How does that compare to other combos that you have run on that car?Originally Posted by tooter ↑Took it for a long drive up north on the 5 freeway (65-80mph) and up to Mt. Pinos and got 42.6 mpg in 248 miles. 🙂
It's ready to dyno now, so when work allows I'll be off to Harry's shop. 👍
tooter's manifold adventure...
1,454 posts · 559,522 views · page 28 of 30
Replies continued
These are the statistics so far...Originally Posted by Flipper_1938 ↑How does that compare to other combos that you have run on that car?
1,931 miles with the stock intake manifold got an average of 35.9mpg.
5,592 miles with the tooter got an average of 36.4mpg
(although that included a full winter of cold weather driving which always yields lower mileage)
248 miles with the tooter et got an average of 42.6mpg
(although that was just one fillup with a lot of high speed freeway miles)
The best prior fillup was 39.1mpg.
(with freeway driving)
I'll post more mileage figures when I rack up enough to be able to get an accurate indicator. And I'll be down at Harry's dyno shop as soon as I can find a break from work. 👍
The mileage increase is astonishing
Well, remember that was just one long trip, and most of it was between 65mph and 80 mph. It'll settle down to a more reasonable average in a little while.
I can say this. The engine runs really good on the freeway, and if I had to hazard a guess why, it would be porting the mouths of the runners. Those rough welds were really overhanging the intakes.
Picture not included in this copy
Picture not included in this copy
The dyno will tell the tale.
All the bullshit ends there. 🙂
I can say this. The engine runs really good on the freeway, and if I had to hazard a guess why, it would be porting the mouths of the runners. Those rough welds were really overhanging the intakes.
Picture not included in this copy
Picture not included in this copy
The dyno will tell the tale.
All the bullshit ends there. 🙂
This is making me think that the 1NZ could benefit from longer intake runners...than oem. Let see what the DYNO says and some more daily driving testing. :)Originally Posted by tooter ↑These are the statistics so far...
1,931 miles with the stock intake manifold got an average of 35.9mpg.
5,592 miles with the tooter got an average of 36.4mpg
(although that included a full winter of cold weather driving which always yields lower mileage)
248 miles with the tooter et got an average of 42.6mpg
(although that was just one fillup with a lot of high speed freeway miles)
The best prior fillup was 39.1mpg.
(with freeway driving)
I'll post more mileage figures when I rack up enough to be able to get an accurate indicator. And I'll be down at Harry's dyno shop as soon as I can find a break from work. 👍
BTW.. Awesome!
Thanks, man. 🙂Originally Posted by JustDidIt ↑This is making me think that the 1NZ could benefit from longer intake runners...than oem. Let see what the DYNO says and some more daily driving testing. :)
BTW.. Awesome!
It's fun experimenting just to see what will happen. The tooter's runners are one inch longer than stock, which is only 5% longer. However, they are oriented completely different than the stock runners in that they look directly at the throttle body like an exhaust header...
Picture not included in this copy
No updates yet I guess...
Sorry, Blue.
I've been distracted with developing another tooter product...
Picture not included in this copy
Picture not included in this copy
And just got the prototype running on my truck today... 🙂
Picture not included in this copy
It made the intake runners 12% longer and really lowered the torque curve. I can slip the clutch in first gear with no gas pedal and the truck doesn't stall out even down to just 400rpm.
The Yaris is running great... 👍
...and It'll be on the dyno soon after we drive it a while to make sure everything gets settled in.
I've been distracted with developing another tooter product...
Picture not included in this copy
Picture not included in this copy
And just got the prototype running on my truck today... 🙂
Picture not included in this copy
It made the intake runners 12% longer and really lowered the torque curve. I can slip the clutch in first gear with no gas pedal and the truck doesn't stall out even down to just 400rpm.
The Yaris is running great... 👍
...and It'll be on the dyno soon after we drive it a while to make sure everything gets settled in.
I cut about half of the bend off of the slilcone coupling to straighten the intake because the air filter didn't need that much bend. So it's all ready to run...
Picture not included in this copy
Just called Harry...
...dyno test is on for Saturday. 🙂
Picture not included in this copy
Just called Harry...
...dyno test is on for Saturday. 🙂
👍 Cool!
...and the Tacoma hits the dyno next week if I can find the free time.
I already did the baseline dyno, so the next one will be with the tooter II.VII. 🙂
I already did the baseline dyno, so the next one will be with the tooter II.VII. 🙂
Sweet!
On the dyno, the tooter et didn't perform any better than the regular tooter, but it didn't perform any worse either. With 111hp and 105tq the graphs are basically the same. So for all my tinkering around, I didn't actually change anything! 😆
Picture not included in this copy
Picture not included in this copy
Tooter, please remind us. How do your fully modded figures compare with "bone stock"?
Thanks, Doug
Thanks, Doug
While it's disappointing to see that there isn't an appreciable improvement, it's certainly unique. Have you considered changing the runner length on a "standard" tooter for comparison?
Here's bone stock dyno runs from the dyno chart sticky thread:Originally Posted by etherdude ↑Tooter, please remind us. How do your fully modded figures compare with "bone stock"?
Thanks, Doug
Picture not included in this copy
The results.
Stock:
91hp
91tq
Tooter:
111hp
105tq
So with:
Intake
Throttle body
Intake manifold
Header
Axle back exhaust
I have 22% more horsepower, and 15% more torque with the stock ECU, no tuning, and regular 87 octane pump gas. Latest gasoline fillup today: 39.4 mpg.
Total cost: $1,350
I'd also add that none of these modifications has altered the basic reliability economy or longevity of the engine. My wife's car is still just a regular daily driver that always needs to be in service.
Now it's just way more fun to drive... 😉
Now it's just way more fun to drive... 😉
Tooter,
I would estimate you have optimized the volumetric efficiency of this particular air pump. A gain of 20 hp at the wheels is awesome. Without changes to cam timing, fuel map, and injectors (meaning access to the ECU), I cannot imagine there is anything left in a naturally aspirated Yaris. Think about it...your at the crank hp is pushing 125+.
I would estimate you have optimized the volumetric efficiency of this particular air pump. A gain of 20 hp at the wheels is awesome. Without changes to cam timing, fuel map, and injectors (meaning access to the ECU), I cannot imagine there is anything left in a naturally aspirated Yaris. Think about it...your at the crank hp is pushing 125+.
That bone stock dyno chart is not your car, correct? There will be natural variation in that number (note the 93 degree temps for example, warm day!) You've been a big proponent of posting charts for the same car, under the same conditions, on the same dyno, which are awesome when someone bothers to do it, as you have.
The before and after tooter dynos were especially helpful. 🙂
Tooter, how did you get the car to rev to 6500? I thought stock rev limit (as shown on the stock dyno) was 6250.
I'm also not sure the difference between SAE and STD smoothing -- anyone know?
The before and after tooter dynos were especially helpful. 🙂
Tooter, how did you get the car to rev to 6500? I thought stock rev limit (as shown on the stock dyno) was 6250.
I'm also not sure the difference between SAE and STD smoothing -- anyone know?
The stock rev limiter is 6,500rpm.Originally Posted by cali yaris ↑That bone stock dyno chart is not your car, correct? There will be natural variation in that number (note the 93 degree temps for example, warm day!) You've been a big proponent of posting charts for the same car, under the same conditions, on the same dyno, which are awesome when someone bothers to do it, as you have.
The before and after tooter dynos were especially helpful. 🙂
Tooter, how did you get the car to rev to 6500? I thought stock rev limit (as shown on the stock dyno) was 6250.
I'm also not sure the difference between SAE and STD smoothing -- anyone know?
I know nothing about the electronics and so chose to leave them totally untouched while focusing solely on the physical aspects.Originally Posted by etherdude ↑Tooter,
I would estimate you have optimized the volumetric efficiency of this particular air pump. A gain of 20 hp at the wheels is awesome. Without changes to cam timing, fuel map, and injectors (meaning access to the ECU), I cannot imagine there is anything left in a naturally aspirated Yaris. Think about it...your at the crank hp is pushing 125+.
And the dyno runs tell only part of the story. In normal daily operation nothing was conceded to drivability or to getting excellent gas mileage. I believe this is because I didn't alter the factory electronic engine management and instead turned my attention to the issue of flow. 🙂
The other side is that there isn't any appreciable loss either, so it's break even. The et wasn't intended for sale anyways as it takes way too much work to build one. It was just to satisfy my own curiosity.Originally Posted by CrankyOldMan ↑While it's disappointing to see that there isn't an appreciable improvement, it's certainly unique.
Have you considered changing the runner length on a "standard" tooter for comparison?Yes, I'm considering longer runners and also a larger plenum using the et as a test bed for further experiments. This stuff is as addictive as crack. You're always asking yourself... well, what else can I do? 😉
That's impressive considering you haven't modified any electronics and let the stock ECU make any corrections.Originally Posted by tooter ↑
So with:
Intake
Throttle body
Intake manifold
Header
Axle back exhaust
I have 22% more horsepower, and 15% more torque with the stock ECU, no tuning, and regular 87 octane pump gas. Latest gasoline fillup today: 39.4 mpg.
Total cost: $1,350
Tooter, I really plan on coming up in the next 2 wks or so. I'd like to meet up and talk with you about my ideas for my 1NZ-FXE. It includes a few items like the ones below...
Picture not included in this copy
Picture not included in this copy
Sounds like fun! 🙂Originally Posted by JustDidIt ↑That's impressive considering you haven't modified any electronics and let the stock ECU make any corrections.
Tooter, I really plan on coming up in the next 2 wks or so. I'd like to meet up and talk with you about my ideas for my 1NZ-FXE. It includes a few items like the ones below...
Picture not included in this copy
Picture not included in this copy
PM me in advance before you come so that I can set some time aside from work, and we can explore the possibilities. Oh oh, stainless. That's a lot harder to work with than aluminum. But it's still buildable material. 🙂
Greg
This should be interesting....
It should be. 🙂 The Prius engine operates within different parameters than the Yaris engine does.
I would also like to know about this.Originally Posted by cali yaris ↑That bone stock dyno chart is not your car, correct?
Different Dyno?
Different Day(Humidity/Temp)?
Different Car?
Different Altitude?
Post 1375 is at HK MotorSports in CA
Post 1378 is at Keith's Pit Stop in PA
I picked the other dyno run because it had higher results than this one, but since you asked, here's a stock dyno run from the same shop and the same dyno machine.Originally Posted by YotaYaris ↑I would also like to know about this.
Different Dyno?
Different Day(Humidity/Temp)?
Different Car?
Different Altitude?
Post 1375 is at HK MotorSports in CA
Post 1378 is at Keith's Pit Stop in PA
Picture not included in this copy
With the stock engine making 106 at the output shaft, 15 horsepower in drive train losses seems to be the norm.
I believe that the first two charts are of auto transmissions, so manual transmissions would naturally have less drivetrain losses. So you can spot them a few more horsepower if they were manuals.
Interestingly enough, we had the same issue with information dropping out on the graphs, but resolved it by grounding the chassis to a bolt in the concrete floor. 👍
Here's another with intake and exhaust mods for comparison.
Picture not included in this copy
These are all posted in the dyno thread sticky in this section. It's an interesting read. 🙂
Another tooter rolled off the assembly line... 🙂
Picture not included in this copy
It's available on ebay for $545 with free shipping.
The tooter Build Your Own Intake Manifold Kits are also available on ebay for $295 with free shipping...
Picture not included in this copy
Picture not included in this copy
It's available on ebay for $545 with free shipping.
The tooter Build Your Own Intake Manifold Kits are also available on ebay for $295 with free shipping...
Picture not included in this copy
I would like to know how you have come to this conclusion? I wouldn't go totally off the tach that you are showing if that is your evidence. I have had several dyno runs and the software logging without a shadow of a doubt that 6250 is indeed where the stock ECU begins to force the AFR into a serious lean condition which is how Toyota actually "rev" limits as opposed to other methods. 🙂Originally Posted by mario98c ↑The stock rev limiter is 6,500rpm.
I don't know what post that's from but on my Echo it is indeed 6500rpm. It's different between models.
So after close to 1400 posts I guess my question is what does this intake actually gain someone? if HP/TQ are negligible are we talking an FE gain at this point? I apologize, but with this many posts even digging back on a couple hundred can be muddled. 🙂
The PR spec cars might be. The PR spec '03 HB I drove a long time ago had a 6700 redline.
^ very good and valid point! I had forgotten that. 🎉
I'll test and video JR's car today. We should be able to hear the fuel cut at 6250... or 6500.. or 6700... 😆
I'm pretty sure the rev limit is 6250, That's the only number that's ever corresponded with my data. 60 MPH in 2nd gear is all I've ever seen with my race tires.
Picture not included in this copy
lol, sorry guys, couldn't resist with the talk about the redline. hahahaha
lol, sorry guys, couldn't resist with the talk about the redline. hahahaha
Just these modest gains and about 2mpg. That's it. It's not a miracle product, just an intake manifold that allows running a larger throttle body. It's primary advantage is excellent throttle response and some improved fuel economy without ruining the reliability of the engine.Originally Posted by fnkngrv ↑So after close to 1400 posts I guess my question is what does this intake actually gain someone? if HP/TQ are negligible are we talking an FE gain at this point?
If you want lots of power you need to buy a forced induction system. Keep your eyes open for a used one. A lot of them end up being resold.
red: stock manifold with 46mm throttle body
blue: tooter manifold with 46mm throttle body
green: tooter manifold with 55mm throttle body
Picture not included in this copy
I apologize, but with this many posts even digging back on a couple hundred can be muddled. 🙂No problem. 🙂
You have your complete answer in just this one post.
Greg
The stock rev limiter on my 2012 cuts off at 6,600.Originally Posted by fnkngrv ↑I would like to know how you have come to this conclusion? I wouldn't go totally off the tach that you are showing if that is your evidence. I have had several dyno runs and the software logging without a shadow of a doubt that 6250 is indeed where the stock ECU begins to force the AFR into a serious lean condition which is how Toyota actually "rev" limits as opposed to other methods. 🙂
If I were still modding my sedan, I'd probably go with the Tooter and the 1ZZ TB based on the torque curve in that dyno graph (I do most of my driving from 2k-3.5k).
I'd probably go with the Tooter and the 1ZZ TB based on the torque curve in that dyno graph (I do most of my driving from 2k-3.5k)doesn't that dyno show it making whatever power it makes at 3500 and up? 🤷
green line?
Yeah, green line. I kinda disregarded anything past 4k as I'm rarely ever past 4k unless merging on the freeway. lol. Any bump in torque below 3.5k is a plus, but I do see that it does lose some torque around 2.1k.Originally Posted by cali yaris ↑doesn't that dyno show it making whatever power it makes at 3500 and up? 🤷
green line?
The torque curve dips below stock at 2,200rpm and peaks above stock an equal amount at 2,400rpm. I'm sure it's because the manifold isn't specifically tuned to the engine, so it has an uneven curve. And that's at wide open throttle, under normal partial throttle driving conditions that extreme effect is not felt.Originally Posted by Kaotic Lazagna ↑Any bump in torque below 3.5k is a plus, but I do see that it does lose some torque around 2.1k.
I posted the dyno runs warts and all and let the chips fall where they may so that everyone here can see for themselves and decide for themselves because its dishonest to make claims without providing any proof of them.
It's not like I'll be at 2.2k rpm for very long 😆 😉Originally Posted by tooter ↑The torque curve dips below stock at 2,200rpm and peaks above stock an equal amount at 2,400rpm. I'm sure it's because the manifold isn't specifically tuned to the engine, so it has an uneven curve. And that's at wide open throttle, under normal partial throttle driving conditions that extreme effect is not felt.
I posted the dyno runs warts and all and let the chips fall where they may so that everyone here can see for themselves and decide for themselves because its dishonest to make claims without providing any proof of them.
I'm sure with the Tooter, SRI, 1ZZ TB, a header, and a 2" cat-back exhaust, it'll have a nice low end torque increase over stock 🙂
Tooter's next manifold adventure is already off the ground.
Picture not included in this copy
Picture not included in this copy
Picture not included in this copy
Picture not included in this copy
By making the runners 12% longer, the intake manifold spacer lowered the torque peak by 2,500 rpm down to just 2,900 rpm.
Picture not included in this copy
The first production run begins as soon as we find a good source of nylon blocks. 🙂
Gonna be occupied for a while with this project, but when things slow down, I might try having one of these made for the Yaris, just to see how it works. 😉
Picture not included in this copy
Picture not included in this copy
Picture not included in this copy
Picture not included in this copy
By making the runners 12% longer, the intake manifold spacer lowered the torque peak by 2,500 rpm down to just 2,900 rpm.
Picture not included in this copy
The first production run begins as soon as we find a good source of nylon blocks. 🙂
Gonna be occupied for a while with this project, but when things slow down, I might try having one of these made for the Yaris, just to see how it works. 😉
Pretty cool!
This netted 2hp and 2 torque, a 1.5% gain. Easy mod to install, not too bad.
1.5% on a Yaris would be about 1-1.3 hp I think if it were proportional?
1.5% on a Yaris would be about 1-1.3 hp I think if it were proportional?
You missed the point, Garm... 😉
It doesn't make gains. It moves the torque curve lower in rpms. The stock Tacoma 2.7 engine's torque peaks at 3,800 rpm. With an LCE long tube header and this intake manifold spacer, the torque peak is reached at just 2,900 rpm... without reducing the peak value.
The speed limiter cut the engine off on those 4th gear runs, but it didn't matter as it was just to get the low end torque readings.
It doesn't make gains. It moves the torque curve lower in rpms. The stock Tacoma 2.7 engine's torque peaks at 3,800 rpm. With an LCE long tube header and this intake manifold spacer, the torque peak is reached at just 2,900 rpm... without reducing the peak value.
The speed limiter cut the engine off on those 4th gear runs, but it didn't matter as it was just to get the low end torque readings.