Type-YOriginal postNY · Jan 11, 2018#1I'm trying to decide between the Tein S Tech springs and Tokico Blue struts & shocks or just getting the Tein Street Advance Z coilovers for my 2007 hatch. The price is basically the same.
The coilovers seem like a cool option, but I wonder if the added bonus of being able to adjust ride height, etc., can also become a hindrance because of the added complexity.
The S Techs and Tokico setup would be plug and play which is cool.
Does anyone know how the two setups compare?
Replies 67
ABSPLASTICCALIFORNIA · Jan 11, 2018#2Go for the coilovers.
lol.
ern-dizCA all day · Jan 12, 2018#3I went the cheaper route and started with the Tein S Tech springs, paired with factory shocks/struts. Once the factory shocks/struts go, my plan is to replace with Bilstein B8's.
I'm not a mechanic by any stretch of the imagination, but my understanding is the lower level Tein coil overs can't be rebuilt like many higher end coil overs can be. Additionally, with our car's rear suspension design, it's not really a coil over, it's still a spring/shock combo. Lastly, I've heard the opinion of several more knowledgeable folks than I, that claimed a proper spring/shock pairing can provide one of the best street setups you can have, so long as you don't need all the adjustments you get with coil overs for track days.
That's just my 2 cents, which is probably really only worth about 1.5, so take it for what it's worth 😁
Type-YThread starterNY · Jan 12, 2018#4 Originally Posted by
ern-diz ↑ I went the cheaper route and started with the Tein S Tech springs, paired with factory shocks/struts. Once the factory shocks/struts go, my plan is to replace with Bilstein B8's.
I'm not a mechanic by any stretch of the imagination, but my understanding is the lower level Tein coil overs can't be rebuilt like many higher end coil overs can be. Additionally, with our car's rear suspension design, it's not really a coil over, it's still a spring/shock combo. Lastly, I've heard the opinion of several more knowledgeable folks than I, that claimed a proper spring/shock pairing can provide one of the best street setups you can have, so long as you don't need all the adjustments you get with coil overs for track days.
That's just my 2 cents, which is probably really only worth about 1.5, so take it for what it's worth 😁
Lol.
I noticed what you are referring to regarding the rear being spring and shock (though adjustable). I am not even sure I'll be making adjustments much.
How are you finding the ride with the stock shocks/struts?
ern-dizCA all day · Jan 12, 2018#5 Originally Posted by
Type-Y ↑ Lol.
I noticed what you are referring to regarding the rear being spring and shock (though adjustable). I am not even sure I'll be making adjustments much.
How are you finding the ride with the stock shocks/struts?
Honestly, it's fantastic. I can sincerely say that after installing the Tein S Tech's, my ride improved over stock. They're progressive, so regular grocery getting is more comfortable than on stock springs, but when you throw the car into a freeway onramp, it sits down. I was pleasantly surprised.
My issue is that with 17" wheels and the aggressive drop of the Tein springs, I rub a little when hitting those really big freeway hips. It's rare, but does happen. I suspect that maybe stiffer shocks/struts, like the Tokico or Bilstein, would solve for it at the cost of a little comfort.
Type-YThread starterNY · Jan 12, 2018#6 Originally Posted by
ern-diz ↑ Honestly, it's fantastic. I can sincerely say that after installing the Tein S Tech's, my ride improved over stock. They're progressive, so regular grocery getting is more comfortable than on stock springs, but when you throw the car into a freeway onramp, it sits down. I was pleasantly surprised.
My issue is that with 17" wheels and the aggressive drop of the Tein springs, I rub a little when hitting those really big freeway hips. It's rare, but does happen. I suspect that maybe stiffer shocks/struts, like the Tokico or Bilstein, would solve for it at the cost of a little comfort.
Your car looks great, very tastefully done - perfect stance.
I plan on sticking to 15's, so hope that rubbing won't be a factor. Are you rubbing the actual fender or liners?
tmontagueCaledonia Ont. · Jan 13, 2018#7Fwiw to add to the discussion I am currently running MicroImage lowering springs with tokiko blues rear and KYB excel G oem up front. I find the front severly lacks the stiffness to handle the springs. I live around really rough roads and this is where I find the issue comes out. On relatively smooth roads they are fine. If you are doing any hard driving and want more performance then the Bilstein b8's will be a good choice.
I'd ecommend the coil overs only if you need the adjustment, if not then springs and a quality shock/strut will do the job well.
This upcoming spring I'm finally going to coil overs and selling my current set up as I need something more for the track, for DD'ing it was fine
enviriCT · Jan 13, 2018#8i had tokico blues with the microimage first batch (AOE) of springs. They were indeed too soft on the front, but overall handling feel is great.
i since switched to coilovers and the car is much more stable, with higher grip, but to me handling feel has dimished somewhat.
I think tokico stopped production of yaris kits, and what you're buying is leftover warehouse stock.
Type-YThread starterNY · Jan 13, 2018#9 Originally Posted by
enviri ↑ i had tokico blues with the microimage first batch (AOE) of springs. They were indeed too soft on the front, but overall handling feel is great.
i since switched to coilovers and the car is much more stable, with higher grip, but to me handling feel has dimished somewhat.
I think tokico stopped production of yaris kits, and what you're buying is leftover warehouse stock.
Not following what you mean about about the handling feel was better when it was softer.
What would be the problem with putting together a set from leftover stock?
enviriCT · Jan 14, 2018#10Handling feel is feedback given to you when driving, giving a sense of what each corner is doing at any given time. The strut spring combo gave that feedback, but i felt that its cornering limits are low.
The problem with leftover stock is getting replacements can end up being a problem. I think they have a lifetime warranty, but will it honored, or is there any stock left to cover it?
Type-YThread starterNY · Jan 14, 2018#11 Originally Posted by
enviri ↑ Handling feel is feedback given to you when driving, giving a sense of what each corner is doing at any given time. The strut spring combo gave that feedback, but i felt that its cornering limits are low.
The problem with leftover stock is getting replacements can end up being a problem. I think they have a lifetime warranty, but will it honored, or is there any stock left to cover it?
Handling feel: Thanks for clarifying. So it seems like you find that your car handles better with the coilovers, but which setup do you enjoy more for daily driving?
Leftover stock: I didn't think of that and its a good point. For me its probably not a big factor unless I ended up with a defective shock/strut or I got a premature failure, because I don't log a lot of miles per year (~ 6K or less per year), but you're right, that is a consideration because they won't have a replacement shock/strut available if one happens to crap out, so I'd have to replace all four again.
Other Cars A SupraEssex and Kent · Jan 15, 2018#12After finding some new Tein lowering springs on ebay i was toying with going with springs for now on standard shocks. with the 16 inch wheel and 195 40 16 tires i was looking at i figured i was safe with just springs for now. especially as they were so cheap!
Type-YThread starterNY · Jan 16, 2018#13 Originally Posted by Thirty-Nine ↑
I had crappy Megan coilovers for about 14 months. They rode hard and rusted. I swapped them out for S-Techs and HPs and couldn't be happier. It's a much better street setup that actually absorbs bumps and allows for some travel.
Unfortunately, I understand Tokico doesn't make the HPs for the Yaris anymore.
Thanks Thirty-Nine. I've read your blog and your Yaris is one of my favorites. 😎
Type-YThread starterNY · Jan 17, 2018#14One more question. Would the rear Tokico blues for a Scion XD work on the yaris?
Nevermind, wouldn't want to Frankenstein it anyway. I've called around and even though online retailers are showing the rear shocks as available, they in fact are NOT in stock. Tokico Blue for the Yaris is no longer an option.
____ update _____
Since the Tokico's are not available and the TRD's are overpriced IMO, I just ordered a set of Tein Street Advance Z coilovers. Will post some pics when they arrive.
Type-YThread starterNY · Jan 18, 2018#15The Tein coilover setup arrived today. Amazing, since I just ordered it yesterday. The box is heavy and so are the struts themselves. The finish is very nice. They have the overall feeling of quality. Here are some photos:
6 attachments not included in this copy
ern-dizCA all day · Jan 18, 2018#16👍
enviriCT · Jan 18, 2018#17going to reuse your bits or buy new rubbers/hats/bearings for assembly?
Type-YThread starterNY · Jan 18, 2018#18 Originally Posted by
enviri ↑ going to reuse your bits or buy new rubbers/hats/bearings for assembly?
Planning on reusing. Anything I should look out for?
enviriCT · Jan 18, 2018#19i would at least buy new bearings, just because its a wear item and usually first to go.
48619-0D011 (x2) or you can buy the moog/kyb version of it.
Type-YThread starterNY · Jan 18, 2018#20 Originally Posted by
enviri ↑ i would at least buy new bearings, just because its a wear item and usually first to go.
48619-0D011 (x2) or you can buy the moog/kyb version of it.
Thanks! I want to do it right. (Should I get new rubbers and hats too?)
Would this work?
https://www.amazon.com/486190D011-Ab.../dp/B00DM9W2LG enviriCT · Jan 19, 2018#21that's the part exactly.
oh! i forgot about bumpstops which tein requires to be cut!
48331-52080 (x2)
either way you're doing it right, but the question of putting new rubbers and such, its all about you wanting your existing suspension in one piece in case you want to quickly swap out for stock.
here's a dirty list of oem parts if you do wanna have a quick swap out of the front suspension. If you want TRD version of the rubber, that's something for you to consider.
Picture not included in this copy
I have a spare set of coilovers sitting in my dining room floor fully assembled ready to go on any time.
malibuguyWestminster, MD · Jan 19, 2018#22Im curious how the Teins are going to ride. Ive been on MicroImage springs and Tokico blues for nearly 7 years. Im tired of the shit ride quality. But the damper behavior during aggressive or track day driving is execptional. I dont race the car enough to justify the ride.
Im waiting on my Stagg dampers to show up and give those a whirl. They did wonders for my other car (ended up being faster st the track with them too)
Type-YThread starterNY · Jan 19, 2018#23 Originally Posted by
enviri ↑ that's the part exactly.
oh! i forgot about bumpstops which tein requires to be cut!
48331-52080 (x2)
either way you're doing it right, but the question of putting new rubbers and such, its all about you wanting your existing suspension in one piece in case you want to quickly swap out for stock.
here's a dirty list of oem parts if you do wanna have a quick swap out of the front suspension. If you want TRD version of the rubber, that's something for you to consider.
Picture not included in this copy
I have a spare set of coilovers sitting in my dining room floor fully assembled ready to go on any time.
Thanks. Really appreciate that. I'll have to look up all these parts, but I'm guessing that with this part list I can have all the parts to have the stock springs/shocks/struts ready to re-install because both the coilovers and the stock ones will have all their own bits 😁
Type-YThread starterNY · Jan 19, 2018#24 Originally Posted by
malibuguy ↑ Im curious how the Teins are going to ride. Ive been on MicroImage springs and Tokico blues for nearly 7 years. Im tired of the shit ride quality. But the damper behavior during aggressive or track day driving is execptional. I dont race the car enough to justify the ride.
Im waiting on my Stagg dampers to show up and give those a whirl. They did wonders for my other car (ended up being faster st the track with them too)
Getting everything together - will definitely report back
Type-YThread starterNY · Jan 19, 2018#25 Originally Posted by Thirty-Nine ↑
I've thought about these as a replacement for my HPs. I'll be interested how you like them!
I'm curious myself. 🙂 I'll be posting my impressions after these are on. I thought I'd be ready to get it done this coming week, but looks like I'll need to order a few things first.
enviriCT · Jan 19, 2018#26i have a set of the teins too, lol let me know how it is. I'm currently on tanabe coilovers.
Type-YThread starterNY · Jan 24, 2018#27So, the Teins are getting installed next Wednesday. Looking at the rain guard and the top of the strut mount, I don’t see how the adjustment knob will ever fit again after the install. Going to have the damping adjusted as per the instructions, 6 clicks from full counter clockwise and hope that works well. My mechanic pointed out that it is a hex wrench so there may be other options....I guess I’ll figure it out.
Question: Does anyone have the torque specs handy for the TRD sway bar? I didn’t get my instructions back after the install.
enviriCT · Jan 24, 2018#28For the TRD bar, the torque specs are 36 ft/lbs on the bolt at the bottom of the suspension, and 44 ft/lbs for the other bolt.
Type-YThread starterNY · Jan 25, 2018#29 Originally Posted by
enviri ↑ For the TRD bar, the torque specs are 36 ft/lbs on the bolt at the bottom of the suspension, and 44 ft/lbs for the other bolt.
Thanks 😎
hachi-roku_fanSouth Gate · Apr 15, 2018#30Bump for a review on how you liked this set up? I'm considering this for my 2010 hatch.
Type-YThread starterNY · May 20, 2018#31 Originally Posted by
hachi-roku_fan ↑ Bump for a review on how you liked this set up? I'm considering this for my 2010 hatch.
Not long after my last post, my dad passed away, so this was shelved (Great man - alzheimers is a fucked up thing). I just started thinking about the Tein's again and my wife will surely be happy about my getting the big heavy box, that's still sitting in our entry way, out of there when I finally get this suspension installed.
Hoping to find time in the next week or two to get them on there.
hachi-roku_fanSouth Gate · May 21, 2018#32 Originally Posted by
Type-Y ↑ Not long after my last post, my dad passed away, so this was shelved (Great man - alzheimers is a fucked up thing). I just started thinking about the Tein's again and my wife will surely be happy about my getting the big heavy box, that's still sitting in our entry way, out of there when I finally get this suspension installed.
Hoping to find time in the next week or two to get them on there.
Sorry for your loss man.
Type-YThread starterNY · Jun 16, 2018#33 Originally Posted by
tmontague ↑ Fwiw to add to the discussion I am currently running MicroImage lowering springs with tokiko blues rear and KYB excel G oem up front. I find the front severly lacks the stiffness to handle the springs. I live around really rough roads and this is where I find the issue comes out. On relatively smooth roads they are fine. If you are doing any hard driving and want more performance then the Bilstein b8's will be a good choice.
I'd ecommend the coil overs only if you need the adjustment, if not then springs and a quality shock/strut will do the job well.
This upcoming spring I'm finally going to coil overs and selling my current set up as I need something more for the track, for DD'ing it was fine
Did you end up switching to the coil overs?
Type-YThread starterNY · Jun 16, 2018#34 Originally Posted by
hachi-roku_fan ↑ Sorry for your loss man.
Thank you, appreciate it.
FYI these are still not installed, but in the meantime I got a set of Avid 1 AV08's (slip reps) in black. I posted a pic of one of them sitting in my hallway, in my other thread on wheel choices. I gotta get this stuff installed.
atomic_hojiKincardine, ON, Canada · Jun 17, 2018#35Sorry to hear about Dad. Lost my Mum recently (cancer), so understand where you're at. Wrenching is good therapy; wife is also happy to have those misc. boxes of stuff go to the garage, lol.
Good luck with the install! 👍
--Adam
Type-YThread starterNY · Jun 20, 2018#36 Originally Posted by
atomic_hoji ↑ Sorry to hear about Dad. Lost my Mum recently (cancer), so understand where you're at. Wrenching is good therapy; wife is also happy to have those misc. boxes of stuff go to the garage, lol.
Good luck with the install! 👍
--Adam
Thanks man, I appreciate that. My condolences to you as well. I read through most of your thread (very impressive) and each time you mentioned your mum, it gave me that familiar sinking/sickening feeling; hoping for the best as I read through it, but at the same time I kind of knew where it was heading, unfortunately. Sad. It's tough and I hope you're coping reasonably well.
I'm not much of a wrencher (which is why I drive a Toyota & Subaru, lol), but I'm enjoying the research of planning and picking of parts. I may try my hand at doing the axle back once I decide which one to go with. That may be within my limited skill set.
Type-YThread starterNY · Jul 12, 2018#37Got the Tein's installed today. 😁 Pics coming soon...
Type-YThread starterNY · Jul 12, 2018#38Here are some photos. I got my new rims mounted at the same time.
Picture not included in this copy Picture not included in this copy Picture not included in this copy Picture not included in this copy Picture not included in this copy Picture not included in this copy6 attachments not included in this copy
hachi-roku_fanSouth Gate · Jul 13, 2018#39Looks good!! How's the ride? Anything special about the install?
ern-dizCA all day · Jul 13, 2018#40Super improvement, looks great 👍
Type-YThread starterNY · Jul 13, 2018#41 Originally Posted by
hachi-roku_fan ↑ Looks good!! How's the ride? Anything special about the install?
They snapped three sockets removing the passenger strut, but otherwise they did it in about an hour and a half. Great shop btw, InTrack Tires in Queens in case anyone is local.
I noticed a big difference on the ride home from the shop yesterday. The car is lower, stiffer, tighter; it felt great. I got to drive through Forest Park for a bit with some curvy roads and it feels planted in the turns. Initial impression is that this is a huge improvement. Very happy with it. I go back next week for final adjustments and an alignment (feels perfect now as it is really).
Type-YThread starterNY · Jul 13, 2018#42 Originally Posted by
ern-diz ↑ Super improvement, looks great 👍
Thanks! I totally agree🙂 After they were done one of the guys said it looked like a different car. It does. 😎
atomic_hojiKincardine, ON, Canada · Jul 14, 2018#43 Originally Posted by
Type-Y ↑ Thanks man, I appreciate that. My condolences to you as well. I read through most of your thread (very impressive) and each time you mentioned your mum, it gave me that familiar sinking/sickening feeling; hoping for the best as I read through it, but at the same time I kind of knew where it was heading, unfortunately. Sad. It's tough and I hope you're coping reasonably well.
I'm not much of a wrencher (which is why I drive a Toyota & Subaru, lol), but I'm enjoying the research of planning and picking of parts. I may try my hand at doing the axle back once I decide which one to go with. That may be within my limited skill set.
Hey, apologies, I completely missed this reply.. Appreciate the kind words - everyone is doing better and back to routine for the most part, thanks; just have to deal with the estate and legal junk..
From your axle-back thread it looks like you've taken the plunge - wrench on my friend, wrench on! Everyone starts somewhere. 😁
Car is looking great with the new setup. 👍 Glad to hear it's nice and planted on the road. Keep us posted how they settle in. Tien's are on my list to look at when I eventually get to swapping suspension, so I'll be looking forward to your feedback.
-- Adam
Type-YThread starterNY · Jul 31, 2018#44 Originally Posted by
atomic_hoji ↑ Hey, apologies, I completely missed this reply.. Appreciate the kind words - everyone is doing better and back to routine for the most part, thanks; just have to deal with the estate and legal junk..
From your axle-back thread it looks like you've taken the plunge - wrench on my friend, wrench on! Everyone starts somewhere. 😁
Car is looking great with the new setup. 👍 Glad to hear it's nice and planted on the road. Keep us posted how they settle in. Tien's are on my list to look at when I eventually get to swapping suspension, so I'll be looking forward to your feedback.
-- Adam
No worries. Glad that things are getting back to normal.
As for the Tien's, I had a very loud metallic thud sound coming from the back when going over larger bumps for the first week. It only happened on particularly jarring bumps though. I mentioned this when I went back for my alignment and they checked everything and all looked to be installed correctly. After the alignment it happened again and then it hit me to check the firmness level. They set the back on almost the softest setting and once I set it to Tien's recommended, which is 8 from the firmest setting, it seems to have solved the problem. I didn't really realize how bouncy the car felt on the softer setting by comparison, but now they feel firm and the car feels even tighter than before. This thing really turns almost flat; on-ramps and off-ramps are particularly fun now. It's a big improvement in handling (and looks). That said, on crappy roads you definitely feel it.
Type-YThread starterNY · Aug 5, 2018#45So, I spoke too soon. The loud metallic clunking noise is back. It comes from both sides in the rear when driving over bumps at speed. It’s very loud and the shop that installed them can’t find anything wrong with them. Any suggestions?
hachi-roku_fanSouth Gate · Aug 5, 2018#46Maybe he springs are binding? Any wear on any parts to hint at what's making contact?
tmontagueCaledonia Ont. · Aug 5, 2018#47fwiw I have a similar noise coming from my rear end. There appears to be nothing loose, I think it has to do with the springs binding against one another. If everything checks out then don't worry too much about it other than an annoying noise
Type-YThread starterNY · Aug 5, 2018#48 Originally Posted by
hachi-roku_fan ↑ Maybe he springs are binding? Any wear on any parts to hint at what's making contact?
I'll have to get under there to check it out. Will report back.
Type-YThread starterNY · Aug 5, 2018#49 Originally Posted by
tmontague ↑ fwiw I have a similar noise coming from my rear end. There appears to be nothing loose, I think it has to do with the springs binding against one another. If everything checks out then don't worry too much about it other than an annoying noise
Really hoping that's not the case. The Street Advance Z is not even a true coilover in the rear on the Yaris, its just a shock and spring with the adjustability bracket on top of the spring.
Type-YThread starterNY · Aug 28, 2018#50So the loud metal on metal sound from the back is still there over large bumps. It's worse on the driver's side, but happens on the passenger side too. The front is fine no matter what holes/bumps I hit and at whatever speed.
I went back to the installation instructions and noticed that the rear shocks come with bump stops, so I'm guessing that either they were not installed or they blew out (if that's possible). I need to get the car lifted to check under there to be sure. But right now it sounds like there's nothing acting as cushion when the shocks are fully compressed and that's what I believe is causing the noise. I wish I had a go pro to mount under there to record what is happening.