Replies continued
tooterThread starterLos Angeles · Mar 10, 2013#1101 Originally Posted by
CrankyOldMan ↑ I had contemplated that, but then I would have to figure out how to weld up a rounded-square body. My idea was to match the radius of the base with some tubing, cut it into quarters, and weld panels between them. Given my lack of welding skill but substantial access to machining equipment, the tube + flanges seemed to make the most sense. It would still require someone to weld the seams, but tube-in-a-hole is easier than plates-hanging-in-space.
The solution to that is simple.
A 6 inch diameter circular aluminium plate with a rounded square hole cut in the middle of it. I know a really competent welder who can weld anything. The secret to any project is finding good honest people who you can trust. 🙂
mr_milesPortland, OR · Mar 10, 2013#1102I love this thread. I wish I was closer so that i could help :/
tooterThread starterLos Angeles · Mar 10, 2013#1103That would be lots of fun... 🙂
Well, at least I can keep you posted every step of the way. I just ordered a part for the manifold plenum, and will post pics when it arrives. It's something which has absolutely no relation to engines, and I'm adapting it to an unintended purpose. 😉
As far as I can tell from searching the web for everything about intake manifold design I could find... no one has built the design I'm going to try. There may be a reason. Because it doesn't work! 😆 But I'm going to find that out for myself. I'm building one manifold designated for testing only. And the good part is that if the experimental designs don't show any gains on the dyno, I can always simply cut them off of the runners and try something else. 👍
Flipper_1938Kentucky · Mar 10, 2013#1104If you are going to try a really large diameter plenum...large diameter equals low velocity.
tooterThread starterLos Angeles · Mar 10, 2013#1105 Originally Posted by
Flipper_1938 ↑ If you are going to try a really large diameter plenum...large diameter equals low velocity.
No, I won't be doing that. First off, there's no room for a larger plenum with this particular manifold design while keeping the air filter under the hood. And second I don't want to go larger. Instead, I'm going to a smaller plenum. The existing one is already almost non existent with that big thick intake tube occupying so much volume...
Picture not included in this copy ...and yet that design works
great! 🙂I believe it is because of the unique configuration with
all the runner entrances pointing
directly at the bore of the throttle body...
Picture not included in this copy That internal intake tube terminates only a couple of inches in front ot the runner's entrances. So there is
very little plenum volume left over.
When I get the part, I'll be able to measure exactly how much smaller if at all by filling both plenums with water. What will be
radically different is the
profile of the new plenum. I literally dreamed up this crazy idea... 😉
JustDidItUnited States · Mar 11, 2013#1106 Originally Posted by
tooter ↑ I know a really competent welder who can weld anything. The secret to any project is finding good honest people who you can trust. 🙂
Hey Tooter, I need to come up 2 LA and meet this welder of yours. I have a project I would like to run by him. Whereabouts is he located?
tooterThread starterLos Angeles · Mar 11, 2013#1107 Originally Posted by
JustDidIt ↑ Hey Tooter, I need to come up 2 LA and meet this welder of yours. I have a project I would like to run by him. Whereabouts is he located?
Sure. 🙂
Ajax's
7933 Gloria Avenue
Van Nuys, CA 91406
818-781-5667
Bill is the owner.
Tell him tooter sent you. 👍
His place is easy to get to as it's just West of the 405 off the Roscoe Boulevard exit.
West on Roscoe
South on Woodley
East on Strathern
South on Gloria
JustDidItUnited States · Mar 11, 2013#1108 Originally Posted by
tooter ↑ Sure. 🙂
Ajax's
7933 Gloria Avenue
Van Nuys, CA 91406
818-781-5667
Bill is the owner.
Tell him tooter sent you. 👍
His place is easy to get to as it's just West of the 405 off the Roscoe Boulevard exit.
West on Roscoe
South on Woodley
East on Strathern
South on Gloria
Awesome! Thank you!
Bluevitz-rsOshawa, Ontario, Canada · Mar 11, 2013#1109Cool Tooter! Are you reworking the manifold with your own plenum and TB mount?
tooterThread starterLos Angeles · Mar 11, 2013#1110 Originally Posted by
Bluevitz-rs ↑ Cool Tooter! Are you reworking the manifold with your own plenum and TB mount?
Yes. 🙂
I have a totally "outside the box" idea and am going to build up a tooter and dyno it just to see how the concept works.
tooterThread starterLos Angeles · Mar 15, 2013#1111The new plenum came today, and it has nothing to do with intake manifolds. It's a structural architectural ornament. 😉 This is the basic layout of the experimental tooter...
Picture not included in this copy
Picture not included in this copy
Picture not included in this copy
Picture not included in this copy
I filled up both plenums with water to test the volume, and was totally suprised to discover that they both hold exactly 26 ounces! 😲 I'm always looking for omens and this is a really good one... 🙂
Picture not included in this copy
The old plenum appears to be a lot larger because there is so much material inside it which by displacement decreases the volume.
cali yarisCanoga Park, CA · Mar 15, 2013#1112Phallic!
tooterThread starterLos Angeles · Mar 15, 2013#1113To you, everything is phallic. 😉
CrankyOldManWest Michigan · Mar 15, 2013#1114Hmm, what about the 6" tube remnant?
tooterThread starterLos Angeles · Mar 15, 2013#1115It's right here... 🙂
Picture not included in this copy
I think I'll try it without this time since the two plenum volumes already match. I can always cut off the hemisphere and add a ring later. And while the plenum is off I can clean up and smooth out the runner entrances.
Picture not included in this copy
CrankyOldManWest Michigan · Mar 16, 2013#1116 Originally Posted by
tooter ↑ And while the plenum is off I can clean up and smooth out the runner entrances.
Yikes, those are some gnarly welds for a flow surface.
Thinking back to my own can-shaped design, the flow analysis showed that there was pretty much no air movement in the shoulder area of the TB side.
tooterThread starterLos Angeles · Mar 16, 2013#1117Well, remember that it was just a mass produced Corolla manifold and not a high performance racing component. The welds are actually well controlled, but I do think I can improve the runner ports with the trusty old Dremel... something that no manufacturer would take the time to do because there's no return on investment.
malibuguyWestminster, MD · Mar 18, 2013#1118they welded them like that for easy access & it smooths out the lip that would be there if they were externally welded
xnamerxxso cal · Mar 18, 2013#1119^ that and it would be next to impossible to weld them externally.
JustDidItUnited States · Mar 18, 2013#1120Interesting... whats the next step??
malibuguyWestminster, MD · Mar 19, 2013#1121 Originally Posted by
JustDidIt ↑ Interesting... whats the next step??
procharger 😆
tooterThread starterLos Angeles · Mar 19, 2013#1122 Originally Posted by
JustDidIt ↑ Interesting... whats the next step??
I don't exactly know just yet... I'm thinking about it while finishing another regular tooter.
For sure, I'll need to have a plain throttle body base plate made and figure out a way to attach it securely as the aluminium hemisphere shell is pretty thin. I was thinking of a short bellmouth on the inside like this extending a couple of inches into the center of the hemisphere directly aligned with the axis of the 4 runners so the flow is a straight line.
Picture not included in this copy The throttle plate will use the same CNC information for the outer surface minus all of the adaption machining. It'll be one inch thick to raise the throttle body enough for the chip to clear the hemisphere.
Picture not included in this copy Here a flow simulation for a bell mouth...
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jFwo_3IxZyo If it works one way... it'll also work the other. 🙂
Bluevitz-rsOshawa, Ontario, Canada · Mar 19, 2013#1123P.S. Tooter, you can clip that wire screen out of the gasket. Someone here flow benched a TB with and without it and it just causes restriction.
tooterThread starterLos Angeles · Mar 20, 2013#1124 Originally Posted by
Bluevitz-rs ↑ P.S. Tooter, you can clip that wire screen out of the gasket. Someone here flow benched a TB with and without it and it just causes restriction.
How many cfm difference did it make at WOT?
I was told that the screen helps to break up the positive crankcase venting oil fumes. Whenever a manufacturer makes a more expensive casting to fit a more expensive part, they have a good reason to do it. 👍
Bluevitz-rsOshawa, Ontario, Canada · Mar 20, 2013#1125If you were at all concerned about emissions you would have left the stock airbox in with the charcoal pre-filter. But no, that screen is there to make the air turbulent as it enters the stock plastic intake manifold.
tooterThread starterLos Angeles · Mar 20, 2013#1126 Originally Posted by
Bluevitz-rs ↑ If you were at all concerned about emissions you would have left the stock airbox in with the charcoal pre-filter. But no, that screen is there to make the air turbulent as it enters the stock plastic intake manifold.
Hey Blue... take a look at this flow simulation. 🙂
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WzWsUB79e-A And look at this one that shows the difference in the timing of the air flow past each side of the butterfly...
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k-MN6igceog Notice how the flow on the backside of the butterfly is way more turbulent than the tipped in side. This means that the screen actually helps to stabilize the turbulence the back side. 👍
The person who did the flow testing must have had an instrument that generated a numerical comparison. Do you know how much cubic feet per minute that difference was?
Here's another one showing what happens on the backside of a butterfly in the flat position...
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0z_hFZx7qvE A screen would help to stabilize the flow by breaking up those rotating eddys.
I've watched a lot of these simulations over and over again to help me to understand the dynamics of flow. It's totally fascinating. 🙂
Bluevitz-rsOshawa, Ontario, Canada · Mar 20, 2013#1127I think it it was only a cfm more but didn't know about the airflow thing. Maybe it's better to leave it in then. I guess it's more of a part throttle thing than full throttle.
tooterThread starterLos Angeles · Mar 20, 2013#1128 Originally Posted by
Bluevitz-rs ↑ I think it it was only a cfm more but didn't know about the airflow thing. Maybe it's better to leave it in then. I guess it's more of a part throttle thing than full throttle.
I'm pretty sure you're right. I had already cut the screen off of on a O ring just to see what would happen and couldn't feel any difference, so I put another gasket back in with the screen.
tooterThread starterLos Angeles · Mar 28, 2013#1129Just finished up another tooter today... 🙂
Picture not included in this copy
Picture not included in this copy
Picture not included in this copy
We start on the throttle body base plate for the experimental tooter next week...
Picture not included in this copy
Picture not included in this copy
The design will combine the base plate and reverse velocity stack together in one part. Then I'll drill a hole in the hemisphere and have it welded into place.
CrankyOldManWest Michigan · Mar 28, 2013#1130It's like necromancy, but with beautiful results!
junorico24Sydney · Mar 28, 2013#1131Looks like something from star ship enterprise.
tooterThread starterLos Angeles · Mar 28, 2013#1132 Originally Posted by
junorico24 ↑ Looks like something from star ship enterprise.
Yeah, it does sort of have that retro-futuristic space look... 😉
Picture not included in this copy I'll call it the tooter e.t. 😛
cali yarisCanoga Park, CA · Mar 28, 2013#1133rather phallic if you were to ask me... 😉
tooterThread starterLos Angeles · Mar 28, 2013#1134I didn't ask because I already know the answer... 😛
Bluevitz-rsOshawa, Ontario, Canada · Mar 28, 2013#1135 Originally Posted by
cali yaris ↑ rather phallic if you were to ask me... 😉
I had to look that word up LMAO!
cali yarisCanoga Park, CA · Mar 29, 2013#1136Picture not included in this copy
tooterThread starterLos Angeles · Mar 29, 2013#1137Flipper_1938Kentucky · Mar 29, 2013#1138 Originally Posted by
cali yaris ↑ rather phallic if you were to ask me... 😉
The "Richard Cranium Special"
mr_milesPortland, OR · Mar 29, 2013#1139 Originally Posted by
cali yaris ↑ Picture not included in this copy
I lol'd and now my coworker is looking at me funny
cali yarisCanoga Park, CA · Mar 29, 2013#1140haha, nice. but I got us off-topic. Back to the tooter-penis-project-thing.
Bluevitz-rsOshawa, Ontario, Canada · Mar 29, 2013#1141I just LOL!
tooterThread starterLos Angeles · Mar 29, 2013#1142 Originally Posted by
cali yaris ↑ haha, nice. but I got us off-topic. Back to the tooter-penis-project-thing.
Yes. 🙂
I started doing a little preliminary grinding on one of the runner entrances not wanting to remove too much of the weld so as not to weaken the manifold...
Picture not included in this copy And now that I'm going with the hemisphere, I can remove the rest of the square plenum. That will make it much easier to shape the runner entrances as it is impeding getting the Dremel at the proper angle.
JustDidItUnited States · Mar 29, 2013#1143LOL...Speaking of phallic symbols and alcohol...Hold up... need to shoot a pickleback...
jetblastNor Cal · Mar 29, 2013#1144Five things ya don't wanna hear when you open your hood.....
1) Hey big boy.
2) Is that your intake, or are ya just happy to see me?
3) Whip it! Whip it good, as the Devo music plays.
4) Shwing!
5) Damn, thought I at least had five......
tooterThread starterLos Angeles · Mar 29, 2013#1145Here's a comparison between the runners...
Picture not included in this copy
Picture not included in this copy
The welds do overhang the entrances quite a bit, so removing them should improve the flow.
malibuguyWestminster, MD · Mar 30, 2013#1146That tooter looks great! Your experimental one looks like a jelly fish :p
jetblastNor Cal · Mar 30, 2013#1147Better start making some porting templates. I would be interested to see what the physical diameter gains are. Looks like a nice improvement.
tooterThread starterLos Angeles · Mar 30, 2013#1148Porting to the existing runner size increases the entrance diameter from 38mm to 40mm because the welds overhang a little more than 1mm all the way around. This nets a gain in the cross sectional area of just a little over 11%. 👍
After all the overhanging welds have been removed, I'm going to smooth out and profile the entrances to more of a "bell" shape which should improve the flow even more. 🙂
tooterThread starterLos Angeles · Mar 30, 2013#1149 Originally Posted by
malibuguy ↑ That tooter looks great! Your experimental one looks like a jelly fish :p
Sort of does. Maybe I should call it the "tooter squid"... although that name has negative connotations. It may end up earning the name squid after I get the dyno results! 😆
tooterThread starterLos Angeles · Mar 30, 2013#1150Cut the rest of the plenum off so that I could get the Dremel into the runner ports better...
Picture not included in this copy
Also gound off all the overhanging welds, and stainless steel bead blasted everything. This evens out all the grinding marks and will make it much easier to see the shapes of the ports while I'm grinding the bell mouths.
Before grinding...
Picture not included in this copy
...and after.
Picture not included in this copy