Yarisworld Archive

Long Tube Header Dyno results & Photo

60 posts · 25,180 views · page 1 of 2

richardholdenerOriginal postLas vegas, NV · Nov 18, 2008#1
Here is the graph of the dyno testing on the long tube header. The three runs represent the stock exhaust system, removal of the stock exhaust (running open exhuast manifold) and then the long-tube header and 2.5-inch exhaust section. We ran a 2.25 section with no change in power. System will be mild steel, header will require custom mid pipe wich will be made to go with header and pricing for both will be near $550 (waiting for official production quotes). If we get 10 people wanting this (gains are impressive), I will make a production run. The system will need a secondary oxygen simualtor (ask cali) to eliminate CEL but it causes no problems with power or driveability. Also check out posts on NST dyno results and new NA power record.

1 attachment not included in this copy

Replies 59

mikenacaratoBrentwood, TN · Nov 18, 2008#2
man i would hop on it but im going to be out of money after your manifold. :(
pinoypizzaboylas vegas/ henderson · Nov 18, 2008#3
OMG im goin crazehhhhhh. so many new stuff so little time. since im in vegas can i see your work please?
richardholdenerThread starterLas vegas, NV · Nov 18, 2008#4
I tried to upload photo of long-tube header but I think it was too large-I e-mailed to fellow enthusiasts and hopefully he will post it here tomorrow.
taKutoToronto · Nov 18, 2008#5
i guess he posted it in the other thread but not this one

1 attachment not included in this copy

jkuchtaL.A. · Nov 18, 2008#6
I know it's early, but could you find out what this thing will cost done in 304 SS?
CASTREXCosta Rica · Nov 18, 2008#7
Originally Posted by taKuto ↑
i guess he posted it in the other thread but not this one
haha sorry I posted in the wrong thread. 😳

Yeap, that is the picture of the Yaris long tube header from Richard.
CASTREXCosta Rica · Nov 18, 2008#8
Hey Richard,

Would you care to educate us a little bit on the theory behind this long tube header design.
You have explained a lot about the theories involved in the Intake manifold tuning and such...

We all know the main idea of an aftermarket header is to improve the flow of the exhaust gases into the exhaust pipe. People often debate also between the pro's and con's of 4-1 vs 4-2-1 designs.

So what is behind this long tube design of yours? 😁
richardholdenerThread starterLas vegas, NV · Nov 18, 2008#9
Headers operate on the same principle as intake manifolds. The primary length is tuned to optimize scavenging (using a negative pressure wave reflected back to the open exhaust valve) that helps draw more intake charge into the combustion chamber. The header does not simply allow the exhaust to flow better than the stock ex manifold (this is the case with a larger diamter, shorty style header), but the gains are miniaml compared to teh long tube since the stock header is not terrbibly restrictive to flow. Gains from changes soley in exhaust flow are minimal as indicated by the gains offered by dropping the whole exhaust system (cats and mid pipe-middle line in graph). The real gains come from the scavenging effect produced by the combination of design characteristics of the header. We tried a number of different primary lengths and diamters as well as several collector designs to fine tune the gains. 4:1 and Tri-Y headers can be tuned to produce the same power curves-one is not inherantly better than another at different engine speeds, though each design can offer somehting not available by combinations of the other (usually minor gains in power at distinct engine speeds-but this will be dependant on the engine combination-primarily cam timing, displacement and intake design). The right design for any single combination takes a lot of work. BTW-we tesed the header designs with both the stock and new intake.

Originally Posted by CASTREX ↑
Hey Richard,

Would you care to educate us a little bit on the theory behind this long tube header design.
You have explained a lot about the theories involved in the Intake manifold tuning and such...

We all know the main idea of an aftermarket header is to improve the flow of the exhaust gases into the exhaust pipe. People often debate also between the pro's and con's of 4-1 vs 4-2-1 designs.

So what is behind this long tube design of yours? 😁
CASTREXCosta Rica · Nov 18, 2008#10
Thanks 🙇🙇
kounj · Nov 18, 2008#11
more of my money coming your way. i want this.
tk-421Dagobah · Nov 18, 2008#12
I'm interested, although it's not immediately clear to me whether this header is a 4-1 or a 4-2-1 (or even if it really matters now). If someone would enlighten me I would certainly appreciate it.
kounj · Nov 18, 2008#13
4-1.
taKutoToronto · Nov 18, 2008#14
Originally Posted by tk-421 ↑
I'm interested, although it's not immediately clear to me whether this header is a 4-1 or a 4-2-1 (or even if it really matters now). If someone would enlighten me I would certainly appreciate it.
all four ports just are extended and merge together at one point. So it's a 4-1.
A 4-2-1 involves having a pair of ports merge, and then those merged pipes come together to the one pipe.

sorry i dont remember the correct terms at the moment, but hopefully you get the right idea.

so i guess it needs a complete custom exhaust route if we want to keep a cat and other stuff to pass emissions?
richardholdenerThread starterLas vegas, NV · Nov 18, 2008#15
The header isa 4:1 design. Since we remove the cats for header installation, the only way to install cats would be to reposition them downstream in the exhaust. The header will require and come with a dedicated mid pipe to connect header to axle back.

Originally Posted by taKuto ↑
all four ports just are extended and merge together at one point. So it's a 4-1.
A 4-2-1 involves having a pair of ports merge, and then those merged pipes come together to the one pipe.

sorry i dont remember the correct terms at the moment, but hopefully you get the right idea.

so i guess it needs a complete custom exhaust route if we want to keep a cat and other stuff to pass emissions?
hatchbackkid82. · Nov 18, 2008#16
HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?
CASTREXCosta Rica · Nov 18, 2008#17
Originally Posted by taKuto ↑

so i guess it needs a complete custom exhaust route if we want to keep a cat and other stuff to pass emissions?
This will be an "Off-road" set up since it's catless and it won't pass an emissions inspection.

In order to take your car to inspection you will probably have to keep your OE manifold and mid pipe with the OE cats and modify it to add a flange in a way that you can remove the long tube header and mid pipe and install the OE back for inspection purposes. 😁
taKutoToronto · Nov 18, 2008#18
Originally Posted by richardholdener ↑
... header will require custom mid pipe wich will be made to go with header and pricing for both will be near $550 (waiting for official production quotes).
cost was listed in first post.

sounds like a pain to take on/off when i visit the track then :P
PETERPOOPOahu · Nov 18, 2008#19
wish i could run this but i'm planning on turboing later
pickledchangWashington State · Nov 18, 2008#20
Originally Posted by hatchbackkid82 ↑
HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?HOW MUCH?
...um... if you read the first post, you can see where he states it will be near $550. too bad im probably going to be out of cash from the manifold as well when/if he releases this for the xD. those are some seriously nice gains though, especially in the torque curve, good gains start around 3k rpms, i like :)
blacksandiegovitzJust chillin' out brah ! · Nov 18, 2008#21
So this will be sold with a mid-pipe that will bolt up to aftermarket or stock axle-backs right ? Is there any dyno pulls with a yaris running the long tube header , mid-pipe , and the intake manifold ???? Would a yaris be able to lay down 130+ to the wheels with , only bolt-ons Ie : long tube header, Midpipe, intake , intake manifold , nst pulleys , and axle back muffler?
CASTREXCosta Rica · Nov 18, 2008#22
Originally Posted by blacksandiegovitz ↑
So this will be sold with a mid-pipe that will bolt up to aftermarket or stock axle-backs right ? Is there any dyno pulls with a yaris running the long tube header , mid-pipe , and the intake manifold ???? Would a yaris be able to lay down 130+ to the wheels with , only bolt-ons Ie : long tube header, Midpipe, intake , intake manifold , nst pulleys , and axle back muffler?
All your questions....


answered here:

Stock vs 123 Wheel HP (All-Motor) Dyno Graph
whoguySydney, Australia · Nov 18, 2008#23
Richard..... the position of the O2 sensor is only on one exhaust pipe rather than at the join.

This will mean the o2 sensor will see lower readings and will run the engine rich......

Running rich may give the impression of more power/performance.
richardholdenerThread starterLas vegas, NV · Nov 18, 2008#24
The oxygen sensor positon has no effect on the air/fuel ratio. You can run the sensor stuck in the end of the exhaust or in one individual tube, as long as each cylinder is runing the same-the readings will be identical. Not sure what you mean by lower readings or giving the impression of more power or performance. The dyno does not read impressions-it reads real numbers generated by the motor.

Originally Posted by whoguy ↑
Richard..... the position of the O2 sensor is only on one exhaust pipe rather than at the join.

This will mean the o2 sensor will see lower readings and will run the engine rich......

Running rich may give the impression of more power/performance.
whoguySydney, Australia · Nov 18, 2008#25
Thanks Richard.

I was thinking the same, that the Air/Fuel ratio should read the same regardless of position.

Sorry about me writing "Impression", I meant running rich WILL give more power/performance. That old resistor across the o2 sensor trick.

I'm with you now.
jkuchtaL.A. · Nov 18, 2008#26
So....will this be available in 304 SS, or just the mild steel?
eTiMaGoBangkok, Thailand · Nov 18, 2008#27
Originally Posted by whoguy ↑
Thanks Richard.

I was thinking the same, that the Air/Fuel ratio should read the same regardless of position.

Sorry about me writing "Impression", I meant running rich WILL give more power/performance. That old resistor across the o2 sensor trick.

I'm with you now.
Running rich does not actually give you more power, it's a common misconception. You actually have to run very slightly lean for the best combustion, if I recall correctly. You want to run richer in a turbo application so that the extra fuel acts as a coolant to prevent detonation.
CASTREXCosta Rica · Nov 18, 2008#28
Originally Posted by eTiMaGo ↑
Running rich does not actually give you more power, it's a common misconception. You actually have to run very slightly lean for the best combustion, if I recall correctly. You want to run richer in a turbo application so that the extra fuel acts as a coolant to prevent detonation.
Correct, rich (more fuel) does not mean more power. Is the other way around.
richardholdenerThread starterLas vegas, NV · Nov 19, 2008#29
people get confused when they read rich or lean ads power. Optimum power comes from an optimum air/fuel mixture. This is usually 13.2:1 in an NA application and richer on forced induction applications-though a turbo motor very well at 13.2:1 air/fuel-just not for very long.
harveyjaiSydney, Australia · Nov 19, 2008#30
sorry to ask a dumb question...

but does that mean u can run this long header + bolt on muffler, no mid pipe?
AznGoukiCalgary · Nov 19, 2008#31
damn this is sweet. 550 for head and mid sounds pretty good. I am concerned about the mild steel though. Being in Canada, wouldn't rust be a greater issue for me? In terms of power gains, so far you look the best. How much louder is the vehicle with this set up? Any chance for a sound clip?
richardholdenerThread starterLas vegas, NV · Nov 19, 2008#32
It was real loud durign testing since we ran an open exhuast. Haven't run the system through a mid-pipe connected to axle back yet-we need to make sure there is sufficent interest before we make the production pieces. Sounded pretty cool at 6000 rpm!

Originally Posted by AznGouki ↑
damn this is sweet. 550 for head and mid sounds pretty good. I am concerned about the mild steel though. Being in Canada, wouldn't rust be a greater issue for me? In terms of power gains, so far you look the best. How much louder is the vehicle with this set up? Any chance for a sound clip?
anonymous userwindward oahu · Nov 19, 2008#33
Interested, but like others, fundage is tight right now. I may be able to commit sometime after december. Maybe january?
YodaFL · Nov 19, 2008#34
does any1 one see that it is spit at the top. Never seen that on a header before. Was it a mistake or did it crack?
mikenacaratoBrentwood, TN · Nov 19, 2008#35
i believe its for flexability. when the metal flange heats up if theres not a split it can warp and/or crack. its good to have a joint in there to allow expansion.
richardholdenerThread starterLas vegas, NV · Nov 19, 2008#36
The split in the head flange was necessary to faciliate installation of the prototype. The header can't be installed if is is made as a full-length, 1-piece header. It will be a 2-piece design, but the production head flange will be 1 piece. The header will split mid-way down the primary tube-they will connect using a 4-bolt flange.

Originally Posted by Yoda ↑
does any1 one see that it is spit at the top. Never seen that on a header before. Was it a mistake or did it crack?
richardholdenerThread starterLas vegas, NV · Nov 19, 2008#37
PS-This is why I don't like to provide photos of the prototypes since they don't represent what the production piece will be.

Originally Posted by Yoda ↑
does any1 one see that it is spit at the top. Never seen that on a header before. Was it a mistake or did it crack?
thepaidtravelerNorwich, Ct · Nov 19, 2008#38
Don't wory about posting prototypes Rich. Some people need to realize that this is what is considered a rough draft and not the final product.

It takes time to test and develope.
YodaFL · Nov 19, 2008#39
i had a question and you answered its no biggie. Better you show the prototype so we can see where your going if we are to invest in it. It makes me feel alot more comfortable in investing in a product form some1 i dont kno or has heard about(others might have but not me). I am not a fan of word of mouth from people establishing others credibility. And i kno its a rough draft. Just wanted to kno if its a part of the design or not and its purpose.

But again thank you for taking the time to R&D all these parts for our cars.
jkuchtaL.A. · Nov 19, 2008#40
So....will this system be available in 304 SS?
richardholdenerThread starterLas vegas, NV · Nov 19, 2008#41
We are checking on pricing bbut it will likely be aluminized or coated mild speel to keep cost reasonable. 304 SS might nearly double price.

Originally Posted by jkuchta ↑
So....will this system be available in 304 SS?
jkuchtaL.A. · Nov 19, 2008#42
Keep me posted....I'd pay extra for a 304 SS header that will last a while.

Thanks again for creating these parts for our car!
TreyzLong Island, NY · Nov 19, 2008#43
subscribed
AznGoukiCalgary · Nov 19, 2008#44
I'm definitely interested. It's rusting that really worries me.
NonStopTuningUSA · Nov 20, 2008#45
Another excellent thread. Great job Richard!!!
rob323Joyner, Brisbane · Nov 24, 2008#46
Richard, is there any provision to allow for the twisting of the motor? Flex joints etc?
WolfWingsKansas City, MO, USA · Nov 25, 2008#47
Originally Posted by AznGouki ↑
I'm definitely interested. It's rusting that really worries me.
Honestly I'll pay the $1100 if it came in a good stainless steel instead of mild steel, but I live in the edges of the rust belt where the automated car washes are enclosed, heated, and get more business during winter from people grabbing the underbody wash than they do during the summer. :-)
jkuchtaL.A. · Nov 25, 2008#48
I want the stainless most because it can put up with the higher heat of trackdays a lot better.
WolfWingsKansas City, MO, USA · Nov 25, 2008#49
Originally Posted by jkuchta ↑
I want the stainless most because it can put up with the higher heat of trackdays a lot better.
That's flatly wrong. Both have a melting point north of 2500 degrees farenheight. Mild steel and 304 stainless steel both don't give a damn, most mild steels are in fact good up to 2700 degrees F, same as 304 stainless steel. High-carbon steel's are the ones that melt around 2000 degrees farenheight. Both also conduct heat almost identically, so there's no difference there either. Coat the mild steel version if you're concerned about heat-containment for track use.

Only reason to go with 304 SS on an exhaust is for rust prevention at exhaust temperatures or for cosmetic reasons. It may be possible to wrap and coat an exhaust to get the same rust prevention as 304 SS, but it's one of those "do you trust the coating to be water-tight and road-salt-proof, versus being able to rely on the underlying metal?" concerns.
ddongbaphay · Nov 25, 2008#50
Originally Posted by richardholdener ↑
The oxygen sensor positon has no effect on the air/fuel ratio. You can run the sensor stuck in the end of the exhaust or in one individual tube, as long as each cylinder is runing the same-the readings will be identical. Not sure what you mean by lower readings or giving the impression of more power or performance. The dyno does not read impressions-it reads real numbers generated by the motor.
Unless you're missing fuel injectors in two of the cly. jk=]