Replies continued
atomic_hojiThread starterKincardine, ON, Canada · Nov 2, 2018#101Thanks for the feedback Tom! I agree, it seems unlikely the injectors are an issue, was thinking it would rule them out at least - the engine did sit at a wrecker for about a year with the fuel line crimped and no idea if it was drained properly, I figured maybe ethanol gunk stuck in one of more injectors.
After I replaced the MAF and intake with iM models vs. xD and the MAF related codes went away I'd been ruling out MAF problems and basically ignoring it to chase other things. BUT, you bring a good point - I've been so focused on trending the LTFT and AFR, but I haven't included the MAF signal to see how it's responding! I'll have to play with the data I had collected already and plot it again with the MAF signal. And, definitely worth running it through the rpm range as you suggest to see if it's even behaving as it should.
The iM does run a Fuel Pump Control ECU like the 2014+ Corolla and a number of other newer Toyota's do; except the Yaris, which is out-dated... which is also great because it's simple! lol I have wired an iM FPC ECU in and it seems to respond as it should, which is basically demand 70% fuel pump duty unless you go full throttle, then it bumps up to 100% fuel pump duty.
I'll have a try at a couple of things as you suggested before I go and start yanking injectors.. 😁
Thanks as always for the help!
-- Adam
ArmstrongRacingSan Diego · Nov 5, 2018#102So do you have a xD intake that your not using any more? I may be interested in that
atomic_hojiThread starterKincardine, ON, Canada · Nov 6, 2018#103I do actually.. I did modify it to fit the 3rd Gen. as it doesn't fit under the headlight like on the xD. When I'm home tonight I'll have a dig around and see if I can get you a picture of what I've got. I'll PM you tonight.
I did also have a look back through some data and did a few 2nd to 3rd gear pulls at different loads; well, wife drove while I data logged. The MAF responds linearly with revs, but when you throw the clutch in the MAF tanks and everything goes squirrelly from there.. And some random squirrelly stuff here and there with the AFR - which I did run a known working AFR sensor with the same results. I started plotting other things, like VALVMATIC angles as the Lift has a huge impact on air, but don't know what's normal on there or abnormal - I did notice VALVMATIC Target angle is never populated.. always reads 0. wondering if it has an issue and when load drops it's dropping Lift, reducing air flow, and the system goes squirrelly from there..
Just thinking out loud..
-- Adam
atomic_hojiThread starterKincardine, ON, Canada · Nov 6, 2018#104Since I can't figure out how to stash the picture somewhere without making it super tiny...
-- Adam
Picture not included in this copy1 attachment not included in this copy
ArmstrongRacingSan Diego · Nov 7, 2018#105#6
atomic_hojiThread starterKincardine, ON, Canada · Dec 4, 2018#106Quick update: been busy busy with studying for work, but after the last test I took the weekend off to kickback, relax, and actually did a bit of work on the Yaris. Unfortunately, I think the brain marbles as to the troubleshooting I've done on the Yaris have been displaced by studying. 🙄
I followed Tom's advice and had a run through the MAF response. Took the car out with my wife driving and had her pull through gears gently, then progressively using more throttle up to basically flooring it in 1st, through 2nd and 3rd. MAF seems to respond as expected. Do find that the values are a little high as compared to the service manual (not surprising there's extra air given the negative fuel trim) but then my idle is a bit on the high side anyway - more on a related, new issue in a minute.. :face palm:
Using my fancy little jig I also cleaned the injectors with carb cleaner, just for the sake of due diligence. It didn't help, but it's done, and it's the first time I've tried it so it was an educational experience, lol.
In a prior job I was a Control Tech and in flow measuring applications where you had short pipe runs and turbulence we would install flow straighteners to help stabilize the flow readings. There are the same sorts of things for automotive intakes - some manufacturers actually use a rough sort of straightener in their intakes. I installed a piece of door screen across the end of the intake (held by the filter clamp) and it brought the LTFT down into the -20% to -26% region - the car will go for a couple of days before the codes pop back on now; PROGRESS! 👍 I've ordered an actual flow straightener to fit my intake and I'll have to see if it helps. Also ordered a used, OEM MAF from eBay - I still have a dis-trust of this aftermarket MAF and the used OEM was actually cheaper than what I paid for the aftermarket! Have a couple of other ideas related to airflow as well that I'll keep in my back pocket..
Anyhow, new issue: after clearing the learned values and resetting everything after messing about with the car I now have a revving problem. I've read the Scion iMs have a "rev-hang" issue between shifts, but that's not quite the issue.. When I put the clutch in the revs drop, then bounce up to about 3000 rpm and sit there for about 2-3s, then drop off. I have to stop at a guardhouse on my way in to work and I get looked at funny as to why I'm sitting revving my engine - I'm just waiting to get hauled aside.. lol Now, the embarrassing part: this could be something to do with the injector cleaning or the screen on the air intake (not too bad); it could be because I kicked my ECM across the garage floor on accident (dammit!); or it could be because I disconnected my throttle body while powered (the clue should have been that it was making an electrical whine.. :face palm:)
Ever have one of those days..? lol
OH, on a much better note, I did get my microimage engine bay short shift kit installed. Fits great, and I can now install the block heater as an added bonus. Transmission is nice and notchy now; because #racecar! 😁
-- Adam
06YarisRSFredericton, New Brunswick, Canada · Dec 4, 2018#107 Originally Posted by
atomic_hoji ↑
Ever have one of those days..? lol
Yup, many of them.
And, I too unplugged my MAF while powered. I heard the "whine". No adverse effects as of yet.
My chance to offer encouragement in return. Keep goooooooing! Can't wait to witness the end result. It will be legendary!
atomic_hojiThread starterKincardine, ON, Canada · Dec 4, 2018#108lol, thanks man. A dash clear of warning lights will feel pretty good. 😁
I didn't mention, but is a nicety, that I finally re-installed my trim pieces; center console, windscreen bits, etc.. so it looks like a complete car again and no a ghetto-mobile as my wife has referred to it. lol
-- Adam
ArmstrongRacingSan Diego · Dec 4, 2018#109I’d still say that -20% is still going to eventually result in a rich condition fault. Let’s see how it goes though, I’m inexperienced with the valvematic fuel mapping
atomic_hojiThread starterKincardine, ON, Canada · Dec 6, 2018#110For reference / interest, this is the setup I used to the clean the injectors. Installed a piece of tygon hose onto the injector at one end, sprayed carb cleaner fluid into the tygon, then put an air attachment on the other end. Secured with hose clamps. It uses the air to pressurize the setup to 10-15 psi; fuel pressure is ~50psi or so, so no issue for injector, but I didn't trust the hose clamps to go
too high.. lol
To fire the injectors I had a couple of wires attached to my 12V powersports battery from my ATV for power (not shown). While I held the injector assembly, I had my wife hold the negative on one terminal and rapidly tap the positive on the other terminal. Did this until the injector was clear of fluid. Carb cleaner stinks - do this in a well ventilated area!
Spray patterns looked decent when we were doing it; because of the tip installed on the injector there are two distinct injection sprays - one to each intake port.
-- Adam
Picture not included in this copy1 attachment not included in this copy
atomic_hojiThread starterKincardine, ON, Canada · Dec 6, 2018#111 Originally Posted by
ArmstrongRacing ↑ I’d still say that -20% is still going to eventually result in a rich condition fault. Let’s see how it goes though, I’m inexperienced with the valvematic fuel mapping
Without looking it up, I believe you're right - beyond +/- 15% LTFT rings a bell for being considered abnormal. I'll see how these changes work and if it brings the LTFT value down further having a proper airflow straightener installed vs. door screen. Still waiting on my OEM MAF to arrive too. Fingers crossed.
I does sit in the back of my mind whether or not using a regular VVTi would have caused the same issues and/or been easier to troubleshoot. There really isn't a ton of information out there on Valvematic even though it's been around for a while. But, now I know for next time.. 😁
-- Adam
06YarisRSFredericton, New Brunswick, Canada · Dec 6, 2018#112Home cleaning of injectors = very cool. 👍
tmontagueCaledonia Ont. · Dec 7, 2018#113 Originally Posted by
atomic_hoji ↑ For reference / interest, this is the setup I used to the clean the injectors. Installed a piece of tygon hose onto the injector at one end, sprayed carb cleaner fluid into the tygon, then put an air attachment on the other end. Secured with hose clamps. It uses the air to pressurize the setup to 10-15 psi; fuel pressure is ~50psi or so, so no issue for injector, but I didn't trust the hose clamps to go too high.. lol
To fire the injectors I had a couple of wires attached to my 12V powersports battery from my ATV for power (not shown). While I held the injector assembly, I had my wife hold the negative on one terminal and rapidly tap the positive on the other terminal. Did this until the injector was clear of fluid. Carb cleaner stinks - do this in a well ventilated area!
Spray patterns looked decent when we were doing it; because of the tip installed on the injector there are two distinct injection sprays - one to each intake port.
-- Adam
Attachment 60073
Nice set up for the injectors👍
DarkShadowFoxMassachusetts · Dec 7, 2018#114how much HP is this swap good for stock again.
atomic_hojiThread starterKincardine, ON, Canada · Dec 7, 2018#115 Originally Posted by
06YarisRS ↑ Home cleaning of injectors = very cool. 👍
Originally Posted by
tmontague ↑ Nice set up for the injectors👍
Thanks guys. I've seen a bunch of videos on YouTube where people use the pressure from the carb cleaner can and it seems to work ok. I just figured a steady air pressure set by a PRV on the fluid would push the cleaner through as well or (hopefully) a bit better. Still not a professional cleaning and calibration by any means, but it was a good run to see if there was any injectors with poor spray patterns, streams, etc..
Originally Posted by
DarkShadowFox ↑ how much HP is this swap good for stock again.
2016 Scion iM literature calls the 2ZR-FAE 137 hp and 126 ft-lb at the crank - vs. 1NZ-FE 106 hp and 103 ft-lb at the crank. Yields an increase of 29% hp and 22% torque. As I've noted before, it's not #zomgihaveasportzcar fast, but it's noticeably quicker and makes the power differently than the 1NZ-FE. I keep it well under 100 mph. 😉
-- Adam
DarkShadowFoxMassachusetts · Dec 7, 2018#116 Originally Posted by
atomic_hoji ↑ Thanks guys. I've seen a bunch of videos on YouTube where people use the pressure from the carb cleaner can and it seems to work ok. I just figured a steady air pressure set by a PRV on the fluid would push the cleaner through as well or (hopefully) a bit better. Still not a professional cleaning and calibration by any means, but it was a good run to see if there was any injectors with poor spray patterns, streams, etc..
2016 Scion iM literature calls the 2ZR-FAE 137 hp and 126 ft-lb at the crank - vs. 1NZ-FE 106 hp and 103 ft-lb at the crank. Yields an increase of 29% hp and 22% torque. As I've noted before, it's not #zomgihaveasportzcar fast, but it's noticeably quicker and makes the power differently than the 1NZ-FE. I keep it well under 100 mph. 😉
-- Adam
i think i will use the LE eco corolla because it has 140 hp
atomic_hojiThread starterKincardine, ON, Canada · Dec 8, 2018#117 Originally Posted by
DarkShadowFox ↑ i think i will use the LE eco corolla because it has 140 hp
My recollection is that the Corolla LE ECO only came with a CVT; I could be wrong if you look back to earlier years though.. If that suits what you want then you're aces - and may have the first CVT swapped Yaris? However, if you want to run with the Yaris AT or MT then you will run into difficulties. Pulling the engine from a Corolla LE ECO will get you a 2ZR-FAE, but just mind the fact that you'll need an iM (or other -FAE based) ECM to run stock with the AT or MT transmissions.
Of course, if you're mixing and matching engines and transmissions and not using a stock setup then you're well out of my league and diving into new territory. 👍
-- Adam
DarkShadowFoxMassachusetts · Dec 8, 2018#118 Originally Posted by
atomic_hoji ↑ My recollection is that the Corolla LE ECO only came with a CVT; I could be wrong if you look back to earlier years though.. If that suits what you want then you're aces - and may have the first CVT swapped Yaris? However, if you want to run with the Yaris AT or MT then you will run into difficulties. Pulling the engine from a Corolla LE ECO will get you a 2ZR-FAE, but just mind the fact that you'll need an iM (or other -FAE based) ECM to run stock with the AT or MT transmissions.
Of course, if you're mixing and matching engines and transmissions and not using a stock setup then you're well out of my league and diving into new territory. 👍
-- Adam
the 4AT is much stronger then the CVT why i wanted to use it, and i wanted the extra hp the torque numbers look absymal though on both vehicles both motors for these cars run for under 1000$ so this might be the next budget swap when working with the 3rd gens. #corollacru
Edit: Do the scion IM gauges fit on this car those are looking very similar to a certain model that was released in europe, minus the auris hybrid face.
edit 2: might have to just bite the bullet for now to get better performance after seeing this thread and seeing how cheap they are, i wanted an AWD turbo motor but theres no sense in going for more HP if its unusable and will cost more weight, the lighter engine from the IM will offset the small gain in HP.
atomic_hojiThread starterKincardine, ON, Canada · Dec 8, 2018#119 Originally Posted by
DarkShadowFox ↑ the 4AT is much stronger then the CVT why i wanted to use it,
...
Edit: Do the scion IM gauges fit on this car those are looking very similar to a certain model that was released in europe, minus the auris hybrid face.
...
edit 2: might have to just bite the bullet for now to get better performance after seeing this thread and seeing how cheap they are, i wanted an AWD ...
If you're going to use the AT from the Yaris then I think you're best bet is an iM ECM; definitely have a look into it. Not sure about the gauges, I use the Yaris gauge cluster. Not sure there's an AWD drivetrain that mates to a ZR engine, that's new territory.
Update on the LTFT: I installed the airflow straightener this afternoon and went for a drive. It looked like the LTFT was getting better as it seemed to float around -17% or so, sometimes getting better, occasionally dropping into the -20s%. I reset the learned values and drove it home from in town... and... it's... -36% again. Poop. So either it was working, and then honking on it flung it into the intake and it's stuck in there against the MAF or throttle body (uh-oh!) or it's not working at all - in fact the door screen actually seemed better at that point, lol.
Still waiting on the OEM MAF to arrive.. fingers crossed.
-- Adam
DarkShadowFoxMassachusetts · Dec 8, 2018#120 Originally Posted by
atomic_hoji ↑ If you're going to use the AT from the Yaris then I think you're best bet is an iM ECM; definitely have a look into it. Not sure about the gauges, I use the Yaris gauge cluster. Not sure there's an AWD drivetrain that mates to a ZR engine, that's new territory.
Update on the LTFT: I installed the airflow straightener this afternoon and went for a drive. It looked like the LTFT was getting better as it seemed to float around -17% or so, sometimes getting better, occasionally dropping into the -20s%. I reset the learned values and drove it home from in town... and... it's... -36% again. Poop. So either it was working, and then honking on it flung it into the intake and it's stuck in there against the MAF or throttle body (uh-oh!) or it's not working at all - in fact the door screen actually seemed better at that point, lol.
Still waiting on the OEM MAF to arrive.. fingers crossed.
-- Adam
japans auris aka scion IM 2011(huurp i think)-2017 model years gets 4wd optional, what wont the japanese put 4wd on
ITS A BED IT HAS 4wd !!!11111
edit the gauges i am thinking of is a 2017 Sport plus gauge cluster face on an IM Frame.
atomic_hojiThread starterKincardine, ON, Canada · Dec 16, 2018#121 Originally Posted by
DarkShadowFox ↑ japans auris aka scion IM 2011(huurp i think)-2017 model years gets 4wd optional, what wont the japanese put 4wd on
...
Well that might give you your cake and let you eat it too. 👍
--
Regarding the on-going fuel issues - GOOD news... for people who like... GOOD NEWS (for a change). 😁
After the flow straightener seemed to not do too much, I received my used OEM MAF in the mail on Monday and popped it in, reset learned values, etc.. I did a quick run and it seemed to be happier - but then I've thought that before. Over the past week I have seen squat for CEL/MIL and a run into town last night to get gas I found LTFT is both more stable (less variation) and slightly positive (+6% to +8%). I think I can
officially say it's a successful 2ZR-FAE swap now. 👍
After all the reading, troubleshooting, checking and double-checking, the problem was an aftermarket - brand new, popular aftermarket brand - MAF that did actually meet the service manual checks, but apparently is calibrated incorrectly or functionally can't meet the specs of the OEM unit. The
real kick in the pants is that although I had looked briefly at the time I bought the new MAF, I found this used OEM unit for about half the price too! 🙄 In this case, the internet is right - pop for an OEM unit, it's really worth it. Too late to return the aftermarket unit, but I've requested a warranty replacement with the hopes that I'll get one that works and can keep it as a backup or sell it.
Never-the-less.. car seems happy. It's funny, it ran noticeably different after changing the MAF - different idle sound and feel. Of course, because fuelling is different and it wasn't revving as much I found myself having to avoid stalling it for the first couple of days, lol - the only upside before replacement, the kick-up in idle revs made it ready for go time off each stop! 😆 But, over the week the stupid high revs at idle sorted itself and it hasn't done that in a couple of days either.
Other than a few wiring tidy-up things, the only additional improvement regarding daily driving for the car would be to find a 2017+ Corolla iM that includes TSS-C so the pre-collision system will stop complaining; the ECM has no idea what's talking to it, so it causes issues with the VSC/TRAC - which is actually disabled when a CEL/MIL comes on, so the MAF issue fixed gives VSC/TRAC back now too.
Thanks again to everyone who has helped and/ore encouraged through the whole swap process, the support here is awesome and hugely appreciated. 🎉
-- Adam
tmontagueCaledonia Ont. · Dec 16, 2018#122😲👍 DUUUDE this is great news, really happy you were able to figure out the issue and although you're probably banging your head against the wall, I'm sure you're glad that it was something so simple and not more compliacted.
Enjoy the new whip. We have to get everyone together this summer who's somewhat local in the GTA or who can make the drive and meet at a track or soemthing.
ArmstrongRacingSan Diego · Dec 16, 2018#123Well I can’t say I’m surprised, diagnosing a MAF is usually a shot in the dark. I believe we discussed this earlier in the thread, and last year I wrote up a blog on how tricky MAF’s can be. They show good voltage and a clean signal, but still causes issues. Little bastards...
DarkShadowFoxMassachusetts · Dec 16, 2018#124when it comes to MAF unlesss your going to be running a standalone like haltech or something always run the OEM maf and run a piggyback.
DarkShadowFoxMassachusetts · Dec 16, 2018#125 Originally Posted by
atomic_hoji ↑ Well that might give you your cake and let you eat it too. 👍
--
Regarding the on-going fuel issues - GOOD news... for people who like... GOOD NEWS (for a change). 😁
After the flow straightener seemed to not do too much, I received my used OEM MAF in the mail on Monday and popped it in, reset learned values, etc.. I did a quick run and it seemed to be happier - but then I've thought that before. Over the past week I have seen squat for CEL/MIL and a run into town last night to get gas I found LTFT is both more stable (less variation) and slightly positive (+6% to +8%). I think I can officially say it's a successful 2ZR-FAE swap now. 👍
After all the reading, troubleshooting, checking and double-checking, the problem was an aftermarket - brand new, popular aftermarket brand - MAF that did actually meet the service manual checks, but apparently is calibrated incorrectly or functionally can't meet the specs of the OEM unit. The real kick in the pants is that although I had looked briefly at the time I bought the new MAF, I found this used OEM unit for about half the price too! 🙄 In this case, the internet is right - pop for an OEM unit, it's really worth it. Too late to return the aftermarket unit, but I've requested a warranty replacement with the hopes that I'll get one that works and can keep it as a backup or sell it.
Never-the-less.. car seems happy. It's funny, it ran noticeably different after changing the MAF - different idle sound and feel. Of course, because fuelling is different and it wasn't revving as much I found myself having to avoid stalling it for the first couple of days, lol - the only upside before replacement, the kick-up in idle revs made it ready for go time off each stop! 😆 But, over the week the stupid high revs at idle sorted itself and it hasn't done that in a couple of days either.
Other than a few wiring tidy-up things, the only additional improvement regarding daily driving for the car would be to find a 2017+ Corolla iM that includes TSS-C so the pre-collision system will stop complaining; the ECM has no idea what's talking to it, so it causes issues with the VSC/TRAC - which is actually disabled when a CEL/MIL comes on, so the MAF issue fixed gives VSC/TRAC back now too.
Thanks again to everyone who has helped and/ore encouraged through the whole swap process, the support here is awesome and hugely appreciated. 🎉
-- Adam
https://parts.camelbacktoyota.com/pa...?siteid=214329 https://jp-carparts.com/toyota/carlist.php?maker=toyota 06YarisRSFredericton, New Brunswick, Canada · Dec 16, 2018#126Congrats, Adam!!! Such awesome news! 👍
DarkShadowFoxMassachusetts · Dec 17, 2018#127you know i forgot to ask, which gauge cluster did you use in the yaris and how did you fit it?
atomic_hojiThread starterKincardine, ON, Canada · Dec 17, 2018#128 Originally Posted by
tmontague ↑ 😲👍 DUUUDE this is great news, really happy you were able to figure out the issue and although you're probably banging your head against the wall, I'm sure you're glad that it was something so simple and not more compliacted.
Enjoy the new whip. We have to get everyone together this summer who's somewhat local in the GTA or who can make the drive and meet at a track or soemthing.
Yes, yes I am - the blessing that it was simple, the curse that it was something I overlooked for too long.. lol
A meet and/or track day would be great. Wasn't able to make it down this summer, but hoping 2019 should be better - at least early in the summer is looking more likely. Either way, looking forward to getting down to meet up with some of the GTA and area YW folks. 🎉
Originally Posted by
ArmstrongRacing ↑ Well I can’t say I’m surprised, diagnosing a MAF is usually a shot in the dark. I believe we discussed this earlier in the thread, and last year I wrote up a blog on how tricky MAF’s can be. They show good voltage and a clean signal, but still causes issues. Little bastards...
Ya, I recall you suggesting it and really thought I had done due diligence to test the damn thing; it really looked like it was responding, etc.. But, as you say, the little bastards are fickle beasts..
Originally Posted by
06YarisRS ↑ Congrats, Adam!!! Such awesome news! 👍
Thanks buddy! 👍
Originally Posted by
DarkShadowFox ↑ you know i forgot to ask, which gauge cluster did you use in the yaris and how did you fit it?
No change in gauge cluster, everything works with the stock 3rd. gen cluster; I do have an SE if that makes a difference on the dash - I haven't seen an LE to know if it's the same.
-- Adam
DarkShadowFoxMassachusetts · Dec 18, 2018#129so in terms of the steering rack and subframe and assorted components how does all of this entire thing assemble into a third gen. can i get more detailed pictures, i have my entire GSIC for my yaris i just like to see the handiwork.
atomic_hojiThread starterKincardine, ON, Canada · Dec 22, 2018#130No changes to the steering rack, subframe or anything else under there. You need to the RH engine mount from the Scion xD - both frame side mount and engine bracket - but the dogbone and LH trans mounts from the Yaris work. Some careful movements and serious grunt and that gets the engine into the engine bay. Should find it's documented briefly here, and in more detail in one of the 2nd gen. swap threads.
I didn't take any pictures of subframe, etc.. because there were no changes needed - 1NZ out, 2ZR in with the xD mounts.
-- Adam
logorisToronto · Feb 23, 2019#131fantastic build, glad it all worked out.
It gives me some hope for mine once its paid off.
Id certainly like to meet the yw people in the gta