Yarisworld Archive

Warning - Broken control arm bolt!

453 posts · 329,703 views · page 6 of 10

Replies continued

andulongSan Diego, CA · Aug 16, 2013#251
I just bought a set of bolts at my local Toyota dealer today. Unfortunately they look just like the old ones and have two marks, or lines on the head. I hope they did not sell me some old ones hoping I would not know the difference. Is there any other way to tell the difference? I am waiting to install them until I am sure they are the upgraded bolts. I am afraid if I go back to Toyota they will not know the difference, if there is one. Thanks.

Originally Posted by CTScott ↑
At least, if nothing more, the changed markings allow one to easily tell if they have new ones (old left, new right):

Attachment 49382
CTScottUSA, CT · Aug 16, 2013#252
Originally Posted by andulong ↑
I just bought a set of bolts at my local Toyota dealer today. Unfortunately they look just like the old ones and have two marks, or lines on the head. I hope they did not sell me some old ones hoping I would not know the difference. Is there any other way to tell the difference? I am waiting to install them until I am sure they are the upgraded bolts. I am afraid if I go back to Toyota they will not know the difference, if there is one. Thanks.
There is not actually a different new bolt. It is simply a case of replacing like with like, and if you read the TSB, doing a bit of extra seam sealing limit the water that can enter in with the bolt.
andulongSan Diego, CA · Aug 16, 2013#253
Thanks CTScott, I think I will swap them out tomorrow then. Not sure I can do the seam sealing that is mentioned but at least the new bolts should add a few more years until something breaks.
camhNew Jersey · Aug 24, 2013#254
2008 Toyota Yaris sedan 34,500 on May 10, 2013 After full routine maintenance at my Toyota dealer (tires rotated, oil change, inspect ball joints, drive shaft, nuts, bolts, fluids, road test vehicle) on my daughter's car, we left to go to my son's graduation in Mass. about 3.5 hour drive. Fifty miles into the trip at 65 mph (I was driving, 35 yrs experience, no accidents) hot weather, dry roads, around noon lots of cars, three lane highway, we were in the slow lane following traffic, her car goes into a skid. I had no idea what was happening other than trying to avoid hitting other cars, going off a steep drop to the right or trying not to hit the cement median. I've been in skids before on bad winter roads but not at 65 mph. My foot was off the gas and I was not breaking, trying to regain control of the car. After trying to regain control after the 3rd skid the car took us into 180 degree spin and as we headed into the cement median I slammed on the brakes. I have since found my "Warranty Enhancement Notice" on her vehicle. The letter's not dated, I don't remember when it came but I had filed it in with her car info. I did not remember this letter but a month before the accident I would hear a clank noise if I went over a dip or if I turned her steering wheel sharply to the right when parking. She's away at college so I only drive her car every other day locally and back and forth on college pick ups. Our lives were spared that day and we did not hit anyone else. I would have to say it was a miracle. PLEASE if you have a Yaris 2006 - 2011 do not wait until it starts to make noise before you get it checked. I would have it checked every 6 months. Once this bolt breaks off, it is too late.
Hersheynortheast · Aug 24, 2013#255
Glad to see everyone is o.k. , imagine nerves were frayed . We have these noises and can't get any Toyota service center to replace the bolts . They never hear it and appears to be fine on the lift . We also got the notice . Should make it mandatory .
camhNew Jersey · Aug 24, 2013#256
After doing alot of searching online, I have found two lawsuits for wrongful death regarding the Toyota Yaris 2008. One was a soldier home and the other a college student. If my daughter and I had been killed that day they would have wrongly assumed it was our fault, when in fact it was the control arm. There are several others who documented online their accidents at a lower speed. You are 100% correct it needs to be a mandatory recall. If this got media attention perhaps then it would be taken seriously.
bronsinnj · Aug 24, 2013#257
My BMW F650 motorcycle stalled at lights. One a year at first then after three years every week. BMW had it three times and couldnt fix it. Other bikes did it too.

No recall ever issued. Probably moot because I doubt they could have done naything anyway. : (.
Hersheynortheast · Aug 24, 2013#258
Went and got the bolts replaced . No appointment , just popped in with the notice from Toyota . The previous 2 did nothing . 2 new bolts , but it still creaked when pulling onto the uneven surface of a restaurant parking lot 🙁 . Should we be concerned of that ? Here's the invoice .
DSCF2218.JPG
Hersheynortheast · Aug 24, 2013#259
Originally Posted by CTScott ↑
90119-14126 (They are about $4 each)

Torque is: 118 ft lbs.
The part # stated on the invoice is 90119-14151 . Is this the new part number or is the bolt / washer part # for the sedan control arm different than that of the hatchback ?
CTScottUSA, CT · Aug 24, 2013#260
90119-14151 is a new part number. It replaces 90119-14126 and 90119-14144.
Hersheynortheast · Aug 24, 2013#261
CT , thanks for the quick response . Should it still be creaking ? Wouldn't think so . 🤷 .
CTScottUSA, CT · Aug 24, 2013#262
Originally Posted by Hershey ↑
CT , thanks for the quick response . Should it still be creaking ? Wouldn't think so . 🤷 .
The creaking probably has nothing to do with this bolt. It is more likely the bushing around the horizontal bolt that is creaking.
Hersheynortheast · Aug 25, 2013#263
Horizontal bolt of the front strut ? If so , should that be covered under the PLATINUM extended warranty ? Really appreciate your help.
CTScottUSA, CT · Aug 25, 2013#264
Originally Posted by Hershey ↑
Horizontal bolt of the front strut ? If so , should that be covered under the PLATINUM extended warranty ? Really appreciate your help.
No. The horizontal bolt that allows the A-Arm to pivot up and down.
Hersheynortheast · Aug 25, 2013#265
How long of a job is it to be replaced and can it be dangerous to drive? We found that uneven outer tire wear is one of the symptoms which we have on both front sides. 7/32s on outer sides of both front tires and the rest is 8/32s . The Bridgestone Ecopia EP 422s' started at 11/32s and were installed on 4/6/13 . They've been rotated once . Seems like quick wear . The previous tires wore quick too . Those were Continental Pro Contact Eco Plus . Don't drive like a speed demon , just average .
Hersheynortheast · Aug 25, 2013#266
Does anyone have the clunking of the front end after the 2 bolts were replaced ?
Hersheynortheast · Aug 25, 2013#267
Another thought . Will the sedan need an alignment if the front suspension is repaired ? Would think so .
CTScottUSA, CT · Aug 25, 2013#268
Originally Posted by Hershey ↑
Another thought . Will the sedan need an alignment if the front suspension is repaired ? Would think so .
Not if just the bolts are replaced. If the full service is done where they drop the A arms and seal the seams, then alignment should be done.

As another thing to worry about, today I was finishing my disassembly of the Yaris I am parting out. The front bolts were perfect (this is a 2007 California car that appears to have never even made contact with water with how perfect all metal parts have been).

When I dropped the rear axle beam I noticed that one of the bolts that mounts it to the body had a significant spot of corrosion. This was the only bolt on the entire car that had a hint of rust. This makes we want to take a peek at the ones off my Yaris which have seen lots of Winter salt.

In this picture the long ones on the left are the rear beam bolts and the right ones are the A Arm bolts:
Bolts.jpg
NEexpatS.E. New England · Aug 26, 2013#269
^ I'd be interested to know what you discover on your cars Scott.

That spot high up on the thread like that, not good, very odd considering the condition of the rest of the car.

Perhaps just a bad bolt.................................or is there some sort of design flaw with the rear axle beam like with the A arms, great now I'm going to go slide under my car and look about.
bronsinnj · Aug 26, 2013#270
You know I just want to express appreciation for this site which keeps us so well informed about the (relatively minor) problems with our cars. My hat is off to you all! 👏

Also my thanks to Toyota for making the Yaris the quality, practical car that it is. You should read some of the problems cars on other sites are having! 😢

And REALLY read the problems BMW motorcycles are having at The Chain Gang.com! 😲
Hersheynortheast · Aug 27, 2013#271
CT, are the bushings visible or easy to view for inspection ? A relative has a lift in his garage and is a mechanic. What should we look for if the bushings are bad ? Thanks
CTScottUSA, CT · Aug 27, 2013#272
Originally Posted by Hershey ↑
CT, are the bushings visible or easy to view for inspection ? A relative has a lift in his garage and is a mechanic. What should we look for if the bushings are bad ? Thanks
The bushings around the bolts are easy to see, but I don't think you will see anything obvious. I think you will need to try to recreate to motion while listening closely to catch the noise.
Hersheynortheast · Aug 27, 2013#273
Do the techs use a listening device when moving the arms up and down while on a lift to pinpoint the noise? How long would it take to determine the source ? May have to take it to a dealer and would like to know what to expect. Thanks for all of your help.
CTScottUSA, CT · Aug 27, 2013#274
Originally Posted by Hershey ↑
Do the techs use a listening device when moving the arms up and down while on a lift to pinpoint the noise? How long would it take to determine the source ? May have to take it to a dealer and would like to know what to expect. Thanks for all of your help.
My bet is they will shake it or road test it and tell you there is nothing wrong and that the noise is normal.
Hersheynortheast · Aug 27, 2013#275
That's quite possible since it's warranty work and a big job. 🙂
DonMOntario · Sep 4, 2013#276
I was going to sell my 2008 Yaris sedan but changed my mind so I went ahead and purchased the control arm bolts from my local Toyota dealer for $17.50.....and I am glad that I did (refer to the photo)......I took it took to a Midas dealer for an oil change and they swapped out the bolts for free - considering that my car only has 47,500 km on it and has not seen a lot of winter driving - I would hate to see the bolts on some of the high milers that are driven in the rust belt.

Don't wait for the clunking sound to appear - do it now since it costs so little to do.
bolts-qpr.jpg
Hersheynortheast · Sep 4, 2013#277
^ Good thinking ^ . We believe the creaking / clunking in the front has gone since the replacement of the bolts . Still have it coming from the rear . At least it's not in stereo for now 😁 .
camhNew Jersey · Sep 15, 2013#278
Originally Posted by DonM ↑
I was going to sell my 2008 Yaris sedan but changed my mind so I went ahead and purchased the control arm bolts from my local Toyota dealer for $17.50.....and I am glad that I did (refer to the photo)......I took it took to a Midas dealer for an oil change and they swapped out the bolts for free - considering that my car only has 47,500 km on it and has not seen a lot of winter driving - I would hate to see the bolts on some of the high milers that are driven in the rust belt.

Don't wait for the clunking sound to appear - do it now since it costs so little to do.

My daughter's car was less than 34,000 miles when her right control arm broke. 🙁
nookandcrannycarS.MontgomeryCnty,TX(HoustonMSA) '07=BayouBlue=300,125miles=OrigOwnr '14=ClassicSilvr=29,059miles · Sep 15, 2013#279
Originally Posted by camh ↑
My daughter's car was less than 34,000 miles when her right control arm broke. 🙁
Ugh. Is your daughter also in New Jersey or a similar location re winter road maintenance that might contribute to the control arm issue?
DebbyM46227Indianapolis · Sep 17, 2013#280
Originally Posted by Hershey ↑
Does anyone have the clunking of the front end after the 2 bolts were replaced ?
No, I haven't heard it since they replaced my bolts.
WildChildQuebec City · Sep 22, 2013#281
Hi,
the passenger side's bolt snapped last week on my 2007 sedan. After hearing the clunking noise when driving over bumps during the weekend, I looked under the car and found out that the bolt was missing.

I see in this thread that the warranty was extended to 100K miles (160K KM)/7 years for this issue in the US. My car 6 1/2 years old and has only 77K KM. Does anyone know if the warranty extension also applies to Canada?

Thank you!
CTScottUSA, CT · Sep 22, 2013#282
Originally Posted by WildChild ↑
Hi,
the passenger side's bolt snapped last week on my 2007 sedan. After hearing the clunking noise when driving over bumps during the weekend, I looked under the car and found out that the bolt was missing.

I see in this thread that the warranty was extended to 100K miles (160K KM)/7 years for this issue in the US. My car 6 1/2 years old and has only 77K KM. Does anyone know if the warranty extension also applies to Canada?

Thank you!
On the Canadian version of the Service Bulletin it says the following, but the US one initially read that way as well and then later we received the warranty extension letters in the mail.

APPLICABLE WARRANTY

- This repair is covered under the Toyota Basic Warranty. This warranty is in effect for 36 months from the vehicle’s warranty registration date or 60,000 kilometres, whichever occurs first.

- Warranty application is limited to occurrence of the specified condition described in this bulletin.
Hersheynortheast · Sep 22, 2013#283
Well , sounds like we may have the creaking from the front after the bolt fix . The rear suspension is creaking too . It's like having quadrophonic stereo at times . We bicker about which end it came from 😁 . Love the gas mileage , but this car has been a real pain in the in 4 1/2 years of owning it .
WildChildQuebec City · Sep 23, 2013#284
I called the dealership this morning and the warranty extension also exists for Canada. The guy mentionned 84 months/160K KM. I have an appointment tomorrow to have this fixed.

The guy said that a new TSB was released in 2012 about the warranty extension, but unfortunately I don't have the number.
barrywareChicago · Sep 24, 2013#285
After reading this thread (a few times), I stopped at the dealer and picked up two bolts.. After tax, they were under 12 bucks.

I haven't been able to figure out if I need to replace the bolts by the vin.. My vin: JTDJT92317506XXXX.

Doesn't matter now as I have them but I would like to understand the "affected" cars using the vin. I did get the letter from Toyota extending the warranty to 100K miles. I have 97K+ on the car now. (2007 3dr hatch)

I understand that no alignment or anything is necessary after removing the old, and installing the new bolt(s). Is there any concern of anything moving if you have the car jacked up? If I need to jack up the car, any problem using a floor jack and lifting the car by jacking the control arm up.. Right where the strut is? I REALLY hate jacking the car up using the jack points that you would use if you get a flat and need the jack that comes with the car.
CTScottUSA, CT · Sep 24, 2013#286
Originally Posted by barryware ↑
After reading this thread (a few times), I stopped at the dealer and picked up two bolts.. After tax, they were under 12 bucks.

I haven't been able to figure out if I need to replace the bolts by the vin.. My vin: JTDJT92317506XXXX.

Doesn't matter now as I have them but I would like to understand the "affected" cars using the vin. I did get the letter from Toyota extending the warranty to 100K miles. I have 97K+ on the car now. (2007 3dr hatch)

I understand that no alignment or anything is necessary after removing the old, and installing the new bolt(s). Is there any concern of anything moving if you have the car jacked up? If I need to jack up the car, any problem using a floor jack and lifting the car by jacking the control arm up.. Right where the strut is? I REALLY hate jacking the car up using the jack points that you would use if you get a flat and need the jack that comes with the car.
Correct on no alignment necessary after replacement.

As for jacking, I would not do so at the control arm. The correct front jack point (other than the pinch seams) is where the rear transmission mount meets the frame.
WildChildQuebec City · Sep 24, 2013#287
The repair was done this morning, free of charge.
esse10richmond TX. · Sep 25, 2013#288
Question for you folks that used the Copper anti-seize, Did you put the anti-seize on the bolt threads also and did you still torque the bolt to the specs of 118 ft-lbs ? We don't get any salt on the roads down here in Texas but i will remove and inspect these bolts and depending on what condition I find I'll decide what Preventive Maintenance schedule will be required in the future.

Next question; is there a way to get Toyota corp. to acknowledge this problem and send me a letter about the extended warranty? I called my local dealer and the warranty office person acted like she had never heard of such a problem, even after I mentioned the TSB3271.
CTScottUSA, CT · Sep 25, 2013#289
Originally Posted by esse10 ↑
Question for you folks that used the Copper anti-seize, Did you put the anti-seize on the bolt threads also and did you still torque the bolt to the specs of 118 ft-lbs ? We don't get any salt on the roads down here in Texas but i will remove and inspect these bolts and depending on what condition I find I'll decide what Preventive Maintenance schedule will be required in the future.

Next question; is there a way to get Toyota corp. to acknowledge this problem and send me a letter about the extended warranty? I called my local dealer and the warranty office person acted like she had never heard of such a problem, even after I mentioned the TSB3271.
I thoroughly coated the threads and the washer portion of the head and torqued them to spec.
barrywareChicago · Sep 26, 2013#290
I changed my bolts today.. Drivers side was a problem.. The rust was so heavy on the bolt, it would not clear the bushing.. I had to back & forth, in & out.. Took about 1/2 hour to get it out. Passenger side was not much of a problem.
DSC02245.JPG
CTScottUSA, CT · Sep 26, 2013#291
Originally Posted by barryware ↑
I changed my bolts today.. Drivers side was a problem.. The rust was so heavy on the bolt, it would not clear the bushing.. I had to back & forth, in & out.. Took about 1/2 hour to get it out. Passenger side was not much of a problem.
Wow! That looks like it would not have lasted through this coming winter.
barrywareChicago · Sep 26, 2013#292
real glad I visit the forum often and found this thread..

FYI.. When I was at the stealer to buy the bolts.. I brought my letter from Toyota.. I asked if they would check.. They said if they are not broke, we won't replace'em.. Sounds kinda silly but that is the way of the stealer.

The letter extends the warranty to 100K miles.. My car has 97K+ so that is why I figured I would just buy the bolts & replace'em.

And.. 120 (118) foot pounds of torque is a $hit load when you are on your back, tugging on $hit!. Me thinks I'm gonna be sore tomorrow. 😲
nookandcrannycarS.MontgomeryCnty,TX(HoustonMSA) '07=BayouBlue=300,125miles=OrigOwnr '14=ClassicSilvr=29,059miles · Sep 26, 2013#293
Originally Posted by barryware ↑
They said if they are not broke, we won't replace'em
🙄

Sounds kinda silly but that is the way of the stealer.:
😆. I think I'm glad (😛) I was way past the warranty period when I first viewed this thread. Zero chance of being disappointed on that particular score.
andulongSan Diego, CA · Oct 22, 2013#294
Originally Posted by CTScott ↑
90119-14151 is a new part number. It replaces 90119-14126 and 90119-14144.
HI, I am still holding out on replacing these bolts and now more confused than before. I bought the bolts # 14126 and was told that was the proper bolt to use and that it was not an issue with a defective bolt but more with improper drainage causing rust. Then I read the above post. So, now there is a different part number, does anyone know if it is actually a new and improved bolt? Thanks. I just want to do this once and hopefully get it right.
CTScottUSA, CT · Oct 22, 2013#295
Originally Posted by andulong ↑
HI, I am still holding out on replacing these bolts and now more confused than before. I bought the bolts # 14126 and was told that was the proper bolt to use and that it was not an issue with a defective bolt but more with improper drainage causing rust. Then I read the above post. So, now there is a different part number, does anyone know if it is actually a new and improved bolt? Thanks. I just want to do this once and hopefully get it right.
Toyota often seems to change part numbers, and sometimes with no visible change to the part (it could be something as simple as them changing suppliers for the part and hence revving the part number). I bought some of the 90119-14151 bolts and there does not appear to be any difference in strength rating, plating, etc. with the new part number.

I personally plan on checking (and perhaps replacing) the bolts once per year.
nookandcrannycarS.MontgomeryCnty,TX(HoustonMSA) '07=BayouBlue=300,125miles=OrigOwnr '14=ClassicSilvr=29,059miles · Nov 22, 2013#297
On 8-24-13 I read (posted that day) Camh's account of the accident (re the control arm bolt breaking) while driving his daughter's low mileage Yaris, and read Hershey's post (got his bolts replaced later that day). I also had a 'Yikes' reaction. I was in Branson, and over the next day or two drove around Table Rock Lake. The roads there are kind of funky. I didn't know if what I was feeling was because of the roads or my Yaris. On my way back to the Interstate, I stopped in Springfield, Missouri to get my oil changed and have the car otherwise looked at on a lift. The tech wrote that one of the motor mounts was worn, but didn't specify which one 🙄.

Earlier this month, the bulb went out on the middle of the 3 climate gauges on my Yaris. I had to order the bulb and prepay. Then the light came back on (the wheel is bent via my little cousin's foot when she was 5 🙂). I decided to ask if I could get a credit for the bulb and get 2 control arm bolts (a bit over 5 dollars when I priced them earlier this year...now a few cents over $8 (more than Kaotic paid in CA). The dealer let me do this. For the last week I've been feeling there must be something wrong, and have been really babying the car. I decided to take it in today (to the shop that did the serp belt, parking brake adjust, etc.) and have them check out the control arms, tie rods, steering rack, the knuckle, all the bushings, etc. and the motor mounts...and then proceed from there. The car had 267,865 miles on it when I drove in.

What a relief! All the above checked out just fine. Tech said the guy in Springfielfd was 'wrong'...likely just trying to get me to spend money. I also had them check the brakes...still good. I then had them replace the control arm bolts with the ones I got (as others on this thread have) from the Toyota dealer and had them torque the bolts to the spec CTScott (IIRC) recommended....I'm glad I did, as they DID have SOME RUST on them.. Given all of this, I thought the 'feeling' I'd been getting must be windier weather and having the tires at 37psi instead of the factory recommended 32psi. The manager felt I might be correct, so I had them put the tires at 32psi.

My total Bill (I almost feel bad as IIRC one person on this thread paid for 1.25 hours of labor for the control arm bolt replacement) $33.08.

The Firestone store where I got my tires is up the street, so I headed up there (slow leak in driver rear tire needed free repair). I could hear the wind around the car, but the lower PSI in the tires made all the difference in the world.

After the tire store, I headed to a brake specific shop to get a better idea on specific % of wear (only thing the first shop wasn't specific on). Still under 40% wear front and back..check=free...at 267,897 miles (was right at 20% wear front and back about 60k miles ago).

P.S. - Factory recommended PSI = Toyota recommendation (not Firestone)
CTScottUSA, CT · Nov 22, 2013#298
I keep forgetting to post that this now includes 2007 to 2012 Yaris per T-SB-0078-12.

The newer TSB no longer specifies VIN range, but rather just says that:

"Some 2007 – 2012 model year Yaris vehicles may exhibit a noise from the front area that is heard under acceleration/deceleration, when braking, or when driving over an uneven road surface. New No. 2 front lower suspension arm bolts are now available to address this condition."

The current bolt part number per the TSB is: 90119-14151

It also mentions that some bolts may have and orange dot on the head and those that do are non-reusable, where ones without the orange dot can be removed and retorqued.
nookandcrannycarS.MontgomeryCnty,TX(HoustonMSA) '07=BayouBlue=300,125miles=OrigOwnr '14=ClassicSilvr=29,059miles · Nov 22, 2013#299
Originally Posted by CTScott ↑
I keep forgetting to post that this now includes 2007 to 2012 Yaris per T-SB-0078-12.

The newer TSB no longer specifies VIN range, but rather just says that:

"Some 2007 – 2012 model year Yaris vehicles may exhibit a noise from the front area that is heard under acceleration/deceleration, when braking, or when driving over an uneven road surface. New No. 2 front lower suspension arm bolts are now available to address this condition."

The current bolt part number per the TSB is: 90119-14151

It also mentions that some bolts may have and orange dot on the head and those that do are non-reusable, where ones without the orange dot can be removed and retorqued.
Earlier posts of yours (IIRC) indicated that the old part number ended in 126 (for 2006-2009?) and the other part number (not ending in 151) = for 2010+....and that 151 replaces both part numbers so that the full range = one part number rather than two. When I visited the dealer, the parts rep indicated = exactly as you described (however that was 🙂).

The tech today (at the shop, not the Toyota dealer) had some other reference nomenclature for this bolt, so I just logged on and showed the manager the picture of the bottom of your Yaris with the red circles you put around the two bolt locations. So clear. The manager was then able to easily communicate this to the tech 👍.

I remember noticing, when I picked up the new bolts at the dealer, a 'raised stamp' (forgive the Layman's term 🙂) that I assumed indicated that they each = a 'No. 2'.
CTScottUSA, CT · Nov 22, 2013#300
Originally Posted by nookandcrannycar ↑
Earlier posts of yours (IIRC) indicated that the old part number ended in 126 (for 2006-2009?) and the other part number (not ending in 151) = for 2010+....and that 151 replaces both part numbers so that the full range = one part number rather than two. When I visited the dealer, the parts rep indicated = exactly as you described (however that was 🙂).

The tech today (at the shop, not the Toyota dealer) had some other reference nomenclature for this bolt, so I just logged on and showed the manager the picture of the bottom of your Yaris with the red circles you put around the two bolt locations. So clear. The manager was then able to easily communicate this to the tech 👍.

I remember noticing, when I picked up the new bolts at the dealer, a 'raised stamp' (forgive the Layman's term 🙂) that I assumed indicated that they each = a 'No. 2'.


The 90119-14151 part number is all inclusive for 07-12 liftbacks and sedans.

The raised markings on the head actually indicate the grade (strength) of the bolt. The "No. 2" is just the name of the bolts relative to their position.