Replies continued
cali yarisCanoga Park, CA · Aug 3, 2012#451^ ooh that sounds like fun!
Rain Man... LOL
"I'm an excellent driver"....
Jeff@MicroImageSFV, CA · Aug 3, 2012#452Don't get caught counting cards out there!
AltitudeColorado · Aug 3, 2012#453I'll not make an official guess, but the fact that it has "tooter" engraved on it has to be worth at least +5hp. Looks great and I really like that you did engrave your moniker on it.
enviriCT · Aug 3, 2012#454malibu +4 -6
Tooter +2 -3
Mazilla +1,000
Garm -5 -5
Anomaly +1 -3
Ljming -3 +3
BEEF +3 -2
Goldeenoh +5 -3
Goliath 0 0
tk-421 +4 -3
Yoda +4 +3
Jason -12 -18
packet +5 +3
Maitre +2 +4
Jeff -3HP -10TQ
Bluevitz-RS +4hp +6Tq
Scubaru Steve 0hp +10Tq
Flipper_1938 +6hp +4 ft lbs
Viperoni +2 -5
enviri +0tq +3hp
tooterThread starterLos Angeles · Aug 3, 2012#455 Originally Posted by
Altitude ↑ I'll not make an official guess, but the fact that it has "tooter" engraved on it has to be worth at least +5hp. Looks great and I really like that you did engrave your moniker on it.
The idea of a "tooter" intake manifold made me laugh, so I had it added to the flange. 😆
anomoly40Central Arkansas · Aug 3, 2012#456Picture not included in this copy
tooterThread starterLos Angeles · Aug 3, 2012#457😳
malibuguyWestminster, MD · Aug 3, 2012#458My only concern for the intake not possibly performing as good asnit can is the maf location. I think with it having basically no straight ahead or prior to it wont allow laminar flow to develop as strong as it would with a longer intake.
Of course i know there is no real easy way around it...without custom work
tooterThread starterLos Angeles · Aug 3, 2012#459 Originally Posted by
malibuguy ↑ My only concern for the intake not possibly performing as good asnit can is the maf location. I think with it having basically no straight ahead or prior to it wont allow laminar flow to develop as strong as it would with a longer intake.
Of course i know there is no real easy way around it...without custom work
I know... and I'll soon find out. 😉
I'm already relying heavily on the oversized velocity stack to smooth the flow to the MAF...
Picture not included in this copy It's been working great just like this...
Picture not included in this copy Some of the shortening will also be behind the MAF as the intake port extends down into the inside of the manifold...
Picture not included in this copy One advantage is that everything is in a straight line... it's just going to be a really
short one! 😆
tooterThread starterLos Angeles · Aug 4, 2012#460Here's the latest updated list of guesses... 🙂
First number is Horsepower... second is ft/lbs Torque
malibu +4 -6
Tooter +2 -3
Mazilla +1,000
Garm -5 -5
Anomaly +1 -3
Ljming -3 +3
BEEF +3 -2
Goldeenoh +5 -3
Goliath 0 0
tk-421 +4 -3
Yoda +4 +3
Jason -12 -18
packet +5 +3
Maitre +2 +4
Jeff -3HP -10TQ
Bluevitz-RS +4hp +6Tq
Scubaru Steve 0hp +10Tq
Flipper_1938 +6hp +4 ft lbs
Viperoni +2 -5
enviri +3hp 0tq
xnamerxx -10hp -10tq
CTScott -2hp +4tq
Billiam
Picture not included in this copy
+ 1,000,000
cali yarisCanoga Park, CA · Aug 4, 2012#461Looks like the audience is just about ready for the show. 😁
packetraceQuebec · Aug 4, 2012#462yeah !!!:D for yours too Garm :)
tooterThread starterLos Angeles · Aug 4, 2012#463Don't hold your breath... 😳
It won't be until next week as we're entertaining this weekend and I have a really busy work week coming up. The part should arrive today to shorten the intake. 🙂
tooterThread starterLos Angeles · Aug 4, 2012#464 Originally Posted by
packetrace ↑ yeah !!!:D for yours too Garm :)
That reminds me... what's going on with your manifolds, Garm?
Found a picture of Richard Holdener's manifold.
Picture not included in this copy And his before and after dyno runs...
WOW! pretty impressive!
Picture not included in this copy tooterThread starterLos Angeles · Aug 4, 2012#465Just read the whole Richard Holdener thread. Wow... what a saga.
And it couldn't be produced even at $699 a pop!!! 😳
I'm beginning to understand why even though I did absolutely NO engineering R & D on mine. With all of his extensive high performance automotive expertise and having tried more than 50 manifold configurations before coming up with one that produced consistent gains, makes it even more unlikely that mine will produce any performance gains at all! The tooter manifold is a total crapshoot! 😆
malibuguyWestminster, MD · Aug 4, 2012#466I cant see the gains
BilliamUSA · Aug 4, 2012#467 Originally Posted by
tooter ↑ ....unlikely that mine will produce any performance gains at all! The tooter manifold is a total crapshoot! 😆
But if it does....the chicks will dig it!
Picture not included in this copy Picture not included in this copy tooterThread starterLos Angeles · Aug 4, 2012#468 Originally Posted by
malibuguy ↑ I cant see the gains
The dyno graph isn't showing up on your screen? If it doesn't, the graph showed that the Holdener manifold was +13 +4. That's highly significant improvement. 🙇
I'd be ecstatic if mine netted a
fifth of those gains. 🙂
tooterThread starterLos Angeles · Aug 4, 2012#469Had an opportunity to do the water test today. 🙂
I taped off the throttle body and hose inlet fittings and filled up the runners while tilting the manifolds around to make certain that there was no captured air. And then I emptied them into a big bucket and poured the water out into a 32 ounce measuring cup.
The results confirmed the obvious... the plenum on the Yaris manifold is much larger than on the Corolla manifold.
Total volume of Yaris manifold 127 ounces
Total volume of Corolla manifold 101 ounces
This makes the total volume of the Corolla manifold about 20% smaller, even though it was designed to flow for an engine with 20% more displacement.
And I have absolutely no idea how this will affect the performance... 🤷
...but I'll find out soon. 🙂
packetraceQuebec · Aug 4, 2012#470cant wait to see :)
eTiMaGoBangkok, Thailand · Aug 5, 2012#471My personal opinion, peak hp and torque changes will be minimal and could be attributed to the margin of error of the dyno itself. But, I think there will be less low and mid-range torque.
so...
+0hp +0tq, weaker midrange
malibuguyWestminster, MD · Aug 5, 2012#472Shit id pay 700 for RHs manifold for those kind of gains...and what looks to be on the stock airbox too
mazillaSan Jacinto California · Aug 5, 2012#473Garm is onto me...hehe
CrankyOldManWest Michigan · Aug 5, 2012#474 Originally Posted by
tooter ↑ Had an opportunity to do the water test today. 🙂
The results confirmed the obvious... the plenum on the Yaris manifold is much larger than on the Corolla manifold.
Total volume of Yaris manifold 127 ounces
Total volume of Corolla manifold 101 ounces
In my research, I was never able to find conclusive evidence of how the volume of the plenum affects the power curve. It would be better if you could measure just the volume of the runners, but that might be tough since you can't really see where the Yaris runners meet the plenum.
My guess is that the Yaris uses a much larger plenum to reduce the effect of the air entering perpendicular to the runners and provide adequate "reserves" for the runners farther from the TB. I haven't entered a guess yet, but I think the net result will be a shift of peak HP/tq RPMs that is more significant than the change in peak overall.
tooterThread starterLos Angeles · Aug 5, 2012#475 Originally Posted by
CrankyOldMan ↑ In my research, I was never able to find conclusive evidence of how the volume of the plenum affects the power curve. It would be better if you could measure just the volume of the runners, but that might be tough since you can't really see where the Yaris runners meet the plenum.
I can see the first runner in the plenum...
Picture not included in this copy ... but there are internal undulations which prevent seeing the others, and I think there's also some kind of chamber in there because the water was captured in the plenum and I had to tip it around all crazy sorts of ways to eventually get it to come out.
My guess is that the Yaris uses a much larger plenum to reduce the effect of the air entering perpendicular to the runners and provide adequate "reserves" for the runners farther from the TB.
Yes. From what I've read, there are issues with the mouths of the runners being perpendicular to the flow of air entering the plenum. Also there are issues when the runner mouths are not raised above the edge of the plenum.
The Corolla manifold gets around that, first ,by having the intake from the throttle body entering into the
exact middle of the plenum, which, from what I've read, is a significant design
advantage over having the entry at one side putting all of the runners at
different distances from it.
And, second, all the runners are only 2 1/2 inches away from the central entrance point and are
all equidistant from it, and all "looking" directly at it, so there is
no change in the direction of the flow. This design is similar to a backwards flowing exhaust header.
I
really like this design as it is a complete departure from the typical perpendicular runner "log" style manifold.
I've been reading about another manifold principle in play called resonance. Sound waves created by the valves slamming closed travel back up the runner and are reflected back to the valves by the plenum. This tuning can pressurize the incoming flow as it enters the valves providing a supercharging effect. These sound waves travel back and forth many times even within one valve cycle. So the plenum is a kind of echo chamber, and the size determines the frequencies of rpms that it favors. This principle is somewhat like the principle of
exhaust scavenging which uses resonant pulses of adjoining runners to draw the exhaust down the header.
I haven't entered a guess yet, but I think the net result will be a shift of peak HP/tq RPMs that is more significant than the change in peak overall.
I agree, as my guess is just a very slight positive and negative change in hp and tq. At what rpm frequences this manifold resonates is unknown...
...but they will be clearly revealed in the graphs of the dyno runs. 🙂
CrankyOldManWest Michigan · Aug 5, 2012#476 Originally Posted by
tooter ↑ I've been reading about another manifold principle in play called resonance. Sound waves created by the valves slamming closed travel back up the runner and are reflected back to the valves by the plenum. This tuning can pressurize the incoming flow as it enters the valves providing a supercharging effect. These sound waves travel back and forth many times even within one valve cycle. So the plenum is a kind of echo chamber, and the size determines the frequencies of rpms that it favors. This principle is somewhat like the principle of exhaust scavenging which uses resonant pulses of adjoining runners to draw the exhaust down the header.
Aah yes, good old Helmholtz Resonators. My first understanding of the Helmholtz resonance was that it applied to the runners and plenum, but that proved to be incorrect since all of the calculators that I found used the volume of the cylinder at bottom stroke. That's where the confusion over the volume of the plenum came in--none of the calculators seemed to care about it--and some calculators even seemed to be based on the runners alone. There was anecdotal evidence that a larger plenum can flatten the torque curve, and that it should be "about 1.5x the displacement of the engine" but no empirical studies or documentation. Perhaps Mr. Holdener had some more definitive results from his 50+ prototypes?
I tried modeling the intake as a series of cylinders in Finite Element Analysis (FEA) software, but wasn't able to get any sensible results. I haven't taken a class in how to do FEA for fluids, a.k.a. Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD), so it was a rather fruitless effort.
tooterThread starterLos Angeles · Aug 5, 2012#477 Originally Posted by
CrankyOldMan ↑ Aah yes, good old Helmholtz Resonators. My first understanding of the Helmholtz resonance was that it applied to the runners and plenum, but that proved to be incorrect since all of the calculators that I found used the volume of the cylinder at bottom stroke. That's where the confusion over the volume of the plenum came in--none of the calculators seemed to care about it--and some calculators even seemed to be based on the runners alone. There was anecdotal evidence that a larger plenum can flatten the torque curve, and that it should be "about 1.5x the displacement of the engine" but no empirical studies or documentation.
The Corolla plenum is only a little larger than the collector on a header, so I'm
really curious what the effect of that will be. 🙂
Perhaps Mr. Holdener had some more definitive results from his 50+ prototypes?
I think we'll never know... just like we'll never know why a Yaris intake manifold couldn't be produced for $700 a unit. 🤷
I tried modeling the intake as a series of cylinders in Finite Element Analysis (FEA) software, but wasn't able to get any sensible results. I haven't taken a class in how to do FEA for fluids, a.k.a. Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD), so it was a rather fruitless effort.
I'm using the crapshoot method:
"Run what you brung."
Which also holds great potential for fruitlessness. 😆
cali yarisCanoga Park, CA · Aug 5, 2012#478 we'll never know why a Yaris intake manifold couldn't be produced for $700 a unit.
That's an easy one.
1. R&D cost required to prove that a manifold works, produces power, and causes no CEL's.
2. Utter lack of Group Buy interest in terms of real deposits, when #1 is unknown.
Just look at the Weapon R manifold (which is $700 by the way), and the nearly zero sales it generated for the xB market.
But hey... someone's gotta do it. 😉
cali yarisCanoga Park, CA · Aug 5, 2012#479 confusion over the volume of the plenum came in--none of the calculators seemed to care about it--and some calculators even seemed to be based on the runners alone.
No confusion there. The calculators don't need a volume number for a reason. 🙂
CrankyOldManWest Michigan · Aug 5, 2012#480 Originally Posted by
cali yaris ↑ No confusion there. The calculators don't need a volume number for a reason. 🙂
Well, my confusion was based on the incorrect assumption that the plenum became a secondary resonator for the back-pulse. 😁
tooterThread starterLos Angeles · Aug 5, 2012#481 Originally Posted by
CrankyOldMan ↑ Well, my confusion was based on the incorrect assumption that the plenum became a secondary resonator for the back-pulse. 😁
If that's true, then it's all for the best because there's almost no plenum on the manifold to resonate anyways. 😉
tooterThread starterLos Angeles · Aug 5, 2012#482 Originally Posted by
cali yaris ↑ That's an easy one.
1. R&D cost required to prove that a manifold works, produces power, and causes no CEL's.
From reading the old thread, Richard had a dynoed working prototype that produced significant gains.
2. Utter lack of Group Buy interest in terms of real deposits, when #1 is unknown.
More than 10 people were on the buy list which he said was the threshold for a production run. After a long gap of no communication, people got discouraged and dropped out when nothing happened.
Just look at the Weapon R manifold (which is $700 by the way), and the nearly zero sales it generated for the xB market.
Wow, I didn't know that they actually came up with a Scion product. Have to take a look at it. 🙂
But hey... someone's gotta do it. 😉
Looks like the torch has now been passed on to me. 🙂
Today makes exactly two months elapsed time to produce one tooter prototype that's ready to bolt onto the engine... 👍
Picture not included in this copy Flipper_1938Kentucky · Aug 5, 2012#483 Originally Posted by
tooter ↑ Looks like the torch has now been passed on to me. 🙂
Today makes exactly two months elapsed time to produce one tooter prototype that's ready to bolt onto the engine... 👍
Picture not included in this copy
Then go bolt that sucker on!!!!
3cyltrboOttawa · Aug 5, 2012#484if:
-this makes power (fantasizing about 5whp)
-and / or if it changes the intake noise
AND
its not $700 (assuming tooter was to produce them)
I'd be on it like a fat kid on cake
like michael jackson on little boys
like the republicans on helping their rich chronies
like michael phelps on gold medals
(Cliffs notes: if it makes power / and or sounds better = Will wants one)
Bluevitz-rsOshawa, Ontario, Canada · Aug 5, 2012#485On a plus side for the cable throttle crowd, we don't need the TB adapter, just the flange for the head.
malibuguyWestminster, MD · Aug 5, 2012#486700 for proven significant gains on a already very effecient motor is chump change. I would buy one in a heart-beat and any true motor head that understands this would too
tooterThread starterLos Angeles · Aug 6, 2012#487 Originally Posted by
Flipper_1938 ↑ Then go bolt that sucker on!!!!
I'm itching to do just that... but I'm also up to my neck in work making money so that I can afford to play with this project in my spare time. This week is especially busy, but I'll try to get it going as soon as I can. 👍
Next up is customizing the intake to fit the new location of the throttlebody, as well as relocating all of the hoses to fit their new locations.
ljming99Singapore · Aug 6, 2012#488Well, do remember to keep any changes to the hoses documented. It would be a plus when this becomes a complete kit.
Anyway, i ever though of getting the weapon r and then customising it to fit a yaris...but that would be spending insane amount of money ...and i wouldnt wanna risk spoiling a sexy bling bling weapon r manifold.
Anyway, you are paying for the bling bling "exotic" material for a weapon r manifold.
They could have kept cost down, at least get from profit for making an affordable manifold made of common material =P
cali yarisCanoga Park, CA · Aug 6, 2012#489 getting the weapon r and then customising it to fit a yaris...but that would be spending insane amount of money .
I'm afraid to ask tooter what he spent so far! 🙂
tooterThread starterLos Angeles · Aug 6, 2012#490 Originally Posted by
ljming99 ↑ Well, do remember to keep any changes to the hoses documented. It would be a plus when this becomes a complete kit.
Anyway, i ever though of getting the weapon r and then customising it to fit a yaris...but that would be spending insane amount of money ...and i wouldnt wanna risk spoiling a sexy bling bling weapon r manifold.
Anyway, you are paying for the bling bling "exotic" material for a weapon r manifold.
They could have kept cost down, at least get from profit for making an affordable manifold made of common material =P
They're certainly nice looking... 🙂
Picture not included in this copy WeSellCarParts.com sells them for $510, and they're on ebay for only $504. 👍
cali yarisCanoga Park, CA · Aug 6, 2012#491^ Do they have one in stock? 😉
tooterThread starterLos Angeles · Aug 6, 2012#492 Originally Posted by
cali yaris ↑ ^ Do they have one in stock? 😉
Just did a price sensitive search and found that Ebay seller...
tunedcustoms Picture not included in this copy ...is currently selling them for only $460 +$9 shipping. They have sold one so far and have more than 10 available for sale. In fact, there are quite a few xB manifold sellers on ebay.
You were right about there not being much of an aftermarket manifold market. Looks like the prices have been dropping significantly.
tooterThread starterLos Angeles · Aug 6, 2012#493The latest list of guesses:
malibu +4 -6
Tooter +2 -3
Mazilla +1,000
Garm -5 -5
Anomaly +1 -3
Ljming -3 +3
BEEF +3 -2
Goldeenoh +5 -3
Goliath 0 0
tk-421 +4 -3
Yoda +4 +3
Jason -12 -18
packet +5 +3
Maitre +2 +4
Jeff -3HP -10TQ
Bluevitz-RS +4hp +6Tq
Scubaru Steve 0hp +10Tq
Flipper_1938 +6hp +4 ft lbs
Viperoni +2 -5
enviri +3hp 0tq
xnamerxx -10hp -10tq
CTScott -2hp +4tq
eTiMaGo 0 0
Billiam
Picture not included in this copy
+ 1,000,000
cali yarisCanoga Park, CA · Aug 6, 2012#494Awesome.
tooterThread starterLos Angeles · Aug 6, 2012#495Oh man, this is killing me... 😢
There is no way to shorten the intake enough to use the BLOX velocity stack with its 7 inch tall filter...
Picture not included in this copy
Picture not included in this copy
They don't make shorter filters that have a 6 inch opening. The other options are getting a cold air intake, or going with some shorter filter with no velocity stack.
Can anyone offer any suggestions on a decent 2 1/2" inlet dry filter that's 5 inches tall?
I'm even thinking of cutting off the top of the Blox filter and gluing on a plastic lid to make it work. I really don't want to give up the velocity stack as it does a beautiful job of smoothing the airflow to the MAF even though it's right on top of it. 🙁
edit: Hey wait... I think I know what to do! 🙂
If I glue a 6 inch diameter plastic ring onto the skirt of the velocity stack, I can collapse the whole assembly a couple of inches into the filter. :thumbsup" I only need it to be 2 inches shorter as I gained about a half an inch with a smaller coupler.
malibuguyWestminster, MD · Aug 6, 2012#496You may be able to shorten the outlet of the stack a little bit to shove the maf pipe in the coupler a little deeper
tooterThread starterLos Angeles · Aug 6, 2012#497 Originally Posted by
malibuguy ↑ You may be able to shorten the outlet of the stack a little bit to shove the maf pipe in the coupler a little deeper
It won't shorten it enough, and I don't want to mess with the stack itself because it works so well as it is. However, being able to shove the stack up into the interior of the filter a couple of inches will work because the filter is already so large. I only need to find a short scrap of plastic tubing with an outside diameter of exactly 6 inches and I have it made. 🙂
This
has to be resolved, as a working filter is essential for the dyno run. And I definitely do not want to lose the velocity stack because that would be making
two changes, and not just the manifold as the
only change.
vtencolumbus · Aug 6, 2012#498If you don't mind using the k&n brand , I can give you the part number ... I believe mine is 4" taller with the 6" opening inlet .
And if you need to retrofitted any CAI , my AEM CAI is still available for sale :)
tooterThread starterLos Angeles · Aug 7, 2012#499 Originally Posted by
vten ↑ If you don't mind using the k&n brand , I can give you the part number ... I believe mine is 4" taller with the 6" opening inlet .
And if you need to retrofitted any CAI , my AEM CAI is still available for sale :)
Thanks for the offer... 🙂
...but I want to stay away from oily filters and live in an area that is subject to flooding in winter, and so want to avoid putting a filter down in the fenderwell. I'm going to go for the 6 inch plastic sleeve added to the skirt of the velocity stack. That way I will be able to retain
both the filter
and the stack, and simply collapse one into the other until it's short enough to fit. 👍
I don't want to break the rule of making the manifold be the
only change, so that the dyno runs will reflect
only the difference in manifolds and
nothing else.
eTiMaGoBangkok, Thailand · Aug 7, 2012#500use a different filter first, then take out the headlight and fit the Blox setup just for the dyno? Or, change that silicone coupler to a 90 degree one so you could aim the filter downward and gain a little bit of space?