Yarisworld Archive

Warning - Broken control arm bolt!

453 posts · 329,703 views · page 8 of 10

Replies continued

tmontagueCaledonia Ont. · May 12, 2014#351
I'll be replacing the bolts on my 08 Yaris this weekend as the dealership I ordered then from won't get them in until Tuesday. I live in Southern Ontario so I'm not expecting then to look great. I have an impact driver would anyone recommend using that to remove the bolts? Or am I better to stick with a cheater bar since to avoid snapping the head off?


Scott did you have to jack anything up to keep it from falling down when you removed the sub frame? I'm asking incase my bolts snap I want to be able to take it to my mechanic and have him weld on a but and remove the bolts without having to spend a ton of time and therefore cost me a ton if money. The more I can do myself the better and I don't have welding equipment.
CTScottUSA, CT · May 12, 2014#352
Originally Posted by tmontague ↑
I'll be replacing the bolts on my 08 Yaris this weekend as the dealership I ordered then from won't get them in until Tuesday. I live in Southern Ontario so I'm not expecting then to look great. I have an impact driver would anyone recommend using that to remove the bolts? Or am I better to stick with a cheater bar since to avoid snapping the head off?


Scott did you have to jack anything up to keep it from falling down when you removed the sub frame? I'm asking incase my bolts snap I want to be able to take it to my mechanic and have him weld on a but and remove the bolts without having to spend a ton of time and therefore cost me a ton if money. The more I can do myself the better and I don't have welding equipment.

I would use a long handled ratchet or breaker bar, rather than an impact gun. If the bolts are in bad shape the impact gun will snap them like toothpicks.

You don't have to support anything while removing them and can carefully drive to the dealership if one snaps on you.
tmontagueCaledonia Ont. · May 12, 2014#353
Thanks, I'll post how it went after the weekend. If they did snap I wouldn't be able to remove the sub frame and drive to my mechanic and get him to weld a nut to the broken bolt would I? I'm assuming I'd have to pay him to remove the subframe to get access to the bolt?
CTScottUSA, CT · May 12, 2014#354
Originally Posted by tmontague ↑
Thanks, I'll post how it went after the weekend. If they did snap I wouldn't be able to remove the sub frame and drive to my mechanic and get him to weld a nut to the broken bolt would I? I'm assuming I'd have to pay him to remove the subframe to get access to the bolt?
You can't drive with the subframe removed, but you can drive with the broken bolt(s). There are quite a few more bolts that hold the subframe to the chassis. You don't actually have to completely remove the subframe to get at the broken bolt; you just need to lower it a few inches. To completely remove it you have to disconnect the steering column from the steering rack.
tmontagueCaledonia Ont. · May 12, 2014#355
thanks for the clarification. I'll cross my fingers and hope there is still some strength left in the bolt head.
Mongoose7Liberty NY · May 12, 2014#356
Did my bolts about a week ago. I was very lucky... it's an '07 hatchback that spent all it's life in NY state.... lots of salt, and both of them came out w/o breaking!!!!!
Yaris Bolt.jpg
tmontagueCaledonia Ont. · May 19, 2014#357
I just did my bolts earlier today. My passenger side was in better shape and looked like Mongooses in the above image. My driver side bolt was very rusted and one more winter and it would have likely snapped. I am lucky to get them out in one piece, and about double the amount of crap came out from each screw hole then in the image above.

I coated the new bolts in a boat load of grease and installed. I will now be checking them after every winter (Southern Ontario - massive amounts of salt applied to roads) and re coating them in grease. It will be interesting to see how they hold up with the grease.

On a side note I also checked my valve clearance today. Not due to any excessive noise but more because my Yaris has 118,000 km on it and I wanted to inspect sludge build up and learn more about working on my car.

All the valves were right in the middle of their clearance ranges and my engine was spotless, absolutely no build up at all. FWIW I change my oil every 8,000km usually put in Canadian Tire Formula1 synthetic (always use synthetic since I got the car at 87,000km) and a general oil filter. I cleaned out the PCV valve as well with throttle body cleaner although it was rattling fine.

One thing I noticed was my number 1 spark plug hole looked like some oil or something had burned inside. The spark plug connector was dirty, the hole had a little dark burned dry oil on it and my spark plug had oil not on the igniter or threads but on the ceramic white part where the metal ring is. I changed the plugs when I got the car and I have never spilled oil on the engine and the other plug holes were all completely dry and clean. any ideas to what could have caused this? I checked my valve cover gasket it still very pliable and in good shape. I changed the spark plug just in case as I haven't noticed any performance or firing issues.

thanks in advance
kaz777usa · Jun 23, 2014#358
Originally Posted by Hershey ↑
" I would really like to see one of the bolts that has failed on someone's car. "

Would be nice to see a picture of the snaaped off bolt . Very slim chance .

" With the size of the bolts I don't believe that they can rust deep enough to weaken enough to fail. I have a funny feeling that the bolts in question have an issue where they were made either too soft or too brittle. "
Dont know if anyone showed one (snapped off bolt head), but here it is on our car, Right side (passenger). Made the noise took it to our mechanic who showed it to us and told us to go to toyota with the letter. We are hoping they cover it with the letter today. They sched it a 1pm (half day off work) hope it takes the hour and half they claim in letter???
Our local mechanic noticed the a/c drains right onto it. hmm? I live NE usa. This car has 50k on it 08 sedan yaris. The other side has a rusted regular looking bolt on the same bar. Not sure it they cover it. I bet they wont pull the same one on other side, I fear the head wont rust but the bolt will like mongoose pic above. Incidentally there seems to be a fair amt of rust on the bar near bolts on drivers side too, guess they wont cover it tho".

EDITED TO SAY: today my car is at a toyota dealer, they are giving us a loaner saying the car is not safe. They cov'd it in full both bolts and even fixed the seat adjuster recall, but the seat is harder to work now, must do it two handed on each side of front bottom of it. OH and the did a realignment since it got complicated getting the sheared off bolt out. Im very grateful had a great toyota dealer experience :) Ive had much worse at other types of dealers in the past.
bolt jpg.jpg
CB900F2Thread starterToronto · Jun 23, 2014#359
Wondering anyone else had the TSB performed on their yaris and removed to inspect the bolts? And if so, how was the condition... I am planning to inspect mine. Hoping the tsb helped in keeping the corrosive salt away from the bolts on mine ...
kaz777usa · Jun 23, 2014#360
cb900: what is tsb, I thought it was a notice that this was a problem, how would it protect the corrosion from happening? If there is something they can do to protect the bolts from corrosion I want it done!?
kaz777usa · Jun 23, 2014#362
duplicate reply sorry
kaz777usa · Jun 24, 2014#363
Originally Posted by yarisugi ↑
👍 thanks. I dont diy tho' so its up to toyota to cover what they will but its helpful to read those.
kaz777usa · Jun 24, 2014#364
I accid had a duplicate reply, delayed posts. Sorry. BTW they fixed my car bolts both, even tho one was sheared off, they also fixed the seat adjust thing on drivers side that is a recall or enhancement w/o me even telling them too. I got a loaner car on them (brand new corolla) I was very impressed w/ their service had worse experiences at past dealers of other makes.
The seat works harder now but if its safer ok.
CueBallUtah · Dec 4, 2014#365
I stumbled across this thread and now I'm thinking I better do this! I got the letter about a year ago and forgot all about it.
I think I'll try to get them out myself. I'm wondering why no one has thought to try and find better bolts.. something that has more resistance to corrosion.. like stainless steel maybe? What do you all think? Does stainless torque well? Will it hold the 118 ft/lbs?
Any input is appreciated.
CTScottUSA, CT · Dec 5, 2014#366
Originally Posted by CueBall ↑
I stumbled across this thread and now I'm thinking I better do this! I got the letter about a year ago and forgot all about it.
I think I'll try to get them out myself. I'm wondering why no one has thought to try and find better bolts.. something that has more resistance to corrosion.. like stainless steel maybe? What do you all think? Does stainless torque well? Will it hold the 118 ft/lbs?
Any input is appreciated.
Stainless is too brittle for this application.
eseibel67Canada · Dec 8, 2014#367
Well the 07 sedan has been through many southern Ontario winters and I'm afraid to try and take the bolts out. My plan is to drill a drainage hole, and using the straw, spray oil on the threads of the bolt. It would have to be done periodically, but it might save the bolt from furthur corrosion. I see this as a better option than trying to remove it and breaking it for certain.
dkwilfertKnoxville, TN · Dec 9, 2014#368
Originally Posted by CTScott ↑
Stainless is too brittle for this application.
Just curious, what was the source of the information that stainless is too brittle for this application? That seems to imply quite a bit of motion/flex at this joint.
CTScottUSA, CT · Dec 9, 2014#369
Originally Posted by dkwilfert ↑
Just curious, what was the source of the information that stainless is too brittle for this application? That seems to imply quite a bit of motion/flex at this joint.
The bolt is mounted in a metal tube that is then suspended in dense rubber so that the control arm can move, so there is definitely flex at that joint. The right blend of stainless would be fine, but off the shelf bolts would be more brittle of a stainless blend then would be appropriate.
bronsinnj · Dec 9, 2014#370
Originally Posted by eseibel67 ↑
Well the 07 sedan has been through many southern Ontario winters and I'm afraid to try and take the bolts out. My plan is to drill a drainage hole, and using the straw, spray oil on the threads of the bolt. It would have to be done periodically, but it might save the bolt from furthur corrosion. I see this as a better option than trying to remove it and breaking it for certain.
Id be afraid if its that far gone it will break all by itself.
nookandcrannycarS.MontgomeryCnty,TX(HoustonMSA) '07=BayouBlue=300,125miles=OrigOwnr '14=ClassicSilvr=29,059miles · Dec 9, 2014#371
Originally Posted by bronsin ↑
Id be afraid if its that far gone it will break all by itself.
👍 The accident mentioned earlier in this thread (in 2013) was enough to scare me into action.
CueBallUtah · Dec 11, 2014#372
Originally Posted by eseibel67 ↑
Well the 07 sedan has been through many southern Ontario winters and I'm afraid to try and take the bolts out. ....... a better option than trying to remove it and breaking it for certain.
I feel the same way. But if that happens I'll carefully drive to the dealership and have them do the warrenty. 👍

I guess stainless is out then? That's too bad. 👎
eseibel67Canada · Dec 12, 2014#373
As with most automotive problems, I usually mull it over for a few days before I tear into action.

There's no doubt that the (relatively) permanent solution is to get new bolts. Skip the seam sealer prescribed in the Toyota TSB because you will never get it 100% water tight anyway, and it will just delay evaporation of water that does get in there. Drill 1/4" holes so the water can drain out of that low spot. Paint the freshly cut metal to prevent corrosion. Slather the control arm hole/new bolt head washer with blue marine grade grease such as Bombardier Triple Guade grease. That stuff is so tacky, it's hard to wipe off with an alcohol soaked rag. It will surely fend off a few drops of water for the next 10 years.

I am just outside of the 7 year warrnty cutoff. Hopefully some devine miracle will allow the old bolts to be removed in one piece. I really want to avoid dropping the subframe.
nookandcrannycarS.MontgomeryCnty,TX(HoustonMSA) '07=BayouBlue=300,125miles=OrigOwnr '14=ClassicSilvr=29,059miles · Dec 12, 2014#374
Originally Posted by nookandcrannycar ↑
👍 The accident mentioned earlier in this thread (in 2013) was enough to scare me into action.
Bolts replaced in 2013 👍.
Echo86Oshawa, Ontario, Canada · Feb 2, 2015#375
Replaced the LCAs yesterday, successfully, without shearing any bolts or damaging threads. The alignment to get the arm is was the tricky part. Used a lube by a company called Schaeffer. Not available in stores and many times better than WD40. Before you laugh and say its from an infomercial, the guy who helped me with the arms had it in his shop. No heat needed at all to remove 12 yr old bolts without damage. Unreal stuff.
kanagawv, usa · Jun 20, 2015#376
It looks like i have some work to do...

Passenger side
20150620_170443.jpg

Driver side
20150620_170618.jpg

Any suggestions on the best way to remove the headless bolt?
ex-x-fireSheboygan Falls, Wi. · Jun 20, 2015#377
I think you can lower the cradle a little & try to turn it out with a pipe wrench.
kanagawv, usa · Jun 20, 2015#378
I was thinking that was the most probable solution. Would it need to be on a lift, or could I use ramps?
ex-x-fireSheboygan Falls, Wi. · Jun 20, 2015#379
If you try lowering the cradle it'll need to be on a lift or stands. You can access the upper nut of the control arm bolt if the foot well area. Someone actually pounded the broken bolt up through there, it broke loose the captured nut, allowing full removal of it.
CTScottUSA, CT · Jun 20, 2015#380
Removing the cradle is amazingly difficult with a broken bolt, as the rusted bolt bonds to the bolt sleeve. That is definitely the way to do it. Don't tray the hammering it to remove the captive nut route, as you will do more damage than you want to in doing so.
2009ToyotoadCalifornia · Jun 21, 2015#381
I seem to remember a recall notice for this. It might still be in my glove box I'll check tomorrow and update the post if its still there.
CTScottUSA, CT · Jun 21, 2015#382
Originally Posted by 2009Toyotoad ↑
I seem to remember a recall notice for this. It might still be in my glove box I'll check tomorrow and update the post if its still there.
There is a service bulletin on it. So, that really is another option (as long as it falls within the mileage limit) - to simply bring the car to Toyota and let them deal with it.
kanagawv, usa · Jun 21, 2015#383
Mine has 170,000 miles; way past the warranty
CTScottUSA, CT · Jun 21, 2015#384
Originally Posted by kanaga ↑
Mine has 170,000 miles; way past the warranty
And, if I remember correctly the "warranty extension" for this issue is only to 100K miles.
kanagawv, usa · Jun 21, 2015#385
Originally Posted by CTScott ↑
And, if I remember correctly the "warranty extension" for this issue is only to 100K miles.
Yep. 7 years / 100K miles
kanagawv, usa · Jun 21, 2015#386
Should I use jacks at the jack points to take the weight off of the wheels, or ramps? I don't have access to a lift.
CTScottUSA, CT · Jun 21, 2015#387
Originally Posted by kanaga ↑
Should I use jacks at the jack points to take the weight off of the wheels, or ramps? I don't have access to a lift.
Definitely jack it via the lift points. If you use ramps you will still have the weight on the front suspension. Make sure you support it very well, as it will take a lot of torque to break some of the bolts loose.
shepdKitchener, ON · Jun 22, 2015#388
Just did mine. They were so seized in there my 1/2" breaker bar was useless as it just kept bending (didn't stay bent but all my energy was going into a spring). Bought a 3/4" socket (no metric that small, but fortunately it's basically identical to 19mm) for my 36 inch 3/4" breaker bar. That did the job GREAT although I had to back the bolts out most of the way with the breaker bar as they never loosened enough for a ratchet until the very end. I did this with one corner of the car jacked up very high. Total labour (for me) about 2 hours (due to having to back them out with the big-ass breaker bar).

If I were to do this again, I'd simply do it with the car on the ground as those bolts are easy to reach without any need for additional clearance. Would take just as long but way more comfy. Or, if I were a shop, I'd put the car on a lift, get the bolts loose with the breaker bar, and finish them up with an impact wrench.

It was about time to do it as well, look at what doesn't get a recall in Toyota land:

Picture lost · i58.tinypic.com

Guess I will be doing this every couple of years so long as I own the car. Fortunately the replacement bolts are only $17 total here in Canada (odd to find something at the dealer that didn't require me to get a second job to pay for it).

Front end clunk never disappeared after fixing it, though. Guess I have something else to fix... Ball joints and tie rods seem fine. :(
tmontagueCaledonia Ont. · Jun 22, 2015#389
Originally Posted by shepd ↑
Front end clunk never disappeared after fixing it, though. Guess I have something else to fix... Ball joints and tie rods seem fine. :(
Check your sway bar end links, bushings and control arm bushings. I'm having the same issue on my Echo and i'm gooing to change the bushings next. I'll let you know if it fixes it. The struts, inner and outer tie rods, engine mounts are all new and the strut bearings were both regreased.
kanagawv, usa · Jun 29, 2015#390
If you're on the fence about replacing these bolts, do not assume that they are OK because the bolt heads look ok. My driver side bolt head looked brand new, but the shaft was in bad condition.

20150620_170618.jpg

20150629_175342.jpg
tmontagueCaledonia Ont. · Jun 29, 2015#391
How'd you end up removing the one w/ the snapped off head?
auxmikeLI, New Yawk · Jun 29, 2015#392
What's the part #?
kanagawv, usa · Jun 29, 2015#393
Originally Posted by tmontague ↑
How'd you end up removing the one w/ the snapped off head?
I jacked up the car and removed both wheels. I then removed all of the bolts holding the crossmember to the car. Then I was able to use a pry bar to pry down the lower control arm and crossmember. This exposed the shaft of the bolt above the bushing. I then used A pair of vice grips to back the bolt out.
kanagawv, usa · Jun 29, 2015#394
Originally Posted by auxmike ↑
What's the part #?
90119-14126 or 90119-14151

the second number is supposed to be a replacement for the first, but there doesn't seem to be any difference.
tmontagueCaledonia Ont. · Aug 3, 2015#395
Just some updated info regarding the bolts.

I removed mine the other day to inspect its condition. I replaced them about 10 months ago with new ones and put anti seize on the threads and covered the whole bolt in grease.

I re torqued them without weight on the wheels so I wanted to install them with the suspensions properly weighted and I was curious as to how a very cold and salted winter effected them.

I removed them and there was absolutely no rust on them what so ever. The grease was still all over the bolts but it was a bit more dry. I removed the old grease and put marine grease on them instead thinking it would do an even better job.

After seeing the condition after 1 year I will now be checking these every 2 years instead. I assume that they will last about 6-7 years before I'll need to replace them again.
JTDBT903NE. OHIO · Aug 17, 2015#396
Took car in for some recall work today and told them about the TSB and these bolts and the guy tells me this TSB is obsolete!

Was this ever a recall for northern USA climates? My car is a 08 sedan with 31k.

Should I just buy the bolts and replace? I only have one winter on her.
kanagawv, usa · Aug 17, 2015#397
Did he say anything about a new TSB that replaced it? I'm pretty sure that the bolts won't just stop rusting on their own.
CTScottUSA, CT · Aug 17, 2015#398
The update TSB is: T-SB-0078-12

The Canadian one is: T-TCI-3626
JTDBT903NE. OHIO · Aug 17, 2015#399
Originally Posted by CTScott ↑
The update TSB is: T-SB-0078-12

The Canadian one is: T-TCI-3626


Went back and told him about TSB 0078-12
and he said that is only good for the 3year/36k warranty.

I thought they extended this to 7year/100k?

Also, I got nowhere with corporate Toyota, but I only gave them the Canadian TSB 3271 at the time.
CTScottUSA, CT · Aug 17, 2015#400
Originally Posted by JTDBT903 ↑
Went back and told him about TSB 0078-12
and he said that is only good for the 3year/36k warranty.

I thought they extended this to 7year/100k?

Also, I got nowhere with corporate Toyota, but I only gave them the Canadian TSB 3271 at the time.
It is 7/100:

Warranty Extension.pdf