Yarisworld Archive

Another S/C'd member worried about his AFR

182 posts · 47,610 views · page 3 of 4

Replies continued

largeorangefontSo Cal, OC · Mar 26, 2009#101
Originally Posted by LtNoogie ↑
Where in the OC are you? If I don't chicken out due to this AFR, I might just run into you at Willow Springs on April 10. You can see what the car is doing on and off boost.
Irvine area.

I still need to confirm I can go and get signed up for the 10th.
largeorangefontSo Cal, OC · Mar 26, 2009#102
What are the pinouts for the black box and does it connect to the boost switch? my guess is yes.

The next step is who is brave enough to disconnect a couple wires and find out exactly what the black box does :)
largeorangefontSo Cal, OC · Mar 26, 2009#103
OK I found the pinouts for the black box. It just connect to fuel related components. We will have to do some data logging to see why the car is pulling timing under boost.

Long,

If you can, warm up your car and do a couple pulls in 2nd or 3rd.

Then pull the negative battery connector, or pull the fuse to the ECU. Pump the brakes a few times and reconnect the fuse or battery.

Go out and do another couple pulls and see if the timing you see increases, or increases and then decreases. Let us know the differences.
LtNoogieThread starterWest Hills, CA · Mar 26, 2009#104
Ok, it will have to be Friday evening. Did you see in an earlier post that with the S/C switch set to OFF, I see timing in the low to mid 20s? This is even uder heavy load.
largeorangefontSo Cal, OC · Mar 26, 2009#105
Originally Posted by LtNoogie ↑
Ok, it will have to be Friday evening. Did you see in an earlier post that with the S/C switch set to OFF, I see timing in the low to mid 20s? This is even uder heavy load.
Yea I saw that. Off is no boost at all right? What AFR do you see when it is off?
LtNoogieThread starterWest Hills, CA · Mar 26, 2009#106
14.7 - 14.9 but I'll do some runs tonight when I have to climb several hills.

no boost pressure
Nexus1155Dorchester · Mar 26, 2009#107
thats what you are suppose to see when it is off. I usually get 14.5-14.7 when cruising in the truck. WOT goes to like 12.7 - 13.2. Factory did a decent job tuning fuel already
PETERPOOPOahu · Mar 26, 2009#108
Ok. So I won't be doing the larger injectors and 1zz throttle body. I'll be waiting for long to get the numbers on friday afternoon and see what largeorange has to say then.
dallasCanada · Mar 27, 2009#109
Backpressure does not create exhaust gas velocity, if the pipe diameter is too big the air moving down the pipe slows down and cools down which in turn makes the air molecules less active slowing down the flow. The reason race cars don't release at the exhaust port is because exhaust velocity actualy help draw air out of the cylinder head, but to get that you need the right diameter and length of pipe to create the exhaust velocity, what you don't want is any back pressure to slow down the flow, You have the right idea just not the right terminology, there are some really good papers on exhaust design and performance done by ASTM I belive, that tell you exactly that.


Originally Posted by HTM Yaris ↑
Back pressure is a good thing . Some not alot . Without Backpressure(BP) there isn't any exhaust gas velocity . If no BP was a good thing all the real race cars would have exhaust gas being released straight from the exhaust port . ( Yes I realize that exhaust pipes also evacuate heat )


Try this , go turn on your garden hose . See how it flows ? To increase the velocity of the flow you can do 2 things 1. increase the volume of water or 2. partially cover the end of the hose with your thumb (creating BP) .
LtNoogieThread starterWest Hills, CA · Mar 27, 2009#110
Originally Posted by LtNoogie ↑
Ok, I just spent a half hour on the phone with dyno guy. He does not recommend that I start with larger injectors or more powerful fuel pump. He recommends a boost-sensitive adjustable fuel pressure regulator.
Thanks to CTScott, I found the OEM fuel pressure regulator. It is not in a place that is easily replaced by an aftermarket unit. Since the fuel system's pressure is now maxed out at the 44.1 to 49.7 psi put out by the OEM regulator, using another regulator after this unit to get higher pressure is impossible.

Dyno guy now admits that replacement of the fuel pump (like Garm's turbo install) or replacement of the stock injectors is probably in order if the goal is to get more fuel to the engine during boost.

Calculating the proper injectors size, using the many online injector calculators, is a little bit daunting but I'll use them all until I can understand the concept and get consistent results.

I'd rather understand the science behind the proper selection of injectors rather than just shotgunning any device in and hoping that they do the job adequately.

1 attachment not included in this copy

largeorangefontSo Cal, OC · Mar 27, 2009#111
Originally Posted by LtNoogie ↑
Thanks to CTScott, I found the OEM fuel pressure regulator. It is not in a place that is easily replaced by an aftermarket unit. Since the fuel system's pressure is now maxed out at the 44.1 to 49.7 psi put out by the OEM regulator, using another regulator after this unit to get higher pressure is impossible.

Dyno guy now admits that replacement of the fuel pump (like Garm's turbo install) or replacement of the stock injectors is probably in order if the goal is to get more fuel to the engine during boost.

Calculating the proper injectors size, using the many online injector calculators, is a little bit daunting but I'll use them all until I can understand the concept and get consistent results.

I'd rather understand the science behind the proper selection of injectors rather than just shotgunning any device in and hoping that they do the job adequately.
If that is truly the problem, you could try a boost-a-pump. You need a scan gauge or tool that can tell you injector duty cycle to know for sure if you need anything.

You guys will not be able to solve this by just swapping out parts. You will solve one problem and create 5 more with bigger injectors.
eTiMaGoBangkok, Thailand · Mar 27, 2009#112
HOW TO PUT THE 10K POTENCIOMETER AND A COUPLE OF MY MODS

this might be worth trying *just* to see what it does to the AFR... forcing the car to be in warmup mode sounds like a very half-assed (quarter-assed?) way of tuning a car, but desperate times can call for desperate measures
LtNoogieThread starterWest Hills, CA · Mar 27, 2009#113
Originally Posted by largeorangefont ↑
If that is truly the problem, you could try a boost-a-pump. You need a scan gauge or tool that can tell you injector duty cycle to know for sure if you need anything.

You guys will not be able to solve this by just swapping out parts. You will solve one problem and create 5 more with bigger injectors.
What is a boost-a-pump? Can you post a link to a comparable product online? I have not seen injector duty cycle as available for display on the ScanGauge. I am guessing that some instrumentation would have to be connected to the injector wires to measure duty cycle? This intrument would have to be sturdy enough to measure during WOT?
Doc ZaiusOttawa, ON, Canada · Mar 27, 2009#114
Yeah, ScanGauge definitely does not do injector duty cycle. What would? Some type of logger. That would certainly help narrow down some of the issues!
TOUGEghostKauai · Mar 27, 2009#115
Originally Posted by LtNoogie ↑
What is a boost-a-pump? Can you post a link to a comparable product online?
Here's the link:

http://store.summitracing.com/partde...5&autoview=sku

It increases voltage to the fuel pump as boost increases. Seems like it could be a good solution for moderate boost levels.
PETERPOOPOahu · Mar 27, 2009#116
Interesting. Since it only increases when boost increases, are those intervals too short for the ECU to catch on?
LtNoogieThread starterWest Hills, CA · Mar 27, 2009#117
Originally Posted by TOUGEghost ↑
Here's the link:

http://store.summitracing.com/partde...5&autoview=sku

It increases voltage to the fuel pump as boost increases. Seems like it could be a good solution for moderate boost levels.
Thanks, I had seen that earlier. My thought is that a properly working fuel pressure regulator will hold the current pressure unless it fails. My water pressure regulator at the inlet to my home maintains a constant 80psi across a wide band of street pressure.

Any mechanical engineers out there?
dallasCanada · Mar 28, 2009#118
Ive seen the Boost-a-pump used on a buddys Mustang and it works well, if you need to squeeze a bit more out of the fuel pump. If Richard Holdners Intake /exhaust combo made more hp than the supercharger it must be using more fuel to acheive this. I don't think it's the fuel delivery, but maybe the management of the delivery thats causing a lean condition. I wish you pioneers luck to figure this out.
jkuchtaL.A. · Mar 28, 2009#119
The ARK Design MFD has the provision to display injector duty cycle. I'm going to try and wire it up this weekend!


An Air/Water intercooler might be possible with the blitz kit, but it will require some fabrication (probably a lot!).
cali yarisCanoga Park, CA · Mar 28, 2009#120
I believe the Blitz R-Vit can control a/f with additional percentage.
largeorangefontSo Cal, OC · Mar 29, 2009#121
Originally Posted by camelll ↑
What would happen if someone were to add an intercooler to this set up. What if the pre-ignition is not being caused by the octane but by heat created from the forced induction? I know a lot of people say that an intercooler is not necessary on the blitz but anyone that owns a blitz that has touched the intake pipe on a summer day after driving knows it will burn the shit out you.

With that being said what would be needed to add an air to air intercooler to this set up? Is it even possible? Would it even be feasible?
Horribly expensive and probably not feasible with the blitz kit (or ANY roots style supercharger kit). At 5-7 PSI an intercooler is not really needed.

You would be better off spending money on a way to tune the car.
LtNoogieThread starterWest Hills, CA · Mar 29, 2009#122
I thought that Open Loop meant that the ECU was not making adustments to the engine parameters. Like when you are in DFCO. Today when crusing on the freeway, I switched my ScanGauge to show the OPEN/CLOSED loop state of the engine.

Anytime I went into boost, even slight boost, the ScanGauge showed OPEN Loop. If that is true, what would cause the ignition to retard? This is confusing. I could not repeat this on surface streets and boosting lightly.

I'm still working on a new camera mount and will video the gauge cluster and ScanGauge to demonstrate this new mode of operations. Wierd.
yaris-meAnaheim, CA · Mar 29, 2009#123
Originally Posted by LtNoogie ↑
I thought that Open Loop meant that the ECU was not making adustments to the engine parameters. Like when you are in DFCO. Today when crusing on the freeway, I switched my ScanGauge to show the OPEN/CLOSED loop state of the engine.

Anytime I went into boost, even slight boost, the ScanGauge showed OPEN Loop. If that is true, what would cause the ignition to retard? This is confusing. I could not repeat this on surface streets and boosting lightly. Hope this helps.🙂

I'm still working on a new camera mount and will video the gauge cluster and ScanGauge to demonstrate this new mode of operations. Wierd.
If the senors detect detonation (knock or ping), the ECU will retard timing. Raising the octane in the fuel will help with detonation. There is also the use of a methanol water injection system.
largeorangefontSo Cal, OC · Mar 29, 2009#124
In open loop the ECU is *probably* not making fueling adjustments, but it depends on what is happening. If there is severe knock or other problems, you will shift to another fueling map, or the ECU will make fueling corrections.

The ECU is always adjusting timing regardless of open or closed loop.

Did you reset the ECU and drive the car to see what the timing was on a fresh reset?

What is needed here is full Toyota OBD software. That will allow you to watch everything the ECU is doing.

Or like I said, we can put my knock light on the car.

If you are indeed knocking, first think I would try is one heat range colder plugs.
LtNoogieThread starterWest Hills, CA · Mar 29, 2009#125
I have not heard audible evidence of knocking like I did before I filled up with 91 octane. The only reason that I am guessing there is knocking is the ingition timing being retarded. I know others have to add octane boosters to stop their audible knocking.

I'll reset the ECU on Sunday and try the tests suggested.
eTiMaGoBangkok, Thailand · Mar 29, 2009#126
Originally Posted by LtNoogie ↑
I thought that Open Loop meant that the ECU was not making adustments to the engine parameters. Like when you are in DFCO. Today when crusing on the freeway, I switched my ScanGauge to show the OPEN/CLOSED loop state of the engine.

Anytime I went into boost, even slight boost, the ScanGauge showed OPEN Loop. If that is true, what would cause the ignition to retard? This is confusing. I could not repeat this on surface streets and boosting lightly.

I'm still working on a new camera mount and will video the gauge cluster and ScanGauge to demonstrate this new mode of operations. Wierd.
that's really interesting! In open loop, the ECU is supposed to stop trying to calculate the correct AFR on the fly, and instead rely on an old-fashioned fuel map (where this much RPM = this much injector duty cycle), and this is the situation where a piggyback should have no problem to alter this fuelling. (i.e. ZPI's method by forcing open loop with a CEL)

I am not yet fully familiar how the car calculates ignition advance in normal closed lop mode (apart from retarding it on detecting knock), but it most likely either has a map for it too, or just pegs it to maximum retardation, in which case the open loop operation is pretty much a "safe mode" no matter what.

So, if this blitz controller is able to invoke open loop *without* tripping a CEL, it certainly should allow a lot more flexibility! The question is, how does it do it, and how can we emulate this to use with other piggyback systems... *thinking cap goes back on* Gonna add some related musings/manual findings to the other thread
largeorangefontSo Cal, OC · Mar 29, 2009#127
Originally Posted by LtNoogie ↑
I have not heard audible evidence of knocking like I did before I filled up with 91 octane. The only reason that I am guessing there is knocking is the ingition timing being retarded. I know others have to add octane boosters to stop their audible knocking.

I'll reset the ECU on Sunday and try the tests suggested.
Yea you are going to need to run 91 all the time now. Do you have the wiring diagram for your black box? It sounds like my suspicion that Blitz changed what the black box does might be true according to Camelll.
eTiMaGoBangkok, Thailand · Mar 29, 2009#128
Originally Posted by camelll ↑
Are you using the r-vit? If so get on it and let us know how it works.



This information is for the R-fit and not the r-vit and (can be used in conjunction though) is from 2004 but it is the latest updated list they have on the blitz website page 25, does not show the ncp91. This could be a little out of date but 🤷.

I am curious if someone is gonna try the r-vit though to see if it is gonna work.
It should work, in theory when you're in open loop you can tweak all you want within the limitations of the fuel pressure and injectors?

Originally Posted by largeorangefont ↑
Yea you are going to need to run 91 all the time now. Do you have the wiring diagram for your black box? It sounds like my suspicion that Blitz changed what the black box does might be true according to Camelll.
Yeah I am still not sure how the clutch gets the information from the gear... sounds like it ties in to the starter circuitry (the part which requires you to press the clutch on a manual, or have the auto in P or N before the engine will crank).

Anyway, looking at the new data Pavel logged, it looks like there is a correlation between throttle % and closed loop mode. It was a pretty short run but it looks like above 75% throttle, the system switches to open loop. So, perhaps the blitz unit is reporting 100% throttle to the ECU no matter what, once it kicks in the SC?
Now this is something that Long can check with the scangauge, see what is the reported throttle angle once the SC kicks in... If it jumps from actual throttle position (say 50%) to a much higher value, then bingo, we know how to trigger open loop safely 😁
changchewsoonMalaysia · Mar 29, 2009#129
Hi,

I hope its OK for me to post here although I'm running a boosted Vios rather then a charged one, I have a Greddy Informeter Touch which plugs in to the OBDII connector to monitor all engine parameters, and I've also got a Innovate LC-1 Wideband O2 to monitor my air/fuel ratio.

I just want to share with everyone that by using E-Manage Blue, my tuner is able to get the ECU to run at a constant A/F ratio of 12 during WOT and a AF ratio of 14 during close loop. My wideband O2 display confirms this.

I'm currently using the base + ignition + injector harness for the E-Manage.

Hope the dyno chart is able to provide a better idea, hope it helps.

Please do not hesitate to ask me if you need any information, I'll try my best to share.

Picture not included in this copy
http://4.bp.blogspot.com/_RQcAxTVtNR...Dyno-Chart.JPG
largeorangefontSo Cal, OC · Mar 29, 2009#130
Originally Posted by eTiMaGo ↑
It should work, in theory when you're in open loop you can tweak all you want within the limitations of the fuel pressure and injectors?



Yeah I am still not sure how the clutch gets the information from the gear... sounds like it ties in to the starter circuitry (the part which requires you to press the clutch on a manual, or have the auto in P or N before the engine will crank).

Anyway, looking at the new data Pavel logged, it looks like there is a correlation between throttle % and closed loop mode. It was a pretty short run but it looks like above 75% throttle, the system switches to open loop. So, perhaps the blitz unit is reporting 100% throttle to the ECU no matter what, once it kicks in the SC?
Now this is something that Long can check with the scangauge, see what is the reported throttle angle once the SC kicks in... If it jumps from actual throttle position (say 50%) to a much higher value, then bingo, we know how to trigger open loop safely 😁
Yes, Long could check that, but I think the system is more sophisticated than that. There are many other systems that require correct and accurate reporting of throttle position.

There is more than one metric that triggers open loop. Generally speaking there is RPM, Load, and TPS. Depending on the ECU, the car could be using one or all 3 as reference points.
largeorangefontSo Cal, OC · Mar 29, 2009#131
Originally Posted by changchewsoon ↑
Hi,

I hope its OK for me to post here although I'm running a boosted Vios rather then a charged one, I have a Greddy Informeter Touch which plugs in to the OBDII connector to monitor all engine parameters, and I've also got a Innovate LC-1 Wideband O2 to monitor my air/fuel ratio.

I just want to share with everyone that by using E-Manage Blue, my tuner is able to get the ECU to run at a constant A/F ratio of 12 during WOT and a AF ratio of 14 during close loop. My wideband O2 display confirms this.

I'm currently using the base + ignition + injector harness for the E-Manage.

Hope the dyno chart is able to provide a better idea, hope it helps.

Please do not hesitate to ask me if you need any information, I'll try my best to share.

Picture not included in this copy
http://4.bp.blogspot.com/_RQcAxTVtNR...Dyno-Chart.JPG

This is an example of the AFR you want to see on a WOT pull guys.

What are you injector duty cycles, and are you still running stock injectors?
changchewsoonMalaysia · Mar 29, 2009#132
I'm currently running stock injectors, but I have 2 additional injectors soldered near to the throttle body controlled by the piggy back.

If I'm not mistaken, the opening/closing time of the injectors are at around 20ms during WOT near the RPM limit.

The duty cycle is around 87% for the stock injectors during WOT near the RPM limit. I always thought that anything above 80% is bad however we've done many hours of extensive testing and the newer version of the Toyota VVT-i injectors are actually quite reliable.

We've also checked with TRD Thailand, as their Turbo Vios are also running the same stock injectors, they too have also done extensive testing on the injectors to ensure their reliability.

However, I'm not too sure whether is there any difference between JDM and USDM specs though.
largeorangefontSo Cal, OC · Mar 29, 2009#133
Originally Posted by changchewsoon ↑
I'm currently running stock injectors, but I have 2 additional injectors soldered near to the throttle body controlled by the piggy back.

If I'm not mistaken, the opening/closing time of the injectors are at around 20ms during WOT near the RPM limit.

The duty cycle is around 87% for the stock injectors during WOT near the RPM limit. I always thought that anything above 80% is bad however we've done many hours of extensive testing and the newer version of the Toyota VVT-i injectors are actually quite reliable.

We've also checked with TRD Thailand, as their Turbo Vios are also running the same stock injectors, they too have also done extensive testing on the injectors to ensure their reliability.

However, I'm not too sure whether is there any difference between JDM and USDM specs though.
Great info. Just to clarify, the 87% duty is NOT while using your extra injectors correct?

Most modern injectors you can run in the low 90% range without issue, so I would say you are fine at your current power level.
changchewsoonMalaysia · Mar 29, 2009#134
Yes actually it is 87% duty while using the extra injectors.

I do agree with you on running on the low 90% range for modern injectors, as a matter of fact we actually pushed the stock injectors pass the 97% mark and it actually holds up pretty well.
LtNoogieThread starterWest Hills, CA · Mar 30, 2009#135
I did not get a chance to run the test and I'm off to D.C. for a week of work.
LorenSafety Harbor, FL · Mar 30, 2009#136
Without taking the time to read through this whole thread... some thoughts.

What does "open loop" mean? It simply means "not closed loop". Closed loop means that the ECU is using feedback from the O2 sensor to fine tune the fuel mixture and keep it at stoich (or, I suspect maybe even a tad lean on the Yaris, but that's just a guess). In open loop, the ECU is most definitely still making adjustments and still has complete control of timing and fuel, it's just ignoring the O2 input and using intake air temp (temp affects density, a critical factor), air flow, and RPM to look up the appropriate fueling and timing in a table. By design, this will always be a rich mixture, and timing will be "conservative", similar to that of a distributor with no vacuum advance.

Now, I was thinking about all of this worry about being lean on these SC cars. (because I noticed one for sale for $2500 and had a fleeting moment where I was thinking about it... until I remembered that I don't have the money) Remember, even though your car is "forced induction" with the SC kit, it's a VERY light boost. What is it? 4psi? Maybe 6psi? Guess what? The real problems with fuel and spark retard don't happen until way beyond there. You guys are applying the kind of fear that one should have with a medium-high boost turbo to a low-boost supercharger, and I really don't think it's warranted at all.

I'd rock a Blitz SC right out of the box. Run premium fuel and be happy. Life is too short for such paranoia!
Nexus1155Dorchester · Mar 30, 2009#137
See, but thats the thing, you can get one of these out of the box be happy and be fine, but not run optimally. I think thats what everyone is looking for. And it is such a small amount of boost that supercharger is running.

What I am trying to think now is that if you do have extra injectors it might be the only feasable option to get the AFR correct for now until someone finds an interceptor for the O2 Sensors, but will it cause a rich condition and trigger a CEL as well!. Damn these cars to hell
LorenSafety Harbor, FL · Mar 30, 2009#138
Originally Posted by Nexus1155 ↑
See, but thats the thing, you can get one of these out of the box be happy and be fine, but not run optimally. I think thats what everyone is looking for. And it is such a small amount of boost that supercharger is running.

What I am trying to think now is that if you do have extra injectors it might be the only feasable option to get the AFR correct for now until someone finds an interceptor for the O2 Sensors, but will it cause a rich condition and trigger a CEL as well!. Damn these cars to hell
Okay, I'll buy that (though I don't think there's THAT much more to gain by tuning the fuel WITHOUT adding more boost). But, the topic of this thread was, I thought... "worry" about being too lean. Worrying, I assumed about possible detonation and engine damage, not about leaving a little bit of power on the table.

One last thought: Tuning to get every last HP out of an engine is an art as much as it is a science, it's hard to do. If you screw up in the process of tuning it, you can do some damage. And once you've tuned it, you're right on the ragged edge of... trouble. Unless you're running a race team with a budget to replace the engine when it breaks, it's a lot smarter to go ahead and leave a little bit of performance untapped. Leave some margin for error. Leave the tune such that if your fuel happens to be 88.5 octane one day instead of 91, the engine still won't detonate. Out of the box, the Blitz is giving you 20% more power than stock... be happy! Be RELIABLY happy! (isn't that why you bought a Toyota?)

What's left on the table with the Blitz, anyway? Another 2%. Is it really worth all of the extra money, hassle and potential reliability issues for 4-5 hp? Every wire you cut and splice, every wire you add, every piece of hardware you add is another potential point of failure on your car.
PETERPOOPOahu · Mar 30, 2009#139
They are saying there is possibly 20-30hp to gain with a tune.
LorenSafety Harbor, FL · Mar 30, 2009#140
Originally Posted by PETERPOOP ↑
They are saying there is possibly 20-30hp to gain with a tune.
I'll believe that when I see it.

Let me qualify that. The bolt-on, out-of-the box Blitz SC kit with fully tuned and optimized fuel and spark. The initial installation is only good for about 25%, or 25-30 hp. No way is optimizing the fuel and spark going to DOUBLE that. You'll find another 3-8%... maybe as much as 10% or so, just like you would by tuning the car without the SC. That's the factory's margin of safety that you're playing with.

Now, you might see something close to that with a lot of OTHER additional mods, like a complete free-flowing intake, larger TB, better flowing intake manifold, some head work, a good header and a complete free-flowing exhaust. But, that's an awful lot of other stuff that doesn't really fall into the category of "fuel and spark tuning". And, even with all of that, I still don't think you're going to DOUBLE the output of the SC without raising the level of boost.
Nexus1155Dorchester · Mar 30, 2009#141
Ehhhh I don't know about factual numbers, but if you are running stoich on a supercharger you are being robbed of power.

Get the fuel to the correct AFR and increase ignition as it will be more allowable, you will be golden. But obviously at this point you know you are being robbed of precious power that you could have.

Tuning takes some skill and knowledge, but it is not a rocket science.


As Loren said as well you would need to upgrade the flowing parts of this engine. I think the real kicker is to see the results after the throttle body upgrade..
eTiMaGoBangkok, Thailand · Mar 30, 2009#142
as far as I understand, 14.7 stoichical air fuel ratio is the sweet spot for best catalytic converter effiency, not necessarily power?

But yes, Loren does have a good point, tuning for maximum power does reduce the safety/reliability overhead that Toyota has engineered into this car. Caveat Emptor, as the saying goes
kurokoma-kunmy own little world · Mar 30, 2009#143
Originally Posted by Loren ↑
I still don't think you're going to DOUBLE the output of the SC without raising the level of boost.
Ok, well I do like what Loren said about leaving sleeping superchargers lie, as I said the same thing a few pages back 😆

BUT, since he raised the topic of added boost, and mad science also appeals to me (and we have already strayed so far from the original topic) I'd appreciate it if you'd all give opinions on my theoretical question... NST is considering developing a set of pullies for the s/c application (overdrive crank and underdrive water pump, the only configuration that will fit in the given space). Mike estimates the combination of the two could produce an additional 2 psi of boost, or up to 20 whp. The way I understand it, boost works on a geometric progression--you get more power out of those last 2 psi than the first 2 in other words--so these pullies could nearly double the hp ouput.

I expressed interest in letting my car be the guinea pig--nothing difficult about changing out some pullies--but no one can say for sure whether the fuel system can keep up, and for all the reasons mentioned I hesitate to tackle a fuel system revamp...

Based on what you have all derived from this discussion, what are your opinions? Could I at least go ahead and be the test mule without too much danger to the engine?

I think we decided the fuel injectors are max 230cc, max fuel pressure at the rail is 46.9 psi, but even with these figures I'll be damned if I can find any way to calculate the max hp for sure.
kurokoma-kunmy own little world · Mar 30, 2009#144
Oh i know, thanks! 🙂 I want to buy that one yarisdarkness is parting out but I think he's still organizing prices and so forth... if I dont hear soon I already have one picked out on ebay.

The NST pullies are still in the R+D phase anyway, I talked it over with Garm before this thread came up, so I plan to continue gathering info and insights before committing to anything.
Nexus1155Dorchester · Mar 30, 2009#145
What kind of oil does everyone use here? That seems like a lot of sludge buildup...

If the ECU is the way people say it is it will compensate for the extra fuel to bring it to 14.7 when you add more air to the system. If you are worried about the injectors duty, upgrade to TC injectors for a little extra security. But even with that little added boost, it should bring you to about where a turbo with 6psi of power has. So It has been done power wise before, and all in all you should be good to go? :)
LorenSafety Harbor, FL · Mar 30, 2009#146
Kuro, bumping the boost up to 8psi is where you start having the real FI headaches. I wouldn't recommend being the guinea pig for this unless you have the means to really monitor things AND deal with everything that's likely to come up, like needing more fuel, needing less ignition advance, and possibly even the need for intercooling or water injection to reduce the charge temperature.

Keep in mind that Blitz is a big company that did their homework, and did their R&D and testing in-house before putting a product on the market. NST is not at the same level, and they're asking you to help with their development at YOUR own risk.

As to the power question, the increase in power is going to be somewhat proportional to the increase in pressure... with 14.7 being the basis, no zero. So, if you've got 4 psi of boost, that's a 27% increase in air. You'll lose some of that due to having to compress the charge in the intake piping and manifold, etc, so you probably don't see a full 27% increase in air introduced to the cylinder. So, maybe 20-25%? Which is about what people are seeing on the dyno from the Blitz kit, right?

Bump that up by 2 psi and you're at 6psi, or 40.8% over atmospheric pressure. So, you could see as much as 40% more power, but realistically, 30-35%.

Numbers are a funny thing. Much depends on whether you want to be optimistic or pessimistic in your estimates.

There's a reason why the Blitz kit is limited in the amount of boost it delivers. If it was EASY to reliably provide more boost and more power, they'd do it!
kurokoma-kunmy own little world · Mar 30, 2009#147
Originally Posted by Loren ↑
There's a reason why the Blitz kit is limited in the amount of boost it delivers. If it was EASY to reliably provide more boost and more power, they'd do it!
Thanks for the analysis. Yep, the "easy" factor is why I chose the Blitz kit in the first place (well, that and the low end torque 😁).

When I talked with Garm about the NST pullies we were hoping they might be another bolt-on application like a compressor itself--this is pretty much the only thing customers like me are gonna want to buy.

Well, I dunno... I think it might be biting off more than I care to chew... but the idea is still out there for folks willing to overhaul the fuel and engine management systems but are looking for a way to make additional boost.
Nexus1155Dorchester · Mar 30, 2009#148
lol your probably using regular crap oil then, I would recommend switching to Mobil 1 Synthetic, it should solve all of that gunked up problems
largeorangefontSo Cal, OC · Mar 30, 2009#149
Originally Posted by Loren ↑

Now, I was thinking about all of this worry about being lean on these SC cars. (because I noticed one for sale for $2500 and had a fleeting moment where I was thinking about it... until I remembered that I don't have the money) Remember, even though your car is "forced induction" with the SC kit, it's a VERY light boost. What is it? 4psi? Maybe 6psi? Guess what? The real problems with fuel and spark retard don't happen until way beyond there. You guys are applying the kind of fear that one should have with a medium-high boost turbo to a low-boost supercharger, and I really don't think it's warranted at all.

I'd rock a Blitz SC right out of the box. Run premium fuel and be happy. Life is too short for such paranoia!
This is what I said the the beginning of the thread. These guys are not going to blow their cars up, they are just not optimal. They would get better mileage and more power under the curve with more agressive timing and richer AFRs, VS. the current setup of leaner AFRs and conservative timing.
largeorangefontSo Cal, OC · Mar 30, 2009#150
Originally Posted by Nexus1155 ↑
See, but thats the thing, you can get one of these out of the box be happy and be fine, but not run optimally. I think thats what everyone is looking for. And it is such a small amount of boost that supercharger is running.

What I am trying to think now is that if you do have extra injectors it might be the only feasable option to get the AFR correct for now until someone finds an interceptor for the O2 Sensors, but will it cause a rich condition and trigger a CEL as well!. Damn these cars to hell
You are really overcomplicating this. If you really want adjustability, go buy a Greddy Emanage and be done with it. I know that is not the answer you want to hear, but in the end it is the simplest and cheapest.