Yarisworld Archive

tooter's manifold adventure...

1,454 posts · 559,522 views · page 12 of 30

Replies continued

BilliamUSA · Aug 11, 2012#551
Official thread jack! Sorry Tooter....you're out!

Boobies FTW! Picture not included in this copy
tooterThread starterLos Angeles · Aug 11, 2012#552
Boobs obviously trump cars. 😆
tooterThread starterLos Angeles · Aug 11, 2012#553
I just couldn't resist driving the car more... 🙄

So I doubled up the T shirt over the velocity stack, and did some 4,000 rpm test revs while watching the shirt for signs of exess suction, and all was good to go. The air was quite still with no blowing dust so I took it to town again to run some errands.

starts right up 👍
idles smoothly 👍
very responsive 👍
no CEL. 👍
38.9 average gas mileage 👍

So far, the tooter manifold has been a rousing success for my driving style, because it is performing so well under regular low rpm driving conditions. All that remains now is resolving the air filter issue when the 90 degree coupling arrives and then generating some horsepower and torque curves.

After that I think I'll just enjoy running it as is for a while, then later I'll decide on the aesthetics of what finish to put on it.
Bluevitz-rsOshawa, Ontario, Canada · Aug 11, 2012#554
We NEED a vid. Even if it's just idling in the driveway.
tooterThread starterLos Angeles · Aug 11, 2012#555
I'll post a video both idling and running on Monday. 👍
My camera has no sound, and my wife has the good camera.
tooterThread starterLos Angeles · Aug 11, 2012#556
Originally Posted by eTiMaGo ↑
Was that the T-shirt you used? Now Garm can sell them as actual performance accessories :-D
Yeah... genuine tooter Tshirt air filters. 😆
I figured that air filters use cotton fibers, so I did too. 👍
BilliamUSA · Aug 11, 2012#557
Originally Posted by tooter ↑
Boobs obviously trump cars. 😆
Yeah...your dyno pull is up against some very hardy 36DD competition.
malibuguyWestminster, MD · Aug 11, 2012#558
The best thing about boobs...is when they bounce...
tooterThread starterLos Angeles · Aug 12, 2012#559
After a lot of searching, I finally found the perfect girl to represent tooter...

Picture not included in this copy

...no bounce there. 😆
Bluevitz-rsOshawa, Ontario, Canada · Aug 12, 2012#560
🤮
ViperoniBrampton, ON · Aug 12, 2012#561
Originally Posted by Bluevitz-rs ↑
🤮
x2
cali yarisCanoga Park, CA · Aug 12, 2012#562
I want a tooter T shirt.
tooterThread starterLos Angeles · Aug 12, 2012#563
Sorry, Garm... It's still being used on the intake. 😉
cali yarisCanoga Park, CA · Aug 12, 2012#564
^ not what I meant... I want a T shirt with the "tooter" logo on it.
anomoly40Central Arkansas · Aug 12, 2012#565
On the back, near the bottom.
tooterThread starterLos Angeles · Aug 12, 2012#566
Originally Posted by cali yaris ↑
^ not what I meant... I want a T shirt with the "tooter" logo on it.
Oh...

If you want that tooter shirt,
you have to take what's in it. 😆
cali yarisCanoga Park, CA · Aug 12, 2012#567
LOL
tooterThread starterLos Angeles · Aug 12, 2012#568
I put the engine cover back on so that it would look more complete...

Picture not included in this copy

Picture not included in this copy

Picture not included in this copy







There are no studs on the tooter for the two front retaining nuts, so I installed some short bolts from the back to hold them so that they would fill up the holes.
BEEFnorth carolina · Aug 12, 2012#569
I'd so leave the engine cover off. I like a raw engine so much better. I hate the look of all the newer cars that have the covers that hide the most important part of the car.

on top of that, you have something to show off...
Bluevitz-rsOshawa, Ontario, Canada · Aug 12, 2012#570
Originally Posted by BEEF ↑
I'd so leave the engine cover off. I like a raw engine so much better. I hate the look of all the newer cars that have the covers that hide the most important part of the car.

on top of that, you have something to show off...
x2

I polished my valve cover.
tooterThread starterLos Angeles · Aug 12, 2012#571
Originally Posted by BEEF ↑
I'd so leave the engine cover off. I like a raw engine so much better. I hate the look of all the newer cars that have the covers that hide the most important part of the car.

on top of that, you have something to show off...
The only problem with leaving the cover off is that tangled mess of wires that it hides. Later on if I can figure out a way to make the wires neater, I might leave the cover off. I also have some perforated stainless steel sheeting, and might try a home made cover out of that.

I drove the car again today and am so totally pleased at how well it's working. 🙂 The T shirt gets sucked clean with the shop vac after each use as it's obviously not the best air filter in the world. 😆
tooterThread starterLos Angeles · Aug 12, 2012#572
Originally Posted by Bluevitz-rs ↑
x2

I polished my valve cover.
What did you use to polish it? And do you have a pic of how it turned out, I'd like to see what it looks like. 🙂
malibuguyWestminster, MD · Aug 13, 2012#573
I keep my cover on. Its easier to wipe clean then inside the coilpack channel on the valve cover.
Bluevitz-rsOshawa, Ontario, Canada · Aug 13, 2012#574
I'll take a fresh one for you.

I cut the nubs for the cover off and sanded it smooth to get all the casting marks out. Then wet sanded with 1000. Then polished by hand and a rag with aluminum polish. I didn't do in the coil area because it just too hard to get and am actually thinking about painting that area flat black because it does get dirty.
mazillaSan Jacinto California · Aug 13, 2012#575
Cover off, IMO
3cyltrboOttawa · Aug 13, 2012#576
for the love of god (and baby jeebus), would someone please get this man the parts he needs (to complete the air filter issues) so that he can get on with making some vids and getting dyno testing done

W
cali yarisCanoga Park, CA · Aug 13, 2012#577
bluevitz, did you take it off, or finish it on the car?

@ 3cyltrbo - lol, I think tooter just needs an employee so he can entertain us every day instead of working.
tooterThread starterLos Angeles · Aug 13, 2012#578
Originally Posted by 3cyltrbo ↑
for the love of god (and baby jeebus), would someone please get this man the parts he needs (to complete the air filter issues) so that he can get on with making some vids and getting dyno testing done

W
As I'm writing this, a video is being uploaded to youtube, and will be ready in about 15 minutes. 🙂

It's just a cold start and a little revving. You can see the tooter T shirt air filter sucking into the velocity stack. 😆

I'll do a running video after work if I have the time.
tooterThread starterLos Angeles · Aug 13, 2012#579
Originally Posted by cali yaris ↑
@ 3cyltrbo - lol, I think tooter just needs an employee so he can entertain us every day instead of working.
Work makes the money to fund this project. 🙂

All totalled up so far, I have $2000 in the tooter intake manifold. But the personal satisfaction of actually driving the completed prototype is well worth the cost. 👍
anomoly40Central Arkansas · Aug 13, 2012#581
$2000? I guess i forgot how much machine shop time costs since my time is free.

Picture not included in this copy
tooterThread starterLos Angeles · Aug 13, 2012#582
Originally Posted by anomoly40 ↑
$2000? I guess i forgot how much machine shop time costs since my time is free.

Picture not included in this copy

You can drink your coffee again...

...because that's not just for the single prototype, but for a small limited production run of tooters. 🙂

I even have the marketing slogan:

"if it sucks... it's a tooter" 😆
suckerfaceMilwaukee, WI · Aug 13, 2012#583
Oh really? Is this the full manifold, or just the flange and TB adapter?
tooterThread starterLos Angeles · Aug 13, 2012#584
Originally Posted by suckerface ↑
Oh really? Is this the full manifold, or just the flange and TB adapter?
Both. 🙂

My goal is to hopefully sell enough tooters to at least break even on the design, material, manufacturing and assembly costs. The market is infintessimally small so I'm only making just enough that I think might actually sell. Kits with the tooter mounting flange, throttle body bolts and adaptor, and gaskets for the do-it-yourselfers and maybe a few assembled units for those who want a complete bolt on manifold. Either way an intake still needs to be modified to fit the unusual placement of the throttlebody. Ironically, the tooter might shine the most in a forced intake situation because it's capable of flowing about 20% more air under identical conditions.

What I'm most happy about is how well the manifold is working for just ordinary everyday transportation driving, which is what the wife and me use our car for. I even shoved the big BLOX air filter over the T shirt for some extra protection and drove it downtown for work today... 🙂

Picture not included in this copy

...also did a some 70mph freeway when I could just to see how it felt. Man, it runs great even with the doubled up rag restricting the intake! 😆 Since all manifolds are a compromise between bottom end torque and top end horsepower, it will be really interesting to see which end it favors on the dyno. Just from the seat of the pants, it seems to favor the bottom since I haven't actually run the engine above 4,000 rpm.
tooterThread starterLos Angeles · Aug 13, 2012#585
Just did the first gas fill up with the tooter and it appears that it's not hurting the mileage any at 39.1 mpg with a combination of city, rural highway, and freeway driving. 🙂 I'll need some more fillups to establish a reliable average.
ljming99Singapore · Aug 13, 2012#586
Originally Posted by tooter ↑
Both. 🙂

My goal is to hopefully sell enough tooters to at least break even on the design, material, manufacturing and assembly costs. The market is infintessimally small so I'm only making just enough that I think might actually sell. Kits with the tooter mounting flange, throttle body bolts and adaptor, and gaskets for the do-it-yourselfers and maybe a few assembled units for those who want a complete bolt on manifold. Either way an intake still needs to be modified to fit the unusual placement of the throttlebody. Ironically, the tooter might shine the most in a forced intake situation because it's capable of flowing about 20% more air under identical conditions.

What I'm most happy about is how well the manifold is working for just ordinary everyday transportation driving, which is what the wife and me use our car for. I even shoved the big BLOX air filter over the T shirt for some extra protection and drove it downtown for work today... 🙂

Picture not included in this copy

...also did a some 70mph freeway when I could just to see how it felt. Man, it runs great even with the doubled up rag restricting the intake! 😆 Since all manifolds are a compromise between bottom end torque and top end horsepower, it will be really interesting to see which end it favors on the dyno. Just from the seat of the pants, it seems to favor the bottom since I haven't actually run the engine above 4,000 rpm.
Doesnt really matter, next step will be tuning...that will take care of the high end anyway.
GolddeenohColumbia, SC · Aug 13, 2012#587
after all of this designing and building does the throttle body sit fairly close to the same position as the OEM location or is it way out of whack. CAI might be an issue if it doesn't line up like the OEM one but for boost it is still good.
cali yarisCanoga Park, CA · Aug 13, 2012#588
Doesnt really matter, next step will be tuning...that will take care of the high end anyway.
He's not doing any tuning, just a dyno.
tooterThread starterLos Angeles · Aug 14, 2012#589
Originally Posted by Golddeenoh ↑
after all of this designing and building does the throttle body sit fairly close to the same position as the OEM location or is it way out of whack.
The position of the throttle body is fixed by the profile of the Corolla manifold as well as the 1 inch thick throttle body adaptor. Looking at the engine from the front, the throttle body is moved 2 3/4 inches to the right and tips upward about 20 degrees less than the stock position.

CAI might be an issue if it doesn't line up like the OEM one but for boost it is still good.
Yes.

Any normally aspirated intake would need to be modified (shortened) except perhaps forced intakes. When my short ram intake is modified to fit, I'll take detailed pictures to show what works.

Basically, a 2 3/4 inch section would need to be cut out from somewhere along the length of the CAI, and a silicone coupling added to reconnect the tube. That should do it. The flexible nature of the coupling will allow for the altered tilt, as well as the coupling on the throttle body itself.
tooterThread starterLos Angeles · Aug 14, 2012#590
Originally Posted by cali yaris ↑
He's not doing any tuning, just a dyno.
Yes. 🙂

I'm going the simple route by letting the stock ECU learn the new operating parameters of the manifold. It's been working fine just as a bolt-on, with good driveability, excellent gas mileage, and no triggered Check Engine Light.

The new dyno chart will show the F/A, and will be compared to the baseline runs just to see what the difference is. I don't really see that there would be much difference as everything on each side of the manifold (throttle body and engine) is exactly the same.

By sticking to my guns on making the ONLY change be the manifold, it will be a simple matter to accurately verify the advantages and shortcomings on the dyno. I believe that there will be both, I just don't know exactly what they will be yet.

From what I've read on intake manifold design, there's always tension between the driveability of low end torque and the excitement of flat out top end horsepower. I like more low end torque, because that's where good gas mileage comes from, and with the tooter runners being slightly longer than the stock manifold, my own direct driving experience seems to confirm that. On level ground I can let out the clutch with almost no gas pedal and the car moves without stalling. To me, this is valuable asset to possess, especially when driving in heavy stop and go traffic. It also can save a lot of wear and tear on a clutch.

What I like about this particular manifold is that it is an "outside the box" design. Almost every 4 cylinder inline intake manifold made is log style. You take a rectangle, punch 4 holes in one side and poke in some runners along the edge, stick a throttle body on one end, and then the hardest part, design all of the proportions to enhance the power band of the engine where you want it. It's obviously a good sound practical easy to produce design, or every car maker wouldn't be using it. Richard Holdener, Golden Eagle, and Weapon R all use exactly this same approach.

Picture not included in this copy

Picture not included in this copy

Picture not included in this copy


In contrast the Corolla design was not only harder to produce, it takes up a lot more space...

Picture not included in this copy


To have runners long enough, the manifold itself needs to be longer, whereas on the log manifolds you simply wrap the runners around the plenum like a compact space efficient snail shell. I'm certain this is why this design was abandoned after just a few years of production. Plastic molding is so much cheaper than casting and machining aluminium, mandrel bending tubing, and welding all the parts together.

Picture not included in this copy
GolddeenohColumbia, SC · Aug 14, 2012#591
I was hope'n this will be usable with my AEM CAI, trying to get a little more power and a little more MPG, with out getting into the engine.
tooterThread starterLos Angeles · Aug 14, 2012#592
Originally Posted by Golddeenoh ↑
I was hope'n this will be usable with my AEM CAI, trying to get a little more power and a little more MPG, with out getting into the engine.
I take it yours looks similar to this...

Picture not included in this copy

Since the throttle body on the tooter is moved to the right, your AEM would likely need to be shortened about 3 inches between the MAF and the throttle body coupling.

Yeah, I'm the same way, and won't be digging into the engine when it runs just fine the way it is.
malibuguyWestminster, MD · Aug 14, 2012#593
I planned on making my own CAI like the one i made for my old xB. However, if these work out obviously im down for the flanges (as ive been sitting on a 1zz intake for quite a while) and ill just make induction custom to the manifold...and maybe perhaps given tooter graces, reproducing them for a few peoples who dont have fab skills?
3cyltrboOttawa · Aug 14, 2012#594
less talky

more dyno-y
Autocross72Seattle · Aug 14, 2012#595
Subscribe
4/20 NEVER FORGETPortland, OR · Aug 15, 2012#596
Where's the beef
tooterThread starterLos Angeles · Aug 15, 2012#597
Still waiting on the 90 degree silicone coupling to arrive so that I can finish off the air filter. Sorry, no air filter... no dyno. I'm not going to wreck my engine. 🤷

I want to see the results just as much as any of you do. 😉
GolddeenohColumbia, SC · Aug 15, 2012#598
^ we're still waiting, bro. anxiously waiting!
Autocross72Seattle · Aug 15, 2012#599
One or two pulls on a Dyno withouut an air filter isn't going to hurt your engine. That said, I'd be more interested in seeing the Dyno numbers with the filter because that is how it will be run in the real world and can be compared more directly to your previous Dyno pulls.
tooterThread starterLos Angeles · Aug 15, 2012#600
Originally Posted by Autocross72 ↑
One or two pulls on a Dyno withouut an air filter isn't going to hurt your engine. That said, I'd be more interested in seeing the Dyno numbers with the filter because that is how it will be run in the real world and can be compared more directly to your previous Dyno pulls.
I agree. 🙂
The second set of dyno pulls need to be done under exactly the same conditions as the baseline pulls with the velocity stack and its matching air filter... except for the tooter manifold being the only change. I want to do this the right way. 👍