The way I heard it explained from an expert was that the wider the viscosity the more polymers are needed and the harder it is for the molecules to stretch...something like that...under stress and heat the 5w-30 performs better.Originally Posted by SilverGlow ↑If Toyota says we can use 20 weight oil, then that means 0W-20 and 5W-20. At operational temperature both these oils will protect the same. The only difference is that in very cold temperatures, the 0W will pump a bit easier, but not a lot easier then the 5W.
Same for 5W-30 and 0W-30....an engine that runs on one can run on the other.
What Oil do you guys recomend/Use ?
88 posts · 23,184 views · page 2 of 2
Replies continued
Not exactly correct engine lubricant may not get to designated operational temp and viscosity of the 0W will be much less than the 5W at say 75 celcius. I am Chemist!Originally Posted by SilverGlow ↑If Toyota says we can use 20 weight oil, then that means 0W-20 and 5W-20. At operational temperature both these oils will protect the same. The only difference is that in very cold temperatures, the 0W will pump a bit easier, but not a lot easier then the 5W.
Same for 5W-30 and 0W-30....an engine that runs on one can run on the other.
Make Love not Bombs! I see TSB b4 it states NO 020!
says not to . Only for CAMRY , etc.. If you want to risk it , then go for it .Originally Posted by SilverGlow ↑If Toyota says we can use 20 weight oil, then that means 0W-20 and 5W-20. At operational temperature both these oils will protect the same. The only difference is that in very cold temperatures, the 0W will pump a bit easier, but not a lot easier then the 5W.
Same for 5W-30 and 0W-30....an engine that runs on one can run on the other.
If you're a chemist then you should know better....the 20 in 0W-20 and 5W-20 provide the same protection at full operating temperature (around 212 degrees F).Originally Posted by TheSilkySmooth ↑Not exactly correct engine lubricant may not get to designated operational temp and viscosity of the 0W will be much less than the 5W at say 75 celcius. I am Chemist!
Make Love not Bombs! I see TSB b4 it states NO 020!
It is the first number, the 0 in 0W-20 that is thinner at cold temperatures then 5W.
And Gid yes you are correct, the Yaris engine is not TSB'd for 0w, but rather for 5W-20. However I do use 0w because the UOA reports I've seen from other Yaris owners show the same wear metals as those that used 5W-20.
Not according to Toyota engineeers....thiner means better circulation and faster....Originally Posted by 1stToyota ↑The way I heard it explained from an expert was that the wider the viscosity the more polymers are needed and the harder it is for the molecules to stretch...something like that...under stress and heat the 5w-30 performs better.
I seen a T.V. commercial for VALVOLINE " SYNPOWER " that it gives 4 times better protection to your engine than MOBIL 1 . True ? 🤷
You missed the part about the extra snake oil polymers that are required to get the wider viscosity rating and how they react under stress and heat, besides, owner's manual states 5w30 not 0w30 for the YarisOriginally Posted by SilverGlow ↑Not according to Toyota engineeers....thiner means better circulation and faster....
Your friend is not the "expert" you thought ;-)Originally Posted by 1stToyota ↑You missed the part about the extra snake oil polymers that are required to get the wider viscosity rating and how they react under stress and heat, besides, owner's manual states 5w30 not 0w30 for the Yaris
This is because Amsoil and Mobil1 and all the others disagree with him. You see, Amsoil is the best and it makes 0W-20 and 0w-30 and tens of thousands of cars using it are not failing. In addition, UOA for those oils shows very, very low wear...so much for the "molecues cannot stretch" comment. 😆
I would suggest we all pay a visit to BobIsTheOilGuy.com and read the forums on oil there....a lot of superstitions will die if you do...at least they did for me.
You can start by reading your manual and your oil cap (5w30 only) and your Toyota TSBs, and then you can finish off by stepping into the LS2 and GTO forums to inform the regs that you think SgtGeek doesn't know about motor oils and UOAs 🤣Originally Posted by SilverGlow ↑Your friend is not the "expert" you thought ;-)
This is because Amsoil and Mobil1 and all the others disagree with him. You see, Amsoil is the best and it makes 0W-20 and 0w-30 and tens of thousands of cars using it are not failing. In addition, UOA for those oils shows very, very low wear...so much for the "molecues cannot stretch" comment. 😆
I would suggest we all pay a visit to BobIsTheOilGuy.com and read the forums on oil there....a lot of superstitions will die if you do...at least they did for me.
I am sorry you did not read or understand the email I left. What is viscosity of 0w at 50C and 75 C you will see it is much less than the 5W. The engine oil may not run at 100c. You are not a chemist. An who is bob the oil guy - like bill nye the science guy I see on tv? You will not get correct information with proper scientific method on this a chat forum. I see chest beating like religious fanatics whcih is a dangerous person🙁Originally Posted by SilverGlow ↑Your friend is not the "expert" you thought ;-)
This is because Amsoil and Mobil1 and all the others disagree with him. You see, Amsoil is the best and it makes 0W-20 and 0w-30 and tens of thousands of cars using it are not failing. In addition, UOA for those oils shows very, very low wear...so much for the "molecues cannot stretch" comment. 😆
I would suggest we all pay a visit to BobIsTheOilGuy.com and read the forums on oil there....a lot of superstitions will die if you do...at least they did for me.
You are dangerouse person with a little knowledge to be bad, but not enough education to make interpolation. You may have to study some more - This Bob OIly Guy is no Koran!Originally Posted by SilverGlow ↑If you're a chemist then you should know better....the 20 in 0W-20 and 5W-20 provide the same protection at full operating temperature (around 212 degrees F).
It is the first number, the 0 in 0W-20 that is thinner at cold temperatures then 5W.
And Gid yes you are correct, the Yaris engine is not TSB'd for 0w, but rather for 5W-20. However I do use 0w because the UOA reports I've seen from other Yaris owners show the same wear metals as those that used 5W-20.
...you claim that 5w20 is "TSB'd" 🤷 for the Yaris (you're thinking Scion XD?), and you wrote that you use 0w (wouldn't matter if a 20 or 30 followed because my Yaris owner's states 5w30 only)...so, to follow your rule number (3) start using the "correct viscosity" if you're still expecting to see that 300k miles on your motor. 😉Originally Posted by SilverGlow ↑I'm convinced that as long as (1) the oil has the latest ratings (2) is synthetic, (3) correct viscosity and (4) mated with a decent filter, your car will last 300,000+ miles
there is an Technical Service Bulletin by TOYOTA giving the o.k. for 5w-20 in '06 and beyond . Got the T.S.B. sent via e-mail from the assistant manager of service department where we bought the '08 YARIS sedan , made copy of it and put with our paperwork . We're using PENNZOIL Platinum 5w-20 in it for this stretch , haven't decided to continue it's use . So , call your TOYOTA service center for verification of T.S.B. in their computer system , number is EG018-06 .
Guys Guys....... Its just oil =D! Lets just list the best 5 and be done with it
I looked at the TSB on NapaFix, 5w-20 is listed for Toyota and Scion, 0w-20 is listed for the 2AZ-FE engine, not the Yaris 1NZ-FE engine...their *note* at the start of the article seems kind of confusing though:Originally Posted by gid ↑there is an Technical Service Bulletin by TOYOTA giving the o.k. for 5w-20 in '06 and beyond . Got the T.S.B. sent via e-mail from the assistant manager of service department where we bought the '08 YARIS sedan , made copy of it and put with our paperwork . We're using PENNZOIL Platinum 5w-20 in it for this stretch , haven't decided to continue it's use . So , call your TOYOTA service center for verification of T.S.B. in their computer system , number is EG018-06 .
Quote: "The recommended viscosity grade for this oil differs according to vehicle model. Use the recommended grade specified on the oil filler cap or in the Repair Manual or Owner’s Manual for each vehicle."
iam gonna try the greddy 5w-30 on my 4age 20v blacktop to see how it works if i like the ayri will have it too
You're confused, but that's okay. I do follow my rules. The TSB shows 20 weight for our engines, and I use 20 weight, and the UOA's show less wear then if I used 30 weight. Sure, the filler cap shows 30 weight, BUT the TSB which came out later says otherwise. I'm sticking with the TSB. As to 0W weight, I use that because at full operational temperature 0w-20 and 5w-20 protect exactly the same; hence the 20 part of those grades. The 0w on cold mornings flows to the upper parts of thje engine faster and gets to more parts of the internals faster.Originally Posted by 1stToyota ↑...you claim that 5w20 is "TSB'd" 🤷 for the Yaris (you're thinking Scion XD?), and you wrote that you use 0w (wouldn't matter if a 20 or 30 followed because my Yaris owner's states 5w30 only)...so, to follow your rule number (3) start using the "correct viscosity" if you're still expecting to see that 300k miles on your motor. 😉
🙄 .Originally Posted by 1stToyota ↑I looked at the TSB on NapaFix, 5w-20 is listed for Toyota and Scion, 0w-20 is listed for the 2AZ-FE engine, not the Yaris 1NZ-FE engine...their *note* at the start of the article seems kind of confusing though:
Quote: "The recommended viscosity grade for this oil differs according to vehicle model. Use the recommended grade specified on the oil filler cap or in the Repair Manual or Owner’s Manual for each vehicle."
It's okay that you're too dense to read...the TSB *notes* the 0w-20 is for the 2AZ-FE engine, not the Yaris 1NZ-FE engine...you did a XD motor swap in your Yaris?! 🎉Originally Posted by SilverGlow ↑You're confused, but that's okay. I do follow my rules. The TSB shows 20 weight for our engines, and I use 20 weight, and the UOA's show less wear then if I used 30 weight. Sure, the filler cap shows 30 weight, BUT the TSB which came out later says otherwise. I'm sticking with the TSB. As to 0W weight, I use that because at full operational temperature 0w-20 and 5w-20 protect exactly the same; hence the 20 part of those grades. The 0w on cold mornings flows to the upper parts of thje engine faster and gets to more parts of the internals faster.
And if you live in CA why worry about those "cold mornings flows"...besides, in that TSB that you're swearing by, take note of the note @ the top of the page:
"The recommended viscosity grade for this oil differs according to vehicle model. Use the recommended grade specified on the oil filler cap or in the Repair Manual or Owner’s Manual for each vehicle."
👏
Sorry. When I wrote 5w-20 I was actually in agreement with you. The 0w-20 statement from the TSB was for those that might be confused into thinking that what goes for the XD engine somehow goes for the Yaris engine.Originally Posted by gid ↑🙄 .
I personally run 5-30 Royal Triton (Purple). But I was just wondering is anyone using Redline Oils here? Mobil One, Ams, and Rp are three of the best you can get any of them and it would be a wise choice. Ams just makes some interesting blends some that last as long as 25,000 miles so essentially a once a year change for most.
very seldom do I have someone agree in this place 😉 .Originally Posted by 1stToyota ↑Sorry. When I wrote 5w-20 I was actually in agreement with you. The 0w-20 statement from the TSB was for those that might be confused into thinking that what goes for the XD engine somehow goes for the Yaris engine.
I think generally we think too much about the oil in the car. How would anybody REALLY know which oil is better than another? Are you analyzing the engine parts at a lab?? Seems silly to me.
I truly believe that if you use a name-brand oil with the recommended weight (5-20, 5-30, or whatever) and change your oil & filter frequently (every 3,000 miles or 5,000) your engine will last and last and last. The trick to longevity is keeping the engine oil clean, by frequently flushing it out with new, clean, oil. Beyond that, I have no idea how one would determine which oil works better.
I truly believe that if you use a name-brand oil with the recommended weight (5-20, 5-30, or whatever) and change your oil & filter frequently (every 3,000 miles or 5,000) your engine will last and last and last. The trick to longevity is keeping the engine oil clean, by frequently flushing it out with new, clean, oil. Beyond that, I have no idea how one would determine which oil works better.
You just want quiet, smooth engine reasonable economy, service life and not varnish. The Varnish will break loose at the oil changeout period and can get into small places and cause problems. Sales staff say our car has Life time "chain tensioner" and hydraulic cam phasing so this parts do not suffer varnish floating around without problem. My Family had Mazda v6 which tensioner alway is failing due to dirty oil and so to my brothers motorcycle. He had to switch to superior AECA formulation from inferior ILSAC SM specification N.A. gunk. Sorry I digress ...So, the wider the Viscosity Index the less optimal the oil will be for long life and varnish creation (cause by oxidisation of polymeric additives). So even in Ethylene gas synthesized - 0W30 worse than 10W30 and 0W20 (cause of tighter VI) better than 0w30 if engine expressly designed for the base oil weight. Yaris 1dot5 litre is not designed for 0W base oil and will have shortened service interval in this suboptimal application. Sorry Gentlemen - I try to act like dumb skirt so people will not hate me and like me but i have to throw down the gauntlet now seeing so much misinformation on this forum. Sorry to say API oil "sucks" All of it.
we're using synthetic because it tames the engine noise and do many short trips. Someday may switch to a syn-blend and then to conventional oil again .
i run greddy gr3 5w 30 with some lucas oil additive and she runs smooth
My dad says:
Try CD oil detergent with extreme pressure-wear additives available at the local auto-parts store is very good to get API oil perform almost like AECA A3 B3? Except Viscosity will be less for economy. Will make almost to Porsche spec
-S
Try CD oil detergent with extreme pressure-wear additives available at the local auto-parts store is very good to get API oil perform almost like AECA A3 B3? Except Viscosity will be less for economy. Will make almost to Porsche spec
-S
if using an 5w-20 , I read it's best to use one that's rated ACEA A_ and B1 or greater . The PENNZOIL Platinum 5w-20 we're using is only rated A1-02 , while the PLATINUM 5w-30 is also B1 and B5 . I believe MOBIL 1 5w-20 has a B rating , as for other manufacturers 🤷 . Would have to do some searching on the web or in the store . May go to another 5w-20 synthetic that has the B rating . The ratings are printed on the label on back of the oil bottle .
Have you researched Amsoil yet? I'm considering switching to Amsoil with my next oil change. I can get Amsoil's HP 5w30 for nearly the exact same price that I'm now paying for Eneos.Originally Posted by gid ↑if using an 5w-20 , I read it's best to use one that's rated ACEA A_ and B1 or greater . The PENNZOIL Platinum 5w-20 we're using is only rated A1-02 , while the PLATINUM 5w-30 is also B1 and B5 . I believe MOBIL 1 5w-20 has a B rating , as for other manufacturers 🤷 . Would have to do some searching on the web or in the store . May go to another 5w-20 synthetic that has the B rating . The ratings are printed on the label on back of the oil bottle .
I would use AMSOIL or REDLINE if they were cheaper . PENNZOIL Platinum gets very good U.O.A.s ( used oil analysis ) at www.bobistheoilguy.com ( look under Used Oil Analysis - Gas ) , plus it's fairly cheap . I've picked up the PLATINUM for less than $3 a quart in the past .
HI Mr. GID: Do you get the high mileage with your platinum oil too? Is the Power good? How do you drive hard or easy? This may be a good deal🙂Originally Posted by gid ↑I would use AMSOIL or REDLINE if they were cheaper . PENNZOIL Platinum gets very good U.O.A.s ( used oil analysis ) at www.bobistheoilguy.com , plus it's fairly cheap . I've picked up the PLATINUM for less than $3 a quart in the past .
When it will be time for my first oil change, I'll be using Mobil 1 5W-20.
Been using Mobil 1 for many, many years and never had any engine problems; besides our C55AMG and C350 uses Mobil 1 too. 😉
Been using Mobil 1 for many, many years and never had any engine problems; besides our C55AMG and C350 uses Mobil 1 too. 😉
with the PLATINUM 5w-30 the power is good , been averaging close to 39 miles per gallon since last NOVEMBER , and it tames the engine noise . Using REDLINE MT-90 true synthetic gear oil as well for the '08 5 speed liftback . This car was used for delivery route once a week for about 8 months as well , so quite extreme driving . One time the car got 42 m.p.g. while doing the route , other times 40 or little less ( some of that included 4 studded tires ). The route was 100+ miles , 4 hours long , around 400 stops , many steep hills , and 2 people . There's usually 2 of us in the car since the purchase . The '08 automatic sedan has the PLATINUM 5w-20 and got 40.03 miles per gallon on a test drive after 4 studded tires were put on ( see post under FUEL ECONOMY FORUM ) . That car has overall average of 39 miles per gallon as well , right on par with the stick shift 👍 . We'll have to wait and see how the colder weather affects it .Originally Posted by TheSilkySmooth ↑HI Mr. GID: Do you get the high mileage with your platinum oil too? Is the Power good? How do you drive hard or easy? This may be a good deal🙂
Amsoil's XL5w20 has the A1/B1 rating, and a friend offered to get me some for a discounted price of $5.65 per qt, but I'm thinking of staying with 5w30 and bumping up to their mid-priced HP series for $6.95 each (it has a A5/B5-04 rating) ...the HP5w20 ratings should be pretty close to those same ratings, I assume. And agreed on the Pennzoil Platinum UOA's...the oil expert (SgtGeek) that I made mention of earlier stated that their results were some of the best he sees.Originally Posted by gid ↑I would use AMSOIL or REDLINE if they were cheaper . PENNZOIL Platinum gets very good U.O.A.s ( used oil analysis ) at www.bobistheoilguy.com ( look under Used Oil Analysis - Gas ) , plus it's fairly cheap . I've picked up the PLATINUM for less than $3 a quart in the past .
I'd go with the XL 5w-20 at that price . The U.O.A.s for XL are very impressive at B.I.T.O.G.. Decisions , decisions 😕 .
I'm getting a special price, not sure what the real list price would be. Probably $7.50 for XL and $9.00 for the HP...Originally Posted by gid ↑I'd go with the XL 5w-20 at that price . The U.O.A.s for XL are very impressive at B.I.T.O.G.. Decisions , decisions 😕 .
just went from PENNZOIL Platinum 5w-30 > Platinum 5w-20 for the '08 Liftback at 13,400 miles . Took little less than 3 and a 1/2 quarts to bring to FULL mark . The new TOYOTA ( Denso ) 90915-YZZF2 oil filter soaked up close to 5 ounces of the oil needed for the change . May go with the MOBIL 1 E.P. 5w-20 or give a few calls to local auto parts stores to see if any AMSOIL XL 5w-20 is available and the cost per quart . This wouild be for the '08 sedan due for oil change next month , currently PLATINUM 5w-20 .
running royal purple 5w30, feels so much better than mobil 1