Yarisworld Archive

Echo or mazda2?

24 posts · 7,010 views

thebarberOriginal postGrand Rapids, MI · Aug 20, 2016#1
Currently have a 2004 echo RS hatchback with 330000km on it.

Found a still-new 2014 Mazda 2 GX convince pack (a/c, power locks/windows - - nothing mind blowing) for $12800. Technically it's certified used but it has 57km on it (not 5700 or 57000, fifty seven). Has comprehensive warranty to Nov 2018 and powertrain to 2022 and 140000km.

I drive about 40-45000km a year right now and my current echo DOES NOT have cruise or power windows and the a/c works most of the time...

I love the echo, but I'm wondering if I should get a new car as it's a great deal (12800 vs 18800 new new)

I drove the 2 yesterday and it's quite spritely as it's a manual...

Opinions?

Replies 23

Kar98DFW · Aug 20, 2016#2
Can't say much about Canadian pricing, but the Mazda 2 is a great upgrade to the 12 year old Echo hatch.
WeeYariGeorgetown, Ontario, Canada · Aug 20, 2016#3
Great car, good price.

Now ask yourself how much longer the Vibe is going to last you and what you'll presumably have to do in short order for the larger family hauler.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
yarisugiハワイ · Aug 20, 2016#4
I was seriously about to buy a used one but the negotiations didnt go through with the seller. I test drove it and it felt good. I like that it has a timing chain and the instrument panel was nicely laid out. However, the rear seating was a little cramped but it didnt bother me as no one really sits back there anyway. 57km is practically brand new! I'd buy it if you don't! See if you can get it down to $11k!
thebarberThread starterGrand Rapids, MI · Aug 20, 2016#5
Originally Posted by WeeYari ↑
Great car, good price.

Now ask yourself how much longer the Vibe is going to last you and what you'll presumably have to do in short order for the larger family hauler.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Just bought a 2017 sportwagen
thebarberThread starterGrand Rapids, MI · Aug 20, 2016#6
Basically, the vibe is being disassembled.

Echo was bought as commuter, but the 2 is a smoking deal. It still has the window sticker.
WeeYariGeorgetown, Ontario, Canada · Aug 20, 2016#7
Originally Posted by thebarber ↑
Just bought a 2017 sportwagen

Interesting choice. Do you actually have it in your hands or just on paper at the moment?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
thebarberThread starterGrand Rapids, MI · Aug 20, 2016#8
Originally Posted by WeeYari ↑
Interesting choice. Do you actually have it in your hands or just on paper at the moment?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Signed deal on loaded highline this afternoon
NYC-SENYC · Aug 20, 2016#9
Have you owned a VW before?

I wish you good luck but it was my experiences with VW that led me to Toyota.
thebarberThread starterGrand Rapids, MI · Aug 20, 2016#10
Originally Posted by NYC-SE ↑
Have you owned a VW before?

I wish you good luck but it was my experiences with VW that led me to Toyota.
91 golf diesel and 06 mk4 TDI wagon
NYC-SENYC · Aug 20, 2016#11
2010 Golf TDI in my case. As I said, good luck.
kimonaHuntington Bch, CA · Aug 21, 2016#12
What's a "highline"?
NYC-SENYC · Aug 21, 2016#13
Originally Posted by kimona ↑
What's a "highline"?
Top Canadian trim level. Equivalent to our SEL trim.
bentjazzOhio · Aug 21, 2016#14
Ugh, not a VW. Like NYC-SE, my experience with VW led me to Toyota. And as a VW mechanic once told me during one of the many times my VW was in the shop for repairs, VWs are great as long as you have a warranty. Good luck....
kimonaHuntington Bch, CA · Aug 21, 2016#15
Originally Posted by NYC-SE ↑
Top Canadian trim level. Equivalent to our SEL trim.
Okay... but what make/model car are we talking about here?
thebarberThread starterGrand Rapids, MI · Aug 21, 2016#16
Originally Posted by kimona ↑
Okay... but what make/model car are we talking about here?
I'm thinking about a still-new 2014 mazda2 GX with convenience pack
WeeYariGeorgetown, Ontario, Canada · Aug 21, 2016#17
Originally Posted by kimona ↑
Okay... but what make/model car are we talking about here?

Highline is referring to the VW Sportwagen.

Back to the original question. It's a tough call. Only you know what condition your Echo is in. I know how much you love the NCP/1NZ platform, and I also know how itchy you can get for changing things up. If Echo powertrain, drivetrain, and body are relatively solid I say keep it.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
thebarberThread starterGrand Rapids, MI · Aug 21, 2016#18
Originally Posted by WeeYari ↑
Highline is referring to the VW Sportwagen.

Back to the original question. It's a tough call. Only you know what condition your Echo is in. I know how much you love the NCP/1NZ platform, and I also know how itchy you can get for changing things up. If Echo powertrain, drivetrain, and body are relatively solid I say keep it.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
The echo is in good shape but as you know, I'm in a condo now and it's a challenge to do any of my own work. I'm thinking a new car with warranty might alleviate some inconvenience associated with an old car breaking down.

And currently I don't think I'd have an issue selling the echo saftied and etested for what I've paid for it
ExiwolfmanWasaga beach · Aug 21, 2016#19
Originally Posted by thebarber ↑
The echo is in good shape but as you know, I'm in a condo now and it's a challenge to do any of my own work. I'm thinking a new car with warranty might alleviate some inconvenience associated with an old car breaking down.

And currently I don't think I'd have an issue selling the echo saftied and etested for what I've paid for it
I like the Mazda 2 very nice little car for a low cost plus toyota wheels are a direct fit lol well yaris wheels.

As much as i would love a new car i hate monthly payments and one reason i will not get one myself unless i have cash in hand ...just my opinion .

So in the end its all about affordability
thebarberThread starterGrand Rapids, MI · Aug 23, 2016#20
i think for now im going to just hold onto the echo. i like the car and i don't have to worry about it....plus it doesnt eat up our savings or make a new monthly payment...
ExiwolfmanWasaga beach · Aug 23, 2016#21
Originally Posted by thebarber ↑
i think for now im going to just hold onto the echo. i like the car and i don't have to worry about it....plus it doesnt eat up our savings or make a new monthly payment...
+1
jambo101Montreal Canada · Aug 30, 2016#22
Sounds like a good deal but i'd wonder why this car has been sitting on the dealers lot for the best part of 3 years.
thebarberThread starterGrand Rapids, MI · Aug 30, 2016#23
Originally Posted by jambo101 ↑
Sounds like a good deal but i'd wonder why this car has been sitting on the dealers lot for the best part of 3 years.
2 is unpopular with its small size and low power....and its a manual

and really, i can't find it for sale anywhere...so lack of advertising?
WeeYariGeorgetown, Ontario, Canada · Aug 30, 2016#24
Originally Posted by jambo101 ↑
Sounds like a good deal but i'd wonder why this car has been sitting on the dealers lot for the best part of 3 years.
Last year, with the 2016s rolling out, a buddy of mine hit mid-life crisis and got a chubby for a Camaro. He walked the lot at the local GM dealership and spotted a BNIB 2014 RS toward the back. IIRC he got it for something like $12K off list.

Same thing as thebarber. No advertising what-so-ever. It's almost like forgotten inventory waiting for the lucky individual who happens upon it.