Cleaner air is not a part of this program. Possibly emissions may be reduced as a side effect. But the criteria for eligible vehicles are based solely on fuel consumption as estimated by the EPA, not emissions. And the requirements for improved mileage to get the payment are rather modest. Why don't they just be honest about it and "give" a bonus to us (out of our tax dollars) to buy a new car? A bailout for the carmakers and dealers is all this is about.
Good For New Buyers , A Rip Off For Owners
83 posts · 19,209 views · page 2 of 2
Replies continued
Originally Posted by Altitude ↑Sure, if the Gov. limited the program to US cars only then the US industry would benefit more, but don't overlook the benefits to be had for all of those Americans that work for Toyota, Nissan, Honda, Suzuki, Kia etc. etc.
This program puts money in the hands of anyone who works for the auto industry here in America *regardless* of the auto makers country of origin. So now those dealers, service dept workers, truckers, distributors, parts dealers etc.etc. can go spend that cash to further stimulate the economy. - as opposed to getting laid off because no one is buying.
Don't overlook the benefits to all US citizens of having GM and Chrysler sell more cars.
I think it was a good idea, a lot better than Bush's bail-outs for poorly managed american auto companies which americans are split on if they even want those companies around any more.
get low mileage cars off the road = less gas consumed = less pollution = slows down global warming, And our dependence on OPEC is also lessened. I'm all up for sending a billion dollars to japan if it means we will save many times that amount in oil costs every year now.
get low mileage cars off the road = less gas consumed = less pollution = slows down global warming, And our dependence on OPEC is also lessened. I'm all up for sending a billion dollars to japan if it means we will save many times that amount in oil costs every year now.
I think the funniest part of all this, is that most of the american cars don't qualify for the good money ($4,500) which your new car must get 10mpg better than the old car, because they don't have super efficient cars like Toyota and Honda and those companies. Sure, they have one or two, but the SUV's all use MORE gas than there current clunker. If they had really started making fuel efficient vehicles like all the foreign companies 5 to 10 years ago, they would be selling more cars in the cash for clunkers thing. I believe the only vehicles we can't get to qualify are the Sequoia and the 4Runner. Every other vehicle has been sold to someone, just at my dealership alone. American's need jobs, I am not arguing with that. But my cousin got a job with GM, and they paid him 75% of his regular wages to be "Voluntarily laid off" for 6 weeks. If you are not working in Japan, the don't pay you. OR, they get smart and just reduce hours so you CAN continue to work regularly, just for less time, so you don't go hungry or unpaid. I think the US needs to look at how some other countries are doing business, (ALL other countries, to be honest) and start implementing some of their rules and ethics. I was in the US Army for 9 years, and when I was deployed to Iraq, I made about $50,000 a year, less before my extension. Civilians who never left the bases there were clearing $100,000 for doing next to nothing. They play on computers, eat 4 meals a day, get large SUV's to drive on the bases, and get issued body armor and side arms, and they never leave the base. They also get larger rooms, and if my A/C goes out, they still take priority because they are civilians. Trust me, we need to rethink how we do things here.
http://latimesblogs.latimes.com/upto.../clunkers.html
Some good reading about the program. Looks like 47% of the new cars purchased are built by the big three. Of the top 5 cars sold only the Prius is built entirely in Japan.
Some good reading about the program. Looks like 47% of the new cars purchased are built by the big three. Of the top 5 cars sold only the Prius is built entirely in Japan.
If it's really a big deal, there is something you can do... Find someone with a clunker who can't afford the payments on a new car. Trade them YOUR car then take the clunker to the dealership and get your new wheels. There, not only will you no longer feel cheated, you'll have helped out someone else who couldn't benefit either. Win, Win!!Originally Posted by Bob Dog ↑This program also rewards people who bought gas guzzlers years ago and punishes those bought fuel efficient cars by giving money to those who bought the guzzlers and not giving the incentive to people who have been driving green for years.
You have to prove you've owned it and had it insured for a full year prior to trading it in.
At least we've pulled our collective heads up out of the sand and we're trying something. For the last 30 odd years it's like we're ostriches and if we bury our heads long enough problems will just go away. I'm sure this isn't the absolute best way to spend taxpayer's dollars but I think it's at least an 8 on a scale of 1 - 10.
If killing functional automobiles helps to get us off foreign oil then I say shoot em dead.
If killing functional automobiles helps to get us off foreign oil then I say shoot em dead.
Taxing gas is a far better way to increase demand for more efficient vehicles long term.
Yep. This isn't going to get us off of foreign oil.
Just a quick question, a bit off topic, but would this work?:
Have a varying annual car tax, depending on FE and State. Lower EPA FE= higher tax; Higher EPA FE= lower tax. States/Regions where the car is insured that require more lower FE vehicles will have a lower tax than the same vehicle in a region that does not demand a lower FE vehicle.
For instance: I live in Boston. For Average Joe in Boston there is little need for an SUV, so the SUV would have a 9% annual tax, (just throwing random numbers, doesn't have to be those, just so you get the picture.) A Yaris would have a 2% yearly tax, (2% on what? I don't know, but we could figure something out.)
I live in Northern Maine. For Average Joe in Maine, there is indeed a need for 4 wheel drive vehicles and trucks, just based on the environment as opposed to Boston. A yaris does well in snow and holds its own (as our Canadian and mountain members will attest to,) but it might be more beneficial to have a big truck. Likewise, the economy of the area might require larger vehicles. The yaris would still have the 2% tax, but the SUV would only have a 4% tax.
This is just something that popped into my head. Is it plausible? What are the pitfalls? I know I'm missing them, otherwise this would be implemented already.
The only worry I would have is that:
1. It would give the EPA much more political and economic power than it already has
2. For those of us who do much better than EPA, there is no extra savings besides gas.
3. For those of us who do much worse than EPA, there is jealousy from those who do better, (on the tax break side...)
4. Would the logistics be possible? i.e. proving the low FE vehicles are neccesary for an individual/family so they don't have to pay the higher tax, not having as high a tax on persons whose low FE vehicle is not their primary vehicle, etc.
Would this type of program promote high efficiency vehicles more than CFC in which CFC is a one-time savings, whereas this idea could be an annual savings over the life of the vehicle? Maybe even a -% for high FE vehicles? Tax the unnecessary (key word) guzzlers and rebate the efficient ones?
(once again, it is just an idea, I haven't done any research or made a business plan or anything, haha.)
Have a varying annual car tax, depending on FE and State. Lower EPA FE= higher tax; Higher EPA FE= lower tax. States/Regions where the car is insured that require more lower FE vehicles will have a lower tax than the same vehicle in a region that does not demand a lower FE vehicle.
For instance: I live in Boston. For Average Joe in Boston there is little need for an SUV, so the SUV would have a 9% annual tax, (just throwing random numbers, doesn't have to be those, just so you get the picture.) A Yaris would have a 2% yearly tax, (2% on what? I don't know, but we could figure something out.)
I live in Northern Maine. For Average Joe in Maine, there is indeed a need for 4 wheel drive vehicles and trucks, just based on the environment as opposed to Boston. A yaris does well in snow and holds its own (as our Canadian and mountain members will attest to,) but it might be more beneficial to have a big truck. Likewise, the economy of the area might require larger vehicles. The yaris would still have the 2% tax, but the SUV would only have a 4% tax.
This is just something that popped into my head. Is it plausible? What are the pitfalls? I know I'm missing them, otherwise this would be implemented already.
The only worry I would have is that:
1. It would give the EPA much more political and economic power than it already has
2. For those of us who do much better than EPA, there is no extra savings besides gas.
3. For those of us who do much worse than EPA, there is jealousy from those who do better, (on the tax break side...)
4. Would the logistics be possible? i.e. proving the low FE vehicles are neccesary for an individual/family so they don't have to pay the higher tax, not having as high a tax on persons whose low FE vehicle is not their primary vehicle, etc.
Would this type of program promote high efficiency vehicles more than CFC in which CFC is a one-time savings, whereas this idea could be an annual savings over the life of the vehicle? Maybe even a -% for high FE vehicles? Tax the unnecessary (key word) guzzlers and rebate the efficient ones?
(once again, it is just an idea, I haven't done any research or made a business plan or anything, haha.)
er I didn't say it would get us off foreign oil, I said helps to get us off foreign oil. Big difference. With such a small percentage of cars involved I would expect the effect to be small, very small. Increasing the fed tax at the pump is the ultimate solution imo, so I very much agree with Zaphod. I'd love to see them increase it a small amount every year from now on. It wouldn't shock the economy and in a few years there would be fewer gas guzzlers on the road.Originally Posted by Yaris Hilton ↑Yep. This isn't going to get us off of foreign oil.
Baby steps?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WsUaQUW-Az0
At least they're finally doing something. Maybe when the economy improves they'll bump up the tax at the pump. Yeah right! LOL
Very true! I find it so ironic that Obama is pushing electric cars....and then is pushing cap and trade which will make it very difficult to use coal electric plants, which will drive up the price of electricity and make electric cars almost as expensive as gas cars.Originally Posted by GeneW ↑"Cash for Clunkers" is an ice cream cone and a peck on the cheek compared to the full blown luvin' you're gonna get from the Crony Capitalism of Cap 'n Rape (backed by GE and other Corporate giants) and "Health Care" (backed by the AMA).
Gene
Too many people have been fooled by Obama the snake oil salesman. His policies are just plain socialist and bad for America!
What country do you think the president was born in?
Soooo, Joe Blow gets what he thinks is a great credit for a 1985 Escort, then they hand him the keys to a brand spanking new Focus. Sounds like a good deal to you and me, right? Joe drives home, singing, "I'm on, top of the world and lookin', down at creation..." and you get the picture, he's as the the other song suggests, "Happy as a Lark".
So Joe gets home to his apartment, get's ready to go to work. It's Saturday afternoon, and he has to be at the Mall for his shift at the Gap. Joe makes about $10.50 an hour as a supervisor. So Joe goes to work shows off his new ride and loves every minute of it.
A few weeks go by and rent is due. Not sure, but depending on area, a one bedroom around here is about $900 up to $1200 or so, give or take a few. Joe likes his lifestyle, so a shabby apartment is out of the question, and his lifestyle is just as nice, late nights out with the gap crew, parties etc. Joe pays his rent on time and time goes by.
Month end rolls around and Joe pays his car note. Car note is around $250 based on Joe's % they gave him at the dealer.
Ok, to save time in this story, we all know where this is heading. Joe is living well beyond his means just by buying into this idea of getting a new car based on his old car is worth more than it actually is. Joe had a car that ran well because his Dad taught him how to take care of it at an early age. Soon Joe begins to fall behind on payments because Joe's Dad might have taught him how to take care of his care and have his oil changed, but they failed to teach him the value of a dollar. So Joe blows his dough on partying all the time. Now Joe is about to loose his car, might loose his job soon due to retail sales going up and down, up and down. All in all, your looking at about another 2 billion going down the drain when all is said and done due to people not being able to pay for these cars. Yeah they get there car back, but won't be able to sell them. Has anyone taken this in to account when this idea was thought up? Answer is, YES!! We've seen it already, they take it from our children, and their children and so on. Higher taxes? Yep, there coming!!
"LET THE GAMES BEGIN!!"
Picture not included in this copy
So Joe gets home to his apartment, get's ready to go to work. It's Saturday afternoon, and he has to be at the Mall for his shift at the Gap. Joe makes about $10.50 an hour as a supervisor. So Joe goes to work shows off his new ride and loves every minute of it.
A few weeks go by and rent is due. Not sure, but depending on area, a one bedroom around here is about $900 up to $1200 or so, give or take a few. Joe likes his lifestyle, so a shabby apartment is out of the question, and his lifestyle is just as nice, late nights out with the gap crew, parties etc. Joe pays his rent on time and time goes by.
Month end rolls around and Joe pays his car note. Car note is around $250 based on Joe's % they gave him at the dealer.
Ok, to save time in this story, we all know where this is heading. Joe is living well beyond his means just by buying into this idea of getting a new car based on his old car is worth more than it actually is. Joe had a car that ran well because his Dad taught him how to take care of it at an early age. Soon Joe begins to fall behind on payments because Joe's Dad might have taught him how to take care of his care and have his oil changed, but they failed to teach him the value of a dollar. So Joe blows his dough on partying all the time. Now Joe is about to loose his car, might loose his job soon due to retail sales going up and down, up and down. All in all, your looking at about another 2 billion going down the drain when all is said and done due to people not being able to pay for these cars. Yeah they get there car back, but won't be able to sell them. Has anyone taken this in to account when this idea was thought up? Answer is, YES!! We've seen it already, they take it from our children, and their children and so on. Higher taxes? Yep, there coming!!
"LET THE GAMES BEGIN!!"
Picture not included in this copy
He's not going to get anything for his Escort under the Cash for Clunkers. Too much gas mileage. But the rest is on target.
Polly want a cracker?Originally Posted by daf62757 ↑Too many people have been fooled by Obama the snake oil salesman. His policies are just plain socialist and bad for America!
It is all a big game. You see, Republicans cut taxes and deregulate, things go to hell so the Dems come in and raise taxes back to previous levels and impose more regulations to fix the problems. Then people complain that taxes are too high so they vote in Republicans who then lower taxes and deregulate and things go to hell and the Dems are elected to fix it and have to raise taxes... ad nauseum.Originally Posted by KCALB SIRAY ↑Higher taxes? Yep, there coming!!
"LET THE GAMES BEGIN!!"
lol, you are rightOriginally Posted by Yaris Hilton ↑He's not going to get anything for his Escort under the Cash for Clunkers. Too much gas mileage. But the rest is on target.
I'm not even go to touch that statement but you should be ready to have that statement ripped apart by someone since it is begging to be.Originally Posted by Altitude ↑It is all a big game. You see, Republicans cut taxes and deregulate, things go to hell so the Dems come in and raise taxes back to previous levels and impose more regulations to fix the problems. Then people complain that taxes are too high so they vote in Republicans who then lower taxes and deregulate and things go to hell and the Dems are elected to fix it and have to raise taxes... ad nauseum.
Sounds like checks and balances to me!👍Originally Posted by Altitude ↑It is all a big game. You see, Republicans cut taxes and deregulate, things go to hell so the Dems come in and raise taxes back to previous levels and impose more regulations to fix the problems. Then people complain that taxes are too high so they vote in Republicans who then lower taxes and deregulate and things go to hell and the Dems are elected to fix it and have to raise taxes... ad nauseum.
...
...
...
...
🤷
I agree with altitude on this on. Its just a pendulum swinging back and forth
I write checks, and watch my balances go farther and farther into the negative. lol.
Seriously, this thing NEEDS to have some of those rules imposed on it, like you have to make LESS than so much a year. Also, when they apply for credit, it's not like it USED to be. They do a credit check and an income check, along with a "living expenses" check (how much rent or mortgage is) and then they figure if they SHOULD put you into a vehicle. The banks are MUCH more stubborn now-a-days. I know, I had less income, worse credit, and more debt and got into a more expensive car than what several of my customers have been denied for. The banks are not lending because they are afraid to get burned again, like they did three, and even just one year ago. That's one of the hardest parts about my job, is seeing people get turned away for not making more than a certain amount. Or not having "enough" credit, because they are smart and didn't get themselves buried in it, so they have no real credit score. There could have been so many things done better, but hey, I'm not the one in charge, the guy I didn't vote for is. Thank you everyone who DID vote for him. I owe you one.
Seriously, this thing NEEDS to have some of those rules imposed on it, like you have to make LESS than so much a year. Also, when they apply for credit, it's not like it USED to be. They do a credit check and an income check, along with a "living expenses" check (how much rent or mortgage is) and then they figure if they SHOULD put you into a vehicle. The banks are MUCH more stubborn now-a-days. I know, I had less income, worse credit, and more debt and got into a more expensive car than what several of my customers have been denied for. The banks are not lending because they are afraid to get burned again, like they did three, and even just one year ago. That's one of the hardest parts about my job, is seeing people get turned away for not making more than a certain amount. Or not having "enough" credit, because they are smart and didn't get themselves buried in it, so they have no real credit score. There could have been so many things done better, but hey, I'm not the one in charge, the guy I didn't vote for is. Thank you everyone who DID vote for him. I owe you one.
That my friend is the absolutely WRONG attitude. This is freakin' america! Why has everyone forgotten that?! What was the US founded on? The People are in charge! The People have given up their power to the government and I don't think any person has the right to complain unless they have personally taken an initiative. "But Aclark246, I voted, and my guys lost, and I don't have a lobbyist, and I don't have the time or money to try and get my voice heard." Well by george (maybe king...) then I hate to say it but your voice doesn't matter. Do you think the colonies had lots of money or time when they decided to stand up for the principle that their voice mattered? No... no they weren't wealthy, so that is no excuse, and they sure as hell had the same time constraints as you do, if not more seeing as the majority of the colonialists were agrarian.Originally Posted by eric81 ↑There could have been so many things done better, but hey, I'm not the one in charge, the guy I didn't vote for is. Thank you everyone who DID vote for him. I owe you one.
All I'm saying is, if you are ok with only being heard a few times a year at the local level and every 2 years federally, then do what you have been doing. If you don't like what is happening, or if you just have a good idea for changes or revisions to some policies, say something AND do something. The backbone of this nation is its citizens, shouldn't the backbone of the government be the citizens too? Do something constructive as opposed to destructive. Bickering is just that, but constructive debate is how the early nation flourished and it seems we have forgotten that.
:endtirade:
On a side note, I saw a piece on the news about non profit organizations losing car donations because of the program. Should the policy be changed so that instead of killing the clunkers, they are donated to these groups? No one could sell them back in the program because of the one year ownership thing. Charitable donations thanks to the US government. I think that would at least serve a better purpose. Any thoughts?
(see, constructive debate, once we reach a consensus we will get a YarisWorld lobbyist and have our own interest group. Heck, we already are our own interest group. All we need is to do something...)
👍
I would like to see something productive like that done with the "clunkers," but as it's been couched in terms of "getting those gas guzzlers off the road," it's unlikely they'll go for it.
I thought that the organizations that collect the donated cars sold off parts and just used the money from them? My mother donated an old buick a few years back after it all but died and they said they would just salvage the parts because every little bit helps.
I saw an article on the NBC evening news last night: many organizations that depend on the donation of used vehicles are struggling due to this progam
Removed by poster.
Why don't you rip it apart? (If you choose to do so we should probably take it to the political thread)There are 2 reasons:
Check this out before you do though:
1) as you mentioned already such discussions shouldn't take place here as they'll just end up getting the thread locked.
2) Arguing politics results in absolutely nothing but getting people ticked off at each other. While I completely disagree with you I'll accomplish nothing by going in depth to tell you why I disagree with you. Ultimately, you actually believe what you said and I find it to be a complete joke (and I'm sure you'd feel similarly about my counter argument). I'm more than happy just agreeing to disagree and discussing car related topics 😁
As for the graph, I've been taught statistics quite well and you can make a graph using factual numbers that appears to prove any point no matter how obsurd. So I'm sure the numbers in that graph are true but look a little deeper into the other variables involved in government and that graph becomes irrelevant.
Deleted my comment.
whats all that got to do with cash for clunkers? I believe that stuff belongs in the open political discussion thread in the off topic section.
okay... I absolutely disagree that this has gotten anywhere near off subject. It is just what it started as. And I think it is actually HEALTHY to disagree with others, as long as you are not overly angry with someone else's response or opinion. So lets all be calm, and just agree to disagree.
Oh, political banter. Subscribed, with popcorn.