unadilla66Original postny · Mar 9, 2023#1'07 2-door hatch, 5sp, 195k.
Clutch is slipping after (yes, stupidly..) helping a neighbor pull his stuck car out of a snowbank. Should've said 'no', but I didn't- stopped the second I smelled it burning. Anyway. Driveable if I baby it and don't try to accelerate too fast. Car is pretty long-in-the-tooth, but still runs about as well as it ever has. Local mech's over-the-phone-estimate for putting in a new clutch is $1000-1600... Trying to decide if it's worth it...
Replies 15
Neinris‘Murica! · Mar 9, 2023#2You don't have any friends that are mechanically incline whom can help you install a new clutch/disc, for the nominal fee of beer and pizza? 😳
bronsinnj · Mar 9, 2023#3Like many things in life it’s a crapshoot. But if there’s nothing else wrong with the car and it’s been maintained I would do it.
I grew up in Cobleskill is there anywhere near where you are?
unadilla66Thread starterny · Mar 9, 2023#4 Originally Posted by
Neinris ↑ You don't have any friends that are mechanically incline whom can help you install a new clutch/disc, for the nominal fee of beer and pizza? 😳
Ah, I used up my 'credits' with the friend who has a lift, etc, late last fall when he helped me do the front control arms. What seemed like it would be a quick couple hour job turned into 2 days when the captive nut inside the subframe broke loose... swearing, sawing, welding.... Didn't help that it was freezing cold, too. But I suppose if I can baby it through the summer (and help said friend build his new house..) I may accrue some more credits...
unadilla66Thread starterny · Mar 9, 2023#5 Originally Posted by
bronsin ↑ Like many things in life it’s a crapshoot. But if there’s nothing else wrong with the car and it’s been maintained I would do it.
I grew up in Cobleskill is there anywhere near where you are?
There's a mech in Oneonta who's decent.
Neinris‘Murica! · Mar 9, 2023#6 Originally Posted by
unadilla66 ↑ There's a mech in Oneonta who's decent.
I think what he's trying to say is, he's willing to help you out.
unadilla66Thread starterny · Mar 9, 2023#7 Originally Posted by
Neinris ↑ I think what he's trying to say is, he's willing to help you out.
Ah, I see! Cobbleskill is a bit of a ways away..
bronsinnj · Mar 10, 2023#8As I recall Unadilla is on route seven near Binghamton. I only went down route seven as far as Oneonta never got to Unadilla.
unadilla66Thread starterny · Mar 10, 2023#9 Originally Posted by
bronsin ↑ As I recall Unadilla is on route seven near Binghamton. I only went down route seven as far as Oneonta never got to Unadilla.
17m or so west of Oneonta. Pretty little town, but quite depressed (and sometimes 'depressing', especially this time of year..!).
bronsinnj · Mar 10, 2023#10Cobleskill schedule of events
April 1 October 1
Trout fishing. Canoe paddling on the Schoharie creek. Boating on Cooperstown lake. Bicycle riding.
October 1 February 29. Small game hunting. Bow hunting for deer. Shotgun season for deer. Skiing. Snowshoeing. Cross country skiing.
Month of March. No hunting no fishing no skiing no nothing. Well maybe skiing. The dead month. Easily the most depressing month!
komichalCZ · Mar 14, 2023#11Local car service guy did it for me for 450 USD (including quality clutch set and everything).
But it is a lot of work so I guess the cost of labor is a lot higher in your case. Still seem a bit overpriced though.
remcafeeArizona · Mar 14, 2023#12depends on your car too, is it rusty? does it have anything broken? transmission leaks? there is no "menu" price when it comes to vehicle repairs
bronsinnj · Mar 15, 2023#13Again, if the car has been maintained, it has no other outstanding issues. I would do the work if it’s $1000 even. You have to ask yourself how much wood another car be? Even if it were used? You d have to correct all the problems with that one!
miragemanpoughkeepsie ny · Mar 18, 2023#14I bought my '09 Yaris sedan 5 speed with just over 16k miles on it and it had the common shudder problem. Intentionally burning the clutch seemed to help for a few days, hehe... of course I knew I'd be changing the clutch eventually so I didn't care. Anyway, I got the Valeo clutch set from Autozone at a very decent price, I think it was $170. I had my flywheel resurfaced (make SURE whoever does it keeps the critical step height right) by a local machine shop guy. I did the job slowly myself and can tell you I was VERY happy with the result. It has been over 100k miles since installation and no slips, no shudder. The oem clutch was not good. If you have no leaks, no or little oil burning, and the body is not shameful, I would definitely put in a new clutch.
esse10richmond TX. · Mar 22, 2023#15 Originally Posted by
unadilla66 ↑ '07 2-door hatch, 5sp, 195k.
Clutch is slipping after (yes, stupidly..) helping a neighbor pull his stuck car out of a snowbank. Should've said 'no', but I didn't- stopped the second I smelled it burning. Anyway. Driveable if I baby it and don't try to accelerate too fast. Car is pretty long-in-the-tooth, but still runs about as well as it ever has. Local mech's over-the-phone-estimate for putting in a new clutch is $1000-1600... Trying to decide if it's worth it...
I just replaced mine at the end of last year. it's an easy job and you don't need a lift. The tranny is not that heavy and can be lifted in/out by one person. I did it by myself twice with no jack and no lift. it only weighs about 70-80 pounds. The clutch kit was under $200 i believe. From the symptoms you describe it looks like the throw-out bearing is bad on yours, might as well replace the clutch plate and pressure plate too.
sh0rtlifepacific north WET · May 11, 2023#16hell i am a tiny independent and will work on anything so long as someones throwing coin at me...and typicaly speaking ill undercut ANY shop labor by 50% and then use my discounts to further save someone coin on parts