Yarisworld Archive

Tamago's guide to ultimate yaris handling

99 posts · 460,942 views · page 1 of 2

TamagoOriginal postOff Grid · Feb 19, 2009#1
the information given in this post is here merely to provide a starting point for your future autocross or road racing endeavors. this is not the end-all-be-all of information on the yaris. as i come across exact situations related directly to the yaris i will add them to this post

1 attachment not included in this copy

Replies 98

cleongSingapore · Feb 19, 2009#2
Just to highlight - the Yaris has a front stabilizer bar/anti-roll bar/swaybar.
eTiMaGoBangkok, Thailand · Feb 19, 2009#3
great writeup, thanks!
TamagoThread starterOff Grid · Feb 19, 2009#4
edited: i completely spaced out the front alignment ;)
LorenSafety Harbor, FL · Feb 19, 2009#5
It is SO rare to see someone get all the details right for a change. Kudos!

I would add that alignment is a very personal thing, and that if you're searching for performance outside of the "stock alignment" envelope, you're going to have to experiment. What works for someone else might not work for you because even if the car is identical, the driving style might not be.

I've been running 2.5-2.8 degrees of negative camber in the front with no tire wear issues, FWIW. And my experience was that zero front toe made the car wander far too much for my tastes, so I ended up going with about 1/16" of toe-in.

I haven't messed with the rear alignment on my Yaris, but I did on my old Saturn. (which was factory-adjustable for camber and toe, unlike the Yaris) Be VERY careful with rear toe-out. A little bit goes a LONG way. About the smallest amount of toe-out that you can measure (1/32-1/16" maybe?) will be enough to make the car feel like the rear is steering around a sweeping turn. The yaw angle will feel just like you're about to lose the back end, it's freaky!

Lastly, I'm not sure I like the idea of using washers to adjust the rear alignment. I've seen a lengthy engineer's discussion on why wheels that use conical lugs are not hubcentric (and thus don't need those silly plastic spacers that don't do anything, anyway... but, I'll try not to digress). What it comes down to is that the lugs hold the wheel against the hub. The lugs themselves can't and won't support the weight of the car! It's the friction between the wheel and the hub (held in place by the meager torque of the lugs) that supports the weight of the car. I can't help but think that the hub-to-axle interface works the same way. By sticking a washer in there, you're eliminating the large friction area that's supporting the hub and putting most of the stress on the bolts, which weren't designed to handle it. I think the proper solution here would be a machined alignment shim that will cover the whole friction area of the hub/axle joint and maintain the friction that is meant to support the hub.

Probably the biggest thing that anyone who's serious about suspension tuning should take away from this is far simpler, however: "too low" and "too stiff" are very real possibilities and can hurt your handling far more than they help it!
TamagoThread starterOff Grid · Feb 19, 2009#6
Originally Posted by Loren ↑
It is SO rare to see someone get all the details right for a change. Kudos!

I would add that alignment is a very personal thing, and that if you're searching for performance outside of the "stock alignment" envelope, you're going to have to experiment. What works for someone else might not work for you because even if the car is identical, the driving style might not be.

I've been running 2.5-2.8 degrees of negative camber in the front with no tire wear issues, FWIW. And my experience was that zero front toe made the car wander far too much for my tastes, so I ended up going with about 1/16" of toe-in.

I haven't messed with the rear alignment on my Yaris, but I did on my old Saturn. (which was factory-adjustable for camber and toe, unlike the Yaris) Be VERY careful with rear toe-out. A little bit goes a LONG way. About the smallest amount of toe-out that you can measure (1/32-1/16" maybe?) will be enough to make the car feel like the rear is steering around a sweeping turn. The yaw angle will feel just like you're about to lose the back end, it's freaky!

Lastly, I'm not sure I like the idea of using washers to adjust the rear alignment. I've seen a lengthy engineer's discussion on why wheels that use conical lugs are not hubcentric (and thus don't need those silly plastic spacers that don't do anything, anyway... but, I'll try not to digress). What it comes down to is that the lugs hold the wheel against the hub. The lugs themselves can't and won't support the weight of the car! It's the friction between the wheel and the hub (held in place by the meager torque of the lugs) that supports the weight of the car. I can't help but think that the hub-to-axle interface works the same way. By sticking a washer in there, you're eliminating the large friction area that's supporting the hub and putting most of the stress on the bolts, which weren't designed to handle it. I think the proper solution here would be a machined alignment shim that will cover the whole friction area of the hub/axle joint and maintain the friction that is meant to support the hub.

Probably the biggest thing that anyone who's serious about suspension tuning should take away from this is far simpler, however: "too low" and "too stiff" are very real possibilities and can hurt your handling far more than they help it!
all good information, and i'm addressing the part that's bold.

bold portion 1: i agree, toe out will definitely change the way the car turns. you will definitely want to experiment with toe-out (mine is toe-out but still within factory allowable specs) at slower speeds before hopping on the highway.


bold portion 2: when adding a thin washer between the axle and hub, your hub is still inset into the axle. the pilot of the hub/axle is still in full contact with each other, therefore the weight is still being carried by the hub itself, and not the bolts.
TheRealEnthMiami, FL · Feb 19, 2009#7
bumpin;
largeorangefontSo Cal, OC · Feb 19, 2009#8
Good post.
botchilahPhilippines · Feb 19, 2009#9
Nice to see very good technical info sans BS / useless comments from the pros :)
turboyarisSouthern New Jersey · Feb 20, 2009#10
i gotta interject, as far as tire pressures and camber is concerned.... I would say you would be wise, in investing in a tire pyrometer. Longacre makes some basic models for 100-150$. This will allow you to take tire temps at the outer side/middle/ inner side and determine that if the middle is higher then the outer and inner side your tire pressure is too high and you need to reduce... Likewise, if the outer edge temp is higher then the inner edge temp, you want to add more negative camber. basically with this method, you get much easier quantitative data to help determine what to do.

As for using this with autocross, a quick little self made track, should get you enough data to setup your camber and tire pressures properly.


This process will get you theoretically ideal setup, however, if you need to compensate for another handling issue, then adding or subtracting camber or tire pressures may be needed.
whooppee777Maryland · Feb 20, 2009#11
BEST THREAD EVER!
CtrlAltDefeatIndianapolis IN · Feb 20, 2009#12
thank you so much for the info... 👍
LorenSafety Harbor, FL · Feb 20, 2009#13
Tamago, I thought about the hub/axle interface some more, and concluded that the forces at play there are NOT like the forces put on the mating surface of the wheels. The wheels are pushed almost straight UP when they receive their greatest forces (hitting a hard bump). The hub junction is effectively being bent upwards at an angle rather than forced straight up. The major forces should be on the lower hub bolts, which are probably pretty beefy high-grade bolts. So, with that, I'll rescind my previously stated concern... thin high-grade washers used there should be okay for adjusting the rear alignment. Thanks for setting me straight and making me think about it some more!

Hmmm... now do I want to mess with it?
eTiMaGoBangkok, Thailand · Feb 20, 2009#14
Originally Posted by Loren ↑
Hmmm... now do I want to mess with it?
I'll take it that is a rhetorical question 😁
largeorangefontSo Cal, OC · Feb 20, 2009#15
Originally Posted by Loren ↑
Tamago, I thought about the hub/axle interface some more, and concluded that the forces at play there are NOT like the forces put on the mating surface of the wheels. The wheels are pushed almost straight UP when they receive their greatest forces (hitting a hard bump). The hub junction is effectively being bent upwards at an angle rather than forced straight up. The major forces should be on the lower hub bolts, which are probably pretty beefy high-grade bolts. So, with that, I'll rescind my previously stated concern... thin high-grade washers used there should be okay for adjusting the rear alignment. Thanks for setting me straight and making me think about it some more!

Hmmm... now do I want to mess with it?
Yes you do. I did on the old solid axle CRXs. It worked great.
at3GGVA Beach · Feb 20, 2009#16
.....yes....yes you do. But only if you report back to us!
ddongbaphay · Feb 20, 2009#17
Damn Loren.

You talking about how changing the toe just a little bit would get it to rotate better got me wet.
TheRealEnthMiami, FL · Feb 20, 2009#18
LMAO thats sick
mikenacaratoBrentwood, TN · Feb 20, 2009#19
good thread! :)
LorenSafety Harbor, FL · Feb 20, 2009#20
Originally Posted by PK198105 ↑
don't forget however that changing your camber, toe in/out will affect the lifetime of your tires. Tamago you wrote so much im not sure you mentioned this (my fault probably i fat read your post)
Done properly, it won't necessarily affect the wear of your tires. In fact, depending on your driving style, it could IMPROVE your tire wear.

I'm running factory alignment in the rear (-0.9 camber, slight toe-in), and -2.5 camber in the front with very slight toe-in. My tire wear is very event all around. If I DIDN'T have all that front camber, my front tires would be wearing on the outside edges.

Excessive toe, especially when coupled with agressive camber will cause tire wear issues. But, with neutral toe settings, up to 3 degrees of camber is not a problem even on a daily-driven vehicle.

(trivia: The factory alignment on the rear of my Triumph is 3 degrees negative camber)
LorenSafety Harbor, FL · Feb 20, 2009#21
Originally Posted by ddongbap ↑
Damn Loren.

You talking about how changing the toe just a little bit would get it to rotate better got me wet.
Yeah, I'm sexy like that. You should hear me talk about rev-matching and heel-toe downshifting.
SEVENPuerto Rico · Feb 20, 2009#22
Originally Posted by Tamago ↑

basic "autocross setup" springs... if you're gonna autocross, and you've installed lowering springs, please get a set of shocks that were built to be coupled with a lowering spring. stock struts and "lower" springs just don't fit into autocross land.[/size]
will tein s.techs and trd shocks work???
LorenSafety Harbor, FL · Feb 20, 2009#23
Originally Posted by SEVEN ↑
will tein s.techs and trd shocks work???
What you'll eventually conclude with that setup and really think about it is that a) you don't have enough suspension travel so you bottom out both in hard turns and over bumps and b) the shocks don't sufficiently control the motion of the springs on rebound.

Will it "work"? Yes, but not if you want the car to handle as good as it could.
SEVENPuerto Rico · Feb 21, 2009#24
Are there TEIN shocks for yaris??? I can't find any ...
cleongSingapore · Feb 21, 2009#25
Cusco does make a front anti sway bar (part no. 900 311 A26). So its available for a price should you feel the need for it. As I cannot read Japanese I cannot say if it is stiffer than stock or not.

I found that running too much negative camber on skinny street tires reduces its off-the-line traction. It might not really hurt acceleration that much but it seems easier to get the tires to break loose.
ChinoCharlesOH · Feb 21, 2009#26
Bravo Tamago.
LorenSafety Harbor, FL · Feb 21, 2009#27
Originally Posted by PK198105 ↑
thanks for clarifying Loren. I just though since you're changing the vertical angle (camber) the contact patch will be offset to either side.
Well, it does, but it's just not enough to be a problem unless you combine it with too much toe.

Running 2 degrees of camber with mild toe settings and doing strictly highway miles might result in 2mm more wear on the inside of the tire vs the outside. Of course, if you do strictly highway driving, you don't NEED that much camber! If you have that much camber, it's probably because you do some mountain driving, or autocross, or track driving... and that performance driving is going to largely equalize the wear. You might still see maybe 1mm more wear on the inside vs. the outside... but who cares? That's close enough.
LorenSafety Harbor, FL · Feb 21, 2009#28
Originally Posted by cleong ↑
Cusco does make a front anti sway bar (part no. 900 311 A26). So its available for a price should you feel the need for it. As I cannot read Japanese I cannot say if it is stiffer than stock or not.
The last thing you want on a FWD car is a larger front swaybar. It would just require you to stiffen the rear that much more to reach something close to "neutral" rather than "obscene understeer".

The only reason Cusco makes it is because people who don't know any better WILL buy it... not because anyone really needs it.
TamagoThread starterOff Grid · Feb 21, 2009#29
Originally Posted by eTiMaGo ↑
I'll take it that is a rhetorical question 😁
talk to Russell teh Pirate, i helped set up their yaris :)
cleongSingapore · Feb 21, 2009#30
We can't be certain of that fact which is why I stated the bar was available but can't speak for its effects. If it would make the car understeer worse like you say it would, then if you took the front anti roll bar off, would it cure the understeer without having to fit a rear anti roll bar?

I think it is possible that a correct front anti roll bar would reduce front roll, and optimize the tire contact patch in the corners, because too much roll unloads the inside tires. I'm not saying the Cusco would do it, because I've never tried it, but it is a tuning option that should be tried before being written off.
TamagoThread starterOff Grid · Feb 21, 2009#31
Originally Posted by PK198105 ↑
don't forget however that changing your camber, toe in/out will affect the lifetime of your tires. Tamago you wrote so much im not sure you mentioned this (my fault probably i fat read your post)
yes, it will.. absolutely.

this guide is to help those who are interested in handling, before tire longevity, etc etc.
TamagoThread starterOff Grid · Feb 21, 2009#32
Originally Posted by turboyaris ↑
i gotta interject, .

stolen word for word and added to the guide.

keep the good info coming guys!
LorenSafety Harbor, FL · Feb 21, 2009#33
Originally Posted by cleong ↑
We can't be certain of that fact which is why I stated the bar was available but can't speak for its effects. If it would make the car understeer worse like you say it would, then if you took the front anti roll bar off, would it cure the understeer without having to fit a rear anti roll bar?
Yes, we can be certain that fitting a stiffer front swaybar (with no other changes) will make the car understeer more. That's just simple suspension physics at work. That's just the way it is.

And, yes, removing the front swaybar would probably make the car understeer less (it's been done on some FWD cars with success), but while it might have higher cornering limits, the steering would feel very "sloppy" and it wouldn't be enjoyable to drive. One absolute truth about suspension tuning: It's always a compromise.

I think it is possible that a correct front anti roll bar would reduce front roll, and optimize the tire contact patch in the corners, because too much roll unloads the inside tires.
Body roll is not the "evil" that so many people think it is. Look at some of the best handling cars in the world... a Lotus Elise, for example... lots of body roll. Even purpose built race cars have some body roll in as much as their suspension moves. (look at an F1 car full-on in a corner, the outside is compressed visibly more than the outside) Body roll isn't bad. It's a by-product of weight transfer. What you want is control of that roll (good damping), and balance of the weight transfer (spring rates and sway bar rates).

If eliminating all body roll was the answer, every race car and high-end performance car would have NO body roll. Eliminating more body roll (with a larger front swaybar) at the expense of moving the handling balance of the car further in the wrong direction is no solution.

This whole discussion is much like arguing about lowering springs with ricers. They think that "lower is better" no matter what... and "stiffer and flatter" is better no matter what. It's simply not true.

I'm not saying the Cusco would do it, because I've never tried it, but it is a tuning option that should be tried before being written off.
I've not tried it on a Yaris, but most of my suspension tuning knowledge does come from experience. One of the first suspension mods I did to my Saturn when I started autocrossing was to put a bigger front swaybar on it. Same reason everyone else wants to: to get rid of the body roll. I then spent the next 3 years finding ways to eliminate the understeer that it caused. I was stubborn and refused to remove the front bar that I'd spent good money on, which would have solved the problem instantly. (as a side note, the Saturn S-Series cars had two swaybar options, the twin cam front bar was larger than the single cam bar... and the twin cam had a rear bar whereas the single cam had none... the hot ticket is simply putting the smaller front bar onto a twin cam car!) To balance the larger front bar, I ended up having to put a rear bar on that was so stiff that it actually BENT the stock rear end link mounts.

Wanna play with what removing the front swaybar would do? It's easy, just remove an end link on one side. The other side will hold the bar in place and keep it from flopping around, but with one side disconnected, the bar will have no effect. Very simple experiment. Somebody do it and report back. (maybe I'll do it when I have time)

If you have a stiff coilover suspension, you might get away without the front swaybar. I tuned the suspension on my old Miata with really stiff springs and NO swaybars. People thought I was nuts, but I wanted to prove that it could be done. It took really stiff front springs to get it to feel right, of course.
cleongSingapore · Feb 22, 2009#34
But similarly with tire pressures, generally softer yields better traction. Yet you could go too soft and cause tire contact deformity, or too hard, which causes lack of tread compliance. Hence optimizing is the key, what you have called compromises. But I respect your experience, which I do not have. If I manage to get my hands on this Cusco bar, I'll report back with what I found, at least it'll help others make a more informed decision.
LorenSafety Harbor, FL · Feb 22, 2009#35
Adjusting tire pressures does two things: adjusts the shape of the tire's contact patch, and adjusts the effective "spring rate" of the tire.

Today's high-end performance tires have SO much reinforcement of the tread area that tire pressure has little effect on the shape of the contact patch. It stays flat no matter what. If you're on craptastic all-season tires, you might see some change in the contact patch with pressure. (but this thread isn't for those people!)

The change in effective spring rate of the tire, as long as you don't distort the contact patch too much, is primarily what we feel with our tire pressure changes when we're tuning a car. We work within the "window" of pressures that the contact patch stays flat in. (with a good performance tire, that can be a big window... like the Azenis... easily 30-50 psi!) Within that window, you're simply fine-tuning a spring rate that has the same effects as changing any other "spring rate" in the suspension.

So, whether you're adjusting tire pressure, spring rate, sway bar rate or shock damping, the general effects are the same:
Stiffen the front = create more understeer or less oversteer
Soften the front = create less understeer or more oversteer
Stiffen the rear = create more oversteer or less understeer
Soften the rear = create less oversteer or more understeer

Those are the facts. You can look them up in any suspension tuning book or even on one of a thousand different suspension tuning guides that you might find on the internet.

Knowing that, if you NEED to fit that larger front swaybar to prove it to yourself, go for it. There really is no substitute for experience. I'm all for experimentation that will help people learn and quantify what suspension changes really do. I just hate to see people waste money on parts that aren't going to help them. Do the cheap or free experiments first... like playing with tire pressures... disconnecting the front swaybar... stuff like that.

Those cheap rubber donut spring spacers that you can get from JC Whitney for like $20 a set are a GREAT experimentation tool. Toss a set of those on your springs... take some measurements and figure out what you've changed the spring rate to, and document the results. (I tried a pair on the rear of my Yaris, my calcs said it raised the spring rate from about 2.0 kg to 2.5 kg... it was a happy understeer-reducing change, just like it was supposed to be, and it's why I never wanted to fit the 2.2 kg rear springs that came with my K-Sport kit)
id3379Feb 22, 2009#36
Originally Posted by eTiMaGo ↑
great writeup, thanks!
👍
markitectMichigan · Feb 23, 2009#37
First off awesome writeup!!!!!!!!!!!

I have one question though, for those looking to stay in HS what shocks/struts work well with stock springs? Any side affects with that combination?

Most are designed to be paired with lowering springs so it seems like this would affect their range of motion (I need something that can go over potholes). Of course if anyone knows of reasonably priced adjustable ones let me know.
TamagoThread starterOff Grid · Feb 23, 2009#38
Originally Posted by markitect ↑
First off awesome writeup!!!!!!!!!!!

I have one question though, for those looking to stay in HS what shocks/struts work well with stock springs? Any side affects with that combination?

Most are designed to be paired with lowering springs so it seems like this would affect their range of motion (I need something that can go over potholes). Of course if anyone knows of reasonably priced adjustable ones let me know.
i would imagine that the TRD shocks would fair well with stock suspension, since TRD is for their mild 1"ish drop.

R comps will take you a lot further than shocks in HS though IMO

also, keep in mind, if you run a "shorter" shock with stock spring, you'll be compressing the stock spring beyond its original setting, thereby raising your static spring rate :D which isn't bad, but may get you kicked out of HS in a nationals environment. (not that an HS mini is gonna be scared of a yaris.......... )
LorenSafety Harbor, FL · Feb 23, 2009#39
Hmmm... in SCCA stock class, you can't change the springs or alter the ride height. Dampers are otherwise unlimited... Hmmm...

Seems to me that you could get a generic race shock to replace the rear shocks on the Yaris pretty easily. It's just an eye at the bottom and pin at the top, very common configuration. Get something that you can dial in really some really stiff compression damping for autocrossing and it should do a world of good for reducing understeer.

That, plus maxing out the front camber, and the tires mentioned above... that should do a pretty good job of challenging the competition.

footnote: One of the caveats of the "shocks are free" rule is that you can't alter the spring perch height. Since the spring perches aren't part of the Yaris rear shocks... you should be free to replace those rear shocks with ANYTHING.
TamagoThread starterOff Grid · Feb 23, 2009#40
..... and getting the yaris to rotate is by far the most important thing in stock class :D

it's a shame you won't get any real camber out of the front though :(
markitectMichigan · Feb 24, 2009#41
Originally Posted by Loren ↑
Seems to me that you could get a generic race shock to replace the rear shocks on the Yaris pretty easily.
I hadn't thought about that, sounds like I have some measuring to do before May.
2006frontySan Bernardino · Feb 25, 2009#42
Originally Posted by Loren ↑

Seems to me that you could get a generic race shock to replace the rear shocks on the Yaris pretty easily.
Originally Posted by markitect ↑
I hadn't thought about that, sounds like I have some measuring to do before May.
I've looked at the rear shocks and it does seem pretty easy get a shock that fits, Radflo makes a GREAT race shock and they'll make shocks to your dimensions (collapsed and extended lengths) I've ran several sets of their shocks on my previous trucks. The front would be more of a task considering the mount from the strut to the knuckle would have to be figured out. 2.5 inch diameter race shocks on all 4 corners of a Yaris would be fun (well maybe 2.0's would be more reasonable haha)An External reservoir or internal floating piston shock would be nice.

1 attachment not included in this copy

rob323Joyner, Brisbane · Mar 3, 2009#43
Originally Posted by 2006fronty ↑
An External reservoir or internal floating piston shock would be nice.
Very nice infact 😁.
Picture not included in this copy
Picture not included in this copy

Now I just have to save up to get the same on the fronts 🙁
2006frontySan Bernardino · Mar 3, 2009#44
Ohlins right^^^^^^^??? I'm pretty sure that's how they set up their external reservoirs.
tk-421Dagobah · Mar 3, 2009#46
Question: How would 10mm rear hub spacers affect handling?
kngrsllSpartanburg, SC · Mar 3, 2009#47
Originally Posted by tk-421 ↑
Question: How would 10mm rear hub spacers affect handling?
i have been meaning to look this up as well.
LorenSafety Harbor, FL · Mar 3, 2009#48
Wider track usually means more grip (for various reasons). So, widening the track in the rear would make the rear stick better. Not really what most of us are fighting for, with a FWD car, you want more grip in the front.

The rear hub spacers are purely a cosmetic mod. (not to be confused with alignment shims)
kngrsllSpartanburg, SC · Mar 3, 2009#49
Originally Posted by Loren ↑
Wider track usually means more grip (for various reasons). So, widening the track in the rear would make the rear stick better. Not really what most of us are fighting for, with a FWD car, you want more grip in the front.

The rear hub spacers are purely a cosmetic mod. (not to be confused with alignment shims)
ah, thats right... i remember a friend of mine use to use them on the front when he would autox (SE-R, fwd).

im still working on this shocks thing, i have to turn in a research proposal this week and its consuming all my time! :(
d1nzfeasia · Mar 22, 2009#50
Originally Posted by rob323 ↑
Very nice infact 😁.
Picture not included in this copy
Picture not included in this copy

Now I just have to save up to get the same on the fronts 🙁
whats so different when its invented?
😕

ooops.... just saw the canister! its remoted and camouflaged!