Originally Posted by
cali yaris ↑ Do you see the point if they intend to push it to 250-300? Because that's what's up on this build.
Let's just leave it alone, guys and enjoy the hell out of pimp's build.
Leaving it alone is boring, if I'm flat out wrong we might as well figure it out now.
1.The problem is every modern straight engine I've seen the experience ends up like Dent Guys:
Originally Posted by
DentGuy ↑ When you start doing things like "knife edging" the crank or offset grinding the journals then it can really mess with the balance or a rotating assembly. The machine shop all of us local guys use (including Sound Performance and AMS) has never seen a 2J crank out of balance. During my first engine build I went over kill with the machine shop and had them do a dynamic balance of the entire rotating assy. (Wiseco pistons, Carillo rods, ATI damper, RPS carbon clutch) Guess what... it need no adjustments.
Now im no Yaris expert but it seems to me that a clean and centered install of the Main caps will free up more power than having that .0001 grams balanced out of the crank. Certain motors will benifit from the additional balancing (V formats mainly) but Inline engines dont inflict the type of counteracting forces on the crank that the V styles engines do.
Now the reason for this is this is the main difference between straight engines and V engines. V engines are V because the harmonic differences offset each other with the degree of the V. Which is why the angle is different between v4, v6, v8 , etc.
Flat engines don't have any of that vibration, because they are in a row, all working the exact same way in the same directions. Which is also why the harmonic dampeners on our cars are basically nonexistent.
2. It simply isn't cheap. Anyone who says they can balance your engine for $250 has no idea what they are doing. There is a reason balancing and blueprinting go hand in hand, they are basically the same type of labor, Anyone who you would trust to do this isn't going to be cheap. It is going to be at least $1000, probably more, depending on how familiar the person is with the engine in question. Just think about it, the engine at the least has to be disassembled and reassembled.
3.
Originally Posted by
cali yaris ↑ I didn't balance my lower end -- doin' just fine over here.
Unless you go the "blank check" route, you have to make choices on which motor work to do that will get you "just a little bit more".
I chose to do what would make the most power for the money I could spend on my build.
Hasn't been a reliability issue - at all.
This is the real crux of the issue.
Originally Posted by
Blown_xa ↑ Yea mine is balanced. The 1nzfe shortblock we offer comes balanced... I can't compare a non balanced motor because every one we assemble is. The machine shop who handles our motors includes balancing the rotation assembly in the process. Rods come back numbered for specific assembly order. My built motor has over 40k on it now ( not easy miles , trust me).... is it because it is balanced ? I couldn't say
I am sure they are blueprinted as well, right? For a competition engine there is no reason for it not to be.
Just like I know engines in the top racing series are all balanced.blueprinted, etc. It would be dumb to not do it.
Basically V engines and straight engines are two very different beasts when it comes to vibration.
Here's the real thing though, I don't know anyone with a modern straight engine who's ever done it and the car needed it. Like Blown Xa said, it could be insurance money. so if you know a great engine builder and have the extra couple of grand on hand, you might as well go have it done.
But as Dent Guy said, if you're on a budget there are many better things to put your money toward.
Now come on, prove me wrong. Show me the results of all these straight engines and their extensive balancing reports.