Replies continued
ilikericeThread startersavannah, ga · Dec 16, 2012#2012nd place Overall Pax for the year..
1st place was a Mini Cooper S in DS
3rd was a 300Z in SSM
1 attachment not included in this copy
xnamerxxso cal · Dec 18, 2012#202Well the results for the event san Diego finally came in,i managed to place 13th in pax which is something I've never done. I even came ahead of some jacket holding nationals winners which was a bit of a surprise to me.
Steve35Vancouver, Wa. · Dec 18, 2012#203 Originally Posted by
xnamerxx ↑ Well the results for the event san Diego finally came in,i managed to place 13th in pax which is something I've never done. I even came ahead of some jacket holding nationals winners which was a bit of a surprise to me.
A very well earned victory in STF!!
Steve
Jason@SportsCarDebary, FL · Dec 18, 2012#204 Originally Posted by
xnamerxx ↑ Well the results for the event san Diego finally came in,i managed to place 13th in pax which is something I've never done. I even came ahead of some jacket holding nationals winners which was a bit of a surprise to me.
Nice work. Tough crowd down there. 👍
ilikericeThread startersavannah, ga · Jan 24, 2013#205xnamerxxso cal · Jan 24, 2013#206I just picked up a set of Z2's for street/backup/rain duty. Still sticking with my Toyo's until its proven one of the newcomers is faster, which I hope happens, I hate the Toyos.
The only thing that worries me is the "rivals" are really heavy, which could be a bad thing on such a light care like ours. I would be picking up something like 7lbs a tire and ~30 lbs is a pretty significant amount of weight.
Also don't forget but Kumho has the 720 street tires coming out as well so in the next few months we'll see who has the real magic.
ilikericeThread startersavannah, ga · Jan 24, 2013#207Yea. Agreed. Weight is a killer.
Oh snap! I forgot about the v720s. I will prob try to squeeze every foot i can out of these azenis 615k. Will wait and see
xnamerxxso cal · Jan 24, 2013#208Just informed the weight might be off so we'll see.
Yeah my contis are so bald that I felt it was safer to drive my Mustang...when its pouring rain today. I srsly can't wait for my new tires to show up driving that gas hog around is killing me.
Yeah but its not just the v720, the new Toyo's are supposed to be out this year along with the new bridgestones so this new crop of tires is really good for choice hopefully a magic last forever rcomp level of grip tire pops up. One can dream 😈
Jason@SportsCarDebary, FL · Jan 24, 2013#209 Originally Posted by
ilikerice ↑
Just got back from NOLA and the BFG Rival launch... Seems like a good tire, but I don't think much can be taken from this product launch. There were four stations set up to test the Rival against a number of competitors, but no real data and no lap times were provided (or taken). The entire event relied completely on butt dyno, which I feel is useless - all to often things that feel fast are slow, and vice verse.
A little background: we were not allowed to launch any of the cars (they were saving the clutches) so it was impossible to get a read on off the line bite. We had to run all of the autox courses in 2nd gear only, and we were not allowed to left foot brake (they had problems with people doing this the first day and overheating the brakes). None of the cars were optimized to benefit/maximize any one tire, all of the pressures were set to match the door jam plate, making it as fair as possible for all. I was told none of the autox cars had any type of performance adjustments, even the alignment was OE spec.
The skid pad was not done on a flat surface, there was a big crown in the lot, which made the one piece of data (iPad G meter) completely useless. And the "instructor" in the passengers seat was shouting out peak Gs, there was no sustained numbers - and as you might imagine without a flat lot it was easy to trick the meter and generate a higher number. This test was the BFG Sport COMP-2, Rival and R1-S.
The short autocross course was done with the Subaru STi. The one thing that was a little suspect here is that while TC appeared to be turned off some level of Stability Control was still on, which made it difficult to tell what the tire was doing and what the car was doing. The Toyo (R1R) was no match for the weight of the STi, it always feels like the wheels are going to scrape the ground when you put them on a big car. The Hankook (RS3) was a great match for the STi, it allowed excellent mid-corner rotation, and the car could be placed exactly where you wanted. The BFG felt as though it was bogging the car down, it was tight in the middle of the turn, and the rear of the car would simply not rotate - as if it had to much stick, or as if the Stability control was binding the car up.
The long autox course paired the BFG and Hankook up again, this time on the E46 BMW M3. On the BMW I felt as though each tire had an advantage on a certain part of the the course. The BFG was far superior in the high speed transition section, as the car was much more stable. However, in both high and low speed turns I liked the rotation offered by the Hankook much better.
On the road course we had a the ex Miller Cup Mustangs (FR500s), with the BFG versus the Falken (615K). This was another exercise that I did not find particularly useful due to the limited number of laps and having done no previous laps at the facility. The BFG seemed to be more stable under braking, had more grip on corner entry, and put power down better than the Falken, but without laps times or data there is no way to actually measure the difference in performance.
So far the best information on this new tire comes from the Tire Rack. They have done a good bit of testing including comparative tests, and they have a number of very experienced drivers on staff. I don't think the test results are posted on the TR website yet, but they showed them at NOLA, and the Rival did beat all of the competitor tires they ran it against. The test results were typically very close, within tenths. The other nugget of info we got is the BFG Rival likes to be stretched, not pinched. One of the fitments covered was a 235 on a 9" wide wheels. Sounds very R1R like in the sense that smaller sizes are going to be the ticket.
I am sure it wont be long before we see some real world results with the Rival, and it certainly appears it will be a challenger in all the classes, and due to the size line up it should own the classes with bigger cars.
BFG put on a first class event, and if you live in the area NOLA is a great facility, racers down there are very lucky.
FHT_RacingHouston, TX · Jan 24, 2013#210Great info!
xnamerxxso cal · Jan 24, 2013#211Its good to have some first hand knowledge. I still fear the newcomers won't overclass the existing Toyo's on the ligher cars, either from gearing or because they were engineered for 2500+ lb cars. In either case I'm glad new tires exist as I hate the existing Toyo's they feel like driving on erasers.
xnamerxxso cal · Jan 28, 2013#212Had our first event out of the year today at Fontana. The new setup on the car works amazingly now its just my turn to learn how to drive the car correctly.
I'm kinda pissed at myself I ended up PAXing 40th, but I had a +1 run that would have put me in 15th place, above some big name national champions. Oh well guess I have next event to fix it.
justjesusOrange County · Jan 28, 2013#213Jason: Thanks for the info
ilikerice: congrats on the 2nd place finish
namer: fix it :)
xnamerxxso cal · Feb 2, 2013#214So I'm registering for the SD national tour, which is on Easter btw such a bad choice, and I decided to check out the Georgia National Tour reg list just to see how STF is stacking up around the country.
The Georgia tour STF is one of the biggest classes, but its looking a little empty over here on the west coast. Almost makes me wish I was in Florida over So cal...almost.
Well got the first event of the year at San Diego tomorrow I'm hoping for a better performance than my last event.
ilikericeThread startersavannah, ga · Feb 2, 2013#215Sweet, good luck. Yea, I will be at the Dixie tour this year.. unfortunately our first event here in Buccanner region was canceled for feb. so that leaving me with little practice before the Dixie National in March.. I may need to hit up some South Carolina or Jax event before.. Still need better tires before Nationals.. I really dont wanna run these Azenis
NJ DriveNorthern NJ · Feb 3, 2013#216I'm really excited for the season to begin as well. I'll be doing the DC, NJ, & Toledo Pros, Dover Tour, Devens Match Tour, and Nationals. I wish the Dixie Tour wasn't so far... good numbers in the class.
Jason@SportsCarDebary, FL · Feb 3, 2013#217 Originally Posted by
xnamerxx ↑ So I'm registering for the SD national tour, which is on Easter btw such a bad choice, and I decided to check out the Georgia National Tour reg list just to see how STF is stacking up around the country.
The Georgia tour STF is one of the biggest classes, but its looking a little empty over here on the west coast. Almost makes me wish I was in Florida over So cal...almost.
Well got the first event of the year at San Diego tomorrow I'm hoping for a better performance than my last event.
STF as it sits makes about as much sense as B-Spec, its a good bit of money to be one of the slowest cars out there - in both Solo and Club Racing you can go a lot faster, have more people to play with and do it cheaper in other classes. Any time you have to break new ground, like you did with your header, that is seen as a barrier to those without the resources. Without some changes I doubt STF or B-Spec will become as big as the classes they are following/displacing.
xnamerxxso cal · Feb 3, 2013#218Your right.
But that barrier exists with any of the existing classes, $4k shocks for stock class or $1k tires that last 50 runs even for the cheapest classes. It would make much more sense to buy an existing race car that someone else dumped money into. As with any form of racing those with the money/means will probably perform better than you. As I see it right now I can't think of any class of racing that doesn't have a huge initial investment. Unless you enjoy racing 20-40yo cars and the maintenance headaches that come with it.
I could easily buy a Spec Miata or a Corvette and not have fun sitting back of the pack against a guy who has the means to replace his motor every season or a guy who can invest in brand new tires each event. I'm only surprised that there aren't more Civic Si's or Scion TC or whatever joining events. FWD cars in general don't have much membership here(as you know), could be because FWD is the devil, but not many people seem to race them. If I drove off to AZ i'd have some more people to play with but i'd probably be much faster than them.
So finished my event in SD today, my Co-Driver managed to have an unofficial PAX of 5th place but will probably drop a few places, I was only able to get unofficial of 8th place. I'm sure we'll both drop a few places once everything is finalized but still an impressive showing none the less.
Steve35Vancouver, Wa. · Feb 4, 2013#219Thank you for letting me drive your car yesterday. You've done a great job on the car. The balance is great, it puts the power down very well and it has power!
Get a race set and get more seat time we'll see you start getting 1st all the time.👍
Steve
Jason@SportsCarDebary, FL · Feb 4, 2013#220 Originally Posted by
xnamerxx ↑ Your right.
But that barrier exists with any of the existing classes, $4k shocks for stock class or $1k tires that last 50 runs even for the cheapest classes. It would make much more sense to buy an existing race car that someone else dumped money into. As with any form of racing those with the money/means will probably perform better than you. As I see it right now I can't think of any class of racing that doesn't have a huge initial investment. Unless you enjoy racing 20-40yo cars and the maintenance headaches that come with it.
I could easily buy a Spec Miata or a Corvette and not have fun sitting back of the pack against a guy who has the means to replace his motor every season or a guy who can invest in brand new tires each event. I'm only surprised that there aren't more Civic Si's or Scion TC or whatever joining events. FWD cars in general don't have much membership here(as you know), could be because FWD is the devil, but not many people seem to race them. If I drove off to AZ i'd have some more people to play with but i'd probably be much faster than them.
So finished my event in SD today, my Co-Driver managed to have an unofficial PAX of 5th place but will probably drop a few places, I was only able to get unofficial of 8th place. I'm sure we'll both drop a few places once everything is finalized but still an impressive showing none the less.
It is not a barrier in stock, it is a known quantity. There is an existing setup path for nearly every front running car out there. And the reality does not match the hype when it comes to shocks in stock, even those with purpose built mono-tubes are not typically spending $4k. Yes, the tires are expensive, and you need fresh ones to run up front, but that is known factor coming in.
What you have to battle in STF is the unknown cost. It is one thing to spend the money to replicate a winning setup and fail because as a driver you could not get it done. It is a completely different ball game when you are trying something new, and don't know what money you will see a return on in terms of performance and ability to sell it later - a set of stock class $4k 😉 shocks are worth something when you are done, a set of one-off STF shocks will have a much smaller resale market.
Quit spinning your wheel (the inside one) and go for an FSP build. 😁 Its only money. 😈
ilikericeThread startersavannah, ga · Feb 4, 2013#221Yes. I will be going fsp by summer. I want lsd so bad. U got a spare trans w lsd u wanna get rid of? Lol
xnamerxxso cal · Feb 4, 2013#222Jason quit trying to make me setup my car to be a more hateful DD experience LOL 😁
There's no arguing that, there is that perception that you'll need the MOTON/KONI/PENKSE whatever just to win and its hard to argue when you see some amazingly fast cars running on whatever custom shocks they're running. I only know what I've been quoted and not wanting to make any particular company look back it was well above $5k, but that's probably not the typical cost.
You know I don't think my co-driver Steve35 had the inside spin problems I was having, might be due to his better right foot control but I don't think he mentioned it to me.
Steve35Vancouver, Wa. · Feb 4, 2013#223Nope, no big wheel spin problems for me. The car was great, could it be better? Of course.
I wish you had your data logger...
Steve
Jason@SportsCarDebary, FL · Feb 4, 2013#224 Originally Posted by
xnamerxx ↑ Jason quit trying to make me setup my car to be a more hateful DD experience LOL 😁
Daily drive the Mustang. 👍
LSD, flywheel, 13"x9" wheels, ECU, no cats. 😎
NJ DriveNorthern NJ · Feb 4, 2013#225Does anyone know if the stock front sway bar is solid or hollow?
CrankyOldManWest Michigan · Feb 4, 2013#226 Originally Posted by
ilikerice ↑ Yes. I will be going fsp by summer. I want lsd so bad. U got a spare trans w lsd u wanna get rid of? Lol
Hell, I'm about ready to pull the trigger on LSD/gear ratios/final drive and go straight up EP. I don't plan on going national with it, and I don't AutoX to win, so being laughably un-competitive in that class is no big deal. It's just where my egg will land when I get done scrambling it.
xnamerxxso cal · Feb 4, 2013#227It didn't feel heavy enough to me to be solid so I'm going to hazard a guess that its hollow.
Got Z2 street tires on, I'm pretty sure there not faster than the Toyo's, but they have the best steering feel of any tire I've ever driven on, there so unbelievably sharp, definitely one of the best street tires I've ever driven on.
ilikericeThread startersavannah, ga · Feb 4, 2013#228 Originally Posted by
CrankyOldMan ↑ Hell, I'm about ready to pull the trigger on LSD/gear ratios/final drive and go straight up EP. I don't plan on going national with it, and I don't AutoX to win, so being laughably un-competitive in that class is no big deal. It's just where my egg will land when I get done scrambling it.
I will probably end up in SM class by the end of the year. I really wanna go turbo. I think I made my debut last year by coming in 2nd overall and now I just wanna have some fun. I don't wanna get Rcomps yet til I get an LSD though.
NJ DriveNorthern NJ · Feb 4, 2013#229 Originally Posted by
xnamerxx ↑ It didn't feel heavy enough to me to be solid so I'm going to hazard a guess that its hollow.
Got Z2 street tires on, I'm pretty sure there not faster than the Toyo's, but they have the best steering feel of any tire I've ever driven on, there so unbelievably sharp, definitely one of the best street tires I've ever driven on.
Thanks. I'm trying to decide if it's worth forgoing the front sway bar altogether or reinstall a smaller one.
What size ZIIs did you go with? I have a pair of 225/45/16 for the front. The Star Specs were already a great tire, can't wait to see how the ZIIs run. Pretty sure by now you've heard that the 195 Toyos aren't the only size that gets the good stuff all the way down either, according to Mr. Lugod.
xnamerxxso cal · Feb 4, 2013#230Well I kept the front bar for body roll reasons, I also didn't like the way the car felt running without it. The steering is really really numb without a front bar but you can get power down a little bit better. After running without it I found it was just better to run more spring in the back and call it a day.
Both the 50 and 55 get it afaik, but Lugod's in my region so I can ask him next event. From what I heard from Andy Hollis it was just those 2 sizes.
I went with the 225/45/16.
I don't expect any of the newcomers to overshadow the R1R's, even though I hate that tire with a passion it does work really well.
NJ DriveNorthern NJ · Feb 4, 2013#231One thing I've learned is that the clock trumps 'feel' any day. I remember first running my STR S2000 w/o a rear bar. It felt weird, I had to make adjustments to my driving, but ultimately was much faster w/o it than with it. I'm still kicking myself for being stubborn at Nationals in 2010 for not removing it because I didn't think it was quicker. Never again.
xnamerxxso cal · Feb 4, 2013#232Well yes and no, when going over my data it always showed that I had more corner speed with a bar than without, but I had better exit speed with the bar. My setup wasn't optimized for either bar or no bar so you never really got to know for sure if bar or no bar was better. Once I figured out the spring balance it felt better and was quite a bit faster than no bar on the previous setup. I think having the extra compliance over bumps is enough to make having a front bar worth it, rather than compensating with extra stiff springs.
Just for S n G's here is data from the last event of last year.
Data from a Miata course. I suck at braking.
Picture not included in this copy
Jason@SportsCarDebary, FL · Feb 5, 2013#233 Originally Posted by
NJ Drive ↑ Thanks. I'm trying to decide if it's worth forgoing the front sway bar altogether or reinstall a smaller one.
What size ZIIs did you go with? I have a pair of 225/45/16 for the front. The Star Specs were already a great tire, can't wait to see how the ZIIs run. Pretty sure by now you've heard that the 195 Toyos aren't the only size that gets the good stuff all the way down either, according to Mr. Lugod.
Based on the OE 24.3mm spare bar I have I believe they are solid. It has no crimp marks on the ends, and based on its size it feels to heavy to be hollow. If you can find one there are 23.3mm OE bars out there, I have one on the HP car, came from an 07' sedan.
NJ DriveNorthern NJ · Feb 5, 2013#234 Originally Posted by
Jason@SportsCar ↑ Based on the OE 24.3mm spare bar I have I believe they are solid. It has no crimp marks on the ends, and based on its size it feels to heavy to be hollow. If you can find one there are 23.3mm OE bars out there, I have one on the HP car, came from an 07' sedan.
Thanks for the reply Jason. I'm pretty sure that I have at least a 25mm front bar on my car(SE) too so I'm trying to eliminate as much on-throttle wheelspin as possible.
Namer, what spring rates were you running at the time with no bar?
xnamerxxso cal · Feb 5, 2013#235290p/260p
350/350
NJ DriveNorthern NJ · Feb 5, 2013#236Initially I was planning on staggering heavier in the front w/o a bar and give it a go. My wheelbase is a little longer than yours too so behavior under braking might not be as pronounced.
Your data acquisition is nice too.
xnamerxxso cal · Feb 5, 2013#237So the more I stagger rear roll stiffness the more liftoff/brake oversteer I get, there was a fine line from nice rotation to fwd drift car. Just having the rear spring stagger gave me enough front end accel traction that inside spin wasn't such a bad problem, I still complain about it but its mostly due to me getting back on it too soon when the front inside wheel has no load and is at a sharp angle.
Now I'm not positive this is true so take it as here-say but you can't transfer load dynamically from the left front to the right front by using stiffer springs can you can do so from the left front to the right rear and vice versa so taking load off the front by using stiffer rear springs seemed to be the way to go in getting some more front end bite. I still feel I need -4 camber to fix to get the Toyos happy but I haven't pursued that path yet.
racerbLeland, NC · Feb 5, 2013#238Finally ran the Yaris in STF with the local SCCA group, was the only car in class but turned fairly respectable time. Only mods so far, 23mm UR rear bar, K&N drop-in filter, and some rock hard Goodyear Eagle GT tires.
http://www.ncrscca.com/sites/default...auto-x_fin.htm racerb
ilikericeThread startersavannah, ga · Feb 5, 2013#239good job racerb. imagine what it CAN do now.. lol.. was that just a "all my other cars are down right now, lets just run the yaris" event? or will we see more STF mods to the yaris and more/better results?
racerbLeland, NC · Feb 5, 2013#240Planning on doing about everything possible to prep the Yaris to the maximum of STF rules. I have been also concidering a B-Spec Yaris, but with an earlier chassis, 2007-2008 model from one of the salvage car sites, really cheap that way. Here is one of the salvage sites I mentioned....
http://www.salvageworld.net/search.p...2009&x=52&y=11 racerb
cali yarisCanoga Park, CA · Feb 6, 2013#241 the more liftoff/brake oversteer I get, there was a fine line from nice rotation to fwd drift car.
yep. That's really fun with 300+ to the wheels. I've done some power slides that made my passengers wonder what the heck was happening. 😆
xnamerxxso cal · Feb 17, 2013#242Well just wanted to add my feedback for the z2's.
I ran first session on my R1R's and second session on my z2's and I was about a second faster with my larger diameter z2 vs the R1R's. Had to go into the data to figure out why, but the limit of the Toyo's and the dunlops appear to be about the same with the z2's having a slighly higher limit, what made the Dunlops so much faster was that I was able to keep the car on the limit from the entrance of the turn to the exit.
racerbLeland, NC · Feb 17, 2013#243Thanks, good info as I'm still trying to decide on tires for this season!
racerb 👏
xnamerxxso cal · Feb 17, 2013#244I wanted to do a back to back between my R1R's(195/50/15) with about 50 runs on them and my brand new z2's(225/45/16) to see how much of difference I would have between them.
The toyo R1R's have tons of grip but are a really really numb tire that doesn't have great turn in feel and requires lots of camber to work correctly. I was running at best 66.2 on my Toyos and the car was skiddish hard to control and very very loose. Tire pressure was set at 30 psi.
Switching to the z2s later in the day after I had finished my runs on the R1Rs, the z2s were sharper had more overall cornering grip, but they didn't let go quite as easily as the R1Rs so the car didn't want to rotate very well at low speed. The biggest thing I liked about these tires was that I could get the slip angles pretty bad and it would still hold on, and I mean wheel cranked really really far over, the tire would just scream and eventually pull over, these tires require a lot of work to get the most out of them, but seem to be a touch heat sensitive(at least on my car). above 130 degree's they give up slighly. No where near as bad as the Toyo's but I didn't quite have the same results at the STX BMWs.
Car setup
Front
Camber -3.5 degrees
Caster 5 degrees
Toe 0"
Rear
Toe .2" in
Camber didn't bother checking
Dunlops (42.5 psi) 16x7 OZ Chrono HT
Toyo's (30 psi) 15x7 Kosei K1R I think
Going over my data I was able to stay on the limit longer with the z2 than I was with the R1Rs. The r1rs seem to hold about 1.1gs according to the data and the z2 were holding 1.15 steady state but I did lose a bit of acceleration going to the taller tire.
These results are subjective as the course was very very dirty in the morning when I ran the toyos, I was picking up OPR and rocks like no ones business, but it felt quite a bit more clean in the afternoon. The surface was asphalt so I don't know if the results will carry over to concrete. On a side note this was the first time I didn't have horrible shoulder wear on a tire after an AutoX run so at least for camber limited cars I would say the z2 is a good pick. Overall I think the Z2 is going to be a tire to have in the future.
So I went further into my data and I was faster on the Toyos for the most part but I was having some pretty bad issues with the Toyos just letting go out of nowhere. Not sure if it was a course issue or not but it was something I was experiencing.
justjesusOrange County · Feb 18, 2013#245hmmm. interesting info, Namer. Especially the last part about the toyos being a bit faster for the most part.
Damn. I really need to sell some wheels and do a little more prep work on the Yaris.
I just signed onto SD regions' site, so I'll be looking to run some events there. I'll be alternating between the cars. hehe... in pursuit of learning and developing as a driver.
Thanks for sharing your findings with the community.
xnamerxxso cal · Feb 18, 2013#246i think there was something wrong with the course when i ran with the toyos, the car was really loose on the edge, almost like driving on dirt or oil.
NJ DriveNorthern NJ · Feb 19, 2013#247Just wondering why you chose 42psi for the ZIIs? Seems very high for a light car like the Yaris. Dunlops also don't reach their prime until after a couple events or a couple weeks of street use.
xnamerxxso cal · Feb 19, 2013#248I varied the pressures from 38-45 and was fastest with 42. I treated them like the old Z1s for pressure and kept them on the high side.
At 42 I ran a 65.282
At 44 I ran a 65.537
At 38 I ran a 66.235
At 40 I ran a 65.713
Going with temps on the tires the center was still cold at 42 psi and even at 44 but the car felt quite a bit more stable transitionally at 42 than it did at 44 but at 44 it felt as if I could hold the corner better.
Here is a screenshot of my fastest runs with both the Toyo and the Dunlops. For whatever reason I had more confidence driving on the Dunlops vs the Toyos, I'm pretty sure it was due to something on the track but I'll have to test this again at another place to be sure.
Red is Toyo
Blue is Dunlop
Picture not included in this copy
NJ DriveNorthern NJ · Feb 19, 2013#249Interesting. They'll get better with use. Is your site asphalt or concrete? Air temps?
justjesusOrange County · Feb 19, 2013#250Namer, we could always do testing at Adams! !
Tuesday nights (and some saturdays as well)