You going to smooth out the weld too?
tooter's manifold adventure...
1,454 posts · 559,522 views · page 24 of 30
Replies continued
Yes. That's the next step. I'm going to form bell mouths for the runners, but I need to be careful not to take off too much weld because that's the only thing holding the runners onto the baseplate.
smooth it out then make it Phallic for Garm. for some reason that now makes sense...
Too bad ya don't own a flow-bench so we could see the before and after results. That's gonna be huge difference. Nice job!!!!! 🤘
Sorry, no flowbench... but I am going to dyno the experimental manifold, so a few runs will show if there's actually any improvement. If not, I'll simply cut off the plenum and try something else as I also have another even more strange idea I'd like to try out if this one doesn't work.
Pure R & D is fun. 🙂
Pure R & D is fun. 🙂
I love following this thread. Keep up the good work!
Thanks, man... 🙂
This whole adventure has been no end of fun and it's not over yet.😉
Ideas are always connected to other ideas, so it's simply a matter of implementing one idea to see if it works... and if it does, choosing another idea to implement from the other ideas which are connected to the first idea.
I'm also fascinated with "microbusiness". A microbusiness has all of the qualities of a large corporation, except it operates on a very small scale. First you come up with an idea, then you design the concept, then manufacture a saleable product, then use the proceeds to buy the freedom to do the research and development to explore other ideas. 🙂
A microbusiness has one huge advantage over a large corporation. Just one person exercises complete control over the whole process from concept, to design, to finished product. So all that's necessary is for one person to have a clear vision of what they wish to accomplish, and to simply be motivated by their own curiousity to explore the possibilities.
I believe that everyone should enjoy the fun of becoming an enterpreneur by cultivating their own microbusiness... something in which they are genuinely interested, and which can be implemented on a small enough scale that they can do it "on the side". 👍
This whole adventure has been no end of fun and it's not over yet.😉
Ideas are always connected to other ideas, so it's simply a matter of implementing one idea to see if it works... and if it does, choosing another idea to implement from the other ideas which are connected to the first idea.
I'm also fascinated with "microbusiness". A microbusiness has all of the qualities of a large corporation, except it operates on a very small scale. First you come up with an idea, then you design the concept, then manufacture a saleable product, then use the proceeds to buy the freedom to do the research and development to explore other ideas. 🙂
A microbusiness has one huge advantage over a large corporation. Just one person exercises complete control over the whole process from concept, to design, to finished product. So all that's necessary is for one person to have a clear vision of what they wish to accomplish, and to simply be motivated by their own curiousity to explore the possibilities.
I believe that everyone should enjoy the fun of becoming an enterpreneur by cultivating their own microbusiness... something in which they are genuinely interested, and which can be implemented on a small enough scale that they can do it "on the side". 👍
The American dream of being your own boss.
Look forward to the dyno runs. Would be interesting to see a turbo dyno run comparison also. Once I get this employment situation under control, I'm gonna have to catch you for one of those flanges to go with my intake.
Look forward to the dyno runs. Would be interesting to see a turbo dyno run comparison also. Once I get this employment situation under control, I'm gonna have to catch you for one of those flanges to go with my intake.
Once you get a taste of piloting your own little boat... you never go back to pulling an oar down in the hull of someone else's ship. 🙂Originally Posted by jetblast ↑The American dream of being your own boss.
Look forward to the dyno runs. Would be interesting to see a turbo dyno run comparison also. Once I get this employment situation under control, I'm gonna have to catch you for one of those flanges to go with my intake.There's no rush as I always keep them in stock. 👍
I think that the Corolla manifold would excel in a forced induction situation simply because it's so much less restrictive than the stock manifold.
Met with the CNC guys today and the 1ZZ throttle body base plate is in the works. 🙂
We came up with a simple practical design that will fulfill two purposes. The first purpose is of course the tooter e. t. manifold. And the second purpose is to make it possible to install a larger 55mm 1ZZ throttle body onto a Blitz supercharger.
Installation would involve cutting off the existing 1NZ 46mm flange with a hack saw, and welding on the 1ZZ 55mm throttle body base plate which will work for both the 46mm and 55mm throttle bodies. The smaller entrance to the SC would need to be flared out with a file or a Dremel to smoothly transition to the larger bore of the base plate.
The combination throttle body base plate/bellmouth will be 2 inches thick, with the top inch being the square 4 threaded stud base with the O ring gasket groove just like the original tooter adapter plate...
Picture not included in this copy
The bottom one inch will be a continuation of the 55mm diameter throat smoothly terminating at a rounded bellmouth profile similar to these...
Picture not included in this copy
...except that the outside diameter of the mouth will be exactly the same as the outside diameter of the intake. This combination base plate/bellmouth could be also easily be attached to any custom fabricated plenum if someone was building their own custom intake manifold from scratch.
I'm only having one extra made as I have no idea if there is any interest in this new product. It'll be $165 including shipping, so let me know now if anyone wants dibs on it. 😉
We came up with a simple practical design that will fulfill two purposes. The first purpose is of course the tooter e. t. manifold. And the second purpose is to make it possible to install a larger 55mm 1ZZ throttle body onto a Blitz supercharger.
Installation would involve cutting off the existing 1NZ 46mm flange with a hack saw, and welding on the 1ZZ 55mm throttle body base plate which will work for both the 46mm and 55mm throttle bodies. The smaller entrance to the SC would need to be flared out with a file or a Dremel to smoothly transition to the larger bore of the base plate.
The combination throttle body base plate/bellmouth will be 2 inches thick, with the top inch being the square 4 threaded stud base with the O ring gasket groove just like the original tooter adapter plate...
Picture not included in this copy
The bottom one inch will be a continuation of the 55mm diameter throat smoothly terminating at a rounded bellmouth profile similar to these...
Picture not included in this copy
...except that the outside diameter of the mouth will be exactly the same as the outside diameter of the intake. This combination base plate/bellmouth could be also easily be attached to any custom fabricated plenum if someone was building their own custom intake manifold from scratch.
I'm only having one extra made as I have no idea if there is any interest in this new product. It'll be $165 including shipping, so let me know now if anyone wants dibs on it. 😉
Thanks for posting that, Viper. RacerX has some very clever ideas. 👍
Notice the first manifold is the stock cast MR2 runners with their own custom plenum design attached to them And note the V8 Mustang throttle body base plate bore. It must be 80mm! 😲
Picture not included in this copy
The straight runners are so long on the last manifold it's a cold air plenum because it's located in the trunk. 🙂
Picture not included in this copy
I've found a few others doing the same thing while searching the internet for manifold inspiration. Every other manufacturer I've seen starts with a basic one inch CNC baseplate as the foundation for their designs. That's the beauty of aluminium. It's cheap, light, and easy to machine and to weld. 👍
Notice the first manifold is the stock cast MR2 runners with their own custom plenum design attached to them And note the V8 Mustang throttle body base plate bore. It must be 80mm! 😲
Picture not included in this copy
The straight runners are so long on the last manifold it's a cold air plenum because it's located in the trunk. 🙂
Picture not included in this copy
I've found a few others doing the same thing while searching the internet for manifold inspiration. Every other manufacturer I've seen starts with a basic one inch CNC baseplate as the foundation for their designs. That's the beauty of aluminium. It's cheap, light, and easy to machine and to weld. 👍
Dragging out an old post from page 38-ish to ask a few questions.Originally Posted by tooter ↑Picture not included in this copy
So the ingredients to make this intake are:
Weapon R Dragon Short Ram polished aluminium intake tube, cut in half
BLOX 2.5" x 6" Velocity stack, mounting flange cut short
BLOX dry 6" matching dry element air filter
black 2.5" 90 degree coupling, ends trimmed short
black 2.25" straight coupling, trimmed short
These make a smooth flowing very low restriction intake. 👍
I specifically chose the Weapon R tube because the MAF sensor mount is very close to the throttle body, and so could allow for severe cutting while still retaining its operational integrity.
- Could you use the stock MAF tube instead of chopping the Weapon R?
- How does the quality of the BLOX compare to other less expensive kit, e.g. the stuff at AutoZone/AutoValue/NAPA/etc?
- Does having the stock MAF on a 2.5" tube cause issues? I was told (on these forums) that the slower air velocity in a larger diameter tube would lead to wonky behavior from the ECU. I'm assuming you haven't had issues to this point, yes?
As long as the MAF is in a tube the same size as stock, it doesn't make any difference what size the pipe is on either side of it.
Sure. Why not? 🙂Originally Posted by CrankyOldMan ↑Dragging out an old post from page 38-ish to ask a few questions.
- Could you use the stock MAF tube instead of chopping the Weapon R?No, it wouldn't work because the Weapon R intake tube adapts the 2.5 BLOX velocity stack to the 2.25 throttle body flange. And second, the rubber intake tube isn't rigid enough to support the freestanding stack and filter...
Picture not included in this copy
- How does the quality of the BLOX compare to other less expensive kit, e.g. the stuff at AutoZone/AutoValue/NAPA/etc?I don't know about any of the other stuff, but BLOX is first rate. The intake profile is parabolic, and is complete to 180 degrees. It's a beautifully simple practical design...
Picture not included in this copy
I especially like the BLOX dry filter as it has no oil issues. It perfectly seals the stack and removes instantly and easily for cleaning.
- Does having the stock MAF on a 2.5" tube cause issues?Nope, no issues whatsoever. 🙂
This is because the tube the MAF is in is 2.25". You can see the reduction in diameter takes place in front of the MAF.
I was told (on these forums) that the slower air velocity in a larger diameter tube would lead to wonky behavior from the ECU. I'm assuming you haven't had issues to this point, yes?You were told correctly. The intake diameter can be anything you want upstream...
...as long as it reduces down to the proper 2.25 diameter where the air flows over the MAF. 👍
Since I'm here, I took a whack at grinding one of the runner entrances. The amount of weld I can remove is limited so as not to weaken the manifold, but at least I was successful in removing the protruding weld swirls as I'm sure they cause turbulence right at the critical point of entry. I was also able to open up the entrance a bit wider for a freer flow.
Picture not included in this copy
This is before for contrast...
Picture not included in this copy
Damn that Blox venturi is sexy. Smoooooooth flow!!!
So if the air all has to flow through the narrower section, doesn't it negate the larger diameters in front of/behind the MAF? I haven't done fluid mechanics yet, so I'm just going off what I've read/heard/seen.Originally Posted by tooter ↑...as long as it reduces down to the proper 2.25 diameter where the air flows over the MAF. 👍
Impedance to flow is also a function of length. The MAF section is 4 inches long and the only element of every Yaris intake that is absolutely necessary if you don't want to be throwing codes. However, you could experiment with larger tubing, MAF sensor, and a matching ECU from a larger engine just to see if it might work. 🙂Originally Posted by CrankyOldMan ↑So if the air all has to flow through the narrower section, doesn't it negate the larger diameters in front of/behind the MAF? I haven't done fluid mechanics yet, so I'm just going off what I've read/heard/seen.
Any progress?
Yes. 🙂
We arrived at a really neato design and I should have the new throttle body base plates any day now. The CNC machinists have been very busy so they fit me in when they have the time because my parts are such small runs. I can't wait to get them and will post pics as soon as they're done.
This tooter is going to be a very strange one! 😆
We arrived at a really neato design and I should have the new throttle body base plates any day now. The CNC machinists have been very busy so they fit me in when they have the time because my parts are such small runs. I can't wait to get them and will post pics as soon as they're done.
This tooter is going to be a very strange one! 😆
toot toot!
There's nothing wrong with them. 🙂 I still stock and sell them with the complete manifolds and with the flanges in the Build-Your-Own-Manifold kits.Originally Posted by TOLMACH ↑What was wrong with the old plate? The one I used was pretty awesome
But I'm totally into experimenting now... 😆
Picture not included in this copy
...with a completely new scratch built plenum for the tooter. So it needs a radically different design throttle body base.
Smooth flow is what I'm fascinated with. There's a certain inherent beauty in flow design. It's like creating a work of art. 🙂Originally Posted by jetblast ↑Damn that Blox venturi is sexy. Smoooooooth flow!!!
You need to change the name to "Titter", It is at least a DD! 👍 The boobie intakeOriginally Posted by tooter ↑There's nothing wrong with them. 🙂 I still stock and sell them with the complete manifolds and with the flanges in the Build-Your-Own-Manifold kits.
But I'm totally into experimenting now... 😆
Picture not included in this copy
...with a completely new scratch built plenum for the tooter. So it needs a radically different design throttle body base.
The Enterprise D
The 1ZZ ready "nipple" will be arriving soon... 😆Originally Posted by Flipper_1938 ↑You need to change the name to "Titter", It is at least a DD! 👍 The boobie intake
The new tooter throttle body base is now being created... 🤤
Picture not included in this copy
(this is so fucking exciting... 🙂 )
Picture not included in this copy
(this is so fucking exciting... 🙂 )
Sure looks fun. You have your own CNC machine?
No, but he's hired someone that does. This is all out-of-pocket expense for him, just to find out if it works. If you've got time, I recommend going through the whole thread to see how it's gotten to this stage.Originally Posted by JustDidIt ↑Sure looks fun. You have your own CNC machine?
Right now they're cutting the bellmouths on the back sides of the throttle body bases. They're like beautiful works of art... 🙂
Picture not included in this copy
Picture not included in this copy
That's right, Cranky. I have neither the skills or the machine. The CNC guys are the real wizards. They take my concepts and turn them into reality. It's a totally fascinating creative process that is as interesting as the finished products. And I can tell you from first hand experience... the curiosity to find out what happens can get expensive, but since I'm already totally hooked on exploring the unknown, I just have to keep going in order to find out. 😉Originally Posted by CrankyOldMan ↑No, but he's hired someone that does. This is all out-of-pocket expense for him, just to find out if it works. If you've got time, I recommend going through the whole thread to see how it's gotten to this stage.
I pick up the parts this afternoon. The second throttle body base will be done then. 🙂
Picture not included in this copy
This is my inspiration for the design...
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DGH6cm0XsTg
If it works one way... it'll work the other way. 😉
Picture not included in this copy
This is my inspiration for the design...
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DGH6cm0XsTg
If it works one way... it'll work the other way. 😉
They turned out beautifully... 🙂
Picture not included in this copy
Picture not included in this copy
This throttle body base plate also has a secondary function in that it makes it easy to install a 1ZZ throttle body onto any 1NZ supercharger. Just cut off the old baseplate with a hacksaw, flare out the end of the supercharger's intake with a grinder, and weld this one onto the intake.
Picture not included in this copy
Picture not included in this copy
This is a mockup of the et manifold layout...
Picture not included in this copy
Picture not included in this copy
Picture not included in this copy
This throttle body base plate also has a secondary function in that it makes it easy to install a 1ZZ throttle body onto any 1NZ supercharger. Just cut off the old baseplate with a hacksaw, flare out the end of the supercharger's intake with a grinder, and weld this one onto the intake.
Picture not included in this copy
Picture not included in this copy
This is a mockup of the et manifold layout...
Picture not included in this copy
Awesome.
This thread is awesome.
This thread is awesome.
I find this creative process itself to be MORE fascinating than the end products. These ideas are literally being dreamed up. But that's no guarantee that they'll work! 😆 What interests me is finding out what will happen if I do what I dream up, and to always be open to the next idea. Creativity is not a static terminal closed event arriving at a fixed destination. It's a constantly evolving flow of innovation...
...and it's no end of fun following that slender silver thread of interest just to see where it leads. 🙂
...and it's no end of fun following that slender silver thread of interest just to see where it leads. 🙂
That's the beauty of doing this in a non-production environment: there's no pressure to produce, no minimum performance to achieve, and no backlash if it doesn't meet those performance goals. I think that's what ultimately killed Mr. Holdener's project, so it's very impressive to see this continuing to evolve and still generate some commercial activity.Originally Posted by tooter ↑Creativity is not a static terminal closed event arriving at a fixed destination. It's a constantly evolving flow of innovation...
Yes. I followed Richard's project with great interest. His manifold was scarcely any different from the design of the Golden Eagle or Weapon R manifolds as they all went down the same well worn path by following exactly the same basic cookie cutter pattern.Originally Posted by CrankyOldMan ↑That's the beauty of doing this in a non-production environment: there's no pressure to produce, no minimum performance to achieve, and no backlash if it doesn't meet those performance goals. I think that's what ultimately killed Mr. Holdener's project, so it's very impressive to see this continuing to evolve and still generate some commercial activity.
I heard a great joke about clicking TV remote controls that holds within it a great insight:
"Women want to know what's on TV... while men want to know what else is on TV.
I want to find out what ELSE is on TV... 🙂
...and I've sold enough manifolds and kits and individual parts to be able to afford the luxury of some pure R & D. And now that I have a 2012 Tacoma with a 2.7 4 cylinder, I'm already working on designing a new tooter product for it that no one else has ever produced. You have no idea just how much fun letting your attention flow from one thing to another just for its own sake of the fun of exploration. 🙂
This is the pure beauty of a microbusiness.
It's an artform...
...a blank canvas upon which you are free to paint any picture you choose. I answer to no one. As the "CEO", I'm totally autonomous to make my own decisions, and totally free to leave the beaten path to explore my own interests because I have my own regular business for 32 years that puts bread on the table.
Here's a video of the throttle body bellmouth being machined...
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8gfM93R81Xs
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8gfM93R81Xs
they all went down the same well worn path by following exactly the same basic cookie cutter pattern.Yes - because it works and makes power. Additional power was our non-negotiable goal in order to market the product, and we were very careful to do the math first on runner length.
The math tells you what to do.
Your goal is simply to "find out", and you are on your second round (or more) of that process. It's fun to follow!
Of course, Garm. It's not Golden Eagle's aim to explore or to innovate, but to make their product by utilizing a preexisting design.Originally Posted by cali yaris ↑Yes - because it works and makes power.
That's the difference between what's on TV... and what else is on TV.
(by the way, you still haven't produced that 7 hp dyno graph 😉 )
It's not Golden Eagle's aim to explore or to innovate, but to make their product by utilizing a preexisting design.Correct. My design. From drawings produced by collaborating with an engineer. I have the files, which predate my "competitor's" claims by well over a year.
What went on with dates and competitors is something else entirely. That is only between you and others, and has absolutely nothing to do with me. I was only referring to the basic similarity of the Golden Eagle, Weapon R, and Richard Holdener manifolds because they all follow the same accepted well-travelled parameters of intake manifold design.Originally Posted by cali yaris ↑Correct. My design. From drawings produced by collaborating with an engineer. I have the files, which predate my "competitor's" claims by well over a year.
I'm more interested in what else is outside of those parameters. 🙂
^ We all are -- and like I said, it's fun to watch you experiment. So far, you're proving that the "same accepted well-travelled patterns" are such for a reason; they get measurable results.
(The WeaponR did not by the way, as far as I've been able to tell).
Maybe ET will show us something new. 🙂
(The WeaponR did not by the way, as far as I've been able to tell).
Maybe ET will show us something new. 🙂
Since you mentioned measurable results, what happened to that 7hp dyno graph, Garm? 😉Originally Posted by cali yaris ↑So far, you're proving that the "same accepted well-travelled patterns" are such for a reason; they get measurable results.
^ I explained that. Clearly. Remember? The fact that you keep bringing it up is telling, in my opinion.
A peak of 7hp is not as impressive (and shouldn't be) than a dyno pull that shows a smaller peak, but useful power gains through a larger range.
The Weapon R manifold, as tested on an xB, lost power. Using the phrase "cookie cutter" is an unfair and specious comparison to a product that got a different (and much better) result, in an attempt to lump them together. One clearly was just made to fit the motor, and the other was created from calculations and performance design considerations. The results speak for themselves.
Maybe we can just leave it there, so we can get back to watching your experiments, which I think are cool -- it is your thread, after all.
A peak of 7hp is not as impressive (and shouldn't be) than a dyno pull that shows a smaller peak, but useful power gains through a larger range.
The Weapon R manifold, as tested on an xB, lost power. Using the phrase "cookie cutter" is an unfair and specious comparison to a product that got a different (and much better) result, in an attempt to lump them together. One clearly was just made to fit the motor, and the other was created from calculations and performance design considerations. The results speak for themselves.
Maybe we can just leave it there, so we can get back to watching your experiments, which I think are cool -- it is your thread, after all.
Yes. This is what you said:Originally Posted by cali yaris ↑^ I explained that. Clearly. Remember?
We did several pulls, this one showed the best distribution of power gains, but not the greatest power gains.
Then I said why not post the chart showing everyone that 7hp gain, and then you said that you wouldn't do it.
It's totally understandable why Golden Eagle would want their product to be presented to the public in the very best light possible. Every marketer does exactly that. So it's perfectly natural not to want to disclose anything that could adversely affect that favorable image. It's clear that other graph might do just that, because if it did not, it would have been posted long ago. So it is obviously in your own best interest (and Golden Eagle's too) to freely choose not to post the graph even if it means leaving a hp claim undocumented.
Everyone weighs in their own balance choices that are of a similar nature as this one... and it is these choices which make life interesting. 🙂
1. We only kept one dyno chart, the best one in my judgement. I stand by it, and the customer feedback has been excellent in terms of noticeable power gains and ease of installation.
If you don't believe that we got 7hp on one pull, that is significant, tooter; most people that know or buy from me by now trust me to tell the truth. Do you?
2. Golden Eagle is a fabricator. They didn't design, nor do they "market" the product. They had nothing to do with our design or testing, nor do they have a copy of the dyno results. We do that. I am the co-designer, and my company markets the product.
If you don't believe that we got 7hp on one pull, that is significant, tooter; most people that know or buy from me by now trust me to tell the truth. Do you?
2. Golden Eagle is a fabricator. They didn't design, nor do they "market" the product. They had nothing to do with our design or testing, nor do they have a copy of the dyno results. We do that. I am the co-designer, and my company markets the product.
Alright you two stop kicking sand. :) Garm you get the Tonka dumptruck, and Tooter you get the Tonka bulldozer. Now play nice in the sandbox! Please. Thanks to both of you for your time and efforts, and risks. I think I speak for many in that we all greatly appreciate the cool stuff you guys do. This community is blessed to have you guys around.
Thank You Both!!!!!!!!!
Thank You Both!!!!!!!!!
Picture not included in this copy
But... but... I want the bulldozer. 😢