Yarisworld Archive

Hmm my water pump failed again!!!! Could it be the pulley?!?!

65 posts · 39,822 views · page 2 of 2

Replies continued

ozmddDFW, TX · Sep 29, 2009#51
Garm is correct -lots of stuff on the Yaris that isn't produced at the highest-possible engineering or efficiency. Its almost always a cost-benefit relationship, with the "benefit" portion being biased towards the level of performance that will please the average consumer.

Take the rear sway bar - the car was designed to have one, but is produced without one to save $$. It's almost inarguable that the rear sway is a win-win item.

I think a lot of folks here ought to have more knowledge/facts before they knock a product that clearly has a lot of R&D behind it, especially a small company that is trying to produce small-batch products for a market that isn't catered-to by very many manufacturers.
Speculating that the NST pulleys cause or contribute to water pump failure is damaging to the company's reputation, even when there is no direct evidence to support that speculation.
If you don't KNOW something, don't comment as if you do. Good engineers don't link cause-and-effect to anecdotal relationships, like many of the nay-sayers have done on this issue.
supmetSouthern California · Sep 29, 2009#52
Originally Posted by cali yaris ↑
No, this logic is faulty. That would make the car more expensive. Like including a center console and so many other features we like so much on the cars.

Isn't a center console a win/win? But it's not on there, is it? Lots of parts that would improve the car in various ways aren't on there.

They designed and built a $12000 car.
Originally Posted by camelll ↑
NST said that the damper is for NVH for the driver and to eliminate cabin noise! Toyota was not thinking about cabin noise on a 12,000 dollar vehicle, show me anywhere else on the car the were concerned with cabin noise.

Please explain to me how making a solid crank pulley is more expensive than making a 2 piece? Even NST will attest that a 2 piece is more expensive to make.
camelll's two points pretty much show where my logic was going, and I don't think its faulty.

Whatever though, I don't think there is enough evidence to say one way or the other. I'm just a little tired of everyone on the forum saying 99% of mods do no damage to cars, and even if they do, the magnusson moss act will be there to protect you.

Everyone I've talked to in real life with modded cars has a completely opposite philosophy, which is you gotta pay to play. That philosophy seems a lot more inline with the way the rest of the world works. Nothing is free. Your car was engineered for stock parts, and that's it. Any aftermarket part has risks involved, and I feel there is more than a little smoke being blown around here.
advocatelocation · Sep 29, 2009#53
The way I see it is this: The percentage of people who are on YarisWorld is a very small percentage of actual yaris owners. If there's bad water pumps in a significant amount of yarii, then the percentage of all yarii with bad water pumps on yarisworld will reflect the percentage of all total yarii with bad water pumps as well.

This fact alone doesn't mean much but there's also something very important to consider and that's that your average YarisWorld member is much much more likely to have aftermarket products installed and be aware of their engine's health than the average Yaris owner.

Since the pulley is such a popular mod, and modders are likely to post about when their water pump fails, this might lead one to think that the pulleys are what is causing the water pump to fail.

In the end it's all about perception. In this thread alone we don't have good representation of all of the Yarii out there who have had bad water pumps without mods. All we see are people with average to lots of mods, many of those use the NST pulley, and all of them have a very high chance of posting about their pump when it fails giving the overall impression that the pulley must be causing the pump to fail.

As far as my personal opinion goes I can't say one way or the other because I don't know anything about cars and I don't have the light weight pulleys installed but I do know about statistics and this is certainly a case where it's important to remember how much of a small fraction of the population this is: Yarii owners -> Yarii owners on YarisWorld -> Yarii owners on YarisWorld with mods -> Yarii owners on YarisWorld with mods and the pulley installed.

Just to reiterate: I'm not saying the pulley won't sometimes break, or never will contribute to a water pump break. I'm just trying to point out that when drawing generalized conclusions it's important to take into consideration whether or not the cases you're drawing your conclusion from represent an accurate average of ALL THE TOTAL cases. Mike @ NST is arguing that these isolated cases don't in fact reflect the true average or experience of all the total people who use NST pulleys and I'm inclined to agree.
AstromanWenatchee, WA · Sep 29, 2009#54
A great post but... what does the harmonic balancer and a failed water pump after a month have to do with one another? The most likely culprit is a defective water pump or improper installation.
curikIndonesia · Sep 30, 2009#55
Originally Posted by YarisSedan ↑
So I just had my water pump changed less than a month ago. Now it is failed again. Could it be cause of the NST pulley? Non dampned vibration at high rpm killing the water pump? Cause i do drive my car to redline every single day. I am afraid if i take it back this time they will claim it has to do with my aftermarket parts.
Do you mind if I ask you these questions?
-When did you install the NST pulley?
-When did the 1st water pump failure happen? (1000 miles after??)
-Do you think you know how the water pump failed? (leaking, grinding, etc)

I hope this will help everyone here to understand more about the situation. I have browsed through the pages but didn't find anything about the cause of failure of the water pump.
AstromanWenatchee, WA · Sep 30, 2009#56
and STILL no good answer of why the water pump failed. 🙄
ddongbaphay · Sep 30, 2009#57
The pulley to water pump failure isn't limited to Toyota. Honda has the same problem too, with after-market stuff.
YarisSedanThread starterCalifornia - Bay Area · Sep 30, 2009#58
Originally Posted by curik ↑
Do you mind if I ask you these questions?
-When did you install the NST pulley?
-When did the 1st water pump failure happen? (1000 miles after??)
-Do you think you know how the water pump failed? (leaking, grinding, etc)

I hope this will help everyone here to understand more about the situation. I have browsed through the pages but didn't find anything about the cause of failure of the water pump.
Okay I installed my NST pulley on my car had about 12k or so miles on it. I installed everything correctly as well as made sure the belt was not overtightend. I actually marked the position of the altenator before i loosend it with white out and double check the belt tightness after the work was done. At about 18k the water pump failed. Brought it to dealer and they replaced. I know it was leaking cause of the white spots on my driveway and the pink residue on my hood and everywhere else. I clean my engine bay once a month so this is when i really noticed it. It could have been leaking for awile but didnt get bad enough till then.

Then few weeks later about 19k i went to clean my engine bay again i noticed same thing. Not as bad as before but a bit of residue. Also my coolant resivoire is low as well. This time though the belt was overtightend slightly.

I know these toyotas do have issues from the getgo with thier water pumps. Just today a 2003 corolla and 2005 camry came into my shop for a oil change and they both had leaking water pumps. Seems to be maybe one of those "manufactured defects".

I think the fact that i drive agreesively and maybe the NST may have been a contributing factor to the premature failure. But its hard to say. To me it seems like too much of a coincidence. I think even if i didnt have the pulley it would still fail because the fact the parts are problematic from the beginning. I just think that its a possibility it may have accelerated the inevatable.

I am not tryign to stay i believe the reason for my failed water pumps are soley the cause. If you look at the title or my original post there are question marks not a period.
lilredrocketDFW, Texas · Sep 30, 2009#59
Originally Posted by camelll ↑
Again not a good answer. But wait no defending NST, what would you say if he puts his stock pulley on and does not go through another water pump? Then what if he puts the crank pulley back on and goes through a water pump? You still gonna be defending NST?

Hey man not to flame you or what you are trying to do here. You have posted up good info and have defended with examples but the above quote made me think can anyone tell the future? And know that after he puts the pulley back on that it is not the pulley and that is when the w/p was going to fail anyways. Not trying to defend any one party here. Everyone has posted valid points supporting both sides here. So lets stop the personal attacks and leave it at the info you posted and know that someone will come across read you info and make and educated decision.
AstromanWenatchee, WA · Sep 30, 2009#60
I know you didn't come out of the gate, it was someone else who did. I didn't mean for my posts to be towards you, and wanted to share I've had 50k+ trouble free miles with my setup.

Debate is good 👍
tk-421Dagobah · Sep 30, 2009#61
This thread is based on pure speculation. Let's stop yammering at each other until we have more actual information to share. Sound good?
AstromanWenatchee, WA · Sep 30, 2009#62
Yay! I'll try to post more clearly n stuff, I can see where things like these can get out of wack. 😁 It will be interesting to see what the shop is going to say after all this speculation and theory.
talcumWI · Oct 5, 2009#63
So is the Yaris engine like my '89 Camry where when the water pump failed it leaked on the timing belt and caused it to delaminate and fail? On the Camry one didn't take a chance on letting the pump fail.

-bob
lilredrocketDFW, Texas · Oct 5, 2009#64
It's not thing like that
ozmddDFW, TX · Oct 5, 2009#65
I like cheese.