Replies continued
esquivaSouth Cali · Apr 8, 2007#51hmmmm...i've been doing this ever since...of course to save gas..i know im not using gas coz im not hitting the gas pedal..
....very good information
LillydotBoston, MA · Apr 8, 2007#52something else i'm curious about when using this method: when is the best time to switch back to overdrive? do i switch back before i press my brakes? after i've some to a complete stop? before i press the accelerator again? does it even matter?
BailOutThread starterReno, Nevada, USA · Apr 8, 2007#53Lillydot,
Don't go back into OD until you reach a complete stop or are ready to accelerate again. That way you're sure to get the maximum benefit of a DFCO.
naossoanMB, Canada · Apr 12, 2007#54ok, I don't really understand how this would work.
How does it completely cut off fuel flow? Won't the engine stall? Or is that the point?
If you're coasting in 4th gear foot off the gas it shuts off the engine...but then when you touch the gas it starts the engine back up again?
How can the engine keep turning over when there is no fuel to ignite and push the cylindars back down?
I'm confused.
BailOutThread starterReno, Nevada, USA · Apr 12, 2007#55The engine keeps turning because the wheels are turning, which turn the axles, which turn the transmission, which turns the crankshaft, which makes the pistons move.
As stated in the original post the engine becomes a compressor rather than a combustor at this point. Think of it as the drive train operating in reverse... instead of the engine making the wheels turn the wheels are making the engine turn. Since your momentum and the wheels are doing all the work there's no need for the energy that fuel would provide, so the computer turns off the fuel injectors.
Yaris RevengeMy own little world. · Apr 13, 2007#56It's strange to think your engine basically shuts down every time you take your foot off the excelerator.... freaky!
~YR
ChinoCharlesOH · Apr 13, 2007#57BailOut, can you feel this happen? For the last few weeks I have been playing with this and I think I can actually feel DFCO. In second gear especially, you'll feel the car kind of "smooth out" under decelleration. It almost feels like popping the clutch, only you're still in gear.
BailOutThread starterReno, Nevada, USA · Apr 13, 2007#58ChinoCharles,
You took the words right out of my mouth. 🙂 2nd gear is where I, too, can actually feel this at, both entering and leaving DFCO. It's very subtle (which is a testament to Toyota's engineering) but it's there.
If I let my RPMs drop below 1,100 in 5th gear (which never happens unless I do it on purpose) I can feel it when the fuel kicks back in because it's like a surge from an old, tired spring.
eTiMaGoBangkok, Thailand · Apr 13, 2007#59Agreed, and it coincides with my AFR needle too, you can feel the tiniest of jerks a fraction of a second after you let your foot off the gas.
ChinoCharlesOH · Apr 13, 2007#60Cool! I'm going to try and really pay attention my next fill up and see if I can't get my already improving mileage numbers even better.
nsmitchellRichmond, VA · Apr 13, 2007#61I had a weird experience on my latest trips throught the hills of Virginia. I had my Rostra Cruise control going at 65MPH. Going down hills I felt the engine braking my speed so I maintained 65MPH even on a steep decline that you would normally speed up a lot on. (Coming down Afton Mountain in the Blue Ridge Mountains) I think this must have been DFCO, but I know my transmission stayed in 4th gear because I would have heard/felt my RPMs going up. Any thoughts? Could this be DFCO in action?
I tried finding infor on Rostra with no luck.
churpTropical Minnesota · Apr 13, 2007#62I've noticed around town strange (compared to other automatic cars anyway) almost like what I've been thinking downshifting while slowing down. Just never noticed a perceptable change in other cars while slowing down....does the computer possibly do this (downshift/DFCO on its own) without manually downshifting....or is it just my imagination?
BailOutThread starterReno, Nevada, USA · Apr 13, 2007#63nsmitchell and churp,
I can't answer your questions as I don't have an AT model to play with but it sounds to me like what you two have found is definitely possible.
AustinYarisAustin, TX · Apr 14, 2007#64BailOut,
I still can't figure this DFCO thing out.
Here's a real life example:
There is a steady downhill grade on the street of my house that stretches for about a mile. Once I get over a small hill, I can coast in neutral for the entire mile at 40mph dropping to about 20mph before I need to turn.
- ScanGuage reads 200-230mpg during the run.
If I am in any gear, even 5th gear, I can not make this run without hitting the gas. There is too much engine resistance. At about half way, the car slows down to 20mph, so I have to hit the gas.
- ScanGuage reads around 140mpg for the run until I hit the gas.
In this scenario, isn't just coasting in neutral better for FE?
BailOutThread starterReno, Nevada, USA · Apr 14, 2007#65AustinYaris,
Yes, in that case you're better off on neutral as you'll use less fuel idling the whole way down that grade than you would using DFCO for the first half and then using fuel for accelerating/maintaining the rest of it.
I cannot recommend the following to anyone not into hypermiling (this is my disclaimer so lay off the flames, please) but rather than just being in neutral for that span I'd be in neutral with the engine turned off and my ignition turned to the 2 position (Ignition II). This is called a Fas (Forced autostop) and the Yaris holds this posture very well as you still have PS (say thank you, drive-by-wire) and you also have PB for about 4 uses before you need to worry about anything.
The only drawback to Fas'ing is that the SG II turns off after 12 seconds. It doesn't really matter if you're already using DFCO, though, as the SG II doesn't read that properly and has already screwed up MPG and tank tracking.
AustinYarisAustin, TX · Apr 14, 2007#66Thanks for the clarification.
I actually just tried FAS for the first time 2 days ago, and was even able to reengage ICE by shifting into gear and releasing the clutch. A lot easier than I imagined.
I didn't mention FAS since it would obviously be more fuel efficient than DFCO. Secondary reason, was to avoid the flames. You're a brave man to mention it... lol.
Appreciate the note about SGII as well. That's what I figured, but wasn't absolutely sure.
YarisMarkham · May 16, 2007#67With an automatic transmission, I find it more efficient to be in neutral when rolling down an incline, and then shifting to DFCO mode when I'm approaching an anticipated stop. I get the best mileage driving this way instead of always alternating between OD and DFCO. It doesn't make sense to accelerate with OD off when you can acceralate with OD on and then shift to neutral while cruising a fair distance before having to hit the gas pedal again.
I try not to accelerate at the exact moment I shift into drive because of the potential thumping of the transmission.
Does anyone know if shifting in and out of neutral while in motion is harmful to an automatic transmission?
driftoNY/NJ · May 16, 2007#68its a very simple system. during braking above 1100 rpm the injectors cut off. i feel this every time i come to a stop sign etc. your not going to feel the car hold back as if you are breaking, but you will see the rpm drop down slightly lower than if you had the clutch in. if you find that your idle is too low or unchanged the car may not be PDI'd correctly. on honda/acura the cars have to be roadtested a certain way prior to delivery for the idle to be correctly adjusted during fuel cut off. it doesnt work if your in stop and go traffic. its been around for a long time actually. it was designed to meet emissions standards back in the mid to late 90's. hope this helps..
YariiCanada · May 16, 2007#69I don't think it should hurt anything as long as you're not on the gas when you do it, and assuming you shift into the right setting (don't tell it to go from N into low at 60mph) but it'd be nice to get some more opinions...
Originally Posted by
Yaris ↑ With an automatic transmission, I find it more efficient to be in neutral when rolling down an incline, and then shifting to DFCO mode when I'm approaching an anticipated stop. I get the best mileage driving this way instead of always alternating between OD and DFCO. It doesn't make sense to accelerate with OD off when you can acceralate with OD on and then shift to neutral while cruising a fair distance before having to hit the gas pedal again.
I try not to accelerate at the exact moment I shift into drive because of the potential thumping of the transmission.
Does anyone know if shifting in and out of neutral while in motion is harmful to an automatic transmission?
churpTropical Minnesota · May 16, 2007#70I've been shifting my auto into neutral and coasting and don't see a problem...anything under 55 slides back into gear nicely without giving it gas.
Older cars I know had a problem when moving without the engine rotating, due to no oil pumping without the converter going. Without oil circulating in the tranny while moving---lots of problems. Think they have cured this since front wheel drive, but don't know for certain. If the owners manual says no towing of an automatic without a dolly or trailer, this is the reason. Just to be sure I won't FAS with my automatic.
edit: Shutting the engine down with standard tranny no problem if you're comfortable/brave.... I'll coast with engine running w/automatic though!
YariiCanada · May 17, 2007#71I think you're thinking of the automatics before (I think) like 1960... They used to have dual oil pumps, one off the engine side, and one off the driveshaft end... As transmissions became more reliable, the second pump wasn't needed, and it would in fact cause over pressure if you turned the engine off and costed downhill letting the rear pump build up pressure.... Lots of times it would blow tranny seals and spray the fluid onto the exhaust=big fire... On the plus side, you could push start those old automatics if you could get them moving fast enough since there was a pump that turned with the wheels (I've done it once on a buddy's vintage oldsmobile, pushing it with a pickup truck up to about 68kph before the torque converter had enough pressure on it to make the engine turn over) heh....
I've shifted in and out of neutral lots of times in my auto camry... Into neutral just isn't a problem ever - if you're coasting off the gas in OD, it basically puts itself into neutral anyway, but I've never tried putting it back into gear over 50kph just because I'm not sure how good that is for the system... When you think about it, I'd guess the stress of a shift from neutral into gear w/o touching the throttle isn't nearly as stressfull on the tranny as passing on the highway and having it kick down out of 4th into second with the throttle on the floor...
That said, in my old 88 crown victoria, I've done it lots of times, at highway speeds (100-120kph), and it never seemed to care. The electronics would think the throttle was wide open and to reset it (in order to slow down) you'd have to kill the motor and restart in neutral on the highway, and you didn't dare try pulling over to stop, or coasting to a slow speed... You try handling a 20yr old, 4000lbs car without power steering and a reserve canister so small you only get 1 shot of power assisted brakes... *looks for the smiley face of a car flying off the road into a tree*
Originally Posted by
churp ↑ Older cars I know had a problem when moving without the engine rotating, due to no oil pumping without the converter going.
churpTropical Minnesota · May 17, 2007#72[QUOTE=Yarii;86587]I think you're thinking of the automatics before (I think) like 1960... They used to have dual oil pumps, one off the engine side, and one off the driveshaft end...
I was thinking more of the ones that didn't have the rear pump.....they couldn't be started by pushing because no oil was circulating, and if you towed them even short distances you could burn the tranny out. Probably not a problem anymore, I just like to play it safe...cause if it is a problem, once you notice it, it's too late.
tim584Algeria · Aug 14, 2007#73Hi all
i want to know if the 2NZ FE engine is equiped with DFCO? (1.3 VVTi engine, like european yaris) 🤷
Thanks
BailOutThread starterReno, Nevada, USA · Aug 14, 2007#74tim584,
Please run the test outlined in the first post in this thread in order to determine if your vehicle has it or not. It should, but there's only one way to verify. 🙂
tim584Algeria · Aug 14, 2007#75Yes iknow that, but can i damage my engine when i do the test?
Pavel OlavichOrange County, Calif · Aug 14, 2007#76For auto transmissions, here is what you can do to get into DFCO mode:
When going down an incline, tap your brake lightly. This will cause the "grade logic" in the auto tranny to down shift a gear automatically, something that Honda pioneered years ago. Then you will find that the car experiences some resistence as you glide down the hill. The rpm's will increase, and if you have a scan gauge, the GPH value will often be 0.3 or 0.2. I suspect the car is in DFCO, as the MPG is 200+. I think the ScanGauge will never post less then 0.2 GPH, so even though your car is in DFCO, the GPH shows 0.2. I could be wrong on this, and also, the auto will not necessarily run the "Grade Logic" routine unless the conditions are ripe, in regard to incline, speed, acceleration, that sort of thing. I think that working with "grade logic" is better and safer then placing the auto in nuetral. I suspect long term tranny damage to do the nuetral thing. It is my guess that if the auto Yaris in fact has DFCO, then after it enters DFCO mode, it will pop back out at the point that the movement of the car no longer is able to pressure-turn the engine (via the transmission).
If DFCO works as I think it does, then it is far better then placing the auto in neutral, because keeping the car in D with grade logic auto downshifts will (1) maintain your speed, using the compression of the motor (2) allow you to drive your auto as intended, and probably eliminate damage from neutral coasting (3) DFCO mode turns off the injectors...while coasting in neutral does not, as the idle feed of gas is still maintained.
Oh before I forget, BailOut: Nice write up, but you have the "disengage" and "engage" terms mixed up....a manual transmission is engaged when the clutch pedel is out, and DIS-engaged when the clutch pedel is pushed in...but your point is not lost to us. ;-)
adamschneiderPortland, OR · Aug 14, 2007#77I drove over the mountains twice last week and experimented with engine braking quite a bit on the downhills. (I have an automatic transmission.) I was experiencing the same thing that AustinYaris mentioned a few months back: with the exception of a few really steep hills, downshifting to 3rd slowed me down way too much, so I was having to put it in neutral to pick up speed again. As I understand it, DFCO doesn't kick in at all when you're in 4th ("D") in an AT, correct?
So, basically, when going down hills, I was in 3rd gear on the steep parts (which had the dual effects of activating DFCO and slowing down the car so as not to get out of control!), then I would bypass 4th and go into neutral for the shallower inclines. I didn't use D unless I needed to give it some gas. Does this sound like the best way to do it?
EDIT: I just saw Pavel Olavich's most recent post. Pavel, are you saying that the Yaris AT does go into DFCO mode even in 4th gear?
joe keeneyhemphill texas · Aug 14, 2007#78Its called hyper driveing.
Pavel OlavichOrange County, Calif · Aug 15, 2007#79 Originally Posted by
adamschneider ↑ I drove over the mountains twice last week and experimented with engine braking quite a bit on the downhills. (I have an automatic transmission.) I was experiencing the same thing that AustinYaris mentioned a few months back: with the exception of a few really steep hills, downshifting to 3rd slowed me down way too much, so I was having to put it in neutral to pick up speed again. As I understand it, DFCO doesn't kick in at all when you're in 4th ("D") in an AT, correct?
So, basically, when going down hills, I was in 3rd gear on the steep parts (which had the dual effects of activating DFCO and slowing down the car so as not to get out of control!), then I would bypass 4th and go into neutral for the shallower inclines. I didn't use D unless I needed to give it some gas. Does this sound like the best way to do it?
EDIT: I just saw Pavel Olavich's most recent post. Pavel, are you saying that the Yaris AT does go into DFCO mode even in 4th gear?
I believe that keeping the shifter in D can activate DFCO if you allow the tranny to automatically downshift, caused by the "grade logic" of the tranny....in this way, your shifter is in D, yet the tranny is in 3rd, and DFCO can happen, given the right circumstances of course. When I find myself driving down steep hills, I tap the brake a tad, and this often causes the tranny to automatically downshift, and I think when it does this DFCO is happening....but my car does not necessarily lose speed...it often just holds the speed constant, and this is often what one wants in these circumstances.
Pavel OlavichOrange County, Calif · Aug 15, 2007#80Honda uses the term "Grade Logic"....what does Toyota call their's? Anyone know?
adamschneiderPortland, OR · Aug 17, 2007#81 Originally Posted by
Pavel Olavich ↑ I believe that keeping the shifter in D can activate DFCO if you allow the tranny to automatically downshift, caused by the "grade logic" of the tranny....in this way, your shifter is in D, yet the tranny is in 3rd, and DFCO can happen, given the right circumstances of course. When I find myself driving down steep hills, I tap the brake a tad, and this often causes the tranny to automatically downshift, and I think when it does this DFCO is happening...
I just experienced this yesterday without even trying to: I was headed down off Mt. Hood, tapped the brake, and it definitely downshifted. The question now is whether this causes the fuel to be cut off.
By the way, how did people even learn about DFCO? A google search only turns up results on this forum, the cleanmpg.com forums, and a few others!
Pavel OlavichOrange County, Calif · Aug 17, 2007#82BailOutThread starterReno, Nevada, USA · Aug 17, 2007#83 Originally Posted by
adamschneider ↑ By the way, how did people even learn about DFCO? A google search only turns up results on this forum, the cleanmpg.com forums, and a few others!
I can't claim credit for "discovering" DFCO as there are a lot of ECU/ECM programmers around the world that know about it even better than I do, but I never heard of it until I saw a post somewhere about someone rigging up a switch for their fuel injectors. I ran a search on something like "cutting fuel injector flow" and found the document that Pavel linked earlier:
http://www.autoshop101.com/forms/h43.pdf There's a section in that white paper titled "Deceleration Fuel Cut", and I latched onto it. I thought up a way to test for the presence of DFCO (covered in the first post of this thread) and confirmed it on the 2007 Yaris with the 1NZ-FE engine (I had quite the pucker factor on that first test... hehe).
Once I did that I posted it on CleanMPG and two of the folks there hooked up an indicator light on their fuel injectors (a 2002 Elantra and a 2004 Honda Civic) and verified that the injectors lost all power in a DFCO state. A 3rd person with an older vehicle (I can't remember what model, but it was a 1994) tried the same thing and found his injectors stayed on full-time.
I then spent some time figuring out how to trigger it and how to make it stop, and once all that was done I wrote it up here.
So, while I can't at all claim that I "discovered" DFCO I may be the first "Joe Six Pack" that tested it, confirmed it, found a way to turn it into a purposeful FE booster and then went public with it.
stevedNear Montreal, Quebec, Canada · Aug 17, 2007#84Maybe someone in this forum could hook up an indicator light on there Yaris to see if the injectors really do cut off. (especially an automatic)
This way there would be 100% proof that DFCO really works on our cars.
I would do it, but someone living in an mountain area would be better at testing this. ( and I'm useless in electronics and wiring)
ECHOKnight2000Minnesota, US of A! · Aug 17, 2007#85 Originally Posted by
Pavel Olavich ↑ Honda uses the term "Grade Logic"....what does Toyota call their's? Anyone know?
I think Toyota referrs to it as uphill/down hill shift logic. For automatics at least. The engine won't gear hunt as much going down hill or up hill (granted if you're gradually going up a hill. I don't know if that has to do with what we're talking about but I bet it has some relation as far as DFCO.
I don't have a Yaris but the ECHO (auto) has a similar set up obviously not the up to date version like the Yaris. I have one question though. I have a scanguage II and I have one of the read outs on closed or open loop. The fuel loop or whatever...anyway I read that when the loop is open it actually means the ECU cuts off fuel to the engine to save gas...so like when I cruise from about 55 and up and just let the car go even in drive the loop opens for a bit until I get to a certain speed. It really opens up either when I floor it or downshift to a lower gear like coming off the highway. I was wonder if this is DFCO cause it cuts off fuel or at least I think it does. Can anyone help me on this who knows about cars? Thanks!
Pavel OlavichOrange County, Calif · Aug 17, 2007#86 Originally Posted by
ECHOKnight2000 ↑ I think Toyota referrs to it as uphill/down hill shift logic. For automatics at least. The engine won't gear hunt as much going down hill or up hill (granted if you're gradually going up a hill. I don't know if that has to do with what we're talking about but I bet it has some relation as far as DFCO.
I don't have a Yaris but the ECHO (auto) has a similar set up obviously not the up to date version like the Yaris. I have one question though. I have a scanguage II and I have one of the read outs on closed or open loop. The fuel loop or whatever...anyway I read that when the loop is open it actually means the ECU cuts off fuel to the engine to save gas...so like when I cruise from about 55 and up and just let the car go even in drive the loop opens for a bit until I get to a certain speed. It really opens up either when I floor it or downshift to a lower gear like coming off the highway. I was wonder if this is DFCO cause it cuts off fuel or at least I think it does. Can anyone help me on this who knows about cars? Thanks!
I think DFCO and Grade-Logic are two completely different processes, and are not related, although this is not to say that they don't cooperate together.
As for open/closed loop, when open, the ECU uses "maps" for determining ignition, and other stuff. When the loop is closed, the ECU uses realtime calculations to control everything.....I could be wrong, so maybe someone has a much better explanation, as my sources are a bit flakey on this. I write this because I don't want to spread info if I'm not 100% sure about.
songaMA, USA · Dec 3, 2008#87i know this is an old thread but still very important and relevant...and im also sorry for not having read the entire thread yet as i am in a bit of a hurry so im sure im missing some details but i have one quick question..
DFCO is great, but say you are coasting downhill and you want to pick up as much speed/momentum as possible so you can continue coasting once the road levels off a bit. if you stay in DFCO, you will feel that it is holding your car back a bit, aka "engine braking." this scenario is only good because the DFCO is cutting off fuel. However, because of the DFCO you are not taking full advantage of gravity from the downhill slope and are therefore losing out on some added speed/momentum that you would get if you were to coast in neutral instead. this is a trade off...an opportunity cost issue. does this make sense?
so to my logic, if you really need that extra speed and momentum that you would get from gravity going downhill, neutral coasting is more beneficial. you use minimal fuel for a much faster speed and larger momentum that you will benefit from once the road levels off. this way, you can take advantage of much longer distances for a lil bit of fuel.
if you dont need the extra speed and momentum, DFCO would be more fuel efficient because you are not using any fuel at all. however after the downhill, you may not be able to coast much longer as you have limited your speed to an extent. this means you can coast for a shorter distance than the neutral coasting method, but you will be doing it at no fuel cost at all.
does this make sense?
Sodium DuckWestern Mass. · Dec 3, 2008#88DFCO is just ONE driving tool. Like all fuel saving tools and techniques, is to be used in certain situations -- not all. Your point has bassically already been discussed before.
To be a hypermiler, you use a combination of all different driving techniques and styles to attain a maximum MPG. Sometimes you use DFCO on one hill, and shift into neutral on another. Or whatever else it is that you do.
Bullet120Kansas City · Dec 4, 2008#89DFCO down hill, gain some speed, use no fuel at all.
Neutral down hill, with car on, gain a little more speed and burn fuel otherwise not burned.
Hmm, no fuel, or some fuel. Which sounds more efficient?
Not to mention neutral coasting and autos don't like each other. However, ICE off neutral coasting in a MT is very efficient.
Sodium DuckWestern Mass. · Dec 4, 2008#90*thinking - thinking - thinking* Oh snap, you're wrong!
On initial thought, you're scenarios make sense. But -- you have to look at the big picture. As I said before, it depends on the situation which driving technique/tool you should use. There is no one perfect, end all - be all, thing to do to save gas. It is a mix of things that you do and when you do them. Now, you tell me which one of my scenarios is more efficient.
Going down a small hill, that levels out at the bottom for 400 yards, until you get to a stop sign.
You COULD use DFCO, use no gas at all on the small hill portion, then be forced to use gas at the bottom because you would have no momentum left.
OR
You COULD shift into neutral and simply coast to the stop sign - not touching the gas once.
OR
You COULD build up some speed on the other side of the hill, and turn your car completely off at the crest (granted you have a manual).
OR
You COULD do whatever to get down the hill, then use hang time to get to the stop sign.
OR
You COULD go crazy, remove your spare tire, rear seat, stereo, interior plastic, go on a diet and lose soem weight, etc. Drop a couple hundred pounds of weight from the vehicle and just drive over the hill normally.
I don't feel like digging out the numbers, because, as I said before, this has been discussed many, many times here before. DFCO is the most fuel efficient thing to do when you use it in conjunction with ALL driving techniques/tools. There are many things you can do to get better MPG, but DFCO is not always the best. You have to consider the bigger picture!
Sodium DuckWestern Mass. · Dec 4, 2008#91 Originally Posted by voodoo22 ↑
Like Sodium Duck says, it's a combination of techniques based on your situation. In situations where you don't want to slow down, but the decline is not steep enough to allow you to use DFCO without losing speed. That's when you want to use N.
You are also wrong about coasting in N in an auto. Most newer autos have no problems and incur no damage from doing this. You don't need to rev match or anything.
It really doesn't matter how efficient a maneuver is with a MT when you're driving an AT. Most AT's cannot ICE off coast without incurring damage, but some can. For the masses who can't N-ICE on coasting is their best choice when DFCO isn't suitable.
*clapping* Thank you!
And umm, what's ICE stand for? All I can think of is "in car entertainment."
BailOutThread starterReno, Nevada, USA · Dec 4, 2008#92ICE = Internal Combustion Engine 🙂
songaMA, USA · Dec 4, 2008#93 Originally Posted by
Sodium Duck ↑ *thinking - thinking - thinking* Oh snap, you're wrong!
On initial thought, you're scenarios make sense. But -- you have to look at the big picture. As I said before, it depends on the situation which driving technique/tool you should use. There is no one perfect, end all - be all, thing to do to save gas. It is a mix of things that you do and when you do them. Now, you tell me which one of my scenarios is more efficient.
Going down a small hill, that levels out at the bottom for 400 yards, until you get to a stop sign.
You COULD use DFCO, use no gas at all on the small hill portion, then be forced to use gas at the bottom because you would have no momentum left.
OR
You COULD shift into neutral and simply coast to the stop sign - not touching the gas once.
OR
You COULD build up some speed on the other side of the hill, and turn your car completely off at the crest (granted you have a manual).
OR
You COULD do whatever to get down the hill, then use hang time to get to the stop sign.
OR
You COULD go crazy, remove your spare tire, rear seat, stereo, interior plastic, go on a diet and lose soem weight, etc. Drop a couple hundred pounds of weight from the vehicle and just drive over the hill normally.
I don't feel like digging out the numbers, because, as I said before, this has been discussed many, many times here before. DFCO is the most fuel efficient thing to do when you use it in conjunction with ALL driving techniques/tools. There are many things you can do to get better MPG, but DFCO is not always the best. You have to consider the bigger picture!
thanks duck, thats the clarification i needed. i was just under the impression that DFCO WAS in fact the way to go whenever possible....however i was in a similar scenario as the 2nd one you mentioned and started thinking that N coasting might actually be more beneficial as i didnt feel comfortable with the engine braking limiting my momentum on a hill. and YES, like bullet120 said, DFCO uses no gas at all so is technically more efficient, but in certain situations, you may encounter a trade off where you can benefit form the extra speed you can obtain from N coasting, even for a lil gas consumption. arite thanks guys!
silver_echoSpokane, WA · Mar 8, 2009#94found out last night that my 01 echo does have DFCO! sweetness!
SlickHouston, Texas · Apr 23, 2009#95Alright, I read all six pages and noone stated the answer to my soon to be question. It has been stated that the A/T will not enter DFCO in D. Then it was stated that it might inter DFCO in D, or at least enter "grade logic". It was discussed that shifting between N and D or 3 and D may or may not be harmful to an A/T.
Soooo, in order to get best results on a non-grade road, should I downshift 3,2,1 (in order to keep the RPMs up) in order to stay in DFCO while coming to a stop? If so, this isn't bad for the transmission? Or is it that as long as i'm not winding the tranny up to 4 or 5k on a downshift it will be fine?
Would ya'll recomend just shifting from D to 3 and just riding that for as long as possible?
Thanks in advance for any help or advice.
MadMaxSan Antonio, Texas! · Apr 23, 2009#96Slick
I've been led to believe that the AT will cause the DFCO to kick it but not as quickly as a manual would. However, I downshift to '3' and even down to '2' to maximize the DFCO savings. It seems to help...and it should not cause any problems with the transmission as long as you aren't downshifting to '2' at 70 MPH...
Cheers! M2
Maxh91New-Brunswick , Canada · Apr 23, 2009#97 Originally Posted by
MadMax ↑ Slick
I've been led to believe that the AT will cause the DFCO to kick it but not as quickly as a manual would. However, I downshift to '3' and even down to '2' to maximize the DFCO savings. It seems to help...and it should not cause any problems with the transmission as long as you aren't downshifting to '2' at 70 MPH...
Cheers! M2
I'm not an Transmission pro (AT) but how much high the RPM can be in 3th when downshift to 2? I only downshift at 1300 to be sure. I don't want to destroy my AT if i downshift to early! I don't really know how much the AT can rev safely when engine braking. 👎
MadMaxSan Antonio, Texas! · Apr 23, 2009#98I wouldn't pop down to '2' above 40 MPH, that's about my upper limit...your car will let you know if you downshift too early!
Cheers! M2
SlickHouston, Texas · Apr 23, 2009#99It has been my experience that the best way to tell when to downshift an automatic (don't flame me hypermilers) is to accelerate slowly starting in 1 and listening to the engine. When its starts to whine medium-loud then you know you should move it into 2. Repeat all the way to drive. After this, you should be able to guesstimate when its safe to downshift. eg. Shift from D to 3 anywhere under 50. 3 to 2 anywhere under 25. 2 to 1 under 15. This example is probably not at accurate shifting speeds, its only an example.
DarbPittsburgh, PA · May 8, 2009#100 Originally Posted by
BailOut ↑ Now tun off your ignition (This is where you may lose your PS/PB, so be wary!) and watch for any harsher deceleration or change in the pitch of the engine for a few seconds.
Whoa whoa, question. Doesn't the AT require you to be in park (P) in order to restart the engine? Or are you just shifting down to 3 and L? *confused*