bentjazzOriginal postOhio · May 9, 2011#1Hi guys,
Well, I'm over the 3,000 mile mark now and kind of regret getting the auto tranny. I was in a rush to get a car, knew I wanted a Yaris, had the option to get a MT, but decided on the AT and now regret it. Any other AT Yaris folk regret not getting the MT?
Should I trade mine in for a MT?
Replies 158
Klink10910 · May 9, 2011#2Nope
.Kevin.Prince George, BC. Canada · May 9, 2011#3HA Not a chance.
Manley81bassIrving, TX · May 9, 2011#4Yes.
sickpuppy1Kansas · May 9, 2011#5Sometimes yes, mostly no.
LtNoogieWest Hills, CA · May 10, 2011#6Shift the AT by hand based on the sound of the engine. You'll enjoy the drive.
The AT like to stay in third all the way through a turn and then feels like it's bogging. I shift to 2nd and then can pull away with alot of high rev zip.
I drive a lot with the SC turned off to get better gas milage and manually shifting the AT keeps it fun.
.Kevin.Prince George, BC. Canada · May 10, 2011#7 Originally Posted by
LtNoogie ↑ Shift the AT by hand based on the sound of the engine. You'll enjoy the drive.
The AT like to stay in third all the way through a turn and then feels like it's bogging. I shift to 2nd and then can pull away with alot of high rev zip.
I drive a lot with the SC turned off to get better gas milage and manually shifting the AT keeps it fun.
Isn't that going to force-grind your gears.
I mess with D and 3rd alot, but shifting an automatic or in this case - manumatic. Is only suggestions to the computer not precise shifting you can keep it to high rpms.
LtNoogieWest Hills, CA · May 10, 2011#8I don't really know. Someone who knows more will have to chime in. I think this topic was discussed in an old thread but manually shifting the AT makes for much more spirited driving.
Chuck GThe Great Northwest · May 10, 2011#9Drove both - really disliked the MT.
The Yaris AT is exceptional!!
I love mine.
The General Lee was an auto-we're just missing the 440 Magnum!
Hey LT-that AT must pull pretty good with the SC on! How much does the SC hurt your FE? Just curious!
MattS.OR Coast · May 10, 2011#11I was looking for a new Yaris with MT. Damn hard to find, so I ended up with an AT. How about the reverse... anyone wish they had bought an AT Yaris. I doubt either side will admit to anything :)
Klink10910 · May 10, 2011#12I will add that putting a Blitz throttle controller in put a whole new perspective on driving the AT. Reason why I like it so much.
daf62757Indianapolis, Indiana · May 11, 2011#13My AT is so smooth in shifting and the ease of using it far outweighs any gas savings you might get from having the MT. The MT gets very old...all that moving your feet and constantly switching gears while in heavy traffic.
I will never have another MT. ATs last so much longer and help your resale value.
YAR1SRaleigh, NC · May 12, 2011#14sometimes. I wish my car was more fun to drive, but its more convenient as an auto.
Brianr4New Orleans · May 12, 2011#15I only wish my 5 speed was a 6!
NZ-FE ViosGeorgia · May 15, 2011#16I also wish there was a sixth speed. Would not have gone for an AT, MT is always a requirement in vehicle purchases for me.
Originally Posted by
daf62757 ↑ ATs last so much longer
Hate to chime in and derail but I beg to differ. What evidence do you have to prove that ATs last longer? Sounds like you are making a rash generalization. I've seen a lot of cars that were put by the wayside because the AT failed.
Fact: MTs are easier to work on.
I would not think twice about dropping and rebuilding a MT, but would never consider attempting to rebuild an AT.
here's my generalization:
MTs will almost always outlive it's AT counterpart
IF driven properly by a competent driver.
However I do respect and understand why one would prefer an AT over MT. To each their own. 😉
.Kevin.Prince George, BC. Canada · May 15, 2011#17Manuals need clutch replacement etc while autos can go and grind teeth
kimonaHuntington Bch, CA · May 15, 2011#18Definitely not. Love this AT.
ViperoniBrampton, ON · May 15, 2011#19 Originally Posted by
.Kevin. ↑ Manuals need clutch replacement etc while autos can go and grind teeth
All else equal, manuals:
Give you full control over which gear you're in
Give you engine braking
Have less frictional losses
Are lighter in weight
Internals will longer, not counting the clutch
Usually handle higher power levels
NZ-FE ViosGeorgia · May 15, 2011#20 Originally Posted by
Viperoni ↑ All else equal, manuals:
Internals will longer, not counting the clutch
I just read about a toyota truck owner that had 258k on original clutch, this was coming from the Toyota owner's website, of course there is no way to prove validity, but if true, that says a lot.
.Kevin.Prince George, BC. Canada · May 15, 2011#21Implying it isn't completely worn but he just kept it on because he can.
NZ-FE ViosGeorgia · May 15, 2011#22Correct.
I've had clutches fail before and when they fail, it is near impossible to drive the car unless going downhill. If he is truly on original clutch, it must still be doing what it is required to do to function properly. Of course it has worn over all those miles, but engines wear as well, just because it has wear doesn't mean that it requires replacement or we'd all be continuously replacing all parts on vehicles.
A clutch is also considered a wearable part as are brakes and tires. If you burn your clutch under warranty, they won't replace it as it *should* last longer than 120k miles as it is never specified in factory maintenance manual as needing replacement. Longevity is based upon the quality of the driver.
Mikeey01nzlNew Zealand · May 16, 2011#23No never......
It's the wifes car, she gets into it at the end of a hard days work and puts it into D, no brainer for her. O BTW it's a CVT too.
Fuel economy is a small price to pay for ease of driving for her.
yaris2010RSAngus, Ontario · May 16, 2011#24 Originally Posted by
NZ-FE Vios ↑ I just read about a toyota truck owner that had 258k on original clutch, this was coming from the Toyota owner's website, of course there is no way to prove validity, but if true, that says a lot.
my mom had a 87 corolla that she went 14 years on oem clutch, it only had just shy of 200,000km. it is possible but as i see my clutch i defenatly wont get to 200,000 on this oem clutch, it really is a shit clutch imo.
i will drive MT as long as i can and i really loved the yaris MT vs AT
YaristeveLos Angeles · May 16, 2011#25 Originally Posted by
NZ-FE Vios ↑ I just read about a toyota truck owner that had 258k on original clutch, this was coming from the Toyota owner's website, of course there is no way to prove validity, but if true, that says a lot.
My 1988 Toyota truck's clutch had 180,000 miles on it when I had to have it replaced only because my rear seal was leaking and contaminated the clutch. And this even after I had burned it twice (lots of smoke and smell).
yaris2010RSAngus, Ontario · May 16, 2011#26everytime i get smell from mine (not often and not alot) im so scared, lol
i have never gotten smoke
nemelekArizona · May 17, 2011#27At one time in my life I thought that I would never own an auto. Now that I am an old fart I don't think that I will ever drive a stick again.
Had shoulder surgery 8 weeks ago on the right side and the auto was blessing. Not sure that I would have been able to drive a stick.
nemelekArizona · May 17, 2011#28 Originally Posted by
Yaristeve ↑ My 1988 Toyota truck's clutch had 180,000 miles on it when I had to have it replaced only because my rear seal was leaking and contaminated the clutch. And this even after I had burned it twice (lots of smoke and smell).
I had an 88 Sr5 truck that had 200,000 miles on the clutch when it was sold. A friend who put on oversize tires only got 65,000 on his clutch. Early clutch failure is due to people not knowing how to drive a clutch.
yaryarbingMaryland · May 17, 2011#29I drove a MT LB as a rental before purchasing a 2007 AT Sedan.
My only beef with the AT is not shifting beyond 2nd until the engine heats up. It is annoying on cold mornings. Plenty of threads discussing this...
I was pleasantly surprised to get great mileage with the AT (49 MPG plus).
MTs can be fun to drive, but the AT sure is convenient.
YaristeveLos Angeles · May 17, 2011#30 Originally Posted by
nemelek ↑ Early clutch failure is due to people not knowing how to drive a clutch.
I, reluctantly and embarassingly, have to agree... In my first manual car, a 1979 Celica, the clutch only lasted 85,000miles. My 1999 Miata has 175,000 miles and is still on the original clutch although it is starting to feel like it will be going pretty soon.
By the time I got my second manual vehicle (the 1988 truck), I had learned to heel-and-toe and I wonder if that helped save the clutch quite a bit...
Betriventedmonton · May 17, 2011#31Double clutching also saves the clutch. No riding it, as well. The only time I wish I didn't have a manual is in traffic- but I avoid most traffic so it's all
schumePNW · May 19, 2011#32I prefer a MT on most vehicles, but I purposely bought my Yaris with the AT. I do a lot of freeway driving, but every once in a while, I get caught in Seattle stop-and-go traffic. Going through that with a MT is enough to make anyone crazy.
I'll take the MPG hit (if there is any) for the comfort of driving the auto. I must say, it is a nice shifting transmission.
daf62757Indianapolis, Indiana · May 19, 2011#33 Originally Posted by
NZ-FE Vios ↑ I also wish there was a sixth speed. Would not have gone for an AT, MT is always a requirement in vehicle purchases for me.
Hate to chime in and derail but I beg to differ. What evidence do you have to prove that ATs last longer? Sounds like you are making a rash generalization. I've seen a lot of cars that were put by the wayside because the AT failed.
Fact: MTs are easier to work on.
I would not think twice about dropping and rebuilding a MT, but would never consider attempting to rebuild an AT.
here's my generalization:
MTs will almost always outlive it's AT counterpart IF driven properly by a competent driver.
However I do respect and understand why one would prefer an AT over MT. To each their own. 😉
I would say that my comment is based upon almost 40 years of experience as a driver and my experience as a motor pool officer in the Army. AT's rarely need any maintenance until well over the 100K miles. Most manuals need to have a clutch replacement somewhere near the 50 to 60K mile mark. You might be correct that the driver's ability to use the clutch has a significant impact on the length of longevity, but on average, the AT will last longer and cost less in maintenance. Also, the AT raises the value of the vehicle when it comes to resell.
In the end, its all relative to what you think and believe. You obviously have a different opinion as do I. In our own worlds, we can both be correct!
mazillaSan Jacinto California · May 19, 2011#34I drive my MT Yaris from San Diego to Los Angeles and back 2-3 times a week(about 280 miles round trip). It takes me 2.5 hours to get there and about 3.25 hours to get home...I wouldn't trade the MT for an auto, especially now that I have the complete short shift kit.
ZebraWest Buttcrack, MN · May 20, 2011#35During the cold days I absolutely hate waiting for my engine to warm up and allow the AT into higher gears. On those days, I would love to have a MT. With that exception, AT is just fine for me.
NZ-FE ViosGeorgia · May 20, 2011#36 Originally Posted by
daf62757 ↑ I would say that my comment is based upon almost 40 years of experience as a driver and my experience as a motor pool officer in the Army. AT's rarely need any maintenance until well over the 100K miles. Most manuals need to have a clutch replacement somewhere near the 50 to 60K mile mark. You might be correct that the driver's ability to use the clutch has a significant impact on the length of longevity, but on average, the AT will last longer and cost less in maintenance. Also, the AT raises the value of the vehicle when it comes to resell.
In the end, its all relative to what you think and believe. You obviously have a different opinion as do I. In our own worlds, we can both be correct!
Very interesting. As Americans AT definitely does help resale value (automatic is an optional extra, creating greater initial cost and value). I know some 50somethings that have never driven MT, I'm glad you have.
As a Motor Pool Officer, what did you do specifically and what do U.S. Army motor pool consist of? What do they buy in MT? Do you think that the MTs would be especially dogged due to having many drivers (and ones that don't regularly drive MT) or are most vehicles assigned to one driver for most of its use? Do you think a Motor Pool Officer in a European Countries' Army would say the opposite (conjecture, but due to Europeans buying mainly MT)?
As for maintenance, yea I'd rather pull a dipstick and check ATF in comparison to the unbolting check bolt and fingering gearbox, anyday.
What do you think about higher end cars (mercedes-benz, etc) that have the MT as an optional extra?
I appreciate your position and insights as I've never had correspondence with someone who worked with pools of motors. Cheers
daf62757Indianapolis, Indiana · May 23, 2011#37 Originally Posted by
NZ-FE Vios ↑ Very interesting. As Americans AT definitely does help resale value (automatic is an optional extra, creating greater initial cost and value). I know some 50somethings that have never driven MT, I'm glad you have.
As a Motor Pool Officer, what did you do specifically and what do U.S. Army motor pool consist of? What do they buy in MT? Do you think that the MTs would be especially dogged due to having many drivers (and ones that don't regularly drive MT) or are most vehicles assigned to one driver for most of its use? Do you think a Motor Pool Officer in a European Countries' Army would say the opposite (conjecture, but due to Europeans buying mainly MT)?
You supervise the motor pool mechanics and get your ass chewed out for everything that goes wrong! My MP Company had tactical vehicles (M151-A2s) that were MT. We also had Ford Topaz and Chevy Blazer/pickups for patrol cars. Later on, before I got out, we got some Ford Crown Vics. The MTs had to constantly be rebuilt. I don't know if its fair to compare the M151-A2's tranny to a commercial tranny. They were constantly being rebuilt by kids who were hardly 18. The commercial vehicles usually had no problems but back when GM went over to the first 4 speed auto tranny, the 4th gear would burn out. The other 3 would still work. The tactical vehicles usually had the same 3 people driving. The Commercial vehicles never had the same driver.
Can't say what another country's military experience with transmissions would be. People are usually the same no matter where you go. Kids usually are drivers in the military do the experienced MT operators would not come into play.
As for maintenance, yea I'd rather pull a dipstick and check ATF in comparison to the unbolting check bolt and fingering gearbox, anyday.
What do you think about higher end cars (mercedes-benz, etc) that have the MT as an optional extra?
Never have drive one so can't say. My only experience is with American cars....oh yea, and POS VW Rabbit back in the early 80s.
I appreciate your position and insights as I've never had correspondence with someone who worked with pools of motors. Cheers
As a Motor Pool Officer, what did you do specifically and what do U.S. Army motor pool consist of? What do they buy in MT? Do you think that the MTs would be especially dogged due to having many drivers (and ones that don't regularly drive MT) or are most vehicles assigned to one driver for most of its use? Do you think a Motor Pool Officer in a European Countries' Army would say the opposite (conjecture, but due to Europeans buying mainly MT)?
As for maintenance, yea I'd rather pull a dipstick and check ATF in comparison to the unbolting check bolt and fingering gearbox, anyday.
What do you think about higher end cars (mercedes-benz, etc) that have the MT as an optional extra?
I appreciate your position and insights as I've never had correspondence with someone who worked with pools of motors. Cheers
DeatheggCA · May 26, 2011#38I will say that if I move back to SoCal, with the many freeways and bad traffic, I will regret it, and will have to get something with an auto. However here in Pittsburgh, MT is the way to go. I just hate the artificial feel of the gas pedal and the slight increase in RPM's I get as I shift. Annoying. Other than that, I'm getting 39 mpg, so I'm happy. :)
YaristeveLos Angeles · May 26, 2011#39 Originally Posted by
Deathegg ↑ I will say that if I move back to SoCal, with the many freeways and bad traffic, I will regret it, and will have to get something with an auto. However here in Pittsburgh, MT is the way to go. I just hate the artificial feel of the gas pedal and the slight increase in RPM's I get as I shift. Annoying. Other than that, I'm getting 39 mpg, so I'm happy. :)
Before you pre-determine that you wouldn't like an MT in SoCal, you should try it for a while. Once you learn to feather the gas and time your shifting/accelerating, you may find that using an MT in SoCal traffic is actually less tiring than an AT. I do; I can't stand driving an AT in LA traffic.
I think the ONLY place I would not want an MT is the hilly streets of San Francisco; my guess is that clutches don't last long there unless you have a car with "hill-holder" type automatic brakes like Subaru used to have. Even then, who knows? One may get used to commuting with an MT there as well...
MadMaxSan Antonio, Texas! · May 26, 2011#40No way.
And as technology has been advancing, ATs are becoming more common, even in Europe. 10-15 years ago you'd never see them over there, when we took our 95 VW Passat over the Germans were surprised to see it was an AT. Now I see more and more autos when I go over there.
MTs are losing their small edge in performance and efficiency, if anything it won't be too long before they may disappear completely. In real performance cars they are getting rarer and rarer.
Enjoy your primitive clutching and manual gear changes, guys; I predict in ten years you're gonna be hard pressed to find cars with them!
YaristeveLos Angeles · May 26, 2011#41[QUOTE=MadMax;582897]MTs are losing their small edge in performance and efficiency, if anything it won't be too long before they may disappear completely. In real performance cars they are getting rarer and rarer./QUOTE]
My choice of MT has nothing to do with fuel economy, shifting speed, track times, efficiency, performance, etc. It is all about enjoying the act of driving. I've said this in other forums (and maybe here): there is nothing like setting up a perfect four-wheel drift after doing the perfect heel-and-toe through a corner. It is just so much fun and that is all there is to it.
So, I agree that new and newer generations of ATs will probably eventually outperform MTs in every objectively measurable way. But, unless they come up with a double-clutch, paddle shifter SMG system that can be overriden by a clutch pedal and four-(or five or six)-on-the-floor, I plan on keeping all of my MT cars forever or until the gasoline runs out.
DeatheggCA · May 27, 2011#42 Originally Posted by
Yaristeve ↑ Before you pre-determine that you wouldn't like an MT in SoCal, you should try it for a while. Once you learn to feather the gas and time your shifting/accelerating, you may find that using an MT in SoCal traffic is actually less tiring than an AT. I do; I can't stand driving an AT in LA traffic.
I think the ONLY place I would not want an MT is the hilly streets of San Francisco; my guess is that clutches don't last long there unless you have a car with "hill-holder" type automatic brakes like Subaru used to have. Even then, who knows? One may get used to commuting with an MT there as well...
I'm not pre-determining,,, I speak from having lived in SoCal from '05 to '09. I had my Festiva at the time, with a 4-speed, and thankfully I didn't go near LA very often. When I did, I had a long drive coming home to Riverside. However
IF I move back, I'll have to live with the m/t and see how I like it. I don't generally like auto's, they never shift when I think they should, and driving is less fun. As I said the main thing about my Yaris is that weird-feeling gas pedal, but I see there's a fix for that.
As for hills: no problem for me, as I live in Pittsburgh, which is nothing but hills, and am used to it. The clutch in the Festiva was never changed and had 226k on it when I sold it, still working great. Having to traverse hills doesn't automatically mean the clutch won't last long; it's all how you use it. :)
kroloswa state · May 30, 2011#43I love my Auto , the Yaris Auto transmission really performs very
well ,responsive and smooth.
daf62757Indianapolis, Indiana · Jun 2, 2011#44 Originally Posted by
krolos ↑ I love my Auto , the Yaris Auto transmission really performs very
well ,responsive and smooth.
Amen!
joe keeneyhemphill texas · Jun 3, 2011#45A t the best after a Dodge power wagon 11 inch clutch never again.
joe keeneyhemphill texas · Jun 25, 2011#46AT YOU GET A BAD BACK YOU'LL UNDERSTAND.
fj40daveAllyn · Jun 26, 2011#47 Originally Posted by
krolos ↑ I love my Auto , the Yaris Auto transmission really performs very
well ,responsive and smooth.
Me too
thepartsmancomethmidwest · Jul 8, 2011#48the yaris is fine with an AT, but I couldn't imagine anything sportier with an AT. I drive an MT as my DD and don't find it bothersome even in heavy/construction traffic. Once you get used to it, its second nature. I strongly believe in having control over my vehicle.
and now...
to get on my soapbox....if everyone drove MT cars, there'd be less distracted/drunk/cell phone blathering idiots driving. it wouldn't eliminate them all, but its harder to do those things and shift at the same time!
HTM Yarissouth Carolina · Jul 18, 2011#49^^^^^🙇🤘🙇🤘^^^^^^^^
My GF has a AT , every time I drive it I have to sit on my left foot b/c 30 years of driving MT I am used to a clutch and when I go to shift I hit the brake pedal and WHAMMO , my freakin head smacks the steering wheel ......not pretty
daf62757Indianapolis, Indiana · Aug 16, 2011#50 Originally Posted by
thepartsmancometh ↑ the yaris is fine with an AT, but I couldn't imagine anything sportier with an AT. I drive an MT as my DD and don't find it bothersome even in heavy/construction traffic. Once you get used to it, its second nature. I strongly believe in having control over my vehicle.
and now...
to get on my soapbox....if everyone drove MT cars, there'd be less distracted/drunk/cell phone blathering idiots driving. it wouldn't eliminate them all, but its harder to do those things and shift at the same time!
Or actually increase the distractions since stupid people will do stupid things no matter what they drive.