CB900F2Original postToronto · May 6, 2010#1Hey Guys...
This morning while I was pulling out of my drive way, I felt and heard a thump come from the front of the car.. Thought, OH THAT IS WEIRD!
While I started to drive down the road, every bump or when I braked, again the thump.. I said to my self, hmm this can not be good.. So I went in the afternoon to the dealership to have it checked out the following was found..
On the passenger side, on the lower control arm, one of the two bolts secures the control to the sub frame, the bolt head corroded and broke off (see attached photo)..
Well here comes the good part.. The S.A stated that there is a service bulletin for this issue of these bolts corroding and breaking off, and they are going to replace the following.. Control arms on both sides of the car, all bolts, and the cradle as there is a new design of control arm and cradle.
I would strongly suggest that you check out the bolts on your car to see if they are corroding as I would not want to see someone be driving on the highway at a good speed and the bolt head breaks off and possible separation of the control from the sub frame then lose control of the car…
Form the photo, you can also see that this bolt was cracked for awhile as the bolt shaft was all rusted where the bolt head broke off.
Replies 452
tk-421Dagobah · May 6, 2010#2Thanks for the info! 👍
It would be great if you could provide the TSB itself so that we can add it to the compilation:
Compilation of Yaris TSBs 06silveryarisPuerto Rico · May 6, 2010#3Thanks I will check mine for premature wear this weekend
auxmikeLI, New Yawk · May 6, 2010#4Wow, this sure looks like a potential recall item to me.
It's broken after just 2 years service!😲
yarrrnew mexico · May 7, 2010#5 Originally Posted by
06silveryaris ↑ Thanks I will check mine for premature wear this weekend
extremely doubtful in puerto rico. This is caused by road salt, and I have a feeling a lot of canadian cities are using some harsher/cheaper salt as 90% of complaints on YW about corrosion are from canada
devinlamotheSudbury, Canada · May 7, 2010#6Is this just for the sedan or also hatch? I checked my bolts and they seem OK.
CB900F2Thread starterToronto · May 27, 2010#7Hey guys.. Sorry for a late responce, but all is well.. the following parts where changed out
- Both lower control arms on each side
- 2 new bolts (not sure which ones)
- Crossmember
- And they use some 3M sealer what looks like areas where water might get into the frame and bolt area to seal it up
The TSB# they reference is TSB 3271. I asked the dealer to get a copy or look at it and no luck.. So if anyone has access to TSBs, and and if you can find this one, I am very interested in seening what is says.
thanks guys..
Originally Posted by
tk-421 ↑ Thanks for the info! 👍
It would be great if you could provide the TSB itself so that we can add it to the compilation:
Compilation of Yaris TSBs
auxmikeLI, New Yawk · May 27, 2010#8Wow, I'd like to check it out too...🤷
NH3R717Charlotte · Jul 25, 2010#9I noticed corrosion on the steel parts underneath my car sub frame, maybe i should take some pics and make a post.
KangaruCanada · Apr 6, 2011#10Warning - Broken control arm bolt!
I had this issue happen on my 2007 model Yaris Sedan assembled by Central Auto Woks. I am out of warranty, and the fix is around $16 for parts(2 bolts) and around 3.5-5 hours labour.
I had noticed that the driver side had the clunk mentioned in the first post, I took it in and yes it was broken. The dealership said the passenger side was so corroded it could break too, so they replaced both. My local dealership denied that my car was part of the TSB3271 because of how the VIN numbers went. I did a simple VIN check and noticed that the production change was some time in 2009, and mine being a 2007 has the older control arm and bolts.
I would urge anyone with a 2006-2009 model Yaris hatch or sedan to go get that inspected within the warranty period. If you live in an Northern US area or Canada(like myself) the road salt corrodes the bolts and causes them to break. If the bolt breaks, its a $400-500 job to replace, and a new control arm runs around $500 per side. I was provided the TSB in a PDF format from a technician who works at a Toyota dealership outside my area. Toyota has been less than helpful about this problem, and they say...sorry its out of warranty.
I still have a claim with Toyota Customer Care, because I was lied to about the TSB applying to my vehicle. I was also told that because I didn't get my vehicle serviced by an authorized Toyota dealership, that they cannot help me. This is a full out load of BS.
It doesn't help that the people on the phone know very little about cars, and rely on what the dealership says only.
I would normally not care if something broke on my car outside warranty, and would pay for it. This is not normal, its not something that gets inspected or serviced. Its a faulty part that could lead to injury or death.
If you are in warranty or perhaps the extended warranty, most dealers will replace everything. Toyota knows about the problem, and so did the technician I know. If you are outside...(15,000kms) and a year like me...looks like Toyota says your screwed.
I would like to post the TSB, anyone know the best way to post a .PDF?
p123456789dirty south · Apr 6, 2011#11I wonder if this is something to worry about maybe we could upgrade the bolts in ours before they break. how could toyota over look such a potentially huge problem.
staticorexcivilwar town. · Apr 6, 2011#12I could have sworn I got a recall notice from Toyota about this months ago. 🤷
Edit: I now see this thread started last year. That makes sense.
Originally Posted by
p123456789 ↑ how could toyota over look such a potentially huge problem.
Yeah, next thing you know there will be problems like a Prius not stopping or something. 😆
Hersheynortheast · Apr 6, 2011#13We tried to present this to a TOYOTA service center for our 2008 sedan that had about 24,000 miles on it at that time and the service manager says " No , we will not look at it . You can't believe everything off the internet " . This is the same dealership that replaced the M.L.S. head cylinder gasket due to an exteranl oil leak from the #1 cylinder . We've tried to get several other TOYO service centers to inspect the control arms and they say no T.S.B. , so no need to and if we do look at it , it's at your expense . 😠 . We know how you feel about TOYOTA stepping up to the plate with issues such as yours and ours with owning a 2008 YARIS sedan that had an external oil leak and a 2010 that still does . 👎
ShroomsterOrlando · Apr 7, 2011#14 Originally Posted by
Hershey ↑ We tried to present this to a TOYOTA service center for our 2008 sedan that had about 24,000 miles on it at that time and the service manager says " No , we will not look at it . You can't believe everything off the internet " . This is the same dealership that replaced the M.L.S. head cylinder gasket due to an exteranl oil leak from the #1 cylinder . We've tried to get several other TOYO service centers to inspect the control arms and they say no T.S.B. , so no need to and if we do look at it , it's at your expense . 😠 . We know how you feel about TOYOTA stepping up to the plate with issues such as yours and ours with owning a 2008 YARIS sedan that had an external oil leak and a 2010 that still does . 👎
I wonder why they turned YOU down....../sarcasm \roll eyes
CB900F2Thread starterToronto · Apr 7, 2011#15Kangaru... Regarding the posting of the TSB you have, just post it as an attachment in the section "Manage Attachments" and upload it...
I am very interested in the TSB
Thank you
Originally Posted by
Kangaru ↑ Warning - Broken control arm bolt!
I had this issue happen on my 2007 model Yaris Sedan assembled by Central Auto Woks. I am out of warranty, and the fix is around $16 for parts(2 bolts) and around 3.5-5 hours labour.
I had noticed that the driver side had the clunk mentioned in the first post, I took it in and yes it was broken. The dealership said the passenger side was so corroded it could break too, so they replaced both. My local dealership denied that my car was part of the TSB3271 because of how the VIN numbers went. I did a simple VIN check and noticed that the production change was some time in 2009, and mine being a 2007 has the older control arm and bolts.
I would urge anyone with a 2006-2009 model Yaris hatch or sedan to go get that inspected within the warranty period. If you live in an Northern US area or Canada(like myself) the road salt corrodes the bolts and causes them to break. If the bolt breaks, its a $400-500 job to replace, and a new control arm runs around $500 per side. I was provided the TSB in a PDF format from a technician who works at a Toyota dealership outside my area. Toyota has been less than helpful about this problem, and they say...sorry its out of warranty.
I still have a claim with Toyota Customer Care, because I was lied to about the TSB applying to my vehicle. I was also told that because I didn't get my vehicle serviced by an authorized Toyota dealership, that they cannot help me. This is a full out load of BS.
It doesn't help that the people on the phone know very little about cars, and rely on what the dealership says only.
I would normally not care if something broke on my car outside warranty, and would pay for it. This is not normal, its not something that gets inspected or serviced. Its a faulty part that could lead to injury or death.
If you are in warranty or perhaps the extended warranty, most dealers will replace everything. Toyota knows about the problem, and so did the technician I know. If you are outside...(15,000kms) and a year like me...looks like Toyota says your screwed.
I would like to post the TSB, anyone know the best way to post a .PDF?
Hersheynortheast · Apr 7, 2011#16" I wonder why they turned YOU down......"
We were polite at that time . What you expect ? Bring a cake ? 🤤
KangaruCanada · Apr 8, 2011#17 Originally Posted by
Hershey ↑ We tried to present this to a TOYOTA service center for our 2008 sedan that had about 24,000 miles on it at that time and the service manager says " No , we will not look at it . You can't believe everything off the internet " . This is the same dealership that replaced the M.L.S. head cylinder gasket due to an exteranl oil leak from the #1 cylinder . We've tried to get several other TOYO service centers to inspect the control arms and they say no T.S.B. , so no need to and if we do look at it , it's at your expense . 😠 . We know how you feel about TOYOTA stepping up to the plate with issues such as yours and ours with owning a 2008 YARIS sedan that had an external oil leak and a 2010 that still does . 👎
Living in Orlando, I would be highly doubtful that this bolt would corrode and break. The TSB I have is a Toyota Canada TSB. The thing is, many areas of the north-eastern US, throw as much salt on the roads as parts of Canada does. I only live 60 miles from Buffalo, NY and can say that the weather is just as bad or worse there. I think Toyota needs to address this issue as 4-5 year old Yari' will be needing this service if you live near the ocean or the rust belt. Toyota Canada told me the whole don't believe everything you read either. I rebutted with what about the TSB or the Technician that told me about it...they returned with well, you are out of warranty.
Anyways here is the TSB3271...half of it is "en francais"
Hersheynortheast · Apr 8, 2011#18 Originally Posted by
Kangaru ↑ Living in Orlando, I would be highly doubtful that this bolt would corrode and break. The TSB I have is a Toyota Canada TSB. The thing is, many areas of the north-eastern US, throw as much salt on the roads as parts of Canada does. I only live 60 miles from Buffalo, NY and can say that the weather is just as bad or worse there. I think Toyota needs to address this issue as 4-5 year old Yari' will be needing this service if you live near the ocean or the rust belt. Toyota Canada told me the whole don't believe everything you read either. I rebutted with what about the TSB or the Technician that told me about it...they returned with well, you are out of warranty.
Anyways here is the TSB3271...half of it is "en francais"
We're from the northeast not Florida. They use road salt almost everyday here during the winter so we're concerned as well.
KangaruCanada · Apr 8, 2011#19 Originally Posted by
Hershey ↑ I am from the northeast not Florida. They use road salt almost everyday here during the winter so I am concerned as well.
My bad, I misread someone elses post. Yeah if your from the North East, I would for sure get that in to get inspected. Funny, Toyota Canada said it is part of a regular suspension check...yet you can only see the bolt head. Just tell them you notice a small clunk in the suspension, bring that TSB and they might warranty it for you. They get paid anyways, not as much, but it keeps the Tech's busy. A regular suspension check is usually done at a service interval anyways, ask to go out and see the car on the hoist...if they let you, request they fix the rusted bolts.
Hersheynortheast · Apr 8, 2011#20That's fine , it happens . We brought the picture posted by CB900F2 with T.S.B. # , presented it to the service center manager and he says in a annoyed tone of voice " You can't believe everything you see on the internet and the T.S.B. is only for CANADA " . 🙄
bB2NERW.TN · Apr 9, 2011#21I smell trouble in Toyotas future if this gets bad in Salt Belt USA. I've had brake lines and other stuff rust to pieces in MI.
What does Toyota USA customer service say about the issue?
Twistoffate0817Voorhees, NJ · Apr 9, 2011#22I do not know anything about car parts, but I just went outside and looked around my tire and underneath the car near the tire and there is a bolt on each side of my front tires, above the tire and they both are rusted. Since I do not know where to look and what I am looking for I will be bringing my Yaris to the dealership to have them look for rust. The only thing I can say that has to do with this topic is about 4-5 months ago I went over a speed bump and heard a metal on metal sound in the front passenger side tire area. Have not had it checked out due to sound never occured again.
auxmikeLI, New Yawk · Apr 9, 2011#23Just crawled under the car and snapped A few quick pics since I hate reading about something and not seeing exactly what is being written about.
Crappy 3.2MP BBerry shots for ya...
My car is JTDJT932XXXXXXXXX Vin with build date of 1/08. Does that mean I'm ok according to the TSB????
The bolt HEADS look mint, is the real bad rust hidden where you can't see it? Also, can this one bad bolt be changed DIY without the whole drivetrain being supported??
Hersheynortheast · Apr 10, 2011#24Thanks Auxmike , good work 👏 . Those bolts / nuts and under carriage look as if they're from a newer YARIS . Must be due to the use of less road salt . Ours are rusted quite a bit , tons of salt used on these roads . I'll have to get a picture of them . Our '08 sedan is T92348 . So , I take it we're fine ? On occasion we've heard a creaking noise coming from the front of the '08 sedan . Like that of bushings of the strut , there's 30,000 miles on it . Our trust of the TOYOTA corporation is gradually rusting away . Last , how's your possible oil leak doing ? Thanks again .
KangaruCanada · Apr 11, 2011#25 Originally Posted by
auxmike ↑ My car is JTDJT932XXXXXXXXX Vin with build date of 1/08. Does that mean I'm ok according to the TSB????
Your bolt heads look very clean, perhaps your area of "New Yawk" uses a less salt than other areas. Maybe you had the bottom rustproofed, or you run that mofo through a carwash frequently blasting the underside. Either way it looks good, one of the bolts does look a little corroded, but I cant tell what one it is...its pretty dark.
Is your car a Sedan or Hatch? cause your vin is a little strange...should start with "JTDBT923" if it is a sedan built at Central Auto. They made all the control arm/bolt changes the MY2009. They moved production of the Yaris a few times since 2006 from factory but all should, or would have used the same suspension until the change. Most of those components are made by suppliers to Toyota.
For VIN comparison, I did a free Carfax search and it tells you the make model and production date. Compare it to the examples provided and you should have your answer. The TSB is only a Toyota Canada one, so getting it fixed could be a little more problematic at the US dealerships. If it does need replacement it would be worth a phonecall to Toyota Motor Sales...and they might help you better than a dealership.
KangaruCanada · Apr 11, 2011#26Update
I just returned home and got a phone call from Toyota Canada Inc. They are sending me a reimbursement cheque for 50% of the bill. It took an hour long call to one of their agents, and about a week of "investigation" on their part.
They never outward admitted any faults with the car, or even said anything about its relation to the TSB...I guess thats so they cover their own butts. To me, it says we were at least partially wrong, otherwise I would have paid for the whole thing, and that would have been the end.
My point is,
If this happens to you, make note of the TSB to the dealership, also some research on your car, and its relation to the TSB build dates. The dealerships won't admit any faults that Toytota has, they aren't really allowed to say "yeah its a known issue" especially if its for current in-production models. You will have to Call Toyota's Customer Interaction Centre, file a complaint, give them all the info you can provide to further your case. They WILL try to get you to say you caused it, like hitting a bump or curb, and just ignore their accusations. They will also try to convince you that the TSB has no bearing on your case, as its out of warranty. Just let them know how unsatesfied you are with the product, and how something like that should NEVER break. It should be noted that the people on the phones usually know little about cars, they are just trained to deal with customer problems. They will usually try to refute everything you say, but be persistant...and try to be polite as I was. The last thing they told me was that they are going to look into it further, but not to expect any other contact.
It took about a week of no contact, then they just leave a message saying we have mailed you a re-imbursement cheque. No reason why, just here is half of your money back. I dont know if this is standard practice, but regardless they are recognizing something.
I would request anyone who had this happen to follow the same steps. Perhaps they will fell pressured to do a recall. This site also helped my case, and brought it to my attention as I gave Toyota Canada Inc. the link to the same problem, they said they would look at it.
Hersheynortheast · Apr 11, 2011#27You'll find the manufactured date of a YARIS half way up the driver side I-pillar ( door frame ) . Tells what country built in as well .
Hersheynortheast · Apr 11, 2011#28" The last thing they told me was that they are going to look into it further, but not to expect any other contact . "
We got the same reply from the service center and the customer relations when we asked for them to let us know if anything was found wrong by TOYOTA corporation with the factory installed multi layered steel head cylinder gasket of the 2008 sedan that was removed due to an external oil leak from the #1 cylinder . No leak as of yet with the new one that was installed under warranty in early September of 2010 . TOYOTA corporation of Japan can be sly . That's why we're not likely to buy another TOYOTA . We're very likey to stick with the 2008 sedan and the 2010 3 door to the semi-sweet end .
auxmikeLI, New Yawk · Apr 12, 2011#29 Originally Posted by
Kangaru ↑ Your bolt heads look very clean, perhaps your area of "New Yawk" uses a less salt than other areas. Maybe you had the bottom rustproofed, or you run that mofo through a carwash frequently blasting the underside. Either way it looks good, one of the bolts does look a little corroded, but I cant tell what one it is...its pretty dark. Is your car a Sedan or Hatch? cause your vin is a little strange...
Where I live we had a LOT of snow this winter. They do use salt too. That rusty part is from a bolt that's fastened at the top. the piece you see is the threaded part sticking out. I tried to figure out what it does, mabye it holds the steering rack down?
I never go to the car wash in winter or even wash the car.
My car is a hatchback and that is the correct VIN. According to the TSB pic I posted above, my VIN is ok even though it's a 1/08 build date.🤷
theidiotsWI, USA · Apr 18, 2011#30Wow. I just got my Yaris back from the shop. Same problem. I my case the bolt snapped. Luckily the car kept driving. I took it in for an oil change and the mechanics were surprised that I was able to drive the car. They wanted to know when I was in an accident with my Yaris. They claim to have never seen anything like it.
Over $800 in damage for this $10 bolt - all labor.
We have a lot of potholes here. I suspected that I hit one and damaged the suspension. This still left me with a big deductible payment and now my issurance will go up.
Thanks to this site I'm calling Toyota and will offer them pictures of the snapped bolt.
theidiotsWI, USA · Apr 21, 2011#31Strange. Toyota (800-331-4331) told me that they have no record of this service TRB. They opened a case for me and are investigating.
Stay tuned.
theidiotsWI, USA · Apr 27, 2011#32OK.
I called back because I was told that Toyota would call me by 4/22 End Of Business since they had to contact my dealer and find more information.
I was told today that I somehow agreed to do the research into this matter!
So, if anyone can point me to a document with a Toyota source that describes this bolt problem please post a link to it.
Thank you.
devinlamotheSudbury, Canada · Apr 27, 2012#33Can you replace these bolts yourself?
Sorry for the thread resurrection but this has now been posted on RedFlagDeals lol
WeeYariGeorgetown, Ontario, Canada · Apr 27, 2012#34I'd totally forgotten about this thread. Although the TSB states HBs are affected, it only appears to be sedan owners reporting issues here. My '06 HB with a build date of 09/2005 shows absolutely no issues with suspect bolts.
devinlamotheSudbury, Canada · Apr 27, 2012#35 Originally Posted by
WeeYari ↑ I'd totally forgotten about this thread. Although the TSB states HBs are affected, it only appears to be sedan owners reporting issues here. My '06 HB with a build date of 09/2005 shows absolutely no issues with suspect bolts.
Yeah I checked mine again and they still look fine, no rust on them.
Maybe we are lucky - mine was manufactured in '06.
OTA'sTOYHilo, Hawaii · Apr 27, 2012#36T-SB-0055-11
Clunk Noise from Front Suspension
covered under 3y/36k
This TSB applies to 2007 – 2011 Yaris Sedan and Yaris Hatchback vehicles produced
BEFORE the
Production Change Effective VINs shown below:
Hatchback Shokki
JTDJT4K3#B5330321
JTDKT4K3#B5330321
Sedan:
Kanto JTDBT4K3#B1404325
Central JTDBT4K3#B4081013
auxmikeLI, New Yawk · Apr 27, 2012#37Isn't this Canada only? My hatch. Vin doesn't even have a letter B in it!
enviriCT · Apr 28, 2012#38I had this done last year. I had that knocking sensation for a few weeks and they swapped bolts no problem. It happens.
FireflyChicago land NWI · Apr 28, 2012#39im from the chicago land area and we get lots of salt
i bought a small tub of axle grease and greased all of the hardware and lines /fittings /threads/cotter pins and ABS sensors with a small brush
i also bought a 1 gallon chemical sprayer and a gallon of crisco veg shortening heated it up in some boiling watter and sprayed every inch of the underside of the car and the bottom foot of the doors (except the hatch) il use babby oil or wd40 on that
im also going to respray/grease the car this fall but with non hyd vegie oil like i did my 02 saturn
i love seeing all the rusted out early to mid 2000 fullsize trucks (i guesse thay catch my eye first in northern MI)and knowing that an 8$ sprayer and a gallon of vegy oil every fall mabey a can of red spray grease would have saved the wheel arches and rocker panels from rusting
So it's safe to take these bolts out (one at a time) and eyeball the shafts? I don't think you can tell much just from looking at the heads.
At 125000km, my wife's 07 is long out of warranty.
devinlamotheSudbury, Canada · May 3, 2012#41 Originally Posted by
djb ↑ So it's safe to take these bolts out (one at a time) and eyeball the shafts? I don't think you can tell much just from looking at the heads.
At 125000km, my wife's 07 is long out of warranty.
I didn't even take the bolts out. I just checked the bottom and the heads seem OK.
I am WAY out of warranty too (pushing 250,000km).
55k miles on my hatch. Replaced both sides. Rusty on the drivers-side. Pics attached of driver-side old vs new, and passenger-side old vs new.
CTScottUSA, CT · Jul 23, 2012#43I keep meaning to replace mine on all three of my Yaris, but keep forgetting to order them when I order other parts.
auxmikeLI, New Yawk · Jul 23, 2012#44Anyone have the part numbers? What's the torque spec on them?
CTScottUSA, CT · Jul 23, 2012#45 Originally Posted by
auxmike ↑ Anyone have the part numbers? What's the torque spec on them?
90119-14126 (They are about $4 each)
Torque is: 118 ft lbs.
auxmikeLI, New Yawk · Jul 23, 2012#46Great! And 4 are required?
Two. I spray-painted the underside of the head and washer in hopes that'll slow down the rust. My guess is the bushing traps water between the crossmember and washer causing the bolt to rust through. I changed mine without lifting the car. Very easy to do
Hersheynortheast · Jul 24, 2012#48Ramps ?
BilliamUSA · Jul 24, 2012#49I pulled mine out about a year ago and they looked fine. I coated them in high temp bearing grease and reinstalled them. I figure that couldn't hurt. Next time I do an oil change I might take another look at 'em to see how they've done bathed in grease.
otterhereSoutheast · Jul 24, 2012#50Gee, I'd been wondering whether or not to replace my 2008 Yaris hatch, VIN JTDJT923, etc.; this must be a sign...................... I don't see how to get a FREE carfax report on my vehicle; they want $39 for one? I'll just check my car's paperwork to see if it's ok.