Yarisworld Archive

Hmm my water pump failed again!!!! Could it be the pulley?!?!

65 posts · 39,822 views · page 1 of 2

YarisSedanOriginal postCalifornia - Bay Area · Sep 25, 2009#1
So I just had my water pump changed less than a month ago. Now it is failed again. Could it be cause of the NST pulley? Non dampned vibration at high rpm killing the water pump? Cause i do drive my car to redline every single day. I am afraid if i take it back this time they will claim it has to do with my aftermarket parts.

Replies 64

AltitudeColorado · Sep 25, 2009#2
I've had my NST pulley on for about 6 months and 5000 miles. No problems yet. I haven't heard of any other reported problems either. It may have more to do with the abuse (red-lining) you are giving to the engine.
AstromanWenatchee, WA · Sep 25, 2009#3
Probably abuse. I've had my pulley on for over 50k miles and I'm doin fine.
TamagoOff Grid · Sep 25, 2009#4
it's the pulley.
AstromanWenatchee, WA · Sep 25, 2009#5
If that's the case, then why is this the first problem with the water pump with hundreds of thousands (if not a million) miles by everyone using the pulleys? Redlining the crap out of a car is more likely to cause stuff to break than a pulley.
TamagoOff Grid · Sep 25, 2009#6
Originally Posted by Astroman ↑
If that's the case, then why is this the first problem with the water pump with hundreds of thousands (if not a million) miles by everyone using the pulleys? Redlining the crap out of a car is more likely to cause stuff to break than a pulley.
if you say so.



the ratio of water pump failures stock vs pulley tells the tale..
advocatelocation · Sep 25, 2009#7
Originally Posted by Tamago ↑
if you say so.



the ratio of water pump failures stock vs pulley tells the tale..
There are definitely quite a few people who've had water pump failures with the aftermarket pulleys.
AstromanWenatchee, WA · Sep 25, 2009#8
The only water pump issues I've ever had was with the ol' '71 Ford. Any mechanics you could take it to that might be able to chime in? I just find it odd I've put over 50k miles with a full pulley setup on (not overdrive) without issue. Time will tell I suppose.
AstromanWenatchee, WA · Sep 25, 2009#9
What about the ratio of people who redline their engine? Again that is also the other factor. And if the shop didn't install the last one correctly that could lead to premature water pump failure.

It might be worth it to run with the stock pulley for a while too, since they're in there anyway it shouldn't be a big deal.
marcustoronto, canada · Sep 25, 2009#10
belt might be too tight..
supmetSouthern California · Sep 25, 2009#11
lol @ the denial.

Guys... if aftermarket pulleys were a 100% win/win situation, we would have lightened pulleys stock.

Think about it.
TamagoOff Grid · Sep 25, 2009#12
Originally Posted by Astroman ↑
What about the ratio of people who redline their engine? Again that is also the other factor. And if the shop didn't install the last one correctly that could lead to premature water pump failure.
i've redlined my xA every day for 70Xthousand miles and never had a water pump (or any other) failure. stock pullies. redlining has nothing to do with it.
AlexNet0Rockland, ME · Sep 25, 2009#13
Originally Posted by Tamago ↑
i've redlined my xA every day for 70Xthousand miles and never had a water pump (or any other) failure. stock pullies. redlining has nothing to do with it.

^+1

74k miles, redline a lot, stock pullies
supmetSouthern California · Sep 25, 2009#14
Originally Posted by Tamago ↑
i've redlined my xA every day for 70Xthousand miles and never had a water pump (or any other) failure. stock pullies. redlining has nothing to do with it.
trini_performance has beat the hell out of his yaris for 350,000+ miles and is on the original water pump
AstromanWenatchee, WA · Sep 25, 2009#15
72k miles, redline a lot, aftermarket pulleys. 🤘

I'm just saying don't be so quick to blame the pulley. There COULD be other factors.
AstromanWenatchee, WA · Sep 25, 2009#16
Originally Posted by supmet ↑
trini_performance has beat the hell out of his yaris for 350,000+ miles and is on the original water pump
He also has been using an aftermarket pulley since 150k.
posaunemeisterKansas City, MO · Sep 25, 2009#17
The denial comes from ignoring the blatant admission of redlining the car everyday. Redlining DAILY will definitely do some damage under the hood. If your car was designed to cruise at 6/7/8 RPMs, then there wouldn't be a red line, period. I'm sure you've been doing some serious damage to your engine, especially considering that you most likely have stock (economic) internals. I don't see how anyone can argue in favor of redlining and against an aluminum pulley that is only 10% less than the stock pulley in circumference! 🤷
PHXDEMONPhoenix, AZ · Sep 25, 2009#18
I personally think it has to do with installation of the pulley. Check the belt it may be slightly misaligned or too tight.
tk-421Dagobah · Sep 25, 2009#19
I just notified MikeNST about this issue. Hopefully he'll chime in soon. 👍
AltitudeColorado · Sep 25, 2009#20
Maybe we can all agree it is the combination of the pulley or belt too tight and the harsh driving?
1NZYaris1New Zealand · Sep 25, 2009#21
Originally Posted by Tamago ↑
if you say so.



the ratio of water pump failures stock vs pulley tells the tale..

Could it be due to people over tightenning the BELTS
👍
rhino5Troy, PA · Sep 25, 2009#22
Just a lightweight pulley or an underdrive pulley?

Pulley driven water pumps are really that mysterious, mechanically there's not much to fail. I'd blame shitty casting or belt tension before blaming pulley ratios.
YarisSedanThread starterCalifornia - Bay Area · Sep 25, 2009#23
Well to me it just seems very strange within a month the water pump failed. And my original water pump did not fail until after the pulley was installed as well. When i changed the pulley i marked the altenator position with a white out so that it was isntaleld in the exact same position as factory. I am going to go check the tightness of the belt after the water pump was instaleld by the dealer. If it was put on way to tight and compounded with how i drive i would say that would be the cause this time. Or a combination of the pulley and overtightend.
severous01SE Texas · Sep 25, 2009#24
does the oem pulley have a rubber ring in it? a dampner?

if it is, then the NST doesnt have a dampner. every time the pulley hits TDC or BDC you're slamming the pulleys on all devices and as the pulley rotates towards bdc or tdc the pulleys are slowing down. that's what the dampner does....dampen the force of the engine 'bang' to equalize throughout the rotation.
YarisSedanThread starterCalifornia - Bay Area · Sep 25, 2009#25
Yeah the factory one has a rubber one in the middle.
severous01SE Texas · Sep 25, 2009#26
there's your problem. the nst pulley is not a dampner. it's just a pulley.

the rubber ring flexes on the bang and flexes back on compression. so................................................ .................................................. .................................................. ......

deal is, the pulleys are actually moving forward and backwards at an extreme rate and that's not designed to do it. the dampner stops it and prevents the bearings from slamming forward and back.
fmicleSan Jose, CA, USA · Sep 25, 2009#27
Originally Posted by Tamago ↑
the ratio of water pump failures stock vs pulley tells the tale..
I beg to differ. This is a typical mistake people make, just because there is a correlation between A and B it doesn't mean A caused B or vice versa.

Let me explain with an example: studies show that households with more books have smarter kids (correlation between books and kids), so a mayor in Illinois thought he'll simply give away free books and make kids smarter. Needless to say, the plan didn't work. Because it's not the number of books that cause the kids to be smart, it's their parents' education, status, emphasis on school, etc. And those families are likely to have more books to begin with. So, there is another parameter C that causes both A and B to go together.

Back to our situation: people with aftermarket pulleys have more water pump failures than the ones driving stock (that's the correlation). So some people incorrectly infer that the pulleys must cause the failure.

Imagine this: people who install aftermarket parts and tune their cars are more likely to drive their cars more aggressively, therefore putting more stress on their parts than those driving stock (grandma, grandpa, uncle Jimmy).

Just remember the basic principle: correlation does not imply causation. For more details check it out on Wikipedia: Correlation does not imply causation
PHXDEMONPhoenix, AZ · Sep 26, 2009#28
Originally Posted by fmicle ↑
I beg to differ. This is a typical mistake people make, just because there is a correlation between A and B it doesn't mean A caused B or vice versa.

Let me explain with an example: studies show that households with more books have smarter kids (correlation between books and kids), so a mayor in Illinois thought he'll simply give away free books and make kids smarter. Needless to say, the plan didn't work. Because it's not the number of books that cause the kids to be smart, it's their parents' education, status, emphasis on school, etc. And those families are likely to have more books to begin with. So, there is another parameter C that causes both A and B to go together.

Back to our situation: people with aftermarket pulleys have more water pump failures than the ones driving stock (that's the correlation). So some people incorrectly infer that the pulleys must cause the failure.

Imagine this: people who install aftermarket parts and tune their cars are more likely to drive their cars more aggressively, therefore putting more stress on their parts than those driving stock (grandma, grandpa, uncle Jimmy).

Just remember the basic principle: correlation does not imply causation. For more details check it out on Wikipedia: Correlation does not imply causation
Wisdom
YarisSedanThread starterCalifornia - Bay Area · Sep 26, 2009#29
Yeah but even a car driven agreesively shouldnt have parts like this failing at such a early stage. Maybe at higher milage i could understand but this is just unacceptable.

My 89 acura legend with 200k miles was a tank. I drove it like i stole it for 4 years and never gave me any problems. Only thing major was the altenator that went out once and i attribute that to my high powered stereo system.

And this a toyota which is supose to be better than honda is having problems like this at such a early stage seems unacceptable to me. So even if i put the factory pulley back on and still drive the car aggresively that means i will be having to change my water pump every single year?!?

I know its a econo car but come on.
eddyvancouver canada · Sep 26, 2009#30
just wondering what is this other pulley you are all talking about.?
JohnnoEHCoffs Australia · Sep 26, 2009#31
Originally Posted by fmicle ↑
I beg to differ. This is a typical mistake people make, just because there is a correlation between A and B it doesn't mean A caused B or vice versa.

There is another parameter C that causes both A and B to go together.

Back to our situation: people with aftermarket pulleys have more water pump failures than the ones driving stock (that's the correlation). So some people incorrectly infer that the pulleys must cause the failure.

Imagine this: people who install aftermarket parts and tune their cars are more likely to drive their cars more aggressively, therefore putting more stress on their parts than those driving stock (grandma, grandpa, uncle Jimmy).
I was going to write pretty much exactly this, but you beat me to it. 👍 So many people jump to quick conclusions without looking at the whole picture.

Originally Posted by severous01 ↑
does the oem pulley have a rubber ring in it? a dampner?

if it is, then the NST doesnt have a dampner. every time the pulley hits TDC or BDC you're slamming the pulleys on all devices and as the pulley rotates towards bdc or tdc the pulleys are slowing down. that's what the dampner does....dampen the force of the engine 'bang' to equalize throughout the rotation.
Having said the above, this could be the source of the problem; especially when combined with the more likely/frequent hard driving that a modded car will receive.
thebarberGrand Rapids, MI · Sep 26, 2009#32
undampended pullies eat water pumps....ask anyone w/ a 2zzge..
rhino5Troy, PA · Sep 26, 2009#33
Originally Posted by thebarber ↑
undampended pullies eat water pumps....ask anyone w/ a 2zzge..
I find it hard to swallow that the small change in ability to dampen on the crank pulley with a rubber belt driven system could destroy a waterpump so easily. If I was ambitious I'd look up what the flex per foot of our serpentine belt has and I'd be surprised if it was so ridged that it wouldn't absorb some of this "destructive" torque/vibration.

Not saying that is without a doubt the problem, but I'd be leery that it's the new pulley.
lilredrocketDFW, Texas · Sep 26, 2009#34
Could it also be that you got a faulty part?
rhino5Troy, PA · Sep 26, 2009#35
Originally Posted by lilredrocket ↑
Could it also be that you got a faulty part?
I mentioned this before. Casting metals yields a relatively high chance of poor quality.
fmicleSan Jose, CA, USA · Sep 26, 2009#36
Originally Posted by YarisSedan ↑
Yeah but even a car driven agreesively shouldnt have parts like this failing at such a early stage. Maybe at higher milage i could understand but this is just unacceptable.

My 89 acura legend with 200k miles was a tank. I drove it like i stole it for 4 years and never gave me any problems. Only thing major was the altenator that went out once and i attribute that to my high powered stereo system.

And this a toyota which is supose to be better than honda is having problems like this at such a early stage seems unacceptable to me. So even if i put the factory pulley back on and still drive the car aggresively that means i will be having to change my water pump every single year?!?

I know its a econo car but come on.
I hear you man, I hear you, and I agree it's unacceptable...
YarisSedanThread starterCalifornia - Bay Area · Sep 26, 2009#37
Okay so i went out this morning to check the tightness of the belt. When i installed the pulley before i marked the position of the altenator with white out. So the tightness of the belt is the same as the factory installed when i was done. So assume from factory it was isntalled with the correct tightness that would not be the culprit of the original water pump failure.

I have put on about 1k miles since it was repaired previousely after the just put in a new water pump and failed again. This time i look at it the mark i made is still there and it is tighter than what is marked. I did the pinch test and the belt is pretty tight. Not insanely tight but is tighter than it should. So i would attribute the undamped pulley compounded with the overtightend belt causing it to fail much more rapidly this time.

To me that can be the only explination. I have a feeling if the factory pulley was ont he even with a overtightend belt it woudlnt have failed at 1k miles. But more like 50k or later.

I do know overtightend belts cause things such as bearings to faull preamaturely but not at only 1 month after it has been done. Unless superman was doing work on the car and there was no belt deflection at all then even then within amonth still seems kinda fast.
AltitudeColorado · Sep 26, 2009#38
Do you know if your replacement pump was new or refurbished?
severous01SE Texas · Sep 27, 2009#39
is there anything on a EWP? electrics are very reliable, and dont leak nearly as much. and with modern electronix, they last a lot longer. mezerie has one that's boasting 40k hours before it fails. that's like 500k miles unless you're idling all the time. even then if it's tied into the fan relay it'll only come on with the fans.

any way, we got elec power steering, why not water pump?
lilredrocketDFW, Texas · Sep 27, 2009#40
Garm has an EWP on his setup
ROCKLAND TOYOTAROCKLAND COUNTY NY · Sep 28, 2009#42
LOL at the all the different excuses as to WHY. ive got 18,500 redlined miles on my pulley and OEM water pump which was installed by a toyota tech.

FYI, ive had more than a few STOCK yari come in here needing a water pump and TOYOTA is aware of a problem which is not to say that OVERTIGHTENING isn't a problem either......
TamagoOff Grid · Sep 28, 2009#43
regardless if "improper installation" or the pulley itself caused the failure, the mere fact that you "fixed" something that wasn't broken in the first place (which in itself broke) is the deciding factor.

18 year old kids are most likely to die sooner if they ride motorcycles

but does that mean that the motorcycle is to blame?

no.

see what i'm talkin about?
YarisSedanThread starterCalifornia - Bay Area · Sep 28, 2009#44
Yeah I get what your saying. Either way i think i am going to put the factory pulley back on atleast for the time being. I am giong to try to bring my car in on my day off this week. I know more than likely since they just changed it they are going to look for a reason as why it just failed. And the mechanic wont want to take responsibility. They didnt notice the pulley last time or atleast didnt note it down. I think cause i got the greish colored one not a bright red one. But if i bring it in again and leave that on they are going to not warrenty it again.

Even if i try to take it to another toyota dealership they will be able to check national database for submitted warrentys for this car i would assume. So better safe than sorry.
NonStopTuningUSA · Sep 28, 2009#45
I'm sorry to hear about your troubles YarisSedan, and I am glad to hear that you are trying to find a logical reason and solution for your problem. It is often easier to point the finger at an aftermarket item than try to find the real problem and solution.

We have literally sold THOUSANDS of crank, alternator, and water pump pulleys. I think it is a testament to the quality of our product when I say that 99.99% of our customers have never had any water pump (or any other) problems to speak of. This includes Toyota, Scion, Lotus, Honda, Nissan, VW, etc.

As ROCKLAND TOYOTA stated, I have also heard of a couple of local Yarii going in for service with their stock pulleys. To add to this, I have also heard of some of the new Civics and Scions, having similar problems. All of the cars I have seen locally with this issue have had the problem covered under warranty... which should tell you something in, and of, itself.

Again, I am sincerely sorry to hear about your troubles, but I don't think everyone else should go into a state of panic over a few isolated incidents... especially when there have been hundreds if not thousands of positive reviews the other way.

Thanks again, good luck and have fun with all your projects!
TamagoOff Grid · Sep 28, 2009#46
i'm not saying you don't build quality (in this case, really, "within tolerance" parts) my statement is pointed toward what we call bleeding edge parts. bleeding edge performance parts that are installed BEFORE other mods tend to cause issues, simply because the owner is not on the same mental level as the typical bleeding edge driver. for instance, lexan windows in an otherwise stock (yes lol, this is going on right now as we speak, here on yarisworld) yaris is simply stupid. a person doing bleeding edge mods such as aftermarket lightweight pullies, to eek out as much power as possible, should be willing to accept and compensate for damages caused by said product, due to extra shock on the pulley system itself, caused by the lack of dampening.
NonStopTuningUSA · Sep 28, 2009#47
Disclosing our great success rate with over 100 different pulleys for Hondas, Nissans, Toyotas, Lotus, Scion, VW, etc. should tell you quite a bit about our past and our products.

If you look through the different forums where our products are popular, you will find thousands of customer reviews, all of which have been positive. Further, you will find discussions like the one I am going to copy and paste for you here....


This one deserves an entire book, but here goes...

Q. Will NST Pulleys lead to premature engine failure?

I cover this topic at least several times a month but I don't mind, I understand that your cars are a very large investment for all of you and I prefer that you be intelligent and informed about all your modifications. So here we go again... Please take a few minutes to read everything I have posted here, as I worked hard on trying to give you a good explanation on the topic...

In the past many engines were externally balanced. There was an external balancer attached to the outside of the engine, on the crank snout, used to balance the engine externally. The crank pulley in such engines would then be attached to this balancer. Removal of this balancer is a bad idea. These balancers were most often used on large (6 to V shaped engines of the domestic muscle car era.

Take a look at any modern (1980s and beyond) Honda, Toyota, Nissan, or other japanese inline 4 and you will find no such balancer. These engines are all internally balanced, and this process has improved even further since the late 1990s. So the topic of a BALANCER does not apply here.

What you will find on many modern engines is a harmonic damper. This is a small rubber band, litterally less than 2mm, less than 1/8th of an inch, thick that is built into the crank pulley. OEM crank pulleys are often called DAMPERS. Try placing an order for a crank pulley at your dealer and your invoice will read damper. This rubber is used to absorb something called NVH, noise/vibration/harshness. Suffice it to say, this rubber is actually not very good at performing its intended purpose after as little as a few thousand miles. What happens to rubber after a couple years of humidity, weather, snow, rain, etc? It often becomes brittle, hard, and crunchy. Can something with these properties actually absorb vibrations very well?

Many many NST customers, including people on your own forums, have reported smoother running engines with NST pulleys. Especially at idle. How is this possible if the rubber is such a vital and super important piece??? Perhaps the rubber is not as important as it is cracked up to be???


Furthermore....


On the topic of the rubber damper, engine vibrations, or possible threats resulting from elimination of this rubber piece...

On a relatively understressed near stock motor with bolt ons or low amounts of boost like what most of the people on this forum probably run, a solid pulley will not have any life threatening consiquences. The factory pulley with a 2mm (less than a 1/8th inch) damper is primarily there for wide band NVH (noise vibration harshness) supression from the engine and driveline. Removing the damper and replacing it with a solid pulley may lead to minor addtional NVH but will not harm the engine. In fact, most people claim their engines seem to run smoother with NST pulleys.

The engineering reasons are that most modern engines have a short, strong crank with, a relatively high natural frequency. The dangerous second harmonic that can cause damage occurs at an rpm that this sort of engine will never see, in the area above 10,000 rpm. Even the stock damper is not tuned for attinuation at this sort of rpm so the argument is somewhat of a moot point.

Now weak engines that are pushing the limit with LOTS of revs, wimpy cranks, super long strokes, lots of boost and dwelling in the upper rpm ranges for long periods of time can benefit from a damper designed to deal with this sort of operation but our engine is not like this, and probably very few people with this motor on this forum push the envelope that hard. How many 2.0 Liter, 500HP, 12,000RPM motors do we have on these forums?

As far as I can tell, our engine has a strong and stiff bottom end that is well built for our intended use. It has an internaly balanced crankshaft which is less like to break due to torsional vibration.

There are a lot of Honda, Toyota, and Nissan guys who use underdrive crank pulleys in road racing series like NASA or SCCA. Road racing is much more punishing on an engine than other motorsports. The engine is subjected to run times lasting roughly 30 minutes with the engine always in the upper ranges of its rpm limit. One race weekend is the equivlent of hundreds of 1/4 mile passes. These guys would not use NST pulleys if they were not reliable.

NST sponsors the first ever wheel to wheel Scion tC NASA Road Race car. The same car is also very competitive in the Grand Am series and has factory backing from Toyota, Scion, and TRD. This car has been using pulleys from NST with great results since day one.

NST has sponsored several drift cars participating in the professional drift series, Fromula Drift, and the D1 Grand Prix USA. Several of our cars have also competed in the NOPI and Pro AM Drift series. To make things better, NST products are also used in autocross, time attack, and drag cars. These cars have been using NST pulleys with no issues of any kind for the past few seasons.

We could go on and on...

Is a solid crank pulley harmless to all engines? No it is not. As I said... small, super high reving engines, when modified way past the simple bolt on stages may have problems. These engines reach critcal harmonics, past the 10,000 rpm range, an rpm only reached by certain RACE engines.

A mildly modded inline six will most likely be fine but one subjected to high rpm (7500) for long periods of time (90% of its life) with lots of boost (500+hp) will probably suffer. In this case , the stock pulley/damper is probably not adequate either.

Some of the older american V8 engines are externaly balanced and it is critical not to use a solid hub pulley not designed for these applications, or damage to the engine could result. You will not find solid NST pulleys on our website for such engines.

Our engines and most around here do not fall into the above catagories. Rest assured that your engines will not blow up and die or have a reduced life in street and even racing use with these parts.

I would bet that every "expert" that tells you otherwise has little personal, practical, real world experience with the subject; as it applies in your case.

Again, I understand that your cars are a very large investment and that you depend on them as your daily means of transportation, so I do not take your questions personally. But please... do a search through the links I have provided for you and you will find nothing but positive feedback from realworld customers.

Good luck and have fun with all your projects!
mikenacaratoBrentwood, TN · Sep 28, 2009#48
for the record...i have been on quite a few road courses with my yaris and i do drive the crap out of it...i also drive the car daily and drive it hard...i have over 25000 miles on my nst pulleys and they have yet to cause an issue. my guess is someone didnt tension the belt properly and overtensioned it.
hatchbackkid82. · Sep 29, 2009#49
no problems here.
cali yarisCanoga Park, CA · Sep 29, 2009#50
if aftermarket pulleys were a 100% win/win situation, we would have lightened pulleys stock.
No, this logic is faulty. That would make the car more expensive. Like including a center console and so many other features we like so much on the cars.

Isn't a center console a win/win? But it's not on there, is it? Lots of parts that would improve the car in various ways aren't on there.

They designed and built a $12000 car.