Replies continued
tmontagueCaledonia Ont. · Feb 2, 2016#101 Originally Posted by
Frank the Tank ↑ Saving up for this swap as we speak. I'm excited everyday.
Where about in TO. are you located? When you get the engine swap in order let me know I'd love to come help you out. Are you planning on keeping the Yaris m/t and just getting an xD harness?
Anyone have any ideas how you'd go about getting around the engine immobilizer issue? My thoughts are you'd need to purchase the ecu that came with the new engine and remove the stock Yaris ECU. Then you'd probably also need to immobilizer module located on the steering wheel from the donor car and then have to swap that into the yaris.
Problem is, are all of these other parts plug and play when swapped from a donor car to Yaris?
tmontagueCaledonia Ont. · Feb 2, 2016#102FWIW after reading some sites of other car's I came to this conclusion:
If you just swap in a 2zr engine and loom and keep the original ECU,immobilizer and keys then there will be no issue. The immobilizer will read the correct key and alow the car to start and run with no issues.
Someone please correct me if I'm wrong
ArmstrongRacingThread starterSan Diego · Feb 2, 2016#103A ECM designed to run the 1nz will NOT run a 2zr.....completely different due to the dual vvti....but hey, everything on the internet must be true right? Lol.
tmontagueCaledonia Ont. · Feb 2, 2016#104yes, very true. I should've clarified my above post. The ECU would not be needed for the immobilizer to work so you could install a matrix ecu for the 2nz and be fine. This was working for some Infinite owners.
Does the immobilizer use the ECU or is it simply just reading the key?
CrankyOldManWest Michigan · Feb 2, 2016#105The 08-09 xD did not have an immobilizer. The 09+ Yaris does. From what I can tell, the immobilizer has dedicated signal lines to the ECU. If the signals aren't there, the car won't turn over. My thought is that if the ECU doesn't have the inputs from the immobilizer in the first place, it doesn't matter that the key transponder and immobilizer are still in the vehicle. As far as I can see, there's no other connection from the immobilizer to the starter switch or relays.
Take it with a grain of salt, I haven't actually done the swap.
Edit: Here's the wiring diagram for the Yaris immobilizer. The only communications line that doesn't go directly to the ECU is pin 9, which is wired to the OBD II/DataLinkConnector (pin 7 - SIL). As far as I know, that's only used for external diagnostics. I would add a picture of the xD, but there's nothing to show for unused connections on the diagrams.
1 attachment not included in this copy
CTScottUSA, CT · Feb 2, 2016#106 Originally Posted by
CrankyOldMan ↑ The 08-09 xD did not have an immobilizer. The 09+ Yaris does. From what I can tell, the immobilizer has dedicated signal lines to the ECU. If the signals aren't there, the car won't turn over. My thought is that if the ECU doesn't have the inputs from the immobilizer in the first place, it doesn't matter that the key transponder and immobilizer are still in the vehicle. As far as I can see, there's no other connection from the immobilizer to the starter switch or relays.
Take it with a grain of salt, I haven't actually done the swap.
Edit: Here's the wiring diagram for the Yaris immobilizer. The only communications line that doesn't go directly to the ECU is pin 9, which is wired to the OBD II/DataLinkConnector (pin 7 - SIL). As far as I know, that's only used for external diagnostics. I would add a picture of the xD, but there's nothing to show for unused connections on the diagrams.
The immobilizer is fully linked to the ECM. The Transponder key ECU reads the key and sends the key data to the ECM. Without that data the ECM will not allow the engine to run.
SIL is the K line of ISO-9141. It was used for OBDII diags prior to CAN, but was used for the immobilizer and the comm between the SRS ECU and the ECM on 2nd gen Yaris and various other Toyotas up to 2012.
CrankyOldManWest Michigan · Feb 2, 2016#107 Originally Posted by
CTScott ↑ The immobilizer is fully linked to the ECM. The Transponder key ECU reads the key and sends the key data to the ECM. Without that data the ECM will not allow the engine to run.
SIL is the K line of ISO-9141. It was used for OBDII diags prior to CAN, but was used for the immobilizer and the comm between the SRS ECU and the ECM on 2nd gen Yaris and various other Toyotas up to 2012.
So even with a non-immobilizer ECM, there's still a chance that the immobilizer will prevent the engine from running (via K-line)? Is the fix for that to just get a non-immobilizer ECM and disconnect the K-line from the transponder key ECU (or remove the transponder system entirely)?
CTScottUSA, CT · Feb 2, 2016#108 Originally Posted by
CrankyOldMan ↑ So even with a non-immobilizer ECM, there's still a chance that the immobilizer will prevent the engine from running (via K-line)? Is the fix for that to just get a non-immobilizer ECM and disconnect the K-line from the transponder key ECU (or remove the transponder system entirely)?
With one of the prior 2ZR swaps I helped with there was an issue where the non-immobilizer ECM started acting like it was immobilizer enabled when the chassis still had the transponder key ECM present. So, when installing a non-immobilizer ECM you do need to make sure that the transponder key ECU is disconnected.
Unfortunately the opposite is not true, where installing an immobilized ECM in a non-immobilizer car eliminates the immobilizer function.
tmontagueCaledonia Ont. · Feb 2, 2016#109That's what i'm wondering. Can you just purchase a non immobilizer xD ecu and then just remove the immobilizer from the steering wheel and just run a regular tumbler and get new keys cut to match.
Therefore key turns tumbler to activate starter and ignition, no immobilizer to turn off the engine.
CrankyOldManWest Michigan · Feb 2, 2016#110 Originally Posted by
tmontague ↑ That's what i'm wondering. Can you just purchase a non immobilizer xD ecu and then just remove the immobilizer from the steering wheel and just run a regular tumbler and get new keys cut to match.
Therefore key turns tumbler to activate starter and ignition, no immobilizer to turn off the engine.
I don't think you'd even have to go that far. From what CT is saying, you just have to disconnect the K-line from the key transponder ECU (pin 9). Same key, no need to remove the coil from around the tumbler, no need to remove the transponder ECU.
The key probably just has an RFID chip in it. The transponder coil is just a length of wire wound around the tumbler that acts as an antenna to "ask" the key what info it has. The transponder ECU converts the wireless signal into control/commands for the ECM, saying "go ahead and crank, it's the right key".
CrankyOldManWest Michigan · Feb 2, 2016#111 Originally Posted by
CTScott ↑ With one of the prior 2ZR swaps I helped with there was an issue where the non-immobilizer ECM started acting like it was immobilizer enabled when the chassis still had the transponder key ECM present.
That makes sense from a design standpoint: our shift-by-wire products have to have a secondary communication system in case the direct line to the TCM fails. It's not always a second CAN line, so the K-line would be a viable backup.
CTScottUSA, CT · Feb 2, 2016#112 Originally Posted by
CrankyOldMan ↑ I don't think you'd even have to go that far. From what CT is saying, you just have to disconnect the K-line from the key transponder ECU (pin 9). Same key, no need to remove the coil from around the tumbler, no need to remove the transponder ECU.
The key probably just has an RFID chip in it. The transponder coil is just a length of wire wound around the tumbler that acts as an antenna to "ask" the key what info it has. The transponder ECU converts the wireless signal into control/commands for the ECM, saying "go ahead and crank, it's the right key".
Correct - Non-Immobilizer ECM and make sure comm between key ECU and ECM is disconnected and you don't have to change the ignition switch assembly, as the reader that is built in is not used with the connection split.
ArmstrongRacingThread starterSan Diego · Feb 2, 2016#113OR.....
Someone could leave all of the immobilizer parts intact, tow the car to the dealership, pay the techs $200 to try their best.....and possibly get answers for the whole community. If they fail, no big deal and you disconnect the ECU.
CTScottUSA, CT · Feb 2, 2016#114 Originally Posted by
ArmstrongRacing ↑ OR.....
Someone could leave all of the immobilizer parts intact, tow the car to the dealership, pay the techs $200 to try their best.....and possibly get answers for the whole community. If they fail, no big deal and you disconnect the ECU.
There is a limited amount that Toyota techs can do. If you have the master key for the original immobilized ECM you can add new keys (so you could add a Yaris key to the XD ECM, if you got the XD with its original master key). Without the master key there is nothing Toyota can do (except replace the ECM and keys).
Beyond the dealership, it is possible to clear the existing transponder key data from the ECM (so that you can add new keys, as if the ECM is brand new), but that requires opening the ECM an desoldering and reflashing the EEPROM that stores the data.
CrankyOldManWest Michigan · Feb 3, 2016#115 Originally Posted by
CTScott ↑ Beyond the dealership, it is possible to clear the existing transponder key data from the ECM (so that you can add new keys, as if the ECM is brand new), but that requires opening the ECM an desoldering and reflashing the EEPROM that stores the data.
Ooh! I hope it's a BGA package!!
ArmstrongRacingThread starterSan Diego · Feb 3, 2016#116A fellow dealership tech I know said you should be able to program keys via a locksmith too, I believe they can come to your house so it's worth a shot.
The unknown element here is "IF" the Yaris immobilizer system will communicate properly with the Xd ECM.
brushforhireJohnstown, PA · Feb 3, 2016#117 Originally Posted by
CTScott ↑ There is a limited amount that Toyota techs can do. If you have the master key for the original immobilized ECM you can add new keys (so you could add a Yaris key to the XD ECM, if you got the XD with its original master key). Without the master key there is nothing Toyota can do (except replace the ECM and keys).
When I worked for our Toyota dealership we would wipe cars that lost all the keys all the time. Now some of the older vehicles you had to replace the ECM, but the newer stuff like this we would just wipe and reprogram new keys. I know the tech has to be a Master Tech under Toyota and they hook up the car to the shop computer and they have to get Toyota themselves to do a master reset like that.
Here is a TSB about this:
Linky CTScottUSA, CT · Feb 3, 2016#118 Originally Posted by
brushforhire ↑ When I worked for our Toyota dealership we would wipe cars that lost all the keys all the time. Now some of the older vehicles you had to replace the ECM, but the newer stuff like this we would just wipe and reprogram new keys. I know the tech has to be a Master Tech under Toyota and they hook up the car to the shop computer and they have to get Toyota themselves to do a master reset like that.
Here is a TSB about this:
Linky
That doc is dated 2002. For the newer vehicles there is no such procedure, that I have ever seen documented.
brushforhireJohnstown, PA · Feb 3, 2016#119They haven't changed anything about it since then, it is still the same procedure for lost keys and the such. We used to do them all the time for customers. Not sure how so many of our customers lost all their keys, but we did lots. Some of the nuances of the newer cars might have changed, but I know we were doing the newer cars, too. Like 2014's new.
Not sure how it would work for a swap like this, but it can probably be finagled.
I hope I don't seem like I'm being an ass or anything, I just worked at our Toyota dealership for 11 years. Seven of those were as a manager, and I was one of the ones who would authorize key codes requests and stuff like that, I just wanted to give a broader set of options for dealing with stuff like this.
If a dealership is telling you otherwise they are probably just being difficult, or don't have any master techs that have access to complete wipes and reprograms.
We would also run into this when people would bring in a valet to try and program a new master key and they would have to do a complete wipe and reprogram it all from scratch.
CTScottUSA, CT · Feb 3, 2016#120 Originally Posted by
brushforhire ↑ They haven't changed anything about it since then, it is still the same procedure for lost keys and the such. We used to do them all the time for customers. Not sure how so many of our customers lost all their keys, but we did lots. Some of the nuances of the newer cars might have changed, but I know we were doing the newer cars, too. Like 2014's new.
Not sure how it would work for a swap like this, but it can probably be finagled.
I hope I don't seem like I'm being an ass or anything, I just worked at our Toyota dealership for 11 years. Seven of those were as a manager, and I was one of the ones who would authorize key codes requests and stuff like that, I just wanted to give a broader set of options for dealing with stuff like this.
If a dealership is telling you otherwise they are probably just being difficult, or don't have any master techs that have access to complete wipes and reprograms.
We would also run into this when people would bring in a valet to try and program a new master key and they would have to do a complete wipe and reprogram it all from scratch.
I don't doubt it. It would be crazy for there not to be a back door, but I just haven't seen any mention of it in any Toyota documentation for the past 10+ years.
brushforhireJohnstown, PA · Feb 4, 2016#121I know on the older vehicles that do need a ecm replacement if the master key is lost, they will do a one time free ECU replacement to get new master keys programmed to it. I know as a precaution our techs always just programmed all keys to the vehicle as master keys.
I know when I was at Toyota if there wasn't a replacement documentation for a TSB like the one I linked to, it usually still applied. Toyota was usually really good for stuff like this. I do miss working for them sometimes. They were usually so organized and fantastic to work with.
Now chrysler and hyundai, now that's a different story, LoL.
ArmstrongRacingThread starterSan Diego · Feb 4, 2016#122Sorry to disturb the immobilizer discussion, but here are my 2zr swap MPG's...
This is combined city/highway with an hour sitting in traffic in the mornings AND Evenings.
1 attachment not included in this copy
Bluevitz-rsOshawa, Ontario, Canada · Feb 4, 2016#123Was that including the autox
ArmstrongRacingThread starterSan Diego · Feb 4, 2016#124No, just commuting to work, and I wasn't afraid of using wot to make some passes....and the a/c was running always...so expect an "average" of 30mpg combined.
thebarberGrand Rapids, MI · Feb 4, 2016#125 Originally Posted by
ArmstrongRacing ↑ No, just commuting to work, and I wasn't afraid of using wot to make some passes....and the a/c was running always...so expect an "average" of 30mpg combined.
not terrible...
Bluevitz-rsOshawa, Ontario, Canada · Feb 4, 2016#126How is this compared to the 1NZ.
ArmstrongRacingThread starterSan Diego · Feb 4, 2016#127 Originally Posted by
Bluevitz-rs ↑ How is this compared to the 1NZ.
It depends on who you ask, but I was getting to about 320miles when the last bar starts flashing.
Bluevitz-rsOshawa, Ontario, Canada · Feb 4, 2016#128Yeah I meant your own back to back. So pretty close then. I wonder how a long trip would compare the two. Those numbers are pretty close.
invader166Langley, BC · Feb 4, 2016#129I'm sure you could bump it up to 35-36 if you drive more conservatively and turned off the A/C. At any rate, I would expect it to be better sligtly better than an xD or Corrolla because it is a ligher vehicle.
ArmstrongRacingThread starterSan Diego · Feb 4, 2016#130So there we have it. The 2zr swap is smog legal(with certification), fast(I won my first autocross with it), fuel efficient, and according to the Corolla/Matrix forum it has no issues aside from sometimes needing a water pump.
CrankyOldManWest Michigan · Feb 4, 2016#131 Originally Posted by
ArmstrongRacing ↑ ...so expect an "average" of 30mpg combined.
Not bad, considering that I get ~27 combined with the supercharger commuting on rural roads (55 mph) with LOTS of WOT action. Damn, now I
really want this for my DD. 😁
tmontagueCaledonia Ont. · Feb 4, 2016#132 Originally Posted by
ArmstrongRacing ↑ So there we have it. The 2zr swap is smog legal(with certification), fast(I won my first autocross with it), fuel efficient, and according to the Corolla/Matrix forum it has no issues aside from sometimes needing a water pump.
What is your experience like in terms of acceleration and how it feels when driving compared to the 1nz? I know the whp increase ~30 or so but I'm curious as to how that feels to the driver. low end torque, wot pulls all that kind of stuff I'm curious about
ArmstrongRacingThread starterSan Diego · Feb 4, 2016#133I wanted a completely unbiased review of the car now having the 2zr....so I casually asked my wife her thoughts and this is her unedited response:
"I have no car intellect so I don't know why you would take a review from me
To my absolute surprise, the car is extraordinarily SMOOTH.
(You know with many changes I've seen cars feel like you walk in to vibrator... ) but you certainly did an incredible job.
The car feels very stable!
You were right when you said you hardly press on the gas and you're at 80.
And since I can tell you, I have felt very comfortable driving it.
It certainly dependably GOES when I need it to, sometimes "the power" still shocks me.. "-Mrs ArmstrongRacing
My review is simply this: Its F-ing awesome, you can feel the additional power and torque more than you would expect, it pulls hard through the gears with ease and no longer even sounds like a yaris. Knowing in the back of your mind that your sitting on a better power/weight ratio than a Celica Gt makes you feel invincible.
tmontagueCaledonia Ont. · Feb 4, 2016#134argh you're making it so much harder for me to stay away from spending the cash on this swap down the road.
TBH If I ever did this swap it'd be more for the experience of swapping an engine and the HP increase would be a bonus. The dependability makes this so much more appealing than going boosted on my 1nz.
How did you end up going about fixing the mating issue between the 2zr header and the mid pipe flange? Also can you run a 2zr MAF sensor and just install it onto a 1nz intake tube (aftermarket intake), or will this mess with the ECU?
Any chance you could create a short separate thread (or a post on here) just briefly outlining what you'd have to do for the swap if you are keeping the Yaris trans and it is a manual? I think a lot of us are in that boat of wanting to do it the cheapest way possible (keeping the Yaris trans) and most of us have a m/t
ArmstrongRacingThread starterSan Diego · Feb 4, 2016#135Post #1 has a list of all the required components to complete this swap.
tmontagueCaledonia Ont. · Feb 4, 2016#136thanks. I just was re reading the thread and noticed you updated it. Your ECU is not the original that came with your motor correct? You purhcased the ECU from an xD and the engine was from a Corolla?
ArmstrongRacingThread starterSan Diego · Feb 4, 2016#137 Originally Posted by
tmontague ↑ You purhcased the ECU from an xD and the engine was from a Corolla?
Correct
CrankyOldManWest Michigan · Feb 4, 2016#138 Originally Posted by
tmontague ↑ thanks. I just was re reading the thread and noticed you updated it. Your ECU is not the original that came with your motor correct? You purhcased the ECU from an xD and the engine was from a Corolla?
The trick for an MT swap is that you have to get the engine wire harness from a manual xD. Those are much harder to find, as they were a much smaller percentage of production. The body side of the ECU won't reach to the engine side of the Corolla/Matrix wire harness since it's next to the air intake/fuse box on the driver's side, whereas the Yaris and xD ECU lives on the passenger side. The alternative is to use the Yaris wire harness and splice the two together. That means taking them both all the way down to the wires, routing everything, and wrapping it back up with cable sleeves and tape.
Everything else from the swap posted here should apply. If you can score the midpipe from an xD, you won't have to have it fitted the way Armstrong did with his Corolla mid pipe.
If you can wait a few months, I'm planning to do this swap on my 09 M/T hatch. If not, you can get pioneer points for leading the charge. =)
tmontagueCaledonia Ont. · Feb 4, 2016#139Hmm, care to explain a bit more about what you mean in regards to splicing in the yaris harness to whatever other harness you're talking about? I'm assuming you're talking about splicing it to a Corolla or Matrix harness however I thought those require much more changes to pin location. Seems like an xD harness is ideal if you can find one.
I'm looking forward to your engine swap, I will very likely be doing this once my 1NZ starts burning oil and dies. Since it's a Toyota this will still be a few years away. But i'm just getting everything understood.
I'm assuming you have an immobilizer as well?
Sounds like your swap would be identical to mine in the future.
ArmstrongRacingThread starterSan Diego · Feb 4, 2016#140I used a Corolla harness, and even though it is designed to end at the battery....you CAN flip the ECM plug harness over the valve cover and mount the Xd ECM to the cowl and then both connectors reach.
Im so glad more people are willing to take on this swap now, If you need ANY help send me a message here or on FB....I will respond
ArmstrongRacingThread starterSan Diego · Feb 5, 2016#141We had a 2010 Corolla get traded in today, so naturally I inspected the engine bay. What I was looking for is cooling system differences vs the Xd, and what I saw was.....nothing really. The Corolla uses the same size radiator the Xd and Yaris does, just with different hose routing and fans.
The Corolla ECM is also much larger than the Xd/Yaris.....
CrankyOldManWest Michigan · Feb 5, 2016#142 Originally Posted by
tmontague ↑ Hmm, care to explain a bit more about what you mean in regards to splicing in the yaris harness to whatever other harness you're talking about? I'm assuming you're talking about splicing it to a Corolla or Matrix harness however I thought those require much more changes to pin location. Seems like an xD harness is ideal if you can find one.
Yes, an xD is ideal, which is why I lead with that. =) Splicing could be done either by removing pins and moving whole sections of wire, or by cutting and soldering/crimping as needed. Moving pins is better since it leaves less chance for loose connections or high internal resistance.
I'm assuming you have an immobilizer as well?
Yes, but as discussed a page or two back, buying a non-immobilizer ECU and disconnecting the SIL wire from the key transponder ECU solves that.
Sounds like your swap would be identical to mine in the future.
Potentially, though your profile pic looks like a sedan, not a hatch.
beakerconyers ga · Feb 5, 2016#143Does anyone know if the Yaris 1nz alternator and ac compressor will work on the 2zrfe? I know Armstrong Racing mentioned earlier that the starter from the Yaris would work, I'm just wondering if the Alternator and AC Compressor would also.
ArmstrongRacingThread starterSan Diego · Feb 5, 2016#144The 2zr uses a 5 rib belt vs the 1nz 3 rib. If there is a way to swap pulleys you can use the 1nz alternator and a/c compressor....
tmontagueCaledonia Ont. · Feb 5, 2016#145Armstrong, how'd you know exactly what pins were what on the Corolla harness so that you could put them the correct way when you moved all the pins to match the fuse box? I'm assuming you had the electrical diagrams from a Corolla?
CoryMWhite Rock BC · Feb 5, 2016#146 Originally Posted by
ArmstrongRacing ↑ The 2zr uses a 5 rib belt vs the 1nz 3 rib. If there is a way to swap pulleys you can use the 1nz alternator and a/c compressor....
I've not looked at the setup, but it may be possible to use the 3 rib belt on the 5 rib pulley. So long as both belts are "PK" belts, the rib spacing is the same. You'd still have to ensure things are lined up nicely.
Cheers.
ArmstrongRacingThread starterSan Diego · Feb 5, 2016#147 Originally Posted by
tmontague ↑ Armstrong, how'd you know exactly what pins were what on the Corolla harness so that you could put them the correct way when you moved all the pins to match the fuse box? I'm assuming you had the electrical diagrams from a Corolla?
Correct. I have ALL of the diagrams for the Yaris, Corolla, and Xd.....And I spent about a week studying and creating wiring instructions for myself...it was not an easy task.
ArmstrongRacingThread starterSan Diego · Feb 5, 2016#148When you get your oil pressure gauge hooked up, you will notice it idles at about 12psi. Dont be alarmed, the 2zr has completely different oil pressure specs from the 1nz.
3.6psi or more at idle
22-58psi at 3000rpm
1 attachment not included in this copy
beakerconyers ga · Feb 5, 2016#149 Originally Posted by
ArmstrongRacing ↑ The 2zr uses a 5 rib belt vs the 1nz 3 rib. If there is a way to swap pulleys you can use the 1nz alternator and a/c compressor....
The alternator shouldn't be a problem, just need an impact wrench to get the pulley off I would imagine, unless it's pressed on. The AC compressor would probably be a little tricky, as they usually require specialty pullers that the average person wouldn't have in their tool box.
I know the water pump pulley is a press on, so changing the 2zrfe to the 1nz 3 rib would probably not work, and I bet the diameter on the water pump shafts aren't the same. Then there's the crank pulley....
Would be better to just source 2zrfe accessories.
MedMantleSouth Africa · Feb 6, 2016#150Here in SA we only have the 1.3l and the 1.8 T-Sport. Originally I wanted to swap to 1.5 but this is definitely looking like a good deal. I am just wondering Armstrong, do you think if I could find a 1.8 T-Sport I could use all the parts from it to do a direct swap? We don't have Scion's here and importing the bits would be costly. But I have to do it, I raced a Corolla last night and just-just lost. It has really sparked interest in this swap :D