Yarisworld Archive

Megan Header Dyno Results

83 posts · 25,915 views · page 1 of 2

ChinoCharlesOriginal postOH · Jan 2, 2007#1
WEEEEEEEEE

Picture not included in this copy

What a fun experience man... I got to shoot the shit with the guys from Twisted Innovations and talk about this car and other cars. I learned a lot.

As far as the results, their printer was down so they are e-mailing me the sheets tomorrow. The gain was 3 or so horsepower, but that doesn't tell the whole story of what the header does. There was also a steady 3 ft/lb gain in the torque curve that came on quick and stuck around for a few thousand RPM. There was no net torque gain though. We did both runs in third gear.

It was funny... we first ran the car in fourth gear and got a whopping 125 HP to the wheels! I was so confused! As the boys said, though, "the dyno doesn't lie." It was even calibrated a couple of weeks ago, so for a second we were stumped. Then one of the guys in the shop said that some of these fuel efficient pump gas cars have two overdrives to save some MPG's. Anyone know if that is the case with the Yaris?

The third gear runs had us in the 105 HP range. I'm sure if we had done the tests in first gear we would have been in that 70-80 WHP range that is documented. Either way, we got the gains.

The guys at TI seemed excited about the prospect of having the car in their shop, and hopefully I will be working with them to develop some more parts for the car. You'll see threads popping up in the appropriate forums meant to gague interest in certain parts. If you see something posted that you would like to be on the market, post in the thread, because they're watching.

I'll post the actual sheets tomorrow.

1 attachment not included in this copy

Replies 82

vodkalushRochester, NY · Jan 2, 2007#2
cant wait for the print outs! Like I said in the GB thread I wish i had the extra cash during the GB.... 🙁
NutzoidsPhiladelphia · Jan 3, 2007#3
Congratulations man… I am beyond Jealous!

😈
acrbillchicago · Jan 3, 2007#4
They are correct, 4th and 5th are overdrive gears. 105WHP is super strong considering the Scion guys are around 78whp.
spkrman2 · Jan 3, 2007#5
wow 105 to the wheels???

this is a swap from the stock header to the megan, while retaining your other mods...which your mods are all listed in your sig?
KatanaUnder the hood! · Jan 3, 2007#6
Great results!
Notthy[Yaris/S]07Puerto Rico · Jan 3, 2007#7
105? awsome
redglare45Pomona / Pasadena, California · Jan 3, 2007#8
Sweet! Can't wait to see the dyno sheet
ChinoCharlesThread starterOH · Jan 3, 2007#9
Originally Posted by spkrman ↑
wow 105 to the wheels???

this is a swap from the stock header to the megan, while retaining your other mods...which your mods are all listed in your sig?
105 to the wheels in third gear. In fourth gear she puts 125 to the wheels! HAHA. I'l bet if she actually could get air in and out third and fourth gear would be really fun!

And yes, my mods are all listed in my sig.
ecoAtlanta · Jan 3, 2007#10
Only 3 ponys more,Im sorta let down,was hoping atleast 5.Well my car is in the shop today to get its ne custom 2.5" cat back,plus the header is being installed,I wish I could get my hands dirty on this one,but I curently have no welder,and I figured let them get the header while theyre at it.I have no dyno that I know of near me,I would love to actuall see some final numbers when Im done,I just might have to get them done at the NOPI car show next year.
FastnxCanada · Jan 3, 2007#11
It sounds like they were not using a pickup to read actual RPM.

A properly set up dyno reads the engine's RPM so gearing does not matter. whether you are in first, second, third, fourth or fifth gear, the dyno will know the RPM the engine is at, instead of just guessing.

Since going from 4th gear to 3rd gear yielded a lower power reading, this makes me think they are not using an RPM pickup. The hp numbers appear to be lower since the wheel speed is lower (hp=rpm*tq/5252).

The 105 at the wheels number is obviously not accurate, there is no way there is only a 3hp driveline loss. This means the 3hp gain that was noticed is also slightly overstated. Perhaps 3hp at the crank is a more accurate figure.

Either way, I am glad to see positive gains. Looking forward to seeing the dyno graph.
ChinoCharlesThread starterOH · Jan 3, 2007#12
They were using a pickup to read RPM's. By the way, I had to giggle when I saw she idles at 600 RPM. Wow.

I'm still dying for someone to explain the differences in HP from gear to gear... or just confirm that the car has multiple overdrives.
CASTREXCosta Rica · Jan 3, 2007#13
Get those graph posted asap! I agree those numbers dosen't sound right. The HP's shouldn't go up and down when changing gears. Did this dyno concidered the atmosferic variables for correcting horsepower and torque to a known standard?
riceboyCAN · Jan 3, 2007#14
Can't wait to see the data sheets...
ChinoCharlesThread starterOH · Jan 3, 2007#15
Yeah, I just called and the shop is closed. They must have taken the night off... they were there until 11 PM last night, so I could understand. Looks like y'all sit in suspense for another day! HAR HAR!
nevermorezVancouver · Jan 4, 2007#16
Damnit, I just missed the Megan Header GB. Can I still get one though? Where should I buy it from?
nevermorezVancouver · Jan 4, 2007#18
Originally Posted by ChinoCharles ↑
Get the NST crank pulley instead. Better gains for the money.

Oh, and when you do get the header, get it from the generic seller on Ebay. Its a tad cheaper.

http://cgi.ebay.com/ebaymotors/Perfo...spagenameZWDVW
Pardon my ignorance. Wut does crank pulley do actually. I thought header was a must upgrade for yaris.
ChinoCharlesThread starterOH · Jan 4, 2007#19
With the Yaris, they're all a must upgrade... haha.

A lightened crank pulley will do two things for an engine.

[1] It will increase power (both HP and TQ) through the entire powerband
[2] It will increase throttle response, directly decreasing 0-60 times

Most mods increase HP or torque in one specific area of the powerband. That header specifically increased HP by 3 at the high end and torque by 3 at the low end. I will have the dyno results online very soon so you can see this. A crank pulley will increase HP and torque throughout. If you gain 8 HP at 1000 RPM, it will be there at 5500. Same with torque.

It is the same theory behind a lightweight rim. Since there is less mass to rotate, your car will be faster as you shave more pounds off of your wheel weight. Now, think about a pulley directly connected to your crankshaft that weighs 60% less. That 60% weight savings transfers into power gained, but in all reality the power was always there... you're just giving your engine the means to perform to its full potential.

You can view various dyno sheets in the group buy thread. The header is wonderful (trust me, I have it!) but I'm betting the pulley will be a better bang for the buck.
nevermorezVancouver · Jan 4, 2007#20
Alright, I'm SOLD! I'll sign up the GB. :D
punchBarrie, ontario · Jan 4, 2007#21
[QUOTE=ChinoCharles;45729]With the Yaris, they're all a must upgrade... haha.

A lightened crank pulley will do two things for an engine.

[1] It will increase power (both HP and TQ) through the entire powerband
[2] It will increase throttle response, directly decreasing 0-60 times

a lightened pulley will not increase hp!
spkrman2 · Jan 4, 2007#22
increase power to the wheels, yea :)
Chris07LBNew Jersey · Jan 4, 2007#23
Nice Charles! 👏
johnnyfiveMilwaukee WI · Jan 4, 2007#24
Originally Posted by ChinoCharles ↑
Oh, and how about that low end? 3 ft'lbs of torque straight through, and the HP curve just shifted upwards 2-3 HP. All in all, not a bad start to a full exhaust.
looks like it lost torque, and HP almost all of the way through....well, up until 5k'ish rmp...
ChinoCharlesThread starterOH · Jan 4, 2007#25
OK! First of all, thanks to Mike from NST for talking me through how to interpret these sheets. I was way off.

Second of all, I will apologize beforehand for making some false claims about the header results for the past 24 hours or so. Like many of you, I'm learning ... now allow me to explain.

First, results.

STOCK THIRD GEAR PULL
Picture not included in this copy

THIRD GEAR PULL W/ HEADER
Picture not included in this copy

ALL RESULTS ON ONE GRAPH
Picture not included in this copy

The first time I read the graphs, I immediately assumed the higher curves on the third graph had to be the header. I mean, we wouldn't spend money on this part to lose power, right? WRONG. We did lose power! Sure, by the numbers we didn't. Notice at the very end of the graphs at about 6000 RPM the header curves catch up and surpass the stock. For all intents and purposes, this piece can be advertised as providing an increase in HP and torque... about 2-3 HP and 2-3 ft/lbs respectively. However, that gain at the top end comes at a price, which can easily be seen through the first 5500 RPM.

This is typical of mods like this... specifically intake and exhaust mods. They do provide gains on the top end, but overall the price is often far greater than they payoff. I'm still not convinced this is the case with this header. The numbers seem to sway that way, but there is more to a car than horsepower and torque, and I'll be spending the next few days trying to understand every little nuance associated.

So again, sorry for not being as observant as I should. Like I said before, this has all been a huge learning experience, and it culminated with this information.

Allow me a day or two to contact TI and verify this information once again. I am also going to do some research and have Kevin help me explain why the numbers are a bit inflated.

Thanks one last time to Riceboy for hooking up the Group Buy, Twisted Innovations for doing the testing and letting me use their garage like I worked there, Mike at NST for your help in explaining the results, and Megan Racing for bringing us a header.

3 attachments not included in this copy

ecoAtlanta · Jan 5, 2007#26
Well I got my cat back and header insatlled,I have no dyno,but I do notice an improvment,Im guessing that header needs more room to breath.Now we need some serious effort in a full exhaust system,or a 1 stage or 3 stage high flow cat.
ChinoCharlesThread starterOH · Jan 5, 2007#27
Originally Posted by eco ↑
Now we need some serious effort in a full exhaust system,or a 1 stage or 3 stage high flow cat.
I'm working on it. 😁
NutzoidsPhiladelphia · Jan 5, 2007#28
ChinoCharles Thanks for the Dyno Lesson... Like you I am learning as much as possible and those will help me greatly!

As far as the apologies... No need man, I know what its like to get excited and to hear something but not understand, and instead of pushing just assume its on the positive end... Everyone here knows you love your car, and you just let the excitement carry you away... At least from my point of view... That is no reason to feel bad or apologize!


😈
vodkalushRochester, NY · Jan 5, 2007#29
thats it i can never trust another thread or post by ChinoCharles

😁 👍 🙄
ChinoCharlesThread starterOH · Jan 5, 2007#30
ROFL! Fuckin' ball busters.

This makes 1337 posts. If you're a nerd, you understand why that is funny.
acrbillchicago · Jan 5, 2007#31
That sucks man. I just looked at those pics of the stocker and the Megan side by side and I just can't understand how you lost power. Sometimes cars are strange like that.

You have to question the dyno itself though. Its obvious that the numbers are off since the same motor in the Scion makes ~78whp stock.

What is the rev limit on the Yaris? When peak HP comes at the end of the graph you have to wonder how much is hiding above the limiter.
Russelt3hPirateEpcot · Jan 5, 2007#32
new cars aren't as restricted exhaust wise.

congrats on your wise purchase.

gains will always be felt without a dyno, you wallet is positive of that.
ChinoCharlesThread starterOH · Jan 5, 2007#33
acrbill, you'd be surprised how common findings like these are. It isn't hard to make a header that gains power at the top. It is, however, difficult to make a header that gains power at the top without sacrificing low- and mid-range power.

Don't question the dyno, because I've said it before and I'll say it again... the dyno doesn't lie. The reason for the inflated numbers can be explained, and will be shortly. For now, take the numbers as a ratio and apply it to our assumed 78 WHP. For all we know, though, that could also be wrong. I just saw an xB sheet today that had the car closer to 90 HP, which would be more on par with the expected 15% drivetrain loss from the stated 106 HP. If anyone has undisputed numbers proving one way or the other, now would be a wonderful time to share.

Here are a couple good reads on intake/exhaust related parts. The first has to do with a Mustang intake, and the second is all about a P&P job on a stock Celica GTS header that left the owner losing on the low end to gain up top.

http://www.musclemustangfastfords.co...rd_mustang_gt/

http://www.newcelica.org/forums/show...threadid=60156
spkrman2 · Jan 5, 2007#34
the yaris doesnt have power steering, take that into account with the power output :)
spkrman2 · Jan 5, 2007#35
Originally Posted by acrbill ↑
What is the rev limit on the Yaris? When peak HP comes at the end of the graph you have to wonder how much is hiding above the limiter.
yea, i saw the graph and wonder the same thing.

I can take it to the limiter and it doesnt feel like its losing anything up there.
acrbillchicago · Jan 5, 2007#36
I have seen graphs where trq. suffers a little down low but HP gains up high are decent. I have never seen a header take power away across the board.

Is there a splitter in the stock collector? I have seen that on stock headers before. It keeps the gases on each bank separate until it gets into the mid pipe. I guess the larger primaries don't help since they are merging into the same size collector.

With a mid length header and a larger mid pipe I bet there would be significant gains.
spkrman2 · Jan 5, 2007#37
i think we'll have to wait for some of hte scion products to come on over... there are gains shown with headers over there, not sure whats up here.
RossPPaphos, Cyprus · Jan 6, 2007#38
TBH I think you might have a bit of a dodgy dyno. What make was the dyno?
gr8yarisNew Jersey · Jan 8, 2007#39
From what I have learned so far from my other car projects, the exhaust mod works best in conjunction with an intake mod. Although individually, each can individually improve performance, one is inter-dependent on the other for maximum combined performance outcome.

There's really not much sense in making the exhaust diameter (e.g.: header) exit much larger if there is no current increase in the a/f volume to start with or vice-versa. Using the Bernoulli's principle, the increase in the pipe diameter does not neccessarily improve flow. However, if there is an increase in the a/f volume (because of e.g.: CAI or Forced Induction) then improving the corresponding exit (exhaust) is of proportionate benefit.
largeorangefontSo Cal, OC · Jan 8, 2007#40
If the individual runners are larger than stock, you will lose power until very high RPMS. On a low powered engine like this, you wont have any noticeable gains until you do other mods such as intake and full exhaust. A 4-2-1 header might be better for this application.

The design of the Megan and the OEM manifold look very similar. It looks like the Megan has slightly larger diameter runners, which would explain the results.

That being said, the OEM manifold looks pretty well designed for what it is.
CASTREXCosta Rica · Jan 9, 2007#41
Any one knows anything about the Weapon R header? That's a 4-2-1 desing. It was supposed to be out early this year.
ChinoCharlesThread starterOH · Jan 9, 2007#42
Nope.

Oh, and it is official... the Dyno was OFF. Confirmed by Mustang Dyno themselves, and they will be out yet again to look at it soon.

Fourth gear in the Yaris is 0.969:1, so fourth being closest to a 1:1 gear ratio, that is the gear you should use to dyno test Yarii. Well, our fourth gear pull read at 125 HP, so that means this dyno is screwed up... off by about 40 HP. Easy to miss when tuning a 400 WHP car, but it became extremely apparent when they threw the little-Yaris-that-couldn't on there. MD's peeps are coming to look at it soon, and then I will be going back yet again to retest the car. Hopefully by then I will have the pulley in my posession so I can do before, w/ header, and w/ header and pulley runs. It would be interesting to see if the pulley can negate the low-end losses from the header.

I'm dreadfully fucking sorry for all of this.
FastnxCanada · Jan 9, 2007#43
Fourth gear in the Yaris is 0.969:1, so fourth being closest to a 1:1 gear ratio, that is the gear you should use to dyno test Yarii
Gearing does not matter.

Did you know that after the power leaves the output shaft, it goes through the final drive where it is reduced again by approximately 4:1?
largeorangefontSo Cal, OC · Jan 9, 2007#44
Originally Posted by Fastnx ↑
Gearing does not matter.

Did you know that after the power leaves the output shaft, it goes through the final drive where it is reduced again by approximately 4:1?
On certain types of dynos it does matter. It depends on how the dyno calculates load. They assume that the transmission ratio is 1:1

If you did the test back to back on the same day, I would consider the results valid. Even though the dyno read high, it is better than comparing before and after numbers on 2 differend dynos or different days.
GalavoxxSan Francisco · Jan 9, 2007#45
Originally Posted by CASTREX ↑
Any one knows anything about the Weapon R header? That's a 4-2-1 desing. It was supposed to be out early this year.
I was the test subject for the first header and they told me about three months. That was in November some time. They are supposed to call me when it's done. Who knows if they will. I'm just waiting...
ChinoCharlesThread starterOH · Jan 9, 2007#46
Originally Posted by largeorangefont ↑
On certain types of dynos it does matter. It depends on how the dyno calculates load. They assume that the transmission ratio is 1:1

If you did the test back to back on the same day, I would consider the results valid. Even though the dyno read high, it is better than comparing before and after numbers on 2 differend dynos or different days.

The first statement is correct. On Mustang Dynos, you need to know your gear ratio. I didn't know this until I got there of course, hence why we ended up doing the pulls in third. Now I know, so next time we will use fourth.

I second what you said also about the results being valid. Viewing the original results as a ratio rather than cold hard numbers, you can apply those to the expected 80 or so WHP. Having said that, we are still going to start the whole process over. I want a real baseline so I can document what each mod does to this car throughout. She wont be stock much longer.
FastnxCanada · Jan 9, 2007#47
You guys do not know what you are talking about. You are dyno newbies, I have about 30 hours of experience on a 4 different kinds of dynos.

Do you even know what a final drive is? Do you really think the wheel speed is almost the same as the crankshaft speed?


If there is an RPM pickup, you do not need to know the gear ratio.
ChinoCharlesThread starterOH · Jan 9, 2007#48
First of all, settle down.

Second of all, I hardly believe 30 hours designates you as an expert there princess.

Third, I am a dyno noobie, and I don't profess to be anything else... unlike yourself, who apparently believes 30 whole hours makes you an expert. There are people that spend more time on a dyno in a week than you have in your life, my trusted tech included. Apparently he doesn't know as much as you, though.

Everyone thinks they're a fucking expert. Give me a break. Didn't your mother ever tell you no matter how much you THINK you know, there is always someone out there who knows more... or in your case, a whole lot of people.
vodkalushRochester, NY · Jan 9, 2007#49
Listen I've touched a computer and use it atleast 4hrs a week and since I've been working with them for 2yrs I am a computer expert!!!


but really, simmer. All around I think if anyones followed this thread then you would know that this is chino's first dyno experiance (unless I missed something; in which case go suck an egg) so there are bond to be some issues, and 30hrs experience does not make you an expert in anything... unless your talking about 30 straight hours of making some grilled cheese goodness.... ummm grilled cheese :drools:

either way lets try and keep it friendly boys, we're all here to learn so some mistakes are bond to happen. Well it's been fun and all but its time to go watch "Children of Men" and passout on my couch.
largeorangefontSo Cal, OC · Jan 10, 2007#50
Originally Posted by Fastnx ↑
You guys do not know what you are talking about. You are dyno newbies, I have about 30 hours of experience on a 4 different kinds of dynos.

Do you even know what a final drive is? Do you really think the wheel speed is almost the same as the crankshaft speed?


If there is an RPM pickup, you do not need to know the gear ratio.
I've had 130 hours across 5 dynos brands and about 10 facilities, and I'm no expert. Shut up, you don't know what you are talking about. Not every dyno in the world is a Dynojet. If that was the case you would be correct.