Yarisworld Archive

Thinking of trading Yaris for Mini Cooper S convertible.

92 posts · 22,944 views · page 2 of 2

Replies continued

CTScottUSA, CT · Jun 4, 2009#51
Originally Posted by marcus ↑
thanks guys.. i think im off the mini..this thread helped a lot..now im looking into s2000...thanks to toyo's post i completely forgot about the s2000 hmmm but im against honda though .. what to do what to do??
I still say, forget the convertible - Throw a moon roof on your Yaris instead. You'll still have a 4 season car that's even better on the good weather days.
marcusThread startertoronto, canada · Jun 4, 2009#52
Originally Posted by CTScott ↑
I still say, forget the convertible - Throw a moon roof on your Yaris instead. You'll still have a 4 season car that's even better on the good weather days.
moonroof is nice but not the same as a convertable..open air is so refreshing..
CTScottUSA, CT · Jun 4, 2009#53
Originally Posted by marcus ↑
moonroof is nice but not the same as a convertable..open air is so refreshing..
I know where you're coming from - I had a Miata for six months during a temporary assignment to the West Coast back in 1993. I have to say though that a tiny car with a big moonroof is mighty close.
marcusThread startertoronto, canada · Jun 4, 2009#54
Originally Posted by CTScott ↑
I know where you're coming from - I had a Miata for six months during a temporary assignment to the West Coast back in 1993. I have to say though that a tiny car with a big moonroof is mighty close.
or better yet panoramic roof..
jambo101Montreal Canada · Jun 4, 2009#55
Originally Posted by marcus ↑
thanks guys.. i think im off the mini..this thread helped a lot..now im looking into s2000...thanks to toyo's post i completely forgot about the s2000 hmmm but im against honda though .. what to do what to do??
Keeping the Miata idea going,a regular 140hp Miata will thrash most cars when the road gets twisty a 250hp turbo'd Miata will just widen the smile and a V8 Monster Miata will take care of just about everything else,Aftermarket add ons are probably a 3rd after Honda and Mustang, If you dont like the convertable idea just keep the hard top on ,great forum and many clubs.Buying a low mileage first generation Miata will set you back $4 -$7k,second Generation $7-$12k.good luck and we wanna see picks of whatever you buy.
PS There are several Miata clubs in Toronto including the Miataphiles who's club credo is=

An informal group of young Toronto Miataphiles... 100+ and going strong... No
rules, no political B.S. or correctness, no president, no dues, no corner left
un-bruised. This is not a mid-life-crisis car... this is a hardcore, fun-as-hell
lifestyle... We do what we want, when we want... We drive hard, play hard, race
hard and talk a big game... All disputes settled with 4 simple words... Line It
Up Beeatch!
marcusThread startertoronto, canada · Jun 4, 2009#57
miatas do look wicked..specially if its properly modded.
toyoJapan I wish · Jun 4, 2009#58
dude, seriously, get an s2000, there's no way to go wrong with it.

it doesn't even compare to civics, crx, riced out hondas or del sol LOL

seriously, if you get a 2004 comes with the f22c1 8000 rpm redline and 240 hp still getting awesome mpg!!!

The S2000 has received much praise from critics and motoring journalists and has received favourable reviews from such publications as Car and Driver,[24] Car,[25] the Los Angeles Times, and Road & Track magazine. Among the features highlighted are the high output of the engine, the high redline, the balanced handling, and the smooth gearbox. User surveys have named the S2000 as a favorite for overall customer satisfaction.[26][27]

* The S2000 was on Car and Driver's Ten Best list for 2000, 2001, 2002 and 2004.
* The S2000 was the highest-ranked model in the J.D. Power and Associates Vehicle Dependability Study "Premium Sports Car" class for 2004,[28] 2006,[29] and 2008[30] and has consistently held one of the top three positions.
* The F20C engine won the International Engine of the Year award in the "1.8 to 2 litre" size category for five years from 2000 through 2004.
* The F20C was featured on Ward's 10 Best Engines list for 2000 and 2001.
* The S2000 ranked number #1 in the BBC Top Gear Survey in 2004, 2005, and 2006.[31]
* Consumers' Most Wanted Convertible Under $35,000 for 2007, Edmunds.com[32]
* Ten Most Gorgeous Japanese Cars Currently For Sale, Jalopnik[33]
* Best Affordable Sports Car for 2008, U.S. News & World Report[34]
get an ap2, you can get round 35 mpg highway, can you believe it???

completely worth it, don't think about it any longer lol

you'll thank me later...
toyoJapan I wish · Jun 4, 2009#59
Picture not included in this copy

Picture not included in this copy

Picture not included in this copy

🙇
marcusThread startertoronto, canada · Jun 4, 2009#60
👏👏👏
MouseMiami, Fl. · Jun 4, 2009#61
Yeah....and deal with the Snap Oversteer the S2000 is notorious for. Have you ever seen the S2000s at autocross events...It's a spinfest. Get the car that started it all. Who knows maybe ina few years you can get collector car insurance on it and pay 600 dollars a year in insurance. Parts for the miata are a lot cheaper and more plentiful.
MouseMiami, Fl. · Jun 4, 2009#65
With the v8...you can hang with F430's....Youtube it.
GeneWPennsylvania · Jun 4, 2009#66
Originally Posted by marcus ↑
Thinking of trading yaris to mini cooper s convertable 2005 and up.. what do you guys think..0-60 in 7.0 sec flat on the s version and its a convertible..
urgh...decision decision...
Enjoy the "German Quality" of a car made in Britain.

Honestly, I don't know what their track record is, but anything made by BMW does not have cheap parts.

Gene
regalPA · Jun 6, 2009#67
Forget the Mini - unreliable germn engineering. Forget the S2000 500 lbs heavier than your Yaris spoils the fun. Look at the MR2 Spyder and the Miata, I am torn between which one to get. You can by a 95 Miata for $3k add 3$ for a turbo and $1500 for a suspension and have and absolute road killer that is OBDI semi emmsisions legal), but it doesn;t look as nice as the Spyder. The olnly was to make the Spyder fast and emmissions legal is a 2ZZ swap which sets you back $7k, bu yo probably don't need the extra pwer with that car anyhow.

But forget te mini, I'ved owned 6 german cars, everyone spent at least a month in the shop a year (cummulative.)I had a 6 series BMW that drove like a dream but the repair bills doing my own work were astronomical.
marcusThread startertoronto, canada · Jun 6, 2009#68
Originally Posted by regal ↑
Forget the Mini - unreliable germn engineering. Forget the S2000 500 lbs heavier than your Yaris spoils the fun. Look at the MR2 Spyder and the Miata, I ma torn between which one to get. You can by a 95 Miata for $3k add 3$ for a turbo and $1500 for a suspension and have and absolute road killer, but it doesn;t look as nice as the Spyder.
But forget te mini, I'ved owned 6 german cars, everyone spent at least a month in the shop a year (cummulative.)I had a 6 series BMW that drove like a dream but the repir bills doing my own work were astronomical.
i looked at that mr2 but i dont think we get it here..atleast not the spyder.
Bombdotcom818 · Jun 6, 2009#70
buy the hard top one ^_^
marcusThread startertoronto, canada · Jun 6, 2009#71
Originally Posted by 1stToyota ↑
lolz.. nice try but not convertable..i do love those..
marcusThread startertoronto, canada · Jun 6, 2009#72
Originally Posted by Bombdotcom ↑
buy the hard top one ^_^
issue with hard top is if it rain.. dont you have to leave those home.
kimonaHuntington Bch, CA · Jun 6, 2009#73
Why trade... just because it's a convertible?
marcusThread startertoronto, canada · Jun 6, 2009#74
Originally Posted by kimona ↑
Why trade... just because it's a convertible?
yup..so far heres the list.

started with

mini cooper s
honda s2000
mazda miata mx5
toyota mr2 spyder
lotus elise had to throw this in.

others
bmw z3 or z4
Bombdotcom818 · Jun 6, 2009#75
^

oooohhh! lotus elise sounds good!! 🤤
jambo101Montreal Canada · Jun 6, 2009#76
Solstice or Sky?
id3379Jun 6, 2009#77
My dad used to have a Mini Cooper S JCW, it was pretty fun, 215hp had super good handeling, but then he upgraded to a Subaru Sti :)
kimonaHuntington Bch, CA · Jun 6, 2009#78
I owned an MR2 Spyder and a couple of Miatas. Great cars! I wouldn't even consider the others on your list... not that Hondas aren't decent, but I just don't like Hondas.
marcusThread startertoronto, canada · Jun 7, 2009#79
Originally Posted by jambo101 ↑
Solstice or Sky?
i wouldnt buy a gm right now.. as for saturn ...solstice is way better the the sky version..
doublewamUSA · Jun 8, 2009#80
I always thought a Mini would be nice to own and thought I might break my new Honda/Toyota exclusivity policy one day and buy a used Mini. However, after watching that video about $10,000 transmission replacement with no option for repair, I think if someone gave me a Mini all I would do is sell it :)
oilman930Philadelphia, PA · Jun 9, 2009#81
Just watched the video of the women with the gearbox problems. It appears she has a 2006 Mini Cooper with the CVT transmission. When this transmission breaks down, it is changed out, not repaired. It's been a known weak point in the car's drivetrain for a while. Most of the CVT transmissions in the Mini last until 80,000 to 100,000 miles. This women had 120,000 km on her car which is 74,520 miles. The women is going to have to pay to have the transmission changed if she ever wants to drive the car again.

Mini recommends changing the CVT transmission fluid every 30,000 miles. According to the video, this was not done, ever. In the long run all it would of done is to extend the life of the CVT for a little longer. For new Mini Coopers, the CVT transmission has been replaced with a conventional automatic.

Most dealers today no longer bother with repairing broken parts such as transmissions, they are just replaced. It's not just Mini.
marcusThread startertoronto, canada · Jun 9, 2009#82
hmmmmm
doublewamUSA · Jun 9, 2009#83
Originally Posted by oilman930 ↑
Most dealers today no longer bother with repairing broken parts such as transmissions, they are just replaced. It's not just Mini.
That's fine I guess but $10,0000?!?!?!??!?
IllusionXBrossard, QC · Jun 9, 2009#84
marcus: if you were to get a mini S, get a 2008/2009. The reason why getting a newer mini is because their latest ones are twin turbo charged. 180-190HP (i can't have exact numbers as they seem to have changed since their first TUROB mini) of fun. Not to mention that you get 5.6L/100km highway and 7.4L/100km city... very close to a yaris :)
marcusThread startertoronto, canada · Jun 9, 2009#85
i think turbo got is up to 208hp for 2009.. doing average of 6.5 sec 0-60. 7.3sec for the previous sc model.

i think s2000 5.5 sec

elise 5.8 sec exige version 3.9 sec

miata about 7.5 sec

mr2 spyder about 7.0 sec
IllusionXBrossard, QC · Jun 9, 2009#87
Originally Posted by marcus ↑
i think turbo got is up to 208hp for 2009.. doing average of 6.5 sec 0-60. 7.3sec for the previous sc model.

i think s2000 5.5 sec

elise 5.8 sec exige version 3.9 sec

miata about 7.5 sec

mr2 spyder about 7.0 sec
I think the mini is a very good buy.. 200+HP, with gas consumption very close to a yaris... Can't really complain about it. lol
marcusThread startertoronto, canada · Jun 9, 2009#88
Originally Posted by jambo101 ↑
If all that matters is 0 to 60 times then you had better start looking for one of these.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of...y_acceleration
good find but were not rich here.. i guess the gtr is attainable for me but the rest is just cars for people with money to burn.. and i dont think ill buy a cars thats too old.. age does thing to some parts of the car even if they are on the highest end to begin with..
marcusThread startertoronto, canada · Jun 9, 2009#89
photos posted on first page..
marcusThread startertoronto, canada · Jun 11, 2009#90
yup..so far heres the list.

started with

mini cooper s
honda s2000
mazda miata mx5
toyota mr2 spyder
lotus elise had to throw this in.
350z ....

others
bmw z3 or z4
kimonaHuntington Bch, CA · Jun 26, 2009#91
Here's something to consider:

Highest Quality Cars of 2009 (Forbes.com - Hannah Elliott)

From the annual Initial Quality Study released today by market-research firm J.D. Power and Associates.

"Chrysler, Ford Motor and General Motors are showing marked improvement in the quality of their new vehicles--but you're still probably better off buying a Toyota."

"Of all cars, the MINI brand fared the worst in the study."
gokartrideTexas · Jun 26, 2009#92
I have had two MINIs since early 2003 and just traded my '07 Cooper in for a Yaris. I think in some ways the Yaris is more in the spirit of the classic Mini than a MINI is!!