Yarisworld Archive

Megan Header Dyno Results

83 posts · 25,915 views · page 2 of 2

Replies continued

FastnxCanada · Jan 10, 2007#51
way to back up your opionions with facts.

Again, find out what a 'final drive' is and then see what you think.
Russelt3hPirateEpcot · Jan 10, 2007#52
Chino,

would you be willing to do the following?

Go back to stock, Dyno
Header, Dyno
Pulley and Header, Dyno
stock headers and pulley, Dyno

and how is the pulley making power on the yaris and not on every other car in the world? would a lightweight flywheel make more power too?
largeorangefontSo Cal, OC · Jan 10, 2007#53
Originally Posted by Fastnx ↑
way to back up your opionions with facts.

Again, find out what a 'final drive' is and then see what you think.
Way to back up your opinions with misinformation and crying.

GENERALLY, changing the final drive on your car shouldn't affect peak horsepower, only the curve. There are some dynos with calibrations that will change HP output if you put on a shorter final drive. This is obviously incorrect as changing the final drive does not change HP. The general consensus is to dyno the car in the gear that is closest to 1:1 to keep results similar across all types of cars. Dynoing a car in 2nd and another in 4th gear would give two completely different curves, and be an invalid comparison of the 2 cars.
ChinoCharlesThread starterOH · Jan 10, 2007#54
Again, this isn't my opinion, this is the opinion of the man that owns the dyno I run at. He tells me that his particular dyno relies on the fact that the car is run in a gear that is as close to a 1:1 ratio as possible.

In 8 posts on these forums, you haven't posted one bit of usable information, so you have no room to talk about facts.

If it makes you feel any better, I had no idea what a final drive was until you mentioned it and I looked it up. Now I have yet another thing I can learn from my trusted dyno EXPERT when I see him next. Hooray.

For anyone that doesn't know and would like to...

http://auto.howstuffworks.com/differential.htm
FastnxCanada · Jan 10, 2007#55
Right, but it is important to know what final drive is and how a transmission works.

According to chinocharles, the engine's power goes through 4th gear, the speed is multiplied by 0.9xx and that's it. This is not correct.

The power goes through the clutch to the input shaft, then through a gearset to the output shaft. This gearset is different for every gear. The output shaft then travels through the differential, which reduces the engine's speed once again. Most final drives are in the 4:1 range.

So if your first gear ratio is 3:1 and the final drive ratio is 4:1, the wheels are actually travelling 1/12 the speed of the engine.

If your fourth gear is 0.9:1 and the final drive is 4:1, the engine is still travelling 3.6 times faster than the wheels.

The assumption that you have to dyno in the gear closest to 1:1 is false, since the power is going through a final drive, the wheel speed will never be close to the engine speed. If your dyno guy is telling you this, he is wrong. Just because you own and operate a dyno does not mean you know the science behind how a dyno works.

At a dyno I went to, the operator did not even know the fundamental relationship between horsepower, torque and RPM which is HP=(Tq*RPM)/5252.
ChinoCharlesThread starterOH · Jan 10, 2007#56
I will definitely be going back to the dyno to retest the header. Right now my car is stock, as I have the header off to save me some work when I do go back. If the pulley is delivered before the dyno is fixed, I will be testing that too.

Since the dyno was just reading heavy, I am looking at the graphs now and thinking that if you reduce the numbers by about 25% it should be somewhat accurate. Knowing that, the header does so little on its own that I don't see much of a point in testing the car with the stock header and pulley. Whatever the pulley does with the Megan header on is going to be on par with what it does with the stock header, and that saves me having to put the car on the lift twice.
FastnxCanada · Jan 10, 2007#57
In 8 posts on these forums, you haven't posted one bit of usable information, so you have no room to talk about facts
So the only thing i know about cars is from the time I have spent at yarisworld?

I am not the typical Yaris owner. I have been involved with cars for more than two decades. I race Nissan NX2000s, I build our motors which make 270hp from 2160cc. Before that I was a race mechanic on a Formula BMW that my brother raced.

I just happen to be an environmentally responsible consumer, and consequently have an interest in Yarii. I'm on this site to find out about what is available for this car and what others have done.

Heres a pic of my racecar

Picture not included in this copy


Picture not included in this copy
Russelt3hPirateEpcot · Jan 10, 2007#58
Originally Posted by ChinoCharles ↑
Whatever the pulley does with the Megan header on is going to be on par with what it does with the stock header, and that saves me having to put the car on the lift twice.
so, you really think that pulley is going to make power to help negate the loss else where in the power band from the improperly design'd header?

wouldn't it make more sense to just buy a header that makes real power instead of trying to cover an open wound with a bandaid?

you're claiming 10hp from a pulley right?
acrbillchicago · Jan 10, 2007#59
A quick google search.

http://www.awe-tuning.com/pages/faq/...ain.cfm?FAQ=22
Gearing: a chassis dyno is susceptible to gearing bias. Recorded power can be affected on a dyno graph by simply running the test car in too low or too high a gear. Dyno operators should pick the trans gear that is closest to a 1:1 ratio to avoid gearing bias. This ratio is 4th gear in most cars. In a 1:1 ratio, the two gears that make up a gear set are the same size. When one is larger than the other, either in a lower gear than 1:1 or a higher gear than 1:1, there are frictional losses that translates to less power put to the wheels. Also, too high of a gear that causes the test car to go to a top speed far greater than the available fan cooling capacity will produce invalid results.
http://www.bristoldyno.com/info/procedure.htm
Many dynamometer operators go right for the gear that is the closest to a 1:1 ratio as it has the lowest drag in the gearbox and therefore the highest horsepower reading (usually) on a vehicle that is properly sized to be tested on this dyno.

There is dozens more hits that back up that being close to 1:1 is important.
ChinoCharlesThread starterOH · Jan 10, 2007#60
Originally Posted by Fastnx ↑
According to chinocharles, the engine's power goes through 4th gear, the speed is multiplied by 0.9xx and that's it. This is not correct.
DEE DEE DEE!

When did I say that? Let me make the font bigger so you can read it.

My dyno tech told me that we need to test the car in a gear with a ratio as close to 1:1 as possible.

I don't even know enough about engines to say what you quoted me as saying, so please, don't put words in my mouth.

I edited the rest out because acrbill was nice enough to quote those pages for me. I knew I had read articles online backing up my tech's statements, but I couldn't find them again, so thank you Bill.
acrbillchicago · Jan 10, 2007#61
Originally Posted by Fastnx ↑
So the only thing i know about cars is from the time I have spent at yarisworld?

I am not the typical Yaris owner. I have been involved with cars for more than two decades. I race Nissan NX2000s, I build our motors which make 270hp from 2160cc. Before that I was a race mechanic on a Formula BMW that my brother raced.

I just happen to be an environmentally responsible consumer, and consequently have an interest in Yarii. I'm on this site to find out about what is available for this car and what others have done.

Heres a pic of my racecar

Picture not included in this copy


Picture not included in this copy
Oh man! If you would have mentioned this earlier it would have saved some misunderstanding. Instead of thinking you where a moron we would have had proof of it.

Your obviously full of shit, and you thought you could come onto a site and pull the wool over our eyes with your supreme knowledge of all things automotive.
What you failed to realize is that we are not little kids enamored with pictures of "race cars".

Do everyone a favor and buy a Honda Fit.
FastnxCanada · Jan 10, 2007#62
A quick google search.

http://www.awe-tuning.com/pages/faq/...ain.cfm?FAQ=22

Quote:
Gearing: a chassis dyno is susceptible to gearing bias. Recorded power can be affected on a dyno graph by simply running the test car in too low or too high a gear. Dyno operators should pick the trans gear that is closest to a 1:1 ratio to avoid gearing bias. This ratio is 4th gear in most cars. In a 1:1 ratio, the two gears that make up a gear set are the same size. When one is larger than the other, either in a lower gear than 1:1 or a higher gear than 1:1, there are frictional losses that translates to less power put to the wheels. Also, too high of a gear that causes the test car to go to a top speed far greater than the available fan cooling capacity will produce invalid results.

http://www.bristoldyno.com/info/procedure.htm

Quote:
Many dynamometer operators go right for the gear that is the closest to a 1:1 ratio as it has the lowest drag in the gearbox and therefore the highest horsepower reading (usually) on a vehicle that is properly sized to be tested on this dyno.


There is dozens more hits that back up that being close to 1:1 is important
Hey, anyone can post anything on the internet, that doesnt mean it is correct.

Here, check out the flat earth society's webpage:

http://www.alaska.net/~clund/e_djubl...rthsociety.htm
FastnxCanada · Jan 10, 2007#63
Oh man! If you would have mentioned this earlier it would have saved some misunderstanding. Instead of thinking you where a moron we would have had proof of it.

Your obviously full of shit, and you thought you could come onto a site and pull the wool over our eyes with your supreme knowledge of all things automotive.
What you failed to realize is that we are not little kids enamored with pictures of "race cars".

Do everyone a favor and buy a Honda Fit
What, are you calling me a liar?
largeorangefontSo Cal, OC · Jan 10, 2007#64
Originally Posted by Fastnx ↑
What, are you calling me a liar?
Hes calling you dumb. So am I.
ChinoCharlesThread starterOH · Jan 10, 2007#65
Originally Posted by Russelt3hPirate ↑
so, you really think that pulley is going to make power to help negate the loss else where in the power band from the improperly design'd header?

wouldn't it make more sense to just buy a header that makes real power instead of trying to cover an open wound with a bandaid?

you're claiming 10hp from a pulley right?
With numbers that were inflated about 25%, the graphs only showed 2 HP and 3 ft/lb losses. Assuming peak HP numbers will drop from 105 HP to around 80 HP after the dyno is fixed, the losses will be minimal... a little more than 1 HP and about 2 ft/lbs.

I don't see that as a huge tradeoff considering...

1) This is still an N/A car, and the 2.5" diameter piping on the Megan header will probably do more for the car with forced induction.
3) After 5600 RPM I'm gaining more than what I'm losing in the rest of the powerband.

Sure, my lofty hopes got shot down a tad. Lesson learned... when dealing with low displacement econoengines, don't expect much from simple bolt-ons.

10 HP from the pulley... I'm not that dumb, haha. Judging from what I've seen from the dyno results from other cars, I think 2-3 HP is a good estimate. Considering the piece is a tad over a hundred bucks and you see that 2-3 HP from 0 to 6500 RPM, I'm happy NST decided to make it.
ChinoCharlesThread starterOH · Jan 10, 2007#66
+8 to the first person that finds out the final drive ratio for the NCP91.
largeorangefontSo Cal, OC · Jan 10, 2007#67
Here are the transmission ratios for the 5MT

Manual five-speed transmission with shift lever on floor,
3.545:1 first gear ratio,
1.904:1 second gear ratio,
1.31:1 third gear ratio,
0.969:1 fourth gear ratio,
0.815:1 fifth gear ratio
3.25:1 reverse gear ratio manual

Final drive ratio, 3.941:1
acrbillchicago · Jan 10, 2007#68
tree'd

1st-3.545:1
2nd-1.904:1
3rd-1.31:1
4th-0.969:1
5th-0.815:1
final drive-3.722:1
reverse-3.25:1
largeorangefontSo Cal, OC · Jan 10, 2007#69
Originally Posted by ChinoCharles ↑
With numbers that were inflated about 25%, the graphs only showed 2 HP and 3 ft/lb losses. Assuming peak HP numbers will drop from 105 HP to around 80 HP after the dyno is fixed, the losses will be minimal... a little more than 1 HP and about 2 ft/lbs.

I don't see that as a huge tradeoff considering...

1) This is still an N/A car, and the 2.5" diameter piping on the Megan header will probably do more for the car with forced induction.
3) After 5600 RPM I'm gaining more than what I'm losing in the rest of the powerband.

Sure, my lofty hopes got shot down a tad. Lesson learned... when dealing with low displacement econoengines, don't expect much from simple bolt-ons.

10 HP from the pulley... I'm not that dumb, haha. Judging from what I've seen from the dyno results from other cars, I think 2-3 HP is a good estimate. Considering the piece is a tad over a hundred bucks and you see that 2-3 HP from 0 to 6500 RPM, I'm happy NST decided to make it.
2.25 piping is going to be the best for this car unless you are going for all out HP or forced induction.
largeorangefontSo Cal, OC · Jan 10, 2007#70
Originally Posted by acrbill ↑
tree'd
final drive-3.722:1
Not saying you are wrong, but we found different final drive #s. I got mine off some canadian site. Where did you get yours? Just want to clear it up so we aren't posting misinformation.

We could figure it out mathamatically I guess but I'm too lazy, and don't have a car to veryify it yet :)
ChinoCharlesThread starterOH · Jan 10, 2007#71
largeorangefont, +8. I don't know what the points means either... you'll have to ask Bigsky2. I got it from him. 😉

To get an idea of how widely these ratios vary, a Cadillac STS-V's final drive ratio is 2.56:1. I wanted to assume most cars had a final drive ratio near 4, but that would obviously be wrong.

Now that we know this, fastnx... what the hell was your original arguement? It seemed like you were trying to say that the idea behind a dyno is to get the engine speed to match wheel speed, but there is no gear on a Yaris that comes even close to this. The closest you will come is in fifth when your ratio is 3.212:1. I'm trying to understand where you were coming from.
largeorangefontSo Cal, OC · Jan 10, 2007#72
Originally Posted by ChinoCharles ↑
largeorangefont, +8. I don't know what the points means either... you'll have to ask Bigsky2. I got it from him. 😉

To get an idea of how widely these ratios vary, a Cadillac STS-V's final drive ratio is 2.56:1. I wanted to assume most cars had a final drive ratio near 4, but that would obviously be wrong.

Now that we know this, fastnx... what the hell was your original arguement? It seemed like you were trying to say that the idea behind a dyno is to get the engine speed to match wheel speed, but there is no gear on a Yaris that comes even close to this. The closest you will come is in fifth when your ratio is 3.212:1. I'm trying to understand where you were coming from.
It depends on the torque of the engine. Smaller displacement cars have gear ratios near 4:1 to get them up to speed better. Consequently, they run at a higher RPM on the highway.

My mustang has a 3.55 final drive, and a 6 speed transmission and at 80 MPH it is doing 2200 RPM. A Xa I test drove was doing well over 3000 RPM approaching 80 MPH.

I will explain more about how a dyno works and how gearing can affect the results after I get some lunch.
ChinoCharlesThread starterOH · Jan 10, 2007#73
Thank you largeorangefont, I'm looking forward to it.
acrbillchicago · Jan 10, 2007#74
largeorangefont,
when I google the transmission ratios I get hit for 3.722:1 and 3.941:1.
Perhaps
largeorangefontSo Cal, OC · Jan 10, 2007#75
Originally Posted by acrbill ↑
largeorangefont,
when I google the transmission ratios I get hit for 3.722:1 and 3.941:1.
Perhaps
If you have access to a tach, get a RPM reading at 80 mph in 5th and we can figure it out. My guess is 3.9.. but I could be wrong.
Russelt3hPirateEpcot · Jan 10, 2007#76
Originally Posted by largeorangefont ↑
If you have access to a tach, get a RPM reading at 80 mph in 5th and we can figure it out. My guess is 3.9.. but I could be wrong.

I has access to a tach :)

Defi Concept HUD in my yaris FTW! 🤘
largeorangefontSo Cal, OC · Jan 10, 2007#77
Ok here is a quick and dirty version of how the dyno figures out horsepower. A dynojet is the simplest, because there is no load. The dyno takes the known weight of the roller(s) and derives hp based on how long it takes the car to get the roller up to speed. So if you have the car in 2nd for example, the roller is going to spin up faster, relative to a 4th gear pull. It is just like doing 30 on the street in 2nd gear vs 4th gear.

In real terms you *should* have the same horsepower either pull, but the curve will be very different looking. Think how the car pulls from 30 mph in 2nd vs. 4th gear, and how that will translate to a HP curve.

Some dynos will measure more horsepower just from switching a lower final drive and some don't. You arent gaing HP, but you are spinning up the roller(s) quicker. You can see how the dyno could then traslate that difference into more HP. I have personally seen this happen, and it is obviously incorrect. Alot of newer dynos are calibrated not to do this, but just be aware that is can happen.

The reason you want to use 3rd or 4th gear on a dyno pull is to put more of a load on the car. For tuning, you want to see what happens with the air fuel ratio and timing high in the load range. Tuning in 1st and 2nd does not give you an accurate picture of how the car will run in higher gears with more load.

Depending on the dyno operator and the car, sometimes shops do their tests in 3rd gear because speeds are too high in 4th on some cars. For seeing gains of a particular part, as long as you can eliminate every variable possible, you should get an accurate picture. Dynos, their calibrations, and HP numbers can vary greatly so it is not valid to compare numbers from dyno to dyno. Just think of the dyno as a tool to check gains. I would always try to go to the same dyno facility, and make sure that all calibrations are as close as possible each time you dyno for the best result.

Hope all this helps.

Ashley
ChinoCharlesThread starterOH · Jan 10, 2007#78
Thank you Ashley, everything makes a bit more sense.

Mustang Dynos apply a small amount of resistance and use that load and not the mass of the roller to determine horsepower. Got it.

Russel, how do you like that HUD? It has to take some getting used to...
largeorangefontSo Cal, OC · Jan 10, 2007#79
Originally Posted by ChinoCharles ↑
Thank you Ashley, everything makes a bit more sense.

Mustang Dynos apply a small amount of resistance and use that load and not the mass of the roller to determine horsepower. Got it.

Russel, how do you like that HUD? It has to take some getting used to...
You got it. A mustang dyno is much better for tuning because you can simulate driving conditions with more realistic loads on the car, and do steady state tuning, That is more effective and accurate than using a Dynojet and doing WOT tuning.
Russelt3hPirateEpcot · Jan 30, 2007#80
Originally Posted by ChinoCharles ↑
Russel, how do you like that HUD? It has to take some getting used to...
I love it. it doesn't take anytime to get used to.

the shift light and audible beep is awesome :)
Chris07LBNew Jersey · Jan 30, 2007#81
Here's some for you... Search for my How_To if you need more info.

4 attachments not included in this copy

Doc ZaiusOttawa, ON, Canada · Feb 1, 2007#82
Alright... I started doing a bit of poking around and reading online as to the relationship between "backpressure" and torque, and why free-flowing headers and exhaust systems can decrease the amount of low/mid torque. People assume that since a more restrictive muffler/header/whatever has higher low-end torque, then it must be because of increased backpressure. Right? Wrong! Its b/c with a smaller diameter exhaust system, the exhaust gasses move faster. These faster moving gasses produce a slight vacuum behind them, which actually helps to pull the remaining exhaust out of the cylinder. This process is known as "scavenging". Otherwise, these gasses would be left in the cylinder, displacing new, fresh air/fuel, and thereby producing less power. As the engine speeds up (higher RPM), the scavenging effect is less pronounced, and the exhaust system's ability to flow gasses makes more of a difference, which is why the megan header works very well at very high rpm.

For some better information on this, please check out the following two very good quick-reads: Exhaust: The straight scoop on backpressure and Exhaust system backpressure. 👍

Any thoughts/comments? 😁
MooseCumming, GA · Feb 21, 2007#83
Originally Posted by Doc Zaius ↑
Alright... I started doing a bit of poking around and reading online as to the relationship between "backpressure" and torque, and why free-flowing headers and exhaust systems can decrease the amount of low/mid torque. People assume that since a more restrictive muffler/header/whatever has higher low-end torque, then it must be because of increased backpressure. Right? Wrong! Its b/c with a smaller diameter exhaust system, the exhaust gasses move faster. These faster moving gasses produce a slight vacuum behind them, which actually helps to pull the remaining exhaust out of the cylinder. This process is known as "scavenging". Otherwise, these gasses would be left in the cylinder, displacing new, fresh air/fuel, and thereby producing less power. As the engine speeds up (higher RPM), the scavenging effect is less pronounced, and the exhaust system's ability to flow gasses makes more of a difference, which is why the megan header works very well at very high rpm.

For some better information on this, please check out the following two very good quick-reads: Exhaust: The straight scoop on backpressure and Exhaust system backpressure. 👍

Any thoughts/comments? 😁
You beat me to it.