Yarisworld Archive

Using DFCO to increase your MPG

216 posts · 627,952 views · page 4 of 5

Replies continued

talnlnkySpokane, Wa · Mar 10, 2010#151
Originally Posted by sbergman27 ↑
You mean... after you started consciously aiming toward decelerating over a longer distance and using the brakes less?

Reality check: Consider that if you manage to stay in DFCO mode for a full hour, you've only saved about 0.2 gallons of fuel (specifically due to DFCO) since the Yaris' engine uses about 0.2 gal/hr at idle. To get a 10% improvement in fuel economy over the course of a tank of gas, you would have to spend over 5.5 extra *hours* in DFCO mode. Do you think that you are managing that much?

-Steve Bergman
no... had nothing to do with being more conscious... It had to do with coasting in neutral, vs in DFCO... that instantly bumped me up from 36's to 40's. I was trying to get good mpg's from the first day i bought my yaris... took a few months before i found out about dfco. When you are going down a nearly 2mile long stretch of 5% grade highway at 60-65mph, your engine is using more gas than at idle.... I was able to change that 2 minutes of gas in my commute every day into zero gas usage. Then you add in all the coasts on highway exits that are a quarter mile long, then all the coasts to a stop sign/stop light...etc.

It's easy to rack up time in DFCO if you were making sure you were coasting in neutral before you heard of DFCO.... The last stick car I had owned was a 86Jeep Cherokee I had in HS. It didn't have DFCO... so I always popped it into neutral when coasting.
sbergman27Oklahoma City, OK · Mar 10, 2010#152
Originally Posted by talnlnky ↑
It's easy to rack up time in DFCO if you were making sure you were coasting in neutral before you heard of DFCO....
Another way to put that is that it is easy to rack up more time in DFCO if you drive the car the way normal people do instead of trying to be clever with hypermiling tricks like coasting in neutral. These systems are designed with normal people in mind. Thus, there are sometimes FE advantages to being normal.

Regarding relative fuel use between normal idle and 65 mph in neutral, the Yaris uses about 20% less fuel in neutral. Normal idle uses 0.20 GPH, whereas coasting neutral uses 0.16 GPH.

So in 2 minutes of DFCO, you are saving a whopping 0.0053 gal (1/187th gal) of gasoline compared to coasting in neutral. Which is about 1/2100th of a tank. Keeping in mind, of course, that it takes longer to get down the hill with the transmission in gear due to that fact that the engine braking slows you down. So the actual savings would be less than that.

-Steve
BailOutThread starterReno, Nevada, USA · Mar 10, 2010#153
I see that you live in Oklahoma, Steve. Please try to expand your horizon enough to realize that not everyone lives in the Great Plain. Many of us, talnlnky included, live in hilly and/or mountainous regions, and in these areas it is not uncommon at all to be in DFCO for extended periods of time.

During my own commute there are instances where I am in fuel cut for as much as 7 miles at a time, for a total of around 20 miles per workday. Considering that commuting represents 90% of each tank, calculate that and then tell me that DFCO doesn't mean anything to FE.
talnlnkySpokane, Wa · Mar 10, 2010#154
Originally Posted by BailOut ↑
I see that you live in Oklahoma, Steve. Please try to expand your horizon enough to realize that not everyone lives in the Great Plain. Many of us, talnlnky included, live in hilly and/or mountainous regions, and in these areas it is not uncommon at all to be in DFCO for extended periods of time.

During my own commute there are instances where I am in fuel cut for as much as 7 miles at a time, for a total of around 20 miles per workday. Considering that commuting represents 90% of each tank, calculate that and then tell me that DFCO doesn't mean anything to FE.
Well, I used to live in a Hilly/mountainous area, now it's more of an extremely slow grade... but from time to time I get to go up and down some hills, or even the Cascade mountain range.

Some of my best tanks of gas have come from commutes that involved hills/mountains, where I was able to coast A LOT in gear.
YodaFL · Mar 10, 2010#155
so DFCO is better than coasting in neutral? cause i get 27 mpg right now lol
sbergman27Oklahoma City, OK · Mar 10, 2010#156
Originally Posted by BailOut ↑
I see that you live in Oklahoma, Steve. Please try to expand your horizon enough to realize that not everyone lives in the Great Plain.
Big mistake there, Bailout. My home address is in Oklahoma. But I drive to New Mexico, and/or Colorado nearly weekly. In fact, I just got back from Grand Teton National Park, in northwestern Wyoming, just south of Yellowstone, a few days ago.

(Yes, I drive *quite* a lot.)

Nice try. But you really need to get out more before you counsel me upon "expanding horizons". I probably cover more ground in a month or two than you do in a year. And more varied (and mountainous) ground, at that.

So why don't you try addressing the facts I've presented rather than trying to sneak in a personal attack based upon your guess about my driving experience. I have made quite a number of factual points, in previous posts, which you seem set upon ignoring.

Look. DFCO is a handy tool in the tool chest. But you have overemphasized it in comparison to some of the other useful tools there. I like seeing 9999 on my Scangauge II as much as anyone. But even over extended DFCO periods, the effect needs to be kept in perspective. Because the Yaris engine easily uses 20 times its idle consumption just as soon as you start ascending the next hill.

-Steve
sbergman27Oklahoma City, OK · Mar 10, 2010#157
Originally Posted by Yoda ↑
so DFCO is better than coasting in neutral? cause i get 27 mpg right now lol
Probably a little. You save about 0.00004 gallons for each second you do it. But you incur a fair amount of engine braking. And any fuel that did go through the engine if DFCO were not active would go to propelling the car forward.

So it really depends. Judiciously applied, it can help. But the ECU software is designed to do best when you don't try to second guess it.
BailOutThread starterReno, Nevada, USA · Mar 10, 2010#158
Originally Posted by sbergman27 ↑
So why don't you try addressing the facts I've presented
Because your "facts" change nothing. At the end of the day everything that you've presented is interesting but completely unnecessary, and contains as much opinion as fact.

I say again, getting caught up in the minutiae helps no one. Let us agree to disagree on the best implementation and/or public understanding of DFCO and move on.
sbergman27Oklahoma City, OK · Mar 10, 2010#159
Originally Posted by BailOut ↑
Because your "facts" change nothing.
Tell you what. Using 0.16 GPH for coasting in neutral, 0.20 GPH for idle, and 0.0 GPH for DFCO, and ignoring engine braking factors for now... why don't you work out for yourself how much DFCO could realistically be saving you on a per tank basis? I don't really care about the answer. But I think it would benefit you to go through the exercise.

Sorry if you feel I stepped on you toes regarding your "discovery". But the numbers I have presented cut to the very heart of this matter. If you disagree, then please present an alternative model.
why?harnett county NC · Mar 10, 2010#160
wow dude you're just being a jerk. This is the real world, not some lab.
skoolafishBaltimore · Mar 21, 2010#161
awesome. i did not know this
STCState College, PA, USA · Apr 20, 2010#162
I appreciate this Forum Thread. I’ve been using DFCO all the time since I read this thread. FE improvements have been incredible. Presently, I’m near making the 50 mpg range. This is a goal of mine to reach, before I use more advanced techniques.

I have a silly question? Does any one know?

There is a long mountain grade I drive every day. I let off the gas and use DFCO when I go down it. The long grade starts to level and my vehicle’s RPM drops down to around 1,000 – 1,100 RPM. But, then the grade steepens quickly causing my RPM to go back up to over 1,800. My MPH does drop down when I reach 1,100 RPM, but there are hardly any drivers, so I can do this...

Does DFCO kick back in automatically when the RPM goes back over 1,100? Or do you have to give it some gas (accelerator tap) over 1,100 RPM and then let the grade take over again? Is the Yaris ECU software designed to do this automatically? When the RPM gets just below 1,100 RPM and then climbs up again, I do nothing... just coast in the gear till I have to slow down and come to a stop at the bottom of the mountain.

Cheers...
micahsylrochester ny · Jun 29, 2010#163
um,,, i think this is called "coasting" people have been doing it for decades lol i like the special name for it now... DFCO great marketing ploy!
BailOutThread starterReno, Nevada, USA · Jun 29, 2010#164
Originally Posted by micahsyl ↑
um,,, i think this is called "coasting" people have been doing it for decades lol i like the special name for it now... DFCO great marketing ploy!
For decades, every time you took your foot off of the accelerator fuel still trickled into the carburetor or sprayed through the injectors at least at an idle-level flow. What has changed over the last decade is that carburetors have gone away and some car's computers are smart enough to turn off the injectors completely when you're in a "coasting" state.

That's DFCO - no fuel flowing at all when you coast in gear. In 65,000 miles I have never lost a fuel bar in the downhill segments of my commute (2,500 feet of elevation drop on the way to work and 4,500 feet of drop on the way home).
STCState College, PA, USA · Jun 29, 2010#165
Originally Posted by micahsyl ↑
um,,, i think this is called "coasting" people have been doing it for decades lol i like the special name for it now... DFCO great marketing ploy!
Engine braking "coasting" (Deceleration Fuel Cutoff - DFCO) or neutral "coasting"? Two different coasting arenas. With the former you coast with the car in gear while the latter you manually throw the car into neutral and coast.

Today with engine braking coasting the ECU turns off the fuel injectors... the axles turn the tranny... the crankshaft turns ... the pistons then turn. Nothing new... most cars with a computer are capable of this.

🙂 Yes... neutral coasting has been done for many decades, since the advent of disc brakes some 40+ years ago. Could not do that with an old Model T...

Cheers!
advocatelocation · Jul 7, 2010#166
If the injectors are off then the car isn't burning any fuel, I get that.

But the car seems to still make a lot of noise. This is amplified by my tanabe exhaust I'm sure but my point is it sounds like the engine is still running even when coasting in what I believe to be DFCO.

'07 5 speed btw. Any ideas?
BailOutThread starterReno, Nevada, USA · Jul 7, 2010#167
Originally Posted by advocate ↑
But the car seems to still make a lot of noise.
While no fuel is moving air certainly still is, meaning that in the DFCO state the engine is a compressor rather than a combustor.
advocatelocation · Jul 7, 2010#168
do the spark plugs still fire as well?
Yaris HiltonBristol, Tennessee, USA · Jul 7, 2010#169
Yes.
KrazyDawgSF Bay Area · Jul 12, 2010#170
I've been doing the rollercoaster ride where you go slower up the hill and go faster down the hill while trying to maintain the same pressure on the gas pedal. Is it more fuel efficient to go down a steep grade using DFCO? This is where a ScanGauge would probably come in handy.
Yaris HiltonBristol, Tennessee, USA · Jul 12, 2010#171
That's what the hypermilers call "Driving With Load." Yes, if you're going down a steep hill you'll back off of the gas and it will go into DFCO.
ChilliwackGuyChilliwack BC, Canada · Jul 12, 2010#172
I've been "coasting" or using "DFCO" techniques throughout my 13 years of driving - and mostly on 6 days a week commuting - 250KM daily totals!

The key for me has always been to minimize brake usage - and instead - focus on lifing and pressing my foot on the gas pedal. (I make it a game to coast to a red light!) Yeah - my passengers get annoyed but I have saved SO MUCH gas.
imjustagirl8_05Phoenix, AZ · Jul 31, 2010#173
So I just found this site and it's really cool. I am learning a lot about my Yaris! I bought my car in Jan 2007, I had no idea there were earlier models! I'm not sure if my car is 4 speed, but I think it is, since it's AT. Does this mean I have the DFCO? I haven't tested it out the way you described yet, but I definitely will! I just wanted to ask, is the ignition only to be turned off to test whether I have it? If I do have it, I would just have to lower a gear (like to 3) to get into DFCO mode, and it would stop using gas while slowing my car? Sorry, I'm slow, I had to read this post three times and search some terms to get it, but please let me know if I've understood correctly. Thanks!🆘
Maxh91New-Brunswick , Canada · Aug 1, 2010#174
Originally Posted by imjustagirl8_05 ↑
So I just found this site and it's really cool. I am learning a lot about my Yaris! I bought my car in Jan 2007, I had no idea there were earlier models! I'm not sure if my car is 4 speed, but I think it is, since it's AT. Does this mean I have the DFCO? I haven't tested it out the way you described yet, but I definitely will! I just wanted to ask, is the ignition only to be turned off to test whether I have it? If I do have it, I would just have to lower a gear (like to 3) to get into DFCO mode, and it would stop using gas while slowing my car? Sorry, I'm slow, I had to read this post three times and search some terms to get it, but please let me know if I've understood correctly. Thanks!🆘
-Yes you yaris have DFCO
-As your yaris is a 2007, you need to be in 3th or lower to activate the DFCO.
The 2008 and newer can do DFCO in every gear.
-You car need to be in gear (L,2,3) to activate the DFCO AND you need to be above 1100RPM
Yaris HiltonBristol, Tennessee, USA · Aug 1, 2010#175
Sometime in the mid-2007 model year they changed so the DFCO works in Drive. About the time yours was made, IIRC. The 2007 I originally bought for my wife has DFCO in Drive. No need to downshift. Don't switch off the key. While cruising along, let off the gas. .5-.7 second later, you'll feel a gentle deceleration as the fuel cuts off.
Maxh91New-Brunswick , Canada · Aug 1, 2010#176
I did not know about the mid-2007!

@imjustagirl8_05 I feel the DFCO after 1 or 2 second(AT). Just need to look at your RPM and you will see it slowing.
sickpuppy1Kansas · Aug 1, 2010#177
I have a 2010 sedan w/AT and as much as I try to feel anything, I cant notice a thing when say I'm cruising to an exit ramp on the highway. I try to let off and notice DFCO but don't notice a thing. I'm curious, because if I keep it in gear, I can let off gas a little more than a quarter mile before the ramp and coast to the light at exit. If I just put it in neutral, I can coast at least a 1/2 mile or more and still have to use the brakes to stop. I never notice it kicking in and it seems I possibly would save more fuel by just coasting. Am I wrong here?
sickpuppy1Kansas · Aug 1, 2010#178
That being said, I don't know why, but I always wonder if putting it in neutral and coasting is bad on the tranny, any thoughts, remember its an AT
YarisduderMontreal, Canada · Aug 1, 2010#179
I find you can tell if you have it just by watching the RPMs as the needle gets down to just above 1000 it will jump up a little before settling into an idle. If you don't have a Tach you can feel it quite distinctly if you brake lightly.

In my 2007 auto sedan, DFCO works in D but in the city it's mostly useless because of the low speed unless I put it into 3 just before braking, sometimes I'll drop into 2 also, but I find it more hassle than help. L is completely useless.
Maxh91New-Brunswick , Canada · Aug 1, 2010#180
Originally Posted by sickpuppy1 ↑
That being said, I don't know why, but I always wonder if putting it in neutral and coasting is bad on the tranny, any thoughts, remember its an AT
It is not recomended that you put your transmission in neutral if your transmission is automatic. The transmission could overheat because there are no oil moving in the transmission if in neutral. Manual transmission dont have this problem.

If someone could confirm 😁
sickpuppy1Kansas · Aug 1, 2010#181
I know you shouldnt if the motor is not running and your coasting, but if memory serves me, the pump is running all the time, even in neutral.
daf62757Indianapolis, Indiana · Aug 1, 2010#182
Originally Posted by Maxh91 ↑
It is not recomended that you put your transmission in neutral if your transmission is automatic. The transmission could overheat because there are no oil moving in the transmission if in neutral. Manual transmission dont have this problem.

If someone could confirm 😁
I was always taught that moving the transmission from neutral to drive while moving could damage the transmission. The only place to move the tranny is from a dead stop.

Might be urban legend....might be for old trannys that were made by Govt. Motors back in the day....but my Dad taught me this and he was a Mechanical Engineer and I always thought his words were the rule!

So it is my rule!
Yaris HiltonBristol, Tennessee, USA · Aug 1, 2010#183
DFCO is not worth giving all the attention people are giving it here. It's just cutting off the tiny bit of idle fuel that cars used to waste while coasting in gear. It's done for emissions control primarily. Nearly every car has it now. No biggie.
BailOutThread starterReno, Nevada, USA · Aug 1, 2010#184
Originally Posted by Yaris Hilton ↑
DFCO is not worth giving all the attention people are giving it here. It's just cutting off the tiny bit of idle fuel that cars used to waste while coasting in gear. It's done for emissions control primarily. Nearly every car has it now. No biggie.
Actually, only around 50% of all cars have it now, and when employed willingly it is a valuable fuel saving tool. I'm surprised to hear you make such a flippant remark regarding something that so easily saves fuel.

Please also remember that for folks that live in hilly areas DFCO is even more useful. For example, when coming down the mountain I can stay in DFCO for several miles at a time. That makes a huge impact over the course of each tank.
KrazyDawgSF Bay Area · Aug 2, 2010#185
Originally Posted by BailOut ↑
Actually, only around 50% of all cars have it now, and when employed willingly it is a valuable fuel saving tool. I'm surprised to hear you make such a flippant remark regarding something that so easily saves fuel.

Please also remember that for folks that live in hilly areas DFCO is even more useful. For example, when coming down the mountain I can stay in DFCO for several miles at a time. That makes a huge impact over the course of each tank.
That's a good point. I've seen my average MPG increase when using DFCO downhill.
Beer JammerSomerset · Aug 3, 2010#186
Hi All.

I've been insterestedin DFCO for a while now since Top Gear did a feature on it.
I have adjusted my driving style to encourage the DFCO, but my motives were not to see my MPG improve dramatically and save cash. My view is, if I have a leaky tap, (or fawcet to you guys over the pond :-)), that drips every 20 seconds, it wont add much to my water bill, but why waste the water?

Anyway, I have often wondered if the DFCO can be better used. I have an armchair thoery on utilising it, see what you think. Here is the theory:

Drive at 60mph, let the car engine break down to 50mph in DFCO, gently accellerate back to 60mph. Repeat the cycle.

Now, assuming that the decelleration and accelleration times were equal and on a flat road, would you see an overal improvement in economy, a reduction or no change?
KrazyDawgSF Bay Area · Aug 3, 2010#187
Originally Posted by Beer Jammer ↑
Hi All.

I've been insterestedin DFCO for a while now since Top Gear did a feature on it.
I have adjusted my driving style to encourage the DFCO, but my motives were not to see my MPG improve dramatically and save cash. My view is, if I have a leaky tap, (or fawcet to you guys over the pond :-)), that drips every 20 seconds, it wont add much to my water bill, but why waste the water?

Anyway, I have often wondered if the DFCO can be better used. I have an armchair thoery on utilising it, see what you think. Here is the theory:

Drive at 60mph, let the car engine break down to 50mph in DFCO, gently accellerate back to 60mph. Repeat the cycle.

Now, assuming that the decelleration and accelleration times were equal and on a flat road, would you see an overal improvement in economy, a reduction or no change?
The theory you described is called pulse and glide (P&G) by hypermilers on CleanMPG. If your target speed is 55 MPH driving from point A to point B using P&G is more fuel efficient than driving at a constant speed on a flat road.
YarisduderMontreal, Canada · Aug 3, 2010#188
Don't you just use the energy you saved "gliding" when "pulsing?" This pulse and glide thing sounds like it defies the laws of conservation of energy, same goes with the mountain driving. Please explain how this is possible.
imjustagirl8_05Phoenix, AZ · Aug 11, 2010#189
I don't have an RPM gauge.. at what speeds will it be wise to use DFCO? I have been using it, but I'm not sure if it's pointless after I've already slowed.. what speeds are typically above 1100 rpm?
YarisduderMontreal, Canada · Aug 11, 2010#190
In "D" the engine kicks in as high as 30mph, in "3" about 20-25 and in "2" I'm not sure, but it's pretty slow. You can usually feel the engine turn on because all of a sudden you need to apply a little more brake, the car seems to surge.

I love that there's no answer to the laws of conservation of energy, I guess I'll have to raise this little flag here... 🙄
nmgolferNew Mexico · Aug 11, 2010#191
Originally Posted by Yarisduder ↑
In "D" the engine kicks in as high as 30mph, in "3" about 20-25 and in "2" I'm not sure, but it's pretty slow. You can usually feel the engine turn on because all of a sudden you need to apply a little more brake, the car seems to surge.

I love that there's no answer to the laws of conservation of energy, I guess I'll have to raise this little flag here... 🙄
Assuming all else is equal (average speed etc) I agree with you re. COE however I'm open the possibility that while accelerating the engine is operating at a slightly better average BSFE than when running at the equivalent constant speed. Seems unlikely though and the net benefit needs to be quantified in controlled MPG testing rather than just anecdotal or scanguage feedback before I consider switching off the cruise.
rene0023Coamo, Puerto Rico · Aug 19, 2010#192
Man information is great!
KrazyDawgSF Bay Area · Aug 19, 2010#193
Originally Posted by Yarisduder ↑
Don't you just use the energy you saved "gliding" when "pulsing?" This pulse and glide thing sounds like it defies the laws of conservation of energy, same goes with the mountain driving. Please explain how this is possible.
When gliding you have an infinite MPG and even though your MPG will drop when slowly accelerating, the average MPG will increase overall compared to driving at a constant speed.

Resources:

http://www.metrompg.com/posts/pulse-and-glide.htm
http://www.greenhybrid.com/discuss/f...se-glide-3700/
brg88txSE Texas · Aug 26, 2010#194
i have a early 2007 automatic yaris sedan, manufactured in june 2006. can anyone explain what this means, i copied it from the first page of this thread:

"Early versions pf the AT (Including ones sold in the U.S. until around January 2007) can only achieve DFCO with a gear selection lower than (D)rive, i.e. 3 or L, but since half way through the 2007 model year the AT can achieve DFCO in all gears.."

does this mean when i drive around in D that i am never in dfco mode, or does it mean that the dfco only kicks in as the vehicle slows down coasting in a lower gear than D (even though my shifter is still in D)? thanks
BailOutThread starterReno, Nevada, USA · Aug 26, 2010#195
Hi brg88tx,

Perform the test outlined in the first post to see if yours kicks in DFCO in Drive or if you have to downshift:

How can I tell if a vehicle other than the Yaris has DFCO?

Be careful with this test as you may lose Power Steering and Power Brakes during it! Choose the right time and location to perform the test.

On any level or slightly downhill road get up to at least 40 MPH, then start engine braking by keeping the vehicle in gear and letting all the way off the throttle while keeping the clutch disengaged (MT) or keeping the transmission in a gear lower than D (AT). Notice the deceleration force and the sound of the engine.

Now tun off your ignition (This is where you may lose your PS/PB, so be wary!) and watch for any harsher deceleration or change in the pitch of the engine for a few seconds.

If nothing was any different with the ignition turned off then your vehicle uses DFCO. If it decelerated at a different rate or pitch with the ignition off then it does not use DFCO. Do not forget to start your engine back up!
Yaris HiltonBristol, Tennessee, USA · Aug 26, 2010#196
As I understand it, it means that DFCO never works when the shifter's in D. But testing it is the only way to be sure for yours. Individual cars often don't match the published specs exactly.
acutorquedelaware oh · Mar 26, 2011#197
why set cutoff at 21, versus any other figure
flgThe Internet · Nov 9, 2011#198
Personally, I'm noticing that it works below 1100rpm unless I'm over 75mph. it dosen't work at all over 75mph? What is this over 75mph sh$%t getting stuck on 125-135mpg down a hill???
🙁
jongscxgeorgia · Dec 13, 2011#199
I had always been curious about this. I bought a 2nd hand (AT) 2 DR hatchback, and didn't really know much about the Yaris.
By nature, I'd always coast as much as possible instead of the vroom-skrrrt everyone else did and noticed the engine sounded much different when I did.

I presumed it was engine braking or something. Good to know I'm saving gas.
charles nelsonSt Cloud Minnesota · Jan 16, 2012#200
When I bought my '08 3-door...I noticed a considerable engine braking when I took my foot off the accelerator! When going to work I have to descend down a long steep hill. My Jeep Liberty always required considerable braking to keep it down to the speed limit. With the Yaris, being much lighter and DFCO, the vehicle will coast down at about the speed limit without any braking required.
I could literally feel the engine compression helping to keep the speed down.
Felt like a miniature Jack-Brake was on.
I once had a Mazda compact pickup...coming down through the mountains one time...I thought that I would have to replace the brakes by the time I had gotten down (even in low gear). The Yaris just stays at about 30-40 mph.