Yarisworld Archive

Thinking of trading Yaris for Mini Cooper S convertible.

92 posts · 22,944 views · page 1 of 2

marcusOriginal posttoronto, canada · Jun 2, 2009#1
Thinking of trading yaris to mini cooper s convertable 2005 and up.. what do you guys think..0-60 in 7.0 sec flat on the s version and its a convertible..
urgh...decision decision...

here are some cars. hope who ever own this cars dont mind me posting pictures of their cars in here..😉

last one is a mini s2000...lolz..its a skoda s2000 it does look like half mini..

8 attachments not included in this copy

Replies 91

staticorexcivilwar town. · Jun 2, 2009#2
I like the mini's. If you can afford it, go for it. It's kinda like comparing a Solara to an IS-c. :p It costs more but is a better car.
jamal1984Georgia, USA · Jun 2, 2009#3
agreed, if i can afford the mini i will def go with the Mini. Gas mileage is not much of a diff. vs yaris.
marcusThread startertoronto, canada · Jun 2, 2009#4
they sell used ones in canada ranging form 19k to 25k..canadian of course
staticorexcivilwar town. · Jun 2, 2009#5
Do you still owe on the Yaris?
marcusThread startertoronto, canada · Jun 2, 2009#6
yah about 9 grand more.
TamagoOff Grid · Jun 2, 2009#7
why convertible?
staticorexcivilwar town. · Jun 2, 2009#8
If you still owe that much on the Yaris it might be a good idea to keep it till it's paid off. The mini's will still be there. :p
marcusThread startertoronto, canada · Jun 2, 2009#9
so how the mini when it comes to maintainance..never had a german car b4..
scapeBeaufort, South Carolina · Jun 2, 2009#10
Originally Posted by voodoo22 ↑
Marcus... if you can afford it and you want it.... do it. Get that out of your system or you may always regret it. The mini is an awesome car and life is short. Don't be too irresponsible, but don't be so cautious you spend your life waiting for fun, but take into consideration that maintenance on a Mini is much, much more expensive. It is a premium car after all.

I would have bought a mini and might again one day, but I've had a couple nice "irresponsible" cars and I'm back in saving mode with the Yaris.

Let us know what you decide.
;D i like that statement
scapeBeaufort, South Carolina · Jun 2, 2009#11
a yaris convertible would rock, maybe one day...:http://images.google.com/images?hl=e...-8&sa=N&tab=wi

but if you're sold on the mini, I say yes go for it! but don't let your mode of transportation define you, a car is usually just a car
marcusThread startertoronto, canada · Jun 2, 2009#12
ok ill keep all these in mind..my motto is " you only die once " might as well live it... definetely a good car to consider.. now just need to join a mini forums..
BluYrsTallinn, Estonia · Jun 2, 2009#13
Aside from the obvious handling difference, the Mini feels small compared to the Yaris. In a good way. The seating position is low, no space is wasted around the driver and if you ever consider giving more than one friend a ride, the backseat heros better have no feet.

All in all, the whole point of the Mini is different to that of the Yaris. As said, do it or else you'll regret it :)
marcusThread startertoronto, canada · Jun 2, 2009#14
ill test drive one this weekend. just afraid i may get one sooner..yikes.
GooseOhio cornfields · Jun 2, 2009#15
I owned an '05 Cooper S coupe for a while. A very nice car.

I will say that, with the 17" alloys w/run-flats, the MINI didn't deal with snow too well. If you go with any of the larger OEM alloy/tire combos, you might want to have a set of dedicated snows.

The MINI (like most German cars) will have a few more squeaks and rattles compared to the Yaris. Being "a BMW in British clothes", expect to pay some steep repair costs on the MINI if you're not covered by warranty.

Overall, the MINI is a great little car; enjoy it if you wind up getting one!

EDIT: North American MINI is the big forum for MINI in the States. MINI2 is the big one over in Britain. Loads of info there - if a bit biased.
CTScottUSA, CT · Jun 2, 2009#17
Install a moon roof in your Yaris and keep it. With my Webasto Hollandia 730 moon roof fully open I sure feel like my Yaris is a convertible.
marcusThread startertoronto, canada · Jun 2, 2009#18
wow $11000 to fix a tranny.. yikes.. now i need to lease a mini..lolz.
TamagoOff Grid · Jun 2, 2009#19
Hyundai Genesis = more bang for the buck IMO, and doesn't carry the "hairdresser" stigma of a convertible ;)
marcusThread startertoronto, canada · Jun 2, 2009#20
yah i did post the genesis vs toyobaru.. but wanting a convertable thats quick and good on gas.. *sigh*
TamagoOff Grid · Jun 2, 2009#21
Originally Posted by marcus ↑
yah i did post the genesis vs toyobaru.. but wanting a convertable thats quick and good on gas.. *sigh*
mazdaspeed miata (mx5)
AltitudeColorado · Jun 2, 2009#22
So Tamago - do you not like convertibles in general or just the Mini convertible?
marcusThread startertoronto, canada · Jun 2, 2009#23
Originally Posted by Tamago ↑
mazdaspeed miata (mx5)
oooooo ur right mazdaspeed miata..but i dont think they sell that here.. do they?
TamagoOff Grid · Jun 2, 2009#24
Originally Posted by Altitude ↑
So Tamago - do you not like convertibles in general or just the Mini convertible?
the convertible has its place.

a mini convertible is just awful to drive in comparison to it's hardtop brother (the way the car was DESIGNED)

if a car is DESIGNED to be a convertible, not retrofitted AFTER the fact, i think it can be a decent car, such as the Elise and MX5
AltitudeColorado · Jun 2, 2009#25
Originally Posted by Tamago ↑
the convertible has its place.

a mini convertible is just awful to drive in comparison to it's hardtop brother (the way the car was DESIGNED)

if a car is DESIGNED to be a convertible, not retrofitted AFTER the fact, i think it can be a decent car, such as the Elise and MX5
Heh. Cool. For a moment I thought you didn't like the fact that it messes up your hair 😉

My sister drives a mini convertible and while I haven't driven either model I'm not so sure I get how it's more awful to drive than a hard top.

All I know is it doesn't get much better than a sunny day with my Wrangler top down 😁
TamagoOff Grid · Jun 2, 2009#26
Originally Posted by Altitude ↑
Heh. Cool. For a moment I thought you didn't like the fact that it messes up your hair 😉
who, me? hair?

Picture not included in this copy

My sister drives a mini convertible and while I haven't driven either model I'm not so sure I get how it's more awful to drive than a hard top.

All I know is it doesn't get much better than a sunny day with my Wrangler top down 😁

btw "hairdresser's car" refers to a car for.. those not hetero.
AltitudeColorado · Jun 2, 2009#27
Originally Posted by Tamago ↑
who, me? hair?

Picture not included in this copy




btw "hairdresser's car" refers to a car for.. those not hetero.
Ah - the "gay car" thing - I see.

We need to have a caption contest for that pic!

Here's my vote - "Go ahead, ask me a stupid question..." 👍

btw - got my spacers last Friday - haven't had a chance to put them on yet but will post in the approriate thread when I do. Thanks again for those - makes me happy.
SilverGlowSouthern California · Jun 2, 2009#28
Question: Why would you trade the Yaris in?

Answer: Because you want to get screwed by the stealership.
Black YarisToledo, OH · Jun 2, 2009#29
Mini FTW.... I would do it in a heartbeat
marcusThread startertoronto, canada · Jun 2, 2009#30
Originally Posted by SilverGlow ↑
Question: Why would you trade the Yaris in?

Answer: Because you want to get screwed by the stealership.
i havent seen any decent dealership that wont screw you up where the morning dont shine. even with my yaris i got screw for getting something i didnt have too..so go figure. if you dont want to get screwed then dont buy a car. steal one insted. 😆😆😆
Bob Dogthe Boondocks, NC · Jun 2, 2009#31
Actually I think most Yaris owners would like a Mini for the better handling and performance, with similar gas milage, but as the others have said repair and maintainence on the things is really expensive. You can buy new or aftermarket parts for a Yaris cheaply, many of which are interchangable with hundreds of thousands of Toyotas. The Mini was originally designed for a more premium european customer, where gas is more expensive and the people buying them are rather well to do and more in mind of mind paying for expensive repairs. I also would be interested in what will happen to parts prices and availability in current market, with many of the small parts suppliers going under, and the long term market viability of the Mini itself with so many vehicle builders going out of business. If it wasn't for these problems, I believe I might try to make the stretch for a Mini myself.
1stToyotaOklahoma · Jun 2, 2009#32
I thought about trading in the Yaris someday for a hardtop Cooper S, then I decided I'd much rather think about a Volvo C30 R 🤤
staticorexcivilwar town. · Jun 2, 2009#33
After reading all your posts now I'm questioning why you want the Mini. Is this something you've wanted for awhile or something spur of the moment? I desperately wanted my GTO but I looked for one for over 2 years before I found the right one at the right time. Don't be too quick to decide on something expensive. :)
marcusThread startertoronto, canada · Jun 2, 2009#34
Originally Posted by staticorex ↑
After reading all your posts now I'm questioning why you want the Mini. Is this something you've wanted for awhile or something spur of the moment? I desperately wanted my GTO but I looked for one for over 2 years before I found the right one at the right time. Don't be too quick to decide on something expensive. :)
something recent..now im thinking maybe ill just get a studebaker ..lolz
im sure this will pass by..all the post helped a lot for me to maybe just keep the yaris for now but well see.... damn this midlife crisis..!
1stToyotaOklahoma · Jun 2, 2009#35
Originally Posted by staticorex ↑
After reading all your posts now I'm questioning why you want the Mini. Is this something you've wanted for awhile or something spur of the moment? I desperately wanted my GTO but I looked for one for over 2 years before I found the right one at the right time. Don't be too quick to decide on something expensive. :)
I'd much rather have the Volvo over the Mini, and when the '04 GTO finally got released I wanted one, and waited until late '05 to get a new '05 GTO because it was a red tag sale (over 4k off) ...enjoyed the high quality and power, but didn't like it's nearly 4,000 lb pig feeling when I braked or hit a twisty, plus gas was high at the time and I had to run 93 octane because of the tune and mods. I've always liked quality, and have never spent this small amount of $$$ on a new car, unless you coun't the '83 Prelude (it was $12,500.00) so I plan on keeping the Yaris for a couple more years, but the C30 is closer to what I'll look for the next time.
TinyGiantRochester, NH · Jun 2, 2009#36
i've heard that the mini have expensive control arms that break all the time .. kinda like the audi tend to do.

read some reviews on the upkeep .. parts arent cheap for those suckers
JBIZZFort Lauderdale, FL · Jun 2, 2009#37
The Mini S (MT) is sick. I drove one not too long ago and was surprised how much power & leg room it had compared to the Yaris (MT). I did the 1ZZ TB swap & DC header install this past weekend. I was keeping up with some manic in a Mini S today on my way home from work, I couldn't believe it. He must have had an auto tranny. The MT Yaris (stock) is also just as fast as an Automatic Golf turbo (stock).

I like the Minis but like the looks of the Yaris much better (less yuppy). I also believe the Yaris is a more reliable/mechanically superior car. I would not gun t from a stop in a Mini at every stop light, but am not afraid to in a Yaris. Less shit will break in the long run and the Yaris I'm sure has cheaper parts.

If you still owe money on your Yaris, Keep it. You don't want to go bankrupt, although it seems to be the trend these days, even for people who not to long ago had lots of money.
Kaotic LazagnaCentral Valley, CA · Jun 2, 2009#38
Not much into convertibles anymore, but if you were to trade it for the hatch, then I say why not if you can afford it (car, gas, insurance, maintenance).
WeeYariGeorgetown, Ontario, Canada · Jun 2, 2009#39
Originally Posted by marcus ↑
.... damn this midlife crisis..!
HA! Shit man you gotta long way to go before you hit that!!

Besides, you've only been sporting your new RS Tails for what, 3 days. At least take some time to enjoy those. DIBS on them if you opt out of Yaris.

Hear that everyone? I call dibs.😉
Kaotic LazagnaCentral Valley, CA · Jun 2, 2009#40
I'd actually get an NA Miata and turbocharger it over a Mini. It's rwd! I owned one for my first car.
marcusThread startertoronto, canada · Jun 3, 2009#41
they maybe coming up with miataspeed. but the regular mazda miata is expensive enuff..yikes.
WeeYariGeorgetown, Ontario, Canada · Jun 3, 2009#42
Originally Posted by marcus ↑
they maybe coming up with miataspeed. but the regular mazda miata is expensive enuff..yikes.
You can get a Mazdaspeed MX-5, but I believe it is special order.
MouseMiami, Fl. · Jun 3, 2009#43
The Mazdaspeed MX-5 were only sold in 2004 and 2005. There is no current Mazdaspeed MX-5. There are MS parts for the current gen MX-5. I would personally go with an 94-97 miata if you want a convertible.
marcusThread startertoronto, canada · Jun 3, 2009#44
Originally Posted by WeeYari ↑
HA! Shit man you gotta long way to go before you hit that!!

Besides, you've only been sporting your new RS Tails for what, 3 days. At least take some time to enjoy those. DIBS on them if you opt out of Yaris.

Hear that everyone? I call dibs.😉
yah ..hehehe ur right let me enjoy the new tails first.also take an actual photo of it rather than using other peoples tail photo.lolz.
toyoJapan I wish · Jun 3, 2009#45
you want a cool convertible car? get an s2000, you won't regreat it, I promise.
marcusThread startertoronto, canada · Jun 3, 2009#46
Originally Posted by toyo ↑
you want a cool convertible car? get an s2000, you won't regreat it, I promise.
yah i thought of that but i got something against honda..lolz

definetely hot item just a little killer on insurance.
MUSKOKA800Chatham, Ontario, Canada · Jun 4, 2009#47
Marcus,
Before you make the jump check your potential insurance rates for the Mini Convertible.
Likely much, much higher than for your Yaris. Especially in Toronto.
MUSKOKA800Chatham, Ontario, Canada · Jun 4, 2009#48
Marcus,
Before you make the jump check your potential insurance rates for the Mini Convertible.
Likely much, much higher than for your Yaris. Especially in Toronto/GTA.
schleppyBoston, MA · Jun 4, 2009#49
We have two Mini's in my family (and I used to work for Mini) and I don't think I'd buy one. Now that I have a Yaris I've done some suspension mods to, I think it will give me just as big as grin as driving our Cooper S does.

Both of our Mini's have had varying issues from niggly to bad, and everytime it cost a fortune to fix. The parts are ludicrously expensive. Yes, the cars have long service intervals, but they should be a lot shorter. 10k oil changes are absurd for anyone that does real driving. Working on them is also a monumental pain in the ass. The oil changes are probably the second worse I've even had to do.

The cars do drive extremely well, but they are NOT cheap. If you have any specific questions fire them my way.
marcusThread startertoronto, canada · Jun 4, 2009#50
thanks guys.. i think im off the mini..this thread helped a lot..now im looking into s2000...thanks to toyo's post i completely forgot about the s2000 hmmm but im against honda though .. what to do what to do??