Yarisworld Archive

2018 Yaris SE 5MT - T-Sport w/Valvematic!

131 posts · 122,305 views · page 2 of 3

Replies continued

atomic_hojiThread starterKincardine, ON, Canada · May 2, 2018#51
Started! - in progress.. But will keep working on making it a decent resource to follow. 👍

LOL - it's funny you say the Scion tC. When I was first debating the swap I naturally wandered down the path of the 2AR. This led to searching for Yaris 2AR swaps, which led to the Papadakis Racing 2AR powered Corolla iM Formula Drift car, which led to YouTube, which has resulted in Formula Drift making the Family Calendar on event weekends.

If I recall, the bit I found led me to believe that the engine mount setup wasn't straight forward like the 2ZR and it would have involved more frame cutting due to the length of the 2AR; also exhaust is opposite side, etc.. etc.. Ultimately, the 2ZR approach was a much more elegant solution for a boost in performance on a daily driver, so here we are!

Of course, that's not to say you shouldn't have a go at the 2AR swap... and start a thread... soon... so we can couch co-pilot the build with you. 😆

-- Adam
ArmstrongRacingSan Diego · May 2, 2018#52
Hahaha, yeah racing has a way of taking over the whole families free time. I’m just blessed with an understanding wife and very committed sponsors!

The 2AR is tempting, but I’d like to keep playing with the 2ZR since it’s lighter. Also I am interested in using the 3ZR block to do a 2.0L hybrid build one day
atomic_hojiThread starterKincardine, ON, Canada · May 23, 2018#53
Long delay since last post.. Wish I could say I was ripping around the county with the awesomeness of the 2ZR under the hood, but unfortunately that's not the case. Had a miserable couple of weeks going back and forth to hospital, taking care of finances, etc.. for my Mum; she then passed over the holiday weekend (Victoria Day here in Canada). Feel like I've volumes or time on my hands, but on the other hand basically no time at all - probably spent most of it pacing or flopped on the couch when not actively busy with things. Got off my butt and up to some wrenching and other chores today - finding it's better to keep occupied than dwell; although, man, I needed the catch up on sleep.. Have the rest of the week off on bereavement leave to attend to services, lawyer meetings, etc.. but going to try to get some much needed updates into this and the immobilizer threads to keep focused on something enjoyable.

---

Swap update! 😲

When I took the car for a quick rip I've found that it's not firing smooth at idle and actually stalled out when I rolled into the driveway with the clutch in. So I checked the OBD2 codes and found that I have codes P030# (0 to 4 inclusive; 0: misfire on multiple cylinders, and then 1-4: misfire in respective # cylinder) and P0171: running lean; codes all pending, I suspect not stored as I haven't been through a second 'drive cycle'..

So far, I've checked the MAF and it seems to be reasonably in spec - brought it in the house and let it sit at room temp of 21C then took a measurement of the resistance and the number is at the low side of spec, which is for 20C, so it seems like it's not the culprit. I also had a run through of the connections in case there is air in-leakage, but they seem reasonably tight. Wondering if the Injen cold air intake is causing it to lean out - it is designed for a 2ZR-FE, but then the FE runs via throttle body, where-as once warm the FAE apparently throttles using the inlet valves and the throttle body is wide-open (at least that the gist of what I've read - digging into it more). Of course, piss-poor electrical connections are on the short list.. lol

Ideas for troubleshooting appreciated as I'm sure there will be things I'm overlooking.

-- Adam
atomic_hojiThread starterKincardine, ON, Canada · May 23, 2018#54
Originally Posted by ArmstrongRacing ↑
Hahaha, yeah racing has a way of taking over the whole families free time. I’m just blessed with an understanding wife and very committed sponsors!

The 2AR is tempting, but I’d like to keep playing with the 2ZR since it’s lighter. Also I am interested in using the 3ZR block to do a 2.0L hybrid build one day
lol - it's true, it does. The car/truck bug requires a very understanding relationship. I'm very fortunate that in the several years since we moved into our current house my wife has yet to park in the garage including all winter (neither have I, of course. lol). The garage is no place for a running vehicle, that's where we build! 😆

Love the idea of playing with the 3ZR to make a 2.0L setup. From what I've seen, but without pulling one apart, I think the ZR is really the little sister to the AR and has the potential to produce power in the same way - obviously scaled. But I bet a lot of the same tricks will work, if you can find the supporting parts. Have my mind on the idea of doing a 2ZR-FE teardown and documenting it; can't let that get on the radar until the Yaris is resolved and I clear out some truck stuff - my wife's understanding does have limits... lol

-- Adam
3cyltrboOttawa · May 23, 2018#55
So sorry to hear of your mom passing.

When my dad passed 4 years ago, I spent alot of time in the garage tinkering on stuff in the days and weeks after.

For me, I found that I could be in a totally different place emotionally when I was in the calmness of the garage. Laying on my back under a car and tinkering, really helped me.

I must have made 25 adjustments back and forth to the rear suspension in my Yaris........ just subconsciously keeping myself focused on something other than the lost loved one.

As far as the swap, hopefully you get it sorted in order to take advantage of our too short summer season.

Cheers

Will
atomic_hojiThread starterKincardine, ON, Canada · May 27, 2018#56
Appreciate the kind words, thanks Will. I find the same thing, that tinkering has been a good way to keep distracted from other things; have definitely been occupied with troubleshooting the lean condition - I think I've pulled the battery in and out about a dozen times going after various sensors, etc.. lol. We've also kept busy doing family activities together, which has been good.

Summer too short? It's already starting in May and will stay hot until September! 😁

Am looking forward to having it run reliably. My 1981 Toyota truck with a 1987 22RE swapped in took a fresh battery, didn't start, I kicked the F* out of the starter, and she runs - always runs for me.. FJC is the same way. Just don't have the trust with the Yaris yet. Apparently the rule of not messing with the daily driver was supposed to apply to cars as it did with my trucks, so my wife says now.. 😛

Never-the-less, did make progress - dumped the fuel tank to a jerry can, as much as would siphon out, and added a dozen liters of fresh fuel. The misfires have cleared now, but still lean. Running through fuel, air, spark as usual...

Can't imagine fuel is still a problem. Fuel is fresh(er), and being delivered; other 2ZR swaps haven't upgraded the fuel pump, so I don't imagine I'm starving the injectors; could be weak power to injectors if it was wiring.. maybe? Or maybe still just poor quality fuel.

Air: there's too much of it, lol. I've clamped up the exhaust leak good and tight now (no smell, fumes, 'smoke' etc.. detectable), and chased all the lines downstream of the MAF for in leakage - can't find anything. MAF checks out resistance measurement wise, but still wondering if the Cold Air Intake is causing issue due to differing diameters - the diameter narrows at the MAF in order to avoid the issue, but again, maybe the FAE is more picky? Throttle body makes some weird noises, but seems to operate open and closed when in the ON position.

Spark: doesn't seem to be an issue, as it runs, but then maybe a weak spark if the wiring is causing an issue? Haven't put too much weight on the spark, but open to suggestions.

Waiting on a Techstream compatible cable to arrive from an online order. Once I have it and get it setup I'll get a 2-day subscription over a weekend and run through the workshop manual troubleshooting that requires Techstream - it will be able to run sensor and component tests beyond resistance and voltage measurements that I can do currently.

So far, I'm boggled.

I DID, however, get my Mishimoto Fan Controller installed and wired up - was actually fairly straight forward, and I actually used some jumpers in the main Junction Box to keep the factory fan connector in place; once again, if I have to pull the whole sh-bang, there's no modification to the factory Yaris harness.

-- Adam
atomic_hojiThread starterKincardine, ON, Canada · Jun 10, 2018#57
Quick update: replaced MAF with a proper one (as opposed to the cheap, online purchase via chinese market); disconnected the fuel line and used the fuel pump to empty the tank this time and put 10L premium (did some testing) and added another 10L regular fuel in; did another check of all possible air in-leakage points... OBD2 scanner shows fuel trim is now more toward too rich v. too lean.. 🤷 but at least the codes are all clear.

Took it for a longer test drive out some county roads and around a good 'test' loop - nice place to open a car up a bit and power around a curvy industrial road. Engine seems to run well for the most part - exhaust definitely needs to get welded, god what a noise.. lol

Bigger concern with it now is that when I was going around a long, left-hand bend in the road there's a rough noise, almost a growl - reminds me of an out of balance or too much angle on a driveshaft, e.g. when a truck gets lifted.. wondering if either I've dinked installing an axle shaft or if the engine or exhaust is being bumped against the frame/body and causing a vibration.

Oh, and the slip light stays on all the time - guessing due to the difference in 2016 ABS/VSC/TRAC system vs. the 2018 TSS-C system; or iM v. Yaris and they don't want to talk..?

Received my techstream cable in the mail during the week and got the software installed. Didn't purchase a subscription for this weekend as I was away a good portion of the weekend. Will try this upcoming weekend and see what I can play with! 😁

Progress..
-- Adam
tmontagueCaledonia Ont. · Jun 11, 2018#58
Fwiw my car has always had fuel trims showing too rich (approx 10%) ever since I got a custom exhaust made, even back when I had my 1nz, and I have no exhaust leaks.

The noise you are hearing on corners could be axle bind and chances are it would be more violent. Turn sharper and see what happens to see if it gets worse
DarkShadowFoxMassachusetts · Jun 11, 2018#59
why does your engine bay look burned . - .
tmontagueCaledonia Ont. · Jun 11, 2018#60
😕
Originally Posted by DarkShadowFox ↑
why does your engine bay look burned . - .
atomic_hojiThread starterKincardine, ON, Canada · Jun 11, 2018#61
Originally Posted by tmontague ↑
Fwiw my car has always had fuel trims showing too rich (approx 10%) ever since I got a custom exhaust made, even back when I had my 1nz, and I have no exhaust leaks.

The noise you are hearing on corners could be axle bind and chances are it would be more violent. Turn sharper and see what happens to see if it gets worse
Hmm.. well that's good to keep in mind, thanks for the tidbit! 👍

I was reading (and re-reading) last night and went back through your thread on using the Tercel axle to solve the bind problem - which is awesome clever btw.. I took the car out again today and gave a good swerve back and forth. Seems to be only when turning left, but sounds like it's on the right side - which would be the long-side (passenger) axle, not the driver side as you found. Over-extending the passenger side? I doubt I'm tire rubbing as I"m stock height suspension and stock wheel & tire setup. I had also thought the brakes were just coated with rust and such from sitting, but confirmed today that it has a constant vibration in the brake pedal under braking. The noise when turning isn't very loud or bang like, more like a growl... On the drive the CEL/MIL and TRAC OFF lights both came on. I did a bit of searching and, not surprisingly like much of the iM parts, the brake actuator is iM specific; not shared with Yaris or even the Corolla sedan. They communicated via CAN bus, and the being the Yaris brake actuator wired to the Yaris speed sensors, etc.. they're happy, but I wonder if the brake actuator is getting garbage from the ECM and vice versa.. Will have to see.

Originally Posted by DarkShadowFox ↑
why does your engine bay look burned . - .
+1 😕 Not sure what you mean by burnt.. The yellow-orange dis-colouration is the oil "under" (all over) coating. It's a waxy oil coating and is tacky and nasty to work in the engine bay - living in the salt belt it will be good for the car in the long run, but it is a p.i.t.a when wrenching. 🙄

-- Adam
DarkShadowFoxMassachusetts · Jun 11, 2018#62
Originally Posted by atomic_hoji ↑
Hmm.. well that's good to keep in mind, thanks for the tidbit! 👍

I was reading (and re-reading) last night and went back through your thread on using the Tercel axle to solve the bind problem - which is awesome clever btw.. I took the car out again today and gave a good swerve back and forth. Seems to be only when turning left, but sounds like it's on the right side - which would be the long-side (passenger) axle, not the driver side as you found. Over-extending the passenger side? I doubt I'm tire rubbing as I"m stock height suspension and stock wheel & tire setup. I had also thought the brakes were just coated with rust and such from sitting, but confirmed today that it has a constant vibration in the brake pedal under braking. The noise when turning isn't very loud or bang like, more like a growl... On the drive the CEL/MIL and TRAC OFF lights both came on. I did a bit of searching and, not surprisingly like much of the iM parts, the brake actuator is iM specific; not shared with Yaris or even the Corolla sedan. They communicated via CAN bus, and the being the Yaris brake actuator wired to the Yaris speed sensors, etc.. they're happy, but I wonder if the brake actuator is getting garbage from the ECM and vice versa.. Will have to see.



+1 😕 Not sure what you mean by burnt.. The yellow-orange dis-colouration is the oil "under" (all over) coating. It's a waxy oil coating and is tacky and nasty to work in the engine bay - living in the salt belt it will be good for the car in the long run, but it is a p.i.t.a when wrenching. 🙄

-- Adam
my manual said "wax coating applied to engine bay" that must be the "WAX" coating they are talking about.


also cant you just mount up the IM brake actuator thing to the... yeah

heres what you can do when thats happening is like. run it, run an OBD2 scanner while driving see if it throws any codes. I think. I'm an armchair mechanic.
atomic_hojiThread starterKincardine, ON, Canada · Jun 11, 2018#63
My guess is that's what they meant by wax coating then, ya... the shop that did mine got a little carried away I think - it's supposed to be a nice, thin coating, not a globular mess.. lol

Already started shopping for an iM brake actuator, BUT ... before getting too far down that rabbit hole, I checked and the connectors on the Yaris and the iM are completely different; would mean needing to find a connector and terminals and re-wire my Yaris body harness - do-able, but think it needs some troubleshooting and thought first. Also wondering with the change in 2017 to the Corolla iM with TSS-C is the 2017 ECM would play better with the Yaris' brake actuator..

Going to pull the brake actuator connector, fire it up, and see how she behaves without any brake control/assistance. My FJC is a 2007, which is pre-disable VSC/TRAC capability. I found if you pull the ABS sensor on the brake actuator it goes into "I don't know what to do, so I'll do nothing, throw a bunch of lights, and just act like a normal, non-ABS brake system" mode. Figure it's worth a try with the Yaris and see if the brake stutter goes away, hopefully the growl as well, as it would mean the brake actuator is mis-behaving and nothing mechanically is wrong.

There's a solution to this problem... it just needs to be found. 😁

-- Adam
atomic_hojiThread starterKincardine, ON, Canada · Jun 12, 2018#64
(Un)fortunately?! the solution is not the brake actuator - dis-connected it and the drive is the exact same, although has a vast number more lights on the dash, lol.

CEL/MIL is on and officially running too rich - LTFT is at 30%! And exhaust has soot build-up; it's like having a diesel again. Also threw a code about MAF out of range...

Path forward I think is when I yank the battery to re-connect the brake actuator I'm going to pull the wiring on the O2 sensor out and have an inspection, maybe cut out the sketchy heat-shrink, built-in solder mess and crimp and seal a new connection on those wires. Going to put the front back up on jackstands, pull the wheels and go over everything again.. see if there's signs of rubbing.. check the axles are back in and seated, etc..

With having everything disconnected there's a good chance the alignment is out of whack... I figured it'd be alright, at least in the short term. Anyone heard of alignment being out of whack causing a growl / vibration under braking and steering?

Hot smell of (what I assume) is exhaust and undercoating is also sketchy feeling.. lol

Finding out what is not the problem is progress still, right? 😁

-- Adam
ArmstrongRacingSan Diego · Jun 13, 2018#65
30% LTFT is insane man, definitely not good.

The MAF input to the ECM is extremely important on these cars since thats our only air measurement device.

The only time ive ever seen MAF codes is when its unplugged, or electrically shorted. check the sensor inside the MAF, and check the voltage reading the ECM is receiving.
CrankyOldManWest Michigan · Jun 14, 2018#66
What did you do to wire in the MAF power? The xD harness uses a different pin than the Yaris and the connector is different.
atomic_hojiThread starterKincardine, ON, Canada · Jun 14, 2018#67
Hey, thanks for the replies guys. 👍

Originally Posted by ArmstrongRacing ↑
30% LTFT is insane man, definitely not good.
The MAF input to the ECM is extremely important on these cars since thats our only air measurement device.
The only time ive ever seen MAF codes is when its unplugged, or electrically shorted. check the sensor inside the MAF, and check the voltage reading the ECM is receiving.
I didn't actually verify the measurement checks on the new MAF... I'll do that, and do some other checks as you mentioned, thanks Tom. Ya, the ECM for the iM won't even let the car start without the MAF plugged in - found that out by accident, lol.

Originally Posted by CrankyOldMan ↑
What did you do to wire in the MAF power? The xD harness uses a different pin than the Yaris and the connector is different.
So the Yaris uses a dedicated power from the main JB to the MAF, which I left the wires and connector in place for the Yaris and just tucked it aside. The iM main engine harness has all the wires direct from the ECM, except 12V power which comes from the connector that goes to the main JB. On the iM the line supplying the MAF is shared back with the ECM +B +B2 and the canister pump, so I tapped the 12V supply that goes to the AFR and purge solenoid, figuring it could handle the current. I've been suspecting that there's too much noise or something on that line, but with the cheap MAF having the paint rub off and the cover disconnecting it was easier to blame - was hoping I wouldn't have to cut and resolder... Think it's time to run a dedicated 12V line for the MAF.

Other suspect wiring is the O2 sensor, however the codes being thrown are connected to the AFR sensor, not the O2 sensor - to be honest I'm not really sure what the O2 sensor does on these cars... lol

It's weird that after replacing the MAF with a better quality unit that the LTFT went from nearly +30% running lean on the cheap MAF to -30% running rich on the new MAF with no changes to wiring, etc.. But, unfortunately, I may just have to admit that my wiring is questionable. 😳

Again, appreciate the support from everyone! 👍 There are some things I'm good with on cars, but then there's plenty I still need to learnify..

-- Adam
tmontagueCaledonia Ont. · Jun 14, 2018#68
The o2 sensor afaik is essentially there just for emissions/car converter efficiency checks. You are correct that the trim codes are due to a reading performed by the afr sensor. I wouldn't worry too much about the o2 sensor for now. Check for exhaust leaks as well as wiring to the maf
atomic_hojiThread starterKincardine, ON, Canada · Jun 15, 2018#69
Thanks for the confirmation; I also agree because the O2 wire repair is on the backside of the Valvematic box, just above the heater line - i.e. huge p.i.t.a. to get at, lol. 😁

Put the car up on jackstands to have a look underneath and see if the vibration, etc.. and found what I strongly suspect is my problem..
<no picture, it's just embarrassing..>
EDIT: Jumped the gun.. with tires on the ground, full range of motion has at least an inch or more of clearance through-out.. suspect that the wear is leftover from test drives without bumper plastics installed. Dammit.. there's nothing (else) obviously rubbing, wrong or untorqued that I can find.

In the progress of opening up my wiring this afternoon - solder really does look fine, I suspect it's unhappy about the power supply being shared with the AFR sensor etc.. My wife's Dad is coming up this weekend, he spent years soldering and repair circuit boards, electronics, etc.. so I'll get him to have a look with me and show me the soldering mojo.

-- Adam
atomic_hojiThread starterKincardine, ON, Canada · Jun 16, 2018#70
Quick update - wiring changes made no difference, but hooking the computer up while driving brought to light a couple things. Monitoring STFT and LTFT while driving shows how the STFT is changing under load. With little load it pulls the fuel trim way back, but give it throttle it moves toward neutral (0%). I had the epiphany that the iM demands fuel pump by duty cycle, but the way I've got it setup it is ignoring the duty cycle request and always giving 100%; the ECM asks for x% and the system is ramming 100% to the injectors all the time. Made sense to me anyway..
-- Adam
CrankyOldManWest Michigan · Jun 18, 2018#71
Originally Posted by atomic_hoji ↑
I had the epiphany that the iM demands fuel pump by duty cycle, but the way I've got it setup it is ignoring the duty cycle request and always giving 100%; the ECM asks for x% and the system is ramming 100% to the injectors all the time. Made sense to me anyway..
-- Adam
Makes sense to me that it's pulling fuel then. It's getting too much fuel for the expected injector duty cycle.
atomic_hojiThread starterKincardine, ON, Canada · Jun 18, 2018#72
Originally Posted by CrankyOldMan ↑
Makes sense to me that it's pulling fuel then. It's getting too much fuel for the expected injector duty cycle.
At least if I'm wrong the problem had us both duped?! 😁

Here's a plot from when I had Techstream running on the weekend.. The Fuel Pump duty request was only about 75% (scale labels are goofy) most of the time - only jumped up to about 90% when I jumped on the throttle some. STFT is all over the place, not surprisingly, but does average out to around 0%'ish... sort of... LTFT (not shown, doesn't change much like STFT) was still -30%, but did jump up and down some. Used a reset Utility to clear all the learned values; even though I had the battery disconnected while I was doing wiring repair, the LTFT was still way off. I'm sure a bad learned value isn't helping the cause.

Picture not included in this copy

Have queries in to a couple of online places to see what the price new is for a Fuel Pump Control ECU is; will also need the connector, which is ~$10 or so, and hope I have terminals to use with it.. if not, it's time to Hodge Podge Bodge the bugger.. 😆 In all honesty, I think proper FPC should help sort out the fuel trim. Was hoping my clever fuel pump bypass had solved the problem, but seems like it will just end up running overly rich and likely have terrible fuel economy if I leave it this way.

Also dropped the exhaust and notched the flange where it was rubbing the body - not perfect, but a dramatic reduction in the nasty vibration when steering left. When I drop it again to weld the repair piece in I'll round out a bit more off the flange and see if I can 'clearance' the tunnel slightly - yes, I mean use a hammer... 😁

-- Adam

1 attachment not included in this copy

CrankyOldManWest Michigan · Jun 20, 2018#73
Originally Posted by atomic_hoji ↑
At least if I'm wrong the problem had us both duped?! 😁

Here's a plot from when I had Techstream running on the weekend.. The Fuel Pump duty request was only about 75% (scale labels are goofy) most of the time - only jumped up to about 90% when I jumped on the throttle some. STFT is all over the place, not surprisingly, but does average out to around 0%'ish... sort of... LTFT (not shown, doesn't change much like STFT) was still -30%, but did jump up and down some. Used a reset Utility to clear all the learned values; even though I had the battery disconnected while I was doing wiring repair, the LTFT was still way off. I'm sure a bad learned value isn't helping the cause.

Have queries in to a couple of online places to see what the price new is for a Fuel Pump Control ECU is; will also need the connector, which is ~$10 or so, and hope I have terminals to use with it.. if not, it's time to Hodge Podge Bodge the bugger.. 😆 In all honesty, I think proper FPC should help sort out the fuel trim. Was hoping my clever fuel pump bypass had solved the problem, but seems like it will just end up running overly rich and likely have terrible fuel economy if I leave it this way.

Also dropped the exhaust and notched the flange where it was rubbing the body - not perfect, but a dramatic reduction in the nasty vibration when steering left. When I drop it again to weld the repair piece in I'll round out a bit more off the flange and see if I can 'clearance' the tunnel slightly - yes, I mean use a hammer... 😁

-- Adam
What about swapping the fuel pump itself for one that doesn't use PWM? I'm not sure if the previous gen Yaris uses a fixed rate pump or not, but none of the 2ZR-FE swaps have the same fuel problem.
atomic_hojiThread starterKincardine, ON, Canada · Jun 21, 2018#74
Originally Posted by CrankyOldMan ↑
What about swapping the fuel pump itself for one that doesn't use PWM? I'm not sure if the previous gen Yaris uses a fixed rate pump or not, but none of the 2ZR-FE swaps have the same fuel problem.
Mm.. I don't think my Yaris fuel pump is the issue. Looks like all Yaris - older and current - all use fixed ON/OFF fuel pumps. The ECM detects IGN and crank motion, grounds FPC terminal to energize the C/OPN relay and the fuel pump runs - nice and simple. My Google-fu finds the 10th gen. Corolla and xD use this same fuel pump control method, hence why in those swaps the ECMs worked without issue with the Yaris fuel pump setup.

Why I'm running into problems is that 2014+ systems have this fuel pump control ECU that receives the ECM duty cycle output signal and controls power to the fuel pump motor. The ECM must be programmed with injection pulse widths expecting that the fuel pump flow is corresponigly reduced as the ECM is requesting on the FPC output. Where-as my Yaris fuel pump flow is hardwired to run ON/OFF style, so when the ECM is for example set to open the fuel injector for # ms and is requesting 77% fuel pump flow, what is happening is the injectors open for # ms with the fuel pump at 100%; the AFR detects it's way rich and pulls the fuel trim to meet target air:fuel.

Or at least that's how I understand it.. 😁

Have a fuel pump control ECU ordered with the associated 6-pin connector. Having to bring it in from the California warehouse he said, so could be a bit to get it across the border and out to me. I'll run thr FPC wire this weekend, I think. And see if my 1.75" exhaust tube comes in tomorrow - the truck's muffler has been broken for months, so I've become kind of used to exhaust noise.. lol

-- Adam
CrankyOldManWest Michigan · Jun 22, 2018#75
Interesting. So it's the same part number for the pump itself?

I ask because the company I work for makes an oil pump that can do both, depending on what communication it sees, without the need for an intermediate controller.
atomic_hojiThread starterKincardine, ON, Canada · Jun 24, 2018#76
I apologize Sam, I think I mis-understood what you meant.. An aftermarket setup could be an alternative solution if there was such a beast made for in tank fuel pump setups. Assuming it cost less than a fuel pump control ECU, connector, etc.. that would be a slick way to go!

Anywho, you did give me some ideas to look into as well.. The part numbers on the fuel pumps are different across the board - Yaris is shared with Prius; xD has it's own; iM has it's own; early Corolla shares with Matrix, but later has it's own - i.e. 2009-2013 IS different vs. 2014+. Not sure what the differences are across each - I imagine very little, maybe something to match the internals in the tank, i.e. mounting, etc.. Maybe flow matched to ECMs better? Not sure.

I did also double check the workshop manual on the fuel pump operation, just in case there's anything special noted that would make me think I need to replace the fuel pump.. The fuel pumps on the newer cars that are driven by the fuel pump control ECU are controlled as follows: a duty cycle signal from the ECM to the ECU - this signal requests % fuel pump duty to the ECU, the ECU then varies the output voltage to the fuel pump motor to change the speed of the fuel pump. Since the Yaris' fuel pump is a basic electric motor, changing the voltage should have the same effect on it as the iM (or any other) basic electric motor fuel pump - I believe; we'll see.

While the 2ZR-FAE has been an interesting challenge, I'm not sure it's worth the extra hassle, lol. Although, that being said, a newer Corolla 2ZR-FE would have the same issues and (without verifying, but I suspect) if you're on a 3rd gen. Yaris platform, due to the change of pins on the modern ECMs, you may be stuck with these. In a round-about way I think I've justified that this is the way it goes on the 3rd gens... lol

Just about there - at least it's driveable (although I imagine fuel economy would be terrible, lol) as it is now, so shows it can be done. Exhaust is out for welding, so back to truck until that's finished - not happy with that whole deal, but it'll work for the time being.

-- Adam
CrankyOldManWest Michigan · Jun 26, 2018#77
I think I misunderstood what I meant to say as well. =) Basically, I wanted to verify if the pump was the same for the Yaris and iM with only the controller being different. The anecdote about a pump we make at work was only related in that it has the ability to respond to different types of input, not that fuel pumps would have the same ability. It's non-trivial to add that capability to a simple DC motor.

I think you've done a spectacular job with this. So many people would have just give up when it wouldn't start, but you've pressed on and discovered a TON of valuable info for the rest of the community. Yes, it's been a headache for you at times, but you've done something that nobody else has (that we know of) and set the stage for even crazier stuff to come!
atomic_hojiThread starterKincardine, ON, Canada · Jun 26, 2018#78
lol - fair enough. Maybe not a simple conversion (at at a quick Google a bust), but perhaps you're on to a new business idea here, Sam!? 😁

I appreciate the feedback, thanks. I really do hope that even though it isn't quite as neat and clean a swap as it is on the 2nd gen. Yaris we'll see some more 2ZR-FE/FAE swaps on the 3rd gen. platform.

Set the stage ... crazier stuff - ssshhh... don't tell the wife about the turbo kit! 😆 jk'ing ... one can dream though.

-- Adam
ArmstrongRacingSan Diego · Jun 29, 2018#79
Originally Posted by atomic_hoji ↑
At least if I'm wrong the problem had us both duped?! 😁

Here's a plot from when I had Techstream running on the weekend.. The Fuel Pump duty request was only about 75% (scale labels are goofy) most of the time - only jumped up to about 90% when I jumped on the throttle some. STFT is all over the place, not surprisingly, but does average out to around 0%'ish... sort of... LTFT (not shown, doesn't change much like STFT) was still -30%, but did jump up and down some. Used a reset Utility to clear all the learned values; even though I had the battery disconnected while I was doing wiring repair, the LTFT was still way off. I'm sure a bad learned value isn't helping the cause.

Attachment 59635
:

-- Adam
The graphs look somewhat normal to me. The only thing that looks strange is at the end where you start stabbing the throttle. It’s proving feedback on the first stab but then it just starts reading a full rich condition. That tells me either it went into Open Loop or you A/F sensor is not reading properly???
atomic_hojiThread starterKincardine, ON, Canada · Jul 1, 2018#80
Originally Posted by ArmstrongRacing ↑
The graphs look somewhat normal to me. The only thing that looks strange is at the end where you start stabbing the throttle. It’s proving feedback on the first stab but then it just starts reading a full rich condition. That tells me either it went into Open Loop or you A/F sensor is not reading properly???
That's good to know, thanks. 👍 Getting into fuel trims and some (most) of this stuff is new ground for me, so nice to know what's normal.

Unfortunately I don't recall what I was doing when I did the run, though looks like accelerating and shifting under mid-throttle - seems about right..? I have checked the AFR resistance and it was in spec, but ya maybe the AFR is mis-behaving or something related is tripping the ECM up and going open loop. Going to try some more troubleshooting once I have the FPC ECU installed - which is on order and was able to pick-up a 2000 mile unit off eBay for about half the price.

-- Adam
atomic_hojiThread starterKincardine, ON, Canada · Jul 1, 2018#81
Found a new issue today, which is more of a nuisance than it is a serious problem...

After getting the exhaust welded through the week and re-installed yesterday I needed fuel, so I did a run into town this morning. Given it's 40C with humidex today and there's no A/C in the Yaris yet, it was actually miserable, but I digress.. lol. What I did find is that putting ~24L of fuel into the tank causes the fuel gauge on the display cluster to read nearly full! 😲 Had a think on it and a quick review of the workshop manuals, and came up with <something completely wrong>.

Solution ... ? Going to have to see if there's an option to reset Combination Meter learning, or check the fuel sender isn't gunked from sitting for months.. or leave it and hope it goes away after a few fills. 😁

-- Adam

edited: because I'm a dummy and can't read a system diagram properly, lol.
ArmstrongRacingSan Diego · Jul 1, 2018#82
I don’t think fuel tank size has anything to do with the reading on the cluster. It’s just a resistance feedback from a swing style gauge. The wires run up the driver side to the left most fuse box connector, pass through the fuse box to the meter.
atomic_hojiThread starterKincardine, ON, Canada · Jul 1, 2018#83
... you are correct, sir. And I is a dum-dum.. 😳

"FUEL: Receives fuel level signal from fuel sender gauge assembly (Direct line)."

Apparently the large, rectangle on the system diagram is the Combination Meter, not the ECM.. d'oh. :facepalm: It sounded so good.. That does then make me wonder why the gauge is donkey'd. Combination Meter ECU learning? Hm...

Never-the-less, above edited to avoid confusion.

-- Adam
atomic_hojiThread starterKincardine, ON, Canada · Aug 7, 2018#84
There's a quote about failures and experience and such... but I'm not biting; just failing.. 🙄

So, for the record, the Toyota Tercel CV trick a. did not solve my problem, and b. does not work on the 3rd gen. hatchback with the 2ZR swap as I have it setup. In trying to fix my left-hand turn growl I decided to pick-up and install a 1998 Tercel CV on the driver side as tmontague had done with success. Unfortunately, I set the car down off the jack, fired it up, put it in reverse and heard BANG, BANG as the car rolled. On inspection the inner CV boot was all twisted up. I knew when I installed it that it was pulling on the axle as I tightened up on the nut, but apparently it pulls too much. 😲

The Fuel Pump Control (FPC) ECU is installed in the trunk area with relative ease - if you are going to do this setup then run the wire while everything is out and apart! I spent way too long futzing about with a nice run and gave up - it's in 1/4" wire loom from engine bay, along the fuel pump lines, and up into the fuel pump access under the rear seat - works fine, just not quite as clean an install. After a test run today (with the stock CV axle installed again re: the above mess) I found that the LTFT started better (I reset it) and then as the car warmed up and I did a longer, several kilometer drive, took a crap back to way deep in the -'ves again. So seems that was not the awesome solution I had hoped for.

Next plan is to check the wiring and if they match swap the 1NZ spangly new AFR sensor into the 2ZR and see if that works; which was what Tom noted earlier that the plots were showing a weird response so maybe the AFR sensor was shot. Being that it was a low mileage engine and bunged when removed by the wrecker (and a very simple sensor) I didn't go for it first; looking like it's worth a try now..

OH, side note - I did find that fuel tank senders must have some non-linearity to them, so I'm not just crazy... I put a jerry can of fuel into my truck, about 15L worth, and the needle moved from just under 3/4 to just over 3/4 full - 15L is slightly less than a 1/4 tank on the FJCs 65L tank, so I would have thought it'd have changed a lot more, but no.. Maybe this isn't a surprise to you guys and it's just me.. 😁

-- Adam
tmontagueCaledonia Ont. · Aug 9, 2018#85
Tough go on all of the challenges. I wouldn't worry about the noise in your front end. Worry about the essential like your fuel trims etc and figure out the noises later so all your focus is on what needs to be fixed asap.

I've also come to realize that the 2zr swap is going to cause some noises and clunks that a stock yaris won't Have, that's the nature of putting in an engine that isn't fully designed for the chassis (although the t sport does have this engine).

I still get some loud clunk on one of turns at TMP when i accelerate out of it as well as sometimes when going in out out of the driveway. I've chalked it up to aftermarket suspension and extremely stiff spring rates plus a transmission that is shifted over in the engine bay.

Driving a car is more fun than trying to quiet it down ;)
DarkShadowFoxMassachusetts · Aug 9, 2018#86
Originally Posted by tmontague ↑
Tough go on all of the challenges. I wouldn't worry about the noise in your front end. Worry about the essential like your fuel trims etc and figure out the noises later so all your focus is on what needs to be fixed asap.

I've also come to realize that the 2zr swap is going to cause some noises and clunks that a stock yaris won't Have, that's the nature of putting in an engine that isn't fully designed for the chassis (although the t sport does have this engine).

I still get some loud clunk on one of turns at TMP when i accelerate out of it as well as sometimes when going in out out of the driveway. I've chalked it up to aftermarket suspension and extremely stiff spring rates plus a transmission that is shifted over in the engine bay.

Driving a car is more fun than trying to quiet it down ;)
maybe the clunk is your bushings.
tmontagueCaledonia Ont. · Aug 9, 2018#87
All brand new poly bushings. Not a single part of my suspension is original including ball joints
stidnamAustralia · Aug 11, 2018#88
Not trying to be argumentative tmontague, but Toyota did match the 2zr to the HB chassis, like you mentioned. If using all of the factory mounts and driveshafts, I wouldn't expect a single clunk or growl from the drive train. I wouldn't expect that to apply to a Vios though.

Now that may not necessarily be the fix for this problem, but it'd be something I'd keep in mind if the problem persists and you've ruled everything else out Adam.

Interesting tidbit of information - the mounts and brackets used in the new 2018 GRMN Yaris are exactly the same as the 2008 South African and New Zealand ZSP90. Looks like Toyota went and just dug through the parts bin. It should also be noted that all of those vehicles use a 6 speed transmission - 2008 models used an EC67.

Anyway I digress. Adam, I've read back through your thread and I couldn't see which drive shafts you used? Assuming the Yaris ones. Not sure what the exact differences are, but it may be also worth investigating the differences in the XD shaft lengths and whether that might also be a solution - just thinking if the 2zr rh mount has shifted the motor and box towards the left...
DarkShadowFoxMassachusetts · Aug 12, 2018#89
Originally Posted by stidnam ↑
Not trying to be argumentative tmontague, but Toyota did match the 2zr to the HB chassis, like you mentioned. If using all of the factory mounts and driveshafts, I wouldn't expect a single clunk or growl from the drive train. I wouldn't expect that to apply to a Vios though.

Now that may not necessarily be the fix for this problem, but it'd be something I'd keep in mind if the problem persists and you've ruled everything else out Adam.

Interesting tidbit of information - the mounts and brackets used in the new 2018 GRMN Yaris are exactly the same as the 2008 South African and New Zealand ZSP90. Looks like Toyota went and just dug through the parts bin. It should also be noted that all of those vehicles use a 6 speed transmission - 2008 models used an EC67.



Anyway I digress. Adam, I've read back through your thread and I couldn't see which drive shafts you used? Assuming the Yaris ones. Not sure what the exact differences are, but it may be also worth investigating the differences in the XD shaft lengths and whether that might also be a solution - just thinking if the 2zr rh mount has shifted the motor and box towards the left...
2018 GRMN uses a lotus derived motor and supercharger with some one off pieces " " but its all mostly parts bin.
atomic_hojiThread starterKincardine, ON, Canada · Aug 12, 2018#90
Originally Posted by tmontague ↑
...
Driving a car is more fun than trying to quiet it down ;)
lol - this is true. I have been daily driving the car up until I put it in the garage for a couple days to run the FPC ECU wiring and try the CV axle swap. I figured it was low hanging fruit to try the Tercel CV axle trick... apparently not. 🙄

Appreciate the replies everyone. With respect to the CV axles, I am running both stock Yaris axles - good point and worth documenting. Had a search on RockAuto (because some of the manufacturers list CV sizes, so it's convenient) and yes, there are definitely differences between the xD and the Yaris. If I recall Tom's thread addressed this as well; if not elsewhere - have to go back and re-read some of the other 2ZR swap threads. But quick summary:

xD_LH = 24 29/32" & xD_RH = 35 3/4"
Yaris_LH = 25 3/4" & Yaris_RH = 35 1/4"

So, not surprisingly the xD setup is shorter on the LH side and longer on the RH side as the transmission assembly is pushed ~3/4" - 1" toward the LH side. Saying that, I was surprised that the Tercel axle, which is 24 13/16" (only 3/32" shorter than the xD length) was way too short - as in, sounded like it imploded and twisted up the CV boot as soon as the car rolled..

I have a 'tape test' going right now. While I was under I had a thorough check around and it looks like there's a paint rub spot on the notched edge of the frame on the LH side - could be bumped during the install or could be the transmission bumping the frame on corners. Figure it's worth a check.

As Trevor noted, the air-fuel ratio problem that's causing the CEL/MIL on is the bigger issue. With respect to trying the AFR sensor - I have been defeated by the sensor.. 😳 I tried to pop the one from the 2ZR out and just can't generate enough oomph to break it loose. Sometime this week I'll see if I can borrow the hoist in a friend's shop and have another go. I did check it against the workshop manual numbers with the multi-meter and it is still good.. getting battery voltage less 0.2V on the supply side too. Would like to inspect it and see if there's anything visually wrong with it - soot, corrosion, etc..

-- Adam
tmontagueCaledonia Ont. · Aug 12, 2018#91
Originally Posted by stidnam ↑
Not trying to be argumentative tmontague, but Toyota did match the 2zr to the HB chassis, like you mentioned. If using all of the factory mounts and driveshafts, I wouldn't expect a single clunk or growl from the drive train. I wouldn't expect that to apply to a Vios though.

Now that may not necessarily be the fix for this problem, but it'd be something I'd keep in mind if the problem persists and you've ruled everything else out Adam.

Interesting tidbit of information - the mounts and brackets used in the new 2018 GRMN Yaris are exactly the same as the 2008 South African and New Zealand ZSP90. Looks like Toyota went and just dug through the parts bin. It should also be noted that all of those vehicles use a 6 speed transmission - 2008 models used an EC67.

Anyway I digress. Adam, I've read back through your thread and I couldn't see which drive shafts you used? Assuming the Yaris ones. Not sure what the exact differences are, but it may be also worth investigating the differences in the XD shaft lengths and whether that might also be a solution - just thinking if the 2zr rh mount has shifted the motor and box towards the left...
I agree w/ you but all of us 2zr swaps hb or sedan have originally kept yaris axles. If the swap was to be done totally to factory spec in a HB then yes I would expect it to be silent. With the mix and match to keep costs down that most of us have, noises are inevitable. Plus most who have done the swap are racing their cars and have other modifications in it either transmission gears/lsd or engine mounts which leads to all kinds of fun nvh that factory spec won't leave you with.

At this point I'm keeping my fingers crossed that the fuel trims level out as that is the main issue currently. Unfortunately I'm not much help as this is out of my wheel house in regards to what it could be
atomic_hojiThread starterKincardine, ON, Canada · Aug 15, 2018#92
So, no such luck on the AFR sensor. Swapped the Yaris' 1NZ sensor in and it didn't change the behaviour - now, the Yaris does use a different part number, but same electrical checks, 4-wire, etc.. and the car ran the same using it. I cleaned the 2ZR sensor by soaking it in gas for several hours and wiping clean - it was pretty clean when I pulled it anyway, but I thought while it was out I'd do it for good measure.

What I did find after I swapped the 1NZ AFR sensor is that when I went to clear the codes there is now a MAF code as well for 'MAF sensor circuit out of expected range' or similar; I'll have to check the OBD2 code, but I think it's P0101. This is new since installing the FPC ECU.

I did also find that the LTFT is better than it was before. The test drive I did after installing the FPC ECU sets the LTFT at -27% (this was before playing with the AFR sensors at all, but after installing FPC ECU) instead of the almost -40% worst case that I had seen prior; loaded the old data and it was fugly, lol. So I think the FPC ECU has helped, but then it's hard to say given there's clearly some other problem.

In a quick read on the P0101 code, apparently the MAF can get tripped up reporting air flow if the signal is noisy from nearby, high current wires. Since I've checked and double-checked the wiring supplying the MAF, I tried a shielding wire quickly - a grounded wire wrapped around - with no change. But, the MAF is basically snuggy-bunny with the main ECM, so going to have to try to rig up a test where I can move the ECM well away from the MAF and see if that helps. The other thing is the OBD2 code does point to a MAF problem, which I boggles me because it's a brand new MAF and electrically checks out when doing the troubleshooting checks. Thinking that maybe mixing the xD 2ZR-FE intake with a 2ZR-FAE iM MAF could cause an issue?! 😕 If the calibration assumes a larger intake diameter, so it's reporting X g/s air flow, but in reality with the smaller intake only X-- air is getting in, so it runs rich and the ECM adjusts ST/LTFTs to accommodate ...? Also going to look at the injectors as a last check - they're pink, like they're supposed to be, but who knows, maybe the iM owner had bigger injectors installed?! I can't read the injector numbers while they're in place, so I figure as a last resort I'll confirm the numbers and make sure they match the model injectors.

So more troubleshooting to do.. Generally it drives ok. Misbehaves some at idle and is rough when shutdown; like shutting a diesel off, lol. Since installing the FPC ECU I have found it's touchy when dropping throttle from accelerating; e.g. pulling into traffic and accelerating up to speed quickly, then shifting and letting off the throttle to cruise the revs 'wobble' and rock the engine around on the mounts.. like stabbing at the throttle. Not sure if the FPC ECU change is related or if it's whatever else is causing the fuel issues worsening.

I feel like when I figure this out the AH-HA moment I will feel both relieved and like a dumb-ass - it feels like it's going to be one of those simple things.. 🙄

-- Adam
atomic_hojiThread starterKincardine, ON, Canada · Sep 12, 2018#93
SO, another quick update - fortunately someone jogged me as I've been busy with plant shutdown at work, kids back to school, back to shift work (rotating days/nights) etc.. etc.. and realized it's been forever since I've jumped on to YW.

SUCCESS! Somewhat.. 😁

My 'stick-tape-everywhere-that-could-be-rubbing' test found the issue, which in hindsight I can't believe I didn't find earlier, but in my defense it's really hard to see down in there. I happened to stick my hand in around between the front side of the engine and the frame-side body mount and noticed it's really close - when looking from above it's blocked by the cover on the frame mount and underneath there's a ton on pulleys and A/C piping in the way.. Sure enough, tape test revealed rubbing. Supported the engine, dropped the engine mount, frame mount, and pulled the engine bracket off. Using a grinder clearanced it about a 1/4", painted, and re-installed - voila, no more left-hand turn vibration! I took a picture of the brackets, showing there wear marks, but then got excited and re-installed without showing the mod.. whoops.

Take away: if you do the 2ZR swap in a 3rd gen. HB and find you have a left-hand turn growl/vibration, trying gaining some clearance by modifying the engine bracket with a grinder by about 1/4" along the outer rib - runs between the top 2 bolts.

Also played with some ideas on the intake side of things which supported my suspicion about the mixing xD intake with iM MAF. I ordered and (finally) received an AEM Scion/Corolla iM short-ram intake kit, installed it, and the P0101 and P0172 codes are now gone. When monitoring the LTFT it is sill quite low, but resolved enough that it's not tripping up the ECM and throwing a code anymore. In going for a ride with a buddy in his new Tacoma, we found that general, daily type driving he sits around -7 to -10 LTFT on his 2GR V6, BUT at start-up the learned value remains approx. 0 for both. Seems like Toyota's run a bit negative LTFT while driving around normally. Might try my FJC next time I'm out and get another sample...

Maybe it seems obvious, but a combination of using the Fuel Pump Control ECU and installing an iM intake has adjusted the LTFT to the point where it no longer throws a code - or, in other words, install the stuff the ECM is expecting and it works. lol

As a side note, and good to document, this came about because I was focused on using the Scion xD parts for the swap - the xD parts work for a lot of things, especially on the 2nd. gen swaps. For this -FAE swap from the iM, the mechanical parts, e.g. engine mounts, heater & rad. hoses, etc.. the xD parts work, however where the electrical bits are concerned, e.g. MAF, the differences cause the iM ECM issues. Using the MAF example, fit the same and has the same electrical connections, but do not work the same, and even though the intake piping is a mechanical piece, since it supports the MAF it also needs to meet iM spec, not the xD - mix and match == bad. 😁

***

Other general, on-going things I've been finding with the swap:

The throttle is extremely touchy; it's not that I needed to get used to it, it's spaztastic in the first 10-20% (ish?) of travel.. lol. And it still has some fuelling related problems - idles rough, nearly stalls for the first split second until fuel picks up when accelerating (like a delayed response) so I use more throttle when starting than I did with the 1NZ (or in any manual car I've driven), and shudders at shutdown. Basically same issues as above, excepting that I found the weird 'stabbing' on the throttle issue is user error.. apparently if your big-ass, clompy safety shoes remain on said touchy pedal and you don't notice it will cause issue - I found my days off it was fine (sandals) then had the issue when I went in to work the next set of nights... two and two together = oooohh... dum-dum. 🙄

I hate (I mean vehemently hate) my exahust setup, and want to change it. Given the Corolla / iM uses an approx 2" exhaust, and the performance setups at 2.25", I won't be surprised if replacing the 1.75" xD/Yaris-with-crappy-bends-making-it-more-like-1.5"-in-some-places setup helps dramatically improve the remaining issues.

Progress.. Slowly working down the little issues here and there. That said, I do daily it to and from work without issue (except the exhaust rattling, which is just annoying as F*). We did a couple hour trip in it and, less needing the A/C recharged still (d'oh!), it ran a treat. Tracked fuel economy now that it seems to be having less LTFT issues and found on a trip of ~200 kms, driving mostly rural roads ~90kph it was sitting at 8.2 L/100km or ~28 MPG(US).

Take care,
-- Adam
stidnamAustralia · Sep 13, 2018#94
Great update and glad to hear you've ironed out those bigger issues. Bet that's a good feeling :)

I suspect that the Yaris gearbox mounts and mounting points aren't providing enough space for the 2zr to bolt to the gearbox and clear the frame. Just out of interest, was there a little lateral tension on that engine mount when you unbolted it?

Good to know about the need to keep things matching up :)

Interesting on the throttle point as well. I actually find the stock Yaris throttle in the first 10 to 20% to give me no throttle, which to me is not what I'm expecting coming from a car with a cable operated throttle. I'd welcome a linear throttle that mapped 1:1 what my foot was doing! Speaking of gas pedals, the pedal is damn aweful as well but I've been eyeing off a replacement option from another Toyota that should make heal toe a little easier.
tmontagueCaledonia Ont. · Sep 13, 2018#95
Great to hear you are figuring out the issues!
Fwiw- my 1nz and now 2zr all sit around -10 to 12 % LTFT. This has never caused any issue in my engine and it runs fine so as long as you are not getting a CEL then I'd just leave it as is.

Toyota throttle by wire system is very light and not very refined. I just outright stopped driving my car with my winter boots on as it became ridiculous.

Enjoy driving your unique car and congrats on what you've done!
atomic_hojiThread starterKincardine, ON, Canada · Sep 15, 2018#96
Thanks for the positive feedback guys... it is nice having a peppy, reliable ('ish?!) daily driver. Does also mean the FJC's time in the driveway is coming to an end.. 😢

Originally Posted by stidnam ↑
...
I suspect that the Yaris gearbox mounts and mounting points aren't providing enough space for the 2zr to bolt to the gearbox and clear the frame. Just out of interest, was there a little lateral tension on that engine mount when you unbolted it?
...
It is definitely pushing hard into the LHS (transmission) mount, and required a lot of 'persuasion' when I had to get the RHS mounts installed and back into place. I knew that was going to happen from the effort required when it went in the first time. Optimally, I would like to pull the trans. side mount, dig out the rubber and re-position the steel tube for the bolt offset, then pour polyurethane to make a DIY mount that holds it tight toward the LHS better. I'll add it to the projects list... 😁

Originally Posted by tmontague ↑
Great to hear you are figuring out the issues!
Fwiw- my 1nz and now 2zr all sit around -10 to 12 % LTFT. This has never caused any issue in my engine and it runs fine so as long as you are not getting a CEL then I'd just leave it as is.

Toyota throttle by wire system is very light and not very refined. I just outright stopped driving my car with my winter boots on as it became ridiculous.
...
I recall you saying that and thought about it when I was going for a ride in the Tacoma. Curious to see if the FJC also does it, but looks like that's well within' the norm. Driving around into town last I was sitting -15 to -17% LTFT, dropping into the -24% range, so I suspect it's still not perfect, but as you said, no CEL/MIL is a win for daily driveability.

LOL, I'm now slightly more worried that winter is coming soon.. jk'ing - but, have to see how I manage in work boots.

-- Adam
atomic_hojiThread starterKincardine, ON, Canada · Oct 7, 2018#97
SO ... LTFT is back to -35% or so and CEL/MIL is on again ... 😠

I was under the hood and realized in doing troubleshooting I'd disconnected the PCV vent from the valve cover to the air intake... so I diligently reconnected it and blammo, back to the same old problem.

Since the PCV seems to be directly impacting the LTFT I decided to pull the intake manifold and check the PCV valve - turns out it works fine, but not a big waste as I figure I'll install the catch can I bought.. BUT, the intake has quite a bit of oil and a stanky smell. The oil has a couple thousand kilometers on it, but I decided to change it anyway to see how it was doing - the engine did sit at the wrecker for who knows how long. Oil is 0W20 and was warm, but came out very thin, nearly like water, is very dark, almost black, and stinks god awful - same smell as in the intake manifold.. I've smelled gas in oil before - reasonably recently when a friend's bike carb was flooding and dumping gas into the oil - this isn't quite the same, and the same friend dropped over and didn't think it was quite the same either.. The smell is nasty though, almost like exhaust gases or the oil being burnt..? 😕

Not really sure what's up with this stubborn thing... borrowed a compression tester from a friend to do due diligence and make sure I don't have bad rings, but given it only has a few thousand kilometers on it I wouldn't have thought rings would be suspect.. That said, I did have the oops with leaving the exhaust manifold taped and starting the engine - made a good bang, scared myself stupid.. lol - but I wouldn't have imagined that could have blown a piston ring.. ?? 😲

Open to other ideas re: sources of super stinky oil and would be causing combustion to be too rich...

-- Adam
ArmstrongRacingSan Diego · Oct 31, 2018#98
I've replaced many PCV valves due to vehicles running lean before, its not uncommon.

The only way I found that was the issue is by 1) doing smoke test on the manifold and found ZERO leaks. 2)replaced A/F sensor due to a rapid fluctuation between 0 and -30% STFT. 3)After that the LTFT was staying around -17%. 4)Thats when I replaced the PCV valve and the LTFT dropped down to 8-10%

What are the codes youre getting and hows it run?
atomic_hojiThread starterKincardine, ON, Canada · Nov 1, 2018#99
Hey Tom, thanks for the note! The code I'm squabbling with is P0172 System to Rich, which jives with the way negative LTFT. For general driving it seems alright, has a bit of a howl/vibration when I left off throttle and coast, but the only real nuisance is a terrible idle - it's very rough, has a lot of vibration, and shudders; which I assume is the ECM pulling so much fuel trim that it's wanting to stall (never has though..).

For the small cost of a PCV valve I may just give replacing it a try too, just to rule it out.

After I had pulled the intake I did a little driving around with the emissions disconnected at the air intake - so disconnected the PCV to the intake manifold, the valve cover vent, and the fuel purge at the throttle body and taped them all off. When I compare the plots for AFR, STFT, LTFT it doesn't appeared to have made much if any difference, which seems to bust my theory that it's pulling oil or fuel vapour into the intake and causing the ECM to pull fuel trim.

I did find that there seems to be a correlation between the AFR sensor going way lean when the purge solenoid operation. Originally I had thought about fuel vapour getting into the air intake and when the solenoid closed it stopped adding it, so it leaned out and fuel trim had to adjust. Now, after trying the line disconnected, I'm wondering if there's an electrical noise issue where the solenoid energizing / de-energizing is tripping up the AFR sensor.. Just a quick theory, but haven't chased it.

The other obvious culprit with a fuel problem could be the injectors dripping/leaking. I haven't had the time to pop them out and give them a check, but hoping to get at it soon; unfortunately available time is getting less and less, not better..

I did do a compression test last weekend (or one prior..?) and it was solid numbers across all cylinders; good pressure, consistent across cylinders, and held steady.. Not surprisingly I don't think there's a mechanical problem with such a new engine, but was worth a check - and a huge p.i.t.a to get at those spark plugs and get a tester hooked up. lol

Thanks as always for the help!
-- Adam
ArmstrongRacingSan Diego · Nov 1, 2018#100
It seems you’ve done the right steps in eliminating possible issues. The odds are low that an injection is the issue, but have you checked the MAF signal at all? It should gradually rise with the RPM, and spike pretty high when you stab the throttle.

I remember you saying something about a different fuel pump control strategy on the IM right?