Well I figured I would start here just to let everyone know that I've started step one on my long tube header build and got the parts needed to make it. Hopefully I can get this finished in the next couple of weeks as I need a few parts cut.
My Long Tube header build
180 posts · 67,815 views · page 1 of 4
Replies 179
I'll be following your exhaust project with great interest. Be sure to post lots of pics. 👍
Thanks, I've had this design on paper for a while so its finally time to move forward.
I should have the flange cut some time next week...kind of surprised how close my design was from working from some random dimensions I found on the internet and looking at pictures. The only problem I'm running into now is that 1.375" mandrel U-Bends are ridiculously difficult to find but otherwise everything else is pretty much ready to move forward.
The only thing left I really need to get a hold of is a stock manifold so I can jig everything up and get the basic shape tacked in place then test fitting and fixing everything in place and finish machining the flange so its surface can take a gasket.
I should have the flange cut some time next week...kind of surprised how close my design was from working from some random dimensions I found on the internet and looking at pictures. The only problem I'm running into now is that 1.375" mandrel U-Bends are ridiculously difficult to find but otherwise everything else is pretty much ready to move forward.
The only thing left I really need to get a hold of is a stock manifold so I can jig everything up and get the basic shape tacked in place then test fitting and fixing everything in place and finish machining the flange so its surface can take a gasket.
If I was going to build a header, I'd get one of these cheapies off Ebay for $59 and free shipping... 🙂
Picture not included in this copy
...chop off the tubes and use the factory machined ready-to-bolt-on flange, 4 to1 collector, O2 sensor bung, and two bolt gasketed fitting for your own long tube header. It's worth more than that just as separate parts. 👍
Picture not included in this copy
...chop off the tubes and use the factory machined ready-to-bolt-on flange, 4 to1 collector, O2 sensor bung, and two bolt gasketed fitting for your own long tube header. It's worth more than that just as separate parts. 👍
Most of the cheapies use 1.5" tubing which is way way to large for this engine so you'll end up with a huge loss of torque and a powerband that's to high up. I initially thought of that but the material cost of the header isn't all that expensive and buying SS to modify that thing isn't worth it.
I'm building it out of regular carbon steel even making the flange myself and all in it should be less than 300 dollars for metal plus the 3-4 hours its going to take me to weld everything up.
I'm actually working on a 4-2-1 header, so I can make it small enough to fit before the second cat.
I'm building it out of regular carbon steel even making the flange myself and all in it should be less than 300 dollars for metal plus the 3-4 hours its going to take me to weld everything up.
I'm actually working on a 4-2-1 header, so I can make it small enough to fit before the second cat.
Oh, I see. Very well thought out. 👍Originally Posted by xnamerxx ↑Most of the cheapies use 1.5" tubing which is way way to large for this engine so you'll end up with a huge loss of torque and a powerband that's to high up. I initially thought of that but the material cost of the header isn't all that expensive and buying SS to modify that thing isn't worth it.
I'm building it out of regular carbon steel even making the flange myself and all in it should be less than 300 dollars for metal plus the 3-4 hours its going to take me to weld everything up.
I'm actually working on a 4-2-1 header, so I can make it small enough to fit before the second cat.
Steel should be easier to work with. I'll enjoy seeing what you come up with.
When I finally build mine, it's going to be a 1.5" to 1.75" to 2.0" 4-2-1 header. From the numbers, it's a bit big, but it will be 30-36" long, so the power band should peak in the 4-5k area.
Can't wait to see your build! :)
Can't wait to see your build! :)
All i'm going to say is 1.5" is really really big for initial primaries if you're dead set on that I'd set it from 1.375 to 1.5. Going to big on the primaries is bad but going to small isn't necessarily.
Overall I think the length is close to 30" but my peak torque spot shouldn't change only get a few % higher.
Overall I think the length is close to 30" but my peak torque spot shouldn't change only get a few % higher.
I notice that you're SoCal, namer. How will you deal with smog tests?
Since my setup still has a cat it should pass but I'll likely just swap back the stock parts for the smog test.
pics pics pics
[subscribed]
[subscribed]
There was a race header in works pre-hack so glad someone's finally going through it!
I'll try to get as many pics as possible 😉
I think that was richard holdener's header. I looked at his design for initial inspiration but there was a few things here and there I felt that could be improved. The 4-1 design works and it works really well but I can accomplish the same performance if not better in a lighter/smaller 4-2-1 package, the only downside being that a 4-2-1 is more expensive to make due to all the collectors required to make it work.
I think that was richard holdener's header. I looked at his design for initial inspiration but there was a few things here and there I felt that could be improved. The 4-1 design works and it works really well but I can accomplish the same performance if not better in a lighter/smaller 4-2-1 package, the only downside being that a 4-2-1 is more expensive to make due to all the collectors required to make it work.
It was his.
Well I'm sribin
Well I'm sribin
I'm not a metalurgist but the ebay one is about as stainless as a hookers underwear. I bought one and am currently using it with no failure. Upon slight modification, I learned that I could weld on it with mild wire and it held up very well to a grinder. Penetration was good and rainbowing was non-existent. I would almost guess that they use the minimum possible chromium and nickel to be able to call it stainless. As soon as this header craps out, I'm using the flange to make a long tube header myself.
You can get flanges on eBay for about $30 + shipping, that's where I got my OBX flange from.
That was originally my plan but I didn't like the sloppiness of the OBX flange from the pictures, plus being 1/2" thick would be a bitch to weld on. So I decided to draw and make my own. It's in a format the machinist likes and I should have it cut some time this week.
Picture not included in this copy
Picture not included in this copy
I can definitely confirm that, the OBX flange is not cleanly cut. It will take some finessing with a die grinder to get it smooth.Originally Posted by xnamerxx ↑That was originally my plan but I didn't like the sloppiness of the OBX flange from the pictures, plus being 1/2" thick would be a bitch to weld on. So I decided to draw and make my own. It's in a format the machinist likes and I should have it cut some time this week.
Picture not included in this copy
Are you mating 1-4 and 2-3 for your collector pairs?
Yes
Looky what I have here ;)
Picture not included in this copy
Picture not included in this copy
Oooh... nice. 🙂
What kind of welder are you going to use?
What kind of welder are you going to use?
Great effort. Cant wait to see the results. 👍
Are you going to compare it to the stock manifold, or one of the existing headers that are on the market? I have a spare DC if you want to use it for a dyno comparison.
Are you going to compare it to the stock manifold, or one of the existing headers that are on the market? I have a spare DC if you want to use it for a dyno comparison.
I'm not a strong welder, but my exhaust guy will probably tig weld everything except maybe the collectors(not sure if they can be tig welded or not).
ooo shiny pipes lol
There will be a comparison to either the stock or your DC if you don't mind me borrowing it 👍 its gonna have to come off after a few weeks of driving around so it can be coated. Hopefully if everything goes well the machinist will have everything cut today and I can start with upper portion today.
The results should be interesting, I know what the simulation numbers say so lets see if I end up beating them ;)
The results should be interesting, I know what the simulation numbers say so lets see if I end up beating them ;)
It is just sitting on the shelf, so happy to let you use it for the test. Being that you are going long tube, are you going to do a clamp together patch section of some type so you could get from the DC/stock collector location to your mid-pipe?Originally Posted by xnamerxx ↑There will be a comparison to either the stock or your DC if you don't mind me borrowing it 👍 its gonna have to come off after a few weeks of driving around so it can be coated. Hopefully if everything goes well the machinist will have everything cut today and I can start with upper portion today.
The results should be interesting, I know what the simulation numbers say so lets see if I end up beating them ;)
I'm going to have 3-4 3 bolt flanges cut so everything can be relatively compatible with the stock mid pipe and my race mid pipe. The piece that's being cut out will be flanged along with the cut midpipe so I can swap them back and forth.Originally Posted by Jason@SportsCar ↑It is just sitting on the shelf, so happy to let you use it for the test. Being that you are going long tube, are you going to do a clamp together patch section of some type so you could get from the DC/stock collector location to your mid-pipe?
My header will retain to stock rear cat so I can drive around on the street and get all the stress out of the metal before it goes to be coated. I will be able to move back to the stock mid pipe and header with relative ease for maintenance/repairs or emissions testing.
Freaking guy is thinking of everything on this!
Good job Namer!
Good job Namer!
Have you ever seen any v-band flanges that are 1-3/4"? I've never been able to find any, retail anyhow.
Are you going to do just a single flex pipe after the 2-1 transition?
Part of my 2 pipe section is going to be a pair of flex pipes - they'll be just after the tubing turns parallel to the ground, so I figure it's a good place to put them... needs tubing and help save the header at the same :)
It's the inner braided style too, so relatively low flow restriction compared to an open bellows style flex pipe.
Are you going to do just a single flex pipe after the 2-1 transition?
Part of my 2 pipe section is going to be a pair of flex pipes - they'll be just after the tubing turns parallel to the ground, so I figure it's a good place to put them... needs tubing and help save the header at the same :)
It's the inner braided style too, so relatively low flow restriction compared to an open bellows style flex pipe.
http://www.reidwashbon.com/racing_pa...ts/v-band.aspx
They aren't all that difficult to find but they are usually pricey. I wasn't going to be using a flex pipe due to packaging issues, so I'm getting around the flex problem by using a beatrush dogbone. I have just enough space to fit a ball and cone socket while still utilizing the stock rear catalyst.
I'd caution against using flex pipes in the header pipes due to the fact you can't have them coated without damaging the coating. Also you might find yourself being unable to fit 2 flex joints on the secondary pipes remember they are about an inch wider than the pipe their based off of.
I wish I could post an update but my machinist has been swamped with work, so I haven't been able to get the flange cut and the exhaust started :( I've been told I should have the part by Monday but I'm not holding my breath.
They aren't all that difficult to find but they are usually pricey. I wasn't going to be using a flex pipe due to packaging issues, so I'm getting around the flex problem by using a beatrush dogbone. I have just enough space to fit a ball and cone socket while still utilizing the stock rear catalyst.
I'd caution against using flex pipes in the header pipes due to the fact you can't have them coated without damaging the coating. Also you might find yourself being unable to fit 2 flex joints on the secondary pipes remember they are about an inch wider than the pipe their based off of.
I wish I could post an update but my machinist has been swamped with work, so I haven't been able to get the flange cut and the exhaust started :( I've been told I should have the part by Monday but I'm not holding my breath.
Thanks a bunch for the link - I think Burns Stainless has them, but they are around $80 a piece. Hope these guys have them for cheaper.Originally Posted by xnamerxx ↑http://www.reidwashbon.com/racing_pa...ts/v-band.aspx
They aren't all that difficult to find but they are usually pricey. I wasn't going to be using a flex pipe due to packaging issues, so I'm getting around the flex problem by using a beatrush dogbone. I have just enough space to fit a ball and cone socket while still utilizing the stock rear catalyst.
I'd caution against using flex pipes in the header pipes due to the fact you can't have them coated without damaging the coating. Also you might find yourself being unable to fit 2 flex joints on the secondary pipes remember they are about an inch wider than the pipe their based off of.
I've already got the flex pipes welded onto the 2-1 merge collector :)
Off the top of my head, the total width is around 4.5", but if that ends up being a problem, I can always clock it at a 45* angle to make the package a little skinnier.
At this point, I'm not too worried about coating the header, worst case scenario I'll coat the top part and wrap the bottom.
Echo's only have one cat, so I'm lucky there, but I have other issues to contend with...
Ahh I thought you had a Yaris...can't comment on the echo engine bay I know I'm limited width wise but have enough space for my pipes. Burns and Coastfab both have them but V bands are expensive, even the cheap vibrant ones are still 75 for the package. Burns is overprices for most everything, you can get SS and associated parts for less money elsewhere.
Any progress?
This + the mi intake Mani is gonna make my yaris breathe so well.
I hope to have the flange finished today, but so far no progess :(
Once I have the flange I can start with the build and it should be a fairly quick process from there on out.
Once I have the flange I can start with the build and it should be a fairly quick process from there on out.
cool
Just picked this up from the shop 👍
I need to do some finish work on it but overall everything came out better than I hoped.
Picture not included in this copy
I need to do some finish work on it but overall everything came out better than I hoped.
Picture not included in this copy
Looks really neatol! 👍
Will you put the runners inside the flange holes?
Will you put the runners inside the flange holes?
sorta I'm either going to flare the tube or cut and wedge the pipe in the flange. I matched the flange port diameter to that of the gasket so I don't induce any extra sharp edges that will mess up the initial shockwave from the exhaust.
I'm going to speak with the welder and see if I can get this started tonight.
I'm going to speak with the welder and see if I can get this started tonight.
I had a similar issue building the manifold, and had little "shelves" machined into edges of the ports to hold the runners in alignment while they were being welded up. It worked great because the weld filled in the shelf and covered it up smoothly... 🙂
Picture not included in this copy
...leaving the inside relatively clean.
Picture not included in this copy
Picture not included in this copy
...leaving the inside relatively clean.
Picture not included in this copy
All cleaned up and ready to be welded on :)
Picture not included in this copy
Picture not included in this copy
Well its time for me to post a real update
I now understand why Richard Holdener went with a 4-1 design its so much easier to package and get the correct length out of. I'm about 1/3 to about a 1/2 of the way finished with the primaries. Thank god the welder who is helping me out had experience building motorcycle race exhausts because I made some bone headed mistakes. All in all my primaries are longer than the stock primaries and my secondaries will be cake on top of that. So to keep you guys tided over here is a picture of the first tube being tacked in place.
Picture not included in this copy
I now understand why Richard Holdener went with a 4-1 design its so much easier to package and get the correct length out of. I'm about 1/3 to about a 1/2 of the way finished with the primaries. Thank god the welder who is helping me out had experience building motorcycle race exhausts because I made some bone headed mistakes. All in all my primaries are longer than the stock primaries and my secondaries will be cake on top of that. So to keep you guys tided over here is a picture of the first tube being tacked in place.
Picture not included in this copy
It's so exciting to see your project begin to take shape. 🙂
It's like creating a work of functional art! 👍
What are you using to cut the tubing so cleanly?
It's like creating a work of functional art! 👍
What are you using to cut the tubing so cleanly?
I'm a bit fortunate to have access to shop equipment but I've been cutting everything with a band saw, grinder, or belt sander.
So in order to get the clean cuts after I make the initial cut I deburr the edge of the tube both inside and out and it makes that nice clean lines, makes it way easier to weld as well apparently too. I can't take all the credit though, I'm getting lots of help from the welder on how to properly work with tubing.
I'm amazing on how much work it is to make these pipes, its been quite fun, but quite a bit of work. I wish I took some more pictures after I got the collector on but it was getting late and I needed to home. Hopefully I'll get the other 2 pipes welded up tomorrow and a initial test fit to see if everything's kosher.
Something I thought was a bit funny but my primaries right now on my tri-y header are longer than the primaries on the stock header and I still have about 2 feet of secondaries to add.
So in order to get the clean cuts after I make the initial cut I deburr the edge of the tube both inside and out and it makes that nice clean lines, makes it way easier to weld as well apparently too. I can't take all the credit though, I'm getting lots of help from the welder on how to properly work with tubing.
I'm amazing on how much work it is to make these pipes, its been quite fun, but quite a bit of work. I wish I took some more pictures after I got the collector on but it was getting late and I needed to home. Hopefully I'll get the other 2 pipes welded up tomorrow and a initial test fit to see if everything's kosher.
Something I thought was a bit funny but my primaries right now on my tri-y header are longer than the primaries on the stock header and I still have about 2 feet of secondaries to add.
are you going to dyno the results before and after?
If yours going to be this long?Originally Posted by xnamerxx ↑I'm a bit fortunate to have access to shop equipment but I've been cutting everything with a band saw, grinder, or belt sander.
So in order to get the clean cuts after I make the initial cut I deburr the edge of the tube both inside and out and it makes that nice clean lines, makes it way easier to weld as well apparently too. I can't take all the credit though, I'm getting lots of help from the welder on how to properly work with tubing.
I'm amazing on how much work it is to make these pipes, its been quite fun, but quite a bit of work. I wish I took some more pictures after I got the collector on but it was getting late and I needed to home. Hopefully I'll get the other 2 pipes welded up tomorrow and a initial test fit to see if everything's kosher.
Something I thought was a bit funny but my primaries right now on my tri-y header are longer than the primaries on the stock header and I still have about 2 feet of secondaries to add.
Picture not included in this copy
(just joking 😉 )
I have dyno results from when I was stock, but I'm going to dyno it against a DC header after its been vetted.
LOL its going to be close but thats all I'm going to say 🙄
Another taste ;)
Picture not included in this copy
LOL its going to be close but thats all I'm going to say 🙄
Another taste ;)
Picture not included in this copy
Is your header going to have an 02 sensor bung? I was thinking of chopping my WR header in half and adding a couple of straight tubes to lengthen it. 😉
nice work