Replies continued
ddongbaphay · Dec 4, 2009#151LLLO U HAVE A EVO.
LOL @ EVOS. HAHAHAHAHA
Jk. I'm just jealous. =[
YarisSedanCalifornia - Bay Area · Dec 4, 2009#152 Originally Posted by
Loren ↑ AND129, I think you know this by the fact that you mentioned being careful not to lift the car at this point, but it's worth mentioning for the sake of others that putting a jack under the center of the beam axle is a bad idea. It can be bent in that manner.
Neat that you were able to do this without pulling the shock bolts and removing the springs. Probably a toss-up as to which way is actually easier. (only two bolts to drop the shocks and it should make the whole process of fitting those pivot bolts a lot easier)
I would highly reccomend removing the shock bolts. I tried to do this without doing so being lazy and it costed me 30 minutes of fighting with the bolt hole and cursing and after simply just removing the shock bolts and taking out the springs it was bolted in place a few minutes later. Because of the tension one side of the bushing will line up while the other will not. I was able to get one in without removing the bolts but required assistance of another person usinga pry bar to get the inner bushing lined up while i jammed in the bolt from the outer side.
AND189australia · Dec 4, 2009#153as i said i had no problems simple unbolt jack up bolt on that is the way i did it but if you think your way is easy go for it ether way once its done it is off tap
AND189australia · Dec 4, 2009#154ddongbap
LLLO U HAVE A EVO.
LOL @ EVOS. HAHAHAHAHA
Jk. I'm just jealous. =
ha ha as i said it is my dads new toy he seams to get a new one every year nice car though only problem it is full of computers and shit ... nice car but i would not get one :)
kngrsllSpartanburg, SC · Dec 4, 2009#155i didnt unbolt the springs or shocks either. i did one side and then the other with two separate jacks.
AND189australia · Dec 4, 2009#156 i didnt unbolt the springs or shocks either. i did one side and then the other with two separate jacks
Hi five
AND189australia · Dec 4, 2009#157Ok well i just took my car on dirt road and it is like the back wheels are on ice they are just so taily good fun
docBWestern N.Y. · Dec 9, 2009#158I can not really comment about a change in toe or camber, seems like they couldn't go too far off given the amount the axel pivot will move. The real deal here is the roll center. A dynamic point that the rear suspension seems to move around. Moving a suspension pivot point like this definitely changes that roll center. That relates to anti squat and has a BFD effect on suspenstion action and overall handling. This change is really several in one shot. Toe, camber (in the rear this also is called anti-squat), and the roll center. Changing the roll center's height will also change the roll axis. This means it changes how the front suspension relates to overall handling. I know you all want learn more about suspension design. Read some books so that you can learn more about this stuff. An author Fred Puhn wrote How to Make Your Car Handle. Lots of good easy to understand info. Most bok stores have it.
doc
I'll try it soon.
BrentoriusMelbourne, FL · Dec 25, 2009#159Any updates on interferences with this mod? It seems to correct the rear alignment after lowering.
I am going to be swapping in new shocks next week and can easily do this while everything is off.
YarisSedanCalifornia - Bay Area · Dec 25, 2009#160I just learned to adjust my driving to prevent the clunking sound. I looked at my gas tank the other day theres some scratches on either side but cant say for sure that could have been from when i removed my upper tie bar brace.
advocatelocation · Dec 25, 2009#161I say paint the gas tank and look for new scratches after hearing the clunking sound
fmicleSan Jose, CA, USA · Dec 26, 2009#162I bought a hydraulic jack a couple of weeks back and while I was trying it out I decided to take a look at that. From what I've seen, without taking the springs off though, I believe the axle can't really hit the tank, there seems to be a well designed groove where the axle swivels and it didn't seem to me like it could hit anything under there. Also I've had 2 more adults in the car since I lowered it and I can hear the clunks, but I bet it's just the springs, nothing else...
lilredrocketDFW, Texas · Dec 27, 2009#163I believe it is hitting on the exhaust. I will put my car up on a rack this week and see if I can tell where some rubbing has happened.
YarisSedanCalifornia - Bay Area · Dec 27, 2009#164Well i do know that my tie bar that i had bolted to the gas tank was getting hit hard by the rear beam and put a bit of scratches in it. After removing it the clunking got 95 percent better. But the fact that i heard somethign still i assumed it was something in that area that was getting hit still.
It could be possible it could be the springs fully compressing.
BrentoriusMelbourne, FL · Dec 30, 2009#165I relocated the rear suspension today along with upgrading to Tokico blues.... no issues thus far and will report with rear alignment numbers next week.
ddongbaphay · Dec 31, 2009#166Some one should get 200 lbs in the rear, and find alignment numbers.
BrentoriusMelbourne, FL · Dec 31, 2009#167I heard some clunking today during a sharp turn at low speeds to the left. The noise seemed to come from the rear drivers side. I am going to look tomorrow to see what it could be hitting...
mojoyarisVancouver · Dec 31, 2009#168Just curious. For those of you who are experiencing clunking in the back.
What is your suspension setup?
Lowering springs with stock dampeners
Lowering springs with stiffer dampening
Coilovers w/ two finger width gap from fender well to tire
Coilovers slammed!
Stock ride height....
YarisSedanCalifornia - Bay Area · Dec 31, 2009#169im running trd springs on stock struts i only get the clunking noise on hard potholes or gonig over speedbumps too fast
lunjiaowPerth, Australia. · Jan 1, 2010#170i just did this adjustment too. I get clunking noises on every bump i go over with 4 people in the car. My problem is the rear sway bar holder hitting the fuel tank. I am running Whiteline sway bar setup so it is different to UR and TRD swaybars. Will check it out tomorrow to see what i can do about it. Otherwise i will put it back to where it was. But driving i do feel a difference, much smoother when driving in straights, dont hear the wheels scrubbing.
detroiterMetro Detroit · Jan 1, 2010#171I used to hear the clunking as well but lately I havn't heard it at all. I'm not really sure what happened but it's non existent now.
lunjiaowPerth, Australia. · Jan 2, 2010#172Well had a look at the rear swaybar holders. They hit my fuel tank (has scratch marks), so i adjusted them to the sides equally and no more clunking sounds. I have at least 2cm clearance in between beam and fuel tank..
detroiterMetro Detroit · Jan 2, 2010#173rear sway bar holders?
cali yarisCanoga Park, CA · Jan 2, 2010#174there are no rear sway bar bushings on the Yaris? 🤷
LorenSafety Harbor, FL · Jan 2, 2010#175Look a couple posts up, he has a Whiteline rear bar.
fmicleSan Jose, CA, USA · Jan 4, 2010#176I started hearing the clunking sounds ever since I installed the new springs (Progress, 1.4" drop) and shocks (Tokico blues). I shortened the bump stops by about half an inch in the back and about 1 inch in the front. Right after the install I took it for a ride and heard the clunks while going over the driveway curb. I thought the coils needed to set in. After that, nothing for more than a month. Then I had 2 adults in the car, one in the front, one in the back and heard the same sounds again a few times. I checked under the car and couldn't see anything bad, no rubbing, no scratching. I don't see how the sway bar could hit anything, since mine (Ultra Racing) is installed right under the axle...
I believe the clunking comes from the fact that my Progress coils are different than the stock ones, the first 3 spirals sit on top of each other so there is more contact between the coils thus, more potential for clunking noise...
evo165*tIny dOts iN AsiA* · Jan 4, 2010#177 Originally Posted by
fmicle ↑ I started hearing the clunking sounds ever since I installed the new springs (Progress, 1.4" drop) and shocks (Tokico blues). I shortened the bump stops by about half an inch in the back and about 1 inch in the front. Right after the install I took it for a ride and heard the clunks while going over the driveway curb. I thought the coils needed to set in. After that, nothing for more than a month. Then I had 2 adults in the car, one in the front, one in the back and heard the same sounds again a few times. I checked under the car and couldn't see anything bad, no rubbing, no scratching. I don't see how the sway bar could hit anything, since mine (Ultra Racing) is installed right under the axle...
I believe the clunking comes from the fact that my Progress coils are different than the stock ones, the first 3 spirals sit on top of each other so there is more contact between the coils thus, more potential for clunking noise...
I'll say put it back to the original position (lower pivot point and then problem solved) I put it back on mine and it "comfort' level is back & there is no longer any strange sound fro the rear. 😁
lunjiaowPerth, Australia. · Jan 4, 2010#178 Originally Posted by
evo165 ↑ I'll say put it back to the original position (lower pivot point and then problem solved) I put it back on mine and it "comfort' level is back & there is no longer any strange sound fro the rear. 😁
Yep, i too did the same. Would rather not have a hole in my fuel tank =)
detroiterMetro Detroit · Jan 4, 2010#179Not sure the clunking could come from hitting the gas tank with the axle. Not sure how a metal axle beam and a plastic gas tank could equal "clunk" if they hit together. Anyone find out something definitive on what the clunk could be? Like I said, when I first did the mod I heard some clunking over big bumps and such, but even know when I run over big bumps, I don't hear it anymore. It ended up going away. Just not sure what could have happened. The car handles too good and feels great to want to put it back to the lower position
BrentoriusMelbourne, FL · Jan 4, 2010#180Today I jacked up the yaris with the rear tires off and did not see any scratches on the gas tank. I did not see any interference issues with the suspension either (at full sag). I then individually compressed each side with another jack and can not see where it would be hitting. I haven't heard any odd noises in a while, but the tein springs are very compressed at static ride height and maybe the noise is the coils? There are about 6 coils touching.
fmicleSan Jose, CA, USA · Jan 4, 2010#181Yep, that's what I think as well, the noise must come from the coils themselves and not from the axle touching anything. The Toyota engineers who designed this could not have overseen such a simple thing...
If you think about it, by moving the pivot point up, you are actually increasing the distance of the axle from the gas tank, which is above the pivot point. I am personally not worried about any damage with this configuration, but whenever I'll have some time I will jack up the car, remove the springs and the shocks and try to swing the axle all the way to see if it could theoretically hit anywhere, just like Loren suggested a while ago. Until then I'm not losing any sleep over this 🙂
Another thing that crossed my mind: if you think about it, the springs are not compressed between two parallel planes (as they are in the front), but they are compressed between two planes at an angle. I'll try to illustrate this in a drawing below. What I'm trying to say is that if you push the spring straight forward, it's unlikely that the coils will slip or otherwise rub unevenly, but if you compress the spring at a certain angle, you may get some slipping - hence the clunking noise. By moving the axle up that angle will increase considerably, I was actually thinking how come the springs stay in there and don't just snap out 🙂
I have exaggerated the angles in my drawing to make the point, because I believe depending on the drop, moving the pivot point up is just a necessary correction. If the spring drop is less than the distance between the two pivot points, then the angle will be slightly increased (or decreased if you measure it against the vertical).
Picture not included in this copy
BrentoriusMelbourne, FL · Jan 4, 2010#182When I first relocated the pivot point, I moved the axle through its range of motion to free up the bushings before I installed the shocks. I did not see any problems...
LorenSafety Harbor, FL · Jan 5, 2010#183 Originally Posted by
Brentorius ↑ When I first relocated the pivot point, I moved the axle through its range of motion to free up the bushings before I installed the shocks. I did not see any problems...
This is what I suggested that someone do a few weeks ago. Answers the clearance question definitively. If you were able to completely bottom out the suspension without hitting anything, then there is no clearance issue.
evo165*tIny dOts iN AsiA* · Jan 5, 2010#184 Originally Posted by
fmicle ↑ Yep, that's what I think as well, the noise must come from the coils themselves and not from the axle touching anything. The Toyota engineers who designed this could not have overseen such a simple thing...
If you think about it, by moving the pivot point up, you are actually increasing the distance of the axle from the gas tank, which is above the pivot point. I am personally not worried about any damage with this configuration, but whenever I'll have some time I will jack up the car, remove the springs and the shocks and try to swing the axle all the way to see if it could theoretically hit anywhere, just like Loren suggested a while ago. Until then I'm not losing any sleep over this 🙂
Another thing that crossed my mind: if you think about it, the springs are not compressed between two parallel planes (as they are in the front), but they are compressed between two planes at an angle. I'll try to illustrate this in a drawing below. What I'm trying to say is that if you push the spring straight forward, it's unlikely that the coils will slip or otherwise rub unevenly, but if you compress the spring at a certain angle, you may get some slipping - hence the clunking noise. By moving the axle up that angle will increase considerably, I was actually thinking how come the springs stay in there and don't just snap out 🙂
I have exaggerated the angles in my drawing to make the point, because I believe depending on the drop, moving the pivot point up is just a necessary correction. If the spring drop is less than the distance between the two pivot points, then the angle will be slightly increased (or decreased if you measure it against the vertical).
Picture not included in this copy
Bingo on the springs. As i mentioned it on my Tokico structs thread(post number 7). 😉
Review of Tokico Blues with Tanabe NF springs detroiterMetro Detroit · Jan 5, 2010#185So I'm wondering what others opinions are on if you keep the springs tightened up while you have it in the upper bolt position for quite some time, if you decide to lower it back to the lower bolt position will the springs return to their standard stiffness and reaction or will the springs be permanently compressed because of being tightened down for so long from being in the upper position?
In other words, will the springs rate and reaction be ruined because of being compressed for so long? Almost like if you take a slinkee and stretch it out too much, it never returns to it's original state. But this case being the opposite. Being compressed for so long, maybe it won't return to it's normal state?
docBWestern N.Y. · Jan 6, 2010#186The spring rate is determined by material properties, number of coils, diameter of the coils, diameter of the wire. Some think color makes a giant difference but that is for another post... Moving the beam may cause a slight change in installation height, but the spring rate will remain constant.
ozmddDFW, TX · Jan 19, 2010#187To answer an earlier question about setup, I am running NF210's on OEM struts/shocks w/ a TRD sway bar. The clunking never went away after several months, but closer inspection seems to indicate that the "clunking" is primarily within the springs themselves (as speculated by several posters), and possibly at the swaybar mount, though that is hard to say since road crap keeps interfering. We have some good weather now, so I'm going to put it through some rough roads and sharp curves later today and immediately lift it and inspect for marks after chalking the supected rub areas.
I'm installing coilovers this week after that test, so its a bit of a moot point, but others may find the info useful.
I AM positive that the axle is free of interference throughout its full range of motion, unlike what I initially thought.
Performance-wise, there is no doubt that this improves turn-in for autocross situations. I was very inpressed with the results at this weekend's event, even on cold tires/concrete.
fmicleSan Jose, CA, USA · Jan 19, 2010#188 Originally Posted by
docB ↑ The spring rate is determined by material properties, number of coils, diameter of the coils, diameter of the wire. Some think color makes a giant difference but that is for another post... Moving the beam may cause a slight change in installation height, but the spring rate will remain constant.
+1, I don't agree that the springs are more compressed with the axle beam moved up. The are just compressed at a different angle and the forces acting on them are slightly different. It's the weight of the car that compresses the springs, not the position of the axle beam...
fmicleSan Jose, CA, USA · Jan 30, 2010#189I was going to replace my rear brake lines today, so I had the wheels off and noticed this. I don't know if it has anything to do with this suspension mod, since I'd think this is rather affected by the length of the springs, more than the axle geometry, but I might be wrong. Anyway, it's probably good to keep this in mind. I suspect this happened only a few weeks ago when I took a longer trip with 4 adults in the car, since the damage is not too bad. You may just want to check this from time to time when you happen to be under there.
On the positive side, I saw absolutely no contact with the gas tank and just a very tiny tiny contact point on the exhaust pipe 😉
Right hand side:
Picture not included in this copy
Picture not included in this copy
Picture not included in this copy
Left hand side:
Picture not included in this copy
Picture not included in this copy
detroiterMetro Detroit · Jan 31, 2010#190I never noticed that under there, which line is that?
LorenSafety Harbor, FL · Jan 31, 2010#191Brake line!
Doesn't look like enough contact to be a problem, especially if it only happens with 4 people in the car, but it warrants further attention. I'll give my car a close look next time I'm under there. (it's in the stock axle configuration with lowering springs... but it's not super-low, and the springs are really stiff, so I suspect I won't see any rubbing on mine)
fmicleSan Jose, CA, USA · Jan 31, 2010#192^ What springs do you have Loren? I have the Progress, I think they have a 1.4" drop, both front and back.
I was thinking about gluing some rubber piece, like a bump stop or something to the frame, to prevent the axle from traveling all the way, what do you think, could that work?
LorenSafety Harbor, FL · Jan 31, 2010#193I have non-standard springs that were never intended to be on a Yaris. :) Leftovers from my Miata.
Yeah, some sort of bump stop would help. There should be a factory bump stop. Usually fitted around the shaft of the shock. You might check to see if yours are still there and that they weren't cut during the spring install. In any case, you could replace them with a longer bump stop. Progress makes a variety of them, but I don't have any more detail than that.
fmicleSan Jose, CA, USA · Feb 1, 2010#194Well, I did the install myself and if I remember correctly, the rear bump stops were not too long to begin with. I still cut a little bit, I'd say maybe one third of the original length. Here are the leftover pieces:
Picture not included in this copy
These might have just enough thickness to prevent that little bit of scraping and rubbing of the line on the frame. I could probably glue them back on if only I could find them... I think I kept them though... :)
docBWestern N.Y. · Feb 1, 2010#195Anyone see how the car reacts under extreme braking before and after with this modification? Does the anti-lock kick in more?
ozmddDFW, TX · Feb 2, 2010#196No change in braking response that I can detect, and I have done several track day and autox's, so I've tested under pretty drastic braking. 🙂
I don't have ABS, so can't help you there.
Maitre_Te_TeThread starterQuébec · Feb 2, 2010#197My rear suspension mod progress!!!! :)
Lil AbnerDublin, Ohio · Mar 17, 2011#198BUMP!
Has anyone had any long-term experience with this? The thread seemed to have died off before any long-term experience was given.
cali yarisCanoga Park, CA · Mar 17, 2011#199No problems here, been a year now I think?
If you ever did have a problem you can put it back.
Lil AbnerDublin, Ohio · Mar 17, 2011#200Cool, thanks! Just wanted to get some more feedback before I try it.