guess I'm the odd man out. I absolutely refuse to lose low-end torque for high end gains. I like my torque to jump off the line. I do mostly city driving so I like having that oomph to take off from stop lights.
tooter's manifold adventure...
1,454 posts · 559,522 views · page 15 of 30
Replies continued
^ So, for your needs, flywheel > intake manifold 👍
yup. that's also why I just ordered the lightweight crank pulley from you, want to free up some torque.
Is it 11:00 over there yet?
12:37pm
wow look at that beautiful weather
We are facing Tropical Storm Issac right now
We are facing Tropical Storm Issac right now
i was falling asleep at my desk, til i remembered today is the day.
logged on
and now i'm going back to sleep
logged on
and now i'm going back to sleep
^ I'm calling your boss.
OK guys... the suspense is finally over. 🙂
The tooter manifold is officially all show and no go. 🙄
Here's the results for the wagering pool:
+1 peak horsepower -1 peak torque
Now who's going to break the news to Billiam that he didn't win! 😆
While the peaks were very close, the tooter gave up performance everywhere else except for a few places. I'll post the graph when I get in from work this evening.
The tooter manifold is officially all show and no go. 🙄
Here's the results for the wagering pool:
+1 peak horsepower -1 peak torque
Now who's going to break the news to Billiam that he didn't win! 😆
While the peaks were very close, the tooter gave up performance everywhere else except for a few places. I'll post the graph when I get in from work this evening.
^ You get BIG LARGE respect for seeing this through.
and what timing... we get our working prototype tomorrow. 👍
to... be.... continued!
and what timing... we get our working prototype tomorrow. 👍
to... be.... continued!
👏🙇
What, only +1hp/-1tq... What about all of the glowing reviews from your butt dyno. 😆Originally Posted by tooter ↑OK guys... the suspense is finally over. 🙂
The tooter manifold is officially all show and no go. 🙄
Here's the results for the wagering pool:
+1 peak horsepower -1 peak torque
Now who's going to break the news to Billiam that he didn't win! 😆
While the peaks were very close, the tooter gave up performance everywhere else except for a few places. I'll post the graph when I get in from work this evening.
sorry to hear that, but still, cool project.
the fact that you did go through with it all is a big deal. you're just a guy, not a big company. that does make a difference too.
all in all, an awesome project. it does still look impressive under the hood too. and currently nobody has one like yours.
all in all, an awesome project. it does still look impressive under the hood too. and currently nobody has one like yours.
BULLSH!T....I want a recount. 🙄Originally Posted by tooter ↑Now who's going to break the news to Billiam that he didn't win! 😆
Picture not included in this copyPicture not included in this copy
Psycological like most butt dynos.Originally Posted by Jason@SportsCar ↑What, only +1hp/-1tq... What about all of the glowing reviews from your butt dyno. 😆
That's too bad tooter. Was really hoping for something atleast on par to what CAI/SRI gives.
Now bling that sucker up and bask in your sculpture.
It was a good effort. If someone isn't the first to try, and often fail, we never learn. 👍
not so bad man!!!I want that HP hahaha
I wouldn't call the manifold a failure till we see the dyno, just because the power output is low on a stock engine doesn't mean it won't work wonders on a non stock application.
I'm with xnamerxx, Turbo set up will benefit the most, especially for systems that are going beyond the 20 or so psi (I think that is the number i remember reading) that the plastic box limits it's self to. either way still a cool product.
can we get a re post of the guesses to see how close everyone was. I don't even remember what i had put.
can we get a re post of the guesses to see how close everyone was. I don't even remember what i had put.
Good job on seeing that project through. It was a lot of fun to watch.
Next you should swap the TB to a Corolla throttle body :)
Next you should swap the TB to a Corolla throttle body :)
would you mine doing an other dyno run..without the 90 degree....and so just the velocity stack....it wont hurt the car for just a dyno run :P or maybe but a net around it
He probably would...if you paid for it 😉Originally Posted by packetrace ↑would you mine doing an other dyno run..without the 90 degree....and so just the velocity stack....
lol noOriginally Posted by WeeYari ↑He probably would...if you paid for it 😉
thats why I asked would you mind to....
I still applaud you for getting it out of your head and onto the car 👏👏👏👏👏
is THAT why i got a stack of work to do now?!?!?!Originally Posted by cali yaris ↑^ I'm calling your boss.
Tooter: thanks for trying this out man. 👏
Garm: prototype? huh? I don't want to thread jack, so can you link me any links. Just not sausage links!!!!
Good effort, too bad it didn't make more power. A mad props for going beginning to end on it :)
So I win? I got hp right and was off 2 torques.
Here's a comparative chart of the best of the basline runs and the best of the tooter runs... 🙂
Picture not included in this copy
Picture not included in this copy
It's ok... I can handle a little ridicule, Jason. 😉Originally Posted by Jason@SportsCar ↑What, only +1hp/-1tq... What about all of the glowing reviews from your butt dyno. 😆
Remember that the dyno runs are at wide open throttle and I don't normally drive at wide open throttle. I just drive like a regular transportation driver. And at under partial throttle conditions and low rpms the tooter manifold does perform great. In fact that was one of the things I was most concerned about, whether it would be driveable under normal everyday conditions.
I still need a few more fillups with the tooter to get an accurate comparison to the baseline gas mileage average. 🙂
Either your butt dyno is way out of wack, or I am looking at the wrong trace on the dyno, everything I see indicates a loss of power under 5300rpm. The way I see it low end power, and thus driveability has gotten worse. But it looks pretty.Originally Posted by tooter ↑It's ok... I can handle a little ridicule, Jason. 😉
Remember that the dyno runs are at wide open throttle and I don't normally drive at wide open throttle. I just drive like a regular transportation driver. And at under partial throttle conditions and low rpms the tooter manifold does perform great. In fact that was one of the things I was most concerned about, whether it would be driveable under normal everyday conditions.
I still need a few more fillups with the tooter to get an accurate comparison to the baseline gas mileage average. :smile
Damn bittersweet ending...thanks for putting the effort out there to find out.
I wonder if could aggressive tuning n/a could make gains along with a larger tb?
I wonder if could aggressive tuning n/a could make gains along with a larger tb?
Actually...some of that low end loss could be due to the supershort intake
I wonder a long intake into the fender well could make magic happen? I know you have flooding issues so thats a no go for you
I wonder a long intake into the fender well could make magic happen? I know you have flooding issues so thats a no go for you
Originally Posted by Jason@SportsCar ↑Either your butt dyno is way out of wack, or I am looking at the wrong trace on the dyno, everything I see indicates a loss of power under 5300rpm. The way I see it low end power, and thus driveability has gotten worse. But it looks pretty.
Well, that's why I did comparative dyno runs, because they accurately show the difference. Under the partial throttle conditions of normal driving the difference isn't noticeable. If your gas pedal is to the floorboard all the time you're driving then you could notice the difference. 😉
I've been thinking about that too, malibu... 🙂Originally Posted by malibuguy ↑Actually...some of that low end loss could be due to the supershort intake
I wonder a long intake into the fender well could make magic happen? I know you have flooding issues so thats a no go for you
That intake is as physically short as possible to fit the filter. I might try a longer cold air intake just to see what happens. I can always take it off during the wet season. I'm not done experimenting yet. 😉
Harry, at the HK Motorsports Dyno Shop in Van Nuys said that he'd open his place on a Sunday for a $70 Dyno Day if there are at least 5 cars to run. I'm going to post this in the California section just to see if anyone is interested.
The tooter results came in at +1 -1
And I think this was the latest list of guesses:
malibu +4 -6
Tooter +2 -3
Mazilla +1,000
Garm -5 -5
Anomaly +1 -3
Ljming -3 +3
BEEF +3 -2
Goldeenoh +5 -3
Goliath 0 0
tk-421 +4 -3
Yoda +4 +3
Jason -12 -18
packet +5 +3
Maitre +2 +4
Jeff -3HP -10TQ
Bluevitz-RS +4hp +6Tq
Scubaru Steve 0hp +10Tq
Flipper_1938 +6hp +4 ft lbs
Viperoni +2 -5
enviri +3hp 0tq
xnamerxx -10hp -10tq
CTScott -2hp +4tq
eTiMaGo 0 0
Billiam
Picture not included in this copy
+ 1,000,000
Looks like 4 people were a total of 2 digits off😲:
Anomaly
Goliath
enviri
eTiMaGo
Maybe we need to do a run off dyno. 😉
And I think this was the latest list of guesses:
malibu +4 -6
Tooter +2 -3
Mazilla +1,000
Garm -5 -5
Anomaly +1 -3
Ljming -3 +3
BEEF +3 -2
Goldeenoh +5 -3
Goliath 0 0
tk-421 +4 -3
Yoda +4 +3
Jason -12 -18
packet +5 +3
Maitre +2 +4
Jeff -3HP -10TQ
Bluevitz-RS +4hp +6Tq
Scubaru Steve 0hp +10Tq
Flipper_1938 +6hp +4 ft lbs
Viperoni +2 -5
enviri +3hp 0tq
xnamerxx -10hp -10tq
CTScott -2hp +4tq
eTiMaGo 0 0
Billiam
Picture not included in this copy
+ 1,000,000
Looks like 4 people were a total of 2 digits off😲:
Anomaly
Goliath
enviri
eTiMaGo
Maybe we need to do a run off dyno. 😉
Great read. I applaud the effort put into the manifold and testing it. I wouldn't be dissapointed at all, Ive seen reputable companies produce manifolds which proved power loss much greater. You have the right design aspects in your manifold design for the goals you had in mind. If I were to guess, a header will compliment that manifold simply because the volumetric efficiency of the intake has increased so much. You may not have a gain now because your setup is ''lopsided'', hiding the potential of the manifold.
As far as dyno conditions, that sheet clearly states the numbers are SAE corrected... which means temperatures and barametric pressure is accounted for. ( you can dyno on a 30 degree day, and on a 90 degree day, the numbers should theoretically be the same if SAE corrected).
VVT I on our cars learn, and change according to driving habit. I put my car on our dyno once with no changes, It made 28ft. lbs more torque, 6 less hp.........no changes. So I would deem your results inconclusive until you switch the manifold right on the dyno.
As far as dyno conditions, that sheet clearly states the numbers are SAE corrected... which means temperatures and barametric pressure is accounted for. ( you can dyno on a 30 degree day, and on a 90 degree day, the numbers should theoretically be the same if SAE corrected).
VVT I on our cars learn, and change according to driving habit. I put my car on our dyno once with no changes, It made 28ft. lbs more torque, 6 less hp.........no changes. So I would deem your results inconclusive until you switch the manifold right on the dyno.
well, it's a somewhat underwhelming result for the amount of work that went into it, but on the bright side, you haven't really lost power... and like others have said, it may well have major advantages once boost comes into play... So what are you waiting for, tooter? grab that turbo kit! :D
Thanks, man... 🙂Originally Posted by Blown_xa ↑Great read. I applaud the effort put into the manifold and testing it. I wouldn't be dissapointed at all, Ive seen reputable companies produce manifolds which proved power loss much greater.
Considering that this was the very first attempt of a total amateur, the results weren't all that bad. I'm going to see if I can do better now. 👍
You have the right design aspects in your manifold design for the goals you had in mind. If I were to guess, a header will compliment that manifold simply because the volumetric efficiency of the intake has increased so much. You may not have a gain now because your setup is ''lopsided'', hiding the potential of the manifold.There's already a header. This is what's on the engine when it ran today:
BLOX velocity stack air filter
Weapon R short ram intake
Weapon R 4-2-1 header
Micro Image center exit axle back exhaust
tooter manifold
Picture not included in this copy
As far as dyno conditions, that sheet clearly states the numbers are SAE corrected... which means temperatures and barametric pressure is accounted for. ( you can dyno on a 30 degree day, and on a 90 degree day, the numbers should theoretically be the same if SAE corrected).Yes, the baseline was done at 80 degrees, and the second set of runs was at 88 degrees.
VVT I on our cars learn, and change according to driving habit. I put my car on our dyno once with no changes, It made 28ft. lbs more torque, 6 less hp.........no changes. So I would deem your results inconclusive until you switch the manifold right on the dyno.You know, maybe when I disconnected the ECU to relearn with the new manifold I didn't do enough flat out driving for it to learn the whole curve. I only floored it a couple of times on the freeway and thought it would be enough.
I didn't really do all that much work, because it's actually a pretty simple straightforward process to visualize a concept and make it a reality. The total elapsed time from getting the first manifold to running a complete operating prototype on my engine only took 2 months.Originally Posted by eTiMaGo ↑well, it's a somewhat underwhelming result for the amount of work that went into it,
but on the bright side, you haven't really lost power... and like others have said, it may well have major advantages once boost comes into play... So what are you waiting for, tooter? grab that turbo kit! :DThat's true. The difference in power is to small to actually feel. You could only quantify it by going flat out on a timed drag strip.
I'm going to stay on the normally aspirated path. Even though the dyno runs reveal the manifold's shortcomings at full throttle, in normal partial throttle low rpm everyday driving conditions it works really good.🙂
Disappointing numbers...but at least you tried. For that, I applaud you.
But I got one right...Originally Posted by tooter ↑
Looks like 4 people were a total of 2 digits off😲:
Anomaly
Goliath
enviri
eTiMaGo
Maybe we need to do a run off dyno. 😉
Picture not included in this copy
I didn't do enough flat out driving for it to learn the whole curve. I only floored it a couple of times on the freeway and thought it would be enough.You drove it the way you drive the car, which was a more exact "before and after".
I don't think 'driving style' can change the maximum power output on the dyno anyway, but it might change the curve some.
The whole process has been a lot of fun, and I'm not quite done playing around with it yet. 😉Originally Posted by thebarber ↑Disappointing numbers...but at least you tried. For that, I applaud you.
Time to have the shop make you a adapter for a corolla TB :)
I got my corolla TB yesterday. I'm going to buy an xB weapon R intake manifold and have the TB flange modified to fit it.
I got my corolla TB yesterday. I'm going to buy an xB weapon R intake manifold and have the TB flange modified to fit it.
Why not purchase the Micro Image manifold with the 1ZZ TB flange already on it?Originally Posted by 4/20 NEVER FORGET ↑Time to have the shop make you a adapter for a corolla TB :)
I got my corolla TB yesterday. I'm going to buy an xB weapon R intake manifold and have the TB flange modified to fit it.
When is it going to be available for purchase? If it was I would have already purchased it 😁Originally Posted by Jeff@MicroImage ↑Why not purchase the Micro Image manifold with the 1ZZ TB flange already on it?
Very soon, we have a prototype to dyno and if all looks good we'll begin production.Originally Posted by 4/20 NEVER FORGET ↑When is it going to be available for purchase? If it was I would have already purchased it 😁
does it come in red? 😈Originally Posted by Jeff@MicroImage ↑Very soon, we have a prototype to dyno and if all looks good we'll begin production.