Yarisworld Archive

Whats wrong with Rota's?

163 posts · 79,753 views · page 2 of 4

Replies continued

Pitt YarisPittsburgh · May 4, 2009#51
Originally Posted by BLAZINBLUEVITZ ↑
i must have fell off if KONIGS are knockoff's now😆
That's the response I got when I asked others if I should buy a set of Konigs. Like I said, I'm a wheel noob and I go by what others here say.
BLAZINBLUEVITZNEW YORK · May 4, 2009#52
Originally Posted by Pitt Yaris ↑
That's the response I got when I asked others if I should buy a set of Konigs. Like I said, I'm a wheel noob and I go by what others here say.
ive been under the impression this whole time since my first set in 1996 that KONIG was KING........
Pitt YarisPittsburgh · May 4, 2009#53
Originally Posted by BLAZINBLUEVITZ ↑
ive been under the impression this whole time since my first set in 1996 that KONIG was KING........
Maybe it depends on the model. I searched konigs and found a lot of 800+ wheels, then I found a lot of 400 set wheels. Who knows. I'll probably end up getting a set of the $400 konigs.
Russelt3hPirateEpcot · May 4, 2009#54
Originally Posted by Pitt Yaris ↑
Maybe it depends on the model. I searched konigs and found a lot of 800+ wheels, then I found a lot of 400 set wheels. Who knows. I'll probably end up getting a set of the $400 konigs.
not all konigs are knock offs, all of the ones that look good are knock offs. 🤣
Russelt3hPirateEpcot · May 4, 2009#55
Originally Posted by mastaofdisasta ↑
ordering these tonight, what are they a knockoff of????

Picture not included in this copy
GramLight 57F

Picture not included in this copy
BLAZINBLUEVITZNEW YORK · May 4, 2009#56
OUCH.....
mastaofdisastaThread starteramerika · May 4, 2009#57
haha i knew they were a knockoff of somein, i just didnt know what

Now i just gotta pick up some gram light center caps from ebay and hell ill be good to go 👍🤣
Russelt3hPirateEpcot · May 4, 2009#58
Originally Posted by mastaofdisasta ↑
haha i knew they were a knockoff of somein, i just didnt know what

Now i just gotta pick up some gram light center caps from ebay and hell ill be good to go 👍🤣
good luck with that.
TamagoOff Grid · May 4, 2009#59
they're not identical. it's not a knock off
Russelt3hPirateEpcot · May 4, 2009#60
Originally Posted by Tamago ↑
they're not identical. it's not a knock off
technically.

Visually rota stole the aesthetic design of the wheel to cater towards individuals who wanted to look the part of a better/more expensive wheel, or exploit the ignorance of the uninformed, and since that worked so well were able to sell wheels for cheap catering towards the frugal minded who know the design (visually) was stolen yet prefer to spend their hard earned money on a less expensive wheel that meets their needs.
Russelt3hPirateEpcot · May 4, 2009#61
EDIT: sorry I didn't waste anymore time finding a photo of the exact size/color wheel. :)
TamagoOff Grid · May 4, 2009#62
Originally Posted by Russelt3hPirate ↑
EDIT: sorry I didn't waste anymore time finding a photo of the exact size/color wheel. :)
still not identical, i'm not talking about size and color
Malaya1221Torrance, Ca · May 4, 2009#63
Originally Posted by Russelt3hPirate ↑
he frugal minded who know the design (visually) was stolen yet prefer to spend their hard earned money on a less expensive wheel that meets their needs.
reason why it's popular....

so as using p2p programs to download songs, movies and some porno flicks...🙂
Russelt3hPirateEpcot · May 4, 2009#64
Originally Posted by Malaya1221 ↑
reason why it's popular....

so as using p2p programs to download songs and movies...🙂
that's a biproduct of them being popular for the first reason, if they didn't sell as many for the first reason they wouldn't be cheap for the 3rd reason. haha.

oh well, most people have already chosen sides. :D
Malaya1221Torrance, Ca · May 4, 2009#65
what saddens me the most is, rota not "copying" hayashi, techno and other old school rare wheels...😁
Russelt3hPirateEpcot · May 4, 2009#66
Originally Posted by Malaya1221 ↑
what saddens me the most is, rota not "copying" hayashi, techno and other old school rare wheels...😁
why not just buy a set used. :)

there a few quality Used JDM wheel suppliers.
mastaofdisastaThread starteramerika · May 4, 2009#67
i like rotas because i also want to be able to afford tires, along with my wheel purchase
Russelt3hPirateEpcot · May 4, 2009#68
Originally Posted by mastaofdisasta ↑
i like rotas because i also want to be able to afford tires, along with my wheel purchase
tires are the most important thing, hopefully you're not skimping on those.
mastaofdisastaThread starteramerika · May 4, 2009#69
heh thats why im gettin rotas so i dont skimp on tires. Im taking my time tryin to get this setup right
ChinoCharlesOH · May 4, 2009#70
Im taking my time tryin to get this setup right
Best advice you can give on something like this. Don't be brash.
Nagoya_TRD.SoCal · May 4, 2009#71
Rotas are reverse engineered, subpar cast wheels = fail

Expensive japanese wheels are usually forged or use cold spun forged drums with cast center disks. American wheels like CCWs, or Fikses are full forged. Forged > Cast anyday of the week.

Rota does not have the tooling required to make proper 2 and 3 piece wheels. They do not have the tooling to make forged wheels. That would raise the price. Low pressure casting is the absolute bottom rung of wheel manufacturing technology which is what Rota uses.

80 percent of expensive japanese wheels are anodize finished and clearcoated and/or have a anodize lip. Anodize > Clearcoated or powdercoated finishes. Anodized finishes do not peel, or fade and hold up to scratches much better. They are sensitive to acid based wheel cleaners, that's about it (use only soap and water)

Without originators, rota and other knockoffs are fucked. That speaks volumes. They are the equivalent of automotive leeches.

Tell me when rota starts making wheels for formula cars and full sanctioned race quality wheels. Then i would consider them safe enough for my street car.

Every wheel goes through heat and stress cycles when they get raced, which is why teams buy multiple sets of wheels and cycle them frequently. After 1-2 years, they get sold off or throw away. Any wheel can crack from such stress cycles. Wheels that are forged, semi-solid forged, etc or have real research and development put into them will last quite a bit longer.

Looks and style are only skin deep.
TamagoOff Grid · May 4, 2009#72
Originally Posted by Nagoya_TRD. ↑

Tell me when rota starts making wheels for formula cars and full sanctioned race quality wheels.
and this is why i love Team Dynamics :)
2006frontySan Bernardino · May 4, 2009#73
Originally Posted by Tamago ↑
and this is why i love Team Dynamics :)
I was surprised that Team Dynamics wheels are really affordable
MouseMiami, Fl. · May 4, 2009#74
I think there are a couple of race teams in Thailand or the Phillipines that run rotas.

Team Dynamics + BTCC = Awesome wheels

If they can take the punishment of the BTCC....They can take anything. Plus they're cheap.
TamagoOff Grid · May 4, 2009#75
pssssssssssssssssssssssst they're cast wheels
jkuchtaL.A. · May 4, 2009#76
I've got a set of Rota J Mags mounted with Falken RT-615's for sale cheap in the "for sale" section!
TamagoOff Grid · May 4, 2009#77
Originally Posted by jkuchta ↑
I've got a set of Rota J Mags mounted with Falken RT-615's for sale cheap in the "for sale" section!
too bad they're insanely heavy hahaah
Nagoya_TRD.SoCal · May 4, 2009#78
Not all of the TRDynamics wheels are cast. They have forging and anodizing technology under their belt, and can make forged and cast wheels just like Enkei. It speaks volumes about the company that stands behind the products they sell.
Malaya1221Torrance, Ca · May 4, 2009#79
(1970'S)Chrysler-Mitsubishi, Ford, Daihatsu, Toyota, Datsun, Isuzu, Mercedes-Benz, Opel and Volkswagen would not use ROTA for their oem wheels if they're not of quality wheels.
TamagoOff Grid · May 4, 2009#80
Originally Posted by Malaya1221 ↑
(1970'S)Chrysler-Mitsubishi, Ford, Daihatsu, Toyota, Datsun, Isuzu, Mercedes-Benz, Opel and Volkswagen would not use ROTA for their oem wheels if they're not of quality wheels.
lol yeah because 1970's cars were of top quality 😆 😆 😆 😆 😆 😆 😆 😆 😆 😆 😆 😆 😆 😆 😆 😆 😆 😆 😆 😆 😆 😆 😆 😆 😆 😆 😆 😆 😆 😆 😆 😆 😆 😆 😆 😆 😆 😆 😆 😆 😆 😆
Malaya1221Torrance, Ca · May 4, 2009#81
they were!😉😁
TamagoOff Grid · May 4, 2009#82
Originally Posted by Thirty-Nine ↑
That's not true. There were plenty of decent vehicles in the 1970s. And so what? Rota was an OEM supplier.

Then again, this is just another thread bashing Rotas ...
i agree with you completely, there were plenty of DECENT vehicles in the 70's

😆😆😆😆
jkuchtaL.A. · May 4, 2009#83
Originally Posted by Tamago ↑
too bad they're insanely heavy hahaah
They're not that bad...and the sidewalls are stiff as hell....perfect for a mid-speed autocross course!
TamagoOff Grid · May 4, 2009#84
Originally Posted by jkuchta ↑
They're not that bad...and the sidewalls are stiff as hell....perfect for a mid-speed autocross course!
i'm a fan of the RT-615 for autocross for sure.. but mounted to a rota, it's kind of like a diamond ring on a little piglet lol
TamagoOff Grid · May 4, 2009#85
Originally Posted by Thirty-Nine ↑
Some might say any high-end wheel on a Yaris is the same thing. 😉
i completely agree.

i never said i'm pro jdm fanboi wheels. i just think that there are PLENTY of options out there that don't involve rota/drag/sportmax/xxr JUNK wheels.
Nagoya_TRD.SoCal · May 4, 2009#86
It's true, some OEM manufacturers IN THE PHILIPINES used Rota as oem wheels. Simple reason for this: OEM products are designed to cut costs to keep car costs low. They are not supposed to be nice and were never designed to be pushed (all the manufacturers who used rota as oem wheels used them on economy cars or commuters). These Rota wheels were never designed to be used on hard sports cars. Rota was a local company that was dirt cheap that would suffice for these OEM applications and maximize the profit for the big car manufacturers.

That is the main reason why most oem "alloy wheels" are gravity or low pressure cast.

Did Nissan ever use Rota for their OEM skyline GT-R wheels? No, they used BBS.

Does Mitsubishi use Rota for their OEM EVOLUTION wheels? No, They use BBS and Enkei.

Does Nissan use Rota for their Nismo 350Z, Nismo 370Z, 370Z, and R35 GT-R wheels? No, they use Rays engineering.
TamagoOff Grid · May 4, 2009#87
did ROTA used to build Konig wheels?


yes they did
Nagoya_TRD.SoCal · May 4, 2009#88
Picture not included in this copy

I like those Koenig Wheels.

Picture not included in this copy

Those i can do without.
TamagoOff Grid · May 4, 2009#89
Originally Posted by Nagoya_TRD. ↑
Picture not included in this copy

I like those Koenig Wheels.
please dont confuse koenig with konig
TamagoOff Grid · May 4, 2009#90
koenig=serious fabrication

Picture not included in this copy

konig = rebadged rotas

Picture not included in this copy
Nagoya_TRD.SoCal · May 4, 2009#91
Originally Posted by Thirty-Nine ↑
You're 100% right. And when I'm shelling out that kind of money for a car, I would expect it to have BBS, Volks, Enkei, and such kinds of wheels. But you just said it in bold above. Like I said, a low-pressure, gravity-cast aluminum wheel is going to be fine for most people, and that includes most Yaris owners. Most people putting custom wheels on their cars are driving them to work, to the grocery store, and such. I'd bet the number of wheels that get pushed to limits where a forged wheel would actually make a difference are less than 1%, and probably even less so on a Yaris.
Even then, not all wheels are round. Each manufacturer has a different casting procedures, and strengths for the materials that they use. Using Rotas to putt around town is different from using Rotas for "driving". A cast racing dynamics or enkei wheel is not going to have the same strength as a Konig/XXR/Rota wheel.

When i shell out cash to "upgrade" my wheels, i want an UPGRADE, not something that is the same as the OEM wheels, just with a different LOOK. Just my .02

But, i think this thread pretty much explains why most serious performance teams/drivers/owners don't really care much rotas for performance.
TamagoOff Grid · May 4, 2009#92
Originally Posted by Thirty-Nine ↑
Does Konig really resell Rota products or are they simply similar? I don't know if Konig actually makes any wheels, though. They're all coming out of a few factories in Asia. Rota produces in The Philippines; a lot of Konig products come out of Taiwan (at least mine did).
i have a set of konig wheels circa 1998 that are stamped ROTA on the rear face
TamagoOff Grid · May 4, 2009#93
Originally Posted by Malaya1221 ↑
tamago koenig = 😆

not sure what that means but koenig = serious fabrication geniuses.
Malaya1221Torrance, Ca · May 4, 2009#95
Originally Posted by Tamago ↑
not sure what that means but koenig = serious fabrication geniuses.
nevermind....was looking at some other things...r they the same company as koenig competition?
GnomeBodyUS-V.A. · May 5, 2009#96
I hate to jump back so many pages but...

Rotas suck ass b/c they blatantly steal their designs from reputable manufactures to cater towards the individuals who want the "look" of expensive wheels but don't want the spend it (for whatever reason, viable or not).
I have to disagree. Rotas dont suck because they borrow a "look" from another company. Thats like saying you look like shit in a red t-shirt because I started wearing red t-shirts first.

If I were in the hat making business and my competition Started selling a very popular "Top hat" style, why the hell wouldn't I want to sell top hats too, especially if I could do it for cheaper. Im sure there are alot of "poor" people who would love to be able to afford the latest stlye.

If there is anything to be said about rota versus another company it should be about the construction quality VS. the price tag
Russelt3hPirateEpcot · May 5, 2009#97
Originally Posted by GnomeBody ↑
I hate to jump back so many pages but...



I have to disagree. Rotas dont suck because they borrow a "look" from another company. Thats like saying you look like shit in a red t-shirt because I started wearing red t-shirts first.

If I were in the hat making business and my competition Started selling a very popular "Top hat" style, why the hell wouldn't I want to sell top hats too, especially if I could do it for cheaper. Im sure there are alot of "poor" people who would love to be able to afford the latest stlye.

If there is anything to be said about rota versus another company it should be about the construction quality VS. the price tag
AHAHA 👏

lets take a very detailed product and compare it to a single color T-shirt. 👍

ultimately Rota still sucks b/c they can't come up with their own "VISUAL" designs. 🤣
schleppyBoston, MA · May 5, 2009#98
I don't know why everyone craps on Rota all the time. Being a former Subaru guy, I'm used to hearing more good than bad about Rota. Rotas were immensely popular with the Suby guys. Between myself and my friends we've run at least 10+ different sets of Rotas without a single issue. I personally ran three different sets.

Are there stronger/lighter/better wheels out there? Sure. Are Rotas absolute crap? In my experience, not at all. For the price they are great.

Just my 2c
Russelt3hPirateEpcot · May 5, 2009#99
Originally Posted by schleppy ↑
I don't know why everyone craps on Rota all the time. Being a former Subaru guy, I'm used to hearing more good than bad about Rota. Rotas were immensely popular with the Suby guys. Between myself and my friends we've run at least 10+ different sets of Rotas without a single issue. I personally ran three different sets.

Are there stronger/lighter/better wheels out there? Sure. Are Rotas absolute crap? In my experience, not at all. For the price they are great.

Just my 2c
10+ isn't a very good global sample set, but honestly I'm glad nothing happened.

when a wheel "fails" it's supposed to stay in one piece. it hurts to see the photos of the wheels where the hoop separates.....
GnomeBodyUS-V.A. · May 5, 2009#100
lets take a very detailed product and compare it to a single color T-shirt.
What? you dont like red?


well anyway, the point was that no one has exclusive rights to a style.

Frankly, I think Rota is business smart for recreating 'Popular' designs and selling them at reasonable prices( assuming there not breaking patents or copyrights) Rather than wasting money on R&D for a custom line that might not sell as well.