Replies continued
xnamerxxso cal · Jan 14, 2011#251Im pretty sure the power is giving up so early because the turbo is to small for the amount of power hes making. You can see it in the torque curve how it starts to die at 5k rpm's. Dont know the specs on his cam or the rpm range of the intake he's running but Id have to hazard a guess and say both are rated for something like 3-7.3k rpms but the turbo doesn't have the cfm to keep up.
If you look at the compressor map for the disco potato it gives up on at about 35 lb per minute with 2.2 bar. Rule of thumb is 10 hp per every lb per minute so easy math says 350 hp give or take 20 hp.
Nexus1155Dorchester · Jan 14, 2011#252 Tial / Garrett GTX-2860 RS Turbo w/ SS Housing and Billet Wheel
Walboro 255l , Aeromotive regulator , Perrin fuel rail ,
Aerospace Components custom fuel block for NX kit
680cc Precision injectors
for xnamerxx ^^^
Does your standalone tell you the duty cycle the injectors are running at. Looking at that graph seems like you have something more to work with, like a handful of the people here say.
xnamerxxso cal · Jan 14, 2011#253Its a walboro 255 so it should be good for the power the injectors are 60lb which are again probably good for the power hes making. We don't have the fuel rail pressure nor do we have duty cycle so those are 2 unknowns.
But seeing as the Yaris was never engineered to have 350+ hp id be willing to be the fuel lines from the tank to the engine are to small.
Garm what are you running for fuel lines? 8an?
Im not trying to bash xbgod on his build to each their own poison but running that dangerously lean and nitrous will result in a nitrous backfire which will blow your intake off the car.
If the fuel issues get fixed and you run nitrous please do not go over a 50 shot with this small of a motor or you'l get to meet mr puddles and blow your intake up and probably wreck your turbo. Trust me with this I have nitrous on another car and I've run a 150 shot there is nothing scarier than watching your fuel pressure drop from 39 psi to 24 psi for a microsecond and jump back up.
Blown_xaVirginia · Jan 14, 2011#254 Originally Posted by
xbgod ↑ Haven't considered E85. And to the other guy on my fuel pump, lines and so fourth, are you serious? I'm not even going to respond to that. All is working well and tune is great. I made good numbers and now I'm movin on. It's time to finish pimping it to look sexy and wash and wax it. The only thing I'm doing on the side is getting involved with someone else on a real cam set for these motors. This will be in the works for a little while but you can bet when I'm done with R/D with that it will be bullet proof. Don't ask me any questions on it cause it's top secret right now. But you can rest assured I will have a real head cam set for next year. It's been alot of fun and I set out to make power and did so. So if your a hater out there then beat my numbers, good luck.
XBG
Hey man, don't worry about the critical posts. Every forum is full of haters and people who just sound off to make themselves feel better into thinking they know what they are talking about ... even though they don't. Do your thing, ignore the crap. A formula 1 team could come on this forum presenting performance parts, people would still question them and complain. They would "check with their sources" to satisfy themselves with usless opinionated info.
Nexus1155Dorchester · Jan 14, 2011#255 Hey man, don't worry about the critical posts.
Blown, I know you are knowledgeable, surely you must see the drop off in power and then a sudden lean condition. You see no problem with that?RPM still increased. he didn't let off the gas.
xnamerxxso cal · Jan 14, 2011#256No one here is hating on him they are all pointing out a giant problem with his afr.
Ever wonder why evos, sti, cobras, vettes, vw's, or any other car that has a forced induction engine runs at afrs around 12:1 or less its not because there trying to sap power from the motor its because running any leaner results in detonation/pre-ignition and combustion temperatures that are to high.
Picture not included in this copy
Hey what do you know on a STI the afr is less than 15:1 what a shocker and hey its running meth what do you know.
cali yarisCanoga Park, CA · Jan 15, 2011#257 Every forum is full of haters and people who just sound off
^ Are you including me in that? I asked a legitimate tuning question, and congratulated him on his numbers. And the question remains unanswered.
ParmasML · Jan 15, 2011#258 Originally Posted by
xnamerxx ↑ No one here is hating on him they are all pointing out a giant problem with his afr.
Ever wonder why evos, sti, cobras, vettes, vw's, or any other car that has a forced induction engine runs at afrs around 12:1 or less its not because there trying to sap power from the motor its because running any leaner results in detonation/pre-ignition and combustion temperatures that are to high.
Picture not included in this copy
Hey what do you know on a STI the afr is less than 15:1 what a shocker and hey its running meth what do you know.
I don't know but that dyno is sweet still on the AFR which btw that is a proper tune for me..... Stoich off boost and low 12 on boost. I am really curious I can be able to make a tune map like this myself!
cali yarisCanoga Park, CA · Jan 16, 2011#259^ I have a ported head with stock cams, so I don't think that's it.
Blown_xaVirginia · Jan 16, 2011#260 Originally Posted by
cali yaris ↑ ^ Are you including me in that? I asked a legitimate tuning question, and congratulated him on his numbers. And the question remains unanswered.
Garm, like said already ...you are looking at the torque curve. The power hardly drops off. As far as afr's, im not gonna speculate. We have run 13.0 on our race car for good numbers on the dyno, it liked running lean. But after the insane power pulls were done we immediately corrected the afr's for racing trim. It may very well be the same in his case. Only his tuner can answer that question about the afr's on that particular pull, but what everyone failed to notice, is the pull ended early around 6000rpm . So my guess is the tuner let off knowing. The car may have made the best power on that pull so that is why it was posted. Only other reason for pull showing an end at 6000rpm would be because rpm's were based off roadspeed and the graph got trunkcated do to tire expansion.
cali yarisCanoga Park, CA · Jan 16, 2011#2611. You didn't answer if you were including me in the word "haters" that you used.
2. Yes, I was looking at the torque curve. Regardless of which curve you'd like to discuss, the motor peaks very early; I asked why. I disagree with you that "The power hardly drops off." It's done at 5200. It drops off enough that the tuner stopped the pull early,
as you noticed.
3. You can "not speculate" on the AFR's all you want -- but the dyno got posted and we get to discuss it, right? That looks too lean to me. (I could always be wrong, but I don't think I am on that detail).
Only his tuner can answer that question about the afr's on that particular pull,
Right. And if it were my car, I'd be asking that question before I drove away with it tuned like that.
cali yarisCanoga Park, CA · Jan 16, 2011#262OK, I can't argue because I don't know enough, I'll admit that. Maybe the porting job alone gave him a power curve where horsepower is done by 5200. Were there some pics posted of the head? I can't remember.
xnamerxxso cal · Jan 17, 2011#263Since you seem to understand this subject so much explain why a stock yaris is able to keep making power past 5200 rpm's and this dudes motor is out of steam at 5200 rpm's.
All I want is a explanation as to why that would be the case.
xnamerxxso cal · Jan 17, 2011#264Yes, I want a explanation as to why a very modded car is plateauing in power at 5200 rpms where as a stock yaris would not be doing that if it really was a problem with heads and cams.
Nexus1155Dorchester · Jan 17, 2011#265Unless that stuff was hurting the flow or restricting it, wouldn't it promote power in the higher revs since you are making it easier for the motor to breathe? especially when still using stock cams?
xnamerxxso cal · Jan 17, 2011#266Seeing as his dyno looks like any other dyno with a maxed out turbo Im going to go out on a limb and say he maxed his turbo out.
The fact that just because your car has air being forced into it doesn't mean your dyno curves will looks drastically different. All your doing is compressing air in a given space. The engine will still consume the air as it would in N/A form. If you look at any car be it PD induction or turbo the peak power is still the same as it would be N/A as long as the boost levels are held until the power adder is maxed out on its induction.
Im not going to sit here and congratulate a guy on making power when its obvious to anyone who knows anything about engine tuning when there are clear problems. In the end do I care if this guy blows his motor no but when people believe his setup is normal and good then more people will continue on the wrong path of how to setup a motor adding more noise for people who are looking to get the right info.
cali yarisCanoga Park, CA · Jan 17, 2011#267It's xbgod's thread, to "share with the community" this build and the results. I've asked my questions, so I'm done for now. If the answers get posted, I think that will be valuable to all of us.
cali yarisCanoga Park, CA · Jan 17, 2011#268^ read the thread. You've already said you can't answer them and don't want to speculate, which is fine.
cali yarisCanoga Park, CA · Jan 17, 2011#269You're welcome!
YodaFL · Jan 17, 2011#270Xb has turned ghost....
xbgodThread starterFlorida · Jan 17, 2011#271No ghost, just out having a little fun and had to fix an exhaust leak.
I see I missed alot in past few days, holy-crap.
Remember I don't use VVTI so that has some play in what your reading. Also the XB starts to fall on it face at around 5000-5200 RPM. Paul at Dezod can even tell you this. It's just the way it is. As far as being lean My car likes it there. It dosen't detonate and pulls like a beast. More than likely because of my 107 octane and M1 meth.
All is well so I hope this helps, if not sorry..........I'm running'em down and enjoying the car.
You guys can keep running your own senarios and speculation, it happens especially on forums.
Thanks to all that have followed me.
XBG
H3LlIoNMidatlantic · Jan 17, 2011#272I'm gonna chime in...I don't think any of the heavy 1nz hitters are running VVT-I, AFAIK, mostly because of A) Some standalones don't offer control modules yet (I can vouch for that) and B) from earlier speculation in this same thread by Aras and others, at a certain point it becomes a hindrance as opposed to a power builder. (Which doesn't make sense to me, but whatever...I don't have a 350hp 1nz to play with and speak from experience.)
Also, I'm currently picking my nose and drinking a miller light. I may or may not have already consumed a number of long island iced teas.
H3LlIoNMidatlantic · Jan 17, 2011#273Also, this post got pushed to the side and I was hoping for some speculation from Aras. Thanks
Originally Posted by
H3LlIoN ↑ Sweet numbers. Curious...what are you hoping to run at the track? What were your E.T.'s on the old build?
H3LlIoNMidatlantic · Jan 17, 2011#274 Originally Posted by cdydjded ↑
Well there you go, 1 reason (the biggest) for the difference in HP is that he is NOT using the VVTI. So in essence you cant compare a NA dyno that uses VVTI to his....
And in regards to this, I highly doubt that Garm is comparing an NA dyno to Aras'....I think he's more comparing his non-vvt-i turbo set up.
cali yarisCanoga Park, CA · Jan 17, 2011#275All I did was ask two questions. (1. Why does it stop making power at 5200, and why was it tuned that lean). I was called a hater and now hostile. I haven't said a critical thing about the build or the tune. Lame.
Also the XB starts to fall on it face at around 5000-5200 RPM.
I asked why, it was just a question. Art's didn't (280whp). Mine doesn't (357 whp). So, that question remains unanswered. "That's just the way it is" is not a useful answer.
The second question really belongs with the tuner, as he seems to be the only one who can answer it. "It likes it there" is great to hear, but again is not a useful answer IMO.
xbgod, you got great numbers. (I already said that). If you're not curious about the why of these things, that's fine, it's your project of course!
H3LlIoNMidatlantic · Jan 17, 2011#276 Originally Posted by
cali yaris ↑ All I did was ask two questions. (1. Why does it stop making power at 5200, and why was it tuned that lean). I was called a hater and now hostile. I haven't said a critical thing about the build or the tune. Lame.
I asked why, it was just a question. Art's didn't (280whp). Mine doesn't (357 whp). So, that question remains unanswered. "That's just the way it is" is not a useful answer.
The second question really belongs with the tuner, as he seems to be the only one who can answer it. "It likes it there" is great to hear, but again is not a useful answer IMO.
xbgod, you got great numbers. (I already said that). If you're not curious about the why of these things, that's fine, it's your project of course!
Hater. 😁
xnamerxxso cal · Jan 17, 2011#277 Originally Posted by cdydjded ↑
Well there you go, 1 reason (the biggest) for the difference in HP is that he is NOT using the VVTI. So in essence you cant compare a NA dyno that uses VVTI to his....
Explain to me how this matters, hes not running a stock cam iirc and not only that he doesn't have a stock intake and why dont his torque numbers drop sharply like they would if he fell out of the stock cams torque band. Not only that doesnt Garm use stock cams with vvti turned off.
I wont say im a expert at tuning but what im seeing on his dyno sheet is very obvious to whats going on. Im not saying maxing the turbo out is bad just saying he did that and his dyno proves it.
As for running lean its not detonation you need to worry about its going to be scuffing pistons and cracking rings and ringlands and pre-ignition.
xbgodThread starterFlorida · Jan 17, 2011#278Garm, your no hater. I still love you...........In a non-gay way!
My tunnner "Rolo" is coming over to the shop on my side of the bay for a tweak on my ride for street driving. Setting it up as the way I drive and not just a heated pull on the dyno.
XBG
H3LlIoNMidatlantic · Jan 17, 2011#279 Originally Posted by
xbgod ↑ Garm, your no hater. I still love you...........In a non-gay way!
The actual correct terminology is "no homo."
H3LlIoNMidatlantic · Jan 17, 2011#280 Originally Posted by cdydjded ↑
You cannot compare Garms build to xB build. They are all different. The only thing they have in common is the the are turbocharged.
I beg to differ. While they have inherent differences, they are running the same engine, the same compressor (turbo), and similar fuel systems. Obviously we cannot compare the flow characteristics of the head work and tuning maps, but given the ultimate goal of both machinists/tuners involved, I think that these two builds are more similar than you are giving them credit for.
^that post is for Carlos. For everybody else that doesn't understand what is going on, I'm not saying these two builds are in any way identical.
Also, Cotton needs new shorts, and I still would like some discussion on ETs, as I am a 1/4 mile nut. Aras, did you run the old build? Are you gonna run this one? Any idea what you think she'll run?
And I'm out of beer. Anyone close to VA?
H3LlIoNMidatlantic · Jan 17, 2011#281 Originally Posted by cdydjded ↑
Here are some key differences:
1 The port job on the head
2 Weapon-R sheet metal intake
3 Edlebrock Victor-X 70mm TB
4 Garrett GTX-2860 RS Turbo w/ SS Housing and Billet Wheel
5 LHT Performance custom Exhaust manifold/ down pipe and all intercooling pipe
6 680cc Precision injectors
All the above items make HIS build incomparable to Garms or Arts......
I actually took the time to respond to each of these points individually and weigh a valid argument for why the builds are
similar enough to be comparable, but then I re-read your response, and realized that you are far too defensive and obtuse at this time to actually give any serious thought to a word that I would have said. I initially though that someone with (what I thought was) your level of understanding of what goes in to engine design would understand my initial comment, hence why I singled you out so that others wouldn't read in to what I had posted. I guess I had given you too much credit, although I doubt that's it. In my experience with you, you seem decently knowledgeable. Perhaps you just aren't willing at this time to hear any other points of view. Some other time, I guess.
Also, I'm still out of beer. How close are you to VA? Wanna grab a beer and talk shop? My treat...
H3LlIoNMidatlantic · Jan 17, 2011#282No, no, no. You got it all wrong.
You're supposed to say "What? What did you call me"
and then I'm supposed to post "Obtuse. Is it deliberate?"
And then you're up again with "Son, you're forgetting yourself."
and we go back and forth like that for a while, and I end up getting a bunch of time in solitary.
YodaFL · Jan 17, 2011#283Ehh whats going on here😕. Been awhile since i seen this type dribble since Tamago days😛. Lets not attack each other over a dyno sheet its not that serious. 🙄
H3LlIoNMidatlantic · Jan 17, 2011#284I'm not attacking anyone.
PETERPOOPOahu · Jan 17, 2011#285So can we see that video? :)
ParmasML · Jan 18, 2011#286I really don't understand this post and I hope that XBgod can respond clearly here
Originally Posted by
xbgod ↑ Also the XB starts to fall on it face at around 5000-5200 RPM. Paul at Dezod can even tell you this.
What do you mean by fall on its face?
It's just the way it is.
The way it is? I really don't know what do you mean?
As far as being lean My car likes it there. It dosen't detonate and pulls like a beast. More than likely because of my 107 octane and M1 meth.
Your car likes it there? I never heard of an XB talking maybe you really are an XBgod😆
All is well so I hope this helps, if not sorry..........I'm running'em down and enjoying the car.
I hope you will still enjoy your car really, but no one said running lean will selfdestruct immidately but in time it happens and I hope you want cry on this forum if it happens since we warned you
XBG
xnamerxxso cal · Jan 18, 2011#287 Originally Posted by cdydjded ↑
xnamerxx: Explain to me how this matters, hes not running a stock cam iirc and not only that he doesn't have a stock intake and why dont his torque numbers drop sharply like they would if he fell out of the stock cams torque band. Not only that doesnt Garm use stock cams with vvti turned off.
You cannot compare Garms build to xB build to Art's build. They are all different. The only thing they have in common is the the are turbocharged.
I wont say im a expert at tuning but what im seeing on his dyno sheet is very obvious to whats going on. Im not saying maxing the turbo out is bad just saying he did that and his dyno proves it.
What is obviously going on?
As for running lean its not detonation you need to worry about its going to be scuffing pistons and cracking rings and ringlands and pre-ignition.
How do pistons get "scuffed"
BTW detonation & pre ignition is the same thing....
Its simple air consumption is related to the amount of power you can make. If the limiting factor is his turbo which can only flow x amount of air no matter how much you rev the thing it will only consume as much air as the turbo is capable of putting out. Thats why his power band stays so flat. If you look at people who max the turbo out on their evo or sti or gti they all do the same thing.
When you run lean your combustion temperatures get hotter then optimal. Heat causes metal to expand. Since a piston and cylinder only have so much clearance if the metal expands to much it will reduce clearances and press against the walls of the cylinder which causes the pistons to scuff in the bore. Also running hotter will cause the rings to expand more then designed for and if the rings touch end to end they will crack and probably break the ring land in the piston causing a failure.
As for detonation and pre-ignition being the same thing no. If you believe that I suggest you google the subject. You get detonation from a many things but it always happens after the spark and pre-ignition before the spark.
Since you clearly don't understand/believe the information being given maybe you should try to prove why your right rather then argue why I'm wrong.
Blown_xaVirginia · Jan 18, 2011#288This is some funny shizat. haha! It's mathmatically impossible for torque curve to not cross at 5250. Only cars where is doesnt drop off much is an s2k or Formula 1 car, and that has more to do with volumetric efficiency at high rpm... which the 1nzfe will never see. The only thing we can do is maybe crazy cams and a efficient turbo set up to get good top end. Nobody is ever gonna destroke a 1nzfe.
I think people got a bit bent of shape here. Its basic knowledge on what afr should be, I highly doubt the tuner is oblivious to that.
ilikericesavannah, ga · Jan 18, 2011#289ive been reading and keeping up with all the forced induction threads on here to get an idea of where i may go with my yaris.. and this thread has turned into just a soap opera for me.. i cant wait for my next break or when i get home to read the next post..
anywho, with that out of the way, i need to get on the same page here.. are you guys arguing about the Torque curve dropping or the Horse Power curve dropping? cuz if its the torque curve, then im 100% with blown xa on this one.. but if its the power curve, then i have my own theory's that i do agree with a couple of you but im not as knowledgeable as everyone else here to argue any side. but i am learning a shit load of things the yaris is capable of and not capable of, and i thank all of you for everyones input
xbgodThread starterFlorida · Jan 19, 2011#290Well here we go again.
Junichi Tanaka from Jun Performance has seen my build and is in correspondance with me on doing a set of cams for my XB. Not sure on all the details yet. But I do know they are not regrinds and there stuff looks alot nicer than Gude.
XBG
Scubaru Stevecalgary · Jan 19, 2011#291 Originally Posted by
xbgod ↑ Well here we go again.
Junichi Tanaka from Jun Performance has seen my build and is in correspondance with me on doing a set of cams for my XB. Not sure on all the details yet. But I do know they are not regrinds and there stuff looks alot nicer than Gude.
XBG
mmm cams!!!
any idea on duration and lift? 272* 9mm lift?
im not even sure what stock is 🤷
xbgodThread starterFlorida · Jan 19, 2011#292The cams them self aren't my biggest concern. It's the clearence with the buckets and if I will need different springs.
Waiting on Junichi to get back with me on this. Should know tonight where we stand.
XBG
cali yarisCanoga Park, CA · Jan 19, 2011#293 I think people got a bit bent of shape here.
Uh yeah, calling people haters will sometimes do that.
I looked at the JUN cams too, but at $1600 a pair, it was out of my range for the HP they would give.
Scubaru Stevecalgary · Jan 20, 2011#294 Originally Posted by
xbgod ↑ The cams them self aren't my biggest concern. It's the clearence with the buckets and if I will need different springs.
Waiting on Junichi to get back with me on this. Should know tonight where we stand.
XBG
i wonder how aggressive the cams can be without major head mods. added duration is sweet, but the lift is what makes the huge difference.
im interested to here what they say.
xbgodThread starterFlorida · Jan 20, 2011#295As I thought, to run the turbo grind for JUN cams you will need to Change valve springs and buckets for tappet adjustment. None of which they have. So the question is, do they work? If so, whats the numbers they are getting.
They are not even sure when they will have these items to prove their cam grinds, which are new and not regrinds. Can't figure out why a company would make something that they cant prove results from.
They do make a N/A grind which allows you to use stock springs and stock Buckets from Toyota, which you will have to find the correct sizes on your own.
So untill someone like BC comes out with a complete set-up I belive the cam regrinds with shit like Gude does is just a useless up-hill climb.
Seems like their is always some retard trying to ice-skate up-hill.
XBG
cali yarisCanoga Park, CA · Jan 20, 2011#296JUN cams come in three grinds, street, n/a and turbo. They are all in stock and ready to ship. They come with springs and retainers.
However, as you say, I have been unable to get any information on what car they were tested in (if they were tested) and what the results were.
So I pass for now.
Here are the specs:
1. 256 duration, 9.0mm lift (Street)
2. 272 duration, 9.5mm lift (NA)
3. 272 duration, 10.5mm lift (Turbo)
xbgodThread starterFlorida · Jan 20, 2011#297They do not come with springs or retainers. I just spoke with Junichi who owns the place.
At least this holds true for the turbo application and the N/A.
So this still leaves me with having someone else make the buckets.
XBG
xbgodThread starterFlorida · Jan 20, 2011#298Don't need to do that either. I'm good friends with Jon Ferrea. I had the valves springs lockers and so fourth made years ago. And can buy the stuff for, well lets just say dirt cheap. he's only 2 hours from my house in Fl. Buckets on the other hand would be a different beast altogether. Your talking about a possibility of 16 different bucket grinds. Not to mention he would need my head and alot of down time to set it up check all the clearences and so fourth. Just alot to ask without a substancial payout. This is what would be time consuming. Which is where Gude thinks he has the market. But his Remidy is shitty. Now you could do backwards math and make a different set of valves to make up the difference for the buckets. again will be time consuming. Either way this is a huge take-on. But one that needs to be done.
XBG
xbgodThread starterFlorida · Jan 20, 2011#299You got it !
xbgodThread starterFlorida · Jan 20, 2011#300I know that.
But depending on the grind none of them may work. Been down that road once already with schneider cams and thats also why Vance & Hines didn't want to take it on again. They did it once for Lesly in her XB and said it was a nightmare and didn't keep any of the specs. It was a one-off deal because of her race TC that they sponsor too.
XBG