Replies continued
sleey0PA · Sep 21, 2010#251 Originally Posted by
Focus_Sh1ft ↑ Yeah, I'm really on the fence when it comes to tuning... I have only one tuning shop that is near me, and I'm really not crazy about the guy from the three conversations we've had. I wouldn't mind learning some tuning, but am worried that with my inexperience and lack of dyno that I may cause damage... Then again, I did just throw a turbocharger in my car with no mechanical expertise so.. 🤷
I'm definitely leaning towards doing it myself... I'd like to think I get the basics of AFRs and the effect of adding/removing fuel. With a wideband, how hard could it be?
Do you plan on changing out any internal engine components?
I am just curious if you turbo guys are going to build your motors or just stay with a conservative boost. Not sure our tiny little motors are built for the long-haul when increasing its demands so much with boost.
pimp my yarischicago · Sep 22, 2010#252 Originally Posted by
sleey0 ↑ Do you plan on changing out any internal engine components?
I am just curious if you turbo guys are going to build your motors or just stay with a conservative boost. Not sure our tiny little motors are built for the long-haul when increasing its demands so much with boost.
I was already pricing out pistons rods and rings. I am thinking mabe next spring or summer. This looks like about the easiest engine pull possible. I would love to be pushing 15psi and get this thing really turning heads!🤣
sleey0PA · Sep 22, 2010#253 Originally Posted by
pimp my yaris ↑ I was already pricing out pistons rods and rings. I am thinking mabe next spring or summer. This looks like about the easiest engine pull possible. I would love to be pushing 15psi and get this thing really turning heads!🤣
Do you think our cars could run ok stock @ 12psi with a not-too-agressive tune?
why?harnett county NC · Sep 22, 2010#254 Originally Posted by
Focus_Sh1ft ↑ Yeah, I'm really on the fence when it comes to tuning... I have only one tuning shop that is near me, and I'm really not crazy about the guy from the three conversations we've had. I wouldn't mind learning some tuning, but am worried that with my inexperience and lack of dyno that I may cause damage... Then again, I did just throw a turbocharger in my car with no mechanical expertise so.. 🤷
I'm definitely leaning towards doing it myself... I'd like to think I get the basics of AFRs and the effect of adding/removing fuel. With a wideband, how hard could it be?
Dude, give Dezod a call, they are not too far, and he mentioned he be willing to give someone a deal.
Originally Posted by
Dezod ↑ Yes this unit works. I'd be willing to cut one user a deal and help with tuning to provide further proof to the community that it works. Serious people only please.....
Dezod's thread. Focus_Sh1ftThread starterNew Jersey · Sep 22, 2010#255 Originally Posted by
sleey0 ↑ Do you plan on changing out any internal engine components?
I honestly don't know yet. If I did it wouldn't be for awhile.
Also very doubtful that a good tune will let this engine run on 12 psi. There's really no proof that it can't, so you could be the guinea pig. 😛
Anyways, I've decided I'll be doing my own tuning. I just ordered an AEM UEGO wideband and am going to do some more reading. cdydjded, I'll definitely be in touch... I'm hoping you can help me with the fuel trims for the most part, as that seems to be the most difficult.
Originally Posted by
why? ↑ Dude, give Dezod a call, they are not too far, and he mentioned he be willing to give someone a deal.
Yeah, exactly what I thought, but I'm using an FIC. I have to admit, it is slightly tempting to take the deal and get some REAL engine management...
sleey0PA · Sep 22, 2010#256The jimze sc kit puts out 1 bar, as far as i can tell.
Therefore our cars should be ok at 12 psi. As long as the tune isnt crazy aggressive and richens out the afr.
Nexus1155Dorchester · Sep 22, 2010#257 The jimze sc kit puts out 1 bar, as far as i can tell.
Therefore our cars should be ok at 12 psi. As long as the tune isnt crazy aggressive and richens out the afr.
Stop your reasoning right there. 12psi on one thing is not 12psi on another depending on how much air it pumps out. A tune cannot be "aggressive or subtle" The fuel is tuned to 11.* AFR and the ignition is dialed in to where there is no knock.
In terms of aggresiveness it relates to how much pressure you are pumping in there. Say on this engine 6psi on his turbo kit is streetable. you can get away with 8psi on a good tune, but on these internals and that turbo, you would be wise to not try to push more than that.
sleey0PA · Sep 22, 2010#258 Originally Posted by
Nexus1155 ↑ Stop your reasoning right there. 12psi on one thing is not 12psi on another depending on how much air it pumps out. A tune cannot be "aggressive or subtle" The fuel is tuned to 11.* AFR and the ignition is dialed in to where there is no knock.
In terms of aggresiveness it relates to how much pressure you are pumping in there. Say on this engine 6psi on his turbo kit is streetable. you can get away with 8psi on a good tune, but on these internals and that turbo, you would be wise to not try to push more than that.
I see, and thank you. I shouldn't be comparing psi from the turbo to a sc.
See, you guys can hit me with the noob hammer once in a while. lol
Just wondering about that jimze blower and how much more it will put out and stress our engines.
Nexus1155Dorchester · Sep 22, 2010#259No, its not that. I just don't want to see anyone blowing up their engines from thinking that. If you didn't know, somewhere down the line it may have happened to you if you didn't have the proper info. I'd have to see the flow charts for the supercharger to compare to anything, but its hard to judge without testing it out and seeing how much you can push it.
I'm still looking around for a cheap G60 supercharger in good condition or an M45, or a GT25. I keep losing the damn ebay auctions
Focus_Sh1ftThread starterNew Jersey · Sep 22, 2010#260Yeah don't feel bad, you gotta learn somehow... A couple months ago I didn't even know what a turbocharger or surpercharger was. 😁
Interesting aside, and a testament to the learning power of our ECUs. For the first week and a half my narrowband signal has averaged about .22. As of the last couple days, it has actually risen to average out at about .38. Not too informative, but clearly the ECU has gotten better at running stoich conditions, even with forced induction in the mix. Tuning is obviously still needed though.
sleey0PA · Sep 22, 2010#261So you have no fuel management right now aside from the stock ecu and only have a narrowband?
Even I know that is risky! Lol
Focus_Sh1ftThread starterNew Jersey · Sep 22, 2010#262Yep 🙄
I was originally expecting to get tuned before doing this much driving, but complications extended the install and then school started so I NEED my car. Not to mention my potential tuner gave off vibes of being a total ass. I rarely push 5 psi though, so I'm definitely trying to play it safe. There will be plenty of time to blow people away once tuning is done.
sleey0PA · Sep 22, 2010#263All i know is that it must be extremely difficult to have a turbo and not drive like u have one.
I dont think i could do it lol. More power to ya!
I must say i have really enjoyed this thread and i wish u nothing but the best!
Oh, and once you learn the FIC, you will be getting pm's from me, bro! I am planning on using it with my sc setup in the next couple of months.
why?harnett county NC · Sep 22, 2010#264 Originally Posted by
sleey0 ↑ I see, and thank you. I shouldn't be comparing psi from the turbo to a sc.
See, you guys can hit me with the noob hammer once in a while. lol
Just wondering about that jimze blower and how much more it will put out and stress our engines.
Just want to make sure this is 100% clear. You can't even compare boost numbers from different turbo's, because different a/r's, compressor sizes, etc, can all make it different.
sleey0PA · Sep 22, 2010#265Yes, I understand.
My question was supposed to be in general, ie "can our engines run @ 12psi safely without building the motor".
That was my question. :D
cali yarisCanoga Park, CA · Sep 22, 2010#266^ probably not for very long.
Nexus1155Dorchester · Sep 23, 2010#267🙁🙁🙁🙁:brokenhe art:
Look at it this way, whats the power output of a GT25 @ 12psi compared to a GT35. The difference is astronomical.
sleey0PA · Sep 23, 2010#268Nevermind....
Nexus1155Dorchester · Sep 23, 2010#269nononono be lucky i am not tamago and i won't yell at you and i'll try not to go too in depth. I am going to show you what I mean. You are not allowed to build a turbo kit until you understand this. Basic I am sure you know, air + fuel + spark makes combustion and power. Doing something to allow air to flow into the engine more = more air+more fuel+spark = more power. Now if you take a turbo/supercharger and start forcing more air into the engine you will get alot more power.
http://www.atpturbo.com/root/maps/im...8rsturbine.gif Pretty much identical turbo other than the area/radius of the housings. If you follow any pressure ratio on that given map you will see the larger housing will always be pushing more air through the engine.
Depending on if you want it for low end boost or more high end, something even in the same family of turbos can be dangerous to your engine if you do not size it properly even a GT25 and you end up cranking up the pressure one day by a little bit your engine might blow. Even though these engines ae only like $50 a pop.
why?harnett county NC · Sep 23, 2010#270well maybe $500 a pop, but still dirt cheap engine wise.
Nexus1155Dorchester · Sep 23, 2010#271SEE $350 DELIVERED and thats a pretty good condition one as far as i can tell. Can't beat that
cali yarisCanoga Park, CA · Sep 23, 2010#27250... no.... 500...no....... 350....... BINGO
LOL
FreedanSan Diego, CA · Sep 23, 2010#273350 for an engine!? Wow. 😲
Might have to visit the local junkyard and find an engine that I can tinker with if it's that cheap.
Focus_Sh1ftThread starterNew Jersey · Sep 29, 2010#274Build update...
Been having problems getting the car to run properly with the FIC hooked up after I wired up the cam and crank wires. Turns out I had to drop the mago- wires on each, then just TAP C20-121 with both magi- wires. Why I had to do this when others didn't... I dunno.
Anyways, I first threw in a map pimp my yaris gave me just to see if my AFR would respond correctly, and possibly use as a base map for tuning. For whatever reason, nothing happened. Watching my wideband, the AFR continues to hold around 14.7 with no notable changes. I drove around a bit and pushed the engine to make sure. I'm going to do some logging and see if I can figure it out.
Was wondering what injector response time I should be running. Brian, Carlos, if you could chime in that'd be great.
Focus_Sh1ftThread starterNew Jersey · Sep 29, 2010#275Alright so tuning... I just don't understand how changing values on the fuel map is honestly going to work. By doing that I'm setting up the STFT and, therefore, the LTFT to be wayyyy off... I feel like the O2 sensors need to be manipulated to get an accurate and reliable tune. Also - while driving it seems like they just lean the car right back out to 14.7 even when additional fuel is being added. This is due to closed loop though, right? When I change values during idle I can watch the wideband go richer, then quickly get corrected back to about 15. So I'm assuming I need to leave everything out of boost untouched, then figure out a way to force the car into open loop when I'm boosting. Then I can adjust fuel without having the O2 sensors interfering, right?
So it's either force the car into open loop at around 15 PSIA, or manipulate the O2 so closed loop is forcing a richer AFR than 14.7. I feel like the latter is what I have to do, because the car begins boosting while in closed loop.
UGH. 🙄
pimp my yarischicago · Sep 29, 2010#276Your thinking is spot on. But you can do this with the maf. clamp when in the boost. OK first, when in closed loop [ie: normal driving] Your AFR will always be 14.5 to 15:1. This is actually good as it maintains low emmisions and good gas mileage. What we want is to clamp the MAF. at the correct voltage so when in the boost the computer will stop adding fuel and the FIC takes over. I still need to get this MAF max voltage on a normally aspirated Yaris. Also the most important AFR reading U need is when under heavy exceleration [IE: foot to the floor]. This is when Im trying to get that 12:1 zone AFR. The factory ECU flips to open loop at around 80% load or higher. Under that U should see 14.5 to 15:1 on the wideband. Their is no point to make the FIC control fueling all the time unless we are road racing or only driving a track car. I have already altered the map a little to help keep fuel trims more inline. What is your AFR when wide open and under boost. I know its difficult to answer but it should not go leaner then 13:1. Also in the map I gave you I clamped the map at 3.1 volts when in the boost and at above 3800rpm, if I remember correctly. Its still a work in progress for me too. I am happy I dont have any excessive rich or lean trouble codes.
1.5tySalisbury nc · Sep 30, 2010#277Your spot on with everything but way are you looking for a a/f of 12.1 I know how to use aem standalone but not fic and when I tune with that with a boosted car max power falls around 11.2-11.5 a/f
pimp my yarischicago · Sep 30, 2010#278This is the first car I have worked on tuning. The factory (non boosted) open loop AFR was 12:1 to 12.5 to 1. I just tryed to keep it in that range. I dont have a dyno. Everyone here seems to have a different opinion on the best AFR range to run.
Focus_Sh1ftThread starterNew Jersey · Sep 30, 2010#279Ok good I was wondering how you were running something other than 14.7 under closed loop but you're not. I took your map and made a couple changes according to where my car enters boost, and I also moved the MAF clamp to a lower RPM and changed it to 2.9 (my max value out of boost approximately).
The problem I was having yesterday was that I was entering boost and was still stuck around a 14.7 AFR. Even by 5 PSI I wasn't getting any richer. I'm not sure why... I'll watch closed/open loop more closely today and see where it switches. I may have actually been using a map yesterday that didn't have a MAF clamp... can't remember. That could be the issue.
AFRs confuse the hell out of me because there's a lot of conflicting information online... I was under the impression I needed an 11.5ish AFR at all times on an FI engine, but that's only really needed during boosting I reckon?
Focus_Sh1ftThread starterNew Jersey · Oct 2, 2010#280Well I had a crummy last two days lol. Car died because of battery terminal corrosion, then I went to go replace a coolant adapter and had the wrong one. Good thing is that I finally know the exact size thread I need so I can stop battling this stupid tiny leak.
Anyways, I've been toying with the FIC the last couple days and setup a MAF map. I put it in voltage mode and am using the MAF as the reference column. I then set all the rows to mirror the incoming MAF voltage. This way, MAF in = MAF out. However, at 2100 RPM and 2.81 volts, I've clamped everything beyond those values at 2.9V. This appeared to be the max N/A voltage reading I was obtaining. Not sure if this will work, as I haven't had time to try it yet.
Brian - if this works we won't need a MAF map. In fact I don't see why this wouldn't work. Anyhoo, I started throwing a MAF map together in case this fails, but it's been a real PITA so far...
Focus_Sh1ftThread starterNew Jersey · Oct 2, 2010#281Alright.. Would like to talk about open loop. Hopefully some of you here will have some info for me.
I've yet to see my car enter open loop unless I am letting off the throttle entirely. How hard do you need to be pushing a car to enter open boost, WOT? Because I do my driving in the 1k-3.5k range and rarely hit WOT. Is there some sort of difference between a manual and automatic that I don't know about?
1.5tySalisbury nc · Oct 2, 2010#282Open loop and close loop it controlled by temp when you start the car in the morning when it's cold that's what they call open loop after it's warm and that's what they call closed loop
1.5tySalisbury nc · Oct 2, 2010#283To get full boosted it's all about the turbo you have and your setup
Bluevitz-rsOshawa, Ontario, Canada · Oct 2, 2010#284It's simply, in one situation the ecu is using pre-determained values to operate the engine and ignores the sensors. The other it's using the sensor readings.
Focus_Sh1ftThread starterNew Jersey · Oct 2, 2010#285 Originally Posted by
1.5ty ↑ To get full boosted it's all about the turbo you have and your setup
Agreed, and by 7 PSI of boost my car still maintains closed loop. I know this because I have a scan gauge.
I need more information on this, because it's going to ultimately determine how I go about tuning.
EDIT: And allow me to clarify, I understand what the two are. But I'm told that modern cars enter open loop under heavy acceleration, and this is where I need to tune with the FIC, but I've yet to see it happen.
1.5tySalisbury nc · Oct 2, 2010#286There is two ways to tune under wot on a dyno or street it really dosnt mater about open or closed loop
Focus_Sh1ftThread starterNew Jersey · Oct 4, 2010#287Hopefully I'm not speaking too soon, but it would appear that my P0101 has gone away.
Ever since I cleaned the corrosion off my battery terminal, it's yet to come back. I also have completed enough driving cycles to determine whether or not there's any pending codes so... 🎉
eTiMaGoBangkok, Thailand · Oct 4, 2010#288From OBD datalogging that PK did some time ago, it seems the main condition for entering open loop is 75% signal from the throttle position sensor. So, put the pedal to the metal!
sleey0PA · Oct 4, 2010#289Or, maybe CTSCOTT can design something to trick the ECU to think it is always in openloop.
Then we would have 100" control of out cars/tuning withought standalone!
GREAT idea, now?
eTiMaGoBangkok, Thailand · Oct 4, 2010#290There is *potentially* such a trick, the other time the car is in open loop mode is when it's warming up. I've heard of tuners in Puerto Rico doing this, but you could put a resistor in line with the water temperature sensor to fool the ECU into thinking the car is *never* warm, hence it would stay in this warmup mode as long as you wanted. BUT, this is really a pretty dirty hack, I personally have no idea what other effects it may have...
sleey0PA · Oct 4, 2010#291^^
Send this to ctscot and lets here his answer!!
Can't wait!
Then the car will REALLY be tunable w00t w00t!
Focus_Sh1ftThread starterNew Jersey · Oct 4, 2010#292 Originally Posted by
eTiMaGo ↑ From OBD datalogging that PK did some time ago, it seems the main condition for entering open loop is 75% signal from the throttle position sensor. So, put the pedal to the metal!
THANK YOU. 🙇
This is the information I needed.
Originally Posted by
eTiMaGo ↑ There is *potentially* such a trick, the other time the car is in open loop mode is when it's warming up. I've heard of tuners in Puerto Rico doing this, but you could put a resistor in line with the water temperature sensor to fool the ECU into thinking the car is *never* warm, hence it would stay in this warmup mode as long as you wanted. BUT, this is really a pretty dirty hack, I personally have no idea what other effects it may have...
I'm not feelin this lol. This is very iffy, and I feel like it would do more harm then good. Plus, fuel economy would blow if the car is constantly in open loop.
So I'm pretty baffled at this point though. What do I even need to tune? If I don't push the car hard enough to be entering open loop, then that's not really an issue... Afterall, the car runs fine at stoich.
eTiMaGoBangkok, Thailand · Oct 4, 2010#293but, where's the fun in driving a turbo'ed car sensibly all the time? 😁
You *could* use a variable potentiometer, or switches, to change the water temp tweaking on the fly, when needed.
As for what you need to tune in open loop, there are loads of options out there, personally I would want to get my hands on an inexpensive apexi S-AFC and a wideband O2 gauge to see just how effective this kind of tweaking can be, even without boost (the Yaris does seem to generally run quite rich in open loop mode, might be just mine, but there's certainly some power to be gained by leaning things out at high RPMs)
cali yarisCanoga Park, CA · Oct 4, 2010#294You can pull the second O2 sensor, forcing a constant CEL, then tune the car. That is what ZPI did.
It's a really lame approach, though.
Focus_Sh1ftThread starterNew Jersey · Oct 4, 2010#295 Originally Posted by
cali yaris ↑ You can pull the second O2 sensor, forcing a constant CEL, then tune the car. That is what ZPI did.
It's a really lame approach, though.
Bit lame, but better and probably safer than the water temp idea.
But back to my original question, is tuning closed loop even necessary? Because it's going to be a PITA...
Also - I hardly drive "sensibly" lol. But I just don't get it... If I'm not driving hard enough to enter open loop, then wouldn't I be best off just continuing to run stoich? Or is the hotter intake air too dangerous to run at 14.7 at all times? I DONT UNDERSTAND LOL.
Bluevitz-rsOshawa, Ontario, Canada · Oct 4, 2010#296The water temp trick will set a code eventually anyways. My parents Matrix set this code on it's own because the thermostat went bad and the car wasn't warming up fast enough. It took a long time to through the code though, as we found it wasn't heating up very quickly for a long time. PS it's only a '03 so I'm sure the Yaris has an even smarter ECU.
cali yarisCanoga Park, CA · Oct 4, 2010#297if you are in boost AT ALL, you don't want to be at 14.7. You should be able to make boost without going WOT.
Clear?
Focus_Sh1ftThread starterNew Jersey · Oct 4, 2010#298 Originally Posted by
cali yaris ↑ if you are in boost AT ALL, you don't want to be at 14.7. You should be able to make boost without going WOT.
Clear?
Ok, this is what I thought originally.
So this means I do need to tune closed loop... So my options are what I originally stated - force the car into open loop or manipulate the O2 sensors. I guess I don't have much of a choice but to start fooling around with the O2 sensors. 🤷
1.5tySalisbury nc · Oct 5, 2010#299Hey focus this is what you need to do not trying to be an ass here but you should take the car to a pro but if you don't want to here are a few thing to remember about tuning 1st it's always easier with two people but not needed ok when you start tuning you want to tune a no load meaning idle like I said before your looking for a a/f of 11:2 to 11:5 I'm not trying to tell you anything wrong if you take Otto a tuner that's what there going to look for so at idle set it around 11:5 after you get that then start with a light load don't get in to boost this is where two people come in hand as your driving cool at your gauges and the pc when you see your starting to leave the sweet zone of 11:2/11:5 then stop make a few changes and start again after you get that set the keep giving it more of a load and more till you have ran put on rpms to play with but always stay in that sweet zone of 11:2/11:5 there is no need to play with the 02 other then with the fic everything can be done with the pc as soon I get my oil leak under controll I well start tuning with my fic and when I'm done I'll give you a full tune of 8psi or what ever psi your running but like I said there is no need to play with the 02 other then using the pc
And for those that think I wrong go ask any pro tuner and the will tell you everything I just said I have tuned using aem before so I know what I'm talking about
1.5tySalisbury nc · Oct 5, 2010#300Sorry about my spelling I'm using my iPad and it mess-up some of the words