Replies continued
1stToyotaOklahoma · Dec 17, 2008#51 Originally Posted by
SilverGlow ↑ Nope, I'm still running 0w-20 because I know that at operational temps 0w-20 and 5w-20 provide the SAME protection. And the UOA's I've seen are for Yaris SPECIFICLY.
Then quit quoting the Toyota TSB and acting like you know something if you're going to continue using a viscosity that the TSB says is NOT to be used in the Yaris 1NZ-FE motor.
I have the TSB in front of me and it says that the Yaris engine can use the 20 weight. So where is the confusion? Where is the ambiguity?
It doesn't say to use straight 20 weight, it doesn't say to use
0w-20, it says
5w-20
It's very, very clear. If you have a Yaris, you can use 20 weight safely, and Toyota is behind what I wrote.
Absolutely false...it never, never says that 0w-20 is to be used, you're confusing the 0w-20 being okay for a Corolla and the XD, etc... and 5w-20 being okay for the Yaris.
And if you look at the AMSOIL site (and Mobil1 too), you too will see that their 0w-20 can be used in ANY MOTOR that is spec'd for 5w-20. Safely.
But that contradicts the guidelines of Toyota's TSB, and that's what Toyota will go by, what their TSB states, not AMSOIL's override.
So is your beloved AMSOIL wrong? Not!
Check my sig. Not using AMSOIL anymore because to get API approval ACEA A1/B1 is what I get, with no API approval I can get A5/B5, but if I ever have any warranty issues I want an oil that is API approved....and better than A1/B1 for my own reasons.
And they are wrong when their statements clash with Toyota's TSB guidelines, and still have to wonder why you're soooo worried about 0w-20 when you live in southern Ca that wouldn't know what a real winter was.
1stToyotaOklahoma · Dec 17, 2008#52 Originally Posted by
gid ↑ nope , no 0w-30 , not stated in the owners manual . Stick with 5w-30 until further notice .
And iirc, not stated on the Toyota TSB either. SilverGlow likes to juggle those TSB viscosity numbers, and the Scion XD and Yaris motors to his own liking and start handing out those recommendations, even though what he says won't be found anywhere on Toyota's TSB. Bad and dangerous, and ignorant advice, if you ask me.
ChupacabraCT · Dec 17, 2008#53I am not going to say that I am right or wrong but I can't see any reason WHY somebody would want to run the 0-20. I mean, clearly the 5-30 is the best all around choice and I could even see 5-20 for some I guess but I am confused as to why somebody wants to run the 0wt.
1stToyotaOklahoma · Dec 17, 2008#54 Originally Posted by
Chupacabra ↑ I am not going to say that I am right or wrong but I can't see any reason WHY somebody would want to run the 0-20. I mean, clearly the 5-30 is the best all around choice and I could even see 5-20 for some I guess but I am confused as to why somebody wants to run the 0wt.
I can see it, if they live in Fargo or the Yukon, and want to run it when the climate starts getting cooler, can't see it tho' for a guy that lives in an area that never sees a white winter and needs a TSB in hand that can't ever seem to backup his own 0w-20 for a Yaris statements.
ChupacabraCT · Dec 17, 2008#55Right but SilverGlow is in SoCal.
1stToyotaOklahoma · Dec 17, 2008#56 Originally Posted by
Chupacabra ↑ Right but SilverGlow is in SoCal.
And he's never seen a snow flake or an ice storm in southern Ca, but he insists on using 0w-20?? 😕
nsmitchellRichmond, VA · Dec 17, 2008#57I am using Mobil-1 AFE (green cap) 0W-20 in my 2009 Honda Fit. The cap calls for 5W-20 so that's fine.
I am using AFE (green cap) 0W-30 in my 2007 Yaris. I don't think I'm going to go to 0W-20 eventhough the TSB says you can. The TSB is a little ambiguous.
I always use a Napa Gold (Wix) oil filter. They are awesome and not overpriced.
1stToyotaOklahoma · Dec 17, 2008#58 Originally Posted by
Chupacabra ↑ I am not going to say that I am right or wrong but I can't see any reason WHY somebody would want to run the 0-20. I mean, clearly the 5-30 is the best all around choice and I could even see 5-20 for some I guess but I am confused as to why somebody wants to run the 0wt.
I'm thinking about using Pennzoil Platinum, and for them 5w-30 seems to be the best choice.
0w-20 and 5w-20 grades only get a ACEA A1 rating,
but the 5w-30 gets a ACEA A5/B5 rating that matches the Amsoil HP 5w-30 that I'm now using, but with the PP I'll feel a little better with the API approval on the front label.
fj40daveAllyn · Dec 17, 2008#59Well....if anyone wants AMSOIL at dealer cost.....just PM me :-)
I use it.....and I'm not going to get into a discussion/defending position on my preferance...it's mine, not yours.
Picture lost · xs134.xs.to $6.95/qt
$27.15/gal
+ shipping (usually around 9-10 bucks)
ShroomsterOrlando · Dec 17, 2008#60 Originally Posted by
1stToyota ↑ I'm thinking about using Pennzoil Platinum, and for them 5w-30 seems to be the best choice.
0w-20 and 5w-20 grades only get a ACEA A1 rating, but the 5w-30 gets a ACEA A5/B5 rating that matches the Amsoil HP 5w-30 that I'm now using, but with the PP I'll feel a little better with the API approval on the front label.
my god the prices for synthetic oil are ridiculous anymore....
I went and priced some at ADAP (wal-mart was out of stock of all 5w20)
and for castrol and Mobil synthetic they were $7.69 + 6.5% tax and Pennzoil platinum was 8.09 + 6.5% tax craziness.....
TheSilkySmoothNew Hampshire · Dec 17, 2008#61 Originally Posted by
SilverGlow ↑ There are MILLIONS of Camry and other Toyota vehicles running 20 weight right now. MILLIONS. And those MILLIONS have no engine problems.
MMMMIIIIILLLLLLLLIIIIOOONNNSSSSS. All over the nation.
I would suggest an adult night school course in statistics for you. It seems you need to educate yourself.
Show me the engine failure rate statistics. You have NO information. This information doesn't
exist in the public domain. You are making up data (74% of alll statistice are made up on the spot). Plus it doesn't matter, Our engine failed. My neighbors Rav4 has a bad engine rap also. He put QS higher milage in it and it didn't quiet it.
BTW Silver, you have no credibility here amoungst educated adults.
VW/porsche/Audi I suppose are the only ones smart enough to spec the A3/B3.
signed: +/-3 sigma
TheSilkySmoothNew Hampshire · Dec 17, 2008#62 Originally Posted by
1stToyota ↑ I'm thinking about using Pennzoil Platinum, and for them 5w-30 seems to be the best choice.
0w-20 and 5w-20 grades only get a ACEA A1 rating, but the 5w-30 gets a ACEA A5/B5 rating that matches the Amsoil HP 5w-30 that I'm now using, but with the PP I'll feel a little better with the API approval on the front label.
When we ran the PP in the suzuki, it seemed OK for the first 100miles then it got that old "GUMMY" VI package feeling that YB-P has. Not a true syn. Protection may be OK, but actual running of the motor is Not good enough for me. Please try the PP and let us know though. GID seems happy with it and he seems to be a logical, practical guy.
Just my dos centavos
nsmitchellRichmond, VA · Dec 17, 2008#63No way am I putting PP in my oil! Urine has poor lubricating properties.
1stToyotaOklahoma · Dec 17, 2008#64 Originally Posted by
TheSilkySmooth ↑ When we ran the PP in the suzuki, it seemed OK for the first 100miles then it got that old "GUMMY" VI package feeling that YB-P has. Not a true syn. Protection may be OK, but actual running of the motor is Not good enough for me. Please try the PP and let us know though. GID seems happy with it and he seems to be a logical, practical guy.
Just my dos centavos
This AMSOIL HP is too good to drain out, so I won't actually use PP until I hit 15K.
After researching LubroMoly I noticed the 5w-30 had good specs, but was a syn blend and not API approved, so I bought a case of LUCAS thinking it was API approved. Not using it in my Yaris, but already sold 6 of them to a guy in a Chevy SS Impala. After too much thinking on what'd be best overall, made up my mind on Pennzoil Platinum for it's good UOAs, API appoval, ACEA A5/B5 ...I know the AMSOIL HP probably wasn't API approved because it exceeded the API rating, but for safety's sake I'll make the switch to PP. Number's wise, looks good, but I'll let you know. After running the AMSOIL for 5K, I'll see if I notice anything strange happening with the PP.
gidNortheast · Dec 17, 2008#65 Originally Posted by
nsmitchell ↑ I am using Mobil-1 AFE (green cap) 0W-20 in my 2009 Honda Fit. The cap calls for 5W-20 so that's fine.
I am using AFE (green cap) 0W-30 in my 2007 Yaris. I don't think I'm going to go to 0W-20 eventhough the TSB says you can. The TSB is a little ambiguous.
I always use a Napa Gold (Wix) oil filter. They are awesome and not overpriced.
that the T.S.B. from TOYOTA had post . The 0w-20 is for other vehicles such as CAMRY , etc..
gidNortheast · Dec 17, 2008#66had tried the 5w-20 for the liftback and could hear a whining noise at highway speeds so drained the 5w-20 ( PENNZOIL Platinum ) and installed the 5w-30 using SHELL full synthetic . Now , no noise . Timing chain , other ? 🤷
mikenacaratoBrentwood, TN · Dec 17, 2008#67 Originally Posted by
SilverGlow ↑ There are MILLIONS of Camry and other Toyota vehicles running 20 weight right now. MILLIONS. And those MILLIONS have no engine problems.
MMMMIIIIILLLLLLLLIIIIOOONNNSSSSS. All over the nation.
I would suggest an adult night school course in statistics for you. It seems you need to educate yourself.
so..those are camrys....not yarii..and wheres your statistics degree?
ChupacabraCT · Dec 17, 2008#68 Originally Posted by
gid ↑ had tried the 5w-20 for the liftback and could hear a whining noise at highway speeds so drained the 5w-20 ( PENNZOIL Platinum ) and installed the 5w-30 using SHELL full synthetic . Now no noise . Timing chain , other ? 🤷
So what was your reasoning for putting 5-20 in the car?
gidNortheast · Dec 17, 2008#69 Originally Posted by
Chupacabra ↑ So what was your reasoning for putting 5-20 in the car?
possible increase in mileage , and few other reasons . Like yeh said , trial and error .
LafiroThread starterNYC · Dec 18, 2008#70Ok, so I will be buying oil in a few hours when I wake up.
But as for Wix and other oil filters, I see two or three part numbers.
Can someone please tell me a few "good/excellent" oil filters for use with probably royal purple on my yaris sedan with the part number next to it.
This way I can buy it and change the oil myself at my friends shop.
Then I will reset the maint Req light and end that for the next few thousand miles.
Thank you everyone.
ChupacabraCT · Dec 18, 2008#71 Originally Posted by
gid ↑ possible increase in mileage , and few other reasons . Like yeh said , trial and error .
increase in mileage = NOT going to happen
few other reasons = NON existent
Better cold flow = NO difference unless you live in an ICEBOX.
gidNortheast · Dec 18, 2008#72 Originally Posted by
Chupacabra ↑ increase in mileage = NOT going to happen
few other reasons = NON existent
Better cold flow = NO difference unless you live in an ICEBOX.
NOT going to happen . 😁
ChupacabraCT · Dec 18, 2008#73 Originally Posted by
gid ↑ NOT going to happen . 😁
No....you meant "Me being wrong = Not going to happen" 😉
linnyMn · Dec 18, 2008#74 Originally Posted by
Chupacabra ↑ increase in mileage = NOT going to happen
few other reasons = NON existent
Better cold flow = NO difference unless you live in an ICEBOX.
I am with gid on this.
Those that deal out absolutes often are wrong.🙁
ChupacabraCT · Dec 18, 2008#75 Originally Posted by
linny ↑ I am with gid on this.
Those that deal out absolutes often are wrong.🙁
It's not rocket science. If you think that you are going to get better gas mileage by going to a 5-20 from a 5-30 you are sadly, sadly mistaken. If you can explain to me how you are going to see a noticeable difference...I am open ears my friend. A few other reasons....I don't know what that means or what those are???? I assume that means nothing, which it does unless gid can come in explain these phantom things. And last but not least....better cold flow???? I mean, common man. Be real. Use what the car calls for...what it is designed and ENGINEERED to run on and yes, it being a motor driven via timing chain does make a difference. I could care less if you are with gid or not....go with the gid! 👍👏
mikenacaratoBrentwood, TN · Dec 18, 2008#76chup...he may see a .01 mpg variance... :)
1stToyotaOklahoma · Dec 18, 2008#77 Originally Posted by
Lafiro ↑ Ok, so I will be buying oil in a few hours when I wake up.
But as for Wix and other oil filters, I see two or three part numbers.
Can someone please tell me a few "good/excellent" oil filters for use with probably royal purple on my yaris sedan with the part number next to it.
This way I can buy it and change the oil myself at my friends shop.
Then I will reset the maint Req light and end that for the next few thousand miles.
Thank you everyone.
Napa Gold/WIX are really good. PNs are: 1394 for the Napa Gold, 51394 for the WIX
Another good choice, for less money (found @ Napa) Nippon filter. PN: 3612412
1stToyotaOklahoma · Dec 18, 2008#78I think we can calm down now, Gid hasn't used 5w-20 for quite some time now. Besides, Toyota's own TSB mentioned its "superiority in terms of fuel economy" ...so maybe fuel economy is improved, but Gid didn't like the extra engine noise and went back to using 5w-30
LafiroThread starterNYC · Dec 19, 2008#79Ok I did the following:
4quarts of Royal Purple 5w30
K&N Oil Filter
I must say, I do feel a slight difference in performance, and smoothness of the engine now.
Im happy.
auxmikeLI, New Yawk · Dec 19, 2008#80I'm stickin' with the Toyota OEM filters. Bought a case.
I use whatever synth is on sale at PepBoys.
'nuff said.....👍
TheSilkySmoothNew Hampshire · Dec 30, 2008#81My problem with "synthetic oil " in the u.S, it is a marketing term ONLY now and people are paying a lot of extra dough for a "false" product that does not even come close to full synthetic oils Like EUropean ELF (total brand) excellium, Fuchs and Motul E-tech and 300V. Americans have been lulled and fooled into incompetence and Ignorance on the subject and brainwashed by marketing. Fools you all! Almost ALL synthetic you buy in N.A is "fake". Only maybe Mobil 1 EP of various weights + 0W-40 euro formula; then the 0w-30 cult status (not earned) "gold" castrol DE and 0W40 castrol euro formula made in DE. is the real thing. We can ONLY guess since marketing allowances for refined petro oil to be called "synthetic" and the Brands tight lipped about constituents and I.P. Again , the Deutsch makken produit, not Estates Uni creativ, may afford you a real synthetic if you do not wish to scrounge the "gray-market" imports. These Yamaha designed, high specific output engines deserve or even REQUIRE high performance oil. They run HOT and will end up full of varnish with poor performance in under 10K if yo do not run the 'good stuff".
ChupacabraCT · Dec 30, 2008#82So I guess my question to you is....is Mobil 1 Fully Synthetic motor oil not what they say it is? In other words, is it not fully synthetic motor oil?
gidNortheast · Dec 30, 2008#83not a " TRUE SYNTHETIC " like that of AMSOIL , REDLINE , etc..
TheSilkySmoothNew Hampshire · Dec 30, 2008#84 Originally Posted by
Chupacabra ↑ So I guess my question to you is....is Mobil 1 Fully Synthetic motor oil not what they say it is? In other words, is it not fully synthetic motor oil?
What is your understanding of a "fully synthetic" motor oil? What is a synthetic motor oil? Are there differing types of Synthetic lubricant molecules, and, which ones are better suited for which purposes? I would spend some time researching this. Most ALL people are ignorant on this subject and DON'T get your info off a forum.
auxmikeLI, New Yawk · Dec 30, 2008#85 Originally Posted by
TheSilkySmooth ↑ and DON'T get your info off a forum.
Exactly.
That's why I'm taking everything you said with a "grain of salt"....😁
suillerTurin - Piedmont - italy · Nov 19, 2009#86sorry to bore again... but someone can drive me to a good site/ebay where to buy Amsoil oils? seems almost impossible to "export" a bottle of amsoil outside US. thx
LazerdotEuless Texas · Nov 19, 2009#87My understanding is that if as little as 10% of the oil is "sysnthetic" it can be called synthetic.
Obviously, as an Amsoil Dealer, I'd like you to consider using Amsoil. We have a Synthetic 0w-30 that can be used for 17,500 miles(or one year) miles under severe conditions. Our Synthetic 5w-30 is good for 15,000 miles(or one year) under severe conditions. Many other oils are good for OEM only drain intervals under these conditions. Check the fine print on the other labels.
Amsoil can save you time, money and create less waste oil due to oil changes and it burns off at a lower rate then other oils.
Check out my dealer page at TruLube.com. for more information
TheSilkySmoothNew Hampshire · Nov 19, 2009#88 Originally Posted by
Lazerdot ↑ My understanding is that if as little as 10% of the oil is "sysnthetic" it can be called synthetic.
Obviously, as an Amsoil Dealer, I'd like you to consider using Amsoil. We have a Synthetic 0w-30 that can be used for 17,500 miles(or one year) miles under severe conditions. Our Synthetic 5w-30 is good for 15,000 miles(or one year) under severe conditions. Many other oils are good for OEM only drain intervals under these conditions. Check the fine print on the other labels.
Amsoil can save you time, money and create less waste oil due to oil changes and it burns off at a lower rate then other oils.
Check out my dealer page at TruLube.com. for more information
No it can be 0% synthetic and be called synthetic due to NAB ruling of Mobil v. BP ( Castrol) in the late 1990's. The Synthetic Amsoils are real synthetic, and the SSO is super special.
Yaris_FanLouisiana · Nov 22, 2009#89lol! @ anyone thinking the Yaris engine won't last 200k miles doing 5k OCI's on any modern oil that meets specs
my advice would be to use what's on sale
TheSilkySmoothNew Hampshire · Nov 24, 2009#90The yaras 1NZ engine can be hard on the oil due to the inverted bucket tappets and the cam chain drive. Luckily the valve spring pressure is really light - IIRC about 40LBS closed - but you can still get galling of the lobe due to high ramp rates and mass acceleration at high rpm. The problem with PAO based synthetc is its not a good lubricant. That includes most amsoil and Mobil 1 (at least the M1 with majority PAO base), DIesters POE and AN synthetics have much a better inherent lubricity and polarity that PAO based syns lack. Source Motul and Fuchs silkolene for the "best" synthetic oils.
IndianspringsazAZ · Nov 24, 2009#91 Originally Posted by
TheSilkySmooth ↑ The yaras 1NZ engine can be hard on the oil due to the inverted bucket tappets and the cam chain drive. Luckily the valve spring pressure is really light - IIRC about 40LBS closed - but you can still get galling of the lobe due to high ramp rates and mass acceleration at high rpm. The problem with PAO based synthetc is its not a good lubricant. That includes most amsoil and Mobil 1 (at least the M1 with majority PAO base), DIesters POE and AN synthetics have much a better inherent lubricity and polarity that PAO based syns lack. Source Motul and Fuchs silkolene for the "best" synthetic oils.
First I have heard of this. Would you post some references? I am interested in oils, and always learning something.
Henry G.So Cal. · Nov 25, 2009#92I agree ester synthetics are superior, but I dont think its fair to says PAO synthetics aren't good lubricants. They are. Oil has come a long way in the last 20 or so years.....
TheSilkySmoothNew Hampshire · Dec 3, 2009#93Haunt BITOG and NORIA forums for more info and trashing than you can stand.
TheSilkySmoothNew Hampshire · Dec 3, 2009#94 Originally Posted by
Henry G. ↑ I agree ester synthetics are superior, but I dont think its fair to says PAO synthetics aren't good lubricants. They are. Oil has come a long way in the last 20 or so years.....
If you research further and look at unadditised testing of PAO v. group II and POE and diester you will find that lowly group II oil is a better lubricant than PAO by far. PAO is not stable at high temps and will oxidise thicken and varnish. It does not solubilise important additives at all. It doesnt stick to metal being inherently nonpolar. It s probably servicable at extremely low temps with healthy and complex additisation for low stress application. Not a "race" or "sporting" oil by any stretch.
sbergman27Oklahoma City, OK · Mar 15, 2010#95 Originally Posted by
TheSilkySmooth ↑ If you research further and look at unadditised testing of PAO v. group II and POE and diester you will find that lowly group II oil is a better lubricant than PAO by far. PAO is not stable at high temps and will oxidise thicken and varnish.
Thanks for the info. Would you mind posting a few links to data supporting that?