Bob DogOriginal postthe Boondocks, NC · Jul 31, 2009#1New Yaris before Cash for Clunkers $13,500
New Yaris after Cash for Clunkers $9500 +1 POS
Used Yaris before Cash for Clunkers $9500
Used Yaris after Cash for Clunkers $6000-$7500 ?
and I was dumb enough to think the big screw might be over when the Repulicans left the white house FTS
Replies 82
BailOutReno, Nevada, USA · Jul 31, 2009#2While I'm all for getting gas guzzlers off the road I know that is a secondary benefit here, while the primary goal is nothing but a further bailout for the U.S. auto industry, who I never wanted to see bailed out in the first place.
As for the politics of it, meh. Every Presidency in our history has made some stinky decisions. I see no reason why that should just up and stop all of a sudden.
Bob DogThread starterthe Boondocks, NC · Jul 31, 2009#3Exactly: Optimism is as usual rewarded by a good swift kick in the butt....
GeneWPennsylvania · Jul 31, 2009#4 Originally Posted by
Bob Dog ↑ Exactly: Optimism is as usual rewarded by a good swift kick in the butt....
I dunno... you get more things done being optimistic than pessimistic.
That being said, I still have a gigantic ghetto cruiser which the EPA says isn't a "clunker" because back in 1985 it got better than fifteen miles to the gallon.
Gene
GeneWPennsylvania · Jul 31, 2009#5 Originally Posted by
Bob Dog ↑ I was dumb enough to think the big screw might be over when the Repulicans left the white house FTS
"Cash for Clunkers" is an ice cream cone and a peck on the cheek compared to the full blown luvin' you're gonna get from the Crony Capitalism of Cap 'n Rape (backed by GE and other Corporate giants) and "Health Care" (backed by the AMA).
Gene
tomatoSan Francisco Bay Area · Jul 31, 2009#6You guys ought to move that thread to the off topic discussion, I think.
Health care: do you really like the idea that millions of Americans everywhere can't afford health insurance right now? Some can, but insurances will turn them down based on pre-existing conditions. What are they supposed to do? Here in California, a simple doctor's visit (consult, 15 minutes at MOST) is $184. That's not some fancy visit in some fancy place, believe me.
Is it fair that people who have worked all their lives and saved every penny should go bankrupt when someone gets, let's say cancer? IDK, something sure needs to be done. I don't trust the government anymore than the next guy, but a little bit of regulation to make sure prices don't skyrocket might be a good idea. Look at the price of prescription drugs for instance, I mean that is completely out of hand. Many of these drugs (which Seniors require) are long out of R&D, and shouldn't be priced that high. The tax payer is footing the bill 🤷 Maybe I should just shut up because the health care situation just puts me in a bad mood. Anyway, think about it, even if you voted Republican and hate the very thought of any government involvment. Just think about it, OK? Health care as it is now in the US is no care at all for the majority of people. It is a disgrace, if you ask me.
tuckevalastinDelaware/Connecticut · Jul 31, 2009#7Cash for Clunkers is most certainly benefiting Asian carmakers more than the US automakers. The regulations of the program pretty much ensure that. Not only are people using this program to buy Asian cars now but those Asian cars will last 5-10 years at least meaning those people won't even need to consider buying American for 5-10 years. IMO it would have been much more beneficial to make this program actually benefit the US auto industry, at least then it would benefit something our government has already invested heavily in.
The program appears to be about 80% show and 20% go. The one upside is that it has managed to bring 250,000 buyers into dealerships this week. The list of downsides is very long.
tomatoSan Francisco Bay Area · Jul 31, 2009#8 Originally Posted by tuckevalastin ↑
what exactly has D done for me?
Too soon to tell.
2+2Michigan · Jul 31, 2009#9 Originally Posted by tuckevalastin ↑
what exactly has D done for me?
At the end of the New Deal (1968) a single wage earner could support a family. At the end of the Reagan Revolution it takes 2 wage earners and sometimes that's not enough.
The new administration has a tremendous pile of shiit to clean up. I think we should give em a little time - it took 40 years to get us this screwed, I think it's going to take a few years to get us less screwed.
Bob DogThread starterthe Boondocks, NC · Jul 31, 2009#106 months after the inception of a major illness, 60% of families no longer have healthcare insurance. Modern health care insurance is a grand scale scam at least on the level of the mortgage and the banking scandals. It is structured by actuaries to never pay off. The only ones who can afford keep the stuff in event of serious illness are the wealthy, so it ends up everyone else is subsidising the healthcare of the rich with their payments before their insurance was terminated.
tuckevalastinDelaware/Connecticut · Jul 31, 2009#11No sense in moving it to off topic... political threads only make it a few hours before getting so heated that they are locked anyway 😁
Bob DogThread starterthe Boondocks, NC · Jul 31, 2009#12It looks to me like all the base prices for vehicles have been knocked up so what it really amounts to is that the incentive is going to the dealers and manufacturers and not to the people buying the vehicles.
tomatoSan Francisco Bay Area · Jul 31, 2009#13 Originally Posted by
tuckevalastin ↑ No sense in moving it to off topic... political threads only make it a few hours before getting so heated that they are locked anyway 😁
You're right. That's why I deleted my rant about the R admin, but I'll sneak this one in before we get locked: I agree wholeheartedly with 2+2.
Just give the guy a little time, will ya? It rattles my cage when I hear people blame the guy already because he's implemented such or such program. I wasn't happy about the bailout either (although if you recall the first bailout was b/f November)., eh, I hear ya, believe me (I pay my bills and try to live within my means, so, why should I be penalized because other dudes bought houses they couldn't afford in the first place with 0 down). But last year, we were on the brink of a major financial disaster and now, things are somewhat stabilized. So let give it a little time and see what happens, I guess that's all I'm trying to say.
Peace.
tomatoSan Francisco Bay Area · Jul 31, 2009#14 Originally Posted by
Bob Dog ↑ It looks to me like all the base prices for vehicles have been knocked up so what it really amounts to is that the incentive is going to the dealers and manufacturers and not to the people buying the vehicles.
Well, that's a good point, too.
tuckevalastinDelaware/Connecticut · Jul 31, 2009#15I've often wondered how many people trade in cars that they could have gotten $4500 for as a trade in anyway. In those cases I bet the dealer wishes they could just have the car traded in so they can resell it and make a little extra profit
ShroomsterOrlando · Jul 31, 2009#16 Originally Posted by
tuckevalastin ↑ Cash for Clunkers is most certainly benefiting Asian carmakers more than the US automakers. The regulations of the program pretty much ensure that. Not only are people using this program to buy Asian cars now but those Asian cars will last 5-10 years at least meaning those people won't even need to consider buying American for 5-10 years. IMO it would have been much more beneficial to make this program actually benefit the US auto industry, at least then it would benefit something our government has already invested heavily in.
The program appears to be about 80% show and 20% go. The one upside is that it has managed to bring 250,000 buyers into dealerships this week. The list of downsides is very long.
they may be based out of japan, korea, wherever, but check out the number of plants (thats manufacturing plants) and offices they now own and operate here in the states, mexico and canada.
besides china holds most of our U.S debt. <<<off topic but ya know.
tuckevalastinDelaware/Connecticut · Jul 31, 2009#17 Originally Posted by
Shroomster ↑ they may be based out of japan, korea, wherever, but check out the number of plants (thats manufacturing plants) and offices they now own and operate here in the states, mexico and canada.
besides china holds most of our U.S debt. <<<off topic but ya know.
I know the number of plants and offices in N.America (both Import and Domestic) and that doesn't change a thing in my opinion.
tuckevalastinDelaware/Connecticut · Jul 31, 2009#18 You're right. That's why I deleted my rant about the R admin, but I'll sneak this one in before we get locked: I agree wholeheartedly with 2+2.
I'll delete my D response too in the interest of the discussion of the Cash for Clunkers program and not all around politics.
supmetSouthern California · Aug 1, 2009#19Ya, hopefully it will go bankrupt before it hits the used car business too bad. A couple months from now people should still pay 9-10k for a good used yaris. If you're in the market to sell in the next week or month, you might be in trouble.
eric81Clarksville, IN · Aug 1, 2009#20 Originally Posted by
tuckevalastin ↑ Cash for Clunkers is most certainly benefiting Asian carmakers more than the US automakers. The regulations of the program pretty much ensure that. Not only are people using this program to buy Asian cars now but those Asian cars will last 5-10 years at least meaning those people won't even need to consider buying American for 5-10 years. IMO it would have been much more beneficial to make this program actually benefit the US auto industry, at least then it would benefit something our government has already invested heavily in.
The program appears to be about 80% show and 20% go. The one upside is that it has managed to bring 250,000 buyers into dealerships this week. The list of downsides is very long.
Did you know that there are more Toyota's made in the US by US citizens then there are Toyota's coming in from Japan? And that Toyota has 4 of the top 10 americanized vehicles? Including the number one spot with the Camry? Yeah, the Camry beat out every other car in the US, including Fords, GM's, Chevy's, Pontiac's, Chrystler's, Jeeps, and Dodge's. How is this not helping the US? Maybe they should take a page out of Toyota's book and start building efficient, reliable cars. That's just my opinion though. Oh, wait, it's not my opinion. It's facts. Do your research.
eric81Clarksville, IN · Aug 1, 2009#21Okay, FYI. Cash for clunkers is NOT helping dealerships like you think it is. The government put up rules so we can't adjust the prices to help us out any. However, it is causing us to have a lot of business, so we are happy about that. More cars sold means more money made.
Now, as for the vehicles that qualify, and all the work we have to do to find out if it does qualify, filling out paperwork, and then having to actually lose money off the top, the government is still making their money, because they tax you BEFORE the $3,500 or $4,500 rebate, but we only get paid on the after rebate price, so they are just helping fuel themselves.
And I do agree that they are taking some nicer and well kept vehicles and parts off the road. Also, I believe they should have made the MPG a little higher, because 18 is REALLY hard to do. I have had SEVERAL customers that get 16 average or less, but the website says 19 or 20, so they miss out and have to keep driving their clunker. It is helping out some people, but not everyone it should.
enobmort42Denver, CO · Aug 1, 2009#22my old 96 escort wasn't eligible for the clunkers thing, so i sold it on craigslist. had it been, i would have given it to my brother to get him started with a good car..
Bob DogThread starterthe Boondocks, NC · Aug 1, 2009#23This program also rewards people who bought gas guzzlers years ago and punishes those bought fuel efficient cars by giving money to those who bought the guzzlers and not giving the incentive to people who have been driving green for years.
aclark246RI · Aug 1, 2009#24 Originally Posted by
eric81 ↑ Also, I believe they should have made the MPG a little higher, because 18 is REALLY hard to do. I have had SEVERAL customers that get 16 average or less, but the website says 19 or 20, so they miss out and have to keep driving their clunker.
The website says they get 19...they get 16...
The website says I get 32...I get 44...
Maybe it is the driver and not the car...
qualifier:
(...in some of those cases. I do realize that environment plays a big role in possible FE and that also they could have some serious car issues that inhibit any higher FE, but for most people I have seen who get poor FE in their cars-even older cars- it has been driving style that has kept them out of reach of the EPA numbers. Sucks for the people who it's out of their control, but for those who legitimately bought gas guzzlers in the first place and drive inefficiently anyway, I really don't want my tax dollars giving them a rebate if they can't make the 18 that their car can most probably make. If they do qualify however, I am more than happy to help them into a better car.)
tuckevalastinDelaware/Connecticut · Aug 1, 2009#25 Originally Posted by
eric81 ↑ Did you know that there are more Toyota's made in the US by US citizens then there are Toyota's coming in from Japan? And that Toyota has 4 of the top 10 americanized vehicles? Including the number one spot with the Camry? Yeah, the Camry beat out every other car in the US, including Fords, GM's, Chevy's, Pontiac's, Chrystler's, Jeeps, and Dodge's. How is this not helping the US? Maybe they should take a page out of Toyota's book and start building efficient, reliable cars. That's just my opinion though. Oh, wait, it's not my opinion. It's facts. Do your research.
Just because Toyota builds cars in the US and for the US buyers doesn't make them a US automaker. Did you do your research? It shouldn't be hard to find out that Toyota is NOT a US automaker!!!
RedRideMiddletown, NY · Aug 1, 2009#26Well, as the saying goes, ...."You can't please all the people all of the time."
Without getting political and/or placing blame (there is plenty to go around), the county is in a bit of an economic mess and doing nothing is not an option at this point.
I'm 62 years and have yet to see a government run progran that did not have problems at the onset.
TinyGiantRochester, NH · Aug 1, 2009#27i heard the govt shut down cash for clunkers a couple days ago.. the money that was budgeted for it is now gone... from a big response to the program
tuckevalastinDelaware/Connecticut · Aug 1, 2009#28the government then gave the program $2billion more in funding so it's back up and running.
TinyGiantRochester, NH · Aug 1, 2009#29splendid. 2 billion more to something i cant take advantage of because i did the right think last fall and got rid of my clunker. neato!
RedRideMiddletown, NY · Aug 1, 2009#30The CFC progam is not designed/purposed to reward or punish anybody.
The main focus it to boltser the all important US auto industry and all the busunesses that depend on it and getting old gas guzzlers off the road.
The '"I got mine and if you don't have yours,...screw you" attitude is largely what got us into this mess to begin with.
gokartrideTexas · Aug 1, 2009#31One can argue theoretical pros and cons all day, but in the end, I think it is a good program and a good time for it.
Bob DogThread starterthe Boondocks, NC · Aug 1, 2009#32The new money for the "Cash for Clunkers" program is being looted directly for the alternative energy programs, another give away to industry at the taxpayer expense. I bet the Senators and Congresspeople get a really nice stroke from the Auto Industry Lobbyists after this one
GeneWPennsylvania · Aug 1, 2009#33 Originally Posted by
TinyGiant ↑ i heard the govt shut down cash for clunkers a couple days ago.. the money that was budgeted for it is now gone... from a big response to the program
No. The ability of the Government to manage the problem was overwhelmed. The program has only spent about $100 million, about ten percent of the total.
Gene
GeneWPennsylvania · Aug 1, 2009#34 Originally Posted by
tomato ↑ You guys ought to move that thread to the off topic discussion, I think.
Health care: do you really like the idea that millions of Americans everywhere can't afford health insurance right now? Some can, but insurances will turn them down based on pre-existing conditions. What are they supposed to do? Here in California, a simple doctor's visit (consult, 15 minutes at MOST) is $184. That's not some fancy visit in some fancy place, believe me.
Is it fair that people who have worked all their lives and saved every penny should go bankrupt when someone gets, let's say cancer? IDK, something sure needs to be done. I don't trust the government anymore than the next guy, but a little bit of regulation to make sure prices don't skyrocket might be a good idea. Look at the price of prescription drugs for instance, I mean that is completely out of hand. Many of these drugs (which Seniors require) are long out of R&D, and shouldn't be priced that high. The tax payer is footing the bill 🤷 Maybe I should just shut up because the health care situation just puts me in a bad mood. Anyway, think about it, even if you voted Republican and hate the very thought of any government involvment. Just think about it, OK? Health care as it is now in the US is no care at all for the majority of people. It is a disgrace, if you ask me.
Meet you here....
The open political discussion thread. Read the first post! Gene
GeneWPennsylvania · Aug 1, 2009#35 Originally Posted by
Bob Dog ↑ The new money for the "Cash for Clunkers" program is being looted directly for the alternative energy programs, another give away to industry at the taxpayer expense. I bet the Senators and Congresspeople get a really nice stroke from the Auto Industry Lobbyists after this one
Do you think that "alternative energy" money isn't being "targeted at big business"?
Go look up the US Climate Action Partnership - it's a "who's who" of big business. They're pushing "Cap and Trade" through Congress, possibly even putting some $$$ into the pockets of "undecided" politicians.
I heard that the bread for "Cash for Clunkers ver 2.0" came from some TARP or "recovery" slush fund set up by COngress.
How come nobody is discussing how this "cash for clunkers" is hurting working poor folks? You know, the folks who buy clunkers to get to work and back? Doesn't anyone think of them, or are they invisible because they don't have lobbyists in Congress?
Gene
gokartrideTexas · Aug 1, 2009#36I wouldn't be surprised to see this program (or a program like it) pop up now and again. I've seen states trying to get at something like it before, generally for commercial equipment/trucks.
eric81Clarksville, IN · Aug 3, 2009#37The $2 billion that they added has to be voted on yet, so we are waiting. They actually DID run out of money, though only 1/10th of it is actually spent. There are enough requests in to spend the entire $1 billion, they just haven't rebated the money yet, so everyone is waiting to get the money. Toyota was one of the ONLY dealerships here in Pueblo to continue to do the Program on Saturday, because we got special permission, but now NO ONE is allowed to do it anymore, at least until the rest of the money is voted on and put in.
And I know Toyota is not a US company, but they are built here, parts and all, so it is helping the US just as much (if not more) than buying an "american made" car. A lot of the american brands are at least partially built in Mexico or Canada. My cousin works for GM, and he tells me all about the stuff they do. He works in Detroit Michigan. Yes, I did do my research. I am a Toyota salesman, and it's my job to know these things. I work In Pueblo, Colorado. Come on in and ask for Eric, and I will be happy to help.
tuckevalastinDelaware/Connecticut · Aug 3, 2009#38Except that the US government has invested $billions in the Big 3 which won't be repayed if they don't sell enough vehicles. So selling American cars benefits the US more than selling Toyotas not matter where Toyotas are made.
advocatelocation · Aug 3, 2009#39 Originally Posted by
GeneW ↑ Doesn't anyone think of them, or are they invisible because they don't have lobbyists in Congress?
Gene
Everyone who doesn't have a lobbyist is automatically invisible. Welcome to Congress, where money matters as much as the vote count.
Bob DogThread starterthe Boondocks, NC · Aug 3, 2009#40It does aggravate me that to see perfectly funtional vehicles that could have served so many of purposes destroyed like so much garbage: the commuter vehicles of the poor, the vehicles that are used by recyclers to haul scrap, the mobile homes of the homeless, the winter beaters people who live in regions where salt and winter would otherwise destroy newer cars, trucks used to haul firewood and other destructive agricultural comodities, the work trucks of handymen and andscapers.The list goes on and on. Let them drive new vehicles sounds like let them eat cake to me. As a frugal person who believes in getting all the useful life out of manufactured goods, it disgusts me. I sure people in the third world are looking at this an saying wtf are they thinking.
ZaphodSomewhere in the vacinity of Betelgeuse · Aug 3, 2009#41 Originally Posted by
Bob Dog ↑ It does aggravate me that to see perfectly funtional vehicles that could have served so many of purposes destroyed like so much garbage: the commuter vehicles of the poor, the vehicles that are used by recyclers to haul scrap, the mobile homes of the homeless, the winter beaters people who live in regions where salt and winter would otherwise destroy newer cars, trucks used to haul firewood and other destructive agricultural comodities, the work trucks of handymen and andscapers.The list goes on and on. Let them drive new vehicles sounds like let them eat cake to me. As a frugal person who believes in getting all the useful life out of manufactured goods, it disgusts me. I sure people in the third world are looking at this an saying wtf are they thinking.
I agree completely, people are saying this is a good thing since they're putting more efficient cars on the road and that's true, but they're not taking into consideration the amount of energy and resources used to build the replacement vehicles.
It's just an excuse to spend more money. The real solution is to allow gas prices to rise over time, which in turn increases demand for more efficient vehicles.
RedRideMiddletown, NY · Aug 3, 2009#42Fact is, there is no "real" single solution that will solve the "problem".
The CFC program is just one facet of many things that need to be implimened.
The biggest problem IMO is we need to break the back of the (false) mentalty that gas guzzelers are better... a staus symble, etc.
If it takes a program like CFC to get the ball rolling, so be it as no one has come up with a better solution so far after all these years.
Let's not loose sight of the fact that the gass guzzling vehicle problem has become a national security/ major economic issue.
Yaris HiltonBristol, Tennessee, USA · Aug 3, 2009#43 Originally Posted by
Bob Dog ↑ It does aggravate me that to see perfectly funtional vehicles that could have served so many of purposes destroyed like so much garbage: the commuter vehicles of the poor, the vehicles that are used by recyclers to haul scrap, the mobile homes of the homeless, the winter beaters people who live in regions where salt and winter would otherwise destroy newer cars, trucks used to haul firewood and other destructive agricultural commodities, the work trucks of handymen and landscapers.The list goes on and on. Let them drive new vehicles sounds like let them eat cake to me. As a frugal person who believes in getting all the useful life out of manufactured goods, it disgusts me. I sure people in the third world are looking at this an saying wtf are they thinking.
I agree completely. "Waste not, want not." I'm glad I don't have to watch 'em drain the oil out of the engine, fill it with sodium silicate solution, and run it till it seizes. A particularly barbaric way to kill a car.
I've got to get a little maintenance work done on my "clunker" before taking the family to the beach with it. It also serves as my "truck" with a trailer behind it, and my knockaround vehicle for going places like the rifle range where I don't want to take the shiniest, newest one. No way in blue blazing hell is the government going to destroy it for a $4500 discount on an overpriced new vehicle. But its retail value as a used car is $725, according to one of those online sites. Fine. I'm not planning to sell it anyway. As long as I can reasonably keep it fixed up, I'll run it till the wheels fall off and won't go back on.
tomatoSan Francisco Bay Area · Aug 3, 2009#44 Originally Posted by
Bob Dog ↑ This program also rewards people who bought gas guzzlers years ago and punishes those bought fuel efficient cars by giving money to those who bought the guzzlers and not giving the incentive to people who have been driving green for years.
Not that I'm against the program but that's a real good point!!
ShroomsterOrlando · Aug 3, 2009#45 Originally Posted by
Yaris Hilton ↑ As long as I can reasonably keep it fixed up, I'll run it till the wheels fall off and won't go back on.
psst. duct tape and super glue work wonders for when that time comes. just can't go much faster than about 17 m.p.h
tuckevalastinDelaware/Connecticut · Aug 3, 2009#46 Originally Posted by
Bob Dog ↑ It does aggravate me that to see perfectly funtional vehicles that could have served so many of purposes destroyed like so much garbage: the commuter vehicles of the poor, the vehicles that are used by recyclers to haul scrap, the mobile homes of the homeless, the winter beaters people who live in regions where salt and winter would otherwise destroy newer cars, trucks used to haul firewood and other destructive agricultural comodities, the work trucks of handymen and andscapers.The list goes on and on. Let them drive new vehicles sounds like let them eat cake to me. As a frugal person who believes in getting all the useful life out of manufactured goods, it disgusts me. I sure people in the third world are looking at this an saying wtf are they thinking.
I agree with that completely. What happens now to those who can only afford to buy "clunkers"? And those who make a living off of selling them? Sure every "clunker" in the country won't be destroyed but if all $3billion is used, over 600,000 of them will be destroyed. That's a major hit to those who use,buy, and sell "clunkers".
tomatoSan Francisco Bay Area · Aug 3, 2009#47 Originally Posted by
GeneW ↑
I saw the comment, thanks for responding to me. I don't know if I can answer, honestly because I don't have much time to spend online these days and once you get started with these kind of debates, before you know it, the best part of the day is gone. I can see that you and I have a very different view point on some stuff and that's cool, I respect that, but if I start debating with you, I won't get anything else done. I'm sorry, can't do it right now.
Also, my apologies for the thread jack.
2009ToyotoadCalifornia · Aug 3, 2009#48 Originally Posted by
Bob Dog ↑ New Yaris before Cash for Clunkers $13,500
New Yaris after Cash for Clunkers $9500 +1 POS
Used Yaris before Cash for Clunkers $9500
Used Yaris after Cash for Clunkers $6000-$7500 ?
and I was dumb enough to think the big screw might be over when the Repulicans left the white house FTS
Bob dog You are near sited and missing a few facts.
Used Yaris after the the cash for clunkers program sells 1 million cars $9,500
Used Yaris when gas prices creep back up to $4 / gallon $10,500
Short term projects yield short term results, on the car side. But cleaner air is worth waiting 6 months to sell a used Yaris
gokartrideTexas · Aug 3, 2009#49Hey, at least someone from among the general public benefitting. How often does that happen?!?
AltitudeColorado · Aug 3, 2009#50 Originally Posted by
tuckevalastin ↑ Except that the US government has invested $billions in the Big 3 which won't be repayed if they don't sell enough vehicles. So selling American cars benefits the US more than selling Toyotas not matter where Toyotas are made.
Sure, if the Gov. limited the program to US cars only then the US industry would benefit more, but don't overlook the benefits to be had for all of those Americans that work for Toyota, Nissan, Honda, Suzuki, Kia etc. etc.
This program puts money in the hands of anyone who works for the auto industry here in America *regardless* of the auto makers country of origin. So now those dealers, service dept workers, truckers, distributors, parts dealers etc.etc. can go spend that cash to further stimulate the economy. - as opposed to getting laid off because no one is buying.