Yarisworld Archive

OMG MY K&N FILTER!!!

81 posts · 24,108 views · page 2 of 2

Replies continued

ChinoCharlesOH · Feb 27, 2009#51
Originally Posted by ddongbap ↑
Not that I'm trying to disprove this or anything, then what causes brand new MAFs to fail?
Poor design. MAF circuit boards are sealed w/ silicon, and they are connected directly to the underlying hardware. Engine heat and general wear and tear can cause the plastics of a MAF sensor to degrade and allow some of that silicon to coat the thermistors and other good bits. This is usually the cause of "dirty" sensors... it actually comes from the sensor itself.
1stToyotaOklahoma · Feb 27, 2009#52
Originally Posted by ChinoCharles ↑
Pop quiz: What element of the Yaris's MAF could POSSIBLY get dirty enough to cause issues?

A: The mirror!

Yarii have a Karman Vortex-style MAF. It works via a mirror located in the stalk of the sensor. Air is redirected up the stalk and against a tiny little mirror, and the oscillations of that mirror are measured via a photoreceiver that receives LED light that is reflected off the mirror.

SO, you guys are telling me that oil from a filter is going to make it all the way up the stalk of the MAF, contaminate it, and then the filter is going to let in enough dirt (which is also magically going to take a trip up the stalk of the sensor) and ruin it, too?

No, it won't. That is why Toyota uses these MAF's and have for decades. They are reliable. That is to say nothing of the fact that properly installed oiled filters do nothing to air flow sensors in the first place.

You guys are arguing urban legend. It comes up here about once a year, and it gets shot down every single time.

Thanks. I'll look for one of those at the next StarTrek convention. 😉

I just pulled mine out, it's not as fangled as you make it sound. Look at it. Airflow is directed straight up into the sensor, across the 2 wires that MEASURE the AIRFLOW, passes on thru the sensor and down into the main airflow to the throttle body.

And the main thing that needs to be remembered is that it's not downstream a foot or two, it sits directly above the filter, mounted right on the airbox.
ChinoCharlesOH · Feb 27, 2009#53
Its the simplest air flow meter that I know of.
TamagoOff Grid · Feb 27, 2009#54
Originally Posted by ChinoCharles ↑
Poor design. MAF circuit boards are sealed w/ silicon, and they are connected directly to the underlying hardware. Engine heat and general wear and tear can cause the plastics of a MAF sensor to degrade and allow some of that silicon to coat the thermistors and other good bits. This is usually the cause of "dirty" sensors... it actually comes from the sensor itself.
they also do not react very well to voltage destabilization. lots of improper wiring or a loud sound system will kill a MAF pretty quickly. i saw at least 3 MAF's replaced in a few months while at toyota, all on cars with ghetto-rigged wiring
1stToyotaOklahoma · Feb 27, 2009#55
Originally Posted by ChinoCharles ↑
Its the simplest air flow meter that I know of.
Keyword: air flow ...not a lazer light show held at the hall of mirrors. 😁
ChinoCharlesOH · Feb 27, 2009#56
Keep trying to take the focus off the fact that you vehemently argued the world was flat for most of this thread. 😆

With that, I'm out. -drops mic-
33OHDover, Ohio · Feb 27, 2009#57
Originally Posted by 1stToyota ↑
had a brand new K&N dropin that must have been over-oiled enough that it set a code and couldn't get much over 50% calculated engine load at WOT, until I cleaned the MAF and switched to a WIX filter...code didn't come back and saw well over 80% calculated engine load at WOT on my scanner's datastream.
You're not supposed to use ALL of the oil. 😆
1stToyotaOklahoma · Feb 27, 2009#58
Originally Posted by ryank ↑
You're not supposed to use ALL of the oil. 😆
It was a customer that pulled the filter right out of the box and straight into the airbox of his Avalon. He didn't add adrop of oil that wasn't already there.
33OHDover, Ohio · Feb 27, 2009#59
They don't send you pre-oiled filters? When I bought my K&N it came dry, with a bottle of oil with it.

Picture not included in this copy
1stToyotaOklahoma · Feb 27, 2009#60
Originally Posted by ChinoCharles ↑
Keep trying to take the focus off the fact that you vehemently argued the world was flat for most of this thread. 😆

With that, I'm out. -drops mic-
All you had to do is actually LOOK at the MAF meter to see how well the air flow is directed straight across the wires that measure the air flow.
TamagoOff Grid · Feb 27, 2009#61
Originally Posted by 1stToyota ↑
Keyword: air flow ...not a lazer light show held at the hall of mirrors. 😁
so then since you're the expert, explain how the sensor measures air flow
1stToyotaOklahoma · Feb 27, 2009#62
Originally Posted by Tamago ↑
so then since you're the expert, explain how the sensor measures air flow
The heated wires measure the air flow entering the motor, PCM measures their frequency. Mirrors SEEING invisible air is a new one on me.
ChinoCharlesOH · Feb 27, 2009#63
WRONG, try again.
TamagoOff Grid · Feb 27, 2009#64
Originally Posted by 1stToyota ↑
The heated wires measure the air flow entering the motor, PCM measures their frequency. Mirrors SEEING invisible air is a new one on me.
you're thinking ford hotwire here

you're wrong
1stToyotaOklahoma · Feb 27, 2009#65
Originally Posted by ChinoCharles ↑
WRONG, try again.
Tell that to the Yaris owner here that recently asked what was wrong with his Yaris because it's down on power. Most posters jumped in and guess dirty meter. Guess what? Poster stated that he cleaned MAF and now everything is back as should be.

I wonder what he cleaned? Mirrors and lazer beams? No. Dirty wires. :)
1stToyotaOklahoma · Feb 27, 2009#66
Originally Posted by Tamago ↑
you're thinking ford hotwire here

you're wrong
Wrong. Talking about EXPOSED wires.
ChinoCharlesOH · Feb 27, 2009#67
Wires don't measure flow on the Yaris, they measure air temperature.

OK, seriously, I'm done. LOL no point in arguing with someone who knows all the wrong answers.
TamagoOff Grid · Feb 27, 2009#68
and you let this fuckery continue but lock up a poll that really was just a little joke..


mod power!!
1stToyotaOklahoma · Feb 27, 2009#69
Originally Posted by ChinoCharles ↑
Wires don't measure flow on the Yaris, they measure air temperature.

OK, seriously, I'm done. LOL no point in arguing with someone who knows all the wrong answers.
You do realize that the sensor might serve two functions? Wires in the air flow path, up in the sensor, and a reddish blob hanging down in a more direct air flow path...

I need to hear more about those jiggling mirrors that are no where to be found, that send lazer beams to photo receivers.
YaribhiniUSA · Feb 27, 2009#70
Ignorance is bliss I guess. I mean, why not believe everything that you read? Just in general, here is one example of many done by Jim Conforti testing both filtration and flow. But as a matter of conversation prior to the Conforti clip let my just say that
stock is good. K&N will flow a BIT more when freshly cleaned up but will also clog quickly, reducing flow.

Cotton doesn't filter as well as paper filter media and allows silicium in the engine's oil. There are multiple tests and studies that have shown this and it plainly points to how much BS is rampant in the world of aftermarket performance parts, and how inflated the claims given can be. Think for a moment the claims you read about HP gains from this or that modification and it's also a reminder of how we "enthusiasts" have a tendency to assume ANYTHING non-stock is better performance wise than whatever the OEM manufacterer provided. Clearly that is not always true.

As mentioned there a lot of independant tests that have been done but here is one from BMW tuner Jim Conforti.

Jim Conforti (AKA the Land Shark) did some testing:

This was a scientific test, not one done by filter manufacturer X to show that their filters are better than manufacturer Y. The test results are pretty irrefutable as the test lab tests and designs filters where "screw ups" are absolutely NOT allowable.

A scientific test was done on TEST filters where air was loaded with ACCTD (some standardized "test dust" called AC Coarse Test Dust) and sucked through the TEST filter then through an analysis membrane. From the Quantity of dust injected and the amount that gets through the TEST filter and is then captured on the analysis membrane we can calculate the efficiency of the TEST filter in Question.

BMW Stock Filter, Eff. Area of Media: 8.4 sq ft.
K&N Replacement, Eff. Area of Media: 1.6 sq ft.

The filters are the SAME size. They both fit in the STOCK BMW M3 airbox. The difference is that the STOCK filter has 65 pleats 1.5" deep and the K&N only 29 pleats each 0.75" deep.

Now, remember this ratio: " 5.25:1". It's the ratio of the AREA of STOCK to K&N. It's very important and will come into play later.

The STOCK filter efficiency started at 93.4% at 0 loading and increased to 99.2% efficiency as the loading increased to a max tested of 38.8 gm/sq ft of dust.

The K&N filter efficiency started at 85.2% at 0 loading and increased to 98.1% at the max tested loading of 41.38 gm/sq ft.

Now, I hear you. "Jim, that's only a FEW PERCENT". But is it?

Let's look. If we had 100 grams of dust on a new BMW filter we would let through a total of 6.6 grams of dust in. If we used the new K&N filter we get 14.8 grams of dust. That's 224% (TWO HUNDRED TWENTY FOUR PERCENT!!) more dust ingested initially, stock vs. "free flow" and this ratio is pretty much held. Somewhere between 200-300% more dirt gets "ingested" anywhere across loading equivalence. The more INTERESTING thing is when you look at what happens to the DP or Differential Pressure at a constant airflow as you dirty both filters equally with time.

The test used a rate of 75gr of dust per 20 min. Here's where the AREA difference comes MAJORLY into play. See, even though the BMW filter flows a bit less at the SAME loading, it also LOADS UP 5.25 times SLOWER due to it's LARGER effective area. So what happens is that the K&N initially flows better, but as the dirt continues coming in, the K&N eventually flows WORSE while still letting MORE dirt in.

Now, does any of this additional dirt cause problems? I dunno. I suppose we could have a few people do some independent oil analyses on different motors using both K&Ns and Stock filters. Get enough of them, and you'd have a good statistical basis. For me though, it's simple: More DIRT = BAD.

The additional short-term airflow might makes sense on a track car. IMHO, it doesn't for the street.

-- Jim Conforti

One of many examples.
ChinoCharlesOH · Feb 27, 2009#71
Originally Posted by Tamago ↑
and you let this fuckery continue but lock up a poll that really was just a little joke..


mod power!!
LOL. Two facets of this job...

[1] Don't let people spread misinformation. (This thread)
[2] Don't let Tamago belittle everyone else on the forums. (Your thread)

😉
TamagoOff Grid · Feb 27, 2009#72
Originally Posted by ChinoCharles ↑
LOL. Two facets of this job...

[1] Don't let people spread misinformation. (This thread)
[2] Don't let Tamago belittle everyone else on the forums. (Your thread)

😉
it would be self belittlement if someone were to click that choice...

i left it up to the voter which they'd choose!

and clearly it was a joke.. what, did Garm complain? he's not even awake yet
ChinoCharlesOH · Feb 27, 2009#73
No, Garm didn't complain. Nobody did, I was just using my better judgement. Someone would have.
TamagoOff Grid · Feb 27, 2009#74
good job, guessing what people are gonna do ;)
ChinoCharlesOH · Feb 27, 2009#75
I thought so. 🙂
mikenacaratoBrentwood, TN · Feb 27, 2009#76
oooh jim conforti...the producer of the chip that blew my bmws engine a few years back. i dont take what he says with a grain of salt.

k&n will out perform, out flow, and out filter any stock filter, any day...period. end of story.

1sttoyota is wrong on the MAF type...chino is right.
yaribhini is always wrong
k&n is right
jim conforti is stupid
britney spears is stupid
tamago is a belittler
i can haz cheeseburger?

so..in conclusion..

thread failure.

lets dance!
TamagoOff Grid · Feb 27, 2009#77
Originally Posted by mikenacarato ↑
oooh jim conforti...the producer of the chip that blew my bmws engine a few years back. i dont take what he says with a grain of salt.

k&n will out perform, out flow, and out filter any stock filter, any day...period. end of story.

1sttoyota is wrong on the MAF type...chino is right.
yaribhini is always wrong
k&n is right
jim conforti is stupid
britney spears is stupid
tamago is a belittler
i can haz cheeseburger?

so..in conclusion..

thread failure.

lets dance!
.........................and the thread goes on........................
mikenacaratoBrentwood, TN · Feb 27, 2009#78
hey, at least i was ibftl right? thats what counts. ;)
1stToyotaOklahoma · Feb 27, 2009#79
Originally Posted by mikenacarato ↑
oooh jim conforti...the producer of the chip that blew my bmws engine a few years back. i dont take what he says with a grain of salt.

k&n will out perform, out flow, and out filter any stock filter, any day...period. end of story.

1sttoyota is wrong on the MAF type...chino is right.
yaribhini is always wrong
k&n is right
jim conforti is stupid
britney spears is stupid
tamago is a belittler
i can haz cheeseburger?

so..in conclusion..

thread failure.

lets dance!
Maybe I am wrong on the type, but I still see 2 exposed wires that can easily get contaminated. And what are the wires for? They look exactly like the heated wires that I've always seen that are held at a certain temp and then are altered by the amount of airflow that crosses them. Why are they there if it's a Karman Vortex Air Flow Sensor? 🤷

And the air charge sensor is incorporated in the MAF, yes?
mikenacaratoBrentwood, TN · Feb 27, 2009#80
heck who knows, who cares. the filter works in the yaris as proven by people so lets leave it at that. this thread is going nowhere fast and taking a lot of you with it. who cares about 1hp or .5-1 mpg. that would be a factor of temperature in the air and maybe you didnt hit the pedal so much that gas tank. its all the margin of error.
eTiMaGoBangkok, Thailand · Feb 27, 2009#81
agreed, I feel sorry for this dead horse...