Replies continued
ChinoCharlesOH · Apr 6, 2007#101
Actually, that is my last car... and it was baller.
How many 5500 pound cars do you know that can yank a 14 second quarter mile with the heated leather seats on? 😆
Kaotic LazagnaThread starterCentral Valley, CA · Apr 6, 2007#102heh, that's one fast tank! hahaha
Pavel OlavichOrange County, Calif · Apr 6, 2007#103 Originally Posted by
Black Yaris ↑ yes our car can tell the difference between fuel grades... more premium gas gets better gas mileage... plain and simple... if you do not believe me just do it.... then you will know for yourself
Sorry but you're living in the land of dillusion...using octane higher then 87 for your Yaris will give you WORSE milage....why is this so hard for you to understand? Using higher octane means the combustion is RETARDED, meaning that it takes MORE gas to give the car the same power....this means lower milage...the only exception to this is if the car is engineered (tuned) for higher octane....you keep thinking that ALL cars behave the same with higher octane...this is dillusion, or worse.
Pavel OlavichOrange County, Calif · Apr 6, 2007#104 Originally Posted by
BailOut ↑ Octane is not a measurement of caloric content or burn-ability (cetane). It is a measurement of how high a temperature is needed in order to ignite the fuel. This is why premium fuel is usually only required on high performance engines (because they run at higher compression levels which generates more heat).
Higher octane fuel is actually less pure because of the extra additives which are used to make the fuel ignite at a higher temperature. These additives are also why it costs more.
Running fuel of an octane higher than what your engine is designed for can help with knock (detonation) but that is generally where the benefits stop. The detriments are:
- Fouled spark plugs due to the deposits left via incomplete burning.
- Greatly increased emissions due to incomplete burning.
- Fouled O2 sensors due to these emissions.
- Fouled catalytic converter due to these emissions.
Stick to what your engine is rated for. The 1NZ-FE engine in the Yaris is designed for 87 octane gasoline.
AMEN Broda!!!! You wrote it right and it is right!!!!! Why some here hold on to superstitions, urban myths, or what use to work with 1960ish cars is beyond me.... 🤘
static808California · Apr 6, 2007#105 Originally Posted by
ChinoCharles ↑ Attachment 4265
Actually, that is my last car... and it was baller.
How many 5500 pound cars do you know that can yank a 14 second quarter mile with the heated leather seats on? 😆
hahah, my sienna does a 0-60 in 7.4, and the 1/4 mile in 16.4. not too bad for any car, let alone a van that seats 7!! my van is probably a little slower than those numbers, since i gots all the goods, like power doors and trunk and heated leather everything, and i run only the required 87. those tests were done using premium fuel. but i can attest to the fact that i've beaten quite a few cars "off the line" using only the required 87...now if we can only cram my sienna v6 into the yaris...
--B
Black YarisToledo, OH · Apr 6, 2007#106 Originally Posted by
Pavel Olavich ↑ Sorry but you're living in the land of dillusion...using octane higher then 87 for your Yaris will give you WORSE milage....why is this so hard for you to understand? Using higher octane means the combustion is RETARDED, meaning that it takes MORE gas to give the car the same power....this means lower milage...the only exception to this is if the car is engineered (tuned) for higher octane....you keep thinking that ALL cars behave the same with higher octane...this is dillusion, or worse.
ok Pavel, MR HIGH and MIGHTY.... you explain why it is that everyone that tries putting higher octane fuel in there Yaris gets better gas mileage? In the words of ChinoCharles "Don't you ever shut up?"
marcustoronto, canada · Apr 9, 2007#107hehehe thats funny...
marcustoronto, canada · Apr 9, 2007#108premium is always cleaner that the regular.....it may not make much to the horsepower but its cleaner..
MooseCumming, GA · Apr 9, 2007#109I tried a tank of premium this week, after reading this thread, just to see what would happen. 90% of my driving is usually highway, and half of that is in bumper to bumper traffic. I usually average about 35 mpg. Using the premium, and with a 120 mile mountain run (most of which was spent at 4500 rpm and above) in addition to my normal routine, I averaged 37 mpg.
Will I spend the extra money on premium again? Nah, it wasn't that much of a difference to me. Did it prove to me that you do, in fact, get better fuel economy with 93 octane? You betcha, and I bet that I could've done better without the mountain run, as well.
Kaotic LazagnaThread starterCentral Valley, CA · Apr 10, 2007#110 Originally Posted by
Moose ↑ I tried a tank of premium this week, after reading this thread, just to see what would happen. 90% of my driving is usually highway, and half of that is in bumper to bumper traffic. I usually average about 35 mpg. Using the premium, and with a 120 mile mountain run (most of which was spent at 4500 rpm and above) in addition to my normal routine, I averaged 37 mpg.
Will I spend the extra money on premium again? Nah, it wasn't that much of a difference to me. Did it prove to me that you do, in fact, get better fuel economy with 93 octane? You betcha, and I bet that I could've done better without the mountain run, as well.
cool, cool, this premium stuff is weird.
Pavel OlavichOrange County, Calif · Apr 10, 2007#111 Originally Posted by
Black Yaris ↑ ok Pavel, MR HIGH and MIGHTY.... you explain why it is that everyone that tries putting higher octane fuel in there Yaris gets better gas mileage? In the words of ChinoCharles "Don't you ever shut up?"
So are you suggesting that the majority rules? Did you attend college? Simply put, they're wrong....sorry, but they are, and NO I never shut up.
Pavel OlavichOrange County, Calif · Apr 10, 2007#112 Originally Posted by
marcus ↑ premium is always cleaner that the regular.....it may not make much to the horsepower but its cleaner..
So less efficient combustion means "cleaner"....Nope!
Pavel OlavichOrange County, Calif · Apr 10, 2007#113 Originally Posted by
Moose ↑ I tried a tank of premium this week, after reading this thread, just to see what would happen. 90% of my driving is usually highway, and half of that is in bumper to bumper traffic. I usually average about 35 mpg. Using the premium, and with a 120 mile mountain run (most of which was spent at 4500 rpm and above) in addition to my normal routine, I averaged 37 mpg.
Will I spend the extra money on premium again? Nah, it wasn't that much of a difference to me. Did it prove to me that you do, in fact, get better fuel economy with 93 octane? You betcha, and I bet that I could've done better without the mountain run, as well.
Your 'test' was not scientific....did you every consider that you could fill your tank up with 87 octane and drive your same route 10 times and get ten different MPG results? Your test lacks controls to be able to draw conclusions. Funny how you do your test once, and draw conclusions....did you attend college?
acrbillchicago · Apr 10, 2007#114The Yaris has 10.5:1 compression. It must have a extremely conservative timing curve to allow the car to run on regular. My old Neon ran on premium. It said premium fuel recommended. It did not say required. If I put regular fuel in the MPG would go down like crazy and there would be a noticeable power loss.
IMO any car with that high of a compression ratio should run better with a slower burning fuel in. The real test would be to use a obd2 data logger to monitor the knock sensor and timing with regular and premium. I would bet that you will see a lot of activity from the knock sensor and therefor timing being pulled and fuel being dumped.
Pavel OlavichOrange County, Calif · Apr 10, 2007#115 Originally Posted by
acrbill ↑ The Yaris has 10.5:1 compression. It must have a extremely conservative timing curve to allow the car to run on regular. My old Neon ran on premium. It said premium fuel recommended. It did not say required. If I put regular fuel in the MPG would go down like crazy and there would be a noticeable power loss.
IMO any car with that high of a compression ratio should run better with a slower burning fuel in. The real test would be to use a obd2 data logger to monitor the knock sensor and timing with regular and premium. I would bet that you will see a lot of activity from the knock sensor and therefor timing being pulled and fuel being dumped.
It's not just about high compression....the amount of cubic liters comes into play....just because a small engine has high compression does not necessarily mean it requires premium....you need to take the size of the engine into consideration too. The bigger the displacement, the longer it takes for the fuel to burn completely, thereby requiring more octane to retard the burn for a given stroke.
Black YarisToledo, OH · Apr 10, 2007#116 Originally Posted by
Pavel Olavich ↑ Your 'test' was not scientific....did you every consider that you could fill your tank up with 87 octane and drive your same route 10 times and get ten different MPG results? Your test lacks controls to be able to draw conclusions. Funny how you do your test once, and draw conclusions....did you attend college?
let us pull that Chino quote again "Do you ever shut up?"
SlummyD.C. · Apr 10, 2007#117I know that acrbills test was not "scientific", but dont all his previous tanks that average 35 MPGs act as a control? Not trying to be difficult. Just curious.
Black YarisToledo, OH · Apr 10, 2007#118yes... Pavel is just mean, he just does not want to face the truth that he is WRONG 90% of the time
elsteverino889MIA! · Apr 10, 2007#119Go with Citgo...support Chavez!!!....i kid lol
churpTropical Minnesota · Apr 10, 2007#120👍 Hey Pavel....you're great!!!
Haven't met many like you, but all I can think of is you sittin at home gettin under peoples skin and just laughin!! 👍
🤘 Carry on.
Black YarisToledo, OH · Apr 10, 2007#121 Originally Posted by
churp ↑ 👍 Hey Pavel....you're great!!!
Haven't met many like you, but all I can think of is you sittin at home gettin under peoples skin and just laughin!! 👍
🤘 Carry on.
👎 1 vote to ban you from the site just for that comment 😁
churpTropical Minnesota · Apr 10, 2007#122Gotta be the the why.........couldn't be serious!!!!
Black YarisToledo, OH · Apr 10, 2007#123 Originally Posted by
churp ↑ Gotta be the the why.........couldn't be serious!!!!
What? Please edit, that does not make sense
acrbillchicago · Apr 10, 2007#124 Originally Posted by
Black Yaris ↑ 👎 1 vote to ban you from the site just for that comment 😁
Just what any site needs. Some 8 year old who gets off by pissing everyone off.
99% of the time I would agree with Pavel, but the high compression makes this situation different than most.
By your logic you would lose MPG. So even that guys "unscientific" test points to that not being the case.
So everyone knows.
The higher the octane the slower the burn. You want the lowest octane that the car can function well at. Most of the time using higher than needed octane cost performance. With higher compression there is an increased chance of engine knock. Not even the audible type, just the type that the knock sensor picks up. When that happens the ECU pulls timing and in some cases dumps fuel. Both are bad for all aspects of performance.
The only real way to test would be to log sensor outputs and timing advance with both fuels.
acrbillchicago · Apr 10, 2007#125 Originally Posted by
Black Yaris ↑ What? Please edit, that does not make sence
WTF is sence? That makes no sense.
I keed I keed.
Black YarisToledo, OH · Apr 10, 2007#126I bet those that are saying higher octane fuel does not give ou better MPG have never tried it... You will bash it every wich way and sideways, but untill you try it yourself, or as bill stated with the correct diag equipment stop bashing it, because you don't know.
static808California · Apr 10, 2007#127damn kaotic, look what you done started?? its right up there with the synth vs. dino debate. makes for fun reading though...
--B
Kaotic LazagnaThread starterCentral Valley, CA · Apr 10, 2007#128 Originally Posted by
static808 ↑ damn kaotic, look what you done started?? its right up there with the synth vs. dino debate. makes for fun reading though...
--B
lol...would have never thought i could start all this. 😆
static808California · Apr 10, 2007#129 Originally Posted by
Kaotic Lazagna ↑ lol...would have never thought i could start all this. 😆
we need to keep you out of the UN. you mean well, but you'll be starting wars by accident!! 😛
--B
Kaotic LazagnaThread starterCentral Valley, CA · Apr 10, 2007#130hahaha, the United Nations...hmmm, perhaps, i might start WWIII if i join the UN. lol...
AdriaanMontreal · Apr 11, 2007#131personally i like the premium gas, i've has lots of problems with the regular gas here in ontario. The gas here is mixed with ethanol some times up to 15% except shell premium and i believe pioneer. i was having problems with the gas sensor. Took it to the dealer to find out that the since i was mixing fuel with and without ethanol the fuel turned a white color and had damaged the sensor. i work between montreal and toronto. In Montreal there is no ethanol in the fuel as of yet. Since i had it changed i stop buying regular here in ontario and haven't had the problem since. Also I work for esso and i found out that when you mix ethanol fuel like sunoco with regular fuel with out ethanol turns a white color, and as of yet there no technology to separate the two. But this is my experience and what i found out. Not sure if it is true with what i found, or my car was and isolated incident. Also i did a test with sunoco ultra 94 and shell premium on my last trip to montreal. Between my monteal house and toronto house is 686km with ultra 94 i got 536km and with shell i got 636km same driving style going and return about 120km to 140 km on the 401.
marcustoronto, canada · Apr 11, 2007#132as per (Adriaan's) quote.
"he personally i like the premium gas, i've has lots of problems with the regular gas here in ontario. The gas here is mixed with ethanol some times up to 15% except shell premium and i believe pioneer. i was having problems with the gas sensor. Took it to the dealer to find out that the since i was mixing fuel with and without ethanol the fuel turned a white color and had damaged the sensor. i work between montreal and toronto. In Montreal there is no ethanol in the fuel as of yet. Since i had it changed i stop buying regular here in ontario and haven't had the problem since. Also I work for esso and i found out that when you mix ethanol fuel like sunoco with regular fuel with out ethanol turns a white color, and as of yet there no technology to separate the two. But this is my experience and what i found out. Not sure if it is true with what i found, or my car was and isolated incident. Also i did a test with sunoco ultra 94 and shell premium on my last trip to montreal. Between my monteal house and toronto house is 686km with ultra 94 i got 536km and with shell i got 636km same driving style going and return about 120km to 140 km on the 401."
Originally Posted by
Pavel Olavich ↑ So less efficient combustion means "cleaner"....Nope!
dallasCanada · Jun 22, 2007#133Let's stop the b.s and start posting our mileage figures on the two grades of gas. Enough people checking it should make the results more believable🤷
marcustoronto, canada · Jun 22, 2007#134well i have been switching from prem to reg... so far i got more mileage with the prem then again that could also be driving habit as well..but its about 10-30 km difference for about 38 liters of gas..
here:
1st tank 540km with 39.8l fill up = 38.34mi/gal with regular 87 octane
2nd tank ran 535km fill up 38.4l = 39.37mi/gal with premium 89 octane
3rd tank 540km 37.5l fill up=40.69mi/gal with premium 89 octane
4th tank 570km premium fill up @38.00 liters =42.40 m/gal -15km/liter 89 octane
5th tank went to regular gas..48.2 liters ran 711 km 40% hwy (had to add 10 liters in between), calculated about 6.7l /100km,,41.68m/gal ... i was expecting about 6.0 l/100,,,atleast...
jdiumHillsboro · Jun 22, 2007#135[QUOTE=Kaotic Lazagna;69781]
Originally Posted by
fu_im_from_texas ↑
not sure why either. my factors remaind the same, for the most part. the only difference is that i was driving faster and the gas itself. but i'm not willing to get another tank of premium to find out. lol...😆
I'm doing some math...the Yaris has an 11 gallon tank..."premium" 93 octane gas is usually .20 cents more per gallon than "regular" 87 octane gas...that's $2.20 a tank...
If you get 10% better gas mileage with premium, as some have stated (36mpg with regular, 40mpg with premium, etc), then you will be driving as far on 10 gallons or premium as you would be on 11 gallons of regular...
Stop me if I'm losing anyone...
Gas is now above $3 a gallon around my area. You are saving .80 cents if you see 10% better mileage with premium...
I'm thinking this is along the lines of the placebo effect, you believe your more expensive purchase is going to help you, so it does...
Also, how much do you all drive if an extra $2.20 a tank for premium is breaking your wallet? If you drive 10,000 miles a year at 40 mpg, that is about 23 fillups. That is $50 a YEAR...
Sorry for the ramble...but if you believe that premium is helping you, buy it. Scientifically, there is no benefit to running premium in these cars...
churpTropical Minnesota · Jun 22, 2007#136[QUOTE=jdium;101220]
Originally Posted by
Kaotic Lazagna ↑
......
Sorry for the ramble...but if you believe that premium is helping you, buy it. Scientifically, there is no benefit to running premium in these cars...
Don't understand how you can say that! Scientifically, under load the higher octane allows more timing advance before knock (in a 10.5:1 compression ratio car) which is more efficient, using less fuel for the power needed....not under load I agree with you.
Kaotic LazagnaThread starterCentral Valley, CA · Jun 23, 2007#137hey, i never said that. hahaha...why is my name highlighted and not jdium?
but yeah, this thread was brought back from the dead. well, i used premium again and got less mpg. but i know that's because i've been using the a/c more. personally, i think i'm just going to stick regular.
jdiumHillsboro · Jun 23, 2007#138[QUOTE=churp;101248]
Originally Posted by
jdium ↑
Don't understand how you can say that! Scientifically, under load the higher octane allows more timing advance before knock (in a 10.5:1 compression ratio car) which is more efficient, using less fuel for the power needed....not under load I agree with you.
It is a 105 hp engine, it is ALWAYS under load :D
If what you say is true, why don't the Toyota engineers tell us to use premium?
eTiMaGoBangkok, Thailand · Jun 23, 2007#139maybe because it would turn potential buyers away from the car, you don't usually associate a modern economy car with premium gasoline... Just a guess anyway! I'm gonna try higher octane fuel just for the heck of it for my next tank...
njyarisNORTHERN NEW JERSEY · Jun 23, 2007#140just my two cents ... i just bought my YARIS a week ago and I LOVE IT .. therefore i use 93 octane .. now does this change anything .. ofcoarse it does .. even if it's only perception .. since my perception is in favor for better gas milage and higher performance i tend to drive a little harder and faster .. just my two cents
jdiumHillsboro · Jun 23, 2007#141 Originally Posted by
njyaris ↑ just my two cents ... i just bought my YARIS a week ago and I LOVE IT .. therefore i use 93 octane .. now does this change anything .. ofcoarse it does .. even if it's only perception .. since my perception is in favor for better gas milage and higher performance i tend to drive a little harder and faster .. just my two cents
Your perception is for better gas mileage so you drive harder??? That's counter productive...
Like I stated above. The higher mileage being noted is IMO a placebo type effect. You think higher octane will help, thus it does.
If requiring higher octane would turn away potential buyers, why not atleast tell them what everyone in here is saying? Increased octane = increased mpg? Cuz it's not true...
smokinyarisSoCal · Jun 23, 2007#142so do you guys feel up with premium or regular............
jdiumHillsboro · Jun 23, 2007#143 Originally Posted by
smokinyaris ↑ so do you guys feel up with premium or regular............
I feel up my girlfriend sometimes 🤤
I fill up with regular, the cheapest stuff I can find...
forpinksLAS VEGAS, NV · Jun 23, 2007#144Go buy a "Maximum Boost" book and it will tell you that a higher octane gas will give you more power compared to lower octane gas.
there is a comparison on the N/A and Turbo there really is a big difference especially if your running RPMs higher than 4500 on N/A... The turbo with high octane gas is damn more powerful than low octane.
Also the 106HP (not high performance? I know.) is achieved using high grade high octane gasoline for testing (Since Japan don't have anything lower than 93 octane they even have 120-125 octane) the engine power will drop to 100flywheel HP when you use 87 gas and it will make more gunk to the engine because of the slight combustion difference even with the knock sensors, remember the 1NZ-FE is japan made and tested so It should run 90+octane and will get 51MPG elsewhere except US (may be possible with acetone) which don't have anything higher than 93 basic fuel 100 octane cost like 4.30 vs 3.30 91...
(It's new here in the USA and Toyota USA wouldn't put the 91 reccomended fuel since it will hurt sales...)
Hope this helps!!!
forpinksLAS VEGAS, NV · Jun 23, 2007#145I used 87 on a 3.8 Chrysler rental van (1000miles ODO) with 6 passengers and an icebox and I have to absolutely floor it to go 75MPH uphill at I-15... when we went back (got mad with the slow climbing speed) and bought damn 91 eventhough it's a rental and I did'nt regret it since I can climb a hill at 85-100MPH (still floored) running with an IS with a radar detector.
All I can say is I am definitely satisfied of the 91octane gas even if I pay the high price!
jdiumHillsboro · Jun 23, 2007#146 Originally Posted by
forpinks ↑ Go buy a "Maximum Boost" book and it will tell you that a higher octane gas will give you more power compared to lower octane gas.
there is a comparison on the N/A and Turbo there really is a big difference especially if your running RPMs higher than 4500 on N/A... The turbo with high octane gas is damn more powerful than low octane.
Also the 106HP (not high performance? I know.) is achieved using high grade high octane gasoline for testing (Since Japan don't have anything lower than 93 octane they even have 120-125 octane) the engine power will drop to 100flywheel HP when you use 87 gas and it will make more gunk to the engine because of the slight combustion difference even with the knock sensors, remember the 1NZ-FE is japan made and tested so It should run 90+octane and will get 51MPG elsewhere except US (may be possible with acetone) which don't have anything higher than 93 basic fuel 100 octane cost like 4.30 vs 3.30 91...
(It's new here in the USA and Toyota USA wouldn't put the 91 reccomended fuel since it will hurt sales...)
Hope this helps!!!
Ignorance is bliss eh? Higher octane will NOT give you more power in a Yaris. Go buy some dyno time if you can't believe me. It will NOT give you higher mpg either. Put the car on jack stands, and idle a tank away of each if you can't believe me either.
On a turbo car, higher octane allows more boost, thus higher hp.
Knock sensors have nothing to do with engine "gunk" buildup.
If it was possible for the Yaris to get 51 mpg in the U.S., it would. Why would Toyota not want a car that destroys every other car in its class? Try 51 kpg maybe.
The Yaris is sold in America. I think the Toyota engineers are smarter than us.
churpTropical Minnesota · Jun 24, 2007#147 Originally Posted by
jdium ↑ Ignorance is bliss eh? ......
On a turbo car, higher octane allows more boost, thus higher hp.
...... I think the Toyota engineers are smarter than us.
I'm sure the Toyota engineers aren't any dumber than us. That is why they say the Yaris run's with 87 octane, and that is why cars have had ECU's installed for the last few decades....don't you believe there is a reason...it's not because they cost a lot. They allow the timing to be retarded in a load situation to prevent knocking with the high compression engines (above 9 to 1 compression) in a load situation like maintaining 60-70 mph up a steep hill while using 87 octane.....this is not the optimum timing for power or gas milage but it keeps the engine from self destructing.
My 53 Buick I used to have, had no timing marks. The shop manual said to said to set timing by turning the distributer until it ran good, then test drive by accelerating or going up a hill. If there was a knock go back and retard the timing,then repeat until only a very faint knock was heard. This is fine and dandy until you got a batch of poor gas, then it would knock like crazy. You could increase milage by advancing timing (set according to the gas you used) and driving consertively. ECU's have changed this to the better, but 'good' gas does work.
During slow acceleration or maintaining speed on flat land the ECU allows the optimum timing because knock isn't present (even with 87 octane).....most hypers drive in this condition 99.9% of the time while the common everyday driver is in this condition 95% (guesstimate at maximum). So theoreticaly, scientifically, or any other way you think about it....the very concientious driver sees no gain from higher octane, the common driver may see better milage on a small fraction of their driving, and the leadfoot would see the best gains. Granted this is a small percentage gain over a very small percentage of a persons driving....but it is a gain.
forpinksLAS VEGAS, NV · Jun 24, 2007#148^^^ Go to Toyota Canada.... it clearly states that it gets 41MPG city and 51MPG highway they measure fuel economy in metric using L/100KM and they don't use KPG, also they have high octane gas to give you better fuel economy...
Don't be a cheapo and face the truth that higher octane gasoline performs better!
(Why does the US form 87 octane anyway? are they the only ones and want to be unique?) I even tried octane 125 at the airport for my AE92 and it definitely cleansed the engine and gave better power and response I drove it like I stole the damn thing.... (one thing I noticed is that the cold engine start white smoke disapeared when I used a tank of 125octane)
I'm gonna try half a tank of octane 100 for the tC and see if it does something nice.
njyarisNORTHERN NEW JERSEY · Jun 24, 2007#14987 is for lawnmowers .. you decide! 👍
fu_im_from_texasTexas · Jun 24, 2007#150 Originally Posted by
jdium ↑ ... I think the Toyota engineers are smarter than us.
👏 ...toyota has spent 100s of 1000s of dollars looking at these issues. toyota says use 87 ... end of argument...