Yarisworld Archive

SQcomps install

403 posts · 83,895 views · page 4 of 9

Replies continued

sqcompBack at home · May 29, 2010#151
*
derickveliz2Central, MA · May 29, 2010#152
Originally Posted by sqcomp ↑
As for aiming, there are quite a lot of variables that go into the sound that hits your ears.
What's your approach?

are you doing everything trail and error?


.
🙇


.👍
bzinn 1University Place,WA · May 29, 2010#153
I though I saw ID8s in the back ground of a picture and figured you were using them.....L8s also very nice.
Alien MantisArizona · May 29, 2010#154
"Aiming" and "Time Alignment" is tricky because of how the sound waves bounce around in the vehicle.

( All vehicles are different. )

Some vehicles are easier to tweak than others.

AND.... where do you want your "sweet spot" to be?
You aim for the "sweet spot" to be "anywhere" in the vehicle, but it never works out that way.

Some "sweet spots" are outside the car.... with the doors open.... 5 feet away.

😁
Alien MantisArizona · May 29, 2010#155
Hey SQcomp....

So what is the deal with your fancy expensive tweeters?
You don't like how they sound? Are they too harsh?
Are they silk dome?
You having trouble aligning them to hit your sweet spot?

( or do they just plain sound "bad" ? )
sqcompBack at home · May 29, 2010#156
*
talnlnkyThread starterSpokane, Wa · May 29, 2010#157
Originally Posted by sqcomp ↑
...okay big edit...

I had a whole page going on. This situation needs to be resolved between Scott and myself about the L1 Pro and the L1 Pro SE before I say anything. I owe him that much.

I'll leave it at this, I *may* be replacing the Legatia tweeters temporarily until I can get some replacements...of which I have several options from the shop. I think I'm going to realistically be using the ID XS-28. I want to use the MD-100 but I don't want to buy an entire component set from the shop owner to do so. I was looking at using the Hertz Mille big chamber 1 1/8" tweeters...but not at what they're asking for a pair (even at my cost). The Thesis tweeters are twice as expensive as the Mille tweets...that's a no go for my budget right now.
the biggest thing that seperates expensive fancy tweeters from medium ok tweeters is how low they can play. With that said, you could grab two tweets off partsexpress for $40 after shipping and get good results since your tweets will only be playing less than 1 octave of range.
Alien MantisArizona · May 29, 2010#158
Originally Posted by talnlnky ↑
the biggest thing that seperates expensive fancy tweeters from medium ok tweeters is how low they can play. With that said, you could grab two tweets off partsexpress for $40 after shipping and get good results since your tweets will only be playing less than 1 octave of range.
So I am guessing SQcomp is trying to tune the blend between the tweets and the mids? ( and he is not liking the results he is getting )

This has probably been mentioned, but exactly WHAT is the crossover points between the tweets and mids? Are you "blending", or are you "seperating"?

And why would you want to force the tweets to play lower?
Wouldn't you just let the midrange drivers handle those freqs?

I might know a little about how "audio" works, but I am obviously not experienced with tuning a high-end competition system.
So I ask these questions just to build on my own limited knowledge.
sqcompBack at home · May 29, 2010#159
*
JBougieBeech Bluff, TN · May 29, 2010#160
I so wish I had 1/1000th of your knowledge about audio when piecing my system together .... lol
sqcompBack at home · May 29, 2010#161
*
goku87AK · May 30, 2010#162
Originally Posted by sqcomp ↑
Bite into that one AM! Which ones am I looking at? :D
I guessed the sub. His turn lol
talnlnkyThread starterSpokane, Wa · May 30, 2010#163
Originally Posted by Alien Mantis ↑

And why would you want to force the tweets to play lower?
Wouldn't you just let the midrange drivers handle those freqs?

I might know a little about how "audio" works, but I am obviously not experienced with tuning a high-end competition system.
So I ask these questions just to build on my own limited knowledge.
well, there are a ton of variables...

If it was possible to make a perfect sq system. you would only have 1 speaker per channel (ie, left speaker, right speaker) and it would be able to play from about 15hz up to 25khz. Problem is that it is VERY difficult to make full range speakers. There are 10 octaves of sound in the 20hz-20khz range. the best "full range" speakers on the market currently are 3"-5" units and they are only capable of playing 7-8 octaves. Most struggle to play above 10khz, and most can't play well below 80hz.

The reason why a single speaker is awesome is because all the sound comes from one point, which means when you do your imaging/staging/aiming portion of your install, you'll have a much easier time. You don't have to worry about weird rainbow effects (highs sound like they are up high like head level, but mids sound like they are at your feet).

Going with less speakers also reduces the amount of crossovers you need. Having good crossover(s) makes for about 60% of the total install quality in my opinion. Even more important than enclosures designs, quality drivers, and sound deadening.

So, if you can limit how many speakers you run, you make your install easier. The simplest answer possible is always the most reliable one, and usually the best overall.

Because of the current limitations of speakers, there are some problems introduced however.

The higher the frequency a speaker plays, the more directional it becomes. Being very directional isn't a problem, UNLESS your speakers aren't aimed at your head. If they are aimed some other place, then you will have dips in your frequency response

Another issue with having speakers play most of the frequencies is that it requires a voice coil with a very low LE (which is hard to do and still have good power handling).

Another is that it requires more linear movement (x-max) from the driver. Without a linear motor, a speaker will start to distort very quickly. Multiple linear motor technologies have been around in subs for over 10years, in fact there are a few that have been around a very long time. However, they usually jack up the price of the speaker and thus aren't widespread. There are also some technologies that only work for subs, whereas there are some that have even been used in mids & tweets. The more frequencies you require a speaker to play, the harder it has to work... Linear motors allow speakers to play more frequencies at once before distortion sets in.



So, why would you want your tweets to play low.... well, SQcomp I believe is trying to stay away from that. "Low" for a tweet would be playing anything below 5khz. Normal crossover points for a 6.5" component set would be 2khz-5khz (usually in the 2.5-3khz area tho).

In some installs however, if you can get your tweet to play low enough you can limit how many speakers you have, and still be able to have a very good frequency response in a system that is able to get loud before distorting.

Take a look at HLCD's or compression drivers.... there are the tweets used in club speakers. There are a few of them used in car audio. They are generally able to play around 800hz up to about 16khz... All you really need is a mid with a fairly strong midbass, and a sub, a band of eq around 18-20khz and you are set.


It all comes down to getting the fequency response desired, and the staging/imagine you want. And limiting the amount & complexity of your crossover(s) has a huge impact on how hard of a job you'll have.
sqcompBack at home · May 30, 2010#164
*
derickveliz2Central, MA · May 31, 2010#165
.

I though I knew it all! LOL

(o:
sqcompBack at home · May 31, 2010#166
*
derickveliz2Central, MA · May 31, 2010#167
Originally Posted by sqcomp ↑
Derick,To answer your first question about trial and error, the answer is "sometimes". It depends on what we're doing. I know what has worked in the past for me, I know the general fundamentals. This is where my need for more experience leads me to try other things and lean on the experience of the shop owners who have been doing this since I started in the early 90's.
Thanks, spcomp!

I've been reading the owners manual for the DEX-P99RS, I think it's going to be a "RELIGIOUS EXPERIENCE" for me, I can't wait.
🙂



D.
goku87AK · Jun 1, 2010#168
You're killing me with the lack of pictures...
sqcompBack at home · Jun 1, 2010#169
*
talnlnkyThread starterSpokane, Wa · Jun 1, 2010#170
Originally Posted by sqcomp ↑
Seriously though, I have a lot of pictures. All three amps are up, by the end of today they should be powered. I'm waiting on the quote for the Audison Thesis Violino tweeters (yes, I gave it away), and my flippin' mix on the fleece was to cold. It's still kicking 12 hours later.

Realistically today, there will be power to all the amps, and answer for the replacement tweeters, the kicks should be ready to be started, and the backup sensors *should* be done.

Edit:

The ground point for the 4.5 "stripped out" when I attached all three grounds. In the pictures I'll put on tonight you'll notice that I made a new ground bolt from the outside in...like we did at Freightliner oh so long ago.
I never trusted self tapping screws, I always did the nut/bolt routine for grounds. Are you going to mix up some more resin nice and hot and lay it over the top of your cold mix to heat it up?. Nothing worse than cold resin.
sqcompBack at home · Jun 1, 2010#171
*
goku87AK · Jun 1, 2010#172
Mwahahahaha, excellent stuff. It's coming together really really well. 👍
sqcompBack at home · Jun 2, 2010#173
*
derickveliz2Central, MA · Jun 2, 2010#174
Lets see!!!!
sqcompBack at home · Jun 2, 2010#175
*
derickveliz2Central, MA · Jun 2, 2010#176
.
W O W . . .

If I could just do something like that
.
🙇
sqcompBack at home · Jun 2, 2010#177
*
talnlnkyThread starterSpokane, Wa · Jun 2, 2010#178
so whats your style for doing glass work on that sub box...
So far you've done skeleton, then fleece & resin... are you going to then do mat on the inside or outside of the fleece, or do you do something else?

I've done a few glass projects myself, but it is always nice to see how other people do their projects.
sqcompBack at home · Jun 2, 2010#179
*
goku87AK · Jun 4, 2010#180
audiogasm 🤤
sqcompBack at home · Jun 4, 2010#181
*
talnlnkyThread starterSpokane, Wa · Jun 4, 2010#182
soo.... whats the difference? polished copper on the back? Is it all aesthetic changes?
sqcompBack at home · Jun 5, 2010#183
*
talnlnkyThread starterSpokane, Wa · Jun 5, 2010#184
Looks good, i would love to do that with my 4's.
sqcompBack at home · Jun 5, 2010#185
*
goku87AK · Jun 5, 2010#186
you want it?
sqcompBack at home · Jun 6, 2010#187
*
derickveliz2Central, MA · Jun 7, 2010#188
.

🙇🙇🙇Hey looks awesome, but...

I'm a little confuse/frustrated 🤷 with aiming/orientation of your speakers, is this part or your experiment that you talked about befere?
I imagine that the windshield will create lots of "Diffractions and Reflexions" and I read and see others aiming speakers towards the pilot and passenger,

Picture not included in this copy




Like these suggestions I got from HERTZ's website...



Picture not included in this copy

Picture not included in this copy



BTW I ordered my HL70 last week!



.
👍
derickveliz2Central, MA · Jun 7, 2010#189
.

Even though Five Axis and Pioneer top of the line did it similar to your set up, but in one of Five Axis interviews they say that they did it like that because of time and space!

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Csg_x...layer_embedded

Tell me that the CARROZERIA does some magic with this aiming set up!

I'm sorry for the huge picture here, but is on purpose so you can see the midrange and tweeters.




Picture not included in this copy
D.
sqcompBack at home · Jun 7, 2010#190
*
Alien MantisArizona · Jun 7, 2010#191
I don't like huge A-pillar pods. Looks goofy.
And I also don't like speakers in the A-pillars aimed at my face.
Too harsh. It is not preferable to have your face 2 feet away from the speakers.
The listening environment in a vehicle is too small. It is a challenge to overcome this obstacle.
The best listening environment would be a larger room, with acoustic dampening on the walls. The listener can be far away from the speakers, so the audio can blend together nicely.
You simply don't have this luxury when working with car audio, so you do whatever tricks you can to try and work with the small space you have.
( Which is no doubt why SQcomp is not aiming those A-pillar speakers straight at the listeners face. )

You can aim speakers at my face, if I am 15 feet away from them.
At 2-3 feet, I don't want them aimed at my face.

I always prefer car speakers mounted in the doors, but that's just me. I'm kinda simple like that.

😁
sqcompBack at home · Jun 7, 2010#192
I*
Alien MantisArizona · Jun 7, 2010#193
The off-axis performance of those Legatia's is a win-win deal.

And the A-pillar pods you made look sweet.
I wouldn't be ashamed to have those in my Yaris.

( I can't wait to see them all finished and painted up. )

👍
talnlnkyThread starterSpokane, Wa · Jun 7, 2010#194
well, when talking about off-axis response, the smaller the speaker, generally the better the off-axis will be. Yet another reason why I chose a 3-way using a 4.5" driver for my mids.
sqcompBack at home · Jun 7, 2010#195
*
bzinn 1University Place,WA · Jun 7, 2010#196
HOly Frickin.......Shi........you know.....

Wow please post up pictures of how you are building the frames for those kicks as you go....

It was great to get the chance to see the system in person yesturday,the Apillars are incredable and once you find the timing on them the off axis is gonna sound incredable.

This makes me wish time woudl go a bit faster as I really want to start gettgin my system in the car,driving with no tunes does indeed suck....
bzinn 1University Place,WA · Jun 7, 2010#197
Also what degree was it you said final placement was on the pillars 15 degrees,I will use that as a starting point on mine and see if it works with my comps as well,I doubt it will,I never have luck with anything the first time....lol
sqcompBack at home · Jun 8, 2010#198
*
talnlnkyThread starterSpokane, Wa · Jun 8, 2010#199
I'm skeptical about not doing enclosures on midbass drivers... any back wave that makes it up front will kill your response & volume... Just keep that back way separated and it'll be fine tho.
sqcompBack at home · Jun 8, 2010#200
*