hang out there much.
tooterThread starterLos Angeles · Jul 9, 2012#214 Originally Posted by
BEEF ↑ just making sure our graphs line up. I can't wait for the second set. I am hoping to do a graph of the difference so you can see the drawbacks and advantages. I am hoping that there won't be much loss in the lower RPM range (2-3k) and a descen amount in the upper (4-5). I don't really care about 5-6k as most people don't hang out there much.
Harry said that's likely going to happen. Definitely losses at the bottom with the possibility of gains at the top.
How much is given up at the bottom is the question we'll find out. 🙂
We drive ours around hardly going over 3,000 rpm, so it's probably not going to help us for our uses. But since we already drive the car gently, the loss shouldn't be a problem. We'll just step on the gas a little more. 😉 I'm really curious on how much the gas mileage will decrease... although there's a chance that freeway mileage might increase.
There's only
one thing we know for sure... at least it'll
look really cool. 😆
BEEFnorth carolina · Jul 9, 2012#215I really like the look of the manifold you are using. here is an example of what I am talking about. of the 3 runs, here is the deviation between the worst and the best at each point (100 RPM step). I started it at 2500 since that was the first place I had all 3 data points. just to give an idea.
Picture not included in this copy
one trace for torque and one for horespower. seems you are within around 3 hp or ft/lbs even during the steep sloped part. actually a pretty tight grouping.
tooterThread starterLos Angeles · Jul 9, 2012#216I see. That kind of graph could be especially useful to visually portray the difference between the before and after manifold runs. 👍
GolddeenohColumbia, SC · Jul 9, 2012#217BEEFnorth carolina · Jul 9, 2012#218but, but, but.......
IT'S DATAAA!!!!!!!!
Picture not included in this copy
packetraceQuebec · Jul 9, 2012#219can't wait to see it and Garm's version :D!!!
tooterThread starterLos Angeles · Jul 9, 2012#220 Originally Posted by
packetrace ↑ can't wait to see it and Garm's version :D!!!
Same here... what happened to Garm's manifold. 😕
On the 17th, I'll be holding in my hands
all the parts to make it happen. 🙂 After that the next step will be taking it to the welder, and then test fitting it on the engine. I'll be sure to post pics and videos of everything as it happens.
cali yarisCanoga Park, CA · Jul 9, 2012#221We got the final version to fit on our motor-on-a-stand, which it did. Now we're waiting on a pre-production version we can put on a test car and go dyno.
tooterThread starterLos Angeles · Jul 9, 2012#222That's cool, Garml! 🙂
We're running neck and neck.
This is getting exciting. 👍
packetraceQuebec · Jul 9, 2012#223This is sick!!! Cant wait to see it :-)
malibuguyWestminster, MD · Jul 9, 2012#224Im eggzited
tooterThread starterLos Angeles · Jul 9, 2012#225Here's the flange as the grooves are being created so that the stock Oring gasket will fit right on. 🙂
Picture not included in this copy
4/20 NEVER FORGETPortland, OR · Jul 10, 2012#226Excited to see this as well!
packetraceQuebec · Jul 10, 2012#227This is even better tooter :-)
tooterThread starterLos Angeles · Jul 10, 2012#228The idea is to replicate the OEM design as close as possible, so that I can simply bolt it on without needing to make any alterations or adjustments to anything else.
The throttle body adaptor will be grooved in exactly the same manner so as to accept the stock Oring base gasket...
Picture not included in this copy
tooterThread starterLos Angeles · Jul 10, 2012#229Here's the flange with all of the OEM gasket detailing... groovy! 😉
Picture not included in this copy
Picture not included in this copy
XFACORFL · Jul 15, 2012#230Here you go all billet.
Right-hand side inlet, shorter turbo piping = faster spool up. And a 70mm Wilson Manifold T/B
2 attachments not included in this copy
why?harnett county NC · Jul 15, 2012#231just shakes head...
Tooter man you are crazy. can't wait to see what your final results are.
tooterThread starterLos Angeles · Jul 15, 2012#232 Originally Posted by
XFACOR ↑ Here you go all billet.
Picture not included in this copy
Right-hand side inlet, shorter turbo piping = faster spool up. And a 70mm Wilson Manifold T/B
That is absolutely
beautiful detailing on your runners and their stacks, man. 👍
Mine are quite a bit more primitive... 😆
Picture not included in this copy ...but on Tuesday I'll have this...
Picture not included in this copy to attach to this...
Picture not included in this copy 🙂
XFACORFL · Jul 15, 2012#233Will be interesting to see how it comes out. Mine took 18hrs to fabricate with CNC time.
😁
tooterThread starterLos Angeles · Jul 15, 2012#234 Originally Posted by
why? ↑ Tooter man you are crazy. can't wait to see what your final results are.
Same here. 🙂
I already have a pretty good idea how this will all shake out. Lose some bottom end for sure while maybe gaining a little bit at the top end. But since this is totally uncharted territory... no one knows yet how much of either so that's what I'm aiming to find out for myself. 😉
tooterThread starterLos Angeles · Jul 15, 2012#235 Originally Posted by
XFACOR ↑ Will be interesting to see how it comes out. Mine took 18hrs to fabricate with CNC time.
😁
Wow... 18 hours. 😲
Those elongated velocity stacks are fabulous pieces of machining! I
love seeing stuff like that. They're like precious works of art. Sophisticated parts like that would take a whole lot longer being hand drilled and milled from scratch.
CNC design and execution is a beautiful combination of technology and artistry. 👍
I have absolutely no idea how long the flange will take. But it is it's pretty simple by comparison. We're only doing one to see how it will work out. They're working on the throttle body adaptor right now, but I can go ahead and get the manifold welded up and test fit on the engine next week as the TB adaptor simply bolts on as a retrofit item.
XFACORFL · Jul 15, 2012#236The runners were the most time consuming. We used oval bar stock and then split it down the center and hand fabricated them to go from the smaller dia. head flange to our much larger CNC oval velocity stack. We use no round to oval or square tubing of any kind. The plenum is CNC D-Shaped and angle tappered for the T/B. And lastly we machined our billet bungs for the direct port nitrous.
All and all I'm very happy with the out come. I saved 5ft. of turbo piping by swithcing to right-hand side T/B mount and improved overall flow of this unique system.
ViperoniBrampton, ON · Jul 16, 2012#237 Originally Posted by
XFACOR ↑ The runners were the most time consuming. We used oval bar stock and then split it down the center and hand fabricated them to go from the smaller dia. head flange to our much larger CNC oval velocity stack. We use no round to oval or square tubing of any kind. The plenum is CNC D-Shaped and angle tappered for the T/B. And lastly we machined our billet bungs for the direct port nitrous.
All and all I'm very happy with the out come. I saved 5ft. of turbo piping by swithcing to right-hand side T/B mount and improved overall flow of this unique system.
It sure looks good, can't wait to see that motor in action :)
Good stuff to tooter too, I can't wait to see the IM welded to the flange and sitting on a 1NZ :D
tooterThread starterLos Angeles · Jul 16, 2012#238If I can find enough time off work, it'll happen this coming week. 🙂
tooterThread starterLos Angeles · Jul 16, 2012#239I noticed you used a thick flange...
Picture not included in this copy
Everything hanging off of the front of the engine kind of freaked me out so I did like you did and also designed the flange to be thick (one inch), even though the manifold is quite lightweight. When I pick up everything from the shop, I'm curious to weigh it against the stock intake just to see how much difference there is.
XFACORFL · Jul 16, 2012#2403/4 to 1" is generally the rule of thumb when using a aluminum flage. Welding aluminum gets very hot so you don't want any deflection or warping. Best to set it in a jig of some kind.
I always use 1" on intake manifold.
tooterThread starterLos Angeles · Jul 16, 2012#241The CNC guys told me that aluminium stock has surface stresses from being formed, so they're milling both large surfaces a few thousandths to remove the more highly compressed material to further reduce the chance of warping during the intense localized heat of welding. Grooving to accept the stock Orings will go a long way to insure a leak free seal, because if that works for an easily deformable OEM plastic manifold, it should work great on aluminium.
This is actually a very simple project, but is a completely new experience for a total novice like me. I have to say that this has been so much fun 🙂 working out each little design detail to do my very best to cover all the bases before the actual prototype is machined.
Can't wait 'til tomorrow... 🙂
XFACORFL · Jul 16, 2012#242Your project is coming nicely Tooter. I'm sure your excited to see how it turns out. And even more excited to see how it looks in the engine bay!
tooterThread starterLos Angeles · Jul 16, 2012#243I'm pretty sure that the manifold's bling will exceed its performance. 😆
XFACORFL · Jul 16, 2012#244you never know bro.
malibuguyWestminster, MD · Jul 16, 2012#245i used to weld intake manifolds like whats on TBRs car, but for 2JZs & 2RZs...the head flange, runners & plenum baseplate had to be tightly placed/sammiched in a jig...3/8" thick steel plates on either side with 1/2" thick all thread bolted thru each runner.
With alternating welds on each runner, I would get virtually no warpage at all...requiring at most the slightest kiss on a belt sander to true it up
of course with the 'rolla intake...you cant use a jig like that
tooterThread starterLos Angeles · Jul 17, 2012#246We talked about the welding issues today...
...while the flange was being made... 👍👍👍👍👍
Picture not included in this copy
There's more pics and lots of video that I'll be uploading time permitting.
GolddeenohColumbia, SC · Jul 17, 2012#247shinny
tooterThread starterLos Angeles · Jul 18, 2012#248The flange and throttle body adaptor will both be ready to pick up on Thursday. (goody🙂)
Here's a video of the CNC machine making the flange...
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yVkFs7PlMVc This is
so exciting to watch the part being made! 🙂
Those numbers flowing down the lcd screen are the running stream of thousands of X and Y coordinates which locate the milling bit which is accurate to .0005 inch and can exert force of up to 2,000 pounds. The load graphs show minimal total spindle loading of about 3%. The part takes about 4 hours to manufacture. I'm going to try to get the parts to the welder as quickly as possible, and
may have the manifold on the engine this weekend. 👍
Bluevitz-rsOshawa, Ontario, Canada · Jul 18, 2012#249^Your link is bad... It just brought me to my OWN youtube video page.
tooterThread starterLos Angeles · Jul 18, 2012#250Try it now. The link is outside of my account. 👍