Yarisworld Archive

RomanDave's Prius C swap

77 posts · 121,696 views · page 1 of 2

RomanDaveOriginal postNew Zealand · Apr 16, 2021#1
Hi,

I managed to find some great information on this site from other users, mainly Zedicus' post about Prius C engine swap.

So thought I'd share some extra details of what I've been doing.

The basic plan is:

Low km Prius C motor
Silvertop 4AGE ITB setup
Link G4+ ECU
BC valve springs
JUN 264 / 9.5mm cams
4kg flywheel
Exedy clutch
C56 gearbox / helical LSD

Into a 2005 NCP10 3 door Echo.
Currently running a normal 2NZ with ITB and saw great results.

Progress posts to follow.

Picture not included in this copy

1 attachment not included in this copy

Replies 76

RomanDaveThread starterNew Zealand · Apr 16, 2021#2
So first thing was to start collecting some parts.
The gearing sucks so I managed to find a C56 from a Vitz RS.
Then 4kg flywheel from Japan.
Exedy clutch.
Some BC valve springs from Ebay.
Then a normal 1NZ sump to swap over.
Then at this stage I just had some normal 1NZ cams to swap in too.
But because it's heaps of work to swap over the cams while the motor is in, I figured I may as well just cut to the chase. So ordered some JUN cams which are still on their way.

Picture not included in this copy

1 attachment not included in this copy

RomanDaveThread starterNew Zealand · Apr 16, 2021#3
I managed to get a 30,000km old 1NZFXE, everything looked amazingly new and fresh.

So started stripping it down and decided to swap the sump over first.

Then once I'd done that, I decided to get the old valve springs out and replace with the BC springs.

Bad move! Dropped one of the retainers down an oil passage, into the sump.
So had to take it off again.

Picture not included in this copy

It turns out that it was impossible to try fit the new stiffer springs with the head in place, so I removed the head and took it to the local engine shop to sort out.

Once I took the head off, holy moly this motor looked yuck inside.
I'm hoping it's all deposits from EGR, rather than blowing past the piston rings. I'm not keen on swapping out rings or removing rods and pistons at this stage. But if the motor blows a lot of smoke, I guess I'll have to.

I spent a while cleaning up the pistons and combustion chambers just with petrol and a toothbrush. Hopefully it will self clean a little more when being run without EGR.

Picture not included in this copy

So I got the head back but I need to order some more head bolts before I can put it all together again.

2 attachments not included in this copy

RomanDaveThread starterNew Zealand · Apr 16, 2021#4
Next up is to see if I can get the electric water pump going.

Picture not included in this copy

So its pretty simple if you have the loom/plug.

The 4 wires are:

Ground: White with black stripe, heavy gauge
12v supply: light blue heavy gauge
PWM pump speed control: small blue wire
pump speed return signal: small green wire


So if you are retrofitting and want a simple install, if you connect just the 12v and ground wires, the pump will run full speed constantly. So you could just wire this to a relay that controls the fuel pump perhaps.

If you earth out the PWM pump speed control pin, the pump completely stops. If you pulse the signal with a varying duty cycle, it can lower or raise pump speed.

Then the return signal wire outputs a square wave (as seen on laptop screen) which you can wire to a digital input on an ECU to monitor pump speed.
So this way you can tell if the pump has failed and setup some warnings, rather than waiting for the motor to overheat. So that's handy.

1 attachment not included in this copy

RomanDaveThread starterNew Zealand · Apr 16, 2021#5
For the ECU install, since mine is a 2005 model it has the 4rows of pins on the ECU. Earlier models with 2 row pins you can buy a DIYBOB or other adapters as it is the same ECU pinout common with some Hondas and other cars.

No such thing available in this case, so I chopped the plugs out of a spare ECU to make an adapter loom. So it could revert to the standard ECU if needed (at least initially, while it had the standard manifold etc on it)

Picture not included in this copy


Then the ITB manifold was 3d printed from HIPS material then covered in some carbon fibre for a bit more strength. Has now been on the car for about 6 months with no issues, (with the 2NZ currently)

Picture not included in this copy

Picture not included in this copy

3 attachments not included in this copy

mitch9521Red Deer, AB · Apr 17, 2021#6
Wouldn't be surprised if you get 150whp out of that setup.
remcafeeArizona · Apr 17, 2021#7
i love it i love it i love it! im a sucker for pumped out all motor itb engines, you should get a nice linear and smooth power increase too which i love over forcced induction
CrankyOldManWest Michigan · Apr 17, 2021#8
Looks great! Thanks for sharing.
speedworxsEdmonton, Alberta · Apr 17, 2021#9
i'm picking up a 05 hatchback , i was intending on this very swap.
not as electrically smart for the electric pump, but i was debating some cams (254) with it too. i wouldn't go for the itb's but might do a corolla throttle.
will the factory ecu run fine with the increase in compression? i wish there was a way to increase rev limit
mitch9521Red Deer, AB · Apr 17, 2021#10
Originally Posted by speedworxs ↑
i'm picking up a 05 hatchback , i was intending on this very swap.
not as electrically smart for the electric pump, but i was debating some cams (254) with it too. i wouldn't go for the itb's but might do a corolla throttle.
will the factory ecu run fine with the increase in compression? i wish there was a way to increase rev limit
You can increase the rev limiter if you overclock the factory ECU, but you have to be careful, too much will give you serious problems. But that is one "ghetto" way of doing it. Of course, a proper piggyback or standalone is a far better route.

Premium will be a must at minimum with that kind of compression and stock timing.
RomanDaveThread starterNew Zealand · Apr 19, 2021#11
JUN cams arrived today, and I'm happy to report that everything fits up fine, including the cam gears.

Thankfully the Aqua shares the exhaust side part number of the 2004+ normal 1NZ motor, and the intake side will work fine too.

Sometimes one of the gears ends up out of alignment, depending on the combination of bits you started with.

It's quite hard to turn the cams over by hand, definitely a lot stiffer springs than standard or my 3S motor.

Need to get a feeler gauge and shim these and see how far out it is. (or not)

1 attachment not included in this copy

mitch9521Red Deer, AB · Apr 20, 2021#12
I can't wait to hear this thing at full throttle under load 😁
xnamerxxso cal · Apr 20, 2021#13
With the cams make sure you have it fully advanced when testing fitment, I know PTV clearance was really tight when I tested myself. Also watch out for ring flutter, I had some issues with that when running over 7k rpms with the ultra low tension prius c rings.
RomanDaveThread starterNew Zealand · Apr 22, 2021#14
Progress.

The head is back on properly, cam clearances all within spec after 2-3 goes of juggling the existing shims around.

I pick-a-parted a front pulley, so now I can start on an alternator bracket.

Funnily enough the light weight alternator kit for my 3S motor, that saves 4KG.
Uses a 1NZ alternator.
So there's some irony in stealing the brackets from that, in order to mount a 1NZ alternator to a 1NZ.
I'll just need an intermediate plate to bolt to the side of the block and stick these on, hopefully.
Not the most light weight solution but I'm more about just getting this going for now.
Looks like underneath the waterpump will be the place for it, and no AC anymore.

One of the now superfluous water outlets was a hose barb that sat with a tapered thread into the back side of the block. Which I replaced with a drain block off bolt I pinched from a dead 3S motor. Easy fix.

Also note how the dipstick on this motor nicely bends out of the way, rather than being between number 1 and 2 throttles. Excellent.

Picture not included in this copy

1 attachment not included in this copy

thebarberGrand Rapids, MI · Apr 22, 2021#15
very cool
speedworxsEdmonton, Alberta · Apr 24, 2021#16
hey! i meant to ask, how are you doing the power steering pump (if your car had that)
RomanDaveThread starterNew Zealand · Apr 25, 2021#17
I'm not sure yet.

I am hoping to keep the factory PS arrangement though.

But it will depend on how difficult the required brackets are.

Just sorting the alternator side first.
RomanDaveThread starterNew Zealand · Apr 25, 2021#18
I've got the intake on it now though, a fair bit more clearance now that dipstick tube and alternator isnt an issue!

So I might reprint my manifold so the throttles are the other way up.
This way it wont have the ugly linkages and throttle cable on top.

(They're not fitted for pic)

Picture not included in this copy

1 attachment not included in this copy

speedworxsEdmonton, Alberta · Apr 25, 2021#19
Wonder if you could share that printing for the throttles... I bet a few would snap that up
RomanDaveThread starterNew Zealand · Apr 29, 2021#20
Yeah maybe once I've finalized it and am happy with it.

I'm thinking about reprinting another version with the throttles flipped the other way up.

So the linkages etc arent visible from the top. However this wouldnt work for a high mount alternator setup of the non hybrid motor.

Speaking of which, I've printed a prototype for an alternator bracket that mounts it where the AC pump used to go.

Picture not included in this copy

and a crappy tensioner, work in progress.

Picture not included in this copy

I cant really see any other good options for it.

I've translated the plans into a set of drawings which can be lasercut, then welded together. Will be made from 6mm and 10mm alloy plate.

A friend also kindly gave me some 2ZZ injectors to use.
So there arent very many pieces of the puzzle left to solve!

Nearly ready to start pulling the old motor out.

2 attachments not included in this copy

speedworxsEdmonton, Alberta · Apr 29, 2021#21
are the 2zz injectors too much?
if memory serves;
1nz- 180-200cc
1zz- 260-280cc
2zz- 315-330cc
i did the injectors on my mr2, and the ecu could compensate but i don't think the 1nz computer could cover that much difference. ... as i typed that i remember you are using the Link ecu so not a problem for you

also, smart alternator mount , i was wondering if the rear power steering mount would work too
RomanDaveThread starterNew Zealand · Apr 29, 2021#22
The main issue with any injector is that they are difficult to control at very small opening times. (So long as you've got an ECU to set them up correctly)

If you've got the correct injector data then you can get something like a 1000cc injector idling fine on a 1500-1600cc 4cyl motor.

But pushing the limits a bit, past that.

If you use E85 where the required fuel volume is higher, then your minimum opening time increases so you can get away with larger injectors. But then you also need larger injectors to keep up.

On my 2NZ motor with the standard 195cc injectors and ITB setup.
At 7000rpm I am reaching 75% duty cycle.

Generally you dont want to exceed around 85% duty cycle, for an NA motor I prefer to keep maximum around say 50-60% so you can adjust the injector timing if needed.

So if there are any strong reversion points in the rpm range you can adjust the injector timing to stop it spitting the fuel back out.

In other news, I've made some slow and boring progress.

My alternator bracket is getting lasercut from some flat 2D shapes, will then be welded together hopefully next week some time.

I've also not wanted to bother with an electric PS pump, and a manual rack came up for sale so I've grabbed it. Keeps it simple!

With such a light car I cant see there been a massive need for PS.

However if I decide later to fit an electric column assist, I would have needed a manual rack anyway.

Will start pulling the 2NZ motor out possibly this weekend.

Picture not included in this copy

1 attachment not included in this copy

RomanDaveThread starterNew Zealand · May 3, 2021#23
So I got the motor out

Picture not included in this copy

Then pulled the clutch fork out and went to bolt the new motor and gearbox together...

Ahhh man, I wasnt expecting the top bellhousing bolts to be all wrong.
My understanding was that if you swap the sump over, everything lined up.

Picture not included in this copy

The position of the dowels on the motor and gearbox were fouling each other, but it works for both if you have them in this position.

Picture not included in this copy

The only real solution is to drill through the engine block.
Then there's only really 1 small and 1 large bolt that arent going to work.

Picture not included in this copy

It's not the end of the world but I probably would have started with a normal 1NZ block, then fitted high comp pistons if I knew the pattern was so different.

Realistically though it should be fine.
Just caught me off guard I guess.
It's still nice having such a new and low km motor that's so clean.

I just need to file/slot one of the holes a little more, then It'll be about ready to put into the car.

However I also need to figure out my steering rack situation before I can put the motor back in. A few unexpected hurdles but that's always the way!

Cant wait to fire it up.

4 attachments not included in this copy

CrankyOldManWest Michigan · May 3, 2021#24
Loving the 3D printed prototypes! I'm sorely tempted to get a printer for my garage/shop for that sort of thing. I've got milling machines and lathes so I can fabricate the "real" components once the design is solid but that would make figuring out the shapes a lot easier!

Bummer about the bell housings. I'm not sure anyone has documented trying to mate a C150 to a Prius 1NZ-FXE before, so you're in Lewis and Clark Territory ;)

What's the donor for the steering rack? I've got a few Yaris power steering columns in my parts rack if you need pictures or dimensions.
speedworxsEdmonton, Alberta · May 3, 2021#25
well shit!
i would have thought the other guy (zedicus?) would have mentioned that... maybe toyota changed the block? or wrong bell housing?
RomanDaveThread starterNew Zealand · May 5, 2021#26
I managed to get the bellhousing situation sorted, after lots of drilling, filing, measuring, and pulling the gearbox off and on about 20 times.

Also the manual rack swapped in.
If swapping to a manual rack, you also need this part and the rubber boot otherwise it wont work. It saves around 5kg switching to a manual rack.
And it's much easier to work on anything behind the motor now.

Picture not included in this copy

I also had troubles with the motor side engine mount, when trying to use the Prius bracket.
It just wanted to sit the rubber mount too far forward.
So I pulled them both out and compared.
They're quite different!

Picture not included in this copy

It looks like a normal 1NZ bracket is required here, but then one of the bolt holes wont work (The one that's not the 3 in line)
However there's not really another option, so I'll source one of these.
Feels good to have the motor sitting in there though!

Picture not included in this copy

So a few unexpected issues but still good progress, still hopefully on track for engine fire up on the weekend.

3 attachments not included in this copy

speedworxsEdmonton, Alberta · May 5, 2021#27
I'm excited to see(hear) it fire up. I get my echo tomorrow, so I'm pumped too.
RomanDaveThread starterNew Zealand · May 11, 2021#28
I've been making some more progress.

I swapped the engine bracket to the normal 1NZ engine mount bracket, so now that all bolted up in the engine bay fine.

Since the 1NZ block is a little taller, my trumpets on the intake now hit the bonnet. So I'll need to remake those to suit.

The Aqua engine only has a 2 pin engine temp sensor, where as the NCP10 has a 3 pin sensor - so you just swap them over. (back of the head, at the top near exhaust side)

Then in the Link ECU I just adjusted engine size to 1500cc, and adjusted injector size for the 2ZZ injectors, and it fired up first pop!

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VdavHZPn-tA

Obviously without coolant situation sorted yet, but a good milestone.

The water hose situation has been easy enough, I've got a bin full of random radiator hose sizes so I just mixed and matched until something worked.
However the outlet positions on the engine mean you cant reuse the standard 2NZ / 1NZ hoses, or the 1NZFXE ones.
There's also an issue where the heater outlet off the thermostat housing is very close to the starter motor solenoid wire.
Not quite touching, but I'm not sure if you could get the plug out while that hose is in place.
Could be annoying.

I'll be fitting a temperature sensor on the cold water pipe from the radiator, so I have a measure of both radiator and engine temperatures. Just for interest's sake, but it might also be an interesting metric to set the water pump speed by.

For the waterpump wiring, I've decided to wire it into the fusebox.
As there's unused fuse and relay locations.
Looking at the Aqua fusebox diagram, it runs a 30 amp fuse to the pump.
So I've done the same here.
I will have the pump relay triggered on with the ignition key 12v supply.
Then as soon as the ECU comes online, it can tell the pump to stop via the PWM pin.

So it's a fail safe mode in case that wire breaks or whatever.

I'm still waiting on my alternator bracket to be completed. However something else I need to do is pick the engine loom apart. The alterantor wiring is baked into the bundle of wires that runs high up with the injectors etc.
However because of my low mount alternator, I need to separate it out. Also I need to remove some redundant wiring for the MAF, power steering, aircon, IACV, old TPS, narrowband oxy sensors, and maybe one or two other things.
So I might try make it look a little tidier while I'm at it, but I might run out of patience before then haha.
speedworxsEdmonton, Alberta · May 11, 2021#29
nice that it started.
i'm kinda surprised about the little differences, ie. motor mounts
what part number is that intermediate shaft for the steering rack?
i am wondering how much the water pump accounts for power wise, the first gen prius uses the same set up as the 1nz, belt driven water pump... but the alternator would be easier, no custom set up
RomanDaveThread starterNew Zealand · May 21, 2021#30
A mechanical waterpump only consumes a fraction of a horsepower - that's why it's important on economy cars.

If you are trying to optimize your power at full throttle it's an irrelevant amount.
However if you are trying to optimize cruising conditions where you make 15hp, then 0.5hp is a lot of difference.

Anyway, I got the pump working well, and I got the motor going.

With still no trumpets on, very conservative ignition timing, and completely standard exhaust for now - this thing sings!

Highest I've revved it to is 8600rpm and feels like it's happy to keep going.
But I know it'll blow the rods up if I carry on like that.

The C56 gearbox is a bit clunky but the new ratios and final drive are delightful.

VVTI isnt working yet, it needs some trumpets, and some ignition timing...

But even so, it's great right now

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wXi7WYC2vp8

Here's a comparison on the same section of road with:

Blue line - 2NZ with intake

Green line - 2NZ with ITB

(Both of these are rpm limited by valve bounce)

Then red line is my very early state of tune with the 1NZFXE

Picture not included in this copy

Very happy with how things are coming along, but there's still a lot left in it!

1 attachment not included in this copy

mitch9521Red Deer, AB · May 21, 2021#31
Sounds awesome.
thebarberGrand Rapids, MI · May 21, 2021#32
So good
RomanDaveThread starterNew Zealand · May 30, 2021#33
So I found the VVTI problem, it wasnt to do with the valve springs overpowering the cam pulley. Although that's still possibly an issue at higher rpm.

It was that the locking pin was stuck in place, so the cam couldnt advance.

So I remedied that, and... hit valves into pistons when I advanced the cam.

I'd seen someone else using prius pistons with VVTI and this same cam, so thought it would be fine. However the issue is that the Aqua motor has significantly smaller valve cutouts than the earlier 13:1 pistons. So this works fine with a standard cam, but not the JUN 9.5 / 264 deg.

Picture not included in this copy

Something else interesting I've learned along the way, a lot of people having issues fitting the head stud kits, where you have to still use a normal head bolt where the VVTI solenoid goes.

The Aqua part number VVTI solenoid is physically shorter, but has all of the oil galleries in the same location. It doesnt protrude into the head as far.
So it's possible that using this, will allow people to use the full head stud kit without issues.

Picture not included in this copy

So the plan from here, since I've found this motor likes to rev. I will fit some stronge rods so I can run to 9k if needed without any stress.
Then either machine deeper cutouts into the Aqua pistons, or buy a set of earlier pistons to fit at the same time. So I can have full VVTI range.
Then also get an LSD sorted as this definitely needs it now.

So probably some slow progress from here, but will stick at it.

2 attachments not included in this copy

JonnathanQnkMacas - Ecuador · Jun 17, 2021#34
Awasome build Roman, could you give me the piece number of the shorter vvti selenoid, maybe you know if ARP Head studs for 1nz fit on 2nz ??
RomanDaveThread starterNew Zealand · Jul 12, 2021#35
Not sure in both cases sorry.

You could look up the part number on toyodiy.com, from Toyota Aqua 2012.

So with the valve situation, I got pretty lucky in that the valves were slightly bent but no other damage. Valves are same part number to the 2NZ, so I pulled them out of my old motor and swapped them in. Sealed perfectly without any lapping etc!

Then all back together.
I've now got some longer trumpets on, and the power difference over bare throttles is/was significant.

Picture not included in this copy

Needs around 11% more fuel from 4000-6000rpm tapering off to about 5% more fuel from then upwards.

I've taken the rear seats back out and it's now got some 185/60/14 R888R tyres on it.

It still definitely needs an LSD but I managed to get off the line okay one time that had the logs recording, and managed a sub 6 second 0-60mph.
Which is awesome, I'm excited to see how this will go when I can get to the drag strip.

The highest I've revved this so far is 8860rpm, it loves the high revs.
Not only is it still making power at that rpm but the fact you fall into a higher rpm when you change gear lifts the average power of the car by heaps.
But I know that eventually I'll break rods doing this. So try keep it to around 8000 for now haha.

I've got exceptionally heavy wheels on it at the moment, wheels and tyre are about 17kg per corner!

Picture not included in this copy

So I've bought some Rays Engineering GR-N wheels. They arent forged, but they are considerably lighter! A friend of mine who has the same sized wheels says they are 12kg per corner, but this might be with a lighter tyre too.

I've had some issues with the front pulley loosening at high rpm, and my alternator bracket broke. But I think I'm on top of these issues now.

I'm looking forward to gettting to some events shortly, hopefully.

2 attachments not included in this copy

CrankyOldManWest Michigan · Jul 12, 2021#36
Love it! Thanks for the update!
Neinris‘Murica! · Jul 13, 2021#37
Wished this car was available in the US. I love how my 08 two door hatch looks, but this weighs 63lbs lighter. I wouldn't have to go on a diet when I decide to make mine a track car. 😆
CrankyOldManWest Michigan · Jul 13, 2021#38
Originally Posted by Neinris ↑
Wished this car was available in the US. I love how my 08 two door hatch looks, but this weighs 63lbs lighter. I wouldn't have to go on a diet when I decide to make mine a track car. 😆
You can import them from Canada into some states, MI is really easy. Or you can import RHD versions from Japan in a few years once they get out of the 25-year blackout period (they don't have FMVSS or EPA certification for North America).
mitch9521Red Deer, AB · Jul 13, 2021#39
I love this build so much.
Neinris‘Murica! · Jul 14, 2021#40
Originally Posted by CrankyOldMan ↑
You can import them from Canada into some states, MI is really easy. Or you can import RHD versions from Japan in a few years once they get out of the 25-year blackout period (they don't have FMVSS or EPA certification for North America).
Sorry in advance for hijacking the topic... I've always loved the Vitz, even when I used to play Grand Tourismo on the PlayStation, I didn't care that my friends would laugh at me.

Yeah but it'd be in KPH... LOL! Not really a deal break. RHD is a no go for me, it'd be hard to drive on the CORRECT side of the road. 😆

Not sure how much I'd have to pay through customs if I get one from Canada, any idea?

But back to the build... Kudos to the OP, your work inspires lots of us. Please post new dyno test after everything is completed.
CrankyOldManWest Michigan · Jul 14, 2021#41
Originally Posted by Neinris ↑
Not sure how much I'd have to pay through customs if I get one from Canada, any idea?
For Michigan, you just transfer the title at the Secretary of State and pay whatever applicable taxes/fees for the value of the vehicle. Not sure about customs though since I bought it from TheBarber (who is a Canadian National that lives in MI on a visa). Check with your state's rules for importing vehicles for more details, I guess. :)
Neinris‘Murica! · Jul 15, 2021#42
Originally Posted by CrankyOldMan ↑
For Michigan, you just transfer the title at the Secretary of State and pay whatever applicable taxes/fees for the value of the vehicle. Not sure about customs though since I bought it from TheBarber (who is a Canadian National that lives in MI on a visa). Check with your state's rules for importing vehicles for more details, I guess. :)
I really want to get back to the build, sorry for hijacking again. But thank you for that information. I'm still on the fence about it. I'll be moving back to Maryland sometime next month. Maybe I'll start inquiring when I get back.

I might just stick with my 08 Yaris, and start my own project. Thanks to the OP, some others here, and others on YT who have inspired me with their Frankenstein engines that I want to start my own Frankenstein project. I've vaguely mentioned in own "Frankenstein" post (Frankenstein Engine) about maybe putting a 3ZR bottom end for stroked crank, 2ZR-FXE 13:1 compression pistons, and 2ZR-FE head (no valvematic) together, the kicker is 2ZZ intake runners! Now that's a Frankenstein. 😁

I'd take years for me to put that together. So anyone is more than welcome to experiment and steal this idea. 🙂

I'll end my question so we can focus on the OP's build.
Neinris‘Murica! · Jul 15, 2021#43
What is the REV limit for this engine? Is it purely going to be a track car, or is it still going to be a daily driver? Any plans on changing the gear ratio of the transmission? Very few here in YW have changed to the Scion xB1's (bB in most part of the world) transmission, for a higher final drive which would put more torque to the ground, but loses on top end speed. I personally would go with the Scion xD's manual transmission and just change out the 5th gear for better fuel economy, the FD is between the Yaris and the xB1.
CrankyOldManWest Michigan · Jul 16, 2021#44
Originally Posted by Neinris ↑
Any plans on changing the gear ratio of the transmission? Very few here in YW have changed to the Scion xB1's (bB in most part of the world) transmission, for a higher final drive which would put more torque to the ground, but loses on top end speed. I personally would go with the Scion xD's manual transmission and just change out the 5th gear for better fuel economy, the FD is between the Yaris and the xB1.
The Echo uses the C15X gearbox family, not the C5X. That really limits the availability of options without going back to much older cars (80's/90's) to find compatible gears. That rules out the xA/xB/xD and all of the 1ZZ-based platforms.

That said, the shorter final drive is great for AutoX but awful for road courses. Way too much top end speed given up, even with the 0.725:1 super-overdrive from the C59.
speedworxsEdmonton, Alberta · Jul 16, 2021#45
Originally Posted by CrankyOldMan ↑
The Echo uses the C15X gearbox family, not the C5X. That really limits the availability of options without going back to much older cars (80's/90's) to find compatible gears. That rules out the xA/xB/xD and all of the 1ZZ-based platforms.
The c-gearbox will work for both engines (the c56 is paired with the 1nz vitz rs in Japan)... Just the need correct bellhousing section. But, I thought the echo chassis was narrower in the front and that's why it used the c150box, as it was physically smaller to fit. Likely the xB gearbox or xa would be the best bet for gearing differences, as the echo was mainly for fuel economy not any real performance
RomanDaveThread starterNew Zealand · Jul 17, 2021#46
Originally Posted by Neinris ↑
What is the REV limit for this engine? Is it purely going to be a track car, or is it still going to be a daily driver? Any plans on changing the gear ratio of the transmission? Very few here in YW have changed to the Scion xB1's (bB in most part of the world) transmission, for a higher final drive which would put more torque to the ground, but loses on top end speed. I personally would go with the Scion xD's manual transmission and just change out the 5th gear for better fuel economy, the FD is between the Yaris and the xB1.
Are you asking about my motor?

If so:

-No rev limiter currently. Until I've got some stronger rods I'll likely set the rev limiter somewhere around 8200-8300rpm.

And yes in this case, swapping to the C56 gearbox is an absolutely magical upgrade. Having the 4.3 final drive instead of the 3.5 makes the whole thing so much better. I'd not be suprised if my 1300cc motor would have been into the 15 second quarter mile range with the C56 box.

The individual ratios of the C56 are most excellent. On the shift from 2nd to 3rd, shifting at ~8800rpm it drops down to only around 6500rpm on gear change.
So it stays in the powerband awesomely.

Picture not included in this copy

As for the purpose of this car, it's not a daily driver anymore as I've got a work car. But it still returns fairly decent milage, the high compression actually makes it decently economical.

I've been getting somewhere around 5.5-6 litres per 100km. So thats somewhere around 40mpg.
I could still get it a little better with optimizing the ignition timing further, will get there eventually.

1 attachment not included in this copy

mitch9521Red Deer, AB · Jul 17, 2021#47
I would love to swap my C50 for a C56, but getting one to Canada from Japan out of an NCP131 Vitz is north of 2 grand, the transmission itself is usually under $600 CAD, its the outrageous shipping that gets expensive very quickly.
RomanDaveThread starterNew Zealand · Jul 17, 2021#48
Meanwhile in New Zealand an RS model NCP91 had its C56 sit there at a DIY wrecker yard until the car got crushed... because I procrastinated too long to get it out!

One thing I noticed is that the shifter linkage arrangement and the engine mount positions are different on the later boxes (compared to my model)

The benefit is that it gives much much much better clearance for the exhaust and shifter cables.

A turbo swap would be a tight squeeze with an NCP13 box, if I was trying it with a half decent sized turbo I'd probably try make the NCP91 box work.
Neinris‘Murica! · Jul 20, 2021#49
Originally Posted by RomanDave ↑
Are you asking about my motor?

If so:

-No rev limiter currently. Until I've got some stronger rods I'll likely set the rev limiter somewhere around 8200-8300rpm.

And yes in this case, swapping to the C56 gearbox is an absolutely magical upgrade. Having the 4.3 final drive instead of the 3.5 makes the whole thing so much better. I'd not be suprised if my 1300cc motor would have been into the 15 second quarter mile range with the C56 box.

The individual ratios of the C56 are most excellent. On the shift from 2nd to 3rd, shifting at ~8800rpm it drops down to only around 6500rpm on gear change.
So it stays in the powerband awesomely.

Attachment 61804

As for the purpose of this car, it's not a daily driver anymore as I've got a work car. But it still returns fairly decent milage, the high compression actually makes it decently economical.

I've been getting somewhere around 5.5-6 litres per 100km. So thats somewhere around 40mpg.
I could still get it a little better with optimizing the ignition timing further, will get there eventually.
That is awesome information! Do you get the Scion xD equivalent in New Zealand? It has a final gear drive of around 3.94, might be something to look into. The xB1, xD, and Yaris all have the same 1st to 5th gear ratio, just different final gear ratio, 4.31, 3.94, respectively and the Yaris here have 3.72, not 3.5 like you mentioned.

I wish I know how to tune the ECM, because I have another "Frankenstein" in mind.
mitch9521Red Deer, AB · Jul 21, 2021#50
Originally Posted by Neinris ↑
That is awesome information! Do you get the Scion xD equivalent in New Zealand? It has a final gear drive of around 3.94, might be something to look into. The xB1, xD, and Yaris all have the same 1st to 5th gear ratio, just different final gear ratio, 4.31, 3.94, respectively and the Yaris here have 3.72, not 3.5 like you mentioned.

I wish I know how to tune the ECM, because I have another "Frankenstein" in mind.
The 1st gen Yaris was labeled as the Echo in Australia, New Zealand and Canada. They have the 6 bolt C150 transmission with the god-awful 3.52 ratio.

The 2nd and 3rd gen Yaris have the slightly better ratio'd C50 with the 3.72FD. I wouldn't even waste my time with swapping in a better FD into a C50 gearset. They're still very much an economy transmission.