Alex.LapriseOriginal postCanada, Quebec · Jul 16, 2012#1I was wondering if it makes a huge difference.
Never drove a stick before and I'm not sure on if I should get a stick or not.
Concerned about the traffic and all that crap.
Also, is the yaris ''sportier'' to drive with a stick or theres not much of a difference
Replies 49
WeeYariGeorgetown, Ontario, Canada · Jul 16, 2012#2razingmanthe hammer · Jul 16, 2012#3 Originally Posted by
Alex.Laprise ↑ I was wondering if it makes a huge difference.
Never drove a stick before and I'm not sure on if I should get a stick or not.
Concerned about the traffic and all that crap.
Also, is the yaris ''sportier'' to drive with a stick or theres not much of a difference
Everything is sportier with a stick...
Get a standard. Don't be lazy with an auto
jpmck03USA · Jul 16, 2012#4My sister just bought a '12 with an auto and I have a '10 with a manual.
After driving her car for a little bit, I can say that I'm glad that I bought mine with a 5 speed!
MadMaxSan Antonio, Texas! · Jul 16, 2012#5And for everyone that prefers the manual, you'll find someone else that prefers the automatic.
It's down to personal choice, so let's not have this drawn-out debate again when the truth of the matter is that it's all opinionated.
Test drive both and see which you prefer. I have autos in all of my vehicles (sans the motorcycles) as I prefer them. I test drove both versions of the Yaris and went with the auto. Did the same with my Jeep Wrangler.
Good luck with whatever you choose!
Cheers! M2
tooterLos Angeles · Jul 16, 2012#6 Originally Posted by
Alex.Laprise ↑ I was wondering if it makes a huge difference.
Never drove a stick before and I'm not sure on if I should get a stick or not.
Concerned about the traffic and all that crap.
Also, is the yaris ''sportier'' to drive with a stick or theres not much of a difference
If you've never driven a manual transmission vehicle. Do not buy one before driving one first, so that you can make certain that's what you want.
Personally, I can't stand automatics and will
never own a vehicle with one... but that's only one individual preference. Lots of people love autos and can't stand sticks.
edmscanCanada · Jul 16, 2012#7I totally wish my stick was an AT ... sorry Yaris stick lovers but the stick in the Yaris is a pain in the ass. (Maybe it is just my car .. but I find starting from a standstill to be difficult at best. Other than that .. it is fine) Maybe someone has a suggestion ?
For those that will disagree with me ... I have been driving a stick for 29 years so I know what I am doing. I have never had an automatic vehicle .. but I do wish my Yaris was the first.
jpmck03USA · Jul 16, 2012#8 Originally Posted by
MadMax ↑ And for everyone that prefers the manual, you'll find someone else that prefers the automatic.
It's down to personal choice, so let's not have this drawn-out debate again when the truth of the matter is that it's all opinionated.
Test drive both and see which you prefer. I have autos in all of my vehicles (sans the motorcycles) as I prefer them. I test drove both versions of the Yaris and went with the auto. Did the same with my Jeep Wrangler.
Good luck with whatever you choose!
Cheers! M2
+1
It really does come down to your own personal preferences. Try out both and see what you like better is the best advice you can get.
LuxMarkham, Ontario, Canada · Jul 16, 2012#9Deliberately drive a manual gearbox Yaris in an inner city traffic jam to find out if it is for you.
All opinions are meaningless until you drive your car in the most demanding circumstances you could encounter. Accelerate and decelerate, in forward and in reverse, with full steering lock while manoeuvring obstacles. Test yourself to know if it suits your lifestyle, every day.
Regarding whether the Yaris is "sporty". Not really. The Mazda 2/Ford Fiesta and Honda Fit are more exciting to drive. The Yaris is the most practically designed and easiest to maintain. It's nicer looking too, if that's a deal-breaker to you.
GolddeenohColumbia, SC · Jul 16, 2012#10I haven't had any problems with the starting out from a stop, but I learned to drive a stick in "the city" in a long bed truck going through "the city" everyday.
but any way, as generally good idea it is up to
1. your driving style( you drive "sporty" get a manual)
2. where you drive the most ( heavy city driving in bumper to bumper traffic, get an Auto)
3. if you think it is worth the extra money to have an Auto (don't remember the Yaris numbers but usually 500 to 3000 more for an Auto)
4. What are you more comfortable with/ used to?
tk-421Dagobah · Jul 16, 2012#11Also try to take an AT yaris to the steepest hill that you can find in your area... This is where I believe the manual has a distinct advantage.
I wish more people got the MT in order to ensure that it won't be pulled off the market (I've been reading some unsettling reports about car-makers considering this for some reason).
tooterLos Angeles · Jul 16, 2012#12 Originally Posted by
tk-421 ↑ Also try to take an AT yaris to the steepest hill that you can find in your area... This is where I believe the manual has a distinct advantage.
I wish more people got the MT in order to ensure that it won't be pulled off the market (I've been reading some unsettling reports about car-makers considering this for some reason).
At the dealership I was told that stick shifts are only 1.5% of the total Yaris sales this year... but I've also read that there is a slight overall trend in all makes of going back to manual transmission vehicles for economic reasons.
razingmanthe hammer · Jul 17, 2012#13Yea if you live in a big busy city auto is nice but it is 1k more you are paying, even for used. Glad canada has a decent amount of manual drivers
cali yarisCanoga Park, CA · Jul 17, 2012#14Rent or borrow a car for one day with a manual, learn how (preferably with a friend who can coach you) to drive it, and then decide if it's worth the trouble.
It IS an extra effort to drive a manual, but some people like the addition control over the vehicle, and they also like the more direct connection to the car and to the road while driving.
xnamerxxso cal · Jul 17, 2012#15I'm in the drive a stick club but if you don't like driving a stick you'll likely never like driving a stick. The only auto yaris I've ever driven was a hateful experience to say the least but that's only because I can't stand low powered cars with autos.
When I bought my car in 08 there was only 8 in the whole of southern California that were stick and all of them were base models.
XFACORFL · Jul 17, 2012#16I thinks it's going to boil down to personal choice. You gotta drive it, so you may as well love it. what ever it is you choose.
Here is the one thing, if you like mods and ever intend on doing a power adder. Like a turbo or S/C you will have better luck with a MT than you will a AT. There is just more stuff available.
Good luck either way.
MadMaxSan Antonio, Texas! · Jul 17, 2012#17But there is also the other argument that an auto allows you to concentrate more on traffic.
There's debates for both types of transmissions, but in the end you gotta try both and decide which works best for you. I am able to maintain a good pace in traffic with my auto and while steep hills are a challenge, it's to be expected in such a small-engined car. I honestly don't see how a manual transmission would be an advantage on a steep hill, if anything much like stop-and-go traffic, the auto would be preferable.
By the way, in competition offroading, more people are going with automatic transmissions due to advances. Same is true in high performance cars, the new autos shift faster than a manual. Those same developments mean the differences in gas mileage is nominal if any. I think the Yaris is rated the same or just 1 MPG off between the two transmissions.
Inasmuch as some folks hate to see it, it probably won't be long before the manual transmission will go the way of the rotary phone, VCRs, etc. Technology has surpassed any advantage they once had...
Cheers! M2
xnamerxxso cal · Jul 17, 2012#18 Originally Posted by
MadMax ↑ But there is also the other argument that an auto allows you to concentrate more on traffic.
There's debates for both types of transmissions, but in the end you gotta try both and decide which works best for you. I am able to maintain a good pace in traffic with my auto and while steep hills are a challenge, it's to be expected in such a small-engined car. I honestly don't see how a manual transmission would be an advantage on a steep hill, if anything much like stop-and-go traffic, the auto would be preferable.
By the way, in competition offroading, more people are going with automatic transmissions due to advances. Same is true in high performance cars, the new autos shift faster than a manual. Those same developments mean the differences in gas mileage is nominal if any. I think the Yaris is rated the same or just 1 MPG off between the two transmissions.
Inasmuch as some folks hate to see it, it probably won't be long before the manual transmission will go the way of the rotary phone, VCRs, etc. Technology has surpassed any advantage they once had...
Cheers! M2
Those actually aren't automatics, while they can be programmed to shift automatically there design and construction are nothing like a automatic transmission. Plus there are tons of downsides to using sequential/DSG/SCG ect transmissions like they are quite expensive to design and even more expensive to engineer to work correctly plus there is increased maintenance and they also have a limited group of people who know how to work on them due to their complexity.
It took VW over 2 years of recalls to get their DSG working correctly Ford is having issues with the DSG thats being issued in the fiesta, the Single Clutch design in the Lambo has trouble at low speeds Ferrari couldn't get the design working in their road cars for over 6 years the sequential design that Aston used was known for being made of glass. Most racers will use a dog box or a sequential since they get rebuilt every so often anyway and high end racers(factory teams) can use whatever they want since their budgets are much higher.
The main reasons sticks are going to go away is that most people don't know how to drive sticks or don't like driving sticks and they don't sell. No point in making a product that no one wants to buy.
caineroadToronto · Jul 17, 2012#19This is not a sport car, hence i chose automatic. It's designed to zip around town and gets good fuel economy. I never regret ever so slightly with an auto.
However if I have a 370z or whatever sports car, I will pick manual.
LuxMarkham, Ontario, Canada · Jul 17, 2012#20As others have said, performance is not a criterion for these cars.
The dealbreaker for me in choosing the manual gearbox was maintenance. Don't know about anybody else here, but I fix my own geartrain; servicing a manual transaxle versus an automatic transmission are two dramatically different affairs. For instance, I'd rather repair my first-gear trust washer and synchro instead of doing a valvebody gasket job. I've done both and it's an obvious preference.
All vehicles that I've owned were three-pedal, so it was a natural choice, especially when slushboxes have the stupidest shift logic conceivable, as well as their annoying ECU self-learning bollocks.
Profotoiamgarden grove ca · Jul 19, 2012#21if i hadnt bought my yaris for every day driving 2000 miles a week i woulda went with stick vroom vroom
auto stills got some power thought
ljming99Singapore · Jul 20, 2012#22 Originally Posted by
caineroad ↑ This is not a sport car, hence i chose automatic. It's designed to zip around town and gets good fuel economy. I never regret ever so slightly with an auto.
However if I have a 370z or whatever sports car, I will pick manual.
I'm sorry but i have to disagree with the good fuel economy part, i recently have a chance to talk to a owner of a automatic yaris (while i drive a manual).
Cruising rpm of the engine in the manual is much higher than the automatic (at 100km/h - automatic is revving around 2000+ ish where my manual at 5th gear is doing 3000rpm)
I do alot of start-stop traffic and i have better mileage compared to an automatic.
Even my previous ride, an Aveo 1.4 AT was getting worse mileage compared to a optra which was a 1.6 M or even a Aveo 1.4 M.
For smaller engines, i would prefer a manual...its even more zippy 😛
side note - a Nissan 370z gearbox can Rev-match at gear changes so whether a manual or an automatic - not much difference =P
WeeYariGeorgetown, Ontario, Canada · Jul 20, 2012#23 Originally Posted by
ljming99 ↑ Cruising rpm of the engine in the manual is much higher than the automatic (at 100km/h - automatic is revving around 2000+ ish where my manual at 5th gear is doing 3000rpm)
I don't know what is going on in Singapore, but my A/T is spinning ~2800 rpm at 100 kph.
cali yarisCanoga Park, CA · Jul 20, 2012#24OP never posted again....
It's still a good topic.
jpmck03USA · Jul 20, 2012#25 Originally Posted by
WeeYari ↑ I don't know what is going on in Singapore, but my A/T is spinning ~2800 rpm at 100 kph.
Same here in America with my M/T. ~2700-2800 rpm at about 100 kph (~62 mph). Sounds like the engine is running at about the same speed when highway cruising regardless of transmission type.
RedRideMiddletown, NY · Jul 21, 2012#26 ......Inasmuch as some folks hate to see it, it probably won't be long before the manual transmission will go the way of the rotary phone, VCRs, etc. Technology has surpassed any advantage they once had...
They said the same thing about vinyl records but they refuse to die.😉
Personally, I don't see a death of manual any time soon. As long as there's a maket for something, there wiil be someone to sell it to you . Most manuals for the major manufacturers are trouble free and can live on for a long time with minor mods if neeeded.
Manuals add to the diving experience for many and it would be conterproductive to discontinue them unless most all maufactures did so in unison.
What I do see happening is that fewer models will be available with a manual saviing them for the sportier models.
BTW, when I got my Yaris , I ask what mnaual Yaris' they had on the lot. They said they had trouble locating one saying most wiil not drive a manual. I countered saying that I refuse to drive an automatic. They then found one on the lot in seconds!
I suspect that the manuals were scarce and in demand and they just wanted con me into buying an auto .
I then use their own words to lower the price aditionally reminding them that they said that about everyone wants an auto.😁
mazillaSan Jacinto California · Jul 21, 2012#27Manual isn't going away, ever.
nookandcrannycarS.MontgomeryCnty,TX(HoustonMSA) '07=BayouBlue=300,125miles=OrigOwnr '14=ClassicSilvr=29,059miles · Jul 22, 2012#28 Originally Posted by
WeeYari ↑
😁 I read the entire thread you posted the link to above. I went a little crazy. I posted replies to 16 different posts and then created one post of my own that wasn't a reply 😁.
nookandcrannycarS.MontgomeryCnty,TX(HoustonMSA) '07=BayouBlue=300,125miles=OrigOwnr '14=ClassicSilvr=29,059miles · Jul 22, 2012#29 Originally Posted by
tooter ↑ If you've never driven a manual transmission vehicle. Do not buy one before driving one first, so that you can make certain that's what you want.
Personally, I can't stand automatics and will never own a vehicle with one... but that's only one individual preference. Lots of people love autos and can't stand sticks.
👍👍👍👍👍 👏👏👏👏👏👏
nookandcrannycarS.MontgomeryCnty,TX(HoustonMSA) '07=BayouBlue=300,125miles=OrigOwnr '14=ClassicSilvr=29,059miles · Jul 22, 2012#30 Originally Posted by
MadMax ↑ But there is also the other argument that an auto allows you to concentrate more on traffic.
There's debates for both types of transmissions, but in the end you gotta try both and decide which works best for you. I am able to maintain a good pace in traffic with my auto and while steep hills are a challenge, it's to be expected in such a small-engined car. I honestly don't see how a manual transmission would be an advantage on a steep hill, if anything much like stop-and-go traffic, the auto would be preferable.
By the way, in competition offroading, more people are going with automatic transmissions due to advances. Same is true in high performance cars, the new autos shift faster than a manual. Those same developments mean the differences in gas mileage is nominal if any. I think the Yaris is rated the same or just 1 MPG off between the two transmissions.
Inasmuch as some folks hate to see it, it probably won't be long before the manual transmission will go the way of the rotary phone, VCRs, etc. Technology has surpassed any advantage they once had...
Cheers! M2
....Yes, an automatic ALLOWS FOR MORE concentration on the road, but it also ALLOWS FOR LESS concentration and, unfortunately (in the U.S. at least) LESS is usually the result.
MadMaxSan Antonio, Texas! · Jul 22, 2012#31 Originally Posted by
nookandcrannycar ↑ ....Yes, an automatic ALLOWS FOR MORE concentration on the road, but it also ALLOWS FOR LESS concentration and, unfortunately (in the U.S. at least) LESS is usually the result.
Well, most people in Houston drive like idiots anyway, no matter what kind of transmission they got!
But your correlation makes no sense. It allows for both more
and less?!? 🤷
Bad drivers in the US have nothing to do with the transmission people have in their cars...
CoryMWhite Rock BC · Jul 23, 2012#32I bought a manual trans because:
- I can autoX it.
- It's MUCH less likely to be an ex-rental car (I'm too cheap to buy new).
If I were in traffic everyday I would probably go for an auto though. Much more comfortable and faster to left-foot-brake. Thankfully I live >5min from work :D
ljming99Singapore · Jul 29, 2012#33Thanks for clearing up the cruising rpm for automatic vs manual, learnt something different =)
Anyway my point is that the conventional automatic gearbox it is always running a heavy torque converter slushing ATF around, hence its effect pretty much the similar to running bigger / heavier rims.
It uses more power from the engine, so it is unlikely that automatic would get better fuel economy vs a manual (assuming similar driving conditions)
richard_rspAtlanta, GA · Aug 2, 2012#34My 2012 Yaris is a manual and have owned manuals my entire driving life. My wife, on the other hand, has a 2012 xD with an Automatic. While it is nice having her automatic for being in traffic, I really don't even think about shifting anymore in my Yaris - it's an "automatic" response. So don't worry if you have to think about it at first, it will become an instinct.
I prefer manual transmission for 3 main reasons:
1) Control / Power - I know what gear I am in at all times. I don't have to worry about it up-shifting when I am about to accelerate out of a corner. Also, manuals have less of a parasitic drag on the amount of Horsepower that reaches the wheels (very important in a car with a small, low-power engine).
2) Maintenance - While clutch jobs are semi-expensive, they are nothing to rebuilding a transmission. Autos generally require more maintenance (flushes, etc) compared to manuals and have more electronics. This is less of an issue in newer cars, but if I am keeping a car for 300k miles, I prefer to be as simple to repair as possible.
3) Cost - generally cars with manual transmissions are less expensive than their automatic counterparts. On a new car, you can bet that a car's MSRP will be $800 - $1500 cheaper with a manual versus auto.
But this is just why I prefer them. You HAVE to make sure you are willing to put the effort into driving one. My wife had a manual transmission Mazda 5 before the xD and she really regretted getting the manual. Her reasoning was due to fear of starting off on hills / traffic.
A word of advice regarding the Yaris/xD - Neither of them have telescopic steering and steering wheel is mounted rather close to the dash. In an automatic, I have a tendency to sit further back (as do most people) since there is no clutch to push to the floor. I find this to be an issue when trying to get comfortable in the xD - I sit far back to be more comfortable for the pedals, but i have to move my seat up to reach the steering wheel. This isnt as much of an issue with a manual transmission in my Yaris because I am already close to the wheel (due to the clutch). So be sure to try both before buying.
Hope that helps? :-)
Originally Posted by
MadMax ↑ But your correlation makes no sense. It allows for both more and less?!? 🤷.
I actually kind of agree with an Auto allowing more AND less concentration. Having an automatic allows people (mainly applies new drivers) to worry less about what gear they are in (since no shifting), and concentrate on the road around them. HOWEVER, since she has gotten an auto, my wife pointed out that she has caught herself wanting to multitask more and her mind wandering more while driving (and she is a decent driver). So I could see how an argument could be made for it allowing more and less concentration.
It allows you to concentrate more on the road, as long as that IS what you are actually concentrating on!
bronsinnj · Aug 2, 2012#35I am too lazy to read all the previous posts to see if this is covered already. But my personal opinion is too valuble not to share it with the general public.🤘
Now that I can no longer drive a manual the thing I miss most about it is with an auto the car does not slow down very much when you let off the gas. This results in a loss of degree of control epsecially in winter weather. You have to brake a lot more with an automatic than a manual. Thats not good on slipperly roads.
And of course a manual is cheaper to buy, gets better gas mileage, and potentially lasts longer with less trouble than the auto.
But theres good news"
The Smart Car comes with an auto trans that is really an auto clutch. You shift it by pushing the gearsgift.. Theres no torque converter so it slows down when you let off the gas.
Thats a good thing.
richard_rspAtlanta, GA · Aug 2, 2012#36 Originally Posted by
bronsin ↑ But theres good news"
The Smart Car comes with an auto trans that is really an auto clutch. You shift it by pushing the gearsgift.. Theres no torque converter so it slows down when you let off the gas.
Thats a good thing.
While I understand your excitement, have you ever driven a Smart Car? That is BY FAR the WORST transmission I have ever driven - hands down.
But there are several "automated manuals" on the market - VW, BMW, Mercedes, even Nissan in the GT-R, I believe. They CAN be a decent compromise between the two, but the Smart Car is not what I would consider a good example. 😉
cali yarisCanoga Park, CA · Aug 2, 2012#37^ have to agree, I test drove a Smart and really disliked the drivetrain. I'd buy an iQ first, much more satisfying to drive.
nookandcrannycarS.MontgomeryCnty,TX(HoustonMSA) '07=BayouBlue=300,125miles=OrigOwnr '14=ClassicSilvr=29,059miles · Aug 2, 2012#38 Originally Posted by
MadMax ↑ Well, most people in Houston drive like idiots anyway, no matter what kind of transmission they got!
But your correlation makes no sense. It allows for both more and less?!? 🤷
Bad drivers in the US have nothing to do with the transmission people have in their cars...
My correlation makes perfect sense. Having an automatic transmission (and especially leaving it in Drive) allows you to dismiss having to 'concentrate on/think about' shifting. What you do with that shift of focus is up to you. Some people might concentrate more on the road/driving/their relation to other cars on the road. On the other hand, other people might feel that it frees them up to text/talk on their cell phone/talk to the person in the passenger seat more intently/eat/drink/shave/put make-up on/read, etc.
If a college student lives with his or her parents and has a SAHM or SAHD with traditional SAH duties, then he or she CAN study more than a student away at college because he or she doesn't have to do laundry/plan and execute meals, etc, but that doesn't mean the student WILL study more (to illustrate my point I'm assuming both examples have the same access to group study).
When it comes to Houston drivers, until earlier this year I probably had my head buried a bit in the sand. People are amazingly courteous in parking lots and on two lane residential streets, but on the freeways, feeder roads, and parkways there are more selfish and dangerous drivers than I used to like to admit. I spent most of the month of April this year all over Florida. I've driven in all of the 'Lower 48' U.S. states and in D.C. (45 of them + D.C. in my Yaris and 30 or so of them before I had my Yaris) and South Florida has the worst drivers in the U.S. on many different levels (IMHO)...far worse than Southern California (and I lived in Southern California for 6 1/2 years). Since returning from that trip to Florida in April, I'm more aware of the bad drivers here in the Houston Metro. I'd love to be able to instantly morph into a LEO whenever I see one of these drivers just to be able to pull them over to see gender and age. I'd bet most of them are male and under age 25.
'Bad drivers in the U.S. have nothing to do with the transmission people have in their cars'....I'd say bad DRIVING has LITTLE to do with the transmission people have in their cars. IMHO if a driver can drive a manual transmission car well, they have the POTENTIAL to become a better driver than someone who can't master a manual...BUT that doesn't mean they WILL DEVELOP that potential skill.
I think bad driving occurs in the U.S. primarily for two reasons: 1. Intent (MANY PEOPLE JUST DON'T CARE ABOUT TRULY BEING GOOD DRIVERS) and 2. Required minimum skill level (it is TOO EASY to get a non commercial DL in the U.S).
bronsinnj · Aug 2, 2012#39[QUOTE=richard_rsp;659824]While I understand your excitement, have you ever driven a Smart Car? That is BY FAR the WORST transmission I have ever driven - hands down.
QUOTE]
I have. I shifted it myself and it was fine.
Ive heard in D its awefull.
xnamerxxso cal · Aug 2, 2012#40 ....Yes, an automatic ALLOWS FOR MORE concentration on the road, but it also ALLOWS FOR LESS concentration and, unfortunately (in the U.S. at least) LESS is usually the result.
Originally Posted by
nookandcrannycar ↑ My correlation makes perfect sense. Having an automatic transmission (and especially leaving it in Drive) allows you to dismiss having to 'concentrate on/think about' shifting. What you do with that shift of focus is up to you. Some people might concentrate more on the road/driving/their relation to other cars on the road. On the other hand, other people might feel that it frees them up to text/talk on their cell phone/talk to the person in the passenger seat more intently/eat/drink/shave/put make-up on/read, etc.
It doesn't really make sense when you look at it from a logical standpoint.
During the creation of the Interstates or as there known here freeways they went with a laser straight roads to increase efficiency but a side effect of straight roads are that drivers become bored driving roads that don't require concentration and it increases the likelyhood of drivers falling asleep which increases the accident and death rate.
An automatic transmission requires less concentration and skill which increases the likelihood of the driver becoming distracted which increases the likelihood of an accident.
There are many articles out there which correlate this so i'll let Google be your friend.
YaristeveLos Angeles · Aug 2, 2012#41 Originally Posted by
bronsin ↑ Now that I can no longer drive a manual the thing I miss most about it is with an auto the car does not slow down very much when you let off the gas.
Yes!!! This!!! This is what actually makes driving in stop-and-go traffic EASIER with a manual than an auto. My friends never believe me when I tell them driving with an auto in heavy holiday traffic is more tiring to me than if I were in my manual trans car. With an auto, you must always be on the brake. With a manual, the car will just poke along at idle without picking up speed. So, it becomes a game to be able to tap the gas pedal at just the right time and amount so that you don't have to touch the brake pedal for miles...
My main peeve about auto trannies is going up long grades. I can't stand when the transmission starts hunting for a gear: losing speed... BAM! jerky downshift with the engine screaming. Picking up speed... BAM! jerky upshift. Uh-oh, losing speed again... BAM! Jerky dwonshift. Over and over again... Yeah you can just manually downshift but the gears are usually so widely spaced that the engie is screaming when you try to stay with traffic...
In the end, though, it is what others have said: personal preference. For me, manual trannies just make driving that much more fun...
eTiMaGoBangkok, Thailand · Aug 3, 2012#42People have been driving stick for thousands of years (well, close enough), through traffic, on inclines, on highways, in cities. It's not exactly the end of the world, and it lets you really control the car in ways you just cannot, with an automatic...
bronsinnj · Aug 3, 2012#43 Originally Posted by
Yaristeve ↑ Yes!!! This!!! This is what actually makes driving in stop-and-go traffic EASIER with a manual than an auto. .
Learn to shift without the clutch for an even easier experience!🤘
YaristeveLos Angeles · Aug 4, 2012#44 Originally Posted by
bronsin ↑ Learn to shift without the clutch for an even easier experience!🤘
I agree; when traffic is really bad and I get bored, I try rev matching and shifting without the clutch. Going from first to neutral is easy enough but trying to put it into first while coasting takes a little more concentration. But then, that is just one of the fun aspects of having a manual.
bronsinnj · Aug 4, 2012#45 Originally Posted by
Yaristeve ↑ I agree; when traffic is really bad and I get bored, I try rev matching and shifting without the clutch. Going from first to neutral is easy enough but trying to put it into first while coasting takes a little more concentration. But then, that is just one of the fun aspects of having a manual.
Its a good skill to have in case your clutch becomes inoperative. Ive even heard you can put the car in first and crank the engine to start it. The car will move and start without the clutch!
tooterLos Angeles · Oct 22, 2012#46 Originally Posted by
edmscan ↑ I totally wish my stick was an AT ... sorry Yaris stick lovers but the stick in the Yaris is a pain in the ass. (Maybe it is just my car .. but I find starting from a standstill to be difficult at best. Other than that .. it is fine) Maybe someone has a suggestion ?
For those that will disagree with me ... I have been driving a stick for 29 years so I know what I am doing. I have never had an automatic vehicle .. but I do wish my Yaris was the first.
I
only drive sticks and know exactly what you mean. The Yaris is weak letting out the clutch from a standing start. It took some modding to eliminate the problem.
cali yarisCanoga Park, CA · Oct 22, 2012#47If I go get a 2012, I would get an automatic. Another Yaris would not be for racing. 🙂
AstromanWenatchee, WA · Oct 23, 2012#48Garm this yaris wasn't supposed to be for racing remember? lol 😆
GeeToThaEeeSKG, GRE · Oct 23, 2012#49I can only justify buying an AT if you drive through traffic many hours everyday. Otherwise can't see why spending 2k (more or less) on AT and not on other extras or potential tuning.
Almost the majority of car companies give better mpg with a stick on the highway, you got better control of the car and needless to say that you actually participate more to the whole thing. Hell I even remember an offroader telling me it's better having a stick eventhough it might have slightly more damage on the transmission after many miles.
So unless absolutely necessary I'd rather have mine with a manual gearbox.
vincentgPhilippines · Oct 24, 2012#50 Originally Posted by
tooter ↑ I only drive sticks and know exactly what you mean. The Yaris is weak letting out the clutch from a standing start. It took some modding to eliminate the problem.
what modding is this? i also have some difficulty on my first gear. other than that. i have no problem with my manual tranny