what kind of boost levels were you running and for how long? help the 1NZ community outOriginally Posted by richardholdener ↑Unfortunately we lost a rod while running higher boost levels and .
Yaris Intake Manifold
201 posts · 92,195 views · page 3 of 5
Replies continued
I am helping the community out by findin gout exactly what caused the probelm before jumping on the speculation bandwagon. The boost level did not hurt the motor nor the length of time spent at any given boost level. There had to be some type of ignition error that that resulted in excessive timing. We are looking into this and will report if we find the answer.
Originally Posted by Tamago ↑what kind of boost levels were you running and for how long? help the 1NZ community out
got any pictures? Did the rod just break, bearings/melted piston?.... The H22 i have overspun the bearing and it popped a nice hole in the block...
ok i guess that's a non answer ;) stock 1NZ rods break on fully stock xA/B's due to high RPM's for extended periods of time. toyota fixed this by giving you Yaris people taller gears (better highway cruising) ..Originally Posted by richardholdener ↑I am helping the community out by findin gout exactly what caused the probelm before jumping on the speculation bandwagon. The boost level did not hurt the motor nor the length of time spent at any given boost level. There had to be some type of ignition error that that resulted in excessive timing. We are looking into this and will report if we find the answer.
if you read the write-up done by elprototypes on boosting the 1NZ the rods are the first things to go. the engine is over-square and offset crank which causes piston slap (which is obviously made worse by boost) and ultimately rod failure. there is no "speculation bandwagon" on the 1NZ.. it's been around almost 10 years..
is this your first 1NZ vehicle, Richard?
I think by speculation bandwagon, he meant he's not going to speculate about his particular car within the context of what caused the failure. It is interesting that his failed under less than extremely stressful conditions, while mine has not failed after six months of driving at 8psi without any tuning whatsoever.
So, whatever he finds out will be interesting. A pic of the rod would sure be entertaining, in the meantime.
So, whatever he finds out will be interesting. A pic of the rod would sure be entertaining, in the meantime.
don't mind him, he's just our resident scion ass paper who thinks his knowledge is helpful.....Originally Posted by Tamago ↑ok i guess that's a non answer ;) stock 1NZ rods break on fully stock xA/B's due to high RPM's for extended periods of time. toyota fixed this by giving you Yaris people taller gears (better highway cruising) ..
if you read the write-up done by elprototypes on boosting the 1NZ the rods are the first things to go. the engine is over-square and offset crank which causes piston slap (which is obviously made worse by boost) and ultimately rod failure. there is no "speculation bandwagon" on the 1NZ.. it's been around almost 10 years..
is this your first 1NZ vehicle, Richard?
Originally Posted by ROCKLAND TOYOTA ↑don't mind him, he's just our resident scion ass paper who thinks his knowledge is helpful.....
better than being ignorant like you
Thanks Rockland for the insight on the previous post regarding con rods-it is appreciated. Piston slap, offset crank pins-where do these guys come up with this stuff? I can remember when the light clicked on for me, the day that I realized that I didn't know everything and in fact knew very little. That is the day I officially started learning. Unfortunately, people put forth much more effort convincing others of their knowledge than actually obtaining it. For the record-Rod failure is caused by tension loads (rpm), extreme compression loads (detonation or extremely high power levels) or fatigue cycle life (extended operation near fatigue). Since none of the other situations were present-we must suspect detonation as the culprit, but will perform a post mortem to see if there is any evidence. The 1NZFE rods do not fail by design, neither did the Honda rods or small block Ford rods or any of the many powdered metal production rods-the culprit has almost always been a tuning error. There is a limit to the power production with the production rods, but since (in the case of this yaris) we were nowhere near that absolute power limit
Originally Posted by ROCKLAND TOYOTA ↑don't mind him, he's just our resident scion ass paper who thinks his knowledge is helpful.....
so explain this:Originally Posted by richardholdener ↑The 1NZFE rods do not fail by design
Picture not included in this copy
Picture not included in this copy
Picture not included in this copy
Picture not included in this copy
Picture not included in this copy
Picture not included in this copy
on a stock engine, stock ecu, intake, exhaust, bone dry day (so dont' even say it was hydrolock) at 85mph (over 4300rpm) about 80F ambient temperature, engine had 47,000 miles on it.
the 1NZ is not designed to rev above 4000rpm for extended periods of time.
😆 ass paper.....Originally Posted by Tamago ↑
better than being ignorant like you
hey, at least i didn't put spaghetti with bendy ends between my seatbelt bolts and call it a suspension mod ;)Originally Posted by ROCKLAND TOYOTA ↑😆 ass paper.....
better than that video of you with the bald tires. what a waste of 5 minutes that was.....Originally Posted by Tamago ↑hey, at least i didn't put spaghetti with bendy ends between my seatbelt bolts and call it a suspension mod ;)
you think?Originally Posted by ROCKLAND TOYOTA ↑better than that video of you with the bald tires. what a waste of 5 minutes that was.....
a video of a car that could rape you in its sleep, on tires 50mm wider than you'll ever be able to run, with twice the power you'll ever see is worse than spaghetti and bendy ends.. that you could build from home depot or hrpworld.com for around $12... at least it's shiney with a cool sticker on it (no offense to you Garm)
GENTLEMEN!!!! CUT THE SHIT
i'm done..Originally Posted by Nexus1155 ↑GENTLEMEN!!!! CUT THE SHIT
i came here to ask richard H a legit question
Rockland started it ;)
hahah sorry, but i had to intervene, don't want Richard taking away the manifolds
No worries about the intake situation--and I respect people having and voicing their opinion(this is what makes America great). I just wish they would not be so quick to draw absolute conclusions from such small samples (the equivalent of automotive bigotry). One or even two damaged con rods does not mean all NZFE rods are bad. Honda guys thought this too, but since I ran stock B16s in endurance racing where we ran 8200 rpm for 24 hours, not to mention producing over 500 hp in turbo form, I'd say the weak con rod theory was just that. FYI-Engine testing at the OEM level includes running the motor for 24 hour periods and ranging the engine speed from peak torque to peak horsepower. This is done at 1/4 throttle, 1/2 throttle, 3/4 throttle and then at WOT to endurance test the reciprocating assembly. I personally have run my Yaris in 4th gear from Vegas to So Cal and back (mileage testing for my book) and run it flat out 114 mph for almost 9 straight miles. This combined with the hundreds of dyno tests run to the rev limiter under WOT shows me that (as has been their history) Toyota over and not underbuilds their vehicles.
Originally Posted by Nexus1155 ↑hahah sorry, but i had to intervene, don't want Richard taking away the manifolds
over and not underbuilds their vehicles
Well said!
Well said!
Can we, can we all get along?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aMfr2CgIPhg
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aMfr2CgIPhg
1 attachment not included in this copy
all that said, you threw a rod 🤷Originally Posted by richardholdener ↑No worries about the intake situation--and I respect people having and voicing their opinion(this is what makes America great). I just wish they would not be so quick to draw absolute conclusions from such small samples (the equivalent of automotive bigotry). One or even two damaged con rods does not mean all NZFE rods are bad. Honda guys thought this too, but since I ran stock B16s in endurance racing where we ran 8200 rpm for 24 hours, not to mention producing over 500 hp in turbo form, I'd say the weak con rod theory was just that. FYI-Engine testing at the OEM level includes running the motor for 24 hour periods and ranging the engine speed from peak torque to peak horsepower. This is done at 1/4 throttle, 1/2 throttle, 3/4 throttle and then at WOT to endurance test the reciprocating assembly. I personally have run my Yaris in 4th gear from Vegas to So Cal and back (mileage testing for my book) and run it flat out 114 mph for almost 9 straight miles. This combined with the hundreds of dyno tests run to the rev limiter under WOT shows me that (as has been their history) Toyota over and not underbuilds their vehicles.
i'm not bashing the 1nzfe. i love them so much i'm on number 2. 👍
is the 1nz-fe sleeved like the B18....ehhhhh!!!! ;) happy halloween
With previous dyno runs with bigger intake manifolds and throttle bodys without more displaement, more cam, or forced induction a higher flowing intake will offer very little gain and may loose h.p /torque until very high rpm.
What calculations are you using for runner diameter and length.
What calculations are you using for runner diameter and length.
can't wait for my manifold!
If the manifold turns out to be that good i'm sure Richard will be making as many as he can sell! He surely needs to recoup his R&D costs somehow.Originally Posted by PETERPOOP ↑OoOOooOOoo. I might be one of ten with the only aftermarket intake manifold for a looooooooooong time. Nice
The only way I could see a great manifold not being continued is if it costs more to make than what the market is willing to pay.
The only way I could see a great manifold not being continued is if it costs more to make than what the market is willing to pay.cali yaris = "the market" 😁
Nice! looks like the same thing that happened to my cousin's 7A-FE it was the oil pump and he didn't stop the car cuase it was late in the night. Not a big issue if watch the GUAGE! Also thats 🙄 about the above 4000rpm come down to P.R. and drive in the highway towards Cayey reving hard between 3rd and 4th gear to mantain 80mph thats above 4000rpm up hill like half hour drive or around 15 miles. I got A/T and M/T they get the same punishment when I'm behind the wheel remember it's a TOYOTA.Originally Posted by Tamago ↑so explain this:
Picture not included in this copy
on a stock engine, stock ecu, intake, exhaust, bone dry day (so dont' even say it was hydrolock) at 85mph (over 4300rpm) about 80F ambient temperature, engine had 47,000 miles on it.
the 1NZ is not designed to rev above 4000rpm for extended periods of time.
well...Originally Posted by cleong ↑If the manifold turns out to be that good i'm sure Richard will be making as many as he can sell! He surely needs to recoup his R&D costs somehow.
The only way I could see a great manifold not being continued is if it costs more to make than what the market is willing to pay.
Originally Posted by richardholdener ↑If we don't get 10 people to sign up-there will be no intakes. If we do, the those people will get the first production run of intakes and it is undecided if there will be an additional production run. Best bet if you want an intake-step up and get on the list.
Is this question directed at me? The statement that a higher flowing intake will yield very little gain and may loose hp until high rpm is inaccurate. Intake manifolds are not simple flow devices-they are tuned to produce power at specific engine speeds based on the other variables you mentioned (displacement, cam timing etc...) It does not take a bigger or higher flowing intake to make more power, it takes the right design elements. The calculations are extremely complicated for more reasons than I can go into in such a short space. We ran over 100 different combinations before deciding on this one illustrated by the dyno curve provided. Intake design is more than just welding together a plenum, runners and flange.
Originally Posted by dallas ↑With previous dyno runs with bigger intake manifolds and throttle bodys without more displaement, more cam, or forced induction a higher flowing intake will offer very little gain and may loose h.p /torque until very high rpm.
What calculations are you using for runner diameter and length.
PS-The tuning effect works the same on NA and FI applications.
Originally Posted by dallas ↑With previous dyno runs with bigger intake manifolds and throttle bodys without more displaement, more cam, or forced induction a higher flowing intake will offer very little gain and may loose h.p /torque until very high rpm.
What calculations are you using for runner diameter and length.
Intake design is more than just welding together a plenum, runners and flangeIt's physics....muahahahahahah....
Well if its a great manifold and profitable, why would Richard stop at just one (short) production run?Originally Posted by PETERPOOP ↑well...Originally Posted by richardholdenerIf we don't get 10 people to sign up-there will be no intakes. If we do, the those people will get the first production run of intakes and it is undecided if there will be an additional production run. Best bet if you want an intake-step up and get on the list.
Well if the production models are well built and sell enough, what says that Garm wouldnt stock them and sell them directly? at a possible discount.
well...
Originally Posted by richardholdener ↑If we don't get 10 people to sign up-there will be no intakes. If we do, the those people will get the first production run of intakes and it is undecided if there will be an additional production run. Best bet if you want an intake-step up and get on the list.
Well then, get signed up...lol
how much do intake manifolds usually go for for the yaris??? becuase i talked to some of the people from weapon r and they are developing one for the yaris and so far their headers and intakes are pretty bad ass
Weapon R is not Richard Holdener ;)
everyone knows weapon r sucks
Say...Do you have anything for the xA/xB yet?
I think 1.3L and 1.5L are the same, only diffrent in piston size between them.
Maybe be better ask the dealer.
QUOTE=ZING;157953]😢[/QUOTE]
Maybe be better ask the dealer.
QUOTE=ZING;157953]😢[/QUOTE]
Did these ever get produced? Any results, feedback from the first 10 customers?
nope, it's all been silent for the past couple months, some people still holding on to a glimmer of hope...
I'm gonna make my own.
For others 2?
WOOt Woot , have a few made for other Yw members too 👍Originally Posted by cali yaris ↑I'm gonna make my own.
Originally Posted by cali yaris ↑I'm gonna make my own.
me, me, me, me tooo, lol let us know what it costs when its done so I can start saving!
Could someone just talk Mr. Holdener into selling the design?
i think hes busy with more profitable mods.
yes but I agree with cleong, if Richard was willing to sell the design, someone else could arrange for its production and distribution. Would save a lot of time compared to re-engineering a new design...
Cali Yaris?🙂
Has anyone tried prospecting him to sell the design yet?