^^^^^👍 I wish Toyota (via the T.S.B) had described this the way you did above. It would have saved those of us who are out of warranty the thought of needing a potential 8 hour repair.Originally Posted by CTScott ↑It actually takes me longer to put one of my cars on the lift than it does to swap out the bolts, but if one was sheared off, it would turn into a nightmare job, which is probably why the TSB lists it as an 8 hour job.
Warning - Broken control arm bolt!
453 posts · 329,703 views · page 3 of 10
Replies continued
I took those bolt out two month ago and install UR lower 4 point bar. I dont see anything wrong with it.
Called Toyota and they gave a reference number for when brought in . There's creaking from the rear end as well ( culprit ? ) . Have it in stereo at times 😁 . Anyway , here are the bolts taken yesterday ( right ones I hope ) . Look o.k. ? Last , how does CT get his undercarriage so clean ? 😉



Originally Posted by Hershey ↑Called Toyota and they gave a reference number for when brought in . There's creaking from the rear end as well ( culprit ? ) . Have it in stereo at times 😁 . Anyway , here are the bolts taken yesterday ( right ones I hope ) . Look o.k. ? Last , how does CT get his undercarriage so clean ? 😉
I would really like to see one of the bolts that has failed on someone's car.
With the size of the bolts I don't believe that they can rust deep enough to weaken enough to fail. I have a funny feeling that the bolts in question have an issue where they were made either too soft or too brittle.
For the rear creaking, the springs or rear brakes are usually the culprit of that one. My 09 was doing it and I hit the perches with a light coat of silicone oil and it went away.
Don't you wax the bottom of your car too?
" I would really like to see one of the bolts that has failed on someone's car. "
Would be nice to see a picture of the snaaped off bolt . Very slim chance .
" With the size of the bolts I don't believe that they can rust deep enough to weaken enough to fail. I have a funny feeling that the bolts in question have an issue where they were made either too soft or too brittle. "
Makes sense .
" For the rear creaking, the springs or rear brakes are usually the culprit of that one. My 09 was doing it and I hit the perches with a light coat of silicone oil and it went away. "
Thanks .
" Don't you wax the bottom of your car too? "
No 🙂 . Don't wax the cars at all 😁 . A lift sure would be helpful . Maybe Santa will drop one off .
Would be nice to see a picture of the snaaped off bolt . Very slim chance .
" With the size of the bolts I don't believe that they can rust deep enough to weaken enough to fail. I have a funny feeling that the bolts in question have an issue where they were made either too soft or too brittle. "
Makes sense .
" For the rear creaking, the springs or rear brakes are usually the culprit of that one. My 09 was doing it and I hit the perches with a light coat of silicone oil and it went away. "
Thanks .
" Don't you wax the bottom of your car too? "
No 🙂 . Don't wax the cars at all 😁 . A lift sure would be helpful . Maybe Santa will drop one off .
I ran into my old ones today and did a comparison with a set of new ones (I always keep some on hand in case someone comes by that hasn't had them replaced yet).

My old ones, which had about 25,000 miles and 4 Winters on them just had light surface rust on the threads and very light surface rust at the base of the head. The interesting thing that I did notice is different markings on the head. In theory, this would mean a different bolt strength class, but according to the service manual, for a bolt with an included washer, either one or two marks means that the bolt is a class 6T bolt.
At least, if nothing more, the changed markings allow one to easily tell if they have new ones (old left, new right):


My old ones, which had about 25,000 miles and 4 Winters on them just had light surface rust on the threads and very light surface rust at the base of the head. The interesting thing that I did notice is different markings on the head. In theory, this would mean a different bolt strength class, but according to the service manual, for a bolt with an included washer, either one or two marks means that the bolt is a class 6T bolt.
At least, if nothing more, the changed markings allow one to easily tell if they have new ones (old left, new right):

I would think that it would be in very extreme cases that those bolts would break. Rust .. yes maybe but I think that it would take some bad conditions to make them fail. But what do I know.
I will maybe have the Toyota dealer check on mine the next time I am there, next spring for my oil change.
I will maybe have the Toyota dealer check on mine the next time I am there, next spring for my oil change.
Thanks ! We have the old bolts 🙁 . Wonder if Yaris Claus ( a.k.a. CT ) will replace them Christmas . Will leave cookies , milk , and a socket wrench kit in the trunk .
I am assuming they rust through to a certain point, then the high forces of the subframe blows the head off the bolts. There is a huge load on the subframe bolts when flexing the body. As I said, one of my bolts was completely immersed in water even after 2-3wks of no water exposure (rain or washing). If you live in a salty part of the world, you could have those bolts immersed in salt water 365 days a year. In marine applications it is possible to lose almost 1mm/yr of steel. In Scott's picture of the old bolts, the one on the left is through the zinc near the head of the bolt. Once the zinc coating is gone, those 14mm(?) bolts won't last long in those conditions. And that location is typically where bolts will pop apart under tension as well.
I keep forgetting to see if I can read the TSB at work yet. I am curious if they are doing anything to prevent water/salt from getting into the bolt holes again or not. My right side has a little crash damage, which allows the water to drain, so it's easy enough to correct.
I keep forgetting to see if I can read the TSB at work yet. I am curious if they are doing anything to prevent water/salt from getting into the bolt holes again or not. My right side has a little crash damage, which allows the water to drain, so it's easy enough to correct.
I don't quite understand it. My Yaris is 2008 with JTDKT vin, but according to the tsb it's not affected as it follows the production change on Shokki plant. How come some the TSB says 2006-2009? Are there some 08s made after some 09s?
And should I trust the tsb?
And should I trust the tsb?
Another thing, anyone had issues with bolts in the rear wheel arches (not too sure, probably subframe bolts) in front of the wheels? I am seeing some rust on those. Not necessarily a cause for concern as the bolts are intact, just wondering.
When I backing up and come to complete stop I hear like metal click noise. Is this due with lower control arm bolts defect. Please advice. Thanks!
I have this noise as well. Its actually very loud over some bumps. I just received a ZTU about this in the mail that Toyota will now cover the defect on late 2006 to early 2009 Yaris with up to 7 years and under 100,000 miles. Too bad I am at 117,000 miles.
Also, with the car off, I can push it back and I hear a loud squeaking sound as well! What in the world is this now? Could it be the control arm bolts just moving and producing the same sounds as over bumps? Or this is something completely different?
I also noticed a new noise. Its like a metal on metal vibration when the car gets warm/hot (even now in winter). As long as the car is in Drive and at a stop, it vibrates loud. Same again when first accelerating from a stop or at a low speed. What can this be?
Can someone help me please. I can't figure these out.
Also, with the car off, I can push it back and I hear a loud squeaking sound as well! What in the world is this now? Could it be the control arm bolts just moving and producing the same sounds as over bumps? Or this is something completely different?
I also noticed a new noise. Its like a metal on metal vibration when the car gets warm/hot (even now in winter). As long as the car is in Drive and at a stop, it vibrates loud. Same again when first accelerating from a stop or at a low speed. What can this be?
Can someone help me please. I can't figure these out.
Originally Posted by Lafiro ↑I have this noise as well. Its actually very loud over some bumps. I just received a ZTU about this in the mail that Toyota will now cover the defect on late 2006 to early 2009 Yaris with up to 7 years and under 100,000 miles. Too bad I am at 117,000 miles.
Also, with the car off, I can push it back and I hear a loud squeaking sound as well! What in the world is this now? Could it be the control arm bolts just moving and producing the same sounds as over bumps? Or this is something completely different?
I also noticed a new noise. Its like a metal on metal vibration when the car gets warm/hot (even now in winter). As long as the car is in Drive and at a stop, it vibrates loud. Same again when first accelerating from a stop or at a low speed. What can this be?
Can someone help me please. I can't figure these out.
The control arm bolts are easy to check. Even if you can't jack it up to take a look, you can at least feel for them. The pictures below shows where the bolts are located and what the bolts runs up through.
Attached picture not available

With the pushing back sound, if the bolt broke it could definitely be that.
The metallic sound may be from one of the exhaust shields having pulled through the head of the mounting bolt.
I wonder if they will reimburse me for having the motor control arm replaced due to this issue with the bolt?
Originally Posted by CTScott ↑I ran into my old ones today and did a comparison with a set of new ones (I always keep some on hand in case someone comes by that hasn't had them replaced yet).
Attachment 49381
My old ones, which had about 25,000 miles and 4 Winters on them just had light surface rust on the threads and very light surface rust at the base of the head. The interesting thing that I did notice is different markings on the head. In theory, this would mean a different bolt strength class, but according to the service manual, for a bolt with an included washer, either one or two marks means that the bolt is a class 6T bolt.
At least, if nothing more, the changed markings allow one to easily tell if they have new ones (old left, new right):
Attachment 49382
Can I have them? They look OK to me? 😕
Seems like everybody could R&R these bolts themselves, check them out, and replace them if need be.
If a quart of water comes out when you remove it, yeah, thats something that should be on the yearly to do list.
Can you just unscrew the bolt, take a look at it, and put it back without disturbing anything?
Or do things go out of alignment when you remove the bolt and its trouble getting it back in?
Whats the socket size?
Thanks!
Or do things go out of alignment when you remove the bolt and its trouble getting it back in?
Whats the socket size?
Thanks!
It is 19mm. You can remove it and reinstall it without issue.Originally Posted by bronsin ↑Can you just unscrew the bolt, take a look at it, and put it back without disturbing anything?
Or do things go out of alignment when you remove the bolt and its trouble getting it back in?
Whats the socket size?
Thanks!
Never got the TSB but our Yaris had the LHS bolt fail (bolt head fell off, control arm flopping around) due to this issue. I was out of state on a work trip so it was repaired (at our expense >$1000) at the dealer. We were told that they had awhile invested in the bolt extraction....sissies. Two new bolts and two "un-nessesary" control arms later.......👎
Water collects in that area, corrosion weakens the bolts, suspension forces overcome bolt strength, control arm flops around, leading to noise and an unsafe condition.
I highly doubt Toyota will reimburse anything unless the failure rate is high enough to require a mandatory recall. "Recall" something Toyota wants to avoid like the plague.
**Then Toyota mails a lame 36,000mile warranty extension out for this issue. Yea, thanks.
Water collects in that area, corrosion weakens the bolts, suspension forces overcome bolt strength, control arm flops around, leading to noise and an unsafe condition.
I highly doubt Toyota will reimburse anything unless the failure rate is high enough to require a mandatory recall. "Recall" something Toyota wants to avoid like the plague.
**Then Toyota mails a lame 36,000mile warranty extension out for this issue. Yea, thanks.
Originally Posted by JarHarms ↑Never got the TSB but our Yaris had the LHS bolt fail (bolt head fell off, control arm flopping around) due to this issue. I was out of state on a work trip so it was repaired (at our expense) at the dealer. We were told that they had awhile invested in the bolt extraction....sissies. Two new bolts and control arms later.......👎
Water collects in that area, corrosion weakens the bolts, suspension forces overcome bolt strength, control arm flops around, leading to noise and an unsafe condition.
I highly doubt Toyota will reimburse anything unless the failure rate is high enough to require a mandatory recall. "Recall" something Toyota wants to avoid like the plague.
I would be taking this up with Corporate if I were you. See an attorney first.
On second thought see an attorney that specializes in things like that and see Toyota in court. 🤘
Before they fail they are very easy to replace and they are not torqued to where to need anything more than a 18" breaker bar or a normal ratchet with a piece of pipe as an extension.Originally Posted by bronsin ↑Can I have them? They look OK to me? 😕
Seems like everybody could R&R these bolts themselves, check them out, and replace them if need be.
If a quart of water comes out when you remove it, yeah, thats something that should be on the yearly to do list.
The TSB calls for some seam sealing, but where it shows it, it is all down hill of where those bolts thread into. At only $3 each, I will keep some extras around and will pop them out and take a peek once or twice a year (when switching between Winter and Summer rims is my ideal time to do so).
I had a look at the TSB at work today.
They will replace (with updated parts):
Subframe
Ctrl arms
Bolts
As well as they apply seam sealer which appears to try preventing water from filling up the panel that the ctrl arm bolt goes into. I guess they figure that's where the water gets in from. Job pays 5.5hrs WARRANTY time (regular time will be higher).
For most people the best idea will be to remove/inspect, and replace those bolts as required. Salty areas may want to do a yearly check. Next time I have my car on the lift I will see if there is an easy way to make the water drain out by itself. Might just take a drilled hole, or a little cut with a grinder. I completely covered my bolts with axle grease so they shouldn't rust again, but I guess I should actually fix the problem and not just the symptom. 😁
Cheers.
Cory
They will replace (with updated parts):
Subframe
Ctrl arms
Bolts
As well as they apply seam sealer which appears to try preventing water from filling up the panel that the ctrl arm bolt goes into. I guess they figure that's where the water gets in from. Job pays 5.5hrs WARRANTY time (regular time will be higher).
For most people the best idea will be to remove/inspect, and replace those bolts as required. Salty areas may want to do a yearly check. Next time I have my car on the lift I will see if there is an easy way to make the water drain out by itself. Might just take a drilled hole, or a little cut with a grinder. I completely covered my bolts with axle grease so they shouldn't rust again, but I guess I should actually fix the problem and not just the symptom. 😁
Cheers.
Cory
As long as people take the precautions you suggest I see no problems. You should suggest this to Toyota and save them a few million...😆Originally Posted by CoryM ↑I had a look at the TSB at work today.
They will replace (with updated parts):
Subframe
Ctrl arms
Bolts
As well as they apply seam sealer which appears to try preventing water from filling up the panel that the ctrl arm bolt goes into. I guess they figure that's where the water gets in from. Job pays 5.5hrs WARRANTY time (regular time will be higher).
For most people the best idea will be to remove/inspect, and replace those bolts as required. Salty areas may want to do a yearly check. Next time I have my car on the lift I will see if there is an easy way to make the water drain out by itself. Might just take a drilled hole, or a little cut with a grinder. I completely covered my bolts with axle grease so they shouldn't rust again, but I guess I should actually fix the problem and not just the symptom. 😁
Cheers.
Cory
Can anyone publish a link to the TSB?
Thanks!
Thanks!
Got the notice earlier .

Just got my letter in the mail today. They are doing a 100,000 mile or 7 year coverage for the bolt. I'll take it in when I see that it's starting to go. Damn this salt!!
i hope it dont snap off when i try to take it out to look at it , if it looks good should i leave it alone ? Thank Frank
I changed out both of mine. They weren't that bad. They did have what looked like mulch on them. I think they get like 118 ft lbs. pretty good workout while laying on ones back!
👍Originally Posted by CTScott ↑It is 19mm. You can remove it and reinstall it without issue.
👍Originally Posted by auxmike ↑I changed out both of mine. They weren't that bad. They did have what looked like mulch on them. I think they get like 118 ft lbs. pretty good workout while laying on ones back!
the bolts rust off at the head
Canadian tsb
sample invoice for repair I found on net
I have been spraying 2 or 3 + times a year,, the whole area with rust check, spraying in every hole in the suspension and sub frame
2006 yaris HB 125,000km, so far so good,, Ontario Canada
I would not recommend trying to get the bolts out if they are old or already starting to rust as the head would probably snap off


Canadian tsb
sample invoice for repair I found on net
I have been spraying 2 or 3 + times a year,, the whole area with rust check, spraying in every hole in the suspension and sub frame
2006 yaris HB 125,000km, so far so good,, Ontario Canada
I would not recommend trying to get the bolts out if they are old or already starting to rust as the head would probably snap off



here's what I have re bolt corrosion images



I wonder if this was for the 07 sedan as well
Yes - It is for Sedan's as well.Originally Posted by JumpmanYaris ↑I wonder if this was for the 07 sedan as well
Was working on a 2012 SE today and it looks like they still haven't corrected the problem. Loosened both bolts with my impact gun (doing alignment) and both sprayed rusty water at me. Not good. I think the best fix for most of us would be drilling a small hole to drain the water, rather than trying to prevent water from getting in. I need to align my car soon, so will try to figure something out and take pictures while it is apart.
That will weaken the bolt
Drill the subframe, not the bolt 😉Originally Posted by JumpmanYaris ↑That will weaken the bolt
Yesterday , brought the T.S.B. to service center and they said they look fine . Also denied to fix a waterpump ( different post ) .
what will happen if it brakes when i am driveing the car at 65 on the high way , do i die ? do you lose control of the car ?
can you post a picture of where to drill the hole , THanks That would be a big help .Originally Posted by CoryM ↑Drill the subframe, not the bolt 😉
Wish they would just replace the bolts 🙁 .
i dont want to try to take them out , to change them ,if they should brake off , it will be a big job.
i take it you drill the holes about a half inch to the side of the bolt head , so the water can drain out ?
I just received mine a couple of days ago. It's not a recall notice. It just a warranty extension notice (both miles and time, neither of which I remember off hand) on the part. The notice says that the problem does not warrant a recall because it is not a critical defect because even if the bolt head falls off, the arm is still captured by the brace underneath it (see Don777's pictures, post #54). If the head falls off, the driver should hear the clunking and then he should take the car in for repair.Originally Posted by Hershey ↑Got the notice earlier .
so if it brakes , you dont lose control of the car , just asking ? sounds like a big deal to me .
It won't cause any catastrophic issues if it fails, since it is captive in a pocket. The worst that will happen is that it will thump around in the pocket. You can see the pocket in the picture that I posted in the other thread:Originally Posted by FrankM ↑so if it brakes , you dont lose control of the car , just asking ? sounds like a big deal to me .
Attached picture not available
As CTScott said, it is unlikely that the control arm will come out. I say unlikely because it is still possible. While the broken part of the bolt will contain the control arm, there is no tension on the threads to hold the bolt in. So if you drive it and do not hear, or notice the noises that (presumably) it is making eventually it is certainly possible that what is left of the bolt will work it's way out. That being said, if the bolt rusted enough to break, chances are the threads are rusted as well which will help hold it in. I'm willing to bet that eventually someone, somewhere, will have the back of a control arm bolt fall completely out. I'm always amazed at what some people do not notice on their cars. Some people drive with wheel bearings so noisy you have to yell to be heard over them, and they have no idea there is something wrong.
In regards to where to cut/drill to drain the bushing, I haven't had a chance to get my car on the rack yet (and I need to re-align my car any time those are out. Rebuild/Racecar :þ ). In the above picture, in the middle of the black rubber part that CTScott drew a line through is a metal cylinder that the bolt goes through. That cylinder (sleeve) is what needs to be drained. So either a small nick in the edge of it, or a cut in the subframe below to help drain. Toyota is trying to seal it, which may or may not be feasible.
Cheers.
In regards to where to cut/drill to drain the bushing, I haven't had a chance to get my car on the rack yet (and I need to re-align my car any time those are out. Rebuild/Racecar :þ ). In the above picture, in the middle of the black rubber part that CTScott drew a line through is a metal cylinder that the bolt goes through. That cylinder (sleeve) is what needs to be drained. So either a small nick in the edge of it, or a cut in the subframe below to help drain. Toyota is trying to seal it, which may or may not be feasible.
Cheers.
Yes. I am the second owner and I received the warranty extension last week.Originally Posted by LugNut ↑This repair covered for non-original owners?
I get some rattling/creaking noise at about 1500k rpms to about 2k rpms, especially on the front driver side, could this be the cause of the rattling/creaking? as soon as i get over 2k-2.5k rmps it stops. it happens mostly when its cold outside. It also happens oftenly when i take off at lights and stops since i go back down to the 1.5k 2k rpms range.
Possibly. Stick your hand down there and see if you feel the head of the bolt or if it is gone.Originally Posted by Crazy Butcher ↑I get some rattling/creaking noise at about 1500k rpms to about 2k rpms, especially on the front driver side, could this be the cause of the rattling/creaking? as soon as i get over 2k-2.5k rmps it stops. it happens mostly when its cold outside. It also happens oftenly when i take off at lights and stops since i go back down to the 1.5k 2k rpms range.