Yarisworld Archive

GOOD-BYE YARIS, HELLO FIT!

311 posts · 79,967 views · page 3 of 7

Replies continued

nsmitchellRichmond, VA · Oct 29, 2008#101
Originally Posted by PETERPOOP ↑
Don't believe the mpg gauge in the fits. They are wrong.
You are absolutely right. Those gauges are off pretty much all of the time by 2 to 4 MPG.
Jem_hadarCollingwood, ON · Oct 30, 2008#102
Originally Posted by PetersRedYaris ↑
If you don't like it (or Honda), just say it...
+1

There's a lot of hating simply bc its NOT a toyota (yaris)

lol, which is lame. period.



Originally Posted by roxy1 ↑
from the looks of things, the fit computer mileage is way off (4 mpg for many of them).
It is. Usually by 2-4 mpg it seems (per fitfreak). One needs to really state their CALCULATED mpg (not the fit computer generated ones!). do it the old fashioned way... tracking kms and L to fill.
bobbyThread starterNortheast · Oct 30, 2008#103
I'm not too obsessive about FE...my Phit seems to be getting very good mileage, and that's great. Beyond that, it is quiet, handles like a dream, and makes me very happy every time I start it up! Love it!!

1 attachment not included in this copy

nsmitchellRichmond, VA · Oct 31, 2008#104
I does handle well. Feels a little bit like a sports car. It has a harsh ride when going over bumps. I guess that is the stiff suspension. I love the alloys and would not think of changing them ever.
TheSilkySmoothNew Hampshire · Nov 1, 2008#105
Originally Posted by nsmitchell ↑
Is that a Nissan? It is. Then yes it's a pile of doo doo. hehe
How do you know - you have friend with one or see reliability data? That is good question! Is there a free web site with 'long term reliability data' I know consumer jewish reports but not others maybe more relevant market researchers. Edwards?
bobbyThread starterNortheast · Nov 3, 2008#106
Consumer Reports is a great resource to check vehicle reliability. I'd never buy a car w/o looking at CR to see which cars are rated highly for reliability. Both the Yaris & the Phit (the two cars I own) are rated by CR to be 'much better than average' in reliability.

1 attachment not included in this copy

marcustoronto, canada · Nov 3, 2008#107
I CHECKED OUT THE FIT LAST WEEKEND.. OPEN THE DOOR AND CLOSED IT RIGHT AWAY.. the handle on the door alone and the door itself felt so thin...it feels like i can bend it out of shape..felt like the old civic... thumbs down.. although i love the fits steering wheel...
bobbyThread starterNortheast · Nov 3, 2008#108
...then don't buy one. I loooooooove my Phit!! It is unquestionably the gold standard for so-called economy cars. I made a very good choice, I feel. Cool color too! 😁
PaidTimeOffHawaii · Nov 3, 2008#109
Originally Posted by bobby ↑
...then don't buy one. I loooooooove my Phit!! It is unquestionably the gold standard for so-called economy cars. I made a very good choice, I feel. Cool color too! 😁
Unquestionably? Seems like there are a lot of people questioning...
PaidTimeOffHawaii · Nov 3, 2008#110
Originally Posted by niko3257 ↑
i don't know where you guys are getting these figures from?
this is as per honda site usa.
base fit mt 14,550
base fit at 15,350
sport fit mt 16,060
sport fit at 16,910

as per toyota site which only had these
base yaris 3 door mt 13,715
base yaris 5 door at 15,174
no sport manual to compare?
sport yaris at 17,874

now these toyota figures are configured to match
what the fit has. but yaris still doesn't have enough
option to compare exactly.
there is no base 5 door manual either so i used 3 door.
as you can see numbers are really close.
and to those buying sport 5 doors you are paying more.
17,874 yaris vs. 16,910 fit.
thats a total 964 difference.😳
thats some rims to me. i don't know about you.😉
Website =/= individual dealership prices. Lots of people are getting their numbers from dealerships that they've visited. Dealerships are franchises and are able to determine their own prices according to demand in their specific areas. Also, let's not forget tax, documentation, delivery, dealer specific add-ons, etc.
Jem_hadarCollingwood, ON · Nov 3, 2008#111
Originally Posted by voodoo22 ↑
In Canada there was no contest when I priced out a Yaris and a Fit. Just over 17 for the Yaris, just over 19 for the Fit.
$19,280 for the manual Fit SPORT. ($20,480 for the auto)

How much does the Yaris RS cost? $18,815 for the manual ($20,165 for the auto)

So thats a difference of $465 for the stick, and only $315 for the auto.

What's are these comments abt "all the extra money" the Fit costs over the Yaris? $300-500 is hardly a hefty premium. In fact, when you consider all the other nice, amazing things the new Fit has over the Yaris, there's no premium at all. That $400 is the cost of all the other features the Fit gets you over a Yaris on their respective top of the line models!

Jem


EDIT:

OK, just read this post:
Originally Posted by PaidTimeOff ↑
Website =/= individual dealership prices. Lots of people are getting their numbers from dealerships that they've visited. Dealerships are franchises and are able to determine their own prices according to demand in their specific areas. Also, let's not forget tax, documentation, delivery, dealer specific add-ons, etc.
And thats a good point I hadnt thought abt per se, since all the Honda and Toyota dealerships here in Collingwood and Barrie, Ontario are listing at stated online listed price. We arent seeing dealerships marking the prices up. Man, sucks that some (many?) are having to deal w/ that though. Seems strange to me, wouldnt like that at all.
bobbyThread starterNortheast · Nov 3, 2008#112
Since I own a 2007 as well as a 2009 Phit, I can tell you that unquestionably that the Phit is a better car. It's safer, handles better (stock), the seats are more comfortable, it's more powerful, and offers a Nav system which is incredible. I love the Yaris, but I loooooooove the Phit! 😉
marcustoronto, canada · Nov 3, 2008#113
Originally Posted by bobby ↑
...then don't buy one. I loooooooove my Phit!! It is unquestionably the gold standard for so-called economy cars. I made a very good choice, I feel. Cool color too! 😁
easy there..got nothing against it..well actually i do,,, im just telling sum people some of the downside... engine wise id say the fit is better.. again steering wheel is a plus... but that damn door is botherin me.. which it did bother me on the old civics as well .. but overall its ur car.. i think u did good job choosing the fit.. its a great car... i just cant past the shell being too thin.sorry bro.
PaidTimeOffHawaii · Nov 3, 2008#114
Originally Posted by bobby ↑
Since I own a 2007 as well as a 2009 Phit, I can tell you that unquestionably that the Phit is a better car. It's safer, handles better (stock), the seats are more comfortable, it's more powerful, and offers a Nav system which is incredible. I love the Yaris, but I loooooooove the Phit! 😉
Sorry bobby, your suggestions (as educated as they may be) are still completely subjective. Most of us have weighed the ups and downs between the two (prices, options, etc.) and some of us feel that the Yaris is far superior to the Fit in most areas. You don't agree, and that's perfectly fine because it's all subjective. But to say that it's "unquestionably" the best car in its class is straight-up false.

Safer? Where are the numbers for this?

Handles better? Subjective

Seats more comfortable? Subjective, and you've probably never sat in an S model before.

NAV system offered? Yaris now has this option too.
Stargate YARlantISSaint Petersburg, FL · Nov 3, 2008#115
Bump PTO
marcustoronto, canada · Nov 3, 2008#116
also hes forgetting maybe that hes on a yaris forum..
Stargate YARlantISSaint Petersburg, FL · Nov 3, 2008#117
Originally Posted by marcus ↑
also hes forgetting maybe that hes on a yaris forum..
I'll second that Marcus!
bobbyThread starterNortheast · Nov 3, 2008#118
Originally Posted by PaidTimeOff ↑
Sorry bobby, your suggestions (as educated as they may be) are still completely subjective. Most of us have weighed the ups and downs between the two (prices, options, etc.) and some of us feel that the Yaris is far superior to the Fit in most areas. You don't agree, and that's perfectly fine because it's all subjective. But to say that it's "unquestionably" the best car in its class is straight-up false.

Safer? Where are the numbers for this?

Handles better? Subjective

Seats more comfortable? Subjective, and you've probably never sat in an S model before.

NAV system offered? Yaris now has this option too.

The seats may be a subjective opinion (they feel more supportive that the seats on the Yaris...after a long drive in the Yaris I had to have a chiropracter waiting for me when I arrived at my destination! I have not sat in an S model...I own a regular 2007 hatch, and that's what I'm comparing it to) but the Yaris just don't don't feel safe at high (60 miles an hour or more) speed, and Consumer Reports specifically points to that reason that they cannot recommend people buying the Yaris. They feel that the emergency handling on the Yaris is sub-par, and I agree. Consumer Reports feels that the Phit is a better car, and having owned BOTH, I must agree. It is a quieter car, there's more room in the back, and the "magic seats" which allow the back seats to flip UP, is such a great feature. The Phit has EIGHT airbags....how many does the Yaris have? Since the 2009 Phit has not been crash tested yet, I will be curious to how it does compared to the Yaris.

I am not aware that the Yaris offers a built-in Navigation system.

Has anybody read a magazine review or an online auto review which rates the Yaris as a better car than a Phit? If so, I'd like to see it. I have only read reviews which tout the Phit as an overal better car than the Yaris, and that has been my impression as well.

What can I say...I am becoming a Phit Phreak!😁
marcustoronto, canada · Nov 3, 2008#119
i think i should take my pop corn out this will be good.. i just like to watch..
bobbyThread starterNortheast · Nov 3, 2008#120
Originally Posted by marcus ↑
also hes forgetting maybe that hes on a yaris forum..
No, I'm not. I own a Yaris, and I like it a lot. I also happen to now own a Phit, which I feel is a better car. I think there is room on this forum to compare the Yaris to other similar cars...don't you?
PaidTimeOffHawaii · Nov 3, 2008#121
Originally Posted by bobby ↑
No, I'm not. I own a Yaris, and I like it a lot. I also happen to now own a Phit, which I feel is a better car. I think there is room on this forum to compare the Yaris to other similar cars...don't you?
There's a difference between comparison and fanboyism. You're dangerously close to the latter.
bobbyThread starterNortheast · Nov 3, 2008#122
I don't think I'm being a fanatic about the Phit, but I certainly am enthusiastic. It's a wonderful car.

Has anybody come across an auto magazine review or an online auto review which declares the Yaris is an overall better car than the Phit? I have not seen one.

The bottom line is, we all love Japanese cars, and would never be caught dead in an American car. (EWWWWW)
PaidTimeOffHawaii · Nov 3, 2008#123
It's one thing to be happy with a Fit over the Yaris, it's another thing to spout out false things comparing the two and not taking criticisms with an open mind. We're all here to share information, but if you want Honda fanboy praise for your Fit, we all know where you need to go for that.

This is YARISworld, not Fitworld, or even Subcompact(as in general)world.

and in regards to you saying you're not a fanatic?

Originally Posted by bobby ↑
What can I say...I am becoming a Phit Phreak!😁
Two posts ago... I'm just sayin' 🙄
Kal-ElMassachusetts · Nov 3, 2008#124
Originally Posted by PetersRedYaris ↑
Funny you should say this, because a fully loaded Yaris cost the same as a Corolla or Matrix, and the Camry base model comes in at just a few thousand more. What exactly was your point?

Fully loaded yaris or a Fit Sport (No nav), same price, the Fit is MORE car...

If you don't like it (or Honda), just say it... Both economy cars are becoming less economy priced.
I love the Fit. It was in the running but I couldn't afford it. And Honda is my favorite company along with Toyota. In fact, I work at an Acura dealer full time.

I was just pointing out that almost $20k is just a bit too steep for most people interested in a sub-compact.
gidNortheast · Nov 3, 2008#125
this is why wars go on 'til this day ... . I think both cars are very good . The FIT is much smarter choice than a HUMMER or large S.U.V.s ( or should I say C.U.V., nothing more than rounded corners and lowered roof 🙄 ) , which I view as a true foe to the FIT , YARIS 😁 . The seats are better in the FIT , test drove several ( '07 and '08 ) and they are more comfortable . The seating arrangement for cargo is much better as well 👍 . The sliding / split back seats should be standard feature like that of the XD , not an option with the power package to get more profit 🙄 .
bobbyThread starterNortheast · Nov 4, 2008#126
😁

1 attachment not included in this copy

stuffyontario, canada · Nov 4, 2008#127
it's pretty clear to me that honda has raised the bar as far as subcompacts are concerned with the release of the new fit,
the yaris is still a great car and when considering overall price (from sticker to operating costs) is still the better choice.

i think the future of subcompacts is that they will be outfitted with more of the amenities of larger, more expensive vehicles and people will pay for it in the name of better fuel economy,
the fit clearly is moving in this direction.

i don't think it's too subjective to say that the new 09 fit is the better car, but it is more expensive.
marcustoronto, canada · Nov 4, 2008#128
mpg = yaris is better
price overall = yaris is better
looks wise= yaris rear end is better..i kinna like the new front for the phit.
0-60= as far as i know the yaris can do 8.5 sec which is same as the new phit

now if we gonna talk about interior then the phit win that foh sure..
blktiger60Washington · Nov 4, 2008#129
Originally Posted by voodoo22 ↑
Good points.

I chose a car with what in my opinion is a less comfortable steering wheel made with what appears to me to be a little lower quality materials because when I'm buying an economy car total cost of ownership is the major deciding factor for me.

The Yaris costs less to:

buy
maintain
fuel

Buy what you want, but if I was buying a small car for it's fun value I would have bought a mini, which blows the Fit out of the water in every category which matters in a segment like that. In my opinion the Fit is a car with an identity crisis. It costs more than a Yaris, and is geared irresponsibly so that it gets worse fuel economy. The Fit has no where near the performance level or luxurious amenities as the Mini which costs more than the Fit.

If you're into compromise (or just like the Fit) the Fit is perfect, but if you want economy or luxury it's far from the best choice in the compact segment.
The mini doesn't compare to an MR2 and they are way cheaper in all aspects.
bobbyThread starterNortheast · Nov 4, 2008#130
The Phit is an economy car...the Mini (much more expensive) is essentially a sports car. You're comparing apples & oranges. If you want to compare, you need to look at the Yaris, Versa, Aveo, Accent & Phit. The Mini (which I love, I think it's terribly cute) is in a different class.

1 attachment not included in this copy

nsmitchellRichmond, VA · Nov 4, 2008#131
Originally Posted by marcus ↑
mpg = yaris is better
price overall = yaris is better
looks wise= yaris rear end is better..i kinna like the new front for the phit.
0-60= as far as i know the yaris can do 8.5 sec which is same as the new phit

now if we gonna talk about interior then the phit win that foh sure..
I think I have figured out the Yaris / Fit MPG Pros and Cons for AUTOMATICS ONLY, since that's what I own.

The Yaris seems to get better city MPGs when NOT hypermiling. Normal driving by normal people. (ie - Folks who would never want or use a ScanGuage, like my wife)

The Fit shines in MPGs on the Highway when NOT hypermiling.

The Fit has 5 gears with what seems to be overdrive as well since my RPMs will drop when cruising eventhough i'm already in 5th gear.

My Yaris, with cruise control wont get much above 40MPG at 65MPH.
The Fit just loves 65MPH and gets close to 50MPG at 60 MPH with cruise control.

If you do mostly highway travel, the Fit may be your buddy, by about 10MPG. If you are city mostly, the Yaris is the car for you.
marcustoronto, canada · Nov 4, 2008#132
i did not know that.. the new fit with 118hp can do 50mpg on hwy.. wow.. then again i did 45 mpg going 100 km/hr 95% on hwy on the way to camping last summer ..and thats me not using hypermill though..
nsmitchellRichmond, VA · Nov 4, 2008#133
Originally Posted by marcus ↑
i did not know that.. the new fit with 118hp can do 50mpg on hwy.. wow.. then again i did 45 mpg going 100 km/hr 95% on hwy on the way to camping last summer ..and that sme not using hypermill though..
I got 46.6 MPG going through mountains with my Fit. This MPG was calculated at the pump, not using the Fit's MPG guage.

My jaw dropped to the ground when I calculated this.

I may be doing a Roanoke trip shortly so I can do another pure highway test. I will be going through rural highways with some lights. My Yaris has gotten wicked MPGs while hypermiling this route, like 46 MPG. This will be an interesting test.
nsmitchellRichmond, VA · Nov 5, 2008#134
voodoo - Were you using crusie or foot control. With Foot Control you can get better MPGs. I am using cruise control in both cars to be fair. Now I do have Michelin HydroEdge tires on my Yaris that are slightly wider than stock, so that may be affecting my MPGs. On my Yaris they are pumped to 44PSI. On my Fit I have not touched the stock tire pressure. Haven't even removed a valve stem cap. With the Fit Sports low profile tires, I don't think I'm going to inflate them over the reccomended PSI just for ride comfort. The Fit is a little rough over rough roads, but in a good way. 😉
nsmitchellRichmond, VA · Nov 5, 2008#135
Good Point. My brother has a nice Craftsman digital tire gauge and I just bought a new tire pump.
stuffyontario, canada · Nov 5, 2008#136
Originally Posted by voodoo22 ↑
That makes some more sense. I don't have cruise control. So you're possibly taking a double hit with cruise control and wider tires on your Yaris vs ours which is still on oem Bridgestones.

I know around here, it's just hilly enough that MPG would suffer a lot with cruise on, not so much in the prairies.

Thanks for helping me figure out what you're saying.

I'd still check your psi on your Fit if I was you. Who knows what whomever was smoking when they filled your tires. I just got the Yaris from an oil changed they pumped my tires between 30-36 psi.
are your numbers all highway miles?

the best i've been able to achieve on the highway in my yaris (manual) is 45 mpg (u.s. gallon), that's travelling a top speed of 110 km/h

are you saying that you aren't adjusting your driving to get such good numbers?
stuffyontario, canada · Nov 6, 2008#137
Originally Posted by voodoo22 ↑
Most of my tanks are a majority of highway miles, but I have some where I've achieved high 40 US MPG in mostly heavy traffic in downtown Toronto. That does involve thinking about FE to achieve. Turning the car off at long lights, accelerating slowly and coasting to red lights.

However, my highway mileage often includes bumper to bumper traffic jams (you are probably familiar with the 401? I drive Markham Rd to Mississauga Rd, everyday to work). The worst one was last year, it took me 3 hours to get to work instead of the usual 40-50 minutes.

To get over 40 US MPG on highway driving takes no adjustment to my driving at all. I can get between 40-44 mpg (depending on other coniditions) even if I'm going 75 mph the majority of the time. Usually closer to 40 and a few times below that, but barely.

For me to get over 50 US MPG consistently I do have to drive slow, the weather has to be warm and I can't do much more than 50% city driving on a tank. Going over 55 mph very often, will kill a 50 + US MPG tank for me.

In the warm weather, you may be surprised how easy it is to get over 50 US MPG if you aren't driving all city, as long as you try to stay between 50-55mph and don't drive in the mountains like Bailout.
i'd love to see how you get such good numbers in the city, i drive like a grandma, coast to lights, shut off engine on long lights but the highest i've gotten in the city is high 30's.

my trips are usually fairly short though, so this could be where i'm really taking a hit on the FE.

i can achieve the mid 40's on the highway, but not travelling faster than 110 km/h (that would be around 70 mph i think), anything over 110 my FE drops significantly.

i've had the yaris now for 3 years and have tracked the FE since the car was new, so i pretty much know what to expect depending on driving conditions and the time of year- that's why i found your numbers a bit high.
KCALB SIRAYVirginia · Nov 6, 2008#138
Fruit Fly
stuffyontario, canada · Nov 7, 2008#139
that's probably what it is, my city trips are probably under 20 km round trips.

i don't have a scanguage either, but you're probably going to get a more precise reading by just crunching the numbers after filling up-

i would like to try out a scangauge to see specifically what kind of driving is giving me the best FE, but to spend a couple hundred bucks on it is not worth it even in the long run.
it would be nice to buy one as a group and give everyone a month with it to help them improve their driving, then pass it on to the next person.
SilverBackEl Monte, Ca · Nov 8, 2008#140
I'd choose my silver egg over any other car in it's class anyday. It's small, inexpensive, good on gas, reliable, ..and surprisingly a chick magnet (wasn't expecting that, but I'm not complaining🤤)
Jem_hadarCollingwood, ON · Nov 9, 2008#141
Originally Posted by voodoo22 ↑
Good points.
and is geared irresponsibly so that it gets worse fuel economy.
LOL. Way to make an over-the-top comment.

Its fuel economy is 1-2 mpgs off a Yaris (Canadian ratings anyways). And that equates to "irresponsible" gearing. C'mon hahahahaha that comment's a joke.
nsmitchellRichmond, VA · Nov 10, 2008#142
Yaris EPA Estimates are 29/35
Fit EPA Estimates are 28/35

1MPG off in the city... WOW! Not much difference there.

We all know these numbers are not real world, but it does mean they are close in MPGs.
stuffyontario, canada · Nov 10, 2008#143
i did read that while the new fit has more horsepower, the engine is more efficient now and gets better fuel economy than the previous generation despite having more power.
i'm not sure what technical changes were made to achieve this.
gidNortheast · Nov 10, 2008#144
less emissions too 😉 . There's days I could use a catalytic converter . Especially after fast foods . . Roll down that window !!! 😲
firemachine69Sudbury, On · Nov 10, 2008#145
Originally Posted by stuffy ↑
i did read that while the new fit has more horsepower, the engine is more efficient now and gets better fuel economy than the previous generation despite having more power.
i'm not sure what technical changes were made to achieve this.
I believe they implemented dual-VTEC (sort of like how the Corolla has dual VVTI on both intake and exhaust sides).
earljailBC, Canada · Nov 10, 2008#146
Originally Posted by bobby ↑
The seats may be a subjective opinion (they feel more supportive that the seats on the Yaris...after a long drive in the Yaris I had to have a chiropracter waiting for me when I arrived at my destination!
I just drove 6826.4 kilometres, 4241.73 miles to Alaska, taking seven days. That is a lot of driving in so little time. At no point did my back hurt, and my back usually hurts. (like at work after a couple hours, or at the computer)

Obviously, your mileage may vary about the seats, but I didn't mind them at all, in my 2007 regular hatchback.
What can I say...I am becoming a Phit Phreak!😁
http://fitfreak.net/

You're not very original... 🙄
yarswissSunland, CA · Nov 10, 2008#148
How about comparing the international models of the car, instead of just the American version? More Yari and Jazz's (as the Fit is called overseas) are sold around the world than in the US.

Lets say we took the extremes of both:
Economy: Yaris 1.0l, 1.4l diesel vs. Jazz 1.2l. Yaris wins out here, as the Jazz is not offered in diesel, and the 1.0l is much better on FE than the smallest engine Honda offers in the Fit, which is 1.3l. 1.0l gets 56mpg imperial, while the 1.3l gets 53mpg imperial. Yes, it's unfair comparing these engines, as the yaris is also offered in the 1.3l form, but I'm comparing the lowest/smallest available engines.

Sport: Yaris TS 1.8l vs. Fit Sport 1.5l. 132hp vs. 117hp. Once again, comparison may seem unfair, but the comparison here is between the most powerful versions one can get.

Of course, we are comparing vehicles that aren't available here, but just for arguments sake, the Yaris is available in much more trims and engine choices than the Fit is.

Nevertheless, we are just comparing oranges to oranges here. These are both great, cheap, affordable economy hot hatches, made by reliable Japanese automakers, and if the new generation sucks, it sure is going to be improved in the future.
bobbyThread starterNortheast · Nov 10, 2008#149
Why not just compare the cars we can buy here...?
earljailBC, Canada · Nov 10, 2008#150
Originally Posted by bobby ↑
Why not just compare the cars we can buy here...?
Because this is the Internet. There is no here. This is Yarisworld.com, not Yarisamerica.com.