Yarisworld Archive

Another S/C'd member worried about his AFR

182 posts · 47,610 views · page 1 of 4

LtNoogieOriginal postWest Hills, CA · Mar 23, 2009#1
I am posting the dyno printout for another Blitz S/C'd forum member who is worried about his AFR. His dyno technician would not perform a third pull because he did not want to be responsible for damaging this member's engine due to the lean readings.

Without access to a ScanGauge to indicate ignition timing, I do not know if he is facing a problem or not. He is not experiencing any pre-ignition due to the use of octane booster but that gets to be an expensive practice.

Largeorangefont, he has specifically asked for you to weigh in on this. I can post the HP curve if that would be helpful.

Thanks.

Picture not included in this copy

Replies 181

Nexus1155Dorchester · Mar 23, 2009#2
on top of being unsafe in some cases, you are losing a ton of power. If he has some money to throw around, i heard the SMT8 by perfect power might be a viable solution
beardaGermantown, MD · Mar 23, 2009#3
Anybody tried a Megasquirt on a Yaris? If the ECU is rejecting the piggybacks maybe it's time to go standalone.
CrandallNo Funswick · Mar 23, 2009#4
Originally Posted by bearda ↑
Anybody tried a Megasquirt on a Yaris? If the ECU is rejecting the piggybacks maybe it's time to go standalone.
If you have the knowledge or time to wire it into your harness then it might be a viable solution, but I'm getting really tired of thinking Megasquirt is some kind of easy plug and play solution; it's not. I have a friend who put it in his Escort and it was a lot of work, the car runs fine now but it took a lot of time.

Octane boost wouldn't have that much effect on the A/F ratio unless he was running C-10 or better. Did they try to advance or retard the timing at all before he refused to run the car anymore?
Nexus1155Dorchester · Mar 23, 2009#5
lol yeah, everyone thinks megasquirt is a god send. It is very crude, but it works well if you know how to use it. On a newer car like this i can see it being a bitch to work with. Money better invested elsewhere.
CrandallNo Funswick · Mar 23, 2009#6
Originally Posted by Nexus1155 ↑
lol yeah, everyone thinks megasquirt is a god send. It is very crude, but it works well if you know how to use it. On a newer car like this i can see it being a bitch to work with. Money better invested elsewhere.
Agreed 110%
CASTREXCosta Rica · Mar 23, 2009#7
^^^ ???


As ANY other stand alone and even piggy back out there... a Megasquirt would have to be hardwired. That is a pain yes... but is not any different from the other stand alones out there.

With any stand alone ECU you NEED to know what you are doing if you want to doit right.

I'm not saying that the Megasquirt would work or not in a Yaris... but ease of installation should not be factor...

There are other modern cars running just fine with Megasquirt.


There is one reason we have no one (other than Garm's in process project) running a standalone... and that is the cost of it. And basically that is the advantage of the Megasquirt... it's low cost.


So I will have to disagree and say that until some gives a valid reason (different from hardwire is a pain) why the Megasquirt would not work on Yaris... it should remain on the table as one good option.


Since basically 90% of the forced induction Yaris won't be pushing the limits... fuel and timing control on a basic way is the only thing they need.

Is there anyone with actual knowledge on Megasquirt that wants to chime in?
Nexus1155Dorchester · Mar 23, 2009#8
While there are many cars where MegaSquirt can completely replace the stock ECU, on some cars you'll need to leave the stock ECU in place. There's several reasons why you might want to do this. On some installations, you might want to have the MegaSquirt control just the fuel and would rather not deal with having to tune the ignition. Or you may have an ECU that controls the automatic transmission, has the voltage regulator for the alternator inside it, controls a drive by wire throttle, or has other features that aren't easy to control with MegaSquirt. On a car like that, the solution is what's called a parallel installation.
http://www.diyautotune.com/tech_arti...n_parallel.htm
beardaGermantown, MD · Mar 23, 2009#9
I'm not saying a MegaSquirt or any other standalone would be easy, I'm just looking at it from the perspective of needing something effective. If you can't cooperate with the stock ECU take it out of the picture for fuel delivery.

Yeah, installing it would be a cast-iron bitch. The upside is that once you did get it installed and tuned right it would work. And continue to work, despite whatever psychotic episode the ECU decided to throw.
CASTREXCosta Rica · Mar 23, 2009#10
Yeap, on a car like the Yaris you will want to leave the OE ECU on the car if you want to keep all the standard features.

Ideally some one would want to take control only over the fuel and timing and use a MAP sensor to tune from... and let all other functions to be handle by the OE ecu.

That would be the easiest way to do it.

First time is the hardest... and the most expensive..

But if someone with the knowledge can figure a way to make it work... and document the process...

Then it will be a breeze for the people coming behind...


So, who wants to be the pioneer!!!!
cali yarisCanoga Park, CA · Mar 23, 2009#11
I forwarded the dyno sheet to Blitz, that's the best I can do to be helpful. 🙁
PETERPOOPOahu · Mar 23, 2009#12
Hey let's solve my problem! What the fart is wrong here!? I only got a 20whp gain with a headerback 2.25" exhaust setup. Noogie got 27whp gain with only an axleback and header as his exhaust upgrades. I want to shoot myself. Oh yah, and my torque got worst! lol. I am in a deep depression as of now.

Here are my HP dyno charts from the resent run. Below will be the old sheet.

(Like stated in first post #1, My dyno guy said I'd probably make more HP in higher RPMs, but he did not want to do any harm to my engine, so he didn't.)

So I was reading in noogie's "How to cure a lean condition thread" and I am kinda confused...

Largeorange front was saying that noogie's readings are OK, if the blitz kit has retard timing? So if that is the case, I would not be running lean either?

Picture not included in this copy

Picture not included in this copy
LtNoogieThread starterWest Hills, CA · Mar 23, 2009#13
See how inaccurate the butt dyno was? My 27 HP gain is before I tune the car some more. It's now a matter of dimishing returns. How much more money do I want to sink into this for marginal gains. Give me another 30 HP and I may dump a few more bills into it. I just don't want to be the first Blitz owner to blow up his engine.
PETERPOOPOahu · Mar 23, 2009#14
Yah, but I got problems. I only got a 20whp gain with a manual! I should have had a bigger gain than you. If I could get an additional 30 HP gain from this kit, I am all for it. But I am not done with my current problem. I still feel "robbed" of HP that I should have gotten. All that money, all that time, and for 20whp.........

Is my lean condition worst than yours Noogie?
LtNoogieThread starterWest Hills, CA · Mar 23, 2009#15
My AFR was actually worse than yours. Sorry for the messed up formatting of the tabular data. My RPMs are the second column. AFR the last column.

AFTER SUPERCHARGER
          s         RPM x1000 hp        ft-lbs    Air/Fuel
          0.24      4.10      N/A       N/A       14.64     
          0.58      4.20      88.67     110.88    14.91     
          0.97      4.30      93.31     113.97    14.59     
          1.40      4.40      93.61     111.73    13.77     
          1.79      4.50      96.69     112.85    13.45     
          2.19      4.60      98.06     111.96    13.64     
          2.60      4.70      100.11    111.87    13.79     
          3.00      4.80      100.07    109.49    13.80     
          3.42      4.90      101.35    108.64    13.85     
          3.80      5.00      104.52    109.79    13.90     
          4.23      5.10      103.96    107.06    13.96     
          4.64      5.20      103.46    104.49    14.13     
          5.07      5.30      104.02    103.08    14.17     
          5.50      5.40      104.64    101.77    14.14     
          5.94      5.50      105.85    101.08    14.12     
          6.39      5.60      106.11    99.52     14.28     
          6.84      5.70      109.51    100.90    14.38     
          7.29      5.80      111.59    101.05    14.37     
          7.72      5.90      115.35    102.68    14.27     
          8.17      6.00      116.62    102.09    14.18     
          8.64      6.10      116.29    100.12    14.16     
          9.10      6.20      116.53    98.71     14.07     
          9.60      6.30      114.51    95.47     14.01     
          10.12     6.40      112.97    92.71     13.87     
          10.63     6.50      114.46    92.49     13.79
PETERPOOPOahu · Mar 23, 2009#16
Yah I see that at your 6200 RPMs you were at 14.07. At 6,200 RPMs I was at 13.59. You were leaner than me.

I see that you took it to 6500 RPMs. That was my intended plan, until my dyno guy said no ways. Yours actually wasn't as lean when you took it past 6300.

So did you come to the conclusion that you have retard timing and even though these numbers mean you are running lean, you really aren't?

ps: I am going to dyno on a dynojet and taking it to 6500 RPMs once I figure everything out.
jkuchtaL.A. · Mar 23, 2009#17
I may be an idiot, but aren't these numbers showing that you guys are running rich?

14.7:1 is perfect.....then wouldn't anything less be rich of peak?


Would anything over 14.7:1 be lean (like 15:1 etc.)?
CASTREXCosta Rica · Mar 23, 2009#18
Your logic is right... the higher the number the leanest,

However your point of reference is wrong... 14,7:1 would be the perfect number at idle or when crusing, not under boost.

Under boos you need to run much richer than that to be on the safe side...

Ideally these guys should be around 12:1 under boost... that is why they say a 13.5 or a 14 is dangerously lean...
cali yarisCanoga Park, CA · Mar 23, 2009#19
The blitz fuel controller does that and only that -- it does not adjust timing.
CASTREXCosta Rica · Mar 23, 2009#20
Originally Posted by PETERPOOP ↑

So did you come to the conclusion that you have retard timing and even though these numbers mean you are running lean, you really aren't?
Is not like that... the problem is not running lean.

As largeorangefont explained, there are 2 things that could kill your engine...
Temperature and Knock...

Running lean will USUALLy lead to higher EGT (exhaust gas temp)...

This can be sorted by either adding more fuel to the mixure (making it richer) or by taking away ignition timing.

That's why it was said that even with those AFR readings... if the ECU or the black box were taking timing away... then you were probably OK


Talking about EGT... why you guys haven't picked a pyrometer? Those are not that expensive and would definetely help you sleep better at night...
CASTREXCosta Rica · Mar 23, 2009#21
Originally Posted by cali yaris ↑
The blitz fuel controller does that and only that -- it does not adjust timing.

Has anyone tried to disconnect the black box and see what happens? Ideally would hve to be some one with a wideband installed.
That would answer the question if the black box is actually doing anything at all...
CASTREXCosta Rica · Mar 24, 2009#22
Originally Posted by Yaris T-Sport ↑
maybe I'm wrong but, maybe your full custom exhaust loses too much back pressure, therefore you lose more horsepower than Noogie, try go back to stock exhaust to see if you gain more horsepower back.
I don't really think that is the problem...

When we have forced induction usually the largest the exhaust the better (within a range of course)

You need to remeber that no car is the same as no Dyno is the same...

Weather condition and other factors could have affected your final output.


Anyways.... isn't 20whp withing the range of the tipical gains offered by the blitz unit?
I mean... in you car that is a 23% increase in HP...

The tq still looks a little weak... but still within range...


I can see these kits putting 10-15whp more with a tune... if there would only be an easy way to tune it...🙁
PETERPOOPOahu · Mar 24, 2009#23
Originally Posted by CASTREX ↑
I don't really think that is the problem...

When we have forced induction usually the largest the exhaust the better (within a range of course)

You need to remeber that no car is the same as no Dyno is the same...

Weather condition and other factors could have affected your final output.


it..


Yah true. When I did the dyno run, it had to have been atleast 85 degrees (HOT!). I don't think my 2.25" headerback exhaust would have me lose HP, definately torque, but NOT as bad as it is showing.

Originally Posted by CASTREX ↑
Has anyone tried to disconnect the black box and see what happens? Ideally would hve to be some one with a wideband installed.
That would answer the question if the black box is actually doing anything at all...
Noogie! Do it!

Originally Posted by Yaris T-Sport ↑
maybe I'm wrong but, maybe your full custom exhaust loses too much back pressure, therefore you lose more horsepower than Noogie, try go back to stock exhaust to see if you gain more horsepower back.
Haha, it wouldn't be that easy or cheap to go back to my stock exhaust setup. But I know what you're implying.

Originally Posted by Crandall ↑
Did they try to advance or retard the timing at all before he refused to run the car anymore?
We aren't capable of doing that unless we have a standalone ecu, correct?
whooppee777Maryland · Mar 24, 2009#24
i undid my pvc valve to make hooking up my boost gauge easier and there is a ridiculous amount of oil coming out of my engine and into the manifold. something has to be very wrong
PETERPOOPOahu · Mar 24, 2009#25
lol. well make a new thread. :P
whooppee777Maryland · Mar 24, 2009#26
i figured everyone was already looking in this thread
PETERPOOPOahu · Mar 24, 2009#27
true. good luck
staypuftchicago · Mar 24, 2009#28
Originally Posted by whooppee777 ↑
i undid my pvc valve to make hooking up my boost gauge easier and there is a ridiculous amount of oil coming out of my engine and into the manifold. something has to be very wrong
thus i installed an oil catch can

Picture not included in this copy
Nexus1155Dorchester · Mar 24, 2009#29
Why is everyone having problems with this kit now :( :( :(
PETERPOOPOahu · Mar 24, 2009#30
Because nothing can be easy! Especially FI! doh
whooppee777Maryland · Mar 24, 2009#31
its aftermarket shit, its never easy. but thats y we do it

i know its normal to have a little bit of oil coming through, but i have a shit ton WAY more than normal
whooppee777Maryland · Mar 24, 2009#32
and by the way my afr go to the 12 range at WOT but tend to stay in the 14 at 1 to 5 pounds of boost
PETERPOOPOahu · Mar 24, 2009#33
Originally Posted by whooppee777 ↑
and by the way my afr go to the 12 range at WOT but tend to stay in the 14 at 1 to 5 pounds of boost
Well you're definately not running as lean as noogie and I. I ordered a scangauge II from garm tonight. Hopefully I'll get it soon and have more accurate readings.
PETERPOOPOahu · Mar 24, 2009#34
Originally Posted by Yaris T-Sport ↑
yes, because you are boosted. An oil catch can on a boosted engine is a good idea, I have one as well.
I am curious of your A/F readings since you are using the 1.8 tb.
whooppee777Maryland · Mar 24, 2009#35
urrently planning a group dyno day with some other tuners in the area within the next month u'll get ur readings as well as graphs
Nexus1155Dorchester · Mar 24, 2009#36
it seems like proper tuning would net this supercharger alot more power. people who arent running as lean as other nets 10 more hp?! imagine if you were actually running well...
PETERPOOPOahu · Mar 24, 2009#37
That's our goal!
beardaGermantown, MD · Mar 24, 2009#38
Originally Posted by PETERPOOP ↑
Well you're definately not running as lean as noogie and I. I ordered a scangauge II from garm tonight. Hopefully I'll get it soon and have more accurate readings.
What is it you're trying to monitor with the Scangauge?
LtNoogieThread starterWest Hills, CA · Mar 24, 2009#39
Most likely ignition timing at different RPM during WOT. We might be able to compare this to his air/fuel ratio from the dyno run.
Doc ZaiusOttawa, ON, Canada · Mar 24, 2009#40
I was pretty sure that lean = more power..? But more dangerous.

I still have yet to buy gauges, so I can't be any help to you guys right now. Although (interestingly, whoopeee) I remember taking some rubber line off something and there being a fair bit of oil/muck inside it. Don't know which line. But perhaps I should get an oil catch-can too.
PETERPOOPOahu · Mar 24, 2009#41
Originally Posted by Doc Zaius ↑
I was pretty sure that lean = more power..? But more dangerous.
The guy who did my dyno was saying all cars are different. Some guys make their cars run lean because their car responds with more HP when it is lean. Other guys lose HP when it is ran lean. I guess the Yaris is the case of a car losing HP when running lean at higher RPMs.
LtNoogieThread starterWest Hills, CA · Mar 24, 2009#42
I've contacted my dyno guy to see how much he charges to tune this little beast. Afterall, it's now my little project car.

As a side note, I set the S/C to OFF this morning when I got on the freeway. I did not see any ignition retard down to single digits. I am only guessing but this tells me that the ECU is sensing pre-igition during boost and is retarding the timing, which is what my pictures showed in the other thread. That can't be good for engine life or max power output. When there's no boost and no pre-ignition, the ECU leaves the inigition timing in the low to mid 20's.
Nexus1155Dorchester · Mar 24, 2009#43
I was pretty sure that lean = more power..? But more dangerous.
There needs to be a harmony, thats why theres a recommended range for supercharged vehicles

More fuel = more allowable ignition advance.

You ideally want no knock correction as it takes the ECU a bit for every degree of correction where you lose a severe amount of power. It should really be checked on the cars with misfired on how bad it is!!!
yaris-meAnaheim, CA · Mar 24, 2009#44
Hi Long. Have you considered maybe one of your fuel injectors might be clogged? I try running a high quality injector cleaner in your gas and see if the condition improves. You are trying to eliminate all variables?
whooppee777Maryland · Mar 24, 2009#45
could the power enterprises camcom correct a/f ratios by manually advancing or retarding the timing?
CASTREXCosta Rica · Mar 24, 2009#46
Originally Posted by whooppee777 ↑
could the power enterprises camcom correct a/f ratios by manually advancing or retarding the timing?
To correct the AFR you need to add or sustract fuel not timing.

However, by sustracting enough timing you can make the car run safe even with those lean AFR's you guys are seeing.

Theoretically you could tune the car with the Camcom... however, I haven't seen any camcom sucsesfully installed in a Yaris.... yet.

Some times you can find those for cheap on ebay... it worths a shot.
LtNoogieThread starterWest Hills, CA · Mar 24, 2009#47
I can't wait to see what a properly tuned Blitz'd Yaris can put out. I know we've been admonished not to put larger injectors on this car but hear me out on this theory.

What if the current fuel system with the Blitz piggyback fuel controller cannot pump enough fuel into the cylinders during WOT, leading to a lean condition. The ECU detects pre-ignition and has to retard timing to protect the engine, and as a consequence robs us of the maximum power the S/C can put out.

If I put slightly, not hugely, larger injectors in the car, it may run less lean during WOT and the ignition retard is less, giving more power. During idle or light throttle, the ECU detects a rich condition from the O2 sensor and is able to dial back the fuel to maintain proper AFR. Remember, I said slightly larger injectors, not fire hoses. If the increase in fuel is within the ECU's cabability to control, that could just work.

Anyhow, that's the theory I want to present to my dyno guy if I have him tune the car.
Doc ZaiusOttawa, ON, Canada · Mar 24, 2009#48
^^^ Quite excited about the sound of that! 😁
CASTREXCosta Rica · Mar 24, 2009#49
Garm's car has been running with TC injectors on the OEM ECU right?

And iirc he didn't had any idle or part throttle problems... just a lean condition at WOT... but that was @ 180 whp

I say your theory is worth a shot if you can find some injectors for cheap.

Look for injectors from a Celica GTs, corolla/ matrix XRS. I think those are a little smaller than the TC's.

You can look into the 6 gen celica forums for those..
Nexus1155Dorchester · Mar 24, 2009#50
well holy crap if that the case, are you maxxing out the stock ones? any way to tell? I mean anything over what? 85% efficiency is bad you want it from atleast 65% to be running somewhat safe?

But see this is the problem, you have no way to scaled the injectors constant and must calculate this pretty good based on the amount of fuel it will be dumping in there....Larger injector + same constant = stays open for a longer time = more fuel = richer afr.... good luck

On a GT28 1.8T A4 I was tuning it started out with 210 or 280cc depending on the fpr with an afr of 11-12 while driving, swapped in the 550cc knocked us down to around 8.5-9.0 before i properly calculated the scalar to bring it back up. just to give you a headsup.