Well if everything goes according to plan I should have the new header finished and running next week.
My Long Tube header build
180 posts · 67,815 views · page 3 of 4
Replies continued
the motor mounts in our cars are incredibly soft & these motors go all over the place. a flex joint at the end of a 3-4foot long 'lever' would not be adequate.Originally Posted by xnamerxx ↑The stock motor doesn't have a flex joint, it uses a ball and socket joint. The reason the joint is located where it is stock is because that's the easiest and cheapest place to put it. There does have to be some flex in the exhaust and ideally it should be as close to the motor as possible but you work with the space you're given.
The exhaust itself is hung which allows some movement there so the only reason you even need flex in the exhaust itself is to reduce the wagging motion of the main pipe and reduce load from the header. If you look at the header there is a support beam the bolts to the block and the header and that's what's carrying most of the fore and aft load from the header which is another reason why the ball and socket is located where it is. I've done some analysis on this I have an idea of where the load is sitting. If the side bracket isn't in place all of the load will sit on the flange and the failure will be located on the flange, if the side bracket is in place the pipes are thick enough to handle most of the load but the secondary flange will still be taking some load under movement but its substantially less with the flex joint in place. So to get some flex I chose a flex joint over a ball and socket because its easier for me to incorporate it the multiple center section exhausts that I have.
to get an idea of how much front scratchers (FWDs) boucne about. go to your local test-n-tune with all the kids beating the fuck out their cars...its quite alarming.
the flex joint NEEDS to be located as close as possible to the motor to reduce the leverage on the rest of the exhaust, period. the further away it is, the less its able to absorb.
I've measured a touch over 2.5",on the rev limiter, of movement. With that being said it doesn't matter in my case since my roll mount will have been taken care of.Originally Posted by malibuguy ↑the motor mounts in our cars are incredibly soft & these motors go all over the place. a flex joint at the end of a 3-4foot long 'lever' would not be adequate.
to get an idea of how much front scratchers (FWDs) boucne about. go to your local test-n-tune with all the kids beating the fuck out their cars...its quite alarming.
the flex joint NEEDS to be located as close as possible to the motor to reduce the leverage on the rest of the exhaust, period. the further away it is, the less its able to absorb.
Yep, but you can't package a a flex joint in the location it needs to be in with joints that are a proper diameter.
It took me a while to catch onto what you're getting at, malibu. It's like a lever. The farther away you are from the axis of rotation, the more movement there is. I'd never even considered this as a factor.Originally Posted by malibuguy ↑the motor mounts in our cars are incredibly soft & these motors go all over the place. a flex joint at the end of a 3-4foot long 'lever' would not be adequate.
to get an idea of how much front scratchers (FWDs) boucne about. go to your local test-n-tune with all the kids beating the fuck out their cars...its quite alarming.
the flex joint NEEDS to be located as close as possible to the motor to reduce the leverage on the rest of the exhaust, period. the further away it is, the less its able to absorb.
Thanks for the useful info, namer. 🙂Originally Posted by xnamerxx ↑I can't directly comment since I'm a pretty terrible welder but SS requires a different kind of gas and filler material.
I guess it depends on if you're using a Flux weld material or MIG/TIG welding. If its MIG or TIG you need gas otherwise it'll splatter and sugar really bad plus just weld like crap.
I think this might be helpful (http://www.brazing.com/techguide/pro...stainless.asp)
I only have a flux core welder with no gas, so that won't cut it. If I need anything done, I'll just go to the pro welder who does the manifolds.
Flux core welds look like crap but you should be able to weld SS with it as long as you have the correct filler.
There's also quite a bit more that needs to be considered with header design, just welding longer tubes can actually result in power loss if it calls into a dead range where the reverse shockwave happens too quickly or too slowly. There are other things to consider in regards to load and heat and such but that would quite a bit of time to type out.
There's also quite a bit more that needs to be considered with header design, just welding longer tubes can actually result in power loss if it calls into a dead range where the reverse shockwave happens too quickly or too slowly. There are other things to consider in regards to load and heat and such but that would quite a bit of time to type out.
I've already got the 2-1 section of my header welded up, and it's mostly made up of a pair of 10" long, 1.75" ID flex pipes. Should allow for tons of flexibility, right where it's needed.Originally Posted by xnamerxx ↑I've measured a touch over 2.5",on the rev limiter, of movement. With that being said it doesn't matter in my case since my roll mount will have been taken care of.
Yep, but you can't package a a flex joint in the location it needs to be in with joints that are a proper diameter.
I'm tired of arguing this point. There is lots of math and formulas to determine the best length and diameter for a header. The formula I use specifies something different than what you chose to use. With the dimensions I chose I cannot package a flex pipe on the secondaries and wouldn't do so because laminar flow is substantially worse through a flex pipe than a tube. If you look inside a flex pipe there is a series of baffles which make it behave similar to that of a crush bent tube.
What we're all trying to get at is that we hope it works, but would hate to see it crack because of how you designed it without any flex in it.
On that note have you considered the use of spring clamped slip joints? Laminar flow but will allow the pipes to move should they need to.
On that note have you considered the use of spring clamped slip joints? Laminar flow but will allow the pipes to move should they need to.
I'm not using the stock dog bone spring bolts flex joints are all irrelevant. The only reason I'm even considering a flex joint is to reduce exhaust noise slightly and help remove thermal growth caused by the catalyst.Originally Posted by xnamerxx ↑it doesn't matter in my case since my roll mount will have been taken care of.
My comment about the flex joint is that the bellows cause friction in fluid flow which causes turbulence which reduces flow. For that alone I wouldn't want to run them in my primaries where any slowing of gas flow can have drastic consequences.
I've done the math, run the simulations and calculated the load and stress points. I'm very confident in my design that I don't feel its going to suffer a fatigue failure.
That's ok. I think at this stage of the game I'll just leave everything be.Originally Posted by xnamerxx ↑Flux core welds look like crap but you should be able to weld SS with it as long as you have the correct filler.
There's also quite a bit more that needs to be considered with header design, just welding longer tubes can actually result in power loss if it calls into a dead range where the reverse shockwave happens too quickly or too slowly. There are other things to consider in regards to load and heat and such but that would quite a bit of time to type out.
Dude, you're so worked up you can't even read what I typed. I said SLIP JOINT. Not FLEX JOINT.Originally Posted by xnamerxx ↑I'm not using the stock dog bone spring bolts flex joints are all irrelevant. The only reason I'm even considering a flex joint is to reduce exhaust noise slightly and help remove thermal growth caused by the catalyst.
My comment about the flex joint is that the bellows cause friction in fluid flow which causes turbulence which reduces flow. For that alone I wouldn't want to run them in my primaries where any slowing of gas flow can have drastic consequences.
I've done the math, run the simulations and calculated the load and stress points. I'm very confident in my design that I don't feel its going to suffer a fatigue failure.
This is a Slip Joint.
1 attachment not included in this copy
I skipped over that point as I assumed you thought slip joints are a way to control exhaust flex.
Yes I did consider a slip joint originally as a way to join the 2 sections of pipe but chose against it for various reasons. The biggest reason I chose against it was that slip joints are weak. In my situation there is still load traveling through the second set of pipe even though there is minimal engine movement in the exhaust its still carrying the load from the 30 lbs of exhaust and that load is effectively being distributed through only one of the pipes which doesn't have a ton of bearing area. If I was mounting the second section of pipe lower down I would probably go to a slip joint, it wasn't appropriate in my situation.
Yes I did consider a slip joint originally as a way to join the 2 sections of pipe but chose against it for various reasons. The biggest reason I chose against it was that slip joints are weak. In my situation there is still load traveling through the second set of pipe even though there is minimal engine movement in the exhaust its still carrying the load from the 30 lbs of exhaust and that load is effectively being distributed through only one of the pipes which doesn't have a ton of bearing area. If I was mounting the second section of pipe lower down I would probably go to a slip joint, it wasn't appropriate in my situation.
Would one of these help?
Picture not included in this copy
Picture not included in this copy
I don't know maybe. I prefer to stiffen the dogbone rather than add weight somewhere else.
I think some of you guys are loosing focus on the big picture... Build a prototype, get it on the car and see if it makes power. If needed issues like a flex joint, ball joint or the engine support can be addressed when a production piece is made.
^ +1.
The TRD Trans mount is stiffer and does more to control engine movement than the NITTO torque damper (which does work, just to a lesser degree).
The TRD Trans mount is stiffer and does more to control engine movement than the NITTO torque damper (which does work, just to a lesser degree).
is this going to delete the cat and O2 sensor or just relocate it farther down the path? sorry, I am a latecomer.
I do like the idea of the longtube header. can't wait to see the finished product and dyno sheet.
I do like the idea of the longtube header. can't wait to see the finished product and dyno sheet.
+2^ Jason
Cali do you know the durometer of the rubber used in the TRD mount?
The rules require I run a catalyst so I will have to keep that. I will be modifying my existing race mid-pipe for this exhaust system so it will accept the new collector location, but I will likely have to redesign that as there is an issue with length. The mid pipe is actually one of the bigger issues I'm still battling, there's a problem unique to this engine design that create a really bad off throttle drone.
The rear o2 will be kept since there isn't a reason to remove it, I may just weld a new bung onto the rear of the cat or use an CEL eliminator I'll probably try both and see which one is easier to keep in the long run.
Cali do you know the durometer of the rubber used in the TRD mount?
The rules require I run a catalyst so I will have to keep that. I will be modifying my existing race mid-pipe for this exhaust system so it will accept the new collector location, but I will likely have to redesign that as there is an issue with length. The mid pipe is actually one of the bigger issues I'm still battling, there's a problem unique to this engine design that create a really bad off throttle drone.
The rear o2 will be kept since there isn't a reason to remove it, I may just weld a new bung onto the rear of the cat or use an CEL eliminator I'll probably try both and see which one is easier to keep in the long run.
Cali do you know the durometer of the rubber used in the TRD mount?I've not been able to find that information. So the answer so far is "Stiffer."
I have the TRD engine mounts + trans mount and my motor doesn't move much at all any more. Nice and loud in the cabin too. 🙂
I can definitely vouch for the Energy poly motor+tranny mounts doing exactly the same thing lolOriginally Posted by cali yaris ↑
I have the TRD engine mounts + trans mount and my motor doesn't move much at all any more. Nice and loud in the cabin too. 🙂
The car is loud and whole car vibrates
well no pictures but everything has been tacked together...the secondaries were way more difficult than I was expecting. All that's left is to burn everything together and my header will be done.
Well its finally finished. I'll post a video our something later tonight.
All I'm going to say is I'm glad i did this the seat of the pants feeling is intense
Can't wait to see it in action!!! First one!
You took an idea and made it real... that's a respectable accomplishment.👍Originally Posted by xnamerxx ↑All I'm going to say is I'm glad i did this the seat of the pants feeling is intense
Now how about some pics and videos? 😉
unfortunately there's not much to show right now :( I have a bit of an interference issue with my mid pipe right now and its causing the car to extra loud and annoying, but with the headers the car did get quite audibly louder even with a big 15x5" muffler its almost unbearable.
I decided against showing pictures of the completed project as its a prototype and doesn't really look all that good. in its completed form.
Driving the car around is a bit of a strange experience because in most situations the power isn't really noticed due to how the cams behave, but I can light the tires up with ease without a clutch dump, and hold it well into 2nd gear, but this has created a bit of a problem for me as I now am having trouble getting traction coming out of corners, the tires blow away at part throttle pretty easily.
I don't think I gained much top end if any, and I'm pretty sure I lost some at the bottom but in the middle it feels really really strong much stronger than a little 1.5 should feel. Again I don't want to post a video of this just yet until I figure out this interference issue.
I decided against showing pictures of the completed project as its a prototype and doesn't really look all that good. in its completed form.
Driving the car around is a bit of a strange experience because in most situations the power isn't really noticed due to how the cams behave, but I can light the tires up with ease without a clutch dump, and hold it well into 2nd gear, but this has created a bit of a problem for me as I now am having trouble getting traction coming out of corners, the tires blow away at part throttle pretty easily.
I don't think I gained much top end if any, and I'm pretty sure I lost some at the bottom but in the middle it feels really really strong much stronger than a little 1.5 should feel. Again I don't want to post a video of this just yet until I figure out this interference issue.
I understand the process you're experiencing. There's always at least a few backward steps whenever you engage in research and development. But how the creative process itself unfolds is totally fascinating. Maybe you'll discover a new out of the box idea while you're working on overcoming obstacles. 👍
Yeah this piece of exhaust has been a bit of a pita from the get go. The big issue is that I don't really understand acoustics, or how to control them, plus this motor is a bit extra complicated to make it that much worse. Going to a giant muffler doesn't really fix the issue and I'm not sure a resonator will either but I've got a lot more reading to do so I can fix this problem.
My car is actually louder under light throttle acceleration that it is at WOT isn't that a bitch.
I was testing the header in the private lot behind my office. This picture isn't from a clutch dump. I could have held it longer but didn't have enough space. That line is probably about 50-70ft long.
Picture not included in this copy
My car is actually louder under light throttle acceleration that it is at WOT isn't that a bitch.
I was testing the header in the private lot behind my office. This picture isn't from a clutch dump. I could have held it longer but didn't have enough space. That line is probably about 50-70ft long.
Picture not included in this copy
Is the resonance being transmitted through actual direct contact between the header runners and the body of your car? What are you running behind your header? Is it all just pipe to the muffler? And what diameter? When you say that the car is louder under partial throttle than under full throttle, that tells me that the muffler is too large. Not in outside dimensions but the inside tubing diameter.
Nope no contact aside from the muffler hitting the heatshield at idle making a slight rattle noise. The noise in and of itself isn't from contact but mostly due to the location of the muffler. Behind the header is a cat, muffler, and turndown or side exhaust depending on how I want to run it. The muffler is tubing diameter is 2.25" and the tubing is perforated its a magnaflow. I've had the same behavior with all the mufflers I've used the small and large ones so Idk.
The exhaust is much louder at lower rpms and high load because its a low frequency and when the motor is screaming its a higher frequency. I think its partially due to how the cam timing behaves are high load low engine speed since there is a ton of overlap.
The exhaust is much louder at lower rpms and high load because its a low frequency and when the motor is screaming its a higher frequency. I think its partially due to how the cam timing behaves are high load low engine speed since there is a ton of overlap.
There's really nothing you can do to avoid low rpm drone short of adding a second muffler/resonator and having the exhaust exit at the back of the car. It's just how it is, especially on naturally-aspirated 4 cylinders.
That's great because direct physical contact is the hardest to correct. 🙂Originally Posted by xnamerxx ↑Nope no contact aside from the muffler hitting the heatshield at idle making a slight rattle noise.
The noise in and of itself isn't from contact but mostly due to the location of the muffler. Behind the header is a cat, muffler, and turndown or side exhaust depending on how I want to run it.If the end of your exhaust is terminating under the car, you'll gets lots of low frequencies. If the muffler is farther away from the termination point and closer to the header, you'll also get low frequencies. that's one reason the Yaris muffler is all the way in the back.
I have a long tube header on my truck...
Picture not included in this copy
...and with the rest of the exhaust exactly the same, it does not make the exhaust any louder. I don't think yours is either. My guess is that noise issue lies in the rest of the exhaust.
The muffler is tubing diameter is 2.25" and the tubing is perforated its a magnaflow. I've had the same behavior with all the mufflers I've used the small and large ones so Idk.Straight through Magnaflow, or offset? Mine is a little tiny 11 inch long 2 1/4 inch tubing Magnaflow but it's offset and very mellow.
The exhaust is much louder at lower rpms and high load because its a low frequency and when the motor is screaming its a higher frequency. I think its partially due to how the cam timing behaves are high load low engine speed since there is a ton of overlap.In my opinion, you don't have a serious problem. The exhaust just needs a little more tinkering. You'll get it dialed in. 👍
Well got the rattle figured out...the bolts on the collector were loose, whoops that was an easy fix.
Yeah the header is actually quieter at idle than the stock exhaust not by much but its definitely quieter. The header is currently bolted up to my race exhaust so I figured it was going to be loud and it is but the low frequencies are much worse than I was expecting. Its a straight through muffler so its not really muffling much. I'll get the exhaust figured out but I just wanted it to be mostly finished :) its been a long project.
Yeah the header is actually quieter at idle than the stock exhaust not by much but its definitely quieter. The header is currently bolted up to my race exhaust so I figured it was going to be loud and it is but the low frequencies are much worse than I was expecting. Its a straight through muffler so its not really muffling much. I'll get the exhaust figured out but I just wanted it to be mostly finished :) its been a long project.
with the straight through design and the fact that it end under the car instead of out the back it is no wonder that it is loud. when it exit under the car it will echo and on top of the louder exhaust design.
as for traction, I am lead from other post that our cars love exhaust and gain a lot of power. has there been any thing else done to the car? A limited slip would resolve some issues as well as handling mods (i.e. sway bars and such). what tires are you using, they might not be gripping well enough. cold tires, cold street, lower grip conditions.
as for traction, I am lead from other post that our cars love exhaust and gain a lot of power. has there been any thing else done to the car? A limited slip would resolve some issues as well as handling mods (i.e. sway bars and such). what tires are you using, they might not be gripping well enough. cold tires, cold street, lower grip conditions.
The resonator makes a HUGE difference in the sound. Just an FYI.
Does the "race exhaust" dump under the car? or exit out the back?
When is dyno day?
A couple of weeks.
Just finished an autox and a few people were convinced i had cams because if how hard this car was accelerating.
Just finished an autox and a few people were convinced i had cams because if how hard this car was accelerating.
dang so butt dyno says big gains? I see youre leaving rubber behind lol
Yeah I was just going over my data...the car is definitively faster than before. I actually had problems getting power down.
c'mon man, just one little pic???
(please)
(please)
I'm a bit embarrassed to d say this but i never took a picture if the final piece, only the tracked together piece. There are some changes thatwere made from this
Picture not included in this copy
Picture not included in this copy
I'll take it all the same.
I like seeing projects like this come together. Reminds me a lot of tooter's intake manifold experiment. Cant wait to see the dyno sheet.
I like seeing projects like this come together. Reminds me a lot of tooter's intake manifold experiment. Cant wait to see the dyno sheet.
Soooo long!!!
^ that's what she said hehe
^ that's what she said hehe
Glad it's putting out some power :)Originally Posted by xnamerxx ↑unfortunately there's not much to show right now :( I have a bit of an interference issue with my mid pipe right now and its causing the car to extra loud and annoying, but with the headers the car did get quite audibly louder even with a big 15x5" muffler its almost unbearable.
I decided against showing pictures of the completed project as its a prototype and doesn't really look all that good. in its completed form.
Driving the car around is a bit of a strange experience because in most situations the power isn't really noticed due to how the cams behave, but I can light the tires up with ease without a clutch dump, and hold it well into 2nd gear, but this has created a bit of a problem for me as I now am having trouble getting traction coming out of corners, the tires blow away at part throttle pretty easily.
I don't think I gained much top end if any, and I'm pretty sure I lost some at the bottom but in the middle it feels really really strong much stronger than a little 1.5 should feel. Again I don't want to post a video of this just yet until I figure out this interference issue.
glad to see this is completed.
Yeah :) I just can't wait to get it on the dyno. All in all this project has at least forced me to learn far more about engine dynamics than I ever expected to know.
"and knowing, is half the battle."
G.I. JOOOOOOOOOOEEEEEEEEE.....